I thought 1,3,5 (dont know the names 😭) were pretty okay actually. 3 and 5 especially stood out.
@lianausamova57662 күн бұрын
stop braging everyone down when there's only one girl that actually can't sing to save her life
@drow85083 күн бұрын
Search about Chinese Knot
@sengmailu7825 күн бұрын
illit 🤢
@ToAll_Multistans6 күн бұрын
I think they're having too much fun being idols and should take it more seriously...
@user-wc1sg9ud9n7 күн бұрын
This guy is a XG troll,clown🤡
@Luckyxcharmx7 күн бұрын
They kind of sounded like if blackpink and new jeans collaborated
@runthecomics7 күн бұрын
Love the quirkiness of the song and video, though the song can be a more serious one as there are toxic people who may live a "clean" lifestyle. That doesn't make you a good person. In my mind this video is song Japanese, especially running from a lettuce dog. LOL. Well, their previous name was SG5 or Sailor Moon 5 based off the anime. So weird, quirky is what they give. So I understand the Young Posse (who I also love) comparison. Great reaction. Want them to win too.
@epiqabadi198 күн бұрын
React vvup please
@Reshma-mv4tj8 күн бұрын
New jeans ?
@FishForFoodNotSport8 күн бұрын
Cringe af
@Cristinavogues.8 күн бұрын
Now.
@soemoe78639 күн бұрын
I feel like i got scammed 🥲
@Frei-23411 күн бұрын
To make a counter argument, what about the knowing brother (variety show) episode of Chaewon singing before their debut, and on her episode on Lee Mujin Service, also Yunjin performance on the band? ^^ Edit: Just want to include Yunjin as opera singer ^^..
@Frei-23411 күн бұрын
Guess gonna give you tip to avoid skibidi toilet episodes... HAHAHAHA
@kuku884611 күн бұрын
I’m going to plonk this here to offer you some added context since you’ve stated in a comment you feel like it’s blown out of proportion. And I personally do think this didn’t have to be the huge deal it is, but when you know the additional context behind it… Well, it kind of sucks. So here’s some important context on _why_ Chinese netizens are so extra upset about Korea doing this (if it was a Japanese MV using Chinese elements and not crediting China, it might still be seen as suck-y, but not to this extent) because of some _very specific_ recent Korean-Chinese discourse. I’ve copied and paste an older comment of mine to explain it-and sorry for the very jaded tone throughout the comment; I’m very tired of the stuff that I cover in the comment itself: Raising an eyebrow at the use of Chinese culture as Korean culture in the music video. I’m not into kpop and I could be angrier about it, but honestly I’m just tired. Hell, I almost find it kind of ironic and funny. A while ago, a pretty cool Chinese manhua artist named Old Xian drew art of their characters in hanfu, and Korean netizens lost their minds over one of the character’s hats. They _insisted_ it was a Korean-exclusive hat. Chinese and Korean people began duking it out on Twitter. I didn’t have any strong feelings about it, but I saw some nasty, _nasty_ sinophobia come out from Korean netizens at the time. They claimed Chinese people didn’t have culture; or that their culture was just the tank man image and the Manchurian queue, with them attaching ugly caricatures of said Qing dynasty queue while laughing at it. They also claimed Chinese netizens were just desperately stealing Korean culture because China is undemocratic and desperate. It was so disappointing, especially since before that, I had a pretty positive view of Korea and an interest in Korean culture and history. But that instance felt like a wake-up call-a reminder that much of the world still hates and looks down on China. So anyway, that’s what feels ironic about this to me. Suddenly Chinese culture is cool to them again, as long as they get to present it as their own. To call another country a desperate, no-culture thief, only to turn around and then pull off a heist like this… Ha. Yeah. Irony. If it sounds like I’m tired and jaded, it’s because I am, at least on this topic. A while ago a Chinese KZreadr made a video to highlight the differences between hanfu and hanbok because a Korean website had claimed a Ming dynasty hanfu as Korean and was again claiming that China was stealing Korean culture (even though hanbok actually received influence _from_ the Chinese Ming in terms of design). Her video was met with massive backlash, where Korean netizens used bots to spam dislikes and comments, much of which was the same copied and pasted rant of sinophobia-about how desperate and pathetic China was, stealing cultures because it lacks democracy and freedom (as if democracy and freedom somehow correlates to the preservation of culture). Of course, Chinese netizens also got quite heated and some made comments about Korea that are also condemnable. But many were just exasperatedly trying to express that China _does_ have a culture and that not everything Chinese is stealing from Korea. Some were also asserting the historical fact about how Korea received influence from China, which _is_ a true historical fact, so I don’t fault them for that at least. I can get the frustration. Plus there was also the whole issue with pickled dishes. If I remember correctly, Chinese paocai got to become an officially recognized intangible heritage, which for anyone else would be a decent fun fact to know, but Koreans viewed it as a theft of their kimchi. And surprise, surprise, it led to even more sinophobia. Similarly, Korean netizens were outraged by China including a girl in a hanbok in the most recent Olympics at China, claiming China was stealing from them again. Except they ignored the fact there were 56 other ethnic dresses showcased at that event, because China has 56 officially recognized ethnicities and Korean-Chinese just so happens to be one of those ethnicities. Even funnier is that other Chinese ethnicities were also in their traditional dress, such as a Vietnamese-Chinese girl in what I believe was an ao dai, but no one from Vietnam grew enraged. It was only Korea. I even remember a Korean street interview where two seemingly teenage girls or young adult women said they were disappointed China would feel the need to steal the hanbok, all while they ironically stood in front of a Korean Confucian temple that still had Chinese characters on it. It’s almost as if…cultures can intermix and mingle and influence one another. It’s almost as if no culture develops purely in isolation. For example, China in fact received a lot of influence from Indian culture in terms of Buddhism and dunhuang and even some of the legends, like Nezha. But at least China admits that. And as one video on this Korean MV situation showed, Japanese culture also acknowledges its influence from China and even has some evolved differences from it. So no one would really care if the MV uses Chinese elements, which it does. They’re just upset nobody is acknowledging that there _is_ that Chinese influence, especially given the recent chaos of many Koreans refusing to see China as having _any_ culture at all. You can see it in the fan, some of the clothing elements, and the design choices like how the clouds or knots are depicted. And while none of that is that grand in isolation, it adds up when all put together-and to be done with no comment about Chinese culture at all, even more so when so many Korean netizens have proven to absolutely _hate_ and even look down on Chinese culture, just leaves a bad taste in some people’s mouths. Even more so hearing that the designer did study in China and used to even tag their art as Chinese before this MV. :/ As for me? I’m just tired. Disappointed, but not surprised.
@jaredt602912 күн бұрын
This is not appreciation. It's not like you were buying things in the mall. You think something is pretty and you love it, then you take it--this is appreciation. And still you dont claim the design is yours. And yes, Korea and China have a lot shared history. But there's always difference in each culture. You can't use this excuse to defend this MV. Last, every elements were listed in the video you saw have their own unique cultural meanings in China. They don't in Korea.
@ukiukimidnight755413 күн бұрын
it’s definitely not for y’all and that’s okay u just don’t get it this song is so sooo aespa y’all just go and listen to drama
@siscob14 күн бұрын
The song is catchy and lyrics were intentional. They were called SG5 but changed it to f5ve. Four out of 5 were in a group called Happiness since 2008 that disbanded last year, one of the best J-Pop girl groups. They were also members of supergroup called e-girls. Together with those two and FEMM, Perfume and FAKY they are the top 5 J-Pop groups for me. Unfortunately, e-girls disbanded in December 2021 after their Christmas Goodbye concert and FEMM disbanded last year also after a decade long career.
@finnrogue943512 күн бұрын
woah, you mentioned such great jpop groups, I hope f5ve can be as legendary as them
@nctneo716714 күн бұрын
im absolutely addicted to this song !!!! the song is really very catchy
@-S.915 күн бұрын
The whole problem with this is that there are many elements in there that are Chinese, and even if there was influence, there definitely are differences between Korean and Chinese culture. Chinese people aren’t mad with Starship and IVE using Chinese elements, they are mad because Korea is claiming it as their own culture. This completely ignores the fact that 1) it originated from China, 2) it still is Chinese and there is basically none of these elements widely used or present in Korean history. 1) For example, the fan used is specifically a shape that was widely popular in Chinese history and media. Korea doesn’t have any record of this particular shaped fan in their history. Also the karst landforms which were not popularized in Korea and were basically a symbol of Chinese paintings. There are a lot more examples in there that were directly derived from China, and clearly not Korean. 2) The knots are called Chinese knots and basically symbol prosperity and wealth, in the olden days they were used as a form of recording daily activities. The ones present in the music video use a braiding style that is MOST DEFINITELY Chinese. Also they are mainly red in China because red is a color of auspiciousness and life. White knots especially used in the hair represent death which is essentially blasphemy. 3) They wear white tops in a certain scene with black skirts. That particular outfit can also be seen in their stage performances. And there is ABSOLUTELY no record of the knot buttons going straight down in a line in Korean history. That shirt style is most definitely Chinese. And a lot of Cnetizens are calling out the tops because 1: it’s Chinese, 2: they have 4 buttons in total which is an even number. It’s an extremely widely known fact among people the general public that living people always wear an odd number of buttons. Even numbers are for the deceased, and the fact that the tops are white makes it even worse. 4) Chinese culture is NO JOKE to Chinese people, Chinese people hold lots of pride in 5000 years of cultural history. And there are definitely some things that may seem weird to foreigners or might seem like jokes, however Chinese people take things like superstition and old sayings very seriously as many of these have originated from Taoist or Chinese monks.
@gilangramadhan747416 күн бұрын
First lol
@Cupidador16 күн бұрын
i was genuinely confused at first listen but i've listened to it at least 30 times since it's release and man oh man is it catchy!
@razraze17 күн бұрын
Support SKZ please. LOVE and Support to them.🙏🙏🙏🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤❤❤🙇♀️
@corinarojas509217 күн бұрын
One of their best songs and video
@iamnotthejessieyouknow886017 күн бұрын
I don’t see any problem here, actually, since the Christmas was already exist in Korean for many years, we shouldn’t call it Christmas anymore, it sounds so selfish, it should be Korean Christmas or Santa’s day, and I do think Jesus is Korean. Also Kong Zi should be Korean too, let’s say the whole universe started in Korean umpire.
@youssafemonster17 күн бұрын
why every song of them is same
@ukiukimidnight755413 күн бұрын
that’s a lie
@Theymademethisway17 күн бұрын
Seriously i thought Some things was wrong with ny ears cause i didn't like the yet even though everyone and their mothers were praising it 🙂 it's just their worst for me but i hope they'll improve once the titke track drops.
@ATOMxEve16 күн бұрын
Heyy thanks for the comment! No worries, you're not crazy! Something did not gel right! I hope their next title track brings them back to form. If you're into aespa, check out my other channel. I introduce my friend who doesn't like kpop to them kzread.info/dash/bejne/eKSMtdx6famygZc.html He had some interesting things to say. Thank you again for stopping by, like and subscribe for more!
@ukiukimidnight755413 күн бұрын
girl bye
@correctandsexyaboutit17 күн бұрын
They're too vocally gifted to be doing a song as "easy" as this, I think that might be why it's underwhelming. If a less talented group did this song I feel like it would have impressed people a lot more, but we've come to expect more from Aespa. That said, I still really liked this song personally.
@ManduJendukie17 күн бұрын
I subbed simply cuz UR RIGHT! they cant sing. They needed to improve pre debut hopefully they improve
@iLLmOfUCaLIVE17 күн бұрын
at first i didnt like it and hoped that the chorus wasnt the chorus but this song is actually so aespa and cool. Sonically its chaotic and a journey yet somewhat nuance. it might actually be my favorite so far. and that 90s vibe breakdown 🤤
@ATOMxEve16 күн бұрын
heeyy, I really want to love this but I can't. The breakdown is awesome! They teased that part and I was so excited. I'm still very much looking forward to their next release! If you're into aespa, check out my other channel. I introduce my friend who doesn't like kpop to them kzread.info/dash/bejne/eKSMtdx6famygZc.html He had some interesting things to say. Thank you again for stopping by, like and subscribe for more!
@razraze17 күн бұрын
I'm only here for Hyunjin. At least they sing better than ILLIT. Please review ATEEZ Coachella performance.🙏🙏🙏🙏🥵🥵🥵🥵🙇♀️🖤🖤🖤
@briant947717 күн бұрын
Weird song but I really love the chorus. Disappointed they missed out on giving winter ice powers
@MotoNinjas17 күн бұрын
Man didn't lie
@ATOMxEve16 күн бұрын
Ahaha, thank you. Alway an honest reaction. Fans don't have to love every song. If you're into aespa and more music reactions, check out my other channel. I introduce my friend who doesn't like kpop to them in this video: kzread.info/dash/bejne/eKSMtdx6famygZc.html Thank you again for stopping by, like and subscribe for more!
@zera806817 күн бұрын
I agree, some parts are good, like the chorus, but as a whole? I don't think it works. The lyrics are weird to me as well lmao. Almost half of them aren't even real words, and most of them don't even mean anything. It's fine to use them every now and then, but when you use them too much, it just becomes hard to focus and understand
@prtysavg17 күн бұрын
are you new to them? their lyrics are always weird and different it’s not anything new so idk why ur surprised
@badfuls27917 күн бұрын
the lyrics are more lore-based so you obviously it's gonna be weird 😭 honestly stop making dumb takes when you know nothing about them
@zera806817 күн бұрын
@@prtysavg no I’m not. I never said that I was surprised either
@prtysavg17 күн бұрын
@@badfuls279 you do realize there’s a lore in the mv here too right hence why the lyrics are weird.. 😭
@zera806817 күн бұрын
@@badfuls279I’m talking about “ah, oh, body bang” stuff. Never said they don’t have lore or anything. Just found it weird
@prmtv17 күн бұрын
I know you're more of a casual fan but here's some info on them for you... they have WAY more than just hype songs. They have a lot of softer stuff too. Levanter Astronaut Chronosaurus Mixtape: OH Cover Me Waiting For Us Muddy Water Leave Collision Chill Voices So many more... They debuted in 2018 They are ages 23 - 26 Fandom name is Stay #2 Best Selling Artist in U.S 2023 #3 Globally Best Selling 2023 They are unique for several reasons... First, the leader Bang Chan was allowed by JYP to hand pick all of the members himself. They were not placed together in a traditional way, by the company. Second all of them are all arounders. They can all sing, rap, dance, produce and write. Third, they have written and produced about 99% of their music. Numbers of songs each member has copyrighted according to Korean Music Association (KOMCA) so far... Bang Chan 182 (#3 in KPop) Changbin 154 (#11) Han 148 (#12) Hyunjin 27 Felix 22 I.N 21 Seungmin 20 Lee Know 17 While they can all do everything they do have 3 different subunits... 3Racha... Bang Chan, Chang Bin and Han which are the main producers. They are always credited as 3Racha. 3Racha Achievements - Four Time Billboard 200 #1 Producers - Hot 100 Hitmakers - 3rd, 11th, 12th Most Credited Idols on KOMCA - Produced Albums Sold Over 20 Million Copies - Japan Hot 100 Hitmakers - 100+ Weeks on Hot 100 Lyricists - 100+ Weeks On Hot 100 Composers - 2023 Asia Artist Awards Best Creator - Makers of Time Magazines 2020 #8 Best Song (their song Backdoor) Danceracha... Lee Know (in charge of leading dance practices), Felix and Hyunjin. They also contribute to the choreography. Vocalracha... Seungmin and I.N While the songs are hype they always have significant meaning to them. Their lyricism is always insane. Since they are so experimental their sound has its own genre and they have a very diverse discography. Example... Gods Menu, Back Door and Case 143 all completely different sounds.
@friedahendy234917 күн бұрын
Great reaction thank you. They produce their own music and it’s there style they cover over 40 genres so everything you can think of try watching Time Out or Lavanter etc.
@ElGato012317 күн бұрын
This has to be their worst song for me. A weird song Chorus and bridge are ok but a little empty on the instrumental. I also don't like the switch between singing and rapping every few seconds. After releasing something like Drama this really is underwhelming.
@ATOMxEve17 күн бұрын
Heey thanks for the comment! I'm echoing a lot of your thoughts. The whole song just doesn't gel as well as their other songs. Love that bridge though. Hope their next release is better! Thank you again for the comment. Like and subscribe for more!
@ukiukimidnight755413 күн бұрын
u clearly don’t anything abt aespa except drama this is so aespa this is what they do have u ever watched next level or savage?
@vic__kinoshita17 күн бұрын
aespa is INOVATIVE thats why you are disappointed
@ATOMxEve17 күн бұрын
Heyyy, thanks for the comment! Yeah they may be, this one didn't hit me as good as Black Mamba or Savage. It's still good but i'm looking forward to the next release already. Thanks again for the comment, like and subscribe for more!
@zakaris725918 күн бұрын
BADUSSY 🗣️
@asleep_or_dead18 күн бұрын
le sserafim's compatible opponent
@dutchmil_bby18 күн бұрын
stan for illit here no matter what.
@Sp_official229 күн бұрын
🤡
@KimHyunlixe18 күн бұрын
Why are you watching the song once again when it does not interest you?? Normally when one hates something they do not wish to see it again. Why then are you rewatching it and creating such a reaction where you are saying its crap?? For your information they make the best music and if its not your type of song don't listen to it and let the ones who like it listen to it. There is no need of doing what you just did
@user-kg9rc9bl6k18 күн бұрын
I think you should delete this,cos have no right to call this a bad song.
@deluluforjoshua19 күн бұрын
Aight bro i get it its your opinions but listen just because its not "loud" doesnt mean its not good, have u ever heard of different genre of songs? Yeah they made a song different from their previous ones and just bc it didnt meet up to your expectations doesnt mean its crap, you couldve said u dont like it but why "lazy" "crap" etc? and plus theyve worked hard for it. Also its their us debut meaning its their first time. Also yh bro stop saying its a bad song everywhere, its so not true.
@Rajammal-md6wo19 күн бұрын
never been disappointed this much in a stay before☹️
@lauren313519 күн бұрын
You can prefer other types of music without discrediting the work that went into this one. The vocals on this track are a masterpiece. I suggest you watch the intro so you can see how much time, thought and effort went into this song’s creation. But, in the interest of transparency, I got turned off to the channel when there was a reaction and one of the first thing’s that was talked about was whether or not HJ’s lips were real. (They are.) But like how is that even relevant.
@Bunnygottalive19 күн бұрын
Guys,him not liking it,MAKES IT A BAD SONG FOR HIM. As a Stay who actually liked it, and thinks it’s better than some of their songs as of late,I totally understand him not liking it because I didn’t like FNF
@diysda17 күн бұрын
Even if it's a bad song to him, he can share his opinions without discrediting the artists work 💀 It's just disrespectful
@seyimethomas186719 күн бұрын
To you is a crap but many of us is the best. If you have listened to it before no need to listen to it again. The song is good.
@kimxiao19 күн бұрын
can't sing - debut can't sing - pre-debut so ... hybe hi??..
Пікірлер
I thought 1,3,5 (dont know the names 😭) were pretty okay actually. 3 and 5 especially stood out.
stop braging everyone down when there's only one girl that actually can't sing to save her life
Search about Chinese Knot
illit 🤢
I think they're having too much fun being idols and should take it more seriously...
This guy is a XG troll,clown🤡
They kind of sounded like if blackpink and new jeans collaborated
Love the quirkiness of the song and video, though the song can be a more serious one as there are toxic people who may live a "clean" lifestyle. That doesn't make you a good person. In my mind this video is song Japanese, especially running from a lettuce dog. LOL. Well, their previous name was SG5 or Sailor Moon 5 based off the anime. So weird, quirky is what they give. So I understand the Young Posse (who I also love) comparison. Great reaction. Want them to win too.
React vvup please
New jeans ?
Cringe af
Now.
I feel like i got scammed 🥲
To make a counter argument, what about the knowing brother (variety show) episode of Chaewon singing before their debut, and on her episode on Lee Mujin Service, also Yunjin performance on the band? ^^ Edit: Just want to include Yunjin as opera singer ^^..
Guess gonna give you tip to avoid skibidi toilet episodes... HAHAHAHA
I’m going to plonk this here to offer you some added context since you’ve stated in a comment you feel like it’s blown out of proportion. And I personally do think this didn’t have to be the huge deal it is, but when you know the additional context behind it… Well, it kind of sucks. So here’s some important context on _why_ Chinese netizens are so extra upset about Korea doing this (if it was a Japanese MV using Chinese elements and not crediting China, it might still be seen as suck-y, but not to this extent) because of some _very specific_ recent Korean-Chinese discourse. I’ve copied and paste an older comment of mine to explain it-and sorry for the very jaded tone throughout the comment; I’m very tired of the stuff that I cover in the comment itself: Raising an eyebrow at the use of Chinese culture as Korean culture in the music video. I’m not into kpop and I could be angrier about it, but honestly I’m just tired. Hell, I almost find it kind of ironic and funny. A while ago, a pretty cool Chinese manhua artist named Old Xian drew art of their characters in hanfu, and Korean netizens lost their minds over one of the character’s hats. They _insisted_ it was a Korean-exclusive hat. Chinese and Korean people began duking it out on Twitter. I didn’t have any strong feelings about it, but I saw some nasty, _nasty_ sinophobia come out from Korean netizens at the time. They claimed Chinese people didn’t have culture; or that their culture was just the tank man image and the Manchurian queue, with them attaching ugly caricatures of said Qing dynasty queue while laughing at it. They also claimed Chinese netizens were just desperately stealing Korean culture because China is undemocratic and desperate. It was so disappointing, especially since before that, I had a pretty positive view of Korea and an interest in Korean culture and history. But that instance felt like a wake-up call-a reminder that much of the world still hates and looks down on China. So anyway, that’s what feels ironic about this to me. Suddenly Chinese culture is cool to them again, as long as they get to present it as their own. To call another country a desperate, no-culture thief, only to turn around and then pull off a heist like this… Ha. Yeah. Irony. If it sounds like I’m tired and jaded, it’s because I am, at least on this topic. A while ago a Chinese KZreadr made a video to highlight the differences between hanfu and hanbok because a Korean website had claimed a Ming dynasty hanfu as Korean and was again claiming that China was stealing Korean culture (even though hanbok actually received influence _from_ the Chinese Ming in terms of design). Her video was met with massive backlash, where Korean netizens used bots to spam dislikes and comments, much of which was the same copied and pasted rant of sinophobia-about how desperate and pathetic China was, stealing cultures because it lacks democracy and freedom (as if democracy and freedom somehow correlates to the preservation of culture). Of course, Chinese netizens also got quite heated and some made comments about Korea that are also condemnable. But many were just exasperatedly trying to express that China _does_ have a culture and that not everything Chinese is stealing from Korea. Some were also asserting the historical fact about how Korea received influence from China, which _is_ a true historical fact, so I don’t fault them for that at least. I can get the frustration. Plus there was also the whole issue with pickled dishes. If I remember correctly, Chinese paocai got to become an officially recognized intangible heritage, which for anyone else would be a decent fun fact to know, but Koreans viewed it as a theft of their kimchi. And surprise, surprise, it led to even more sinophobia. Similarly, Korean netizens were outraged by China including a girl in a hanbok in the most recent Olympics at China, claiming China was stealing from them again. Except they ignored the fact there were 56 other ethnic dresses showcased at that event, because China has 56 officially recognized ethnicities and Korean-Chinese just so happens to be one of those ethnicities. Even funnier is that other Chinese ethnicities were also in their traditional dress, such as a Vietnamese-Chinese girl in what I believe was an ao dai, but no one from Vietnam grew enraged. It was only Korea. I even remember a Korean street interview where two seemingly teenage girls or young adult women said they were disappointed China would feel the need to steal the hanbok, all while they ironically stood in front of a Korean Confucian temple that still had Chinese characters on it. It’s almost as if…cultures can intermix and mingle and influence one another. It’s almost as if no culture develops purely in isolation. For example, China in fact received a lot of influence from Indian culture in terms of Buddhism and dunhuang and even some of the legends, like Nezha. But at least China admits that. And as one video on this Korean MV situation showed, Japanese culture also acknowledges its influence from China and even has some evolved differences from it. So no one would really care if the MV uses Chinese elements, which it does. They’re just upset nobody is acknowledging that there _is_ that Chinese influence, especially given the recent chaos of many Koreans refusing to see China as having _any_ culture at all. You can see it in the fan, some of the clothing elements, and the design choices like how the clouds or knots are depicted. And while none of that is that grand in isolation, it adds up when all put together-and to be done with no comment about Chinese culture at all, even more so when so many Korean netizens have proven to absolutely _hate_ and even look down on Chinese culture, just leaves a bad taste in some people’s mouths. Even more so hearing that the designer did study in China and used to even tag their art as Chinese before this MV. :/ As for me? I’m just tired. Disappointed, but not surprised.
This is not appreciation. It's not like you were buying things in the mall. You think something is pretty and you love it, then you take it--this is appreciation. And still you dont claim the design is yours. And yes, Korea and China have a lot shared history. But there's always difference in each culture. You can't use this excuse to defend this MV. Last, every elements were listed in the video you saw have their own unique cultural meanings in China. They don't in Korea.
it’s definitely not for y’all and that’s okay u just don’t get it this song is so sooo aespa y’all just go and listen to drama
The song is catchy and lyrics were intentional. They were called SG5 but changed it to f5ve. Four out of 5 were in a group called Happiness since 2008 that disbanded last year, one of the best J-Pop girl groups. They were also members of supergroup called e-girls. Together with those two and FEMM, Perfume and FAKY they are the top 5 J-Pop groups for me. Unfortunately, e-girls disbanded in December 2021 after their Christmas Goodbye concert and FEMM disbanded last year also after a decade long career.
woah, you mentioned such great jpop groups, I hope f5ve can be as legendary as them
im absolutely addicted to this song !!!! the song is really very catchy
The whole problem with this is that there are many elements in there that are Chinese, and even if there was influence, there definitely are differences between Korean and Chinese culture. Chinese people aren’t mad with Starship and IVE using Chinese elements, they are mad because Korea is claiming it as their own culture. This completely ignores the fact that 1) it originated from China, 2) it still is Chinese and there is basically none of these elements widely used or present in Korean history. 1) For example, the fan used is specifically a shape that was widely popular in Chinese history and media. Korea doesn’t have any record of this particular shaped fan in their history. Also the karst landforms which were not popularized in Korea and were basically a symbol of Chinese paintings. There are a lot more examples in there that were directly derived from China, and clearly not Korean. 2) The knots are called Chinese knots and basically symbol prosperity and wealth, in the olden days they were used as a form of recording daily activities. The ones present in the music video use a braiding style that is MOST DEFINITELY Chinese. Also they are mainly red in China because red is a color of auspiciousness and life. White knots especially used in the hair represent death which is essentially blasphemy. 3) They wear white tops in a certain scene with black skirts. That particular outfit can also be seen in their stage performances. And there is ABSOLUTELY no record of the knot buttons going straight down in a line in Korean history. That shirt style is most definitely Chinese. And a lot of Cnetizens are calling out the tops because 1: it’s Chinese, 2: they have 4 buttons in total which is an even number. It’s an extremely widely known fact among people the general public that living people always wear an odd number of buttons. Even numbers are for the deceased, and the fact that the tops are white makes it even worse. 4) Chinese culture is NO JOKE to Chinese people, Chinese people hold lots of pride in 5000 years of cultural history. And there are definitely some things that may seem weird to foreigners or might seem like jokes, however Chinese people take things like superstition and old sayings very seriously as many of these have originated from Taoist or Chinese monks.
First lol
i was genuinely confused at first listen but i've listened to it at least 30 times since it's release and man oh man is it catchy!
Support SKZ please. LOVE and Support to them.🙏🙏🙏🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤❤❤🙇♀️
One of their best songs and video
I don’t see any problem here, actually, since the Christmas was already exist in Korean for many years, we shouldn’t call it Christmas anymore, it sounds so selfish, it should be Korean Christmas or Santa’s day, and I do think Jesus is Korean. Also Kong Zi should be Korean too, let’s say the whole universe started in Korean umpire.
why every song of them is same
that’s a lie
Seriously i thought Some things was wrong with ny ears cause i didn't like the yet even though everyone and their mothers were praising it 🙂 it's just their worst for me but i hope they'll improve once the titke track drops.
Heyy thanks for the comment! No worries, you're not crazy! Something did not gel right! I hope their next title track brings them back to form. If you're into aespa, check out my other channel. I introduce my friend who doesn't like kpop to them kzread.info/dash/bejne/eKSMtdx6famygZc.html He had some interesting things to say. Thank you again for stopping by, like and subscribe for more!
girl bye
They're too vocally gifted to be doing a song as "easy" as this, I think that might be why it's underwhelming. If a less talented group did this song I feel like it would have impressed people a lot more, but we've come to expect more from Aespa. That said, I still really liked this song personally.
I subbed simply cuz UR RIGHT! they cant sing. They needed to improve pre debut hopefully they improve
at first i didnt like it and hoped that the chorus wasnt the chorus but this song is actually so aespa and cool. Sonically its chaotic and a journey yet somewhat nuance. it might actually be my favorite so far. and that 90s vibe breakdown 🤤
heeyy, I really want to love this but I can't. The breakdown is awesome! They teased that part and I was so excited. I'm still very much looking forward to their next release! If you're into aespa, check out my other channel. I introduce my friend who doesn't like kpop to them kzread.info/dash/bejne/eKSMtdx6famygZc.html He had some interesting things to say. Thank you again for stopping by, like and subscribe for more!
I'm only here for Hyunjin. At least they sing better than ILLIT. Please review ATEEZ Coachella performance.🙏🙏🙏🙏🥵🥵🥵🥵🙇♀️🖤🖤🖤
Weird song but I really love the chorus. Disappointed they missed out on giving winter ice powers
Man didn't lie
Ahaha, thank you. Alway an honest reaction. Fans don't have to love every song. If you're into aespa and more music reactions, check out my other channel. I introduce my friend who doesn't like kpop to them in this video: kzread.info/dash/bejne/eKSMtdx6famygZc.html Thank you again for stopping by, like and subscribe for more!
I agree, some parts are good, like the chorus, but as a whole? I don't think it works. The lyrics are weird to me as well lmao. Almost half of them aren't even real words, and most of them don't even mean anything. It's fine to use them every now and then, but when you use them too much, it just becomes hard to focus and understand
are you new to them? their lyrics are always weird and different it’s not anything new so idk why ur surprised
the lyrics are more lore-based so you obviously it's gonna be weird 😭 honestly stop making dumb takes when you know nothing about them
@@prtysavg no I’m not. I never said that I was surprised either
@@badfuls279 you do realize there’s a lore in the mv here too right hence why the lyrics are weird.. 😭
@@badfuls279I’m talking about “ah, oh, body bang” stuff. Never said they don’t have lore or anything. Just found it weird
I know you're more of a casual fan but here's some info on them for you... they have WAY more than just hype songs. They have a lot of softer stuff too. Levanter Astronaut Chronosaurus Mixtape: OH Cover Me Waiting For Us Muddy Water Leave Collision Chill Voices So many more... They debuted in 2018 They are ages 23 - 26 Fandom name is Stay #2 Best Selling Artist in U.S 2023 #3 Globally Best Selling 2023 They are unique for several reasons... First, the leader Bang Chan was allowed by JYP to hand pick all of the members himself. They were not placed together in a traditional way, by the company. Second all of them are all arounders. They can all sing, rap, dance, produce and write. Third, they have written and produced about 99% of their music. Numbers of songs each member has copyrighted according to Korean Music Association (KOMCA) so far... Bang Chan 182 (#3 in KPop) Changbin 154 (#11) Han 148 (#12) Hyunjin 27 Felix 22 I.N 21 Seungmin 20 Lee Know 17 While they can all do everything they do have 3 different subunits... 3Racha... Bang Chan, Chang Bin and Han which are the main producers. They are always credited as 3Racha. 3Racha Achievements - Four Time Billboard 200 #1 Producers - Hot 100 Hitmakers - 3rd, 11th, 12th Most Credited Idols on KOMCA - Produced Albums Sold Over 20 Million Copies - Japan Hot 100 Hitmakers - 100+ Weeks on Hot 100 Lyricists - 100+ Weeks On Hot 100 Composers - 2023 Asia Artist Awards Best Creator - Makers of Time Magazines 2020 #8 Best Song (their song Backdoor) Danceracha... Lee Know (in charge of leading dance practices), Felix and Hyunjin. They also contribute to the choreography. Vocalracha... Seungmin and I.N While the songs are hype they always have significant meaning to them. Their lyricism is always insane. Since they are so experimental their sound has its own genre and they have a very diverse discography. Example... Gods Menu, Back Door and Case 143 all completely different sounds.
Great reaction thank you. They produce their own music and it’s there style they cover over 40 genres so everything you can think of try watching Time Out or Lavanter etc.
This has to be their worst song for me. A weird song Chorus and bridge are ok but a little empty on the instrumental. I also don't like the switch between singing and rapping every few seconds. After releasing something like Drama this really is underwhelming.
Heey thanks for the comment! I'm echoing a lot of your thoughts. The whole song just doesn't gel as well as their other songs. Love that bridge though. Hope their next release is better! Thank you again for the comment. Like and subscribe for more!
u clearly don’t anything abt aespa except drama this is so aespa this is what they do have u ever watched next level or savage?
aespa is INOVATIVE thats why you are disappointed
Heyyy, thanks for the comment! Yeah they may be, this one didn't hit me as good as Black Mamba or Savage. It's still good but i'm looking forward to the next release already. Thanks again for the comment, like and subscribe for more!
BADUSSY 🗣️
le sserafim's compatible opponent
stan for illit here no matter what.
🤡
Why are you watching the song once again when it does not interest you?? Normally when one hates something they do not wish to see it again. Why then are you rewatching it and creating such a reaction where you are saying its crap?? For your information they make the best music and if its not your type of song don't listen to it and let the ones who like it listen to it. There is no need of doing what you just did
I think you should delete this,cos have no right to call this a bad song.
Aight bro i get it its your opinions but listen just because its not "loud" doesnt mean its not good, have u ever heard of different genre of songs? Yeah they made a song different from their previous ones and just bc it didnt meet up to your expectations doesnt mean its crap, you couldve said u dont like it but why "lazy" "crap" etc? and plus theyve worked hard for it. Also its their us debut meaning its their first time. Also yh bro stop saying its a bad song everywhere, its so not true.
never been disappointed this much in a stay before☹️
You can prefer other types of music without discrediting the work that went into this one. The vocals on this track are a masterpiece. I suggest you watch the intro so you can see how much time, thought and effort went into this song’s creation. But, in the interest of transparency, I got turned off to the channel when there was a reaction and one of the first thing’s that was talked about was whether or not HJ’s lips were real. (They are.) But like how is that even relevant.
Guys,him not liking it,MAKES IT A BAD SONG FOR HIM. As a Stay who actually liked it, and thinks it’s better than some of their songs as of late,I totally understand him not liking it because I didn’t like FNF
Even if it's a bad song to him, he can share his opinions without discrediting the artists work 💀 It's just disrespectful
To you is a crap but many of us is the best. If you have listened to it before no need to listen to it again. The song is good.
can't sing - debut can't sing - pre-debut so ... hybe hi??..