What happened to the harmonica player. He changed his hair. The sound is passable. The only original member is him. So he is vision is gone. To bad. That band was tight. This looks like three individuals . The suits the hair. The jackets just don't belong.
@camraz753 күн бұрын
lol not sure what happend to the harmonica player the sound was missed. I know the bass player has passed away recently. and gordie is big sugar
@scottsevertson180325 күн бұрын
power trio RULES !
@garysonnex514027 күн бұрын
Put some jeans and a black t shirt on and leather jacket and grow your hair. Loose the beard. He looks pretty. What happened to the harmonica. I know it's live but yuk.
@scottsevertson180316 күн бұрын
really ?! this is the SHIT
@garysonnex514027 күн бұрын
Get rid of the fancy suits the stupid Mohawk. He looks like a gay fashion plate. Instead of a rockstar. The video for this song makes this look awful. I like big sugar but this performance sounds and looks like they are trying too hard to be cool and are looking old.
@solarguy13242 ай бұрын
Old men should not wear sleevless shirts.
@JessicaTanner-fq7zu3 ай бұрын
Party boys!
@garysonnex51404 күн бұрын
I'm not sorry. The latter is him and musicians. The previous is a tight group. 😅 The latter looks like something out of . KC and Sunshine band. Yuk..
@longsnapper53813 ай бұрын
Love their music but Ed's a tool......
@bobmarchetti88784 ай бұрын
Lucky??? Lol
@CebuShortRides6 ай бұрын
Wohooo!! cant wait to see CS this 2024!
@buccaneersfan13787 ай бұрын
Edwin still got it
@bradwebster69527 ай бұрын
This has got to be the most boring rock band ever. The music just doesn't go any where
@shawness939 ай бұрын
The lead vocals are a bit rough these days
@darrenchichak4429 ай бұрын
OMG!!!!!!!!!! SO UNDER RATED!!!!!!! LOVE EDWIN , I MOTHER EARTH !!!! WHEN THEY WERE THE MOTHERS!!!!!!!! GOD BLESS AND GOD SPEED
@BrianMason100010 ай бұрын
His voice is hatched and he has to read all the lyrics!
@loudtowncar8 ай бұрын
Can you explain?
@BrianMason10008 ай бұрын
Explain what? He can’t sing or remember the words!
@BrianMason10008 ай бұрын
@@loudtowncarhe can’t sing or remember his words!
@loudtowncar8 ай бұрын
@@BrianMason1000 we all get older.
@eljenfajardo380910 ай бұрын
just saw them tonight in Edmonton. Wow they put on a really good show! My favorite band of all time!
@ratutora775411 ай бұрын
Hope they come to Brisbane
@tman666311 ай бұрын
Seeing them in Edmonton next week, Aug 27…so pumped!
@user-bx4mh4fz1r11 ай бұрын
Great Music
@adamlee73011 ай бұрын
I saw them live on February 28th, 2023 at Seaworld, Orlando, they were so good, they closed with Run, and for my first ever live concert, i was so happy it was Collective Soul
@ekarukin3 ай бұрын
you will look back at it 50 years from now and it will still be one of the best shows to catch in a life time
@betterthandeadohyea450011 ай бұрын
Canada? Blessed? Welcome to Communism.
@shanefarrow692811 ай бұрын
Pretty decent recording Mr. G & M guy !! lol
@camraz7511 ай бұрын
how did you find me on here?
@shanefarrow692811 ай бұрын
Just showed up ! lol
@BlazingShackles11 ай бұрын
Just saw them last night in San Diego. Was everything I expected and more, WOW!
@Julie-yw9dz11 ай бұрын
😊😅😊😅
@brandonwilsonwilson4046 Жыл бұрын
I love this song
@woodyalexander1224 Жыл бұрын
Collective Soul freakin ROCKS
@Miguel_2112 Жыл бұрын
This band was never the same without Master Guitarist 🎸 Ross Childress 🎸. Now they're just ok. Not even 3 guitarists can replace Ross Childress.
@BlazingShackles11 ай бұрын
no doubt ross was great but go to their concert and you will change your mind.
@Miguel_211211 ай бұрын
@@BlazingShackles I saw them (3) times with Ross, and one time after Ross, and I thought they were definitely not the same, they were weak and the guitar riffs we're short. I stand behind my comment by saying they were never the same .
@BlazingShackles11 ай бұрын
@@Miguel_2112 of course not the "same". would Rush be the same with Ringo Star on drums?
@Miguel_211211 ай бұрын
@@BlazingShackles I've seen more then 300+ concerts and when a band member leaves or dies, the groups are never the same and usually not as good.
@BlazingShackles11 ай бұрын
@@Miguel_2112 well obviously you are not open to alternate opinions, you're ego is too big. good luck to you sir.
@theyettifromcanada3688 Жыл бұрын
And brilliant recording of this too Mr Ray!!!!
@camraz75 Жыл бұрын
Why thank you!
@theyettifromcanada3688 Жыл бұрын
I'm looking forward to seeing them here in Saskatoon soon. I'd like to make a few trips to enjoy seeing them a few times. They rock and love the audience interaction.
@teresabatz Жыл бұрын
P r o m o S M
@claudiarae6892 Жыл бұрын
❤️🔥💋❤️🔥💋
@claudiarae6892 Жыл бұрын
Ed has the BEST hair! ❤❤
@steelvalleywoofstock7371 Жыл бұрын
Of all the concerts I've seen over my lifetime, this was by far my favorite close and walkoff I have seen. We had goosebumps in Warren, Ohio. I had forgotten how much I loved this song. Thanks for sharing.
@aminudinthsiregar1775 Жыл бұрын
Thanks for sharing...
@samultraflame2043 Жыл бұрын
I'm glad you recorded this because my camera sucked at the concert, it was my first and it was damn good!
@camraz75 Жыл бұрын
no prob i recored a great copy of shine and my card went full with about 15 second left in the song
@camraz75 Жыл бұрын
check out my pictures from the show facebook.com/camraz1975
@warmonger8799 Жыл бұрын
Jude 🤬
@cecilcrawdad Жыл бұрын
Another song ruined by a cellphone.
@sandraweilbrenner67 Жыл бұрын
I just subbed. Great version of this song.
@camraz75 Жыл бұрын
Thanks
@delainiebetts3844 Жыл бұрын
I was standing beside you
@penknight85322 жыл бұрын
Selling you dumb idiot... Selling not Smoking. Good job ruining this song.
@pattyboy91832 жыл бұрын
who is that guy dressed up in a star wars costume at 6:52
@camraz752 жыл бұрын
it was on Halloween. He came out at the beginning with a mic and you thought it was raine
@pattyboy91832 жыл бұрын
@@camraz75 oh ok
@kevinnason36383 жыл бұрын
Love this
@ant-13823 жыл бұрын
High energy rock and roll, thats what I like!! None of this nanby pamby crap on the air waves today.
@rjf70233 жыл бұрын
6:30 i think he made a lyric mistake. He said "Nothing" for the part in the chorus that goes "nothing, nothing.. but i " however, he caught himself after the first "nothing" and carried on correctly with: I found out... what when wrong" etc.
@burtreynolds29693 жыл бұрын
What venue?
@camraz753 жыл бұрын
Center in the square
@melodymartin17234 жыл бұрын
Oh my god! So flat!! And where was the energy???
@SuperPineboy4 жыл бұрын
ED LANE
@patriotrising62144 жыл бұрын
My new favorite band !
@JohnDoe-qu7gm4 жыл бұрын
Holy crap!!! This is the person who sung that awesome song? Wtf was that?!?!? If you sound that bad live you shouldn’t be able to cash checks for a kick ass recorded song. Awful!!!
@joshuamcinnis57704 жыл бұрын
he sounds awful here, but I saw them in September and he sounded fantastic. must've been a bad night
@jessecerasus96212 жыл бұрын
@@joshuamcinnis5770 he took off his in ear in the beginning. shit. he couldn't hear the song, he knew that would be painful.
@gaboquintana36285 жыл бұрын
Did the "band" became ... and then they were 2 ??
@ethanwalker8565 жыл бұрын
I could have done without the delay pedal noodling in the beginning. Singer sounds about as good as he ever did live IMO, which is to say not as good as studio version.
Пікірлер
What happened to the harmonica player. He changed his hair. The sound is passable. The only original member is him. So he is vision is gone. To bad. That band was tight. This looks like three individuals . The suits the hair. The jackets just don't belong.
lol not sure what happend to the harmonica player the sound was missed. I know the bass player has passed away recently. and gordie is big sugar
power trio RULES !
Put some jeans and a black t shirt on and leather jacket and grow your hair. Loose the beard. He looks pretty. What happened to the harmonica. I know it's live but yuk.
really ?! this is the SHIT
Get rid of the fancy suits the stupid Mohawk. He looks like a gay fashion plate. Instead of a rockstar. The video for this song makes this look awful. I like big sugar but this performance sounds and looks like they are trying too hard to be cool and are looking old.
Old men should not wear sleevless shirts.
Party boys!
I'm not sorry. The latter is him and musicians. The previous is a tight group. 😅 The latter looks like something out of . KC and Sunshine band. Yuk..
Love their music but Ed's a tool......
Lucky??? Lol
Wohooo!! cant wait to see CS this 2024!
Edwin still got it
This has got to be the most boring rock band ever. The music just doesn't go any where
The lead vocals are a bit rough these days
OMG!!!!!!!!!! SO UNDER RATED!!!!!!! LOVE EDWIN , I MOTHER EARTH !!!! WHEN THEY WERE THE MOTHERS!!!!!!!! GOD BLESS AND GOD SPEED
His voice is hatched and he has to read all the lyrics!
Can you explain?
Explain what? He can’t sing or remember the words!
@@loudtowncarhe can’t sing or remember his words!
@@BrianMason1000 we all get older.
just saw them tonight in Edmonton. Wow they put on a really good show! My favorite band of all time!
Hope they come to Brisbane
Seeing them in Edmonton next week, Aug 27…so pumped!
Great Music
I saw them live on February 28th, 2023 at Seaworld, Orlando, they were so good, they closed with Run, and for my first ever live concert, i was so happy it was Collective Soul
you will look back at it 50 years from now and it will still be one of the best shows to catch in a life time
Canada? Blessed? Welcome to Communism.
Pretty decent recording Mr. G & M guy !! lol
how did you find me on here?
Just showed up ! lol
Just saw them last night in San Diego. Was everything I expected and more, WOW!
😊😅😊😅
I love this song
Collective Soul freakin ROCKS
This band was never the same without Master Guitarist 🎸 Ross Childress 🎸. Now they're just ok. Not even 3 guitarists can replace Ross Childress.
no doubt ross was great but go to their concert and you will change your mind.
@@BlazingShackles I saw them (3) times with Ross, and one time after Ross, and I thought they were definitely not the same, they were weak and the guitar riffs we're short. I stand behind my comment by saying they were never the same .
@@Miguel_2112 of course not the "same". would Rush be the same with Ringo Star on drums?
@@BlazingShackles I've seen more then 300+ concerts and when a band member leaves or dies, the groups are never the same and usually not as good.
@@Miguel_2112 well obviously you are not open to alternate opinions, you're ego is too big. good luck to you sir.
And brilliant recording of this too Mr Ray!!!!
Why thank you!
I'm looking forward to seeing them here in Saskatoon soon. I'd like to make a few trips to enjoy seeing them a few times. They rock and love the audience interaction.
P r o m o S M
❤️🔥💋❤️🔥💋
Ed has the BEST hair! ❤❤
Of all the concerts I've seen over my lifetime, this was by far my favorite close and walkoff I have seen. We had goosebumps in Warren, Ohio. I had forgotten how much I loved this song. Thanks for sharing.
Thanks for sharing...
I'm glad you recorded this because my camera sucked at the concert, it was my first and it was damn good!
no prob i recored a great copy of shine and my card went full with about 15 second left in the song
check out my pictures from the show facebook.com/camraz1975
Jude 🤬
Another song ruined by a cellphone.
I just subbed. Great version of this song.
Thanks
I was standing beside you
Selling you dumb idiot... Selling not Smoking. Good job ruining this song.
who is that guy dressed up in a star wars costume at 6:52
it was on Halloween. He came out at the beginning with a mic and you thought it was raine
@@camraz75 oh ok
Love this
High energy rock and roll, thats what I like!! None of this nanby pamby crap on the air waves today.
6:30 i think he made a lyric mistake. He said "Nothing" for the part in the chorus that goes "nothing, nothing.. but i " however, he caught himself after the first "nothing" and carried on correctly with: I found out... what when wrong" etc.
What venue?
Center in the square
Oh my god! So flat!! And where was the energy???
ED LANE
My new favorite band !
Holy crap!!! This is the person who sung that awesome song? Wtf was that?!?!? If you sound that bad live you shouldn’t be able to cash checks for a kick ass recorded song. Awful!!!
he sounds awful here, but I saw them in September and he sounded fantastic. must've been a bad night
@@joshuamcinnis5770 he took off his in ear in the beginning. shit. he couldn't hear the song, he knew that would be painful.
Did the "band" became ... and then they were 2 ??
I could have done without the delay pedal noodling in the beginning. Singer sounds about as good as he ever did live IMO, which is to say not as good as studio version.
Yeah, kinda cringey pretentiousness....