Пікірлер

• 
  @Allhoney33Ай бұрын

  Indian by birth??? Not by blood??

• 
  @ALavin-en1krАй бұрын

  One of the oldest languages is Sanskrit, most Indo-European languages are based on it. The alphabet of Sanskrit was based on actual sounds at its origin. It was a language that was given. Just the same as water and oxygen were given.

• 
  @user-tl6iu3ee3fАй бұрын

  frist. all the respect to the father of the linguistic moderne and the grammar generative the language :is systems of sings : the photo of the brain : the imagination of our mind ot all the objets and the things and the organisms.....ect the photo physique : it the repersentation of photo of the brain the spoken repersente the specific language with specific environment with specific linguistic second the language it mettre it related with what we want frome this language's frome the language it give personnonalite to human kind what we want like pruprose frome this language's it came fro the existe fro this human kind.

• 
  @xepheru3067Ай бұрын

  They put me in speech therapy classes in kindergarten and the first grade. They used to laugh at me and then they trained it out of me. 😢

• 
  @xepheru3067Ай бұрын

  Yes, we used to play with those sling shots as kids. Juvembers.

• 
  @shilpa87172 ай бұрын

  I really thank modern technology ,for giving me opportunity to listen to Professor Chomsky . From India I can listen to him and I can relate him to our ancient rishi Panini .

• 
  @maxgotts58953 ай бұрын

  Start is 4:45

• 
  @BraniG-psyc033 ай бұрын

  😊😊😊

• 
  @larrymiller98733 ай бұрын

  What year is this

• 
  @BNK24424 ай бұрын

  It is really hard to take seriously a guy who writes an entire article about if it is plausible that taylor swift used the word patriarchy in 2010 or something. This guy's podcast was god damn aweful.

• 
  @moumitasarkar68955 ай бұрын

  Instructive session

• 
  @archana_gamit5 ай бұрын

  It's my privilege to listen to you sir

• 
  @patelsatish17105 ай бұрын

  Dr.SatishKumar Savjibhai Patel Roll number 70, 4th Online Refresher course in Languages, Gujarati Department, Smt.M.C.Desai Arts and Commerce College, Prantij

• 
  @gayatrigovalvanshinanda69215 ай бұрын

  It's always pleasure to listen him... Chomsky contended that the human brain is specially wired for language acquisition. This differed from other linguists, who contended that humans learn language by watching other humans.

• 
  @BraniG-psyc033 ай бұрын

  😊

• 
  @user-di4wn9rk4y5 ай бұрын

  Noam Chomsky discribe important of language in his outstanding lecture. -Dr. Virenkumar Pandya BDK ARTS AND COMMERCE COLLEGE GADHADA

• 
  @Jigarbhatt15885 ай бұрын

  Nice Dr Jigar Bhatt Assistant professor SSSU Veraval

• 
  @rameshvasava45695 ай бұрын

  Very interesting

• 
  @Sarvebhavntusukhinah11115 ай бұрын

  बहुत सुंदर प्रस्तुति ।

• 
  @abhishekkumardarji45345 ай бұрын

  Nice

• 
  @jitendrakumarkharadi6975 ай бұрын

  effective and informative session

• 
  @Sarvebhavntusukhinah11115 ай бұрын

  Good information sir

• 
  @ashvinbarad31025 ай бұрын

  Good

• 
  @meghanadharne74385 ай бұрын

  Very informative session

• 
  @Peter-qz8qs8 ай бұрын

  I'm always finding something new (to me) and amazing on this website.

• 
  @atheoma8 ай бұрын

  awww the kid in the end was adorable 🫶🏼 thanks for sharing, great stuff!

• 
  @carlwhitehair42829 ай бұрын

  America, if you don’t why this tribe is unrecognized, come visit the Hopi village, the Navajos, the Zuni, Pueblo, Utes & you know how real native Americans look, speak, & all the stolen culture taken from them by fake tribes such as this one.

• 
  @ashokkumargashokkumarg331110 ай бұрын

• 
  @robertgloverjr11 ай бұрын

  I've been listening to Chomsky KZread videos daily for nearing a month. On his linguistics side this is by far the best I've viewed yet. It's is such a privilege and blessing to have these imperishable encapsulations of Chomsky at his best available forever.

• 
  @Roofers-Nail-Hardest Жыл бұрын

  It matter matters Noam, when a child says no it means no. Eating dinner w accused child abusers is unacceptable.

• 
  @pasisovi Жыл бұрын

  Chomsky is falling as an authority in linguistic.

• 
  @Brillig2 Жыл бұрын

  I'm glad I found this video. In the '70s I was part of a Ken Pike monolingual demonstration. My role was to hit him with a stick and be hit by him with a stick. I think there was more, but that's what I remember.

• 
  @johnpattipeiluhu441 Жыл бұрын

  Dear the author, do you have the pdf or power point of her presentation that i can download? I am really interested in documenting minor language in Indonesia so it Will bring a great reference for my fieldwork. In addition, I am also a doctoral student in Indonesia so your help Will bring a huge knowledge for my study.

• 
  @yairalkon4944 Жыл бұрын

  4:54 - Dan giving an introduction 7:11 - Are there words in Pirahã for comparing quantities? 7:54 - Did you [Dan] have an appropriate certificate to conduct research on the Pirahã? 12:46 - How accurate are the claims that Pirahã doesn't have any way to mark future or past? 13:39 - What were the 3 instances which you described as attemps to murder you? 16:10 - How accurately does the editing of the interview with Noam Chomsky in the film? And how would you respond to the observation that diversity isn't a proof of a genetic determination? [Regarding universal grammar] 18:53 - Were you allowed to return and visit the Pirahã? 19:31 - Do you think that the lack of recursion in Pirahã is evidence of language being a result of culture and not biology? Their language seems still very ordinary and human to me. 24:57 - Are other linguists allowed or interested to research the Pirahã? 26:53 - What was it like for you to show the film to an audience of linguists? 27:51 - To what extent did your children learn to speak Pirihã? 29:19 - Who chose the film's title? 30:24 - If the Pirahã have no words for color, how do they speak about color? 31:27 - Is it true that anything that can be said in Pirahã can also be whistled? 33:17 - How well do the Pirahã learn Portuguese and it's linguistic elements which are foreign to them? (Such as recursion, counting, color, etc.) 36:49 - Given thousands of languages with recursion, how does the apparent lack of recursion in Pirahã constitute as a proof for recursion not being a fundemental part of language?

• 
  @mattfucella3442 Жыл бұрын

  genuinely the most boring speaker and most boring video i have ever had the displeasure of witnessing and listening to

• 
  @areyeh4979 Жыл бұрын

  What if the native speaker is not that patient?

• 
  @MuantanamoMobile Жыл бұрын

  Then you might have another problem all together.

• 
  @augustosarmentodeoliveira3023 Жыл бұрын

  the coffing is very annoying

• 
  @havefunbesafe Жыл бұрын

  I love how Chomsky can speak on any subject in plain layman terms yet with laser focus clarity…man knows his subject matter.

• 
  @waindayoungthain2147 Жыл бұрын

  🙏🏻 I thought it not completely if’s the truth twisted in deep sense to no one sense😔🥺how’s the freedom to kill and get the money for the business or pandora. I feel sadness and shivering with the rawness attitude aggression of none human, it’s pressing me on selfishness by the government’s, especially with the Palestinians🥺, I cried every time in words for extremist reasons to explain why and what’s happening with the Truth and Religious, tills it’s not happening with with the Israeli government invading annexation the same way for the Russia sovereignty, while they walking in the process of supposedly Vic on no evidence whatsoever 🤥🤥. They are not responding anything about their killing people, robbing, attacking civilians with Warriors sexual aggression togetherness against civilians. How’s the manipulation process going on for the Ukraine 🇺🇦 zero, he is Stu, no thinking, no knowledge whatsoever but got money😔.

• 
  @waindayoungthain2147 Жыл бұрын

  🙏🏻I just going with the consequences of the truth twisted walking with lies being on my concern about each situation, you can make it’s if’s the evidence has leads the Behavior of brutality human are not human😊. Nothing complicated please , but the definition words are not enough for the truth twisted by un human causes for planning purposes that is covered themselves, it’s the theme of the illusion process protecting by their Propaganda🙏🏻. How’s hardest doing with the Un community by your mercy, they trying to destroy and delete me🤥🇺🇳. Or I tried please, they have no vision for the future they are down turn with the historical reverse to revenge for Russia. They have no today so they have No tomorrow. The theme is repeating ways of War’s seeking for money and they are not responding anything or they are the government’s, they are not by their brutality mafia and Nazi Holocaust. How’s fakes to support the World, but they leading the World Nuclear ☢️ Wars ironic attitude towards the Un mission🙏🏻.

• 
  @waindayoungthain2147 Жыл бұрын

  🙏🏻, if’s the political conspiracy has no theories, but it’s exquisite furnishings for the government organization to make for themselves, which there’s no evidence to implement any concrete policy but the human bodies killed. This was your evidence, intentions for getting what the democratic government did? For me if’s it’s the imagination what to do with your self opinion, it’s normal thing they covered to take trouble for humanity, there’s no complications, only the deceiving twisted their political system and Biblical to support themselves views. What’s to explain if’s your expectations are simple, I just explain as it’s been, if’s the process of science is ways of the Cause and Effect process, it’s easy to explain with your behavior seemingly Lab 🧪, and It’s to proven please. How’s no evidence whatsoever for your book 📕 on the Consent of human propaganda🤥🙏🏻. They always lied everything about democratic outlawed and they tried to make its concretely but it’s not. What’s their laboratory 🥼 on human life in effective ways I learned from their brutal rudeness and ignorance about their behavior since they are civilians they have ever been but mount of praise each other’s in violence scenarios, that they are 🙏🏻🤥🤥🤥🤥.

• 
  @sanghitasarkar9626 Жыл бұрын

  It is experience of a lifetime to be able to listen to him.

• 
  @hemantkharadi6342 Жыл бұрын

  Thank you Sir

• 
  @drishyad6237 Жыл бұрын

  A new and enlighted experience of listening Chomsky.. 🙏

• 
  @hemantsuthar8110 Жыл бұрын

  Effective

• 
  @AtriRajgor Жыл бұрын

  સુંદર

• 
  @dr.truptibhavsar9876 Жыл бұрын

  Very nice talk....👏

• 
  @Rajendrakumar_Bambhaniya Жыл бұрын

  Roll No - 76, Rajendrakumar Rameshbhai Bambhaniya, Assistant Professor, Smt. C. R. Gardi Arts College, Munpur, Mahisagar - Gujarat

• 
  @meghanadharne7438 Жыл бұрын

  Very interesting and informative session

• 
  @ramsinhparmar8658 Жыл бұрын

  Very nice,....

• 
  @ravidekani9300 Жыл бұрын

  Informative session 🙏