KZread's voice of reason. Catholic social critic who creates video essays on the important subjects of our time. I sometimes make response videos, too.
If you enjoy my work, you can also find me at the links below.
Christians forced their belief on people, this movie is historically accurate.
@galaxy-wg1lf41 минут бұрын
Not to mention that chattel slavery was basically non-existent in medieval Europe.
@tylercoffman1941 минут бұрын
This is a giant crock. In the standard bible, old testi, its standard practice for them to eradicate every living thing Im looking at you Jericho 'Christians hands are force' just analyze this from a militaristic stand point and not your self confirming biases Soldiers dont win wars by dying for their country, they win by making the other side die for theirs To imply either side is 'peaceful' is nutters during literal 'holy war' is dumbfoundingly ignorant of the human's ability to DEHUMANIZE each other for shit as simply as skin, sex LET ALONE religion I grew up in this cult, I escaped this cult, I hope one day you will
@HollyRoseBeecham54 минут бұрын
I find it repulsive that the french still continue to celebrate Bastille day. The events of the revolution should be shunned, not celebrated...its shameful!
@xD3MONxIxSOULx2 сағат бұрын
This video is nonsense. This is the equivalent of "dropping 2 atomic bombs on Japan was actually a good thing because it ended the war". Having an opposite view to common knowledge makes you feel special and smarter but it doesn't make you right.
@johnobeid672 сағат бұрын
Brilliant. Brilliant. Brilliant. Can’t say anything else about this video. Thank you.
@elephantalk3 сағат бұрын
It's killing me how he says "my favorite crusade" like it's a franchise
@user-uz7dm6qn3y4 сағат бұрын
Obviously, both sides were barbaric hordes spreading their religion by the sword.
@jacksonrowell48845 сағат бұрын
Cope
@pokedev82156 сағат бұрын
Carl Sagan: "Muh Dark Ages!" The "Dark Ages:" *has the Rosary, the Summas, The Divine Comedy, the Franciscan and Dominican Orders, the Poor Clares, Thomism, Scotism, Saint Bonaventure, the Cistercians, Blessed Charlemagne, Saint Boniface, the Benedictine Orders, the Nobertines, Gregory Palamas (saint in Eastern Orthodoxy, but not in Catholicism), Saints Francis of Assisi, Dominic, Didacus, Bernardino, Malachy, Clare, Bernard, and many based things you might have never heard of*
@KhuzzPRO-castinater6 сағат бұрын
Man your vocabulary is so hard.
@Ghall27087 сағат бұрын
I’ve always thought of Europe from the 400s to 900s as a complete mess and a time you simply would not want to be alive. Shit like Italy being completely destroyed the plague of justinian the Arab invasions the constant war.
@es78218 сағат бұрын
Louis the XVth was Louis’ XIVth great-grandson
@robertrenato8 сағат бұрын
This was pretty spot on! When I found this phaenomenon I mainly sticked to Hololive JP, (Korone, Watame-as You've shown) they were pretty consistent with quality of talent and content. Sadly the degeneracy is taking over slowly, and fewer and fewer can keep their content pure. From HoloEN I found Ina to be the most wholesome one, mainly doing art and decent stuff. When I first saw her design I was most skeptical, but I think the person behind the character didn't want to take it to weird directions, and now all subsequent outfits are pretty conservative and fits her content.
@aqibamran92118 сағат бұрын
nah this oss the most biased shit ive ever seen. someone need to make a video criticize the many faults in this video
@d-not-u93009 сағат бұрын
Good stuff
@robertrenato9 сағат бұрын
I started watching Your channel (found it in looking for a Catholic perspective regarding Protestantism) and even before I got to this one, a debunking video was recommended by youtube. Doing my usual quick "check twitter profile" check revealed that youtuber to be- shockingly, I know- a COMMUNIST:D Keep up the good work!
@aceofcards78310 сағат бұрын
It tried so hard to be anime but not even aniwave and anitaku (AKA gogoanime) fell for the lie.
@aceofcards78310 сағат бұрын
Actually I would say that they didn't even bother to try making it like anime.
@nicomoreno502810 сағат бұрын
Biased.
@lokeyGee8710 сағат бұрын
The inquisition was mean and messed up
@miroslavgalic520911 сағат бұрын
Not a word about Fourth crusade that sacked Constantinople and made muslims able to undermine only real christian empire we all today know as Byzantine Empire! Catholics from Western Europe made it posible for Ottomans to come to Vienna because those same Catholics destroyed Orthodox Christian Empire that stood between Christendom and Islam! Shame on you!
@TheJudge193311 сағат бұрын
The Eldians are abused and exploited by a subverisive race with an atrocity story invented to justify it Whatever could the Japanese have meant by this?
@andremodesto14 сағат бұрын
The time has come for a whole new set of crusades
@clarekuehn437215 сағат бұрын
Please do one on Toledo Js.
@sayedalihashim156816 сағат бұрын
You forgot to mention that crusaders killed other Christians that weren't catholics.
@user-zp7lc7bn4y12 минут бұрын
You forgot that this is lie since nestorians are as christian as muslims Also arent the muslims ones that fought sunni vs shia?
@toddstroger950516 сағат бұрын
Peaceful Christians, ha, ha.
@user-zp7lc7bn4y11 минут бұрын
Saladin is consider by many to be slave trader and devil
@kurisari193716 сағат бұрын
Ever since learning the truth about the Crusades as a European, I have changed my mindset a lot. Our ancestors weren’t the savages-the Jihadists were and still are. Christianity has since become peaceful and accepting (even lax) whilst Islam has never stopped being full of hatred, violence and the clear goal to destroy all infidels. I feel immense gratitude for these brave (if ruthless) men who protected Europe and paved the way for us. Europeans must remember how much our ancestors have fought for. They weren’t given this land. They defended it for centuries. I’m filled with love and respect for their sacrifices.
@RG-iw7py17 сағат бұрын
Well done!
@mmmnah768417 сағат бұрын
As a former Hentai Addict and the path to recovery is difficult but still better than when i didn't start. I'll say this. Hentai addiction is horrifying giving this obscure view of what sex is and it just gets worse as you go down this path of sexual immorality. But sure temptations come and go but its best that you dont feed onto them
@Eluul17 сағат бұрын
I like your stuff. I would love to see you do a video on the Bolshevik Revolution
@theamazingempiricist18 сағат бұрын
This video deserves way more views. Thank you for this great work, Pax Tube - God Bless!
@Vidhur19 сағат бұрын
If you ever wondered where the blight that is marxism came from...
@user-no5zh6un6d19 сағат бұрын
The crusades where more than righteous
@deelady5319 сағат бұрын
The crusades were an illegal invasion. Just as bad as muslims.
@user-zp7lc7bn4y11 минут бұрын
It is like saying that USA invasion in france was illegal xD
@GutsOfRivia20 сағат бұрын
The crusades arent somthing you cant paint as one side good and one side bad. Both sides had flashes of horrible atrocities and heroic valor. Its far too complicated to just say Muslim Bad Christan good or vise versa. Also blaming the dark age soley on the islamic world is a bit dishonest as much of the devstation wrought during that time was from the churches within europe supressing knowledge and northern and slavic invasion and general infighting.
@abdalamustafe9622 сағат бұрын
4:11 come on man islam prohibited slavery now not then, please understand the religion before you make any video. All respect
@user-zp7lc7bn4y10 минут бұрын
XDDD then why muslims were selling biggest ammount of slaves?
@abdalamustafe9622 сағат бұрын
2:15 ok i still haven't seen the whole video but this information has no meaning. Islam roughly started at 630 AD after the conquer of mecca
@JukeBoxDestroyer22 сағат бұрын
Sagan was Jewish, I'm shocked I tells ya.
@DumbJockQuaterback23 сағат бұрын
Wikipedia also has a pedophile bias.
@TheNotoriousMrDeeКүн бұрын
It doesn't have to be about race; weak people with low character can be easily influenced by people smarter than them with an agenda. Victimhood is encouraged by the enemies of a peaceful, cohesive society. Some with power thrive when a population are constantly divided.
@threatassessment216Күн бұрын
The devil and his “people “ them you know…… do not want Christians to unite and fight against his lies
@Constant-prettyКүн бұрын
Not all of them were good, the children s crusade was not awesome, well it wasn't actually a crusade, cause it never got approved by the pope, but almost everyone calls it a crusade
@Ilovecats812Күн бұрын
Best explanation ever keep this kind of energy but there will be many haters who can't accept the truth
@CharlieApplesКүн бұрын
These comments be like “I live in an overwhelmingly Christian country where Christianity specifically is extra special and protected by society, the government, the police, and the churches, where atheists are called immoral Satan worshippers and Muslims are called terrorists, but…I’m just sick of the anti-Christian rhetoric I heard was happening.”
@SolidStateSimulations20 сағат бұрын
These people really are so lost, it's crazy. I'm not even sure how shit like this gets recommended to me either, I'm just clicking to see if people are still sane, and while the shit that keeps getting upvoted is usually unhinged, at least it's good to know that some recent comments still have some semblance of sanity.
@reemussummusКүн бұрын
and muslims continue to persecute christians
@Im-not-alone-Im-full-of-myselfКүн бұрын
0:00 Intro 1:49 France Before Revolution 8:08 Influence of the Enlightenment 12:08 The Revolution Begins 19:48 The Reign of Terror 25:22 The Revolution Winds Down 27:18 Conclusion
@Im-not-alone-Im-full-of-myselfКүн бұрын
00:02 French Revolution was more complex than a simple oppression narrative 02:14 France was a prosperous and influential nation prior to the revolution. 06:44 The decline in religious standards and the rise of Freemasonry in France 08:57 Debate over government's role and individual freedom during the Enlightenment 13:12 The French Revolution escalated due to inequality and mob violence. 15:15 The National Assembly made catastrophic mistakes in 1790 19:12 Radicalization of the French Revolution 21:07 The French Revolution's brutal tactics led to mass killings and a lack of accountability. 24:53 The reign of terror during the French Revolution led to the downfall of the Jacobins. 26:51 French Revolution led to unexpected consequences French Revolution was more complex than a simple oppression narrative - The Revolution involved a mix of shifting allegiances and complex conflicts - Events of the Revolution had both positive improvements and damaging consequences France was a prosperous and influential nation prior to the revolution. - France faced challenges in reforming its institutions due to industrialization, mass literacy, and population growth. - France's financial problems, exacerbated by wars and excessive spending, led to a deep debt crisis. The decline in religious standards and the rise of Freemasonry in France - The increase in Masonic lodges and Freemason leaders in the coming Revolution - The decline of religious standards and the impact of the Age of Enlightenment Debate over government's role and individual freedom during the Enlightenment - The Enlightenment emphasized science and reason, sparking debates on government purpose and public involvement. - Enlightenment thinkers clashed with traditional views on man's nature and freedom, promoting new ideas. The French Revolution escalated due to inequality and mob violence. - The Estates General was unable to agree on reforms due to disproportionate voting power favoring the nobility and clergy. - The wealthy bourgeoisie led the radical change, hijacked the National Assembly, and seized church property to address the debt crisis. The National Assembly made catastrophic mistakes in 1790 - The Civil constitution of the clergy law enslaved the Catholic Church under French government control. - Major opposition arose as the majority of Bishops and priests refused the Loyalty oath. Radicalization of the French Revolution - Jacobins took control after September massacres and executed King Louis - Reign of terror began with Committee of Public Safety targeting enemies of Liberty The French Revolution's brutal tactics led to mass killings and a lack of accountability. - The Committee of Public Safety established a harsh regime where anyone suspected of opposition was arrested and executed. - The Rebellion in Vendee, though initially successful, was brutally pacified by the government resulting in over 100,000 civilian deaths. The reign of terror during the French Revolution led to the downfall of the Jacobins. - Moderates retaliated against the Jacobins, leading to a coup and their eventual guillotining. - The Directory took over, but their corruption and military reliance paved the way for Napoleon's dictatorship. French Revolution led to unexpected consequences - Napoleon's defeat in 1815 ended the Revolution, leading to monarchy restoration and a period of political conservatism in Europe - Revolutionaries failed due to a loss of touch with reality and created a system worse than what they overthrew
@ryanadams2610Күн бұрын
I hate the debate around the term "dark age". To clarify there is in fact multiple dark ages in multiple periods and places. I feel greek historians use the term best, to describe a gap in time where little recording of what was going on or the records didn't survive, in greek history this woud be post bronze age right before the forming of the city states we think of. I feel the period from roman collapse to the formation of the early medieval kingdoms or possibly even the regin of Charlemagne was a European dark age. Reasons are really simple 1 rome collapsed 2 with the collapse technology critical to large urban infrastructure was lost i.e. running wate via aqueducts 3 areas that were once unified under a single government were now split up into smaller petty kingdoms of germanic barbarians 4 ancient literature like the Odyssey were lost i several areas, this no doubt disrupted the progress of art and literature in greco-roman areas.
Пікірлер
Christians forced their belief on people, this movie is historically accurate.
Not to mention that chattel slavery was basically non-existent in medieval Europe.
This is a giant crock. In the standard bible, old testi, its standard practice for them to eradicate every living thing Im looking at you Jericho 'Christians hands are force' just analyze this from a militaristic stand point and not your self confirming biases Soldiers dont win wars by dying for their country, they win by making the other side die for theirs To imply either side is 'peaceful' is nutters during literal 'holy war' is dumbfoundingly ignorant of the human's ability to DEHUMANIZE each other for shit as simply as skin, sex LET ALONE religion I grew up in this cult, I escaped this cult, I hope one day you will
I find it repulsive that the french still continue to celebrate Bastille day. The events of the revolution should be shunned, not celebrated...its shameful!
This video is nonsense. This is the equivalent of "dropping 2 atomic bombs on Japan was actually a good thing because it ended the war". Having an opposite view to common knowledge makes you feel special and smarter but it doesn't make you right.
Brilliant. Brilliant. Brilliant. Can’t say anything else about this video. Thank you.
It's killing me how he says "my favorite crusade" like it's a franchise
Obviously, both sides were barbaric hordes spreading their religion by the sword.
Cope
Carl Sagan: "Muh Dark Ages!" The "Dark Ages:" *has the Rosary, the Summas, The Divine Comedy, the Franciscan and Dominican Orders, the Poor Clares, Thomism, Scotism, Saint Bonaventure, the Cistercians, Blessed Charlemagne, Saint Boniface, the Benedictine Orders, the Nobertines, Gregory Palamas (saint in Eastern Orthodoxy, but not in Catholicism), Saints Francis of Assisi, Dominic, Didacus, Bernardino, Malachy, Clare, Bernard, and many based things you might have never heard of*
Man your vocabulary is so hard.
I’ve always thought of Europe from the 400s to 900s as a complete mess and a time you simply would not want to be alive. Shit like Italy being completely destroyed the plague of justinian the Arab invasions the constant war.
Louis the XVth was Louis’ XIVth great-grandson
This was pretty spot on! When I found this phaenomenon I mainly sticked to Hololive JP, (Korone, Watame-as You've shown) they were pretty consistent with quality of talent and content. Sadly the degeneracy is taking over slowly, and fewer and fewer can keep their content pure. From HoloEN I found Ina to be the most wholesome one, mainly doing art and decent stuff. When I first saw her design I was most skeptical, but I think the person behind the character didn't want to take it to weird directions, and now all subsequent outfits are pretty conservative and fits her content.
nah this oss the most biased shit ive ever seen. someone need to make a video criticize the many faults in this video
Good stuff
I started watching Your channel (found it in looking for a Catholic perspective regarding Protestantism) and even before I got to this one, a debunking video was recommended by youtube. Doing my usual quick "check twitter profile" check revealed that youtuber to be- shockingly, I know- a COMMUNIST:D Keep up the good work!
It tried so hard to be anime but not even aniwave and anitaku (AKA gogoanime) fell for the lie.
Actually I would say that they didn't even bother to try making it like anime.
Biased.
The inquisition was mean and messed up
Not a word about Fourth crusade that sacked Constantinople and made muslims able to undermine only real christian empire we all today know as Byzantine Empire! Catholics from Western Europe made it posible for Ottomans to come to Vienna because those same Catholics destroyed Orthodox Christian Empire that stood between Christendom and Islam! Shame on you!
The Eldians are abused and exploited by a subverisive race with an atrocity story invented to justify it Whatever could the Japanese have meant by this?
The time has come for a whole new set of crusades
Please do one on Toledo Js.
You forgot to mention that crusaders killed other Christians that weren't catholics.
You forgot that this is lie since nestorians are as christian as muslims Also arent the muslims ones that fought sunni vs shia?
Peaceful Christians, ha, ha.
Saladin is consider by many to be slave trader and devil
Ever since learning the truth about the Crusades as a European, I have changed my mindset a lot. Our ancestors weren’t the savages-the Jihadists were and still are. Christianity has since become peaceful and accepting (even lax) whilst Islam has never stopped being full of hatred, violence and the clear goal to destroy all infidels. I feel immense gratitude for these brave (if ruthless) men who protected Europe and paved the way for us. Europeans must remember how much our ancestors have fought for. They weren’t given this land. They defended it for centuries. I’m filled with love and respect for their sacrifices.
Well done!
As a former Hentai Addict and the path to recovery is difficult but still better than when i didn't start. I'll say this. Hentai addiction is horrifying giving this obscure view of what sex is and it just gets worse as you go down this path of sexual immorality. But sure temptations come and go but its best that you dont feed onto them
I like your stuff. I would love to see you do a video on the Bolshevik Revolution
This video deserves way more views. Thank you for this great work, Pax Tube - God Bless!
If you ever wondered where the blight that is marxism came from...
The crusades where more than righteous
The crusades were an illegal invasion. Just as bad as muslims.
It is like saying that USA invasion in france was illegal xD
The crusades arent somthing you cant paint as one side good and one side bad. Both sides had flashes of horrible atrocities and heroic valor. Its far too complicated to just say Muslim Bad Christan good or vise versa. Also blaming the dark age soley on the islamic world is a bit dishonest as much of the devstation wrought during that time was from the churches within europe supressing knowledge and northern and slavic invasion and general infighting.
4:11 come on man islam prohibited slavery now not then, please understand the religion before you make any video. All respect
XDDD then why muslims were selling biggest ammount of slaves?
2:15 ok i still haven't seen the whole video but this information has no meaning. Islam roughly started at 630 AD after the conquer of mecca
Sagan was Jewish, I'm shocked I tells ya.
Wikipedia also has a pedophile bias.
It doesn't have to be about race; weak people with low character can be easily influenced by people smarter than them with an agenda. Victimhood is encouraged by the enemies of a peaceful, cohesive society. Some with power thrive when a population are constantly divided.
The devil and his “people “ them you know…… do not want Christians to unite and fight against his lies
Not all of them were good, the children s crusade was not awesome, well it wasn't actually a crusade, cause it never got approved by the pope, but almost everyone calls it a crusade
Best explanation ever keep this kind of energy but there will be many haters who can't accept the truth
These comments be like “I live in an overwhelmingly Christian country where Christianity specifically is extra special and protected by society, the government, the police, and the churches, where atheists are called immoral Satan worshippers and Muslims are called terrorists, but…I’m just sick of the anti-Christian rhetoric I heard was happening.”
These people really are so lost, it's crazy. I'm not even sure how shit like this gets recommended to me either, I'm just clicking to see if people are still sane, and while the shit that keeps getting upvoted is usually unhinged, at least it's good to know that some recent comments still have some semblance of sanity.
and muslims continue to persecute christians
0:00 Intro 1:49 France Before Revolution 8:08 Influence of the Enlightenment 12:08 The Revolution Begins 19:48 The Reign of Terror 25:22 The Revolution Winds Down 27:18 Conclusion
00:02 French Revolution was more complex than a simple oppression narrative 02:14 France was a prosperous and influential nation prior to the revolution. 06:44 The decline in religious standards and the rise of Freemasonry in France 08:57 Debate over government's role and individual freedom during the Enlightenment 13:12 The French Revolution escalated due to inequality and mob violence. 15:15 The National Assembly made catastrophic mistakes in 1790 19:12 Radicalization of the French Revolution 21:07 The French Revolution's brutal tactics led to mass killings and a lack of accountability. 24:53 The reign of terror during the French Revolution led to the downfall of the Jacobins. 26:51 French Revolution led to unexpected consequences French Revolution was more complex than a simple oppression narrative - The Revolution involved a mix of shifting allegiances and complex conflicts - Events of the Revolution had both positive improvements and damaging consequences France was a prosperous and influential nation prior to the revolution. - France faced challenges in reforming its institutions due to industrialization, mass literacy, and population growth. - France's financial problems, exacerbated by wars and excessive spending, led to a deep debt crisis. The decline in religious standards and the rise of Freemasonry in France - The increase in Masonic lodges and Freemason leaders in the coming Revolution - The decline of religious standards and the impact of the Age of Enlightenment Debate over government's role and individual freedom during the Enlightenment - The Enlightenment emphasized science and reason, sparking debates on government purpose and public involvement. - Enlightenment thinkers clashed with traditional views on man's nature and freedom, promoting new ideas. The French Revolution escalated due to inequality and mob violence. - The Estates General was unable to agree on reforms due to disproportionate voting power favoring the nobility and clergy. - The wealthy bourgeoisie led the radical change, hijacked the National Assembly, and seized church property to address the debt crisis. The National Assembly made catastrophic mistakes in 1790 - The Civil constitution of the clergy law enslaved the Catholic Church under French government control. - Major opposition arose as the majority of Bishops and priests refused the Loyalty oath. Radicalization of the French Revolution - Jacobins took control after September massacres and executed King Louis - Reign of terror began with Committee of Public Safety targeting enemies of Liberty The French Revolution's brutal tactics led to mass killings and a lack of accountability. - The Committee of Public Safety established a harsh regime where anyone suspected of opposition was arrested and executed. - The Rebellion in Vendee, though initially successful, was brutally pacified by the government resulting in over 100,000 civilian deaths. The reign of terror during the French Revolution led to the downfall of the Jacobins. - Moderates retaliated against the Jacobins, leading to a coup and their eventual guillotining. - The Directory took over, but their corruption and military reliance paved the way for Napoleon's dictatorship. French Revolution led to unexpected consequences - Napoleon's defeat in 1815 ended the Revolution, leading to monarchy restoration and a period of political conservatism in Europe - Revolutionaries failed due to a loss of touch with reality and created a system worse than what they overthrew
I hate the debate around the term "dark age". To clarify there is in fact multiple dark ages in multiple periods and places. I feel greek historians use the term best, to describe a gap in time where little recording of what was going on or the records didn't survive, in greek history this woud be post bronze age right before the forming of the city states we think of. I feel the period from roman collapse to the formation of the early medieval kingdoms or possibly even the regin of Charlemagne was a European dark age. Reasons are really simple 1 rome collapsed 2 with the collapse technology critical to large urban infrastructure was lost i.e. running wate via aqueducts 3 areas that were once unified under a single government were now split up into smaller petty kingdoms of germanic barbarians 4 ancient literature like the Odyssey were lost i several areas, this no doubt disrupted the progress of art and literature in greco-roman areas.
CRUSADE 2.0
We are so back.