I see that Claudia McDonald as injured and no yellow card. Did noone see how she was injured? I am sure if an English player injured someone then we would see a yellow card.
@michaelvidal197127 күн бұрын
They should change the rules so you get a bonus point for every four tries.
@rjhayes-dc1ji28 күн бұрын
🤔🤔Ref thick 🤷🏾♂️🤤🤤🤤🤤
@kevinjones6610Ай бұрын
What a horrible ref.certainly italys 16th man
@michaelvidal1971Ай бұрын
I am confused Sarah Beckett was red carded for a dangerous tackle yet when Abby Dow had her leg broken nothing happened. I am not sure if that was because it was friendly fire or none of the officials saw how it happened.
@robinholland1136Ай бұрын
I've just noticed Marlie Packer having a cheeky leg wax at 59.50 on the match clock. Whatever next?
@allayton972Ай бұрын
I think they need to pension Mo Hunt off now. Lost count of how many times she got caught and all she does is moan to the rest of the team and the ref. Time to bring back Infante.
@terencebennison6275Ай бұрын
Applause for the referee, she did a good job in a 'tetchy' game played in front of a hostile french crowd.
@terencebennison6275Ай бұрын
Jess breach can't tackle for toffee, she should not play against a fired up France! Her half hearted tackles led to two french tries, she may look good when ball in hand streaking down the wing, but she might as well not be there in a one to one tackling situation. She tackles to high and seems to have an aversion to tackling opponents around the legs.
@devonshire5482Ай бұрын
I was at that game. What was the song people sang in the second half of the game?
@BaileyBrum5 күн бұрын
1.46.10 - The Killers , Mr Brightside 😊
@Russia-bulliesАй бұрын
Congrats to England.Where was England’s dominance when they lost the World Cup to the Kiwis?England should concentrate on the World Cup,instead of the 6 Nations,if you ask me.
@lonestar67093 күн бұрын
They lost, because of the ref. And they thrashed New Zealand, the last two times, we've met. The Roses have put the Ferns on the rack. All season, undefeated. How much dominance do you want?!
@PatrickKelly-lz3pv2 күн бұрын
did you miss the part when early in the game England had a player sent off,, so for most of the game they played with a player short, even under those circumstances they almost won.
@PoweroftouchАй бұрын
So chuffed I was therex
@PoweroftouchАй бұрын
Excited for the semi-final tomorrow.so glad u uploaded this game so I can rewatch and get super duper excited x
@pumkineater7219Ай бұрын
It would be nice to be able to cut Brian Moore out of the commentary. Pity, wish we could.
@terencebennison6275Ай бұрын
I don't agree, his commentary and his knowledge of the game, particularly around the the front rows offers a lot to people such as I who know very little of what goes at the coal face of the game.
@Russia-bulliesАй бұрын
The 1st half punishment on Amy Cokayne was too harsh as the Scottish player was lifted by 2 players unintentionally.
@1973thebigd2 ай бұрын
brain Moore just doesn't shut up negativity all the time get rid of him
@Russia-bulliesАй бұрын
Moore is only negative to the bad sides.
@kjosie1002 ай бұрын
why are these 3 commentators (Brain Moore etc)not speaking FRENCH? They are so biased towards the FRENCH it is unbelievable that they call themselves English. Total bias, anti-English B.S.
@kjosie1002 ай бұрын
head and shoulder above all the other players.... AITCHISON PLAYER OF THE MATCH... 6 conversion 12 pts and marshalled the English team from back to front. All the stick she has taken from the media and those USELESS COMMUNTATORS, TO KICK AN 100% MATCH IS HEROIC. Look at what the score would have been without those 12pts .
@michaelmorgan92892 ай бұрын
Thank goodness the the commentator informed us that WOMEN are playing this Rugby Match. I'm really happy that Sara Orchard tell us at every opportunity that WOMEN are playing this game. Without her constant & condescending commentary I would be confused. Other than that. Well Done to both teams for giving us a good match.
@66marlinmikeАй бұрын
Commentator did her best to ruin the match I turned the volume down at half time.
@michaelmorgan9289Ай бұрын
@@66marlinmike Her overly patronising comments usually do ruin any commentary.
@66marlinmikeАй бұрын
@@michaelmorgan9289 Vaccinated with a gramaphone needle
@ranjankarki57432 ай бұрын
such I love rugby forever such All time my favorite game women rugby I keep watching forever
@allanfreeman42672 ай бұрын
79.50 italy scrum half breaks allcroft and ward break from scrum have to turn and still tackle scrum half both played whole game player short just about sums up how poor italy are
@icarus8772 ай бұрын
What a wonderful performance, artistry and skill. I am a huge fan and actually really looking forward to watching so much more. This is how rugby should be played. I am so fed up of the over muscled and under skilled men's game. I was involved with rugby at a college in the mid to late 90's and there was a group of young ladies wishing to play, I helped form a team and they actually played a couple of games. I was always worried literally sick if any of the players got hurt. Please understand some of the male prejudices in the women's game are born of protectionism not ridicule - that was just how I felt as a man. Watching this game has eased my conscience around some of the injuries I saw the girls receive which I still feel today. My player of the match was Scarratt - she was sublime. Kildunne was magnificent.
@stephencrewes57732 ай бұрын
Maggie kept banging on about jeopardy. But if Wales had converted some of their opportunities, they would have given England a closer game.
@paulm24672 ай бұрын
That forward pass given in the first half came backwards out of the hands, it should’ve been a try for Breach under the current laws.
@AndrewUnderwood-pl1ur2 ай бұрын
The "raw' half time stats are meaningless! If you are having to tackle more and run more metres for nothing, well I guess that mean you are losing! Metres made /try= something comparable. Tackles /metre made, = something comparable. Raw stats are useless, may as well use Jersey colour, White better than Blue, nonesense as an objective statement
@ericb94262 ай бұрын
I slowed down both of those bad calls. Ref was wrong on both. I understand you have to make the call in the moment but that's why there's a TMO. Was he asleep?
@truthseekerreal12 ай бұрын
Had to stop there ois some pain i want to watch dry 💩
@Russia-bullies2 ай бұрын
Its amazing that English women are good enough to play at the English men’s home.
@kenspedding45942 ай бұрын
Why is their not a single male analyst on so much for sex equality but the BBC are so pro women it’s beyond double standards.
@joyfulzero85318 күн бұрын
Are you judging this on a single game? They do have Brian Moore on. He was not here on this occasion. How many women do they have on the men's rugby coverage?
@kjosie1002 ай бұрын
What the HELL are those commentator drinking? All they kept saying was that Scotland suffered because of the weather conditions ,,, I believe that BOTH TEAMS WERE PLAYING ON THE SAME PARK; SO THEREFORE THE WEATHER CONDITIONS APPLIED TO BOTH TEAMS! When England scored; those same commentators stated it is too easy for England, what an INSULT TO THE SCOTTISH DEFENCE. , Scotland kick the ball high into AIR; where the wind will blow it back at them and MOORE shouts out that the weather conditions are awful. England in BOTH halves of this match dealt with the weather conditions better than Scotland, they have better MANAGEMENT. The kicker Scotland brought on at half time should have been on from the start of the match, so she had the wind at her back and could kick for Goal (with so many penalties flying around). The first sending off was incorrect, there are TWO not one England player lifting the Scotland player off the ground and then lowered her to the ground, therefore if it is deemed a sending off offence then BOTH SHOULD HAVE BEEN SENT OFF and why then, in the Second half when a Scottish player lifted an England player in the same manor and dumped the English player to the ground, no penalty awarded, no review and therefore no sending off. Once again the commentator say nothing. England are the No.1 team in the world because they are well trained, act as a UNIT, the forward are superb, the backs are fantastic (DOW is a master) and have a management team that works with the players to get the best out of each other, It is not luck but hard work that only France and New Zealand can match. Do not knock England for being the best, praise them for the hard work they put in. Nobody knocks America's women's football team for being the No.1, nobody knocks Spain for having the best European women's football team, so why knock ENGLAND WOMENS RUGBY TEAM FOR BEING THE BEST?
@66marlinmikeАй бұрын
Commentator has to say something whether it makes sense or not isn't considered
@michaelvidal19712 ай бұрын
Why do they not immediately stop play when a player is injured rather than having the medic work around play. Does anyone know what happened with the player who was injured.
@michaelvidal19712 ай бұрын
Was this the first match in this six nations campaign where we did not have a try from Dow, Kildunne or Breach?
@allayton9722 ай бұрын
Lucy Packer is too indecisive and too slow.
@arthurspils25655 күн бұрын
I think switching her and Mo Hunt's numbers was a good call, she does the job well but is just better at it for shorter periods than the full match...
@AndrewUnderwood-pl1ur2 ай бұрын
Meat in boots rugby, "pick and go" time after time.When will it dawn on the forwards that they cannot cross the line and allow the backs to play? I wonder why the Ferns have no worries playing these teams. Rugby is a running game, set up by the forwards. Forwards win the ball, Backs win the game!
@AndrewUnderwood-pl1ur2 ай бұрын
Munarini is an awful ref.
@robinholland11362 ай бұрын
Help me on this one, please. The disallowed Bourdon Sansus try. If we accept that she did touch it and then her team mate charged it down, wasn't she still offside as she was in front when she tried to gather the ball? I have to admit that I'm rather confused . . .
@AndrewUnderwood-pl1ur2 ай бұрын
If Bourdon Sansus touched it, she played it back (albeit unwittingly) to Annaëlle Deshayes , I think , who then would have knocked the ball on. If Bordon Sansus was in an offside position, it would not have mattered, as the try was the result of a knock-on and hence disallowed as well. If that is the case, the only difference would have been the sanction, being a scrum, not a penalty. (Not sure if this is correct but logically, it seems to explain things).
@robinholland11362 ай бұрын
@@AndrewUnderwood-pl1ur Thanks for that. That was my reasoning, too, but the commentators and the players seemed to be suggesting that had Bourdon Sansus touched it and it was then charged down, the try could have been awarded. I didn't see it that way. I might just pass the question on to Nigel Owens and see what he says. Because, as we all know, Nige is the 'man who knows'.
@AndrewUnderwood-pl1ur2 ай бұрын
Who is the commentator here, Did she swallow a thesaurus/dictionary combo? Please decribe the game but leave the flowery descriptions out of the lightning fast, breathlessly quick, never ending, end to end, heart pounding leg pistoning, bone crunching game of rugby. If I want that crop, I will read Shakespeare!
@michaelvidal19712 ай бұрын
I think the italians were playing with 16 including the ref still did not help. England played almost the whole match with 14.
@michaelvidal19712 ай бұрын
I was watching the England Women Under 20's match against the Army. I think some of the players were given a dressing down after that match. The goal kicking was very good with only 3 missed conversions.
@13206132 ай бұрын
This isn’t touch rugby. Those Irish women need to learn correct tackle techniques to be competitive.
@paulm24672 ай бұрын
Why do the commentators big up the Welsh when they are clearly struggling, claiming that the Welsh are defending well when they have missed the first tackle, yet again, and then failed to prevent the offload. It isn’t doing them any favours and they subsequently look foolish when the score goes stratospheric.
@michaelmorgan9289Ай бұрын
Because the game is on the BBC which has a history of being anti English in their news and sports commentary.
@andrewjackson72552 ай бұрын
55mins 32 sec - Jess Breach needs to learn to tackle..... like Abby, Ellie & Meg
@aaeeturner2 ай бұрын
Doesn't tackle,doesn't get shirt dirty
@ericb94262 ай бұрын
Scotland "so the long ball isn't working - let's do the long ball again" Huh?
@maelughran69812 ай бұрын
Context is important here.... there are TEN TIMES as many women players under England Rugby to choose a team from.
@paulm24672 ай бұрын
The commentary is very weird, after 10 minutes they’re bigging up the Irish scrum when it’s clearly struggling, going backwards and only living on scraps thanks to a couple of penalties against the English women.
@michaelmorgan9289Ай бұрын
That's typical of the the BBC Commentator Sara Orchard. She's extremely PC & calls the players "women" continuously as if the viewers are too ignorant to understand that they're watching Womens Rugby.
@xylophone-on3js2 ай бұрын
That was a good game - for an England fan - but it would have been much, much closer if France hadn't made so many mistakes. France had so many good players who played really well - both Menagers, Escudero, tiny but tough Vernier, and the irrepressible Pauline Bourdon, but the whole team didn't match the same standard. Thanks for posting, although the video standard was not good: the resolution I got was 854x480@25fps, which meant that the players were just unidentifiable blobs when they weren't in a close-up shot. It's the kind of poor quality I've come to expect from KZread though.
@allanfreeman42672 ай бұрын
dannah o,brien ....useless..yes she can kick a goal ...absolutey nothing else kicking from hand too wayward and no chase cant tackle never chases her own kicks no accelerastion and just wanders around lost,,a luxury player ireland cannot afford to have with the state of thier game at the minute
@joyfulzero85318 күн бұрын
They have plenty to work with as she is. She can learn about all the other stuff, from hood coaches, playtime, watching others, and playing in situations where her team has some chance of spending time on the ball.
@AndrewUnderwood-pl1ur2 ай бұрын
Huge congrats to Ireland Women, World Cup qualification and WXV 1 games in the autumn.
@adamroberts85362 ай бұрын
Sorry, but the constant commentary about discipline yellow/red cards is tedious. Find a modern, professional team, under the current laws doesn't get regular cards.
@stephencrewes57732 ай бұрын
Yeah. The french had three yellows before the finale. Then they get yellow upgrade to red. The coaches tried to tell them it's the way the game is going with these cards.
@joyfulzero8532 ай бұрын
They are, in effect, saying that they must not get Red cards, or yellow, against the Black Ferns.
Пікірлер
Loved Megan Jones’ second try. 👏🏻
I see that Claudia McDonald as injured and no yellow card. Did noone see how she was injured? I am sure if an English player injured someone then we would see a yellow card.
They should change the rules so you get a bonus point for every four tries.
🤔🤔Ref thick 🤷🏾♂️🤤🤤🤤🤤
What a horrible ref.certainly italys 16th man
I am confused Sarah Beckett was red carded for a dangerous tackle yet when Abby Dow had her leg broken nothing happened. I am not sure if that was because it was friendly fire or none of the officials saw how it happened.
I've just noticed Marlie Packer having a cheeky leg wax at 59.50 on the match clock. Whatever next?
I think they need to pension Mo Hunt off now. Lost count of how many times she got caught and all she does is moan to the rest of the team and the ref. Time to bring back Infante.
Applause for the referee, she did a good job in a 'tetchy' game played in front of a hostile french crowd.
Jess breach can't tackle for toffee, she should not play against a fired up France! Her half hearted tackles led to two french tries, she may look good when ball in hand streaking down the wing, but she might as well not be there in a one to one tackling situation. She tackles to high and seems to have an aversion to tackling opponents around the legs.
I was at that game. What was the song people sang in the second half of the game?
1.46.10 - The Killers , Mr Brightside 😊
Congrats to England.Where was England’s dominance when they lost the World Cup to the Kiwis?England should concentrate on the World Cup,instead of the 6 Nations,if you ask me.
They lost, because of the ref. And they thrashed New Zealand, the last two times, we've met. The Roses have put the Ferns on the rack. All season, undefeated. How much dominance do you want?!
did you miss the part when early in the game England had a player sent off,, so for most of the game they played with a player short, even under those circumstances they almost won.
So chuffed I was therex
Excited for the semi-final tomorrow.so glad u uploaded this game so I can rewatch and get super duper excited x
It would be nice to be able to cut Brian Moore out of the commentary. Pity, wish we could.
I don't agree, his commentary and his knowledge of the game, particularly around the the front rows offers a lot to people such as I who know very little of what goes at the coal face of the game.
The 1st half punishment on Amy Cokayne was too harsh as the Scottish player was lifted by 2 players unintentionally.
brain Moore just doesn't shut up negativity all the time get rid of him
Moore is only negative to the bad sides.
why are these 3 commentators (Brain Moore etc)not speaking FRENCH? They are so biased towards the FRENCH it is unbelievable that they call themselves English. Total bias, anti-English B.S.
head and shoulder above all the other players.... AITCHISON PLAYER OF THE MATCH... 6 conversion 12 pts and marshalled the English team from back to front. All the stick she has taken from the media and those USELESS COMMUNTATORS, TO KICK AN 100% MATCH IS HEROIC. Look at what the score would have been without those 12pts .
Thank goodness the the commentator informed us that WOMEN are playing this Rugby Match. I'm really happy that Sara Orchard tell us at every opportunity that WOMEN are playing this game. Without her constant & condescending commentary I would be confused. Other than that. Well Done to both teams for giving us a good match.
Commentator did her best to ruin the match I turned the volume down at half time.
@@66marlinmike Her overly patronising comments usually do ruin any commentary.
@@michaelmorgan9289 Vaccinated with a gramaphone needle
such I love rugby forever such All time my favorite game women rugby I keep watching forever
79.50 italy scrum half breaks allcroft and ward break from scrum have to turn and still tackle scrum half both played whole game player short just about sums up how poor italy are
What a wonderful performance, artistry and skill. I am a huge fan and actually really looking forward to watching so much more. This is how rugby should be played. I am so fed up of the over muscled and under skilled men's game. I was involved with rugby at a college in the mid to late 90's and there was a group of young ladies wishing to play, I helped form a team and they actually played a couple of games. I was always worried literally sick if any of the players got hurt. Please understand some of the male prejudices in the women's game are born of protectionism not ridicule - that was just how I felt as a man. Watching this game has eased my conscience around some of the injuries I saw the girls receive which I still feel today. My player of the match was Scarratt - she was sublime. Kildunne was magnificent.
Maggie kept banging on about jeopardy. But if Wales had converted some of their opportunities, they would have given England a closer game.
That forward pass given in the first half came backwards out of the hands, it should’ve been a try for Breach under the current laws.
The "raw' half time stats are meaningless! If you are having to tackle more and run more metres for nothing, well I guess that mean you are losing! Metres made /try= something comparable. Tackles /metre made, = something comparable. Raw stats are useless, may as well use Jersey colour, White better than Blue, nonesense as an objective statement
I slowed down both of those bad calls. Ref was wrong on both. I understand you have to make the call in the moment but that's why there's a TMO. Was he asleep?
Had to stop there ois some pain i want to watch dry 💩
Its amazing that English women are good enough to play at the English men’s home.
Why is their not a single male analyst on so much for sex equality but the BBC are so pro women it’s beyond double standards.
Are you judging this on a single game? They do have Brian Moore on. He was not here on this occasion. How many women do they have on the men's rugby coverage?
What the HELL are those commentator drinking? All they kept saying was that Scotland suffered because of the weather conditions ,,, I believe that BOTH TEAMS WERE PLAYING ON THE SAME PARK; SO THEREFORE THE WEATHER CONDITIONS APPLIED TO BOTH TEAMS! When England scored; those same commentators stated it is too easy for England, what an INSULT TO THE SCOTTISH DEFENCE. , Scotland kick the ball high into AIR; where the wind will blow it back at them and MOORE shouts out that the weather conditions are awful. England in BOTH halves of this match dealt with the weather conditions better than Scotland, they have better MANAGEMENT. The kicker Scotland brought on at half time should have been on from the start of the match, so she had the wind at her back and could kick for Goal (with so many penalties flying around). The first sending off was incorrect, there are TWO not one England player lifting the Scotland player off the ground and then lowered her to the ground, therefore if it is deemed a sending off offence then BOTH SHOULD HAVE BEEN SENT OFF and why then, in the Second half when a Scottish player lifted an England player in the same manor and dumped the English player to the ground, no penalty awarded, no review and therefore no sending off. Once again the commentator say nothing. England are the No.1 team in the world because they are well trained, act as a UNIT, the forward are superb, the backs are fantastic (DOW is a master) and have a management team that works with the players to get the best out of each other, It is not luck but hard work that only France and New Zealand can match. Do not knock England for being the best, praise them for the hard work they put in. Nobody knocks America's women's football team for being the No.1, nobody knocks Spain for having the best European women's football team, so why knock ENGLAND WOMENS RUGBY TEAM FOR BEING THE BEST?
Commentator has to say something whether it makes sense or not isn't considered
Why do they not immediately stop play when a player is injured rather than having the medic work around play. Does anyone know what happened with the player who was injured.
Was this the first match in this six nations campaign where we did not have a try from Dow, Kildunne or Breach?
Lucy Packer is too indecisive and too slow.
I think switching her and Mo Hunt's numbers was a good call, she does the job well but is just better at it for shorter periods than the full match...
Meat in boots rugby, "pick and go" time after time.When will it dawn on the forwards that they cannot cross the line and allow the backs to play? I wonder why the Ferns have no worries playing these teams. Rugby is a running game, set up by the forwards. Forwards win the ball, Backs win the game!
Munarini is an awful ref.
Help me on this one, please. The disallowed Bourdon Sansus try. If we accept that she did touch it and then her team mate charged it down, wasn't she still offside as she was in front when she tried to gather the ball? I have to admit that I'm rather confused . . .
If Bourdon Sansus touched it, she played it back (albeit unwittingly) to Annaëlle Deshayes , I think , who then would have knocked the ball on. If Bordon Sansus was in an offside position, it would not have mattered, as the try was the result of a knock-on and hence disallowed as well. If that is the case, the only difference would have been the sanction, being a scrum, not a penalty. (Not sure if this is correct but logically, it seems to explain things).
@@AndrewUnderwood-pl1ur Thanks for that. That was my reasoning, too, but the commentators and the players seemed to be suggesting that had Bourdon Sansus touched it and it was then charged down, the try could have been awarded. I didn't see it that way. I might just pass the question on to Nigel Owens and see what he says. Because, as we all know, Nige is the 'man who knows'.
Who is the commentator here, Did she swallow a thesaurus/dictionary combo? Please decribe the game but leave the flowery descriptions out of the lightning fast, breathlessly quick, never ending, end to end, heart pounding leg pistoning, bone crunching game of rugby. If I want that crop, I will read Shakespeare!
I think the italians were playing with 16 including the ref still did not help. England played almost the whole match with 14.
I was watching the England Women Under 20's match against the Army. I think some of the players were given a dressing down after that match. The goal kicking was very good with only 3 missed conversions.
This isn’t touch rugby. Those Irish women need to learn correct tackle techniques to be competitive.
Why do the commentators big up the Welsh when they are clearly struggling, claiming that the Welsh are defending well when they have missed the first tackle, yet again, and then failed to prevent the offload. It isn’t doing them any favours and they subsequently look foolish when the score goes stratospheric.
Because the game is on the BBC which has a history of being anti English in their news and sports commentary.
55mins 32 sec - Jess Breach needs to learn to tackle..... like Abby, Ellie & Meg
Doesn't tackle,doesn't get shirt dirty
Scotland "so the long ball isn't working - let's do the long ball again" Huh?
Context is important here.... there are TEN TIMES as many women players under England Rugby to choose a team from.
The commentary is very weird, after 10 minutes they’re bigging up the Irish scrum when it’s clearly struggling, going backwards and only living on scraps thanks to a couple of penalties against the English women.
That's typical of the the BBC Commentator Sara Orchard. She's extremely PC & calls the players "women" continuously as if the viewers are too ignorant to understand that they're watching Womens Rugby.
That was a good game - for an England fan - but it would have been much, much closer if France hadn't made so many mistakes. France had so many good players who played really well - both Menagers, Escudero, tiny but tough Vernier, and the irrepressible Pauline Bourdon, but the whole team didn't match the same standard. Thanks for posting, although the video standard was not good: the resolution I got was 854x480@25fps, which meant that the players were just unidentifiable blobs when they weren't in a close-up shot. It's the kind of poor quality I've come to expect from KZread though.
dannah o,brien ....useless..yes she can kick a goal ...absolutey nothing else kicking from hand too wayward and no chase cant tackle never chases her own kicks no accelerastion and just wanders around lost,,a luxury player ireland cannot afford to have with the state of thier game at the minute
They have plenty to work with as she is. She can learn about all the other stuff, from hood coaches, playtime, watching others, and playing in situations where her team has some chance of spending time on the ball.
Huge congrats to Ireland Women, World Cup qualification and WXV 1 games in the autumn.
Sorry, but the constant commentary about discipline yellow/red cards is tedious. Find a modern, professional team, under the current laws doesn't get regular cards.
Yeah. The french had three yellows before the finale. Then they get yellow upgrade to red. The coaches tried to tell them it's the way the game is going with these cards.
They are, in effect, saying that they must not get Red cards, or yellow, against the Black Ferns.