Frankly its a good documentary about picturing what happened chronologically. However it lacks a little bit of the neutral journalistic posture that should be promoted in a political documentary. Stuff like the narrator saying "the collapse of Canada" "breaking Canada" "the end of Canada" "the destruction of the country" "the survival of the country" is definitely canadian nationalist vocabulary.
@chauve631024 күн бұрын
Vive le Québec libre!
@ButchMcLarty2 ай бұрын
I think the Montreal Canadiens hockey club made the difference in the No vote
@jacobsnider73042 ай бұрын
What a mistake...would have been great to be free of them. Please Quebec - try again.
@DFandV3 ай бұрын
Quebec referendum in 1995 to leave Canada, remain win. Scotland referendum in 2014 to leave the United Kingdom, remain win.
@gabrieltheriault92413 ай бұрын
@TylerBucketKZread you should listen to this if you want to learn more about 1995's Quebec referendum for independance
@user-zr6pl6nb6z4 ай бұрын
That song at 45:30 is very catchy.
@danieldydzak6914 ай бұрын
Quebec is fantastic but so is canada. Vive le canada et quebec .
@Christian_Martel5 ай бұрын
58:48 Too late for remorse.
@bibouley24595 ай бұрын
Vive le Québec libre. Pour ma patrie mon peuple et ma belle langue le français!!!
@Ejb9056 ай бұрын
The accents be dammed. The sepreptist movement made Toronto the true city in Canada, before the 70's it was Montreal. This movement helped send a million people out of Quebec, mainly anglos and allos. I am one of them, i tired of the division and left for more lucrative and warmer weather
@herps5886 ай бұрын
Lol screw this fake, bland, soulless post-national joke of a country called "Canada"
@Walt787 ай бұрын
I worked for an American-Canadian company. I learned a great deal about Canada and its idiosyncracies. Particularly Québec, as since I'm Francophone I worked a lot with Québécois. They should take advantage of having two official languages to make a population naturally bilingual. However, they don't. The documentary is pretty good. I watch it from time to time.
@sylvainb23667 ай бұрын
À 53:23 la narratrice est muette concernant le nombre de personnes présentent au love-in, on comprend, c'était malaisé de le dire, on pourrait en déduire combien ça a coûté, mais ça Chrétien s'en foutait, comme il l'a déjà dit. Les forces étaient tellement inégales, le fédéral avait un budget illimité, on n'aura jamais la vérité, il a des complices partout.
@r.c.brousseau96558 ай бұрын
I’ve always had the utmost respect for Jean Chretien! On the other hand, Jacques Parizeau had none of the qualities to make him a great leader, and history proves a much.
@isidoremathon528 ай бұрын
Vive le Québec libre !
@g_y.rtz4208 ай бұрын
this looks like a job for EREN JAEGER
@omarelshayal333710 ай бұрын
remember that night well. Was on edge..then Euphoria....then anger with Parizeau's comments.
@garyholt831510 ай бұрын
brian tobin was a federal cabinet minister and actually served the country with much wisdom. cant say that about any of them today.
@sylvainb236611 ай бұрын
Le Canada c'est deux pays dont l'un, plus peuplé, a la mainmise sur l'autre, comment peut-il y avoir équité ? Francophones du Québec, il est temps d'accéder à nos aspirations profondes. Soyons fiers et ayons confiance en nos moyens !
@sylvainb236611 ай бұрын
7:57 Il n'est jamais trop tard pour bien faire mon ti-Jean, faut pas baisser les bras comme t'as fait, c'est honteux, surtout que tu nous montres que t'as pensé à tes intérêts personnels avant ceux de ton peuple.
@sylvainb236611 ай бұрын
Jacques Parizeau, quel grand personnage !
@sylvainb236611 ай бұрын
La prochaine fois sera la bonne, aucun doute là-dessus, just watch us !
@sylvainb236611 ай бұрын
Tout Québécois francophone qui combat la souveraineté est un ignorant, rien de moins. Le Québec n'a pas d'avenir dans la confédération canadienne, il va perdre son poids démographique ce qui va l'isoler de plus en plus de toute façon.
@sylvainb236611 ай бұрын
Part 3 soon ! Les Québécois attendent l'ultime prochain grand rendez-vous.
@alainpare81911 ай бұрын
VIVE LE QUÉBEC LIBRE
@caesarwept316211 ай бұрын
money and the ethnic vote won the election. blueprint for Obama, Biden and Justin Trudeau
@LightPink Жыл бұрын
Comparing the french unload's comment section to this one is interesting 😅
@AG-ni8jm Жыл бұрын
I love Quebec but they need to learn to speak proper French
@sylvainb236610 ай бұрын
You just don't know how to appreciate our accent
@hamalakarris577 Жыл бұрын
Anyone know the name of the song at 1:03:27?
@sylvainb236610 ай бұрын
Le début d'un temps nouveau
@jtnelson4579 Жыл бұрын
16:29
@rogerpenroset.blaine4233 Жыл бұрын
57:16 😂😂 that boy didn't understand what he was saying
@rstevens1836 Жыл бұрын
I've watched this doc 10 times or so. Captivating and educational about Canada and Quebec and the bitter differences between the two. I hope I can visit Quebec and learn more about the people, culture, and learn both sides of the separation/unification issue. Learn some Francais too. I hope for peace between Canada and Quebec and any province or territory who wants to secede. Let's not go back to the violent nightmare Quebec was back in the 60's s'il te plaît!
@fredklein3829 Жыл бұрын
What is wrong with these francophones who cannot say Charlottetown the correct way? Research shows Charlotte is actually a French name, yet they make it sound like CHOCOLATE Town. Are they stupid?
@tommym.6074 Жыл бұрын
Parizeau was only a big looser !
@pierresigouin3556 Жыл бұрын
Without the province of quebec canada will be just a silence and boring country who ll keep this attachment to the british monarchie ..as colonianisme
@TMBpk Жыл бұрын
Very good documentary.
@goldeneve Жыл бұрын
question….during the referendum of 95 and 80 while Jean Chretien and pierre trudeau and the rest of politicians in Ottawa and Canadians everywhere was stressing about this. Where was the Governor General in those years during the referendum ?
@electronsd Жыл бұрын
They had nothing to do because the govenor generals role is apolitical
@goldeneve10 ай бұрын
@@electronsdah I think I got the answer thanks
@jeffreykaufmann2867 Жыл бұрын
If the Question was more simple: Do you agree that Quebec should become a independent Country the Yes side would have less than 45%.
@liamcdm3689 Жыл бұрын
Most likely less than that even. Hardline sovereignists are probably 35-40% of the population at most. Then there's the 15 or 20% that are soft nationalists that are more interested in the distinct society philosophy over separation.
@freddysirocco957711 ай бұрын
Because that is not the question. The more simple question is "do you want to gave Canada a last chance instead we become indépendant" That is the question
@Paranoid_Found Жыл бұрын
Fascinating documentary
@denelson832 жыл бұрын
Essentially what Chrétien was arguing is that Parizeau had made his referendum into a "push poll", trying to manipulate the electorate into giving Parizeau what he wanted.
@annehebert5102 жыл бұрын
Anglo-Canadians should just join the United States where you belong. You're just Americans loyal to the British crown. That's all you ever were, that's all you ever will be.
@elscorpioperfecto32602 жыл бұрын
I wonder how the Albertans in the mark 49:40-49:43 feel their decision to rally for unity???? 25 years later they want WEXit lol.
@mcawilson602 жыл бұрын
Chretien was the consummate globalist. Lol at him quoting The Economist mag. To him, patriotism is love of massive bureaucracies and subversive judiciaries pushing Leftist agendas under the guise of institutional authority & prestige.
@mcawilson602 жыл бұрын
Suspect if Quebec had voted Yes, the globalist ruling class in the US would've tried to punish Quebec. Canada is essentially a node of the Globalist American Empire (GAE), and the GAE wouldn't have tolerated this type of devolution, or self determination of a distinctive European diaspora. The sentiments of Clinton admin pol Wesley Clark about the unacceptability of relatively homogeneous nation states in Europe give a big clue about this. There is a barely concealed hatred of European cultures and peoples in the US Deep State. Thus their enthusiasm for mass immigration from the 3rd World.
@Cazador601402 жыл бұрын
Quebec should stay in Canada , remain strong economically , socially and watch it sink into the sea , 1867 Canada is no more
@patriceguerette78072 жыл бұрын
What the ROC (reste of Canada outside Québec) will never understand is that Canada is not their country it's ours. They are only americans with a Queen.
@paddocklockersby80892 жыл бұрын
Honestly, Canada should remain together. Remember when Jean-Francois Lisee percieved earlier in Part 1 that Lucien Bouchard's illness was part of a curse every time there was a surge of seperatism in Quebec? How about Parizeau's comments about Francophones and the Money and Ethnic vote comments? We haven't forgot about that either. It's more proof that trying to seperate Canada from Quebec is plain stupid.
@goldeneve Жыл бұрын
True
@maxgo91062 жыл бұрын
the separatist shows their real color in that concession speech...........bunch of racist people
@amogusenjoyer2 жыл бұрын
What is really sad is not necessarily the outcome of the referendum in my opinion. It's the realization that we used to have actual statesmen, on both sides, who had actual convictions and a vision. We are left with absolutely nothing more than inane and empty politicians who do not see or care about anything more than the results of the next polls. There are no statesmen left in canada (or in quebec) and it's future is going to be bleaker than it ought to be.
Пікірлер
Frankly its a good documentary about picturing what happened chronologically. However it lacks a little bit of the neutral journalistic posture that should be promoted in a political documentary. Stuff like the narrator saying "the collapse of Canada" "breaking Canada" "the end of Canada" "the destruction of the country" "the survival of the country" is definitely canadian nationalist vocabulary.
Vive le Québec libre!
I think the Montreal Canadiens hockey club made the difference in the No vote
What a mistake...would have been great to be free of them. Please Quebec - try again.
Quebec referendum in 1995 to leave Canada, remain win. Scotland referendum in 2014 to leave the United Kingdom, remain win.
@TylerBucketKZread you should listen to this if you want to learn more about 1995's Quebec referendum for independance
That song at 45:30 is very catchy.
Quebec is fantastic but so is canada. Vive le canada et quebec .
58:48 Too late for remorse.
Vive le Québec libre. Pour ma patrie mon peuple et ma belle langue le français!!!
The accents be dammed. The sepreptist movement made Toronto the true city in Canada, before the 70's it was Montreal. This movement helped send a million people out of Quebec, mainly anglos and allos. I am one of them, i tired of the division and left for more lucrative and warmer weather
Lol screw this fake, bland, soulless post-national joke of a country called "Canada"
I worked for an American-Canadian company. I learned a great deal about Canada and its idiosyncracies. Particularly Québec, as since I'm Francophone I worked a lot with Québécois. They should take advantage of having two official languages to make a population naturally bilingual. However, they don't. The documentary is pretty good. I watch it from time to time.
À 53:23 la narratrice est muette concernant le nombre de personnes présentent au love-in, on comprend, c'était malaisé de le dire, on pourrait en déduire combien ça a coûté, mais ça Chrétien s'en foutait, comme il l'a déjà dit. Les forces étaient tellement inégales, le fédéral avait un budget illimité, on n'aura jamais la vérité, il a des complices partout.
I’ve always had the utmost respect for Jean Chretien! On the other hand, Jacques Parizeau had none of the qualities to make him a great leader, and history proves a much.
Vive le Québec libre !
this looks like a job for EREN JAEGER
remember that night well. Was on edge..then Euphoria....then anger with Parizeau's comments.
brian tobin was a federal cabinet minister and actually served the country with much wisdom. cant say that about any of them today.
Le Canada c'est deux pays dont l'un, plus peuplé, a la mainmise sur l'autre, comment peut-il y avoir équité ? Francophones du Québec, il est temps d'accéder à nos aspirations profondes. Soyons fiers et ayons confiance en nos moyens !
7:57 Il n'est jamais trop tard pour bien faire mon ti-Jean, faut pas baisser les bras comme t'as fait, c'est honteux, surtout que tu nous montres que t'as pensé à tes intérêts personnels avant ceux de ton peuple.
Jacques Parizeau, quel grand personnage !
La prochaine fois sera la bonne, aucun doute là-dessus, just watch us !
Tout Québécois francophone qui combat la souveraineté est un ignorant, rien de moins. Le Québec n'a pas d'avenir dans la confédération canadienne, il va perdre son poids démographique ce qui va l'isoler de plus en plus de toute façon.
Part 3 soon ! Les Québécois attendent l'ultime prochain grand rendez-vous.
VIVE LE QUÉBEC LIBRE
money and the ethnic vote won the election. blueprint for Obama, Biden and Justin Trudeau
Comparing the french unload's comment section to this one is interesting 😅
I love Quebec but they need to learn to speak proper French
You just don't know how to appreciate our accent
Anyone know the name of the song at 1:03:27?
Le début d'un temps nouveau
16:29
57:16 😂😂 that boy didn't understand what he was saying
I've watched this doc 10 times or so. Captivating and educational about Canada and Quebec and the bitter differences between the two. I hope I can visit Quebec and learn more about the people, culture, and learn both sides of the separation/unification issue. Learn some Francais too. I hope for peace between Canada and Quebec and any province or territory who wants to secede. Let's not go back to the violent nightmare Quebec was back in the 60's s'il te plaît!
What is wrong with these francophones who cannot say Charlottetown the correct way? Research shows Charlotte is actually a French name, yet they make it sound like CHOCOLATE Town. Are they stupid?
Parizeau was only a big looser !
Without the province of quebec canada will be just a silence and boring country who ll keep this attachment to the british monarchie ..as colonianisme
Very good documentary.
question….during the referendum of 95 and 80 while Jean Chretien and pierre trudeau and the rest of politicians in Ottawa and Canadians everywhere was stressing about this. Where was the Governor General in those years during the referendum ?
They had nothing to do because the govenor generals role is apolitical
@@electronsdah I think I got the answer thanks
If the Question was more simple: Do you agree that Quebec should become a independent Country the Yes side would have less than 45%.
Most likely less than that even. Hardline sovereignists are probably 35-40% of the population at most. Then there's the 15 or 20% that are soft nationalists that are more interested in the distinct society philosophy over separation.
Because that is not the question. The more simple question is "do you want to gave Canada a last chance instead we become indépendant" That is the question
Fascinating documentary
Essentially what Chrétien was arguing is that Parizeau had made his referendum into a "push poll", trying to manipulate the electorate into giving Parizeau what he wanted.
Anglo-Canadians should just join the United States where you belong. You're just Americans loyal to the British crown. That's all you ever were, that's all you ever will be.
I wonder how the Albertans in the mark 49:40-49:43 feel their decision to rally for unity???? 25 years later they want WEXit lol.
Chretien was the consummate globalist. Lol at him quoting The Economist mag. To him, patriotism is love of massive bureaucracies and subversive judiciaries pushing Leftist agendas under the guise of institutional authority & prestige.
Suspect if Quebec had voted Yes, the globalist ruling class in the US would've tried to punish Quebec. Canada is essentially a node of the Globalist American Empire (GAE), and the GAE wouldn't have tolerated this type of devolution, or self determination of a distinctive European diaspora. The sentiments of Clinton admin pol Wesley Clark about the unacceptability of relatively homogeneous nation states in Europe give a big clue about this. There is a barely concealed hatred of European cultures and peoples in the US Deep State. Thus their enthusiasm for mass immigration from the 3rd World.
Quebec should stay in Canada , remain strong economically , socially and watch it sink into the sea , 1867 Canada is no more
What the ROC (reste of Canada outside Québec) will never understand is that Canada is not their country it's ours. They are only americans with a Queen.
Honestly, Canada should remain together. Remember when Jean-Francois Lisee percieved earlier in Part 1 that Lucien Bouchard's illness was part of a curse every time there was a surge of seperatism in Quebec? How about Parizeau's comments about Francophones and the Money and Ethnic vote comments? We haven't forgot about that either. It's more proof that trying to seperate Canada from Quebec is plain stupid.
True
the separatist shows their real color in that concession speech...........bunch of racist people
What is really sad is not necessarily the outcome of the referendum in my opinion. It's the realization that we used to have actual statesmen, on both sides, who had actual convictions and a vision. We are left with absolutely nothing more than inane and empty politicians who do not see or care about anything more than the results of the next polls. There are no statesmen left in canada (or in quebec) and it's future is going to be bleaker than it ought to be.