thats cool but if anyone whos feeling slightly rambunctios be it a kid with a bat or a drunk collage student all those poking out tubes are getting destroyed 100% as a game to see who can smash the most or just for fun.
@ferrytadema242417 сағат бұрын
I I I I to much self esteem.
@theolnevКүн бұрын
Nice project. Thank you
@evanleeturnerКүн бұрын
In Texas these will end up housing yellowjackets and mosquitoes
@JoeMakesКүн бұрын
Don't forget spiders! (I lived in Austin back in the day)
@TheMrCheezlezombieКүн бұрын
Then they fill with water and rot, Animals next inside your walls. So many problems with it.
@JoeMakesКүн бұрын
I only see solutions
@icd-italiancustomdrone8100Күн бұрын
Ciao video bellissimo!! can I ask a question, what about adding small amounts of water in the hollow bricks? could also help boost the plants and biodiversity.
@JoeMakesКүн бұрын
Grazie! I love it and will test on the next version
@kitten-inside2 күн бұрын
The easiest way to use this, which I saw in a radio concert hall, is lining a wall with traditional red bricks turned to their side. The brick holes become sound trapping "pipes", and whatever you say magically disappears into the wall. It was surprisingly effective given the minimal manufacturing cost (compared to any specialised shape).
@JoeMakesКүн бұрын
Yup, I write about this in my thesis paper. You might like it. Linked in the description
@Bettinasisrg2 күн бұрын
We have so many incredible minds making fantasist strides in eco related things of all kinds that we need to survive yet we are not implementing them. Why? Money for the few, lots and lots of money made by us for them. Until we're dying it won't change on it's own. Vote for the environment.
@JoeMakesКүн бұрын
Cheers!
@BlissLovePeace3 күн бұрын
who made the drawing of the vitruvian man? .... yeah, thought so ...
@JoeMakes2 күн бұрын
I did. It was all me
@vandervir3 күн бұрын
How good is plastic as sound absorber? There is already abundance of that everywhere, and with plastic extruders it could be used easier to make overlay puzzles in public places.
@JoeMakes2 күн бұрын
Feel free to 3D print the file I put out there for free
@lonraigh073 күн бұрын
Dont understand english, but we need this material... Woow
@JoeMakes3 күн бұрын
Thanks! Glad you liked it! What language do you know?
@AlchemicRaker3 күн бұрын
What happens when rain is inevitably blown into the cavities?
@JoeMakes3 күн бұрын
Using terracotta helps to weep the water away, but I'll test that in the next version!
@wesb264 күн бұрын
Will it still work if you put something that keeps birds out?
@JoeMakes3 күн бұрын
I'll test that in the next version 👍
@wesb263 күн бұрын
Sorry brother. I guess you answered that already😂 I’m sold. Good luck with this.
@Christian-fy5dz4 күн бұрын
If we eliminated road noise think of how much better life would be.
@JoeMakes3 күн бұрын
I agree! (You might like my thesis in the description)
@user-to2gh7sg3l5 күн бұрын
Those are some phony legos for sure.
@JoeMakes3 күн бұрын
I like this. They should use these as weird coconuts under the palm trees
@user-to2gh7sg3l5 күн бұрын
What happens when they get filled with ice and crumble onto the roadway?
@JoeMakes3 күн бұрын
They would probably fill with water first before ice
@user-to2gh7sg3l5 күн бұрын
If it was a bong it would creative as well as useful.
@JoeMakes3 күн бұрын
That can also happen!
@bbsara01465 күн бұрын
This is actually useful research. Academics tend to think in abstract terms, but discovering the process for fabricating these shapes in clay seems like a discovery in itself.
@JoeMakes3 күн бұрын
Thanks so much! There was plenty of abstract thinking going on, but trying to bring it back to actual design and manufacturing techniques to improve the built environment. Glad you liked it. You might enjoy my thesis in the description. (I'll do an updated version on the second version of the brick)
@markstevens17295 күн бұрын
Brilliant! Your conclusion brought it back to the design fundamentals. I’m thinking I missed the purpose of the ceramics limitation. One would think modern materials know how would help scale the manufacturing. The impact and simplicity are impressive.
@JoeMakes3 күн бұрын
Thanks so much! The ceramics limitation was a constraint because we wanted to explore that path of materials other than plastics and concrete. It was a challenge, and was a pleasant surprised in our outcome. (I wouldn't recommend clay for a business proposal, but was great fun in academic research). I'll do a second version with new improvements soon!
@ericw35176 күн бұрын
Cool, but trees and shrubs work great too.
@JoeMakes3 күн бұрын
Yeah, I cover that in my thesis. You might enjoy reading it. (Linked in the description)
@macrumpton6 күн бұрын
I wonder if these resonators could be integrated into the structure of cars to reduce noise at the source? Specifically I am thinking that the wheel wells could have two walls with the resonant spaces in between them to absorb the tire noise that seems to be the majority of automobile sound.
@JoeMakes6 күн бұрын
Yes, they are incorporated into engine blocks and internal car parts. You might enjoy my thesis (linked in the description)
@procrastinathor45947 күн бұрын
As a Czech native I can confirm that krčma means tavern :D
@JoeMakes6 күн бұрын
Na zdraví!
@matchke17 күн бұрын
0:16 not only in czech. Also in slovak.
@JoeMakes6 күн бұрын
Na zdraví!
@SorbusAucubaria7 күн бұрын
Very interesting. If something like this could be incorporated in fasads of the buildings and it actually would make the sound environment more pleasant, this could be revolutionary and make cities more pleasant.
@JoeMakes6 күн бұрын
Thanks, you might like my thesis where I go into this more! (Linked in the description)
@mallek19897 күн бұрын
Oh man…. you’re testing different materials on resonators?! You should’ve taken an apprenticeship with a real acoustics engineer. You have a fundamental misunderstanding of acoustics. Clay won’t stop low frequency energy. Your “resonators” are acting more like broadband absorbers than they are resonators. That would be great if the broadband absorption were actually efficient; but this is going to be extremely inefficient at both broadband and targeted absorption. It’s absolutely gonna do both, but it’s not going to do either well. But maybe my standards are a lot higher than yours. I’m used to thinking in terms of room absorption. I guess if you’re not looking to do any major absorption, then this may be fine to cut a few decibels from random frequencies in the air.
@JoeMakes6 күн бұрын
Yeah, we knew ceramics was a challenge, but that's the material the school went with. So it was fun to explore!
@mallek19897 күн бұрын
Helmholtz resonators absorb very specific frequencies at a very narrow frequency band. Traffic noise is just that… noise. Noise has no fundamental frequency or harmonics. If you absorb 60hz from noise using Helmholtz resonators, then you still have 20-55hz and 65-20khz. This isn’t gonna work. Low end acoustic absorption is the most difficult type of acoustic absorption. Helmholtz and membrane traps only target very specific frequencies. 20-300Hz is a HUGE target. That’s 4 octaves. Quadratic diffusion would’ve probably been your best bet outdoors.
@JoeMakes6 күн бұрын
Thanks, you might like my thesis where I cover this more (linked in the description)
@w8stral7 күн бұрын
So, LOTS of bird nests...
@JoeMakes6 күн бұрын
And Spiders!
@w8stral6 күн бұрын
@@JoeMakes gartner snake abodes...
@dengueberries7 күн бұрын
Great video. I learned a lot. What happened after the project? Is it possible to create absorption of specific frequencies by altering the shape? Btw, referring to Bloomsbury as "downtown" is pretty hilarious
@JoeMakes6 күн бұрын
Thanks! I moved back to the States and gave the prototype wall to the University. I'm working on a second iteration altering the shape and will make a video about that.
@madman38918 күн бұрын
perfect homes for mice ?
@JoeMakes7 күн бұрын
And Spiders!
@abhisheksreenivasan93538 күн бұрын
Awesome work there budd 👏 appreciate sharing it !
@JoeMakes7 күн бұрын
Thanks! Glad you liked it!
@scottdsouza79858 күн бұрын
@Joe Makes you should try using hay so that it will absorb the moisture evenly.
@JoeMakes7 күн бұрын
Thanks!
@FarmerBenny9 күн бұрын
Could this work combined with pollinator habitat incorporated into the voids? Or could this work scaled up at a larger size using concrete?
@JoeMakes8 күн бұрын
I like it! Great ideas
@mffmYT9 күн бұрын
The New Brick & Final Prototye moment; after try, fail, learn, repeat you cheked other ideas, adapted and identified the core idea. I would like to see Bringze Li's reaction to his brick base.
@JoeMakes6 күн бұрын
Thanks! Bingze did more research in robotic arm carving, which you can check out here: fifteen2022.bartlettarchucl.com/dfm-2022/alternative-ceramic-designs
@LeeLLewis9 күн бұрын
Want for my bedroom!
@JoeMakes8 күн бұрын
It's yours!
@DMT4Dinner9 күн бұрын
Wonder how they’d be as hempcrete
@JoeMakes8 күн бұрын
Nice!
@tthappyrock3689 күн бұрын
Hello from the Portland metro area! This design element sounds amazing! The county is redoing our street so car and other traffic will be 20+ feet closer to my front door. Noise was already enough of a problem that it was difficult to have conversations in the front yard. These bricks would be a great help in reducing traffic noise after they're done! I would totally install these if I could make them, have them made or buy them!
@JoeMakes3 күн бұрын
PDX represent! Thanks! The file is free to download and 3D print
@chillpillology9 күн бұрын
the Q on hemholtz are pretty narrow iirc.
@JoeMakes6 күн бұрын
True
@numbzober990111 күн бұрын
Wow I love the idea, I recently graduated from architecture college looking for inspiration on how could brick and clay evolve to accomodate the architecture and I really love the presentation.
@JoeMakes10 күн бұрын
Thanks so much! Glad you liked it. You might enjoy my portfolio and thesis papers (linked in the description)
@numbzober990110 күн бұрын
@@JoeMakes wow thank you I would love to read your thesis paper.
@tim5724311 күн бұрын
All very good. Can you explain Tillinghast resonators next?
@JoeMakes10 күн бұрын
Haha, I'll leave that for your video.
@alexeykrylov999512 күн бұрын
32:30 "algae and fungi and stuff can grow on these bricks which would help with the visual" WHAT???
@JoeMakes10 күн бұрын
I take it you don't like green living walls? I wouldn't walk into a tech conference lobby room if I were you.
@alexeykrylov99954 күн бұрын
@@JoeMakes That's moss, not algae and fungi then. Algae and fungi is the green-black stuff that grows on rotting untreated wood and sometimes on the walls if rainwater from the roof hits the wall, for example. And the black stuff that grows on the walls inside humid locations.
@baldieman6412 күн бұрын
Create a quiet spot for a picnic. Have it unusable because the wall is full of wasp nests...
@JoeMakes10 күн бұрын
But they will help eat the leftovers
@weareallbeingwatched460212 күн бұрын
The romans places empty pots filled with straw in the corners to improve acoustics in interior and exterior architectural designs
@JoeMakes10 күн бұрын
Nice! Thanks for this
@weareallbeingwatched460210 күн бұрын
@@JoeMakes if you don't put things in the pots to absorb the energy, they *amplify the frequency in question*. In recording studios we generally avoid helmholtz resonators for this reason.
@satanlover13412 күн бұрын
you could have made them as a bent shape between a t and a triangle creating the resonators in the inbetween and making it much simpler to mass produce and implament
@JoeMakes10 күн бұрын
Slip casting is still a challenge with 90 degree angles
@satanlover13412 күн бұрын
why didnt you just make them long and simply apply a series of Ts along a wall
@JoeMakes10 күн бұрын
Tetris blocks
@EliSheldon112 күн бұрын
super sick, this should be trending!
@JoeMakes12 күн бұрын
Thanks bro! Share it with your friends 🤩
@sevjij12 күн бұрын
Lacked one thing that would have made it perfect - making it profiled like actual guitar, rather than a toy. Neck and stock is too blocky and even body lacks a lot of curvature so that it does not dig in arm. How about making v2.0 that could actually fool someone into thinking it is real guitar?
@JoeMakes12 күн бұрын
Who wants to play an actual guitar when you can play Guitar Hero?
@sevjij12 күн бұрын
@@JoeMakes precisely, that question would have been more convincing and cheeky if it looked like an actual guitar.
@peteleoni966512 күн бұрын
A box with a hole in it. A resonator. The rest os all this window dressing.
@JoeMakes10 күн бұрын
It's actually not meant for windows, too heavy. I recommend watching it again
@davidkleinman492012 күн бұрын
Any chance you will release the files for the guitar body and the neck?
Пікірлер
Very very cool Mr Pub 👍
thats cool but if anyone whos feeling slightly rambunctios be it a kid with a bat or a drunk collage student all those poking out tubes are getting destroyed 100% as a game to see who can smash the most or just for fun.
I I I I to much self esteem.
Nice project. Thank you
In Texas these will end up housing yellowjackets and mosquitoes
Don't forget spiders! (I lived in Austin back in the day)
Then they fill with water and rot, Animals next inside your walls. So many problems with it.
I only see solutions
Ciao video bellissimo!! can I ask a question, what about adding small amounts of water in the hollow bricks? could also help boost the plants and biodiversity.
Grazie! I love it and will test on the next version
The easiest way to use this, which I saw in a radio concert hall, is lining a wall with traditional red bricks turned to their side. The brick holes become sound trapping "pipes", and whatever you say magically disappears into the wall. It was surprisingly effective given the minimal manufacturing cost (compared to any specialised shape).
Yup, I write about this in my thesis paper. You might like it. Linked in the description
We have so many incredible minds making fantasist strides in eco related things of all kinds that we need to survive yet we are not implementing them. Why? Money for the few, lots and lots of money made by us for them. Until we're dying it won't change on it's own. Vote for the environment.
Cheers!
who made the drawing of the vitruvian man? .... yeah, thought so ...
I did. It was all me
How good is plastic as sound absorber? There is already abundance of that everywhere, and with plastic extruders it could be used easier to make overlay puzzles in public places.
Feel free to 3D print the file I put out there for free
Dont understand english, but we need this material... Woow
Thanks! Glad you liked it! What language do you know?
What happens when rain is inevitably blown into the cavities?
Using terracotta helps to weep the water away, but I'll test that in the next version!
Will it still work if you put something that keeps birds out?
I'll test that in the next version 👍
Sorry brother. I guess you answered that already😂 I’m sold. Good luck with this.
If we eliminated road noise think of how much better life would be.
I agree! (You might like my thesis in the description)
Those are some phony legos for sure.
I like this. They should use these as weird coconuts under the palm trees
What happens when they get filled with ice and crumble onto the roadway?
They would probably fill with water first before ice
If it was a bong it would creative as well as useful.
That can also happen!
This is actually useful research. Academics tend to think in abstract terms, but discovering the process for fabricating these shapes in clay seems like a discovery in itself.
Thanks so much! There was plenty of abstract thinking going on, but trying to bring it back to actual design and manufacturing techniques to improve the built environment. Glad you liked it. You might enjoy my thesis in the description. (I'll do an updated version on the second version of the brick)
Brilliant! Your conclusion brought it back to the design fundamentals. I’m thinking I missed the purpose of the ceramics limitation. One would think modern materials know how would help scale the manufacturing. The impact and simplicity are impressive.
Thanks so much! The ceramics limitation was a constraint because we wanted to explore that path of materials other than plastics and concrete. It was a challenge, and was a pleasant surprised in our outcome. (I wouldn't recommend clay for a business proposal, but was great fun in academic research). I'll do a second version with new improvements soon!
Cool, but trees and shrubs work great too.
Yeah, I cover that in my thesis. You might enjoy reading it. (Linked in the description)
I wonder if these resonators could be integrated into the structure of cars to reduce noise at the source? Specifically I am thinking that the wheel wells could have two walls with the resonant spaces in between them to absorb the tire noise that seems to be the majority of automobile sound.
Yes, they are incorporated into engine blocks and internal car parts. You might enjoy my thesis (linked in the description)
As a Czech native I can confirm that krčma means tavern :D
Na zdraví!
0:16 not only in czech. Also in slovak.
Na zdraví!
Very interesting. If something like this could be incorporated in fasads of the buildings and it actually would make the sound environment more pleasant, this could be revolutionary and make cities more pleasant.
Thanks, you might like my thesis where I go into this more! (Linked in the description)
Oh man…. you’re testing different materials on resonators?! You should’ve taken an apprenticeship with a real acoustics engineer. You have a fundamental misunderstanding of acoustics. Clay won’t stop low frequency energy. Your “resonators” are acting more like broadband absorbers than they are resonators. That would be great if the broadband absorption were actually efficient; but this is going to be extremely inefficient at both broadband and targeted absorption. It’s absolutely gonna do both, but it’s not going to do either well. But maybe my standards are a lot higher than yours. I’m used to thinking in terms of room absorption. I guess if you’re not looking to do any major absorption, then this may be fine to cut a few decibels from random frequencies in the air.
Yeah, we knew ceramics was a challenge, but that's the material the school went with. So it was fun to explore!
Helmholtz resonators absorb very specific frequencies at a very narrow frequency band. Traffic noise is just that… noise. Noise has no fundamental frequency or harmonics. If you absorb 60hz from noise using Helmholtz resonators, then you still have 20-55hz and 65-20khz. This isn’t gonna work. Low end acoustic absorption is the most difficult type of acoustic absorption. Helmholtz and membrane traps only target very specific frequencies. 20-300Hz is a HUGE target. That’s 4 octaves. Quadratic diffusion would’ve probably been your best bet outdoors.
Thanks, you might like my thesis where I cover this more (linked in the description)
So, LOTS of bird nests...
And Spiders!
@@JoeMakes gartner snake abodes...
Great video. I learned a lot. What happened after the project? Is it possible to create absorption of specific frequencies by altering the shape? Btw, referring to Bloomsbury as "downtown" is pretty hilarious
Thanks! I moved back to the States and gave the prototype wall to the University. I'm working on a second iteration altering the shape and will make a video about that.
perfect homes for mice ?
And Spiders!
Awesome work there budd 👏 appreciate sharing it !
Thanks! Glad you liked it!
@Joe Makes you should try using hay so that it will absorb the moisture evenly.
Thanks!
Could this work combined with pollinator habitat incorporated into the voids? Or could this work scaled up at a larger size using concrete?
I like it! Great ideas
The New Brick & Final Prototye moment; after try, fail, learn, repeat you cheked other ideas, adapted and identified the core idea. I would like to see Bringze Li's reaction to his brick base.
Thanks! Bingze did more research in robotic arm carving, which you can check out here: fifteen2022.bartlettarchucl.com/dfm-2022/alternative-ceramic-designs
Want for my bedroom!
It's yours!
Wonder how they’d be as hempcrete
Nice!
Hello from the Portland metro area! This design element sounds amazing! The county is redoing our street so car and other traffic will be 20+ feet closer to my front door. Noise was already enough of a problem that it was difficult to have conversations in the front yard. These bricks would be a great help in reducing traffic noise after they're done! I would totally install these if I could make them, have them made or buy them!
PDX represent! Thanks! The file is free to download and 3D print
the Q on hemholtz are pretty narrow iirc.
True
Wow I love the idea, I recently graduated from architecture college looking for inspiration on how could brick and clay evolve to accomodate the architecture and I really love the presentation.
Thanks so much! Glad you liked it. You might enjoy my portfolio and thesis papers (linked in the description)
@@JoeMakes wow thank you I would love to read your thesis paper.
All very good. Can you explain Tillinghast resonators next?
Haha, I'll leave that for your video.
32:30 "algae and fungi and stuff can grow on these bricks which would help with the visual" WHAT???
I take it you don't like green living walls? I wouldn't walk into a tech conference lobby room if I were you.
@@JoeMakes That's moss, not algae and fungi then. Algae and fungi is the green-black stuff that grows on rotting untreated wood and sometimes on the walls if rainwater from the roof hits the wall, for example. And the black stuff that grows on the walls inside humid locations.
Create a quiet spot for a picnic. Have it unusable because the wall is full of wasp nests...
But they will help eat the leftovers
The romans places empty pots filled with straw in the corners to improve acoustics in interior and exterior architectural designs
Nice! Thanks for this
@@JoeMakes if you don't put things in the pots to absorb the energy, they *amplify the frequency in question*. In recording studios we generally avoid helmholtz resonators for this reason.
you could have made them as a bent shape between a t and a triangle creating the resonators in the inbetween and making it much simpler to mass produce and implament
Slip casting is still a challenge with 90 degree angles
why didnt you just make them long and simply apply a series of Ts along a wall
Tetris blocks
super sick, this should be trending!
Thanks bro! Share it with your friends 🤩
Lacked one thing that would have made it perfect - making it profiled like actual guitar, rather than a toy. Neck and stock is too blocky and even body lacks a lot of curvature so that it does not dig in arm. How about making v2.0 that could actually fool someone into thinking it is real guitar?
Who wants to play an actual guitar when you can play Guitar Hero?
@@JoeMakes precisely, that question would have been more convincing and cheeky if it looked like an actual guitar.
A box with a hole in it. A resonator. The rest os all this window dressing.
It's actually not meant for windows, too heavy. I recommend watching it again
Any chance you will release the files for the guitar body and the neck?
Yeah, I’ll put it out tomorrow 👍