If you learn something new, it was a worthwhile day.
@michaelkhoo58462 күн бұрын
This is the best explanation of Milankovitch cycles I have seen, thank you!
@royw-g31202 күн бұрын
Malenkovitch calculated all of this on paper and using a slide rule. He should be as well known as Einstein.
@susangoaway3 күн бұрын
That's pretty bad. It completely misinterprets certain concepts like orbital mechanics (why would an object spiral into the parent body? That violates energy conversion) Meanwhile the L4 and L5 points are not necessarily stable. This is a major mistake that was made here. L4 and L5 are only stable for the case where one of the bodies is far more massive than the other body, which in the case of the system Earth-Sun is true. This video introduces a lot of misunderstanding.
@mr89663 күн бұрын
0.04%
@mr89663 күн бұрын
why is this only talking about the last 10,000 years in relation to a cycle that is billions of years old
@ItsJustAstronomical3 күн бұрын
This is a follow up to my original video on the Milankovitch cycles. I already covered the longer time span in my first video, but I got a lot of questions about where we are now so I added this video.
@manishdorwal66904 күн бұрын
Thks buddy ...I wish I had found u 12 hrs earlier
@robertlesliewallis2794 күн бұрын
The earths firy centre sumtimes gets drenched with the oceans that cools the core and induces ice ages.Is it the thin wispy atmosphere that creates ice ages ,or the hot molten core that ,controlled by oceanic forces,inflicts these changes?.Bob.
@robertlesliewallis2794 күн бұрын
Why do we not investigate this theory oh you superior folk?
@jamesk8s18 күн бұрын
🙌
@snoopcyrus2hasrealspeed8268 күн бұрын
0:14 who did that
@ItsJustAstronomical8 күн бұрын
I put him in the credits "Bucket Thrower / Water Boy: Jonathan Timothy". He's a friend of mine.
@ninhos1239 күн бұрын
Click bait using milankovich cycles. Anyone here that understands milankovich precession could help me out with a dilemma regarding moments of the seasons and the cycle of milankovich assumptions. If you divide the precession into 360 degrees at 180 degrees (around 12900 years ) the earth's inclination axle wobbling will change in opposite direction, the hemisphere that used to near of the sun on summer seasons now is far from and is in winter seasons, and vice versa for the other hemisphere. (Solstice june/December). But where would be at 90 degrees/270 degrees, (6400 years ) should the summer/winter seasons be happening at the equinox months and springs/autumn on Solstice months? If earth wobbling on milankovich precession at quarter of the turn 90 degrees at Solstice positions the inclination 23.5 will be in the same position as actual position now on the equinox. So every 6400 years summer/winter months would change for spring/autumn months and vice versa. Anyone could help me out here and tell me what I am doing wrong. Thank you
@ItsJustAstronomical9 күн бұрын
My video about precession gets into this: kzread.info/dash/bejne/k5iu2pdtZ9Pak84.htmlsi=jFbUGuD1kQDE0I8g. The issue is whether or not you're calculating the year based on the position of the earth (a sidereal year) or based on the seasons (a tropical year). Since our calendar is based on the tropical year, the timing of the seasons won't change, but the constellations in the sky in a given month will change.
@jfarinhote9 күн бұрын
Can disturbances occur? If any meteorites or anything hit or come close, what will happen then?
@ItsJustAstronomical9 күн бұрын
A comet or astroid could hit, but that's unlikely. Space is so big that it's unlikely.
@JiraffeGroup9 күн бұрын
So What exactly IS the source of the "rotational force" ?
@ItsJustAstronomical9 күн бұрын
There's a bulge around the equator from the rotation of the earth. Since the earth is not a perfect sphere the sun and moon's gravity pulls on one side of the earth more causing the precession.
@JiraffeGroup9 күн бұрын
@@ItsJustAstronomical Sorry, I should have been more clear: the supposed force that acts on the axis to "push" the axis over, causing precession -- what's the force acting on the axis?
@JiraffeGroup9 күн бұрын
@@ItsJustAstronomical Also: Thanks for your reply!
@ItsJustAstronomical9 күн бұрын
Gravity, see above.
@JS-jh4cy10 күн бұрын
Excellent expl,explanation of why we don't need to keep paying damn taxes for green shitty government policies
@zackakai51735 сағат бұрын
How much does Exxon and BP pay you to shill for them?
@JS-jh4cy10 күн бұрын
Nothing to do with screaming greenies, and using some gas in the car, like the hyped up climate alarmists, this is the best theory yet
@JS-jh4cy10 күн бұрын
Farts make a difference
@freepilot773212 күн бұрын
Getting my BFR/IPC soon. Great video to brush up on this topic. Great job by the way.
@freepilot773212 күн бұрын
But, but the earth is flat. Lol
@ivanhunter390713 күн бұрын
Wrong.. the malinkovitch cycle has been disproved.. DO Oscillations!!
@Go_Bremerhaven14 күн бұрын
That was awesome. Right now reading Seven Eves and they were discussing LaGrange points. Couldn't visualize what was being discussed. This video helped immensely. Thank you
@tobiasyoder15 күн бұрын
Thanks this is great! Was getting really frustrated with that stupid ball analogy because I couldn’t explain why there would still be coriolis force if the ball was thrown east west. Without that it’s not clear how we get from ball throwing to the cyclone picture you see everywhere
@NotfromDateline15 күн бұрын
The tilt of the Earth's axis is responsible for Neanderthals. Cool.
@Sifisomabanga16 күн бұрын
Why I didnt learn this in school..... Awesome explanation
@pauljackson407517 күн бұрын
Best explanation I have seen!
@cedricmusangu437019 күн бұрын
Tell me again,Climate Change is a human making?
@sH-ed5yf12 күн бұрын
It absolutly. But it is not the only factor...
@zackakai51735 сағат бұрын
The current warming trend is, yes.
@JustAstroStuffs20 күн бұрын
But time period of persession is 27 thousand years if I'm not wrong. But from this video it doesn't seem like that ?
@ItsJustAstronomical20 күн бұрын
Yes, it's 27,000 years. This video is a short correction to my other video which gets into that
@olboyhim337120 күн бұрын
If that’s the case how does land on the imaginary equator line stay warm your math ain’t mathing
@ItsJustAstronomical20 күн бұрын
Sunlight hits the equator more directly. I have another video that explains this: kzread.info/dash/bejne/qoyBt5eEqbCeibw.html
@ninhos12320 күн бұрын
Anyone seeing united Nation label on this video against misinformation, global warming is man made. Is crazy 🤪?. Thank you for your vídeos very educational. It doesn't matter what united national special interests 😂
@MrHuNTeR_exe20 күн бұрын
Bro just cleared up how tides work with a 3 second insert to a vid. Chefs kiss 1:05
@rogerdiogo689321 күн бұрын
Humanity has cold 🥶 phobia, they afraid to talk about the cold 😢
@rameshiyer515121 күн бұрын
Very well explained. Milankovitch cycle is a bit complicated but the graphics and animation make it easier to understand.
@andreallumiquinga206322 күн бұрын
wwwwoooooooooooooooooo loove it!!! thanks
@marcsman0722 күн бұрын
So clearly explained and well put-together.
@jashyboo23 күн бұрын
This was an amazing animation and explanation thank you
@suewright129923 күн бұрын
Very many thanks indeed for an excellent and so very informative video! I found it so very amazing, so much so that I’ll be saving them all to go over them again and again. A brilliant video which everyone should watch, perhaps then they wouldn’t constantly complain at how the meteorologists/presenters always gets the forecasts wrong!!
@BattsetsegSankhuu25 күн бұрын
You are my sunshine my only sunshine you make me happy
@katana196026 күн бұрын
I'm not sure of the extent of in impact, but sun spots also have an effect, I believe it's an eleven year cycle.
@agmartin212726 күн бұрын
None of this is true. The Global Warmings is caused by gas engines and whatnot. Pay no attention to what this man says and buy electric cars from China. Problem solved. Can I have my money now China? Collective we / the west are sooooo gullible. We are at war with China and we don't remotely understand the long timeframe they have been cultivating all this mis-info.
@sH-ed5yf12 күн бұрын
Both is true....
@bobthebuilder955327 күн бұрын
The thing is we need farming. We need industry. These aren't negotiable. Otherwise, we'd still be in the stone age. The mistakes made by the industrialists of the world have benefitted mankind greatly. Yes, there is a cost. Every action has effect. If we start carbon footprint madness then we will sink back into a stone age. Man is adaptable. The planet will not die, and it bounces back from whatever insults its taken over the last several million years. Volcanic activity and meteor hits have had deadly impacts on the planet. The planet survives. Short of a nova of our sun, this planet will endure. What bothers me more is environmental pollution and that includes garbage. Spilling poisons into water ways and burying it into the ground will kill eco-systems and people, alike. To me, that is much more important. Without ground water and healthy soil there is no cattle or chickens, or vegetables. We starve.
@bobthebuilder955327 күн бұрын
Interesting. This gives you a much better idea of the elements that influence our climate. This makes complete sense. What passes for "climate" science today leaves me skeptical. but cyclical changes due to the three major moderators mentioned above, puts the changes in context. Man made madness that passes as science today does not make sense unless you have a political agenda to fulfill and press on all others.
@zackakai51735 сағат бұрын
- "unless you have a political agenda to fulfill and press on all others." Yeah, like fossil fuel companies paying rightoids like you to shill for them. Actually no, that's giving you too much credit. You're just the gullible rube who's been conned by the aforementioned rightoid shills, and is now brainlessly parroting their misinformation.
@milan164628 күн бұрын
You must not forget that a volcano eruption drags more than all cars and factories in 100 years and that we are right now at the beginning of the solarium minimum which is known for its unstable weather etrem weather and volcanic eruptions and earthquakes
@mitchjohnson4714Ай бұрын
So this is a great explanation and I love it. But I have a request. I get how entropy works, but I’m having trouble imagining the scenario where all the molecitles end up in a corner of the room. I understand that it’s a one in a huge number probability. I get that. I’m just having trouble even understanding how such a scenario could even happen, I mean the scenario leading up to it. It occurs to me that it would be easier for me to imagine if I saw one of these reverse videos where you ran a simulation where you started all the particles in one corner of the “room” with different velocities and then take a simulation, but then ran it backwards to show how it could conceivably happen. Do you think you would do that please?
@ItsJustAstronomicalАй бұрын
OK, I made a special animation just for you: kzread.info/dash/bejne/gqiB0bptgqybh7w.html Notice that none of the laws of physics are being broken here (besides the 2nd law). The scenario is possible, just very unlikely.
@mitchjohnson4714Ай бұрын
@@ItsJustAstronomical Thanks. I love how the wall comes down like "Let's just make this permanent."
@joyboy1468Ай бұрын
Im building a very detailed world for my dnd campaign/book and i cant say enough how much you have helped me. Thank you.
@nicolasclermont893Ай бұрын
It's so awesome how you've taught your kids this. Love it.
@skinnyassc9275Ай бұрын
Yeah earth will spin once a month in 1.47 × 10^16 years later.
@professorfoxtrotАй бұрын
Thanks to capitalism we're not in a frozen wasteland eating snow
@outthere9370Ай бұрын
A lot of people think ice ages are a common occurrence. They are "not" common at all.
@johnjacobs3502Ай бұрын
.....
@MyMemphisableАй бұрын
Thanks!
@ItsJustAstronomicalАй бұрын
Thanks for your support!
@MyMemphisableАй бұрын
@@ItsJustAstronomical I really love how creative and succinct your videos are. Perfect blend of intuitive visuals and mind boggling physical phenomena!
Пікірлер
If you learn something new, it was a worthwhile day.
This is the best explanation of Milankovitch cycles I have seen, thank you!
Malenkovitch calculated all of this on paper and using a slide rule. He should be as well known as Einstein.
That's pretty bad. It completely misinterprets certain concepts like orbital mechanics (why would an object spiral into the parent body? That violates energy conversion) Meanwhile the L4 and L5 points are not necessarily stable. This is a major mistake that was made here. L4 and L5 are only stable for the case where one of the bodies is far more massive than the other body, which in the case of the system Earth-Sun is true. This video introduces a lot of misunderstanding.
0.04%
why is this only talking about the last 10,000 years in relation to a cycle that is billions of years old
This is a follow up to my original video on the Milankovitch cycles. I already covered the longer time span in my first video, but I got a lot of questions about where we are now so I added this video.
Thks buddy ...I wish I had found u 12 hrs earlier
The earths firy centre sumtimes gets drenched with the oceans that cools the core and induces ice ages.Is it the thin wispy atmosphere that creates ice ages ,or the hot molten core that ,controlled by oceanic forces,inflicts these changes?.Bob.
Why do we not investigate this theory oh you superior folk?
🙌
0:14 who did that
I put him in the credits "Bucket Thrower / Water Boy: Jonathan Timothy". He's a friend of mine.
Click bait using milankovich cycles. Anyone here that understands milankovich precession could help me out with a dilemma regarding moments of the seasons and the cycle of milankovich assumptions. If you divide the precession into 360 degrees at 180 degrees (around 12900 years ) the earth's inclination axle wobbling will change in opposite direction, the hemisphere that used to near of the sun on summer seasons now is far from and is in winter seasons, and vice versa for the other hemisphere. (Solstice june/December). But where would be at 90 degrees/270 degrees, (6400 years ) should the summer/winter seasons be happening at the equinox months and springs/autumn on Solstice months? If earth wobbling on milankovich precession at quarter of the turn 90 degrees at Solstice positions the inclination 23.5 will be in the same position as actual position now on the equinox. So every 6400 years summer/winter months would change for spring/autumn months and vice versa. Anyone could help me out here and tell me what I am doing wrong. Thank you
My video about precession gets into this: kzread.info/dash/bejne/k5iu2pdtZ9Pak84.htmlsi=jFbUGuD1kQDE0I8g. The issue is whether or not you're calculating the year based on the position of the earth (a sidereal year) or based on the seasons (a tropical year). Since our calendar is based on the tropical year, the timing of the seasons won't change, but the constellations in the sky in a given month will change.
Can disturbances occur? If any meteorites or anything hit or come close, what will happen then?
A comet or astroid could hit, but that's unlikely. Space is so big that it's unlikely.
So What exactly IS the source of the "rotational force" ?
There's a bulge around the equator from the rotation of the earth. Since the earth is not a perfect sphere the sun and moon's gravity pulls on one side of the earth more causing the precession.
@@ItsJustAstronomical Sorry, I should have been more clear: the supposed force that acts on the axis to "push" the axis over, causing precession -- what's the force acting on the axis?
@@ItsJustAstronomical Also: Thanks for your reply!
Gravity, see above.
Excellent expl,explanation of why we don't need to keep paying damn taxes for green shitty government policies
How much does Exxon and BP pay you to shill for them?
Nothing to do with screaming greenies, and using some gas in the car, like the hyped up climate alarmists, this is the best theory yet
Farts make a difference
Getting my BFR/IPC soon. Great video to brush up on this topic. Great job by the way.
But, but the earth is flat. Lol
Wrong.. the malinkovitch cycle has been disproved.. DO Oscillations!!
That was awesome. Right now reading Seven Eves and they were discussing LaGrange points. Couldn't visualize what was being discussed. This video helped immensely. Thank you
Thanks this is great! Was getting really frustrated with that stupid ball analogy because I couldn’t explain why there would still be coriolis force if the ball was thrown east west. Without that it’s not clear how we get from ball throwing to the cyclone picture you see everywhere
The tilt of the Earth's axis is responsible for Neanderthals. Cool.
Why I didnt learn this in school..... Awesome explanation
Best explanation I have seen!
Tell me again,Climate Change is a human making?
It absolutly. But it is not the only factor...
The current warming trend is, yes.
But time period of persession is 27 thousand years if I'm not wrong. But from this video it doesn't seem like that ?
Yes, it's 27,000 years. This video is a short correction to my other video which gets into that
If that’s the case how does land on the imaginary equator line stay warm your math ain’t mathing
Sunlight hits the equator more directly. I have another video that explains this: kzread.info/dash/bejne/qoyBt5eEqbCeibw.html
Anyone seeing united Nation label on this video against misinformation, global warming is man made. Is crazy 🤪?. Thank you for your vídeos very educational. It doesn't matter what united national special interests 😂
Bro just cleared up how tides work with a 3 second insert to a vid. Chefs kiss 1:05
Humanity has cold 🥶 phobia, they afraid to talk about the cold 😢
Very well explained. Milankovitch cycle is a bit complicated but the graphics and animation make it easier to understand.
wwwwoooooooooooooooooo loove it!!! thanks
So clearly explained and well put-together.
This was an amazing animation and explanation thank you
Very many thanks indeed for an excellent and so very informative video! I found it so very amazing, so much so that I’ll be saving them all to go over them again and again. A brilliant video which everyone should watch, perhaps then they wouldn’t constantly complain at how the meteorologists/presenters always gets the forecasts wrong!!
You are my sunshine my only sunshine you make me happy
I'm not sure of the extent of in impact, but sun spots also have an effect, I believe it's an eleven year cycle.
None of this is true. The Global Warmings is caused by gas engines and whatnot. Pay no attention to what this man says and buy electric cars from China. Problem solved. Can I have my money now China? Collective we / the west are sooooo gullible. We are at war with China and we don't remotely understand the long timeframe they have been cultivating all this mis-info.
Both is true....
The thing is we need farming. We need industry. These aren't negotiable. Otherwise, we'd still be in the stone age. The mistakes made by the industrialists of the world have benefitted mankind greatly. Yes, there is a cost. Every action has effect. If we start carbon footprint madness then we will sink back into a stone age. Man is adaptable. The planet will not die, and it bounces back from whatever insults its taken over the last several million years. Volcanic activity and meteor hits have had deadly impacts on the planet. The planet survives. Short of a nova of our sun, this planet will endure. What bothers me more is environmental pollution and that includes garbage. Spilling poisons into water ways and burying it into the ground will kill eco-systems and people, alike. To me, that is much more important. Without ground water and healthy soil there is no cattle or chickens, or vegetables. We starve.
Interesting. This gives you a much better idea of the elements that influence our climate. This makes complete sense. What passes for "climate" science today leaves me skeptical. but cyclical changes due to the three major moderators mentioned above, puts the changes in context. Man made madness that passes as science today does not make sense unless you have a political agenda to fulfill and press on all others.
- "unless you have a political agenda to fulfill and press on all others." Yeah, like fossil fuel companies paying rightoids like you to shill for them. Actually no, that's giving you too much credit. You're just the gullible rube who's been conned by the aforementioned rightoid shills, and is now brainlessly parroting their misinformation.
You must not forget that a volcano eruption drags more than all cars and factories in 100 years and that we are right now at the beginning of the solarium minimum which is known for its unstable weather etrem weather and volcanic eruptions and earthquakes
So this is a great explanation and I love it. But I have a request. I get how entropy works, but I’m having trouble imagining the scenario where all the molecitles end up in a corner of the room. I understand that it’s a one in a huge number probability. I get that. I’m just having trouble even understanding how such a scenario could even happen, I mean the scenario leading up to it. It occurs to me that it would be easier for me to imagine if I saw one of these reverse videos where you ran a simulation where you started all the particles in one corner of the “room” with different velocities and then take a simulation, but then ran it backwards to show how it could conceivably happen. Do you think you would do that please?
OK, I made a special animation just for you: kzread.info/dash/bejne/gqiB0bptgqybh7w.html Notice that none of the laws of physics are being broken here (besides the 2nd law). The scenario is possible, just very unlikely.
@@ItsJustAstronomical Thanks. I love how the wall comes down like "Let's just make this permanent."
Im building a very detailed world for my dnd campaign/book and i cant say enough how much you have helped me. Thank you.
It's so awesome how you've taught your kids this. Love it.
Yeah earth will spin once a month in 1.47 × 10^16 years later.
Thanks to capitalism we're not in a frozen wasteland eating snow
A lot of people think ice ages are a common occurrence. They are "not" common at all.
.....
Thanks!
Thanks for your support!
@@ItsJustAstronomical I really love how creative and succinct your videos are. Perfect blend of intuitive visuals and mind boggling physical phenomena!