Пікірлер

• 
  @asimnawaz92565 күн бұрын

  India was not Africa. It had an advanced civilisation but still it was far behind England. Apart from other things, Europeans were far more educated as compared to general Indians. Let's take the example of artificial fertiliser, it was based on German research, but it came to India through its contact with Britain . When we compare the education level of two societies, we can say that Indians were semi-literates whereas Europeans were highly educated people. It is undeniable fact, why would we distort history.What's the purpose of telling lies to public?

• 
  @iloveatish9 күн бұрын

  Irfan Habib , reputed historian 🙂🙂

• 
  @iloveatish10 күн бұрын

  they are wearing the colors of the cricket teams

• 
  @sarahp138328 күн бұрын

  This talk given by Manu was so refreshingly engrossing. Manu brought history alive with his excellent talk, studded with factual details , straddling centuries of Indian history, and intelligently condensed in one easy flow . Do we have professors of his calibre in any of our universities today ? Decades back, in LSR , the history hour was so dull, that we skipped it, rather than be forced to concentrate on the insipid drone of the history lecturers. Another point which deserves to be commended, is when Manu drew our attention to the current Government's misplaced sense of cultural loyalty rooted in religious bigotry. Senselessly they have expended crores of rupees, to mulishly erect temples in supposedly historic spots, so as to avenge the destruction done to our temples by past invaders . What a way of making peace with our collective consciences! If we care so deeply about the preservation of our cultural heritage, what have you got to say about the general state of decay of so many priceless heritage monuments all across India, whose architectural grandeur and their sheer scale of magnificence is beyond compare . Today they are crumbling relics of the past. The awe inspiring temples of the South ,are in such a sorry state of neglect, with ugly electirc wires looped spaghetti- -style, in the most irreverent manner around the stunning idols ......what is the archaelogical department of India doing to preserve our much celebrated heritage? Thank you Manu for this brilliant talk.

• 
  @854888992 ай бұрын

  I thoroughly enjoyed this respectful, factual and spirited debate between two well matched experts on the subject of the British colonisation of India.

• 
  @dcompany52402 ай бұрын

  Zareer is been paid by british alias looters, so his speech doesn’t make sense😂😂

• 
  @youthwave2 ай бұрын

  Is it litfest or shitfest?

• 
  @RaitaNag3 ай бұрын

  But WhatsApp history can change election

• 
  @nirmalakutty94163 ай бұрын

  Enjoyable all the way thru

• 
  @RR-wp8jt3 ай бұрын

  Now I understand how brown coolies like Dr. Masani managed to motivated rule a huge subcontinent

• 
  @anilbahl61324 ай бұрын

  Zareer kept shifting goalposts whenever Shashi whacked his nonsense! The fact is the British LOOTED india and actually destroyed the NW by creating a D grade nation called Pakistan to PREVENT USSR accessing the Arabian Sea trade routes. The thieving Brit’s entered into an evil back room illicit agreement with Jinnah to allow the Pakistanis to ANNEXE the INDEPENDENT COUNTRY of Baluchistan (yes they got independence along with India and Pakistan)! Why was a special reservation of seats allowed for Muslims? Were there special reserved seats where only Hindus could vote for Hindus? The whole Zareer argument is bereft of figures of the LOOT & PILLAGE of Hindustan by enslaving British “royalty”! Why did Britain create an INCOMPETENT RADCLIFFE LINE as far back as 1943 (under the India hater Churchill) and implement it in a matter of weeks in 1947? Churchill was a lousy SOB whose bones should be interred and fed to pigs! The time has come when Britain has collapsed because they cannot sustain without LOOT! Britain shall pay dearly for their repressive and cruel exploitation of colonial (mis)rule! As per latest research these lousy buggers owe a reparation of USD 45 TRILLION to India. We don’t want it. Let the nation of lousy shopkeepers feed on that LOOT! We will rule that shitty nation very soon - all their business is mostly under Indian dominance anyways India shall NEVER FORGET that the lousy Brit’s sent in the HMS Eagle Fleet into the Arabian Sea when the jerk Nixon sent the USS Enterprise into the Bay of Bengal in 1970, only to scoot like rats when the Russian subs showed up in between East Bengal (Bangladesh) and their fleet. Indians shall never forget. We shall rule UK economically India shall be glorious again! Boo to white skinned lickers like Zareer! 👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼

• 
  @RaitaNag4 ай бұрын

  First of all taking 7 year old to such a movie shows immaturity of the parent

• 
  @venug26174 ай бұрын

  Eloquent........

• 
  @nandamenon35184 ай бұрын

  Alas! Sashi protests too much! And he talks over his interlocutor.

• 
  @nandamenon35184 ай бұрын

  Poor Sashi, facing someone with facts. Sashi is getting rattled and resorting to speaking over his debater without facts to support his argument. Until now, no one ever contracted him, so now he resorts to just speaking over his interlocutor and raising his voice. Poor debater.

• 
  @gintasasd3 ай бұрын

  Yeah, it's kinda same as chinise "historians," and politics say China was grate until the west arrived sometime people shoud swallow there pride amd just accept the truth

• 
  @dranzergigs83332 ай бұрын

  ​@@gintasasd to accept that non white people are an inferior race?

• 
  @manishrdesai14 ай бұрын

  2024 I watching this video

• 
  @infinity704554 ай бұрын

  2024

• 
  @parjanyashukla1765 ай бұрын

  (8:00) LMAO 🤣 Shurpanakha quoting Shariah. So Shurpanakha belonged to which fiqh of Islam. 😂

• 
  @narayananskp6 ай бұрын

  While I agree that things were not black and white and there were silver linings here and there, it is what the majority of incidents and that the overall drive was religious for the invaders is something we need to acknowledge. Once the fact that these terrible atrocities were committed is acknowledged only we decide how to go ahead in a better way. The problem is the reluctance to acknowledge these.

• 
  @gc959156 ай бұрын

  Brilliant kid.

• 
  @Archer3967 ай бұрын

  What a roast you guys😅😂😂

• 
  @asimnawaz92568 ай бұрын

  Apart from racial considerations, there was practical necessity to keep Europeans in top bureaucratic positions. White people in India had to deal with ultra high occupational hazard. So handing top jobs like Commissioner of Police and Civil Administrator of City to local Indians could create security issues for Europeans.

• 
  @tradfluteman8 ай бұрын

  I commend any Indian who loves their country, and is justly proud of their independence movement, who is also brave enough to discard historical caricatures and myths about British rule. I'm not defending the Raj; noted economists like Amartya Sen are highly critical of it, and that makes me hesitate to fully embrace what Masani is saying here, but we need more open-hearted curiosity and less snap judgment in this world.

• 
  @mainakmukhopadhyayy5498 ай бұрын

  Watching this video in 2023, after the muzzafarnagar school incident, his words at 33:37 just blows your mind off! Its uncanny how he predicted the consequences so precisely.

• 
  @dumdumdumdum88048 ай бұрын

  Seeing all the stupids praising this idiot who want to be poster boy of the british just like Gandhi and Nehru, your ancestors must be crying, no victor write any bad history about themselves and you are reading their writings to know the damage they done to India, this guy is idiot but may be due to his loyalties could not be trusted because of being momo follower, that itself reduced his credibility if he could not decide what is right and wrong being Momo as humanity role model he is just a zombie, nothing else.

• 
  @smitachandra4328 ай бұрын

  We had south Indian history in our books and were taught it but then our school gave lots of importance to the humanities also rather than science and maths which most schools tend to.

• 
  @Maahii78799 ай бұрын

  🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

• 
  @pradipghose21259 ай бұрын

  Sorry 1885

• 
  @pradipghose21259 ай бұрын

  Mr Zareer was talking about rule of law. Are the two debaters aware that Indian judges in High Court were paid two third salary paid to British judges. till 1985.

• 
  @NeelamS-hk4jm10 ай бұрын

  These people operate in entirely different world and hence the effect of their lyrics and soulful intelligent music

• 
  @user-fl4gh3vd8k10 ай бұрын

  Britishers never came to India to serve us,East India Co wanted to do trade,then plunder n loot eventually!period.from sone ki chidiya 2 destruction

• 
  @gauravkamal302710 ай бұрын

  Tharoor lacked facts. Later emotions and n at d end truth .... 😂😂😂😂. Fucked up. Masani made it. ❤

• 
  @hemlatagurjar346510 ай бұрын

  What a intellectual 💖

• 
  @user-ox4yb2yc1f5 ай бұрын

  Com k k Lal salam lalolalsala.❤

• 
  @Kepier8810 ай бұрын

  Shashi Tharoor is talking bullshit. English ships were made of Oak, and would last around 30 years on average, and it is a better material than Mahogany. It resists salt water corrosion better and is easier to work with. Indian ships would have been made with Teak, not Mahogany' that was the standard material in the tropics. He doesn't even know what he is talking about. Britain has been at the front of naval architecture for 3 centuries. The East and West Indiaman ships were British and Dutch ships, the best at the time. Look up the build records, they're online. The only exception were the ships built by Wadia Group/ Wadia Family of Bombay Docks, who supplied high quality ships - Tharoors fictional account has no relation to that history. Britain had every right to protect its own ship building industry in 1817 and protect its workers...how is this even controversial? Is it racist for the British government to be pressured to protect its tax payers? He has no interest in the truth. He has made his mind up and simply runs his mouth with inaccurate data trying to confirm his bias.

• 
  @mohuamaitra448310 ай бұрын

  Commendable truly

• 
  @JeanDeaux-uj5cg10 ай бұрын

  This debate was over in the first five minutes when the guy in blue gave an erroneous export figure was corrected by the guy in green and said "but the point I'm trying to make". Let's not let the facts get in the way shall we. Then at the end it all makes sense, one is a politician and one is a historian. One likes facts the other likes votes. Warning Hitlers rise to power followed a similar path, nationalism and victimhood.

• 
  @music_suzic11 ай бұрын

  That's how debates are done... Listening, Countering with facts and acceptance...not the way our Hindi Media organises debates... shouting, shouting and SHOUTING

• 
  @aalekhsharma8 ай бұрын

  brother please watch debates on dd news

• 
  @Pcolloins11 ай бұрын

  Love this Debate. It’s a very interesting part of history. Respect to them both

• 
  @wanderlust...H11 ай бұрын

  At 5.58 / yeah bro send him to Dadar Shivaji Park. We'll have chai 😆

• 
  @damarubhandari725311 ай бұрын

  At least one of you dhould go and fuck momta

• 
  @Matrix-Documentaries11 ай бұрын

  Consciously choosing to defend the rapacious actions of your ancestors just shows how immoral and rotten you Britishers in the comments are.

• 
  @donkeydesiamericanprofessor11 ай бұрын

  Exactly one hundred percent correct Indians are horrible people committing atrocities against Indians and blaming the British you are 100% correct

• 
  @freneticness6927 Жыл бұрын

  Talking about gdp before the industrial revolution is silly.

• 
  @donkeydesiamericanprofessor11 ай бұрын

  You can never give Indians any education they will never learn Indians will never learn

• 
  @Alphabetatheta-fl1vz Жыл бұрын

  Jai Shri Ram

• 
  @Alphabetatheta-fl1vz Жыл бұрын

  Take Name of Saint Sri Hanuman Prasad Poddar with Respect!

• 
  @majidmumtaj8886 Жыл бұрын

  Alphabetathetalauda

• 
  @ankits7106 Жыл бұрын

  @@majidmumtaj8886 chup bay jihadi mc

• 
  @majidmumtaj8886 Жыл бұрын

  ​@@ankits7106 #lovejihadi.... Apni choti behen se puch..... oopz....She is sucking me now...

• 
  @batman7323 Жыл бұрын

  Epic Shit!!!

• 
  @AshishKumar-kv4hr Жыл бұрын

  ITT: Non Indians justifying all the atrocities of British Raj. Shame on you. Could you say the same about Hitler?

• 
  @AshishKumar-kv4hr Жыл бұрын

  @RobertClive1757 they weren't at least dying by the millions. At least not before both British and Mughals.

• 
  @AshishKumar-kv4hr Жыл бұрын

  @RobertClive1757 take your meds. If they're available, that is.

• 
  @donkeydesiamericanprofessor11 ай бұрын

  Indians love to believe that the British were horrible against Indians but it was the Indians that committed atrocities against Indians emblem the British Exactly one hundred percent correct Indians are horrible people committing atrocities against Indians and blaming the British you are 100% correct

• 
  @Pudin-kc2oz9 ай бұрын

  ​@@donkeydesiamericanprofessor Despite pretending to be a multicultural society Racism against black people grew after 1860, when race-based discrimination was fed by then-popular theories of scientific racism.[16] Attempts to support these theories cited 'scientific evidence', such as brain size. James Hunt, President of the London Anthropological Society, in 1863 in his paper "On the Negro's place in nature" wrote,"the Negro is inferior intellectually to the European...[and] can only be humanised and civilised by Europeans."[17] Following disarmament in 1919, surplus of labour and shortage of housing led to dissatisfaction among Britain’s working class, in particular sailors and dock workers. In ports, such as South Shields,[18] Glasgow, London's East End, Liverpool, Cardiff, Barry and Newport there were fierce race riots targeting ethnic minority populations. During violence in 1919 there were five fatalities, as well as widespread vandalism of property. 120 black workers were sacked in Liverpool after whites refused to work with them. A modern study of the 1919 riots by Jacqueline Jenkinson showed that police arrested nearly twice as many blacks (155) as whites (89). While most of the whites were convicted, nearly half of Black arrestees were acquitted. Jenkinson suggests that the courts acknowledged their innocence and were recognising and attempting to correct for police bias.[19] Racial segregation existed throughout much of the country in the early 20th century. The landmark case Constantine v Imperial Hotels Ltd (1944) established an important step in the development of modern anti-discrimination law[20] and according to Peter Mason, it "was one of the key milestones along the road to the creation of the Race Relations Act of 1965."[21] Popular Trinidadian cricketer Learie Constantine was awarded damages at the High Court after being turned away from the Imperial Hotel in Russell Square, London in 1943. The proprietor believed his presence would offend white American servicemen staying at the hotel, as the United States Armed Forces were still racially segregated. Public and political opinion was in Constantine's favour over the case. In Parliament, then Under-Secretary of State for Dominion Affairs Paul Emrys-Evans said the government: "most strongly condemns any form of racial discrimination against Colonial people in this country."[22] Although racial discrimination continued in England, this case was the first to challenge such practices in court. Critics regard it as a milestone in British racial equality in demonstrating that black people had legal recourse against some forms of racism.[23] There were further riots targeting immigrant and minority populations in East London and Notting Hill in the 1950s, leading to the establishment of the Notting Hill Carnival.

• 
  @AshishKumar-kv4hr Жыл бұрын

  Genocide of millions of Indians just so that the British twats could feed their army and population across the globe and this man calls it "improvement of India". I agree the British left a bunch of good things in India, made railway network to where normally it wouldn't have back then, and infrastructure probably here and there but that doesn't even cover up 1% of the atrocities they carried out in those 200 years

• 
  @AshishKumar-kv4hr Жыл бұрын

  @RobertClive1757 gaslighting me won't absolve your criminal ancestors of their sin. They're gonna rot in hell and so will your future generations.

• 
  @donkeydesiamericanprofessor11 ай бұрын

  Explain to me how you think the British committed genocide by stealing food from Indians Indians love to believe that the British were horrible against Indians but it was the Indians that committed atrocities against Indians emblem the British Exactly one hundred percent correct Indians are horrible people committing atrocities against Indians and blaming the British you are 100% correct

• 
  @Zehrila0753R Жыл бұрын

  Basically Zareer Masani is talking about Indian history when there were Mughals all over India, obviously at that time when Britishers were in India it was Mughal period so after hearing all these things not that much surprise but this There are many flaws in the video also because he is talking to a politician not a historian, otherwise as I am interested in history and this curiosity helps me to know more about history and as much as I know, so I am sure if a historian and this man had a debate, he would have lost very badly.

• 
  @donkeydesiamericanprofessor11 ай бұрын

  Unbelievable that Indians would rather believe a politician than a world-renowned Indian historian it's Indian mentality to be fooled Explain to me how you think the British committed genocide by stealing food from Indians Indians love to believe that the British were horrible against Indians but it was the Indians that committed atrocities against Indians emblem the British Exactly one hundred percent correct Indians are horrible people committing atrocities against Indians and blaming the British you are 100% correct

• 
  @gintasasd3 ай бұрын

  The thing is, Dr. masani had a conversation with the politician who's enter look is uk evil before India was great later it was bad he build he's support from ultra nationalists so expecting Mr tharror to talk about more history less politics would ruin he'd enter look becouse he would have to understand that British build up India or others ways it wouldn't be profitable

• 
  @revealedgnosis Жыл бұрын

  Book called Colonialism: a moral reckoning, Came out by Nigel Biggar . In this book he Totally Evicerates Tharoors arguments with cold hard historical Truth. Go buy it and you'll see Emiprically that Britain helped India in many many ways, its a complex history but this guy lies and distorts to a whopping degree.

• 
  @donkeydesiamericanprofessor11 ай бұрын

  Sashi Tharoor politician spewing lies Unbelievable that Indians would rather believe a politician than a world-renowned Indian historian it's Indian mentality to be fooled Explain to me how you think the British committed genocide by stealing food from Indians Indians love to believe that the British were horrible against Indians but it was the Indians that committed atrocities against Indians emblem the British Exactly one hundred percent correct Indians are horrible people committing atrocities against Indians and blaming the British you are 100% correct

• 
  @krushnadeepsonu35524 ай бұрын

  I'm gonna buy it.

• 
  @beatup4236 Жыл бұрын

  Even though British invaded India, it turned out to be a blessing in disguise for the Majority of Indians (so called lower castes)