what the hell is this? scary music for a normal bycicle horn? -.-
@BarryTheElephant Жыл бұрын
What became of this project? Likewise, it would be fantastic to have access to it.
@sgcazan2 жыл бұрын
this is like a fever dream
@richardnelson81212 жыл бұрын
Ｐ𝐫Ｏ𝕞Ｏ𝓢ｍ
@rogercawkwell54132 жыл бұрын
Without a doubt, the most offensive noise I have heard on KZread.
@boblsturm2 жыл бұрын
Be nice to Ruth!
@StephenTravisPope2 жыл бұрын
Where are the green-screen effects? Shouldn't you both be floating in outer space? OR in front of a Hawaiian waterfall?
@jean-pierreyvert2 жыл бұрын
Superbe, bravo ! 😊😊👍👍😊😊
@itstherealjammin2 жыл бұрын
Ah man what an anti-climax :(
@SusanJERitta4 жыл бұрын
It's a pretty tune, but when you play it like an air it is absolutely stunning! I may try to make this a quarantine to learn myself.
@eshed4 жыл бұрын
'grats Bob!
@sumitpatidar65854 жыл бұрын
Played Wonderfully😍
@JannekeSlagter-trekharmonica4 жыл бұрын
I like it, hihi!
@HandsomeH.U.N.K.5 жыл бұрын
Art the clown!
@MrLuridan5 жыл бұрын
Hilarious! Great tune
@eshed6 жыл бұрын
Nice scenery and nice playing ;)
@chrlsstotz86796 жыл бұрын
Can you put this on a CD for me but without the cat audio in The Arian
@boblsturm6 жыл бұрын
Ha ha. You don't like the no no cat? I can remove from the mix. :)
@chrlsstotz86796 жыл бұрын
It's funny, but I guess I just want to hear only what the AI has created. You obviously don't have to though. But it would be very cool if all the separate tracks were on a CD (:
@chrlsstotz86795 жыл бұрын
Hey Bob Sturm can you please remove the noise from The Arian
@emmanuelgoldstein97106 жыл бұрын
Which software are you using there?
@emmanuelgoldstein97106 жыл бұрын
Matlab... python?
@boblsturm6 жыл бұрын
MATLAB
@emmanuelgoldstein97106 жыл бұрын
...what?
@Kram10326 жыл бұрын
Gee I Wonder Whether This Was Computer Generated
@boblsturm6 жыл бұрын
Not this one! This is a real traditional tune. :)
@weltsauerstoff6 жыл бұрын
A tried it a tad slower: soundcloud.com/weltsauerstoff/1166-conquest-of-brittany
@boblsturm6 жыл бұрын
Wonderful! That was real quick. :) I love the chord progression.
@bcalhoun416 жыл бұрын
Erie. Still, quite interesting.
@fromthehub6 жыл бұрын
A classic of the genre.
@pacerhemi66406 жыл бұрын
Μαλακίες .
@hamjuice3456 жыл бұрын
I am triggered
7 жыл бұрын
Pretty interesting. Did you record that with a speaker-to-microphone setup? Sounds that look like a baby/child voice can be heard at several spots during "Arian, The", especially at the end of it 06:23-06:26 . These are not generated with the musical score, are they?
@thebottomlesstunebox46467 жыл бұрын
Thanks. No, it is all from synthetic instruments I mixed in Reaper. The sound you hear is from a particularly famous viral video. Artistic license. :) I didn't have to pitch shift it either.
@chrlsstotz86796 жыл бұрын
Why did you put it there
@robbm.cupich21207 жыл бұрын
Hahahaha
@fearfeasog7 жыл бұрын
"the humours of time pigeon." is my favorite title ever. and did i hear the "oh my long John" cat in "the arian?" omg! awesome!
@boblsturm7 жыл бұрын
Thanks for listening! Yes, the "no no no cat" is in there. I didn't even have to pitch shift it either.
@lizasplaylist7 жыл бұрын
I laughed so hard
@Kram10327 жыл бұрын
Do you also have more recent experiments? You keep uploading stuff that apparently already is two years old. Which, mind you, isn't bad for the music. It's just that, within two years, a lot could happen in AI. A folk-rnn 2.0 from today might be much better than the one you used back then.
@boblsturm7 жыл бұрын
Hi Kram. While this piece was produced by the original folk-rnn, we have constructed several other versions since then and have been studying their properties. Have you heard this? highnoongmt.wordpress.com/2016/12/24/taking-a-christmas-carol-toward-the-dodecaphonic-by-derp-learning/ We also have several new pieces coming up at this workshop: highnoongmt.wordpress.com/2017/02/28/mar-25-folk-music-composed-by-a-computer-inside-out-festival/ Then there is our concert coming up, which will feature new stuff too: highnoongmt.wordpress.com/2017/02/26/partnerships-tickets-tue-23-may-2017-at-1900-eventbrite/
@Kram10327 жыл бұрын
Unfortunately it won't be easy for me to get to Great Britain but I'm glad to hear/read that you are also working on new stuff :) I like both of those compositions drawn from Christmas music although I gotta say neither seem particularly Christmassy. - Which isn't necessarily a bad thing. They actually sound a good deal more interesting than most Christmas music.
@Kram10327 жыл бұрын
So by "best" you mean "best-matching", right? In that case it'd be hardly surprising for the algorithm to get it right. I think you need to add some conditionals on that to make these more music-like. But wait, this was almost two years ago. How have things changed? Surely there is a better state of the art out there now? And a bunch of new and impressive work on musical generation has since been done.
@boblsturm7 жыл бұрын
Thanks Kram. In this case, "best" means the posterior probability of the classification is at least 0.9999. The point of this experiment was to show how misleading "classification accuracy" is for music genre recognition. Since that time, things haven't changed. Most researchers are still using classification experiments to measure success in "genre recognition".
@Kram10327 жыл бұрын
I see. I think I agree that perhaps researchers put a bit too much merit in such ideas. Though with better architectures, the model could probably be improved. Notably on the image generation side of things, huge improvements were made just recently, using things like priors that tell the system how natural images actually look like, or General Advisorial Networks (GANs) which learn to tell it whether what it produces is actually what it thinks it produces. I'd imagine such would greatly improve the genre classifier too, especially with respect to robustness against otherwise very easily generated match outliers. (By which I don't mean that they are rare but rather that they are far away from the actual examples they are trained on. - if the system you picked actually is trained like a NN anyway... Though I'd imagine such a task to be precisely where NNs shine, compared to hand-corded techniques)
@Kram10327 жыл бұрын
It sounds like so many other songs. Neat!
@Kram10327 жыл бұрын
Very unconventional but nice. It still is somewhat repetitive at times but it's much closer to something actually cohesive than most computer-synthesized music. Your orchestration certainly helps that of course, but still
@user-kf1vu7ki9x8 жыл бұрын
مرحبا
@user-kf1vu7ki9x8 жыл бұрын
مرحبا
@boblsturm8 жыл бұрын
Hello!
@TwoMinutePapers8 жыл бұрын
Insanity. Easily the best RNN music I've heard so far. Not even close. Thanks!: )
@boblsturm8 жыл бұрын
+Károly Zsolnai-Fehér (Two Minute Papers) Thanks! Keep in mind that a significant amount of magic comes from the orchestration, which is entirely due to me. Also, I selected these pieces from over 100,000 ABC outputs of the system because I like how much they "fail" to represent the training material. :)
@brehbrehgentil7 жыл бұрын
Hey love both of your work Bob Sturm and Two Minute Papers. I have checked out most of your videos Károly they're all fantastic. Bob I have a question: I have recently graduated and have been self-teaching some ML for the past month I have a few of the necessary basics down and am now looking into neural networks. More specifically I am going over the CS224 course on RNNs. Would you recommend any books/literature on neural networks which tackle the intersection of neural networks and music generation? Many thanks to both of you for your hard work
@-danR4 жыл бұрын
Starts off sort of normally then goes full Zappa.
@ravelite9 жыл бұрын
quite dramatic
@bertaga4110 жыл бұрын
Lovely.
@LucasDestrem10 жыл бұрын
1:23 : ?????????
@mrjohnnymack11 жыл бұрын
Didn't you even notice all the things blowing up behind you? Impervious?
@krischristenson357811 жыл бұрын
Is this software available for download anywhere online? I've looked quite a bit and only find the paper. I ask because I'm a master's student, studying music composition and am giving a presentation on Atomic Decomposition for my Electro-Acoustic Music class on Monday. I thought it would be better to actually have the software so I could perform decompositions during the presentation than to simply play this video. Thanks for any help you can give.
@lawomega111 жыл бұрын
Beautifully played,I think you both have enormous talent ,and in time you will both be A1 on your chosen instruments . Good that you enjoy the spirit of olde English morris music from long ago!!!
@Juliuses12 жыл бұрын
Yes! Nice recording! And it is a good way to learn the difference between draw-push-draw and push-draw-push !
@Marjan-creative12 жыл бұрын
very nice!
@cincachoo12 жыл бұрын
Bob Strum this a wonderful....it is also to MIDI With the well timed MIDI arrangement you have gone a long way You are half way there All the best
@boblsturm13 жыл бұрын
Thank you NJKatwoman! You can add your own Ploink if you want. :)
@YARNBARF13 жыл бұрын
Just curious as to what all of that "clacking" noise is? I thought that was sweet when your Father in law and your wife toasted each other. :D
@YARNBARF13 жыл бұрын
So I finally got my button accordion about a month ago, and am enjoying learning how to play it. And I am in the process of learning this tune, but I keep stopping and waiting for the "PLOINK"! lol!
Пікірлер
what the hell is this? scary music for a normal bycicle horn? -.-
What became of this project? Likewise, it would be fantastic to have access to it.
this is like a fever dream
Ｐ𝐫Ｏ𝕞Ｏ𝓢ｍ
Without a doubt, the most offensive noise I have heard on KZread.
Be nice to Ruth!
Where are the green-screen effects? Shouldn't you both be floating in outer space? OR in front of a Hawaiian waterfall?
Superbe, bravo ! 😊😊👍👍😊😊
Ah man what an anti-climax :(
It's a pretty tune, but when you play it like an air it is absolutely stunning! I may try to make this a quarantine to learn myself.
'grats Bob!
Played Wonderfully😍
I like it, hihi!
Art the clown!
Hilarious! Great tune
Nice scenery and nice playing ;)
Can you put this on a CD for me but without the cat audio in The Arian
Ha ha. You don't like the no no cat? I can remove from the mix. :)
It's funny, but I guess I just want to hear only what the AI has created. You obviously don't have to though. But it would be very cool if all the separate tracks were on a CD (:
Hey Bob Sturm can you please remove the noise from The Arian
Which software are you using there?
Matlab... python?
MATLAB
...what?
Gee I Wonder Whether This Was Computer Generated
Not this one! This is a real traditional tune. :)
A tried it a tad slower: soundcloud.com/weltsauerstoff/1166-conquest-of-brittany
Wonderful! That was real quick. :) I love the chord progression.
Erie. Still, quite interesting.
A classic of the genre.
Μαλακίες .
I am triggered
Pretty interesting. Did you record that with a speaker-to-microphone setup? Sounds that look like a baby/child voice can be heard at several spots during "Arian, The", especially at the end of it 06:23-06:26 . These are not generated with the musical score, are they?
Thanks. No, it is all from synthetic instruments I mixed in Reaper. The sound you hear is from a particularly famous viral video. Artistic license. :) I didn't have to pitch shift it either.
Why did you put it there
Hahahaha
"the humours of time pigeon." is my favorite title ever. and did i hear the "oh my long John" cat in "the arian?" omg! awesome!
Thanks for listening! Yes, the "no no no cat" is in there. I didn't even have to pitch shift it either.
I laughed so hard
Do you also have more recent experiments? You keep uploading stuff that apparently already is two years old. Which, mind you, isn't bad for the music. It's just that, within two years, a lot could happen in AI. A folk-rnn 2.0 from today might be much better than the one you used back then.
Hi Kram. While this piece was produced by the original folk-rnn, we have constructed several other versions since then and have been studying their properties. Have you heard this? highnoongmt.wordpress.com/2016/12/24/taking-a-christmas-carol-toward-the-dodecaphonic-by-derp-learning/ We also have several new pieces coming up at this workshop: highnoongmt.wordpress.com/2017/02/28/mar-25-folk-music-composed-by-a-computer-inside-out-festival/ Then there is our concert coming up, which will feature new stuff too: highnoongmt.wordpress.com/2017/02/26/partnerships-tickets-tue-23-may-2017-at-1900-eventbrite/
Unfortunately it won't be easy for me to get to Great Britain but I'm glad to hear/read that you are also working on new stuff :) I like both of those compositions drawn from Christmas music although I gotta say neither seem particularly Christmassy. - Which isn't necessarily a bad thing. They actually sound a good deal more interesting than most Christmas music.
So by "best" you mean "best-matching", right? In that case it'd be hardly surprising for the algorithm to get it right. I think you need to add some conditionals on that to make these more music-like. But wait, this was almost two years ago. How have things changed? Surely there is a better state of the art out there now? And a bunch of new and impressive work on musical generation has since been done.
Thanks Kram. In this case, "best" means the posterior probability of the classification is at least 0.9999. The point of this experiment was to show how misleading "classification accuracy" is for music genre recognition. Since that time, things haven't changed. Most researchers are still using classification experiments to measure success in "genre recognition".
I see. I think I agree that perhaps researchers put a bit too much merit in such ideas. Though with better architectures, the model could probably be improved. Notably on the image generation side of things, huge improvements were made just recently, using things like priors that tell the system how natural images actually look like, or General Advisorial Networks (GANs) which learn to tell it whether what it produces is actually what it thinks it produces. I'd imagine such would greatly improve the genre classifier too, especially with respect to robustness against otherwise very easily generated match outliers. (By which I don't mean that they are rare but rather that they are far away from the actual examples they are trained on. - if the system you picked actually is trained like a NN anyway... Though I'd imagine such a task to be precisely where NNs shine, compared to hand-corded techniques)
It sounds like so many other songs. Neat!
Very unconventional but nice. It still is somewhat repetitive at times but it's much closer to something actually cohesive than most computer-synthesized music. Your orchestration certainly helps that of course, but still
مرحبا
مرحبا
Hello!
Insanity. Easily the best RNN music I've heard so far. Not even close. Thanks!: )
+Károly Zsolnai-Fehér (Two Minute Papers) Thanks! Keep in mind that a significant amount of magic comes from the orchestration, which is entirely due to me. Also, I selected these pieces from over 100,000 ABC outputs of the system because I like how much they "fail" to represent the training material. :)
Hey love both of your work Bob Sturm and Two Minute Papers. I have checked out most of your videos Károly they're all fantastic. Bob I have a question: I have recently graduated and have been self-teaching some ML for the past month I have a few of the necessary basics down and am now looking into neural networks. More specifically I am going over the CS224 course on RNNs. Would you recommend any books/literature on neural networks which tackle the intersection of neural networks and music generation? Many thanks to both of you for your hard work
Starts off sort of normally then goes full Zappa.
quite dramatic
Lovely.
1:23 : ?????????
Didn't you even notice all the things blowing up behind you? Impervious?
Is this software available for download anywhere online? I've looked quite a bit and only find the paper. I ask because I'm a master's student, studying music composition and am giving a presentation on Atomic Decomposition for my Electro-Acoustic Music class on Monday. I thought it would be better to actually have the software so I could perform decompositions during the presentation than to simply play this video. Thanks for any help you can give.
Beautifully played,I think you both have enormous talent ,and in time you will both be A1 on your chosen instruments . Good that you enjoy the spirit of olde English morris music from long ago!!!
Yes! Nice recording! And it is a good way to learn the difference between draw-push-draw and push-draw-push !
very nice!
Bob Strum this a wonderful....it is also to MIDI With the well timed MIDI arrangement you have gone a long way You are half way there All the best
Thank you NJKatwoman! You can add your own Ploink if you want. :)
Just curious as to what all of that "clacking" noise is? I thought that was sweet when your Father in law and your wife toasted each other. :D
So I finally got my button accordion about a month ago, and am enjoying learning how to play it. And I am in the process of learning this tune, but I keep stopping and waiting for the "PLOINK"! lol!