You better bet I've been waiting for this analysis of RM's MV!!! I know your takes will make me think and realize so much! You're very appreciated!
@cutemew1517 сағат бұрын
Amazing explanation!
@samnu75198 сағат бұрын
Omg that’s so good explained
@nj.732511 сағат бұрын
The lyrics spring's always been here, I will sleep in her eyes reminds me of the lyrics to Change ft Wale. "I see grass growing in winter's eyes." In that song, it was about having hope in your perspective even though your current situation is cold/despairing/winter. So to me that lyric says 'spring/hope has always been here, i can finally rest in her perspective' some people think spring's always been here is joons way of convincing himself that nothing is wrong and he can stay in the familiarity without having to leave. and that the line you are my pain, divine, divine is about growth and finding yourself being painful and repetitive but ultimately important, right for you, and true. I like that interpretation too.
@nj.732511 сағат бұрын
This is amazing! It showed me a part I missed. I do also think that actually maybe he leaves right place wrong person for wrong place right person, because the maze we only see disconcerting half-rooms so something is still not quite right. a continuing loop of self-discovery and the call to come back to me
@DianaRamirez-sm5nxКүн бұрын
58.7k subscriber here❤
@bookishtheories18 сағат бұрын
Welcome!! 🥰💙
@fathinaleeya8466Күн бұрын
i....was so so so impressed..like bfr iam just like okay this is seventeen`s nes song but now...wow what a masterpiece..
@blairscott3863Күн бұрын
The first part of video is about finding direction and purpose. The second part is about finally finding yourself
@Sesamsesam59Күн бұрын
I loved your explanation !
@penelopepitstockКүн бұрын
Beautiful - love this interpretation! 💜
@DarkWing494Күн бұрын
This is my comment to the video before knowing anything concrete. "To me he is traveling with his other personalities. A cool/boss one, a kid/scared one, a happy go lucky/positive one, a logical/want to figure put things one and RM the one who made it in the spotlight. I think when he see things he can see from many perspectives of him same time. So he is getting lost on how he should juggle his perspective. Ofcourse I could be totally off but it's how I interpret this MV."
@ilavila714Күн бұрын
You did a great job with the timeline but I think you made a small mistake regarding the werewolves. Sure, they are getting closer in 2002/03, but on Twitter, they posted on January 22nd about the boys setting off to another place. They left Greyville on September 3rd, 2000, which means that Khan meeting the others happend around some (maybe 1 or 2) months ago. And because TGC is taking place 20 years before Riverfield, the werewolves settled to Riverfield in 2020 before the vampire boys. This also explains why they lost their winning streak in nightball. ;)
@kellyhudson6452Күн бұрын
Brilliant analysis!
@LazyFluffКүн бұрын
You always manage to make MVs so relatable, thank you
@susieangelo64102 күн бұрын
People: Please put on the CC to catch up on the extremely-fast-speed explanation of this Video -- which her Theory is very good, to say the least. 😉
@laurahilliker53362 күн бұрын
@Bookish Theories, The last sequence of numbers on the elevator which is12523222 This is what my theory is if you were to add up 1+2+5+2+3=13 The next sequence of numbers are triple 2s add them up is 2+2+2=6 answer is 6/13 which is the debut month and day and also the year 2013 but if you write it 6/13/13 BTS‘s debut date! Course this is just my mathematical theory I don’t know if that is correct but it seems logical !?😊💜 what do you think ARMY?
@susieangelo64102 күн бұрын
Thank you for solving the "Mystery" which you made the perfect sense of it all.
@bookishtheories18 сағат бұрын
Love this explanation, thank you for solving it! 🫶🏻🥰
@exploring_k12542 күн бұрын
Mrs Ma'am!!! You are a genius. I've always enjoyed your deep dives videos, you are actually such a big part of my process to become ARMY ^^ Namjoon is so cool honestly! it's moments like these that I find that the best part about being ARMY is growing up together with the boys and relating to their life journeys even though we live in different realities.
@ichi_san2 күн бұрын
this is a very good analysis of both the view point of a toxic lover seductress who is yanking their partner on a very dangerous tightrope on purpose, toying with how they can both help and ruin them. but i also love how you focus on how the song can also be an inner conflict between darker and lighter sides of Selugi. the idea of good, dark and balance is PERFECT
@dreester2 күн бұрын
AMAZING JOB! Thank you so much for your analysis 💜🙌
@pilaraneiros63092 күн бұрын
Brilliant! Thank you so much for your analysis. You helped me to notice some details that I didn't realize before. Great job and explanation.
@nougat752 күн бұрын
I was looking forward to your video because there was definitely a lot to discuss about this MV! Thank you so much as always <3 Apart from the interesting meaning and the artistry, I also loved how fun and absurd the MV looked. I think it is one of my favorite music videos ever!
@bethelliot71402 күн бұрын
Wow! This is soo helpful! 🤯💜
@user-gt6el2vz1q2 күн бұрын
Thank you for helping me understand his artistry!
@gretchend68232 күн бұрын
Thank you so much. 💜
@saoirseandreapatriciacrowl5062 күн бұрын
The members near to Namjoon on lost video are all men and a woman right??
@saoirseandreapatriciacrowl5062 күн бұрын
Namjoon being in a labyrinth to find yourself it's an amazing concept and part of lost video scenario as well
@saoirseandreapatriciacrowl5062 күн бұрын
I feel I don't belong in my neighborhood because they're some rude crazy people and crackheads or people who is obsessed with having family and kids and I'm not like them. I feel like I don't belong to my neighborhood but I have met nice and interesting people worldwide who make me feel that I belong
@siggispock51022 күн бұрын
Thank you! When I saw the reference to "nowhere" and "42" I laughed loud. Yes, that is the one aspect of looking at the world, one I can identify with a lot. Maybe I should explain for younger ppl: A hitchhikers guide through the galaxy is a book by Douglas Adams published in 1979. They have this gigantic computer which is supposed to elaborate on the sense of life. They wait and wait until the answer finally comes out. The answer is: 42. Another adorably idea is a computer who suffers from depression and threatens to pull his plug. We couldn't stop laughing because we had been so intense on changing the world for the better and then: 42.
@cct28252 күн бұрын
This was EXCELLENT, thank you!
@noemibernal48822 күн бұрын
Thanks for the analysis. Really great, as usual 💜 And you helped me realise that one of the places he explores is the archive, or rkive, his Insta name, which made me chuckle 😄
@sunshine-pp6jc2 күн бұрын
I still don't understand 😢😢😢
@niasetian20062 күн бұрын
Wait i just realizing that lipstick part! What if the stranger that ymenehcra meet is sua?! Sua have lipstick in the mv!
@jessicawerling94952 күн бұрын
OHMYGOSH OHMYGOSH OHMYGOSH!!! THANK YOU!!! I've been dying to talk and understand this video and you just confirmed and helped my brain soooo much!!!
@ananyaa66642 күн бұрын
This was a great analysis! Thank you once again Bookish Theories!
@msnim80262 күн бұрын
❤❤❤❤❤
@kimsunoobaragui2 күн бұрын
I love your explanations so much, I can understand better and from a very mature point of view, thank you.
@bhaktichaudhary17972 күн бұрын
As always, amazing analysis! I have always felt that Namjoon, more than any other of the guys, has struggled to find his identity amongst all the public experiences they are having. Sometimes I feel like they were all overwhelmed, and I hope we as fans have not added to their pain. But Namjoon more than the others talks about being trapped in these endless circles of self examination without exit. I think he can take some comfort from the fact that nothing stays the same. It can be a sad fact, but also a good one. If he is going round and round in his self journey, he can remember that just living, experiencing, and aging changes our perspectives. One day, he will see it all differently, and maybe feel Better
@ananyaa66642 күн бұрын
Your comment made me tear up! I cannot help but feel sad thinking we might also have contributed to his pain with our almost smothering love? Anyway, I hope he does take comfort in the idea that change and transience are truths that cannot be denied!
@siggispock51022 күн бұрын
I am not sure I would call it an "endless circle of self examination".This would be true for someone suffering from depression. Self examination is sth positive, desirable, ongoing. What I do understand is that he is trapped in his role, the expectation of the outside world (including fans, especially fans) and with this album he tries to get out of it (at least for those who are interested). He was so exited in one vlive when he said he was working on sth new. I hope the majority of fans will not just ignore it.
@ananyaa66642 күн бұрын
@@siggispock5102 Your point is very much valid. However, let me just give my two cents: I feel it could also be interpreted as "an endless circle of self-examination" if it is seen as an emotion/pain/sadness felt at a particular moment in time because don't we all go through phases when we feel suffocated with no way out? Of course, if seen as an endless cycle for life, it can probably be interpreted as depression but I think he is expressing what he felt at a particular phase of his life, which won't remain forever, hopefully as the OP mentioned. Feel free to correct me. But that's what I felt!
@siggispock51022 күн бұрын
@@ananyaa6664 Thank you for explaining your thoughts. I agree, at the time they made the album he felt stuck, no exit, angry and frustrated, he didn't get any relief from "indigo" (too intellectual, too much distance to his subjects?) And it probably took a lot of courage for him to express this in his new songs, disregarding possible reaction of the fandom. Damn, how can somebody like him always be "positive"! Remember Festa 2022, where he still fought with himself over the idea of having to take responsibility for the wellbeing of their fans. To publish this album might actually be one of the biggest decisions in his life, giving him the freedom he needs as a person and an artist. Fuck the expectations, fuck the reactions! I see the hiphop RM who started all this, had to give up so much to be successful. Later he can go back to some of the things he needs to do in his position, it won't matter that much any more (like you said). Did you notice, in a way he does away with the damn Kpop rule "everything for the fans"? The ppl who helped him to come to this decision: well done! Thinking about all the things BTS had to do, all the boxes (i.e.FS) they had to click make me angry and yes, annoyed about the immature part of the fandom which demands all this from them. Ups, I get very emotional myself, lol.
@moniquebairdwagener6044Күн бұрын
I have had one of the same thoughts as you, how much have we as fans contributed to the pressure/stress 😢
@Saphira2NE12 күн бұрын
The voice is so irritating, hope you change to something suitable to listen to.
@Lilacstarphish-cv3qm2 күн бұрын
I would love to see your theory on RM's new LOST! mv
@fancydancer20162 күн бұрын
I’m not sure if anyone has noticed this, but when Yeosang is wearing his white suit, he has a fedora as his boutonnière.
@onlyurbear3 күн бұрын
i wonder if the next album is connected to this era because they film it in the same place as chiki
@onlyurbear3 күн бұрын
WAIT. so this IS connected to R toV VCR
@Crazyeg1233 күн бұрын
i think the shady bunny might be Danielle. the shadow claw turns into the yellow bunny and in the inkigayo “bubble gum” performance intro danni is wearing a green and silver ring. in the how sweet music video she is wearing a green and gold ring (and the yellow ring pop during the call back to the hype boy lollipop scene) i’ve been at the “how sweet” music video all day, can’t wait to see your take, i’ve noticed many symbols.
@Lovely_Lady343 күн бұрын
Oh... you had some insights I didn't see or get. Those colors on the face was something I was really wondering about and being each others support does usually mean that you need to balance each other out indeed. Furthermore, him not truly smiling during the second time in those different scenarios was something that was indeed also off for me and didn't completely been able to place. But now I got it, even if he was himself without dealing with any mental illness, he wouldn't still be happy as it's still not what he wanted. Thank you for the clarification! Anyone has any idea about those round small windows meaning? Only one door had three and another had four. What meaning does that have? That's probably the last thing that I didn't seem to get really. Oh and when the sound increases to become more complex over time is something I have been wondering about. Why that increndo? Is it that life has become more complex as he learned to understand more about himself?
@Raereraere3 күн бұрын
The timeline is insane
@Moonwalkmj3 күн бұрын
I just realized that in Drama too the girls seems to not be themselves and that’s why they are fighting each other. They can’t trust each other. In supernova too because all the members are bullying Giselle and in Armageddon they are talking about « which one is AI »… i’m so excited to see more. I think the different eye colors have something to do with the storyline
@BigSkinty913 күн бұрын
6:06 the jk on the left😂
@woefulnix4 күн бұрын
Everytime I get into theorizing about SKZ I check your videos, your theories are so good and help me make my own sense of the story/the meaning of the song so nicely! Thank you for linking so many dots and making so many cool theories always!
Пікірлер
You better bet I've been waiting for this analysis of RM's MV!!! I know your takes will make me think and realize so much! You're very appreciated!
Amazing explanation!
Omg that’s so good explained
The lyrics spring's always been here, I will sleep in her eyes reminds me of the lyrics to Change ft Wale. "I see grass growing in winter's eyes." In that song, it was about having hope in your perspective even though your current situation is cold/despairing/winter. So to me that lyric says 'spring/hope has always been here, i can finally rest in her perspective' some people think spring's always been here is joons way of convincing himself that nothing is wrong and he can stay in the familiarity without having to leave. and that the line you are my pain, divine, divine is about growth and finding yourself being painful and repetitive but ultimately important, right for you, and true. I like that interpretation too.
This is amazing! It showed me a part I missed. I do also think that actually maybe he leaves right place wrong person for wrong place right person, because the maze we only see disconcerting half-rooms so something is still not quite right. a continuing loop of self-discovery and the call to come back to me
58.7k subscriber here❤
Welcome!! 🥰💙
i....was so so so impressed..like bfr iam just like okay this is seventeen`s nes song but now...wow what a masterpiece..
The first part of video is about finding direction and purpose. The second part is about finally finding yourself
I loved your explanation !
Beautiful - love this interpretation! 💜
This is my comment to the video before knowing anything concrete. "To me he is traveling with his other personalities. A cool/boss one, a kid/scared one, a happy go lucky/positive one, a logical/want to figure put things one and RM the one who made it in the spotlight. I think when he see things he can see from many perspectives of him same time. So he is getting lost on how he should juggle his perspective. Ofcourse I could be totally off but it's how I interpret this MV."
You did a great job with the timeline but I think you made a small mistake regarding the werewolves. Sure, they are getting closer in 2002/03, but on Twitter, they posted on January 22nd about the boys setting off to another place. They left Greyville on September 3rd, 2000, which means that Khan meeting the others happend around some (maybe 1 or 2) months ago. And because TGC is taking place 20 years before Riverfield, the werewolves settled to Riverfield in 2020 before the vampire boys. This also explains why they lost their winning streak in nightball. ;)
Brilliant analysis!
You always manage to make MVs so relatable, thank you
People: Please put on the CC to catch up on the extremely-fast-speed explanation of this Video -- which her Theory is very good, to say the least. 😉
@Bookish Theories, The last sequence of numbers on the elevator which is12523222 This is what my theory is if you were to add up 1+2+5+2+3=13 The next sequence of numbers are triple 2s add them up is 2+2+2=6 answer is 6/13 which is the debut month and day and also the year 2013 but if you write it 6/13/13 BTS‘s debut date! Course this is just my mathematical theory I don’t know if that is correct but it seems logical !?😊💜 what do you think ARMY?
Thank you for solving the "Mystery" which you made the perfect sense of it all.
Love this explanation, thank you for solving it! 🫶🏻🥰
Mrs Ma'am!!! You are a genius. I've always enjoyed your deep dives videos, you are actually such a big part of my process to become ARMY ^^ Namjoon is so cool honestly! it's moments like these that I find that the best part about being ARMY is growing up together with the boys and relating to their life journeys even though we live in different realities.
this is a very good analysis of both the view point of a toxic lover seductress who is yanking their partner on a very dangerous tightrope on purpose, toying with how they can both help and ruin them. but i also love how you focus on how the song can also be an inner conflict between darker and lighter sides of Selugi. the idea of good, dark and balance is PERFECT
AMAZING JOB! Thank you so much for your analysis 💜🙌
Brilliant! Thank you so much for your analysis. You helped me to notice some details that I didn't realize before. Great job and explanation.
I was looking forward to your video because there was definitely a lot to discuss about this MV! Thank you so much as always <3 Apart from the interesting meaning and the artistry, I also loved how fun and absurd the MV looked. I think it is one of my favorite music videos ever!
Wow! This is soo helpful! 🤯💜
Thank you for helping me understand his artistry!
Thank you so much. 💜
The members near to Namjoon on lost video are all men and a woman right??
Namjoon being in a labyrinth to find yourself it's an amazing concept and part of lost video scenario as well
I feel I don't belong in my neighborhood because they're some rude crazy people and crackheads or people who is obsessed with having family and kids and I'm not like them. I feel like I don't belong to my neighborhood but I have met nice and interesting people worldwide who make me feel that I belong
Thank you! When I saw the reference to "nowhere" and "42" I laughed loud. Yes, that is the one aspect of looking at the world, one I can identify with a lot. Maybe I should explain for younger ppl: A hitchhikers guide through the galaxy is a book by Douglas Adams published in 1979. They have this gigantic computer which is supposed to elaborate on the sense of life. They wait and wait until the answer finally comes out. The answer is: 42. Another adorably idea is a computer who suffers from depression and threatens to pull his plug. We couldn't stop laughing because we had been so intense on changing the world for the better and then: 42.
This was EXCELLENT, thank you!
Thanks for the analysis. Really great, as usual 💜 And you helped me realise that one of the places he explores is the archive, or rkive, his Insta name, which made me chuckle 😄
I still don't understand 😢😢😢
Wait i just realizing that lipstick part! What if the stranger that ymenehcra meet is sua?! Sua have lipstick in the mv!
OHMYGOSH OHMYGOSH OHMYGOSH!!! THANK YOU!!! I've been dying to talk and understand this video and you just confirmed and helped my brain soooo much!!!
This was a great analysis! Thank you once again Bookish Theories!
❤❤❤❤❤
I love your explanations so much, I can understand better and from a very mature point of view, thank you.
As always, amazing analysis! I have always felt that Namjoon, more than any other of the guys, has struggled to find his identity amongst all the public experiences they are having. Sometimes I feel like they were all overwhelmed, and I hope we as fans have not added to their pain. But Namjoon more than the others talks about being trapped in these endless circles of self examination without exit. I think he can take some comfort from the fact that nothing stays the same. It can be a sad fact, but also a good one. If he is going round and round in his self journey, he can remember that just living, experiencing, and aging changes our perspectives. One day, he will see it all differently, and maybe feel Better
Your comment made me tear up! I cannot help but feel sad thinking we might also have contributed to his pain with our almost smothering love? Anyway, I hope he does take comfort in the idea that change and transience are truths that cannot be denied!
I am not sure I would call it an "endless circle of self examination".This would be true for someone suffering from depression. Self examination is sth positive, desirable, ongoing. What I do understand is that he is trapped in his role, the expectation of the outside world (including fans, especially fans) and with this album he tries to get out of it (at least for those who are interested). He was so exited in one vlive when he said he was working on sth new. I hope the majority of fans will not just ignore it.
@@siggispock5102 Your point is very much valid. However, let me just give my two cents: I feel it could also be interpreted as "an endless circle of self-examination" if it is seen as an emotion/pain/sadness felt at a particular moment in time because don't we all go through phases when we feel suffocated with no way out? Of course, if seen as an endless cycle for life, it can probably be interpreted as depression but I think he is expressing what he felt at a particular phase of his life, which won't remain forever, hopefully as the OP mentioned. Feel free to correct me. But that's what I felt!
@@ananyaa6664 Thank you for explaining your thoughts. I agree, at the time they made the album he felt stuck, no exit, angry and frustrated, he didn't get any relief from "indigo" (too intellectual, too much distance to his subjects?) And it probably took a lot of courage for him to express this in his new songs, disregarding possible reaction of the fandom. Damn, how can somebody like him always be "positive"! Remember Festa 2022, where he still fought with himself over the idea of having to take responsibility for the wellbeing of their fans. To publish this album might actually be one of the biggest decisions in his life, giving him the freedom he needs as a person and an artist. Fuck the expectations, fuck the reactions! I see the hiphop RM who started all this, had to give up so much to be successful. Later he can go back to some of the things he needs to do in his position, it won't matter that much any more (like you said). Did you notice, in a way he does away with the damn Kpop rule "everything for the fans"? The ppl who helped him to come to this decision: well done! Thinking about all the things BTS had to do, all the boxes (i.e.FS) they had to click make me angry and yes, annoyed about the immature part of the fandom which demands all this from them. Ups, I get very emotional myself, lol.
I have had one of the same thoughts as you, how much have we as fans contributed to the pressure/stress 😢
The voice is so irritating, hope you change to something suitable to listen to.
I would love to see your theory on RM's new LOST! mv
I’m not sure if anyone has noticed this, but when Yeosang is wearing his white suit, he has a fedora as his boutonnière.
i wonder if the next album is connected to this era because they film it in the same place as chiki
WAIT. so this IS connected to R toV VCR
i think the shady bunny might be Danielle. the shadow claw turns into the yellow bunny and in the inkigayo “bubble gum” performance intro danni is wearing a green and silver ring. in the how sweet music video she is wearing a green and gold ring (and the yellow ring pop during the call back to the hype boy lollipop scene) i’ve been at the “how sweet” music video all day, can’t wait to see your take, i’ve noticed many symbols.
Oh... you had some insights I didn't see or get. Those colors on the face was something I was really wondering about and being each others support does usually mean that you need to balance each other out indeed. Furthermore, him not truly smiling during the second time in those different scenarios was something that was indeed also off for me and didn't completely been able to place. But now I got it, even if he was himself without dealing with any mental illness, he wouldn't still be happy as it's still not what he wanted. Thank you for the clarification! Anyone has any idea about those round small windows meaning? Only one door had three and another had four. What meaning does that have? That's probably the last thing that I didn't seem to get really. Oh and when the sound increases to become more complex over time is something I have been wondering about. Why that increndo? Is it that life has become more complex as he learned to understand more about himself?
The timeline is insane
I just realized that in Drama too the girls seems to not be themselves and that’s why they are fighting each other. They can’t trust each other. In supernova too because all the members are bullying Giselle and in Armageddon they are talking about « which one is AI »… i’m so excited to see more. I think the different eye colors have something to do with the storyline
6:06 the jk on the left😂
Everytime I get into theorizing about SKZ I check your videos, your theories are so good and help me make my own sense of the story/the meaning of the song so nicely! Thank you for linking so many dots and making so many cool theories always!
You're very genius