I think it's silly to judge people from the 17th, 18th, 19th, and even 20th century by 21st century standards. You are totally fine telling White Americans that their ancestors were bad, while acting like every other ethnic group in history have been saints. People didn't have the same standards of morality back then, it was a totally different and quite tribalistic world. Everybody had in-group biases, not just Europeans. Why are you pretending like the English settlers in North America should have had the same moral standards as a Harvard student in 2024?
@electriczombie8299Ай бұрын
You should have Douglas Murray come on, get some opposing views points.
@IslamAkefEbeidАй бұрын
Oh Harry Truman did not like the Israeli's here is a proof below. Infact I would say he is the most Pro Palestianian if you will. If that means anything. He recognized that they exist and did not like that the Israeli's wanted most of the land. kzread.info/dash/bejne/mohhuJl8k8LXXdY.html
@ahsenzafar80372 ай бұрын
@christiansmith-of7dt2 ай бұрын
If you dont reach out to people how are you going to give them anything
@wuteva342 ай бұрын
Israel has totally become one big Jonestown, with a never ending supply of Kool-Aid given to them by the United States and my tax dollars !! They’re delusion of racial and religious superiority over every other living organism on planet earth has reached epidemic proportions! For 75 years, the United States has been perpetuating this delusion, and helping it along
@cocoloco2852 ай бұрын
Miserable fkctrd5
@dominicphillip58162 ай бұрын
Vote for Cornell West as a third party candidate.
@dominicphillip58162 ай бұрын
Proff Khalidi is very articulate and intelligent however he surely must of heard of the Granada pogrom of 1066 or the Safed pogrom of 1834.
@emmaa81622 ай бұрын
Some really good questions.
@emmaa81622 ай бұрын
I have learnt so much from Prof Khalidi about the history of Palestine from YT videos and his extensive book ' The 100 years war on Palestine'. He is an incredible scholar and educator. Thank you, Prof Khalidi.
@electriczombie82992 ай бұрын
Get a real job
@MisterTea1232 ай бұрын
Dr Khalidi is unapologetic and erudite - I love it!
@MisterTea1232 ай бұрын
One of the most important voices on Palestine, needs to be amplified and preserved for posterity
@MisterTea1232 ай бұрын
Excellent interview, Professor Khalidi is an overflowing reservoir of experience, knowledge and insight but can explain things so clearly and calmly. Thank you
@blackcreekorganicfarm2962 ай бұрын
Facist racist genocidal apartheid state I have believed this since I was 18 I am now 53 And nothing has been done against Israel to hold it to account by any country
@evamurray25642 ай бұрын
Hamas is responsible.
@Sana05672 ай бұрын
The problem with people in diaspora is at some point they don’t understand their country and their people mind anymore because they are westernized. Jennin camp was going to be evacuated after the end of holiday. The people is displaced to perhaps Jordan. Alaghsa mosque would be handed over to Isr and West bank will be emptied from Pls. They were not armed and they had no choice to leave. Arab leaders sold pls to Isr by Ibrahim accord. Ha*mas, governing body in Gaza was working on a plan to reverse the page. They sacrificed Gazans to rescue their people. That is what a responsible government does. Do not repeat western language by calling them Isl*mists arm group. What the nationalists did for Pls other than collaboration and corruption. That is their legacy.
@satnamo2 ай бұрын
Without British imperialism, the apartheid state of Israel wouldn’t exist ❤
@thanissara15362 ай бұрын
Excellent interview - at last the real questions folks want to hear about. Thank you!
@wolfiesown2 ай бұрын
Why is the Palestinian claim to self-determination disputable? It was their land, their villages, their homes, their airports, even if first the Ottomans and then the British occupied them.
@brodieofficial2 ай бұрын
So insane to listen to this now… I really wish we could hear from Noam, but I’ve heard that he’s really sick. 😔
@justinemukhopadia60222 ай бұрын
Do the Israeli people choose to be ignorant, have they no curiosity or consciousness ? Have the Israeli people have no understanding of the need for critical thinking.
@omegahaddad8332 ай бұрын
Omar Aziz, you have really captured my attention with your impartial questions. Your scholarship is in the right question. Dr. Khalid, is an encyclopedia on the subject and a national treasure! Thank you 🙏.
@boardoffisheries86402 ай бұрын
Does anyone go back 15,000 years to the archeological and archeogenetic Natufian culture of people who lived in these Palestinian lands 9000 years before Moses and the Bible’s limited history? Maybe we need to name this fine land after the remarkable Natufian people instead of the degradation of a bullying Israeli terrorist regime that makes a mock of the holy land.
@edelsmith11382 ай бұрын
Absolute BS
@Nigelzenig2 ай бұрын
What are you talking about?
@sandrajensen4972 ай бұрын
Great in-depth discussion!
@ellenpearce62572 ай бұрын
Wasn’t was it the PentagonPapers that ended the war.?
@waltraudboxall7602 ай бұрын
🎉 27:14 A stunningly informative and well presented dialogue. Rashid Khalidi is, in my view, one of the foremost Palestinian voices whose encyclopaedic knowledge of Palestinian history is exemplary. My initiation into the plight of European Jews started 78 years ago in South Germany. The industrial scale barbarism and displacement of European Jews was all I ever learnt then. Only in August 2008, when I happened to walk into the Patriothall in Edinburgh and saw Jane Frere’s ‘The Return of the Soul: the Nakba 1948’ did my mind and heart get a jolt. And now, after 75 years of Israeli settler activity, displacement and brutal killing under a multifarious umbrella of self-defense, international law, and shielding politics, a segment of history previously erased emerges. The patterns of historic Übermensch enactments worldwide are crude reminders of our tragic human shortcomings. A rational perspective on the history of human conflict presented with invigorating acuity and credible evidence as seen here offers some light. Oh how I need it…
@victormeidan10622 ай бұрын
Palestinian history ? But the Palestinians were the name of Israelis before the War of Independence. Look at the following terms - they all denote Hebrew, Jewish entities before 1948 ! Palestine Post Joint Palestine Appeal Palestine Philharmonic Orchestra Palestine Brigade Palestine Football Team Anglo-Palestine Bank Whoops.
@jo-annerichardson342 ай бұрын
I must say that I truly believed that Joe Biden would not let Israel have a green light to what ever they want knowing full well what Netanyahu is and what his goal has always been. Then Biden claimed he was a Zionist. Enough said. Shocking in every way. Great interview. Thankyou.
@frannyfrench4522 ай бұрын
Excellent interview. Thank you, Omar Aziz. I just started reading "The Hundred Years' War on Palestine" and got pulled in immediately. Looking forward to more on your channel, which I just discovered and immediately subscribed to. Peace!
@brentriley49112 ай бұрын
American politicians will not advance support in large part because they know Palestinians don't understand or engage politically and therefore are risky, and a danger to incumbency.
@SukhdevSingh-ge5rj2 ай бұрын
Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸💚💚💚💚💚💚💚☪️☪️☪️☪️☪️☪️☪️ Allahuakhbar Allahuakhbar from Malaysia 🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻
@brentriley49112 ай бұрын
Resistance by "any means necessary", will not lead to liberation, equality or to integration
@Nigelzenig2 ай бұрын
History does not really support that claim.
@LenaDiab-pn5tn2 ай бұрын
GOAT
@safadig2 ай бұрын
As much as I respect Prof Khalid I’d opinion, I am not hopeful of Israel coming to terms with accepting Palestinians. Younger generations are being indoctrinated in Israel to an ideology that is far more extreme than existed or will exist
@stephencunningham65572 ай бұрын
Zionism simply isn't compatible with any two or one State solution by its very nature. Zionism has to be expunged from the Levant for any solution to be successful.
@dorianmichelarmenterossanc6682 ай бұрын
You don’t believe en settler colonialism projects cuz they can turn into national projects and u put USA as example? Did u realized the genocide USA settlers and government done to Native Americans & also Black People? I really disagree with you in this part of ur discussion
@rodluther9822 ай бұрын
Great interview but I wish you would have asked him about his impressions of what “really” happened on October 7th. The Israeli government has backpedaled a couple of times on the grossly exaggerated number of Israeli casualties on that day. And the military has admitted to killing their own civilians which was also corroborated by testimonies of survivors. Also there is the possibility that Israel let 10/7 happen in order to have an excuse for genocide/ethnic cleansing,an Israeli 911, if you will.
@stephencunningham65572 ай бұрын
Poor Black people in South Carolina primary have actually increased Genocidal Joe's vote.
@ShimonCleopas2 ай бұрын
Identifying God: the smartest retaliatory strike vs Iran, support for Israel and stop to genocide! Another urgent open appeal to "Joseph". Date: Feb 4, 2024 07:00 PST Boss: 1. "IUDAS = SAUDI" are God's "nuclear codes": the Saudis are the real Jews and true descendants of JUDAH: what a DECEPTION? 2. God chose Israel not because they are "Jews" but as "sandbox" to form the Immaculate Conception, the RESTRAINER. 3. Had INTEL done a superb job, the holy war on terror coulda woulda shoulda've been won decisively on Oct 7, 2001 without loss of troops, limbs and trillion$. 4. Btw: Oct 7 is the Feast of the RESTRAINER's Rosary! 5. The timeliest favor "Joseph" can return to the RESTRAINER who gave "Joseph" victory in 2020 is to support Israel God's way, not Hannibal's. 6. Actions requested: a. Declare ceasefire, b. Tell Bibi and Abbas: "get ready to march down the isle" (John 2:1-11 Wedding at Cana), c. Ask Blinken to invite leaders to the wedding banquet: Matt 22:1-14, d. Espouse the RESTRAINER's petition to #CongressDotGov: "Jesus Christ FAIR RETRIAL NOW!" 7. The Legion of Mary trained this "sinner", an UberEats driver, to testify, guaranteed: Armageddon: Jesus Christ (TRUTH) vs DECEPTION, Temple of TRUTH above Temple Mount, Genesis 3:15, 2nd Coming, Rapture, Emmanuel, The Apocalypse, Judgement Day, FORGIVENESS of SINS, EndOfDay6/StartOfDay7, Age of Truth, Ingathering, Abraham family reunion, Messianic Age, God's Millennial Kingdom, The Lord’s Day, Etc!!! 8. RESTRAINER's insinuation this 3rd-day: "they have no more wine." John 2:3. 9. Any human response to "holy attacks" other than FAIR RETRIAL equals more dead troops and deeper debts. 10. Even God's sacrificial Tenth Red Heifer (TRH) is so obviously encoded to help Israel study Messiah Jesus! Prophet Simeon Junior, Secretary of Curia-Woman of Revelation, President-Queen of Peace, @ShimonCleopas.
@ahagamama2 ай бұрын
I must be a young person, then, according to Rashid Khalidi - I dropped MSM around age 65 and now I am 79-- still cannot watch MSM.
@ge12mma345ge122 ай бұрын
Hey, I’m nearly 81 and won’t go near msm.
@ge12mma345ge122 ай бұрын
7
@alrosano57862 ай бұрын
I use to hate trump , now it is Biden , why yesterday man, too old and stupid, has spent most of his political life fundraising for the Zionist lobby, Irish ☘️ my ass !
@alrosano57862 ай бұрын
Americans don’t have to vote 🗳️, good 👍 because if you do you end up with a politician !
@alrosano57862 ай бұрын
Not if the Zionist lobby manages to close all universities?
@alrosano57862 ай бұрын
Touch their pockets and everything will change ? Yep 👍!
@alrosano57862 ай бұрын
The average American will not know if his on ass was on fire 🔥 , diabetes ? Some understanding when sugar levels drops !
Пікірлер
Genocide? Lol
I think it's silly to judge people from the 17th, 18th, 19th, and even 20th century by 21st century standards. You are totally fine telling White Americans that their ancestors were bad, while acting like every other ethnic group in history have been saints. People didn't have the same standards of morality back then, it was a totally different and quite tribalistic world. Everybody had in-group biases, not just Europeans. Why are you pretending like the English settlers in North America should have had the same moral standards as a Harvard student in 2024?
You should have Douglas Murray come on, get some opposing views points.
Oh Harry Truman did not like the Israeli's here is a proof below. Infact I would say he is the most Pro Palestianian if you will. If that means anything. He recognized that they exist and did not like that the Israeli's wanted most of the land. kzread.info/dash/bejne/mohhuJl8k8LXXdY.html
If you dont reach out to people how are you going to give them anything
Israel has totally become one big Jonestown, with a never ending supply of Kool-Aid given to them by the United States and my tax dollars !! They’re delusion of racial and religious superiority over every other living organism on planet earth has reached epidemic proportions! For 75 years, the United States has been perpetuating this delusion, and helping it along
Miserable fkctrd5
Vote for Cornell West as a third party candidate.
Proff Khalidi is very articulate and intelligent however he surely must of heard of the Granada pogrom of 1066 or the Safed pogrom of 1834.
Some really good questions.
I have learnt so much from Prof Khalidi about the history of Palestine from YT videos and his extensive book ' The 100 years war on Palestine'. He is an incredible scholar and educator. Thank you, Prof Khalidi.
Get a real job
Dr Khalidi is unapologetic and erudite - I love it!
One of the most important voices on Palestine, needs to be amplified and preserved for posterity
Excellent interview, Professor Khalidi is an overflowing reservoir of experience, knowledge and insight but can explain things so clearly and calmly. Thank you
Facist racist genocidal apartheid state I have believed this since I was 18 I am now 53 And nothing has been done against Israel to hold it to account by any country
Hamas is responsible.
The problem with people in diaspora is at some point they don’t understand their country and their people mind anymore because they are westernized. Jennin camp was going to be evacuated after the end of holiday. The people is displaced to perhaps Jordan. Alaghsa mosque would be handed over to Isr and West bank will be emptied from Pls. They were not armed and they had no choice to leave. Arab leaders sold pls to Isr by Ibrahim accord. Ha*mas, governing body in Gaza was working on a plan to reverse the page. They sacrificed Gazans to rescue their people. That is what a responsible government does. Do not repeat western language by calling them Isl*mists arm group. What the nationalists did for Pls other than collaboration and corruption. That is their legacy.
Without British imperialism, the apartheid state of Israel wouldn’t exist ❤
Excellent interview - at last the real questions folks want to hear about. Thank you!
Why is the Palestinian claim to self-determination disputable? It was their land, their villages, their homes, their airports, even if first the Ottomans and then the British occupied them.
So insane to listen to this now… I really wish we could hear from Noam, but I’ve heard that he’s really sick. 😔
Do the Israeli people choose to be ignorant, have they no curiosity or consciousness ? Have the Israeli people have no understanding of the need for critical thinking.
Omar Aziz, you have really captured my attention with your impartial questions. Your scholarship is in the right question. Dr. Khalid, is an encyclopedia on the subject and a national treasure! Thank you 🙏.
Does anyone go back 15,000 years to the archeological and archeogenetic Natufian culture of people who lived in these Palestinian lands 9000 years before Moses and the Bible’s limited history? Maybe we need to name this fine land after the remarkable Natufian people instead of the degradation of a bullying Israeli terrorist regime that makes a mock of the holy land.
Absolute BS
What are you talking about?
Great in-depth discussion!
Wasn’t was it the PentagonPapers that ended the war.?
🎉 27:14 A stunningly informative and well presented dialogue. Rashid Khalidi is, in my view, one of the foremost Palestinian voices whose encyclopaedic knowledge of Palestinian history is exemplary. My initiation into the plight of European Jews started 78 years ago in South Germany. The industrial scale barbarism and displacement of European Jews was all I ever learnt then. Only in August 2008, when I happened to walk into the Patriothall in Edinburgh and saw Jane Frere’s ‘The Return of the Soul: the Nakba 1948’ did my mind and heart get a jolt. And now, after 75 years of Israeli settler activity, displacement and brutal killing under a multifarious umbrella of self-defense, international law, and shielding politics, a segment of history previously erased emerges. The patterns of historic Übermensch enactments worldwide are crude reminders of our tragic human shortcomings. A rational perspective on the history of human conflict presented with invigorating acuity and credible evidence as seen here offers some light. Oh how I need it…
Palestinian history ? But the Palestinians were the name of Israelis before the War of Independence. Look at the following terms - they all denote Hebrew, Jewish entities before 1948 ! Palestine Post Joint Palestine Appeal Palestine Philharmonic Orchestra Palestine Brigade Palestine Football Team Anglo-Palestine Bank Whoops.
I must say that I truly believed that Joe Biden would not let Israel have a green light to what ever they want knowing full well what Netanyahu is and what his goal has always been. Then Biden claimed he was a Zionist. Enough said. Shocking in every way. Great interview. Thankyou.
Excellent interview. Thank you, Omar Aziz. I just started reading "The Hundred Years' War on Palestine" and got pulled in immediately. Looking forward to more on your channel, which I just discovered and immediately subscribed to. Peace!
American politicians will not advance support in large part because they know Palestinians don't understand or engage politically and therefore are risky, and a danger to incumbency.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸💚💚💚💚💚💚💚☪️☪️☪️☪️☪️☪️☪️ Allahuakhbar Allahuakhbar from Malaysia 🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻
Resistance by "any means necessary", will not lead to liberation, equality or to integration
History does not really support that claim.
GOAT
As much as I respect Prof Khalid I’d opinion, I am not hopeful of Israel coming to terms with accepting Palestinians. Younger generations are being indoctrinated in Israel to an ideology that is far more extreme than existed or will exist
Zionism simply isn't compatible with any two or one State solution by its very nature. Zionism has to be expunged from the Levant for any solution to be successful.
You don’t believe en settler colonialism projects cuz they can turn into national projects and u put USA as example? Did u realized the genocide USA settlers and government done to Native Americans & also Black People? I really disagree with you in this part of ur discussion
Great interview but I wish you would have asked him about his impressions of what “really” happened on October 7th. The Israeli government has backpedaled a couple of times on the grossly exaggerated number of Israeli casualties on that day. And the military has admitted to killing their own civilians which was also corroborated by testimonies of survivors. Also there is the possibility that Israel let 10/7 happen in order to have an excuse for genocide/ethnic cleansing,an Israeli 911, if you will.
Poor Black people in South Carolina primary have actually increased Genocidal Joe's vote.
Identifying God: the smartest retaliatory strike vs Iran, support for Israel and stop to genocide! Another urgent open appeal to "Joseph". Date: Feb 4, 2024 07:00 PST Boss: 1. "IUDAS = SAUDI" are God's "nuclear codes": the Saudis are the real Jews and true descendants of JUDAH: what a DECEPTION? 2. God chose Israel not because they are "Jews" but as "sandbox" to form the Immaculate Conception, the RESTRAINER. 3. Had INTEL done a superb job, the holy war on terror coulda woulda shoulda've been won decisively on Oct 7, 2001 without loss of troops, limbs and trillion$. 4. Btw: Oct 7 is the Feast of the RESTRAINER's Rosary! 5. The timeliest favor "Joseph" can return to the RESTRAINER who gave "Joseph" victory in 2020 is to support Israel God's way, not Hannibal's. 6. Actions requested: a. Declare ceasefire, b. Tell Bibi and Abbas: "get ready to march down the isle" (John 2:1-11 Wedding at Cana), c. Ask Blinken to invite leaders to the wedding banquet: Matt 22:1-14, d. Espouse the RESTRAINER's petition to #CongressDotGov: "Jesus Christ FAIR RETRIAL NOW!" 7. The Legion of Mary trained this "sinner", an UberEats driver, to testify, guaranteed: Armageddon: Jesus Christ (TRUTH) vs DECEPTION, Temple of TRUTH above Temple Mount, Genesis 3:15, 2nd Coming, Rapture, Emmanuel, The Apocalypse, Judgement Day, FORGIVENESS of SINS, EndOfDay6/StartOfDay7, Age of Truth, Ingathering, Abraham family reunion, Messianic Age, God's Millennial Kingdom, The Lord’s Day, Etc!!! 8. RESTRAINER's insinuation this 3rd-day: "they have no more wine." John 2:3. 9. Any human response to "holy attacks" other than FAIR RETRIAL equals more dead troops and deeper debts. 10. Even God's sacrificial Tenth Red Heifer (TRH) is so obviously encoded to help Israel study Messiah Jesus! Prophet Simeon Junior, Secretary of Curia-Woman of Revelation, President-Queen of Peace, @ShimonCleopas.
I must be a young person, then, according to Rashid Khalidi - I dropped MSM around age 65 and now I am 79-- still cannot watch MSM.
Hey, I’m nearly 81 and won’t go near msm.
7
I use to hate trump , now it is Biden , why yesterday man, too old and stupid, has spent most of his political life fundraising for the Zionist lobby, Irish ☘️ my ass !
Americans don’t have to vote 🗳️, good 👍 because if you do you end up with a politician !
Not if the Zionist lobby manages to close all universities?
Touch their pockets and everything will change ? Yep 👍!
The average American will not know if his on ass was on fire 🔥 , diabetes ? Some understanding when sugar levels drops !
Too much information!
Fantastic interview