Yes, all Nomex DT have a typical sound. The Yulong Guo of China which was built with Dammann blue-print sounds very much the same too.
@antoniopozo9311Ай бұрын
Incredible
@nickpearsonuk2 ай бұрын
I have built a few classical guitars, all traditional solid top fan brace instruments other than my one attempt at a double top. This was inspired by a brief twiddle on David Russell’s Dammann guitar. It was quite simply incredible. Power and volume yes, but with a dark and complex sound as well. Dammann is just a great guitar builder; his early traditional instruments sound amazing as well. To dismiss these modern designs without playing a variety, or more importantly listening to them being played by top class musicians is foolish.
@user-pl4ve5kl1k4 ай бұрын
Toni Muller guitar sweet.
@hngi264 ай бұрын
It’s sad to see some people actually succumbs to the faulty design, because it limits the full spectrum of beautiful classic Spanish guitar, the double top design has big sound but that’s where it stops! There’s no harmonics extension, all notes are muddled like wolf notes everywhere. This video makes this design sounds very mysterious without practical context. 这个短片介绍太过夸张，使用神秘语气 把 一个平平无奇的双面板吉他说到天花龙凤，没有实际的深入探讨 音色 优势何在。除了大音量之外 毫无可取。
@quocanh95nguyen6 ай бұрын
I really fall in love with Gernot Wagner guitar when I listened to Jason Vieaux played his one for the first time
@enricopg17 ай бұрын
Question to the player: do you hear any abvious difference? Because to my ear the sound very very similar…
@chuan-kangshih787 ай бұрын
什麼都沒說啊！裝腔作勢賣關子。你真知道點什麼？
@cminorhuynh25479 ай бұрын
Both maker are wonderful but I must take Wagner all the way
@ClassicalGuitarMusings9 ай бұрын
Legendary guitarist
@ClassicalGuitarMusings9 ай бұрын
Amazing
@robertocapocchi837910 ай бұрын
Beautiful playing.
@jamesstroud3230 Жыл бұрын
To my ear when hearing in person Wagner is the best Spruce and Dammann the best Cedar.
@franzharting2268 Жыл бұрын
Super Klang, vier phantastische Gitarren. Sehr schön gespielt.
@lucarinaldovillani63 Жыл бұрын
Nice
@kamarienedwards1757 Жыл бұрын
0:45 3:00
@alchemist1111 Жыл бұрын
I love the sound of Dammann’s guitars, they just stand out to me.
@johnlay3040 Жыл бұрын
This guy is excellent. I wonder why he hasn't appeared on world stage. Or maybe he has, I'm just too ignorant. Dammann and Wagner are like the Steinway and Bosendorfer of guitars.
@jozsefhalajko6995 Жыл бұрын
Bösendorfer. R at the end.
@johnlay3040 Жыл бұрын
They all sound almost the same.
@javierelizondoh Жыл бұрын
Hi, thank you. Wonderful. Have you tried Michel Brück guitars? If you have, please post me a link. Thank you for your work on theses videos
@aquasonora Жыл бұрын
Beautiful sound!!! Congratulations
@qingchuan1004 Жыл бұрын
thank you!
@DouglasThompson Жыл бұрын
DAMMANN!!! DOES THAT THING HAVE 2 TOPS?...Gonna have to double mic it.
@Alexandr2222 Жыл бұрын
Почему гитарные мастера и музыканты уверены, что вот это ездиние по ушам - именно то, что люди будут слушать? Да от такого слушатель просто разбежится. Искать надо инструмент у которого звук будет приятный для слушателя.
@josefbianco81422 жыл бұрын
很美的曲子，求曲名。谢谢！
@CRGuitarist2 жыл бұрын
It's the Spruce Gernot Wagner for me... Great playing!
@lingzhao57192 жыл бұрын
Where can I buy one
@DominicOrlando2 жыл бұрын
Julia Florida kzread.info/dash/bejne/o6KrsbiRpreYhNo.html
@renshimarek2 жыл бұрын
C ! :)
@angelikaseegers-classicalg80532 жыл бұрын
Thank you for sharing this video - great sound !
@edzmuda68702 жыл бұрын
How what?
@MorganStuartGuitar2 жыл бұрын
Thanks! Great video!
@guitarmusic19692 жыл бұрын
Very beautiful instruments. If you know where can I buy these instruments let me know please 🙏
@SeanSamimiGuitarist2 жыл бұрын
Very nice tone, well done on the interpretation
@SeanSamimiGuitarist2 жыл бұрын
1:22 Lebisch 2:02 Kirschner 3:06 Lebisch
@SeanSamimiGuitarist2 жыл бұрын
Very good tone and playing Qingchuan that makes this experiment worthwhile
@SeanSamimiGuitarist2 жыл бұрын
1:21 Wagner 2:35 Lebisch 3:53 Kirschner
@qingchuan10042 жыл бұрын
thank you Sean!
@wow65932 жыл бұрын
你是在谈棉花么 ？谈棉花为什么还加声卡？ 要是弹的吉他比地铁下面弹的差远了 人家还有几个鼓掌的……
@onceuponatime20102 жыл бұрын
Even a cheaper guitar (a 500$) copes with all the musical tasks. Well MAAAYBE it wouldn't give you the neccessary sonority, but are you serious, man or Ms.?;) Are you ready to pay several thousand dollars to get the extra sound power only? Instead of having one expensive guitar I decided to get three cheap ones and I am happy. They are all different - for different styles of classical stuff, they are super comfy to deal with. So what else do you need?
@rikjamesguitare2 жыл бұрын
Bravo!! The setting gives me vibes of the house in Parasite, gorgeous playing as well!
@onceuponatime20102 жыл бұрын
That is a pity guitar repertoire isn't of an equal rank as famous luthiers' guitars are. So, no sense at all to play an expensive guitar. A 800-1000(max) dollar guitar easily does the job.
@DeOmnibusDubitandum762 жыл бұрын
Interesting logic. Would you then agree that, given the paucity of the cello repertoire, it was futile for Rostropovich to bother playing whatever scores were available on his Duport Stradivarius? I thought not.
@nickpearsonuk2 ай бұрын
And the oft repeated limited repertoire statement is simply nonsense. The classical guitar has a huge repertoire consisting of pieces written for guitar and transcriptions of music for other instruments. It’s frustrating to hear the same the same old arguments rehashed with little justification.
@furknee062 жыл бұрын
You should throw a Kenny hill signature in the mix.
@Dhammawitt2 жыл бұрын
Do you know the 2021 Dammann was nomex? I believe he started using balsa wood in between some years ago.
@user-ml9jt1vp6o2 жыл бұрын
老師 有沒有其他推薦的雙面板?
@AlexRomanovGuitar2 жыл бұрын
The 2021 Gernot Wagner Cedar definitely stood out!
@themusiccovenant2 жыл бұрын
Master performance
@themusiccovenant2 жыл бұрын
Master performance
@bambooshama2 жыл бұрын
Just beautiful!! 🙏
@scottkleyla77522 жыл бұрын
The masters apprentice has a legacy of orders to complete! A trade shop of this quality is a profession of heart and spirit.
@robertbdesmond2 жыл бұрын
First of all, thank you for this informative video. Much appreciated by a guitar maker such as myself. I have been struggling with the sound of Double Top guitars since I first heard one 20+ years ago. I've had a few in my workshop for repairs and adjustments and I found them to be difficult to love, sound wise. One was a Bruck, one was a Muller and one was a Kirschner. All 3 were beautifully crafted. But all 3 had the same problem. Some notes were very strong and some notes were weak, some rang forever and some did not. All 3 were Bass heavy. The trebles were weak. They were all very unbalanced and did not sound like a wooden top, but rather, something else all together. That said, some of what I heard was incredible. So, I started experimenting and built a few guitars with what I call the Desmond "Partial Double Top". I did not copy anyone else, first of all. Anyway, the results were impressive in many ways. The point is, Double Top guitars are HERE TO STAY. The younger players have been introduced to them and want them. So, if a guitar maker wants to stay in business, he or she better start making Double Top guitars, in some way or another. I'm not sure they fall into the category of "Guitars" anymore, but rather "Double Top Guitars" would be better. They are completely different sounding from a great Traditional classical guitar. So like all guitars, find one and buy it. You can never have only one guitar anyway. That's my take on Double Top guitars. Some of the best concert guitar players are demanding them, so that tells you something right there. Good day.
@nebovas94322 жыл бұрын
You forgot to say anything about unrealistic difference in price between double top and standard classical. Double top can be 5 times more expensive and what you get is not better at all.
@BobStCyr2 жыл бұрын
Hi Robert, I am an amateur luthier. I too have played several double tops, and Smallman style lattice braced too that were not very good sounding, with some of the problems you point out. I'm not familiar with the partial double top that you refer to I'd like to learn more about that. You should check out kzread.info/dash/bejne/amaOuJiOgr2zZ5M.html it's very interesting , and even more interesting is that most of the viewers did not choose the double top as the best sounding. I'm skeptical of the weight advantage from the double tops. If you research Torres guitars you will find that many of them had tops that are in the 1.5 - 1.7 mm thick range. I agree with you that the double top is almost a different instrument. The best double top that I have played was a Kenny Hill. Once upon a time people wanted to make the harpsichord louder. They did it and called it the piano. The piano is capable of things the harpsichord is not but if you listen to music that was written for the harpsichord played well on a harpsichord and then the same music played on the piano it's obvious that we lost something when we made the harpsichord louder. Pepe Romero Sr. said the musical performance is a joint effort of the composer, the player and the instrument maker, perhaps we makers need to show players the beauty of sound that is in those solid tops. Manuel Barrueco has gone back to playing his Ruck, and many of those other players only play their double tops when they feel they need the extra loudness but not otherwise.
Пікірлер
Yes, all Nomex DT have a typical sound. The Yulong Guo of China which was built with Dammann blue-print sounds very much the same too.
Incredible
I have built a few classical guitars, all traditional solid top fan brace instruments other than my one attempt at a double top. This was inspired by a brief twiddle on David Russell’s Dammann guitar. It was quite simply incredible. Power and volume yes, but with a dark and complex sound as well. Dammann is just a great guitar builder; his early traditional instruments sound amazing as well. To dismiss these modern designs without playing a variety, or more importantly listening to them being played by top class musicians is foolish.
Toni Muller guitar sweet.
It’s sad to see some people actually succumbs to the faulty design, because it limits the full spectrum of beautiful classic Spanish guitar, the double top design has big sound but that’s where it stops! There’s no harmonics extension, all notes are muddled like wolf notes everywhere. This video makes this design sounds very mysterious without practical context. 这个短片介绍太过夸张，使用神秘语气 把 一个平平无奇的双面板吉他说到天花龙凤，没有实际的深入探讨 音色 优势何在。除了大音量之外 毫无可取。
I really fall in love with Gernot Wagner guitar when I listened to Jason Vieaux played his one for the first time
Question to the player: do you hear any abvious difference? Because to my ear the sound very very similar…
什麼都沒說啊！裝腔作勢賣關子。你真知道點什麼？
Both maker are wonderful but I must take Wagner all the way
Legendary guitarist
Amazing
Beautiful playing.
To my ear when hearing in person Wagner is the best Spruce and Dammann the best Cedar.
Super Klang, vier phantastische Gitarren. Sehr schön gespielt.
Nice
0:45 3:00
I love the sound of Dammann’s guitars, they just stand out to me.
This guy is excellent. I wonder why he hasn't appeared on world stage. Or maybe he has, I'm just too ignorant. Dammann and Wagner are like the Steinway and Bosendorfer of guitars.
Bösendorfer. R at the end.
They all sound almost the same.
Hi, thank you. Wonderful. Have you tried Michel Brück guitars? If you have, please post me a link. Thank you for your work on theses videos
Beautiful sound!!! Congratulations
thank you!
DAMMANN!!! DOES THAT THING HAVE 2 TOPS?...Gonna have to double mic it.
Почему гитарные мастера и музыканты уверены, что вот это ездиние по ушам - именно то, что люди будут слушать? Да от такого слушатель просто разбежится. Искать надо инструмент у которого звук будет приятный для слушателя.
很美的曲子，求曲名。谢谢！
It's the Spruce Gernot Wagner for me... Great playing!
Where can I buy one
Julia Florida kzread.info/dash/bejne/o6KrsbiRpreYhNo.html
C ! :)
Thank you for sharing this video - great sound !
How what?
Thanks! Great video!
Very beautiful instruments. If you know where can I buy these instruments let me know please 🙏
Very nice tone, well done on the interpretation
1:22 Lebisch 2:02 Kirschner 3:06 Lebisch
Very good tone and playing Qingchuan that makes this experiment worthwhile
1:21 Wagner 2:35 Lebisch 3:53 Kirschner
thank you Sean!
你是在谈棉花么 ？谈棉花为什么还加声卡？ 要是弹的吉他比地铁下面弹的差远了 人家还有几个鼓掌的……
Even a cheaper guitar (a 500$) copes with all the musical tasks. Well MAAAYBE it wouldn't give you the neccessary sonority, but are you serious, man or Ms.?;) Are you ready to pay several thousand dollars to get the extra sound power only? Instead of having one expensive guitar I decided to get three cheap ones and I am happy. They are all different - for different styles of classical stuff, they are super comfy to deal with. So what else do you need?
Bravo!! The setting gives me vibes of the house in Parasite, gorgeous playing as well!
That is a pity guitar repertoire isn't of an equal rank as famous luthiers' guitars are. So, no sense at all to play an expensive guitar. A 800-1000(max) dollar guitar easily does the job.
Interesting logic. Would you then agree that, given the paucity of the cello repertoire, it was futile for Rostropovich to bother playing whatever scores were available on his Duport Stradivarius? I thought not.
And the oft repeated limited repertoire statement is simply nonsense. The classical guitar has a huge repertoire consisting of pieces written for guitar and transcriptions of music for other instruments. It’s frustrating to hear the same the same old arguments rehashed with little justification.
You should throw a Kenny hill signature in the mix.
Do you know the 2021 Dammann was nomex? I believe he started using balsa wood in between some years ago.
老師 有沒有其他推薦的雙面板?
The 2021 Gernot Wagner Cedar definitely stood out!
Master performance
Master performance
Just beautiful!! 🙏
The masters apprentice has a legacy of orders to complete! A trade shop of this quality is a profession of heart and spirit.
First of all, thank you for this informative video. Much appreciated by a guitar maker such as myself. I have been struggling with the sound of Double Top guitars since I first heard one 20+ years ago. I've had a few in my workshop for repairs and adjustments and I found them to be difficult to love, sound wise. One was a Bruck, one was a Muller and one was a Kirschner. All 3 were beautifully crafted. But all 3 had the same problem. Some notes were very strong and some notes were weak, some rang forever and some did not. All 3 were Bass heavy. The trebles were weak. They were all very unbalanced and did not sound like a wooden top, but rather, something else all together. That said, some of what I heard was incredible. So, I started experimenting and built a few guitars with what I call the Desmond "Partial Double Top". I did not copy anyone else, first of all. Anyway, the results were impressive in many ways. The point is, Double Top guitars are HERE TO STAY. The younger players have been introduced to them and want them. So, if a guitar maker wants to stay in business, he or she better start making Double Top guitars, in some way or another. I'm not sure they fall into the category of "Guitars" anymore, but rather "Double Top Guitars" would be better. They are completely different sounding from a great Traditional classical guitar. So like all guitars, find one and buy it. You can never have only one guitar anyway. That's my take on Double Top guitars. Some of the best concert guitar players are demanding them, so that tells you something right there. Good day.
You forgot to say anything about unrealistic difference in price between double top and standard classical. Double top can be 5 times more expensive and what you get is not better at all.
Hi Robert, I am an amateur luthier. I too have played several double tops, and Smallman style lattice braced too that were not very good sounding, with some of the problems you point out. I'm not familiar with the partial double top that you refer to I'd like to learn more about that. You should check out kzread.info/dash/bejne/amaOuJiOgr2zZ5M.html it's very interesting , and even more interesting is that most of the viewers did not choose the double top as the best sounding. I'm skeptical of the weight advantage from the double tops. If you research Torres guitars you will find that many of them had tops that are in the 1.5 - 1.7 mm thick range. I agree with you that the double top is almost a different instrument. The best double top that I have played was a Kenny Hill. Once upon a time people wanted to make the harpsichord louder. They did it and called it the piano. The piano is capable of things the harpsichord is not but if you listen to music that was written for the harpsichord played well on a harpsichord and then the same music played on the piano it's obvious that we lost something when we made the harpsichord louder. Pepe Romero Sr. said the musical performance is a joint effort of the composer, the player and the instrument maker, perhaps we makers need to show players the beauty of sound that is in those solid tops. Manuel Barrueco has gone back to playing his Ruck, and many of those other players only play their double tops when they feel they need the extra loudness but not otherwise.
请问你现场所听到的跟你录音的声音会有差别吗？
肯定会不一样，好琴现场会更好听