Пікірлер

• 
  @UmerSami2823 сағат бұрын

  Good Effort brother.......always wait for your videos 😍

• 
  @3rd_POV22 сағат бұрын

  Thank you so much 😀

• 
  @nowshadk07Күн бұрын

  For now let's keep this noval for later. But nicely explained as always.

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Hahah good plan.

• 
  @footballnewsviews4650Күн бұрын

  Is Mai aik sawal uthta hai Agar ye consensus se hua tw rape kese hua Or dusra age of consent hai kya phir Is par french post modernists Foucault wagera ne b controversially age of consent ko kum kene ko kaha 😮

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Consensus: it’s not mentioned in the novel, remember he is an unreliable narrator. Age of consent: very controversial topic bro. I don’t know.

• 
  @SamkjrКүн бұрын

  Sir, should one consider studying liberal arts as it teach us how to become articulated.

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Hmmm …Yar there are many factors and variables that should be considered in these types of decisions. I am a big fan of all areas within humanities, but as I said one has to take these decisions very carefully. Why not though??

• 
  @SamkjrКүн бұрын

  Can you please elaborate ; what variables we should be focusing on the best sir? As everyone says what's the use of a bachelor of arts degree. And it goes like it teaches you how to think. And so should i select art stream after 10th, sir?

• 
  @SamkjrКүн бұрын

  By the way i'm a big fan of the great novels you discuss in your videos especially dostoevsky's works.

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  @@Samkjr hahaha I am not sure. You should connect with a career counsellor. I mean one has to earn a living also!!!

• 
  @musalone1405Күн бұрын

  Sir kierkegaurd pe video bnaaye.❤

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Yar thora time day zaroor banaonga. Thx

• 
  @mrs.h-bombmccairn8098Күн бұрын

  I only watched the movie. The story is extremely disturbing and offensive. I don't think I would be reading it.

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Agreed, yes it’s very disturbing.

• 
  @Saadkhan-zc1ltКүн бұрын

  Sir subscriber's aye ya na aye lekin apka kam hamesha KZread me yaad rahega

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Thx

• 
  @zishanraza2761Күн бұрын

  Thanks for existing

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Lol

• 
  @prashantkumarsingh5224Күн бұрын

  sir very very congratulation for 2k subscribers🥳🤩🤩

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Thanks Prashant

• 
  @Bookas-mb2pzКүн бұрын

  👍

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Thx

• 
  @shoaibnedКүн бұрын

  since i already watched movie Lolita based on this novel but the way you narrate this novel made it double bonanza.

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Thank you Sir

• 
  @LawExplainedOfficialКүн бұрын

  Good Morning Sir..Have A Nice Day. Very Informative Video🙏

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Thx

• 
  @akshatsaxena8429Күн бұрын

  Class apart. Love and admiration from India!

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Thank you brother

• 
  @ghazalaabdi4712Күн бұрын

  Best

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Thx

• 
  @awaizkhetran3607Күн бұрын

  Finally bestiest person came on KZread 🎉

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Thanks brother

• 
  @nowshadk072 күн бұрын

  I read this book. It really is a bit difficult for someone who doesn't have knowledge of previous philosophers especially I found some Husserl Quoted a lot. So some of it went ser k uper se. Haha. But there are many good chapters. I liked Duan Juansim Chapter. Drama. conquest. In first few pages Camus writes Any reason to live is a great reason for die as well It reminded me of Ishq main farak nahi jene oor marne ka Usi ko dekh k jete hain jis kafir pe dham nikle I have one question that I wanted to ask. In Drama(page 80) there is a line. If it was essential to love at stage like people really do, our speech would be in code. What did he mean by that.

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  I think in this section he is saying, life is absurd and we are all acting our parts, and that is why we like dramas. Because in drama, actor plays a character for few minutes and then it is finished. Drama is absurd and life is absurd. Actor tries to give some meaning to drama but then it gets over, so is life. Actor has only 2 tools body and voice - a mime actor can only use one tool that is his body, he cannot speak, so he has to use magnified body gestures and also his silence has to be used as an act of speech. If an actor is allowed to speak his heart, like he does in his normal life, he will have to talk in codes. Camus was a stage actor and director - he uses a lot of similar analogies. I hope I was helpful.

• 
  @nowshadk07Күн бұрын

  @@3rd_POV yes He has given amazing similarities between life and acting. And I think I got it. Thank you 😊 Waiting for another video.

• 
  @LawExplainedOfficial3 күн бұрын

  Sir Hegel Ki Thymos Concept Kya Hai?

• 
  @3rd_POVКүн бұрын

  Plato Yar yeh Thymos purana concept hai - Plato ka. Plato kay dialogue "Republic" main isko detail main bataya hai plato nay (meri video dekho Republic per). Plato bolta hai kay human soul kay 3 parts hotay hain (1) Logos (in the head) - rationality / reason----------------------------------------------------philosophers (2) Thymos (in the chest) - emotions / feelings / bravery / SPRIT-------------------warriors Thymos is the part of the human personality that demands recognition of one’s inner dignity, and the seat of the emotions of pride, anger, and of shame. (3) Eros (in the stomach) - bodily needs/ sex / food----------------------------------------farmers / craftsmen /mazdoor Hegel I am not sure if you know the basics of Hegel's philosophy of history. If you do not please check out the following link it will give you a basic idea of Hegel's Historicism. philosophynow.org/issues/129/Hegel_on_History If you know Hegel's Historicism, Thymos / spiritedness , according to Hegel has been the primary driver of the entire human historical process. I hope I was helpful.

• 
  @LawExplainedOfficialКүн бұрын

  theek h sir..apne reply kia thankyou..bas plato wali hi video dekhni baki hai apki..mai late aya apke channel par..but shukriya khuda ka ap se rabta hua..thankyou ur every setence is a book for us viewers..🙏

• 
  @nirajsmiling55403 күн бұрын

  Should i read fyodor dostoevsky novels ? What we can learn from dostoevsky novels ?

• 
  @3rd_POV3 күн бұрын

  100% - we can all learn very deep insights about human psychology, emotions, desires and fears from his novels. All 5 of his major novels are worth reading.

• 
  @nirajsmiling55403 күн бұрын

  @@3rd_POV which 5 novels ?

• 
  @3rd_POV3 күн бұрын

  @@nirajsmiling5540 google kar lo

• 
  @Stern54953 күн бұрын

  Make a video on. Religious countries are scientifically poor. The way people understood religious Book's are wrong. European did different things,than east islamic countries. Quran is for intellectual .not for idiots.

• 
  @AwaisRajput-ob9yo3 күн бұрын

  Sir can u recommend a book which can help me to understand basic concept philosophy so then i can read philosophers book

• 
  @3rd_POV3 күн бұрын

  My advice would be to watch KZread videos on philosophy for at least 1 year. There is a lot of very good content available online, which can give you a good start. Then start reading the original text of famous philosophers.

• 
  @AwaisRajput-ob9yo3 күн бұрын

  And sir kindly made a video or guide us how to read books fast and memorise them just like you do i love reading books but i cant do it swiftly

• 
  @3rd_POV3 күн бұрын

  Don’t read fast, enjoy books and spend time with them. Philosophy books demand active reading.

• 
  @AwaisRajput-ob9yo3 күн бұрын

  Sir whose book should i read aisha jalal or ishtiaq ahmed and who is more authentic to pre partition history because they both accuse each other of false evidence.

• 
  @3rd_POV3 күн бұрын

  No idea, I have not read them, not my area. Thx

• 
  @user-cv3yp7tr9w4 күн бұрын

  Sir please make a video on STOICISM

• 
  @3rd_POV3 күн бұрын

  I am not a fan of Stoic philosophy but, will for sure, cover it in any of the upcoming videos. Thanks for the suggestion.

• 
  @user-cv3yp7tr9w4 күн бұрын

  Great content....

• 
  @3rd_POV3 күн бұрын

  Thx

• 
  @mrs.h-bombmccairn80984 күн бұрын

  I'm learning from your talks, thank you. I would've never imagined, when we were children that you would be so well versed in philosophy and i would be here half way around the world listening to you. This is absolutely and most pleasantly awesome!

• 
  @3rd_POV4 күн бұрын

  Thank you for the appreciation. Yes so many school memories rushed in my mind when I saw your message yesterday, and also the fact that you are so far away (I am in Canada for last 10 years) and we still got connected through this medium - strange times. Thanks this appreciation means a lot.

• 
  @AwaisRajput-ob9yo4 күн бұрын

  And 3rd question sir plz recommend some history books plz

• 
  @3rd_POV4 күн бұрын

  Story of civilization by Will Durant.

• 
  @AwaisRajput-ob9yo4 күн бұрын

  Or sir 2nd question ha henry kessinger ki book diplomacy buy krlu achi book ha?

• 
  @3rd_POV4 күн бұрын

  Nothing wrong in reading his books - even though he was a war criminal- don’t believe everything you read

• 
  @AwaisRajput-ob9yo4 күн бұрын

  Sir 1 question ha pakistani writer ma dr mubarik ali ki books parh sakte hn ap k according wo accurate hn ya fazool plz reply he has written alot of books on history

• 
  @3rd_POV4 күн бұрын

  Dr. Mubarak Ali is a great historian- he is an asset for us Pakistanis.

• 
  @AwaisRajput-ob9yo4 күн бұрын

  @@3rd_POV thank u sir i will read him

• 
  @mrs.h-bombmccairn80985 күн бұрын

  👏👏🤜

• 
  @mrs.h-bombmccairn80985 күн бұрын

  I have just tuned in. I never thought you would become a historian. Amazing! Regards, fatima emiko.

• 
  @3rd_POV5 күн бұрын

  Hey Fatima -- OMG small world. I hope you are doing great. Great to see your message. Thanks yes somehow I turned into a nerd. Bad things happen!!!

• 
  @mrs.h-bombmccairn80985 күн бұрын

  @@3rd_POV is it bad. No one else thinks so. Well done.

• 
  @3rd_POV5 күн бұрын

  @@mrs.h-bombmccairn8098 thx - let’s stay connected through this.

• 
  @Stern54955 күн бұрын

  Modi k minister's all illeterate. Agenda hinduvuta. Communal politics

• 
  @mmsudan15 күн бұрын

  Enjoyed listening to this and several other videos by you. Very informative. Thanks and regards

• 
  @3rd_POV5 күн бұрын

  Thank you Sir for appreciation.

• 
  @mubasharraza87998 күн бұрын

  Wonderful. Apne bohat acha anylysis kiya. Thanks.

• 
  @3rd_POV8 күн бұрын

  Thx

• 
  @LawExplainedOfficial9 күн бұрын

  Happy Eid Ul Zuha Ali Sir.. Next Video Kis Topic Par Bnaoge Aap ?

• 
  @3rd_POV9 күн бұрын

  Eid Mubarak - yar topic abhi decide naheen Kara.

• 
  @LawExplainedOfficial9 күн бұрын

  @@3rd_POV Okay Sir

• 
  @saveoursoulsos860110 күн бұрын

  Please make long vudeo on A 100 yr old man climbed on a window and disappeared.

• 
  @shoaibned10 күн бұрын

  today i know what is post modernism... good work.

• 
  @3rd_POV10 күн бұрын

  Thanks

• 
  @SarasAtheistAdvaita10 күн бұрын

  You may be correct but is generally believed that Hannibal did have elephants in his army, and he is especially famous for taking Elephants across the Alps. This is a friendly critique, I truly appreciate your work.

• 
  @3rd_POV10 күн бұрын

  Thanks for your comment and appreciation. I checked a few sources after reading your comment (e.g., History Channel) and all mention that Hannibal did have elephants in his military. I think that is what I mentioned in the video. Thanks for the comment.

• 
  @SarasAtheistAdvaita9 күн бұрын

  @@3rd_POV You did say that.... for some reason I heard it wrong. apologies for the inconvenience ..

• 
  @3rd_POV9 күн бұрын

  No worries- please share my videos in your groups-thx

• 
  @SarasAtheistAdvaita9 күн бұрын

  ​@@3rd_POV Hi sure I will, you may consider watching videos of HS Sinha . He is was a student/ teacher of philosophy.. passed away around a year ago.

• 
  @3rd_POV9 күн бұрын

  Yes, I have watched all his videos. What a great man he was.

• 
  @SarasAtheistAdvaita10 күн бұрын

  Perhaps a few words regarding Benjamin could have been included

• 
  @SarasAtheistAdvaita10 күн бұрын

  Your videos are very good... thank you for posting.

• 
  @3rd_POV10 күн бұрын

  Agreed- good point

• 
  @footballnewsviews465011 күн бұрын

  1 ghante ki videos ap 2 parts Mai bnaen channel k lie acha hoga logo ka intizar bhi kam hoga or algorithm ka bhi pait bhar jaega regular content se😂

• 
  @3rd_POV11 күн бұрын

  Good idea brother

• 
  @knowmyversion11 күн бұрын

  strawman fallacy

• 
  @LawExplainedOfficial7 күн бұрын

  yes it is strawman fallacy.

• 
  @knowmyversion11 күн бұрын

  had se zada sach likha rossuaeu ne apni buraian bhi puri sachai se likh gya

• 
  @3rd_POV11 күн бұрын

  Haan Saint Augustine nay bhi bohat sach likha hai

• 
  @knowmyversion11 күн бұрын

  Jo philosophy parh le wo self help nh parhta😅

• 
  @3rd_POV11 күн бұрын

  Agreed, nothing against self help books though

• 
  @zishanraza276111 күн бұрын

  Post modernism is the Most bullshit idea ,

• 
  @3rd_POV11 күн бұрын

  Thx for watching

• 
  @nowshadk0712 күн бұрын

  Yes in one or the other video Jordan Peterson says Post Modernists don't want people ro have cars and all that. I had an question. Since this concept of soul, Plato's idea of an ideal world that we can't see in this world seems similar to our Abrahamic religions. We can safely say that Abrahamic religions have Platonic basis. Right? Then To which degree Islam has Greek Influence? Here in India also people had came up with Aatma and Swarg(Heaven). Can we say here in India this idea devloped independently?

• 
  @3rd_POV12 күн бұрын

  Christianity borrowed a lot from Greeks. There are many passages in New Testament that are copied from Homer’s Odyssey. Christianity is a combination of Hebraic and Greek traditions. I made a video on Saint Paul who invented Christianity. Islam borrowed heavily from Christianity/ Judaism. Greeks borrowed many ideas from East, could be India or Egypt or Mesopotamia. Agar Pythagoras Egypt na gata parhnay Kay liye… things would have been very different!!!

• 
  @nowshadk0712 күн бұрын

  When you mentioned death of the author first name that came to my mind was Ghalib haha then you also gave his example. 😊

• 
  @3rd_POV12 күн бұрын

  Hahaha

• 
  @MoizAli-iy2wg12 күн бұрын

  Amazing explanation

• 
  @3rd_POV12 күн бұрын

  Thank you

• 
  @mubasharraza879912 күн бұрын

  Apka Andaz e biyaan bohat Kamal hai , video banate rahiya ga , Shukriya.

• 
  @3rd_POV12 күн бұрын

  Thanks brother

• 
  @mubasharraza879912 күн бұрын

  ❤

• 
  @3rd_POV10 күн бұрын

  Thx

• 
  @jinturay231812 күн бұрын

  You are Awesome sir love your lectures 🎉🎉love from India 🇮🇳

• 
  @3rd_POV12 күн бұрын

  Thank you

• 
  @MoizAli-gy8sg13 күн бұрын

  Keep it up thanks for sharing knowledge

• 
  @3rd_POV12 күн бұрын

  Thanks for appreciating