This is the turning point. She is unseen by the soldiers and represents the "blind eye" the world has of ongoing events. This is the instant when Oscar Schindler turns from being an entrepreneur and becomes a humanitarian.
@galielgwangkellykwon2 күн бұрын
Galiel Gwang is still not allowed to use her real birth name to today, just so that imposters can thieve and steal and cover up kidnaps.
@galielgwangkellykwon2 күн бұрын
Galiel Gwang still gets everything stolen from her every day, being raped and assaulted in a dying City, dying under bad ethos.
@supernovic994 күн бұрын
When i hear people making jokes about hitler or the holocaust, the first thing that comes to my mind is thid movie. The suffering depicted is enough to make me sad
@GreenFuel005 күн бұрын
This scene was much deeper for me. I saw a little girl alone and afraid, too innocent to even understand what's happening. Someone's daughter ripped from her parents, nobody to protect her, left to die alone.. i cried when I saw her running down the street, only scene that truly brought me to tears. What an amazing and well directed movie showcasing the true horrors that took place during the holocaust.
@user-ff4zd7lh3q7 күн бұрын
Is Spielberg going to make a film about hind
@johntechwriter8 күн бұрын
Your subconscious rejection of “2001” is on point. Every person who tells me how wonderful that film is stops cold when I ask them what it was about. Here’s a hint: It’s not about HAL. And you have company. At the film’s original screening for the studio executives, dozens walked out. To understand the movie’s story line, I read Arthur C. Clark’s eponymous novel, and I ended up enjoying the book far more than the movie. When you read the book, the movie makes sense. But at what point is the director indulging to excess the aspect of film making he enjoys most - in Kubrick’s case, cinematography? I suggest that point has been reached if you need to read the book to understand the movie. And even then the movie is seriously flawed. Can you name a character from it? Did you understand the final sequencer? Or did the whole thing strike you as a sterile intellectual exercise, something a chess grand master would be inclined to do? And yes, Kubrick was one. Kubrick’s genius with visuals is beyond question. But visuals are valuable only to the extent they help the audience understand the characters and the story. Since the Stone Age we have been a story-telling species. Stories help us make sense of the world and our lives in it. To those who argue that as a genre science fiction is less emotionally involving than, say, a love story, I give you Ridley Scott. This director knows what visuals are for, and who hasn’t been knocked out by “Alien?” When calling up my science fiction favorites, the top two were directed by Ridley Scott: “Alien,” and what I consider his masterpiece, “Blade Runner.” While exciting visually, their most compelling aspect is the progression of the characters through the story line. During production, Rutger Hauer improvised the film’s legendary moment of existential regret: ” . . . All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain.” The genre where two-dimensional characters are pretty much required is satire, and Kubrick’s “Dr. Strangelove” succeeds brilliantly. But to those whose worship of Kubrick clouds their judgment I offer as proof, “Full Metal Jacket.” What was it about and why was its ending such an anticlimax? In “The Shining,” Kubrick loses control of his lead character, and as a result, Nicholson is so far over the top, I found his performance bordering on comedic. Never have I seen Nicholson so off course. He needed a director like “the little Pole,” Roman Polanski, to rein him in. The result was Jack’s best-ever performance in “Chinatown.” So yes, when assessed in terms of its emotional connection with the audience, “2001” is not a success. Any work of art that fails to establish this bond is doomed to be second rate, regardless of the scenery.
@johntechwriter8 күн бұрын
Spielberg’s weak point - and every director has one - is sentimentality. In this film, just as I thought he was getting the upper hand, in comes the girl in the red coat. Pushing something over the edge and in the process breaking the audience’s suspension of disbelief is known in the business as jumping the shark. Spielberg does it here. Watching Neeson, Fiennes and Kingsley ply their trade got me through the rest of the film.
@margaretgaal93710 күн бұрын
The movie was powerful and haunting when it came out. So many feelings from people. Yet today, where is the care? We are numb and think prayers will help (and it is important to pray) but do we call or do or give to help our neighbor, or an issue impacting women and thus society, or care for another nation in war or attacked in horror (from Oct 7,2024 to present)? The past is a canceled check but today is Our opportunity.
@DEEANNA8812 күн бұрын
I wonder if these people that support Palestine has seen this movie?
@brucekilby995716 күн бұрын
A True masterpiece made by a master. The girl in red is a powerful entity in a film of non entities. Schindlers grave is in Israel,the best way to thank him. Shalom Oscar.🙏🇮🇱😢
@AngelaVlahos17 күн бұрын
I think germany had its reasons
@Geojr81517 күн бұрын
He shouldn’t have wasted all his money to transport those Jews to the other labor camp. The camp he was going to had prisoners that he could have just saved instead while not going broke in the process
@LEEvaibhavyadav18 күн бұрын
I thank god that i wasn't born in that time or lived in that scenario . It was horrible and a pathetic ideology nobody deserves hate or crime and it has no direction but it's just there.
@nadavzip20 күн бұрын
I completely agree with this analysis. That was my opinion about the girl in red ever since I first saw the movie about ten years ago. We have a saying in hebrew which roughly translates to: “each and every individual life is a fully fleshed world”. And that saying is what comes to my mind every time I see the movie, and specifically the girl in red.
@MsDisneylandlover26 күн бұрын
Remember watching this 8s n high school or middle school..
@MsDisneylandlover26 күн бұрын
Powerful movie and scary. Especially songs..blacks n news had it hard. Ppl of all races non whites had it hard smh..
@amandakerley397326 күн бұрын
On a visit to Auschwitz I noticed that in the stacks of shoes, suitcases and clothes it was the red coloured ones that stood out even after all these years! I wondered at the time if that’s where Spielberg got the idea from!
@youchris6726 күн бұрын
World: Help us to defeat Trump and MAGA. They are the reincarnation of Hitler and the Nazis. A disgraced and shamed former US president wants to created a "Unified Reich" in America.
@valloj11826 күн бұрын
And everything started from "student protests against Jews", as usual.
@susannafriman844827 күн бұрын
Red
@salimjouini325529 күн бұрын
there is another girl in red in Palestine
@ljront3126Ай бұрын
People didn’t learn about the holocaust. Just about the film. That’s wrong!
@zyxw200022 күн бұрын
And there are still Holocaust deniers who say it never happened.
@calinutza33Ай бұрын
I can not rewatch it again , one time was enough , I don’t want to cry again , the little girl in red is a beautiful Angel in heaven now !
@insanehybrid35Ай бұрын
I read a theory tyler was the narrators stronger version but at the end of the movie the nafrator is so strong that he doenst need a stronger version
@garystroud1629Ай бұрын
I think Fight Club is telling a spiritual story. The narrator is engaged in some kind of “spiritual materialism” with his yin-yang table and sterile office life. Then, as with prince Siddhartha, he leaves his safe environment and experiences ageing, sickness and death. But the guided meditations don’t bring relief and he creates a false ego in Tyler and tries to punish his body and give up material possessions. Still no good. Eventually he realises that to achieve true enlightenment (and not the premature enlightenment that Tyler refers to) he must kill his ego, dis-illusion himself and encounter reality for what it truly is.
@52benlevyАй бұрын
your cinematic analysis is correct, but the reason for the red girl derives from a testimony of a survivor saying he saw his little girl with a red coat being taken by the nazis. he was observing her getting further and further until she was just a red dot on the horizon fading away. He never saw her again.
@GeorgeDiamond-mf9tdАй бұрын
Do Palestinian lives matter?
@user-ij7rb2wu9o5 күн бұрын
Depends on what you mean by Palestinian
@prakharkumaranand841Ай бұрын
Great video. Great analysis.
@houseofdiamontiАй бұрын
I’ve never seen that movie so to see the part with the little girl was absolutely heartbreaking 💔 💔💔
@hallo2353Ай бұрын
I just finished watching the movie few minutes ago. not gonna lie, the ending scene where Schindler starts to realize he could've saved a few more people if he had flipped the car and the badge made me shed tears.
@bitianiАй бұрын
Im 40 years old and Isaw this movie for the first time tonight. I wasnt preparded for this. Ive never cried before in a movie... Im so angry right now... Germany must pay for thier war crimes!
@zyxw200022 күн бұрын
They did.
@princechidiebere-qu8ghАй бұрын
Did Steven Spielberg say this to you?
@peterswires84392 ай бұрын
Plenty of children murdered in Gaza probably looked like that little girl, and the US Government is happy to help Israel to go on doing it. Rather dilutes this American film director's message.
@zyxw200022 күн бұрын
You're talking only about the ultra-orthodox.
@tesselaynes54282 ай бұрын
When its in black and white it makes you feel that its a machination of your subconscious and not real. Becoming more unreal every generation until it becomes a myth then a legend. Then it happens again because you forgot.
@user-mf6li4sw6n2 ай бұрын
Life never ends . Spirit is in a state of grace forever. God did not create the destructible but the indestructible.
@MahmoudAfgany2 ай бұрын
Think about people in Gaza. Think about the innocent people getting killed every day!
@Kenitso2 ай бұрын
Absolutely heartbreaking.
@MarioFaker2 ай бұрын
30 damn minutes of trailers is what killed it for me
@mrains1002 ай бұрын
A great movie, but I have only seen it once. Can't handle the evil.
@bethhart70332 ай бұрын
Am speechless
@rainold-56082 ай бұрын
A beautiful analysis of a tragic & briliant movie.
@RatedArggg2 ай бұрын
Apparently, the actress who played the little girl was traumatized, not by making the movie, but by people's treatment of her after it was released. They asked her all kinds of questions about the Holocaust.
@desiree62562 ай бұрын
What we personally find horrible and bizarre is that there are a majority of those whom say that they NEVER want a Holocaust to be repeated like this again, BUT YET they don't WANT to visit the concentration camps and HORRIBLY say it was an illusion and NEVER HAPPENED. HELLO!! WAKE UP!! the concentration camps ARE STILL THERE!! 😡
@olgamartinez58552 ай бұрын
So sad 😢I just can’t seem to understand why.
@kerryharrison38062 ай бұрын
I recently watched a film called Remember Me which starred Robert Pattinson. The story uses a similar device in its telling of the 9/11 attacks on the WTC. It poignantly reminds us of the humanity of the individual which is usually lost in the statistics of the event.
@davidwild22 ай бұрын
One of the most appalling decisions of his career.
@PredestinedtowinforJesus2 ай бұрын
If one person can matter, it makes all the other lives in the film matter 🌹
@AnaM77772 ай бұрын
The girl in red is heartbreaking, total sadness, & the death of innocence.
@lalouyaakoubi31843 ай бұрын
Sadly the history is repeating itself, and an ongoing genocide is happening at gaza . But the man kind don't learn from history. God save gaza from this genocide. Every life matter independently of the religion and nationality
Пікірлер
This is the turning point. She is unseen by the soldiers and represents the "blind eye" the world has of ongoing events. This is the instant when Oscar Schindler turns from being an entrepreneur and becomes a humanitarian.
Galiel Gwang is still not allowed to use her real birth name to today, just so that imposters can thieve and steal and cover up kidnaps.
Galiel Gwang still gets everything stolen from her every day, being raped and assaulted in a dying City, dying under bad ethos.
When i hear people making jokes about hitler or the holocaust, the first thing that comes to my mind is thid movie. The suffering depicted is enough to make me sad
This scene was much deeper for me. I saw a little girl alone and afraid, too innocent to even understand what's happening. Someone's daughter ripped from her parents, nobody to protect her, left to die alone.. i cried when I saw her running down the street, only scene that truly brought me to tears. What an amazing and well directed movie showcasing the true horrors that took place during the holocaust.
Is Spielberg going to make a film about hind
Your subconscious rejection of “2001” is on point. Every person who tells me how wonderful that film is stops cold when I ask them what it was about. Here’s a hint: It’s not about HAL. And you have company. At the film’s original screening for the studio executives, dozens walked out. To understand the movie’s story line, I read Arthur C. Clark’s eponymous novel, and I ended up enjoying the book far more than the movie. When you read the book, the movie makes sense. But at what point is the director indulging to excess the aspect of film making he enjoys most - in Kubrick’s case, cinematography? I suggest that point has been reached if you need to read the book to understand the movie. And even then the movie is seriously flawed. Can you name a character from it? Did you understand the final sequencer? Or did the whole thing strike you as a sterile intellectual exercise, something a chess grand master would be inclined to do? And yes, Kubrick was one. Kubrick’s genius with visuals is beyond question. But visuals are valuable only to the extent they help the audience understand the characters and the story. Since the Stone Age we have been a story-telling species. Stories help us make sense of the world and our lives in it. To those who argue that as a genre science fiction is less emotionally involving than, say, a love story, I give you Ridley Scott. This director knows what visuals are for, and who hasn’t been knocked out by “Alien?” When calling up my science fiction favorites, the top two were directed by Ridley Scott: “Alien,” and what I consider his masterpiece, “Blade Runner.” While exciting visually, their most compelling aspect is the progression of the characters through the story line. During production, Rutger Hauer improvised the film’s legendary moment of existential regret: ” . . . All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain.” The genre where two-dimensional characters are pretty much required is satire, and Kubrick’s “Dr. Strangelove” succeeds brilliantly. But to those whose worship of Kubrick clouds their judgment I offer as proof, “Full Metal Jacket.” What was it about and why was its ending such an anticlimax? In “The Shining,” Kubrick loses control of his lead character, and as a result, Nicholson is so far over the top, I found his performance bordering on comedic. Never have I seen Nicholson so off course. He needed a director like “the little Pole,” Roman Polanski, to rein him in. The result was Jack’s best-ever performance in “Chinatown.” So yes, when assessed in terms of its emotional connection with the audience, “2001” is not a success. Any work of art that fails to establish this bond is doomed to be second rate, regardless of the scenery.
Spielberg’s weak point - and every director has one - is sentimentality. In this film, just as I thought he was getting the upper hand, in comes the girl in the red coat. Pushing something over the edge and in the process breaking the audience’s suspension of disbelief is known in the business as jumping the shark. Spielberg does it here. Watching Neeson, Fiennes and Kingsley ply their trade got me through the rest of the film.
The movie was powerful and haunting when it came out. So many feelings from people. Yet today, where is the care? We are numb and think prayers will help (and it is important to pray) but do we call or do or give to help our neighbor, or an issue impacting women and thus society, or care for another nation in war or attacked in horror (from Oct 7,2024 to present)? The past is a canceled check but today is Our opportunity.
I wonder if these people that support Palestine has seen this movie?
A True masterpiece made by a master. The girl in red is a powerful entity in a film of non entities. Schindlers grave is in Israel,the best way to thank him. Shalom Oscar.🙏🇮🇱😢
I think germany had its reasons
He shouldn’t have wasted all his money to transport those Jews to the other labor camp. The camp he was going to had prisoners that he could have just saved instead while not going broke in the process
I thank god that i wasn't born in that time or lived in that scenario . It was horrible and a pathetic ideology nobody deserves hate or crime and it has no direction but it's just there.
I completely agree with this analysis. That was my opinion about the girl in red ever since I first saw the movie about ten years ago. We have a saying in hebrew which roughly translates to: “each and every individual life is a fully fleshed world”. And that saying is what comes to my mind every time I see the movie, and specifically the girl in red.
Remember watching this 8s n high school or middle school..
Powerful movie and scary. Especially songs..blacks n news had it hard. Ppl of all races non whites had it hard smh..
On a visit to Auschwitz I noticed that in the stacks of shoes, suitcases and clothes it was the red coloured ones that stood out even after all these years! I wondered at the time if that’s where Spielberg got the idea from!
World: Help us to defeat Trump and MAGA. They are the reincarnation of Hitler and the Nazis. A disgraced and shamed former US president wants to created a "Unified Reich" in America.
And everything started from "student protests against Jews", as usual.
Red
there is another girl in red in Palestine
People didn’t learn about the holocaust. Just about the film. That’s wrong!
And there are still Holocaust deniers who say it never happened.
I can not rewatch it again , one time was enough , I don’t want to cry again , the little girl in red is a beautiful Angel in heaven now !
I read a theory tyler was the narrators stronger version but at the end of the movie the nafrator is so strong that he doenst need a stronger version
I think Fight Club is telling a spiritual story. The narrator is engaged in some kind of “spiritual materialism” with his yin-yang table and sterile office life. Then, as with prince Siddhartha, he leaves his safe environment and experiences ageing, sickness and death. But the guided meditations don’t bring relief and he creates a false ego in Tyler and tries to punish his body and give up material possessions. Still no good. Eventually he realises that to achieve true enlightenment (and not the premature enlightenment that Tyler refers to) he must kill his ego, dis-illusion himself and encounter reality for what it truly is.
your cinematic analysis is correct, but the reason for the red girl derives from a testimony of a survivor saying he saw his little girl with a red coat being taken by the nazis. he was observing her getting further and further until she was just a red dot on the horizon fading away. He never saw her again.
Do Palestinian lives matter?
Depends on what you mean by Palestinian
Great video. Great analysis.
I’ve never seen that movie so to see the part with the little girl was absolutely heartbreaking 💔 💔💔
I just finished watching the movie few minutes ago. not gonna lie, the ending scene where Schindler starts to realize he could've saved a few more people if he had flipped the car and the badge made me shed tears.
Im 40 years old and Isaw this movie for the first time tonight. I wasnt preparded for this. Ive never cried before in a movie... Im so angry right now... Germany must pay for thier war crimes!
They did.
Did Steven Spielberg say this to you?
Plenty of children murdered in Gaza probably looked like that little girl, and the US Government is happy to help Israel to go on doing it. Rather dilutes this American film director's message.
You're talking only about the ultra-orthodox.
When its in black and white it makes you feel that its a machination of your subconscious and not real. Becoming more unreal every generation until it becomes a myth then a legend. Then it happens again because you forgot.
Life never ends . Spirit is in a state of grace forever. God did not create the destructible but the indestructible.
Think about people in Gaza. Think about the innocent people getting killed every day!
Absolutely heartbreaking.
30 damn minutes of trailers is what killed it for me
A great movie, but I have only seen it once. Can't handle the evil.
Am speechless
A beautiful analysis of a tragic & briliant movie.
Apparently, the actress who played the little girl was traumatized, not by making the movie, but by people's treatment of her after it was released. They asked her all kinds of questions about the Holocaust.
What we personally find horrible and bizarre is that there are a majority of those whom say that they NEVER want a Holocaust to be repeated like this again, BUT YET they don't WANT to visit the concentration camps and HORRIBLY say it was an illusion and NEVER HAPPENED. HELLO!! WAKE UP!! the concentration camps ARE STILL THERE!! 😡
So sad 😢I just can’t seem to understand why.
I recently watched a film called Remember Me which starred Robert Pattinson. The story uses a similar device in its telling of the 9/11 attacks on the WTC. It poignantly reminds us of the humanity of the individual which is usually lost in the statistics of the event.
One of the most appalling decisions of his career.
If one person can matter, it makes all the other lives in the film matter 🌹
The girl in red is heartbreaking, total sadness, & the death of innocence.
Sadly the history is repeating itself, and an ongoing genocide is happening at gaza . But the man kind don't learn from history. God save gaza from this genocide. Every life matter independently of the religion and nationality