yes yes yes yes if we want this kind of rule we will go back to europe which rt now is more free tgan here
@C_H_Toons2 күн бұрын
If they made coalitions, wouldn’t that… kinda bring us back to square one?
@yashagrawal882 күн бұрын
Make such a video about India.
@williamwolf28443 күн бұрын
Some parts of this video were good. Maybe the best was showing evidence that for outlier groups, their cultural, rather than their economic, policies are the most important in determining which party they'll vote for. However, this video ignores so many things that it's frankly ridiculous. 1. It is essential to look at voting procedures, which can broadly be divided into two groups: winner-take all (first-past-the-post) OR something like proportional representation or ranked choice voting. Ignoring how the former favors two main parties is lazy. Simply adding 2 more parties to the US will make almost no difference if winner-take all (first-past-the-post) is used to determine the victor in single-candidate constituencies. 2. There is plenty of coalition building that takes place in US politics as well as in other "two-party systems". It generally focuses on intra-party rather than inter-party coalitions. In the US and other "two-party systems", there is a great deal of intra-party coalition building. 3. Mentioning Mike Pence as any kind of national leader is just plain stupid. He has never had any national following. He was chosen as a nothing-candidate to be vice president. Mentioning him as a possible leader, even in a hypothetical case, shows us the low quality of the poll and research that this video relies on. 4. The four main political currents that this video mentions are, in fact, represented in various ways by the two main US parties. There are all kinds of regional variations: a left-of-center candidate in New York or San Francisco is not the same as one in Alabama. This is often obscured by the intra-party coalition building that inevitably takes place in "two-party systems". 5. The video constantly confounds "parties" and "candidates". The video says, "There is no one to represent these two groups," which is false. It is true that the center of each of the two main parties is not in the upper left or the lower right quadrant, but in the US, people vote not for a party but for a candidate, and there are, contrary to what this video claims, many candidates in each of these two quadrants. This is especially true for Democrats who are, by national standards, more conservative than the party as a whole. This also used to be true several decades ago for Republicans who were more liberal than the national average for the GOP. The contrast with the UK (the home country of the narrator) is relevant here. In the UK system (and more generally in Westminster type and parliamentary systems as a whole), for elections to the legislature, people vote for a party, not for a candidate. This is one reason why often candidates can be shifted from one constituency to another. It's also why, in general, prime ministers are elected indirectly (as is the case with the US) than directly. Generally, it is the party in the legislature with the majority or plurality of seats which is asked to form a government. Many Europeans themselves are unaware that they have indirect elections of their prime minister; they mistakenly believe that the US does (via the Electoral College) but that they have direct elections of their head of government. In general, they do not. The narrator ignores that there is a considerable degree of variation in the US even among the same party. The system of primary elections is one means that tries to bridge this deviation from the stated, official platform of a party and the actual politics of candidates on the level of the local constituency. It allows people in that constituency to choose as their candidate from among people with a wide range of positions. The narrator, by constantly confusing "party" and "candidate" (a confusion which would be less of a problem in a system like the UK's where there is less intra-party variation than in the US, and far less of a problem in European parliamentary systems with proportional representation, where there is even less intra-party variation, but more inter-party variation), continually sees gaps and absences ("there is no party for this quadrant of political values!!!"") when there are, indeed, candidates for those various combinations of liberal and conservative, economic and cultural.
@rvw2bdragon1393 күн бұрын
Not buy themselves and the answer is simple water, both states are desperate for water.
@donaldekhoff79995 күн бұрын
Form two or three new States where the citizens can be properly represented and therefor gain their Constitutional rights. These three new States would help balance the diversity of State land masses as well as having each new State consist of similar local geographies so their special interests can find representation at the Federal level. Don't loose the opportunity presented by a new Federal restructure to accomplish this overdue restructuring. The East Coast is made up of many smaller States while the West has much larger States. This needs to be re-balanced for fair Federal representation of the People. Idaho could take on or give up land as needed to find an optimal outcome. Currently the people living in these areas have no effective representation and are therefore economically compromised by no fault of their own. Fixing this problem is long overdue and should be sponsored at the Federal Level as part of it's authority to Regulate Interstate Commerce, which is an enumerated responsibility.
@dominicp.27026 күн бұрын
Yes, let's have 5 parties, but make sure they're headed by the same idiot leaders we have now. This will surely solve something, not actual problems, but something.
@Michael.M237 күн бұрын
I would vote for the Nationalists haha
@jerryross71357 күн бұрын
The conservative, hard working, people of Oregon are sick and tired of paying taxes to a controlling government who "hates" them and "their way of life" The purple hairs in Multnomah County needs all the taxes from conservatives to construct Gov Kotex's new California. Everything from our water, gardening, cattle ranching, and our 2A rights are constantly under attack. Javier Milei, President of Argentina said it best "They will use your very own taxes to destroy you and your way of life". Phuk Kotex and her ilk. They are in "control" and will likely roadblock this endeavor to join Idaho. Were like a mother of 3, being raped in our beds at night by an illegitimate government. We are being suffocated in Oregon and warned to be quiet. We cant defeat the ballot printing commies in Multnomah County who use Mail In ballots to remove any equity of the people. WE MUST STOP MAIL IN BALLOTS IN OREGON
@d3thkn1ghtmcgee747 күн бұрын
I love how they talk about the PSLs complicated history but don't talk about how the AIP has ties to the Silver league party which was fascist party funded by the literal Nazis in the 30s 🙄
@muhlenberg26087 күн бұрын
I'm waiting for something like this in Minnesota, where a "greater Minnesota" or "Wester Minnesota" statehood has been talked about. The Twin Cities of Minnesota are overwhelmingly Democrat, the western two thirds of Minnesota is overwhelmingly Republican.
@lindaarmstrongjackman97888 күн бұрын
No way Trump “aced” this test. 😂
@kellythompson38658 күн бұрын
Trumps readin from a Q-card! Notice he looks to his left quickly. He he he!
@juanitapacheco57758 күн бұрын
If he pass that test how come he can’t answer simple questions when he is interviewed
@pisos959 күн бұрын
Stating that the Democratic party is left from a European perspective is pretty laughable. What a joke that the equivalent to Merkel in the USA is called left
@itstaylor213710 күн бұрын
we would need rank choice voting
@worldadventuretravel10 күн бұрын
Let's tell the truth. Women are realizing it adds no value to their lives to go from taking care of themselves, paying their own bills, pursuing their interests, and enjoying their communities to becoming domestic slaves for men- to clean up after them, raise their kids, have no time for lives or interests of their own anymore, and often STILL having to work full-time jobs. And then after they waste their best years doing all of that, men leave them for younger women and fight them in divorce courts. That's ON TOP OF living under a late-stage dystopian crapitalist empire that has absolutely no safety net and refuses to even provide basic things in return for our taxes like healthcare and affordable housing. Yet people are still confused about why birthrates are falling? 😂 Make it make sense.
@robertcurry786010 күн бұрын
That would be terrific for Eastern Oregonians who ae GOP Conservatives and completely disagree with the radical,, liberal, Leftist, communist Western Oregon POV.
@martentrudeau694811 күн бұрын
Voting works when all votes are counted, but that has is not happened in recent years. Problem we have is our government will not and can not investigate vote fraud from within the government system which is corrupt. Corruption is embedded in government. Corporations get their mandates from their creditors and not We the People.
@bfattori0111 күн бұрын
Not a chance. Those people might wanna have a little right wing racist utopia, but not happening in my lifetime!
@elizabethalton409711 күн бұрын
I live in in Oregon and I’d vote for becoming part of Idaho
@psychicdriver422911 күн бұрын
Idagon.
@psychicdriver422911 күн бұрын
Oreho.
@dare2scheme90411 күн бұрын
Right, so the voters aren't a factor. This is really enriching 🗑️
@lisaschreiber289311 күн бұрын
big surprise republicans want to take away peoole’s rights who don’t think like them
@eldiabloramon11 күн бұрын
😮 that would literally be the MOST STUPID thing America could do… if Texas or California succeeds from the nation it will leave everyone including Texas and California hyper vunrable to attack from Russia and China. America needs to get its head out of it butt, and open its eyes to our external threats from abroad.
@claycoates505611 күн бұрын
now this is interesting I have heard many times that Texas has long age Paid there taxes to become its on its own this may be but the problem in the costs of governing among other things interesting is it not???
@davidschwartz512711 күн бұрын
This is why we have the Electoral College, I believe it should be taken to the country level to better represent the United States population.
@coziboi287211 күн бұрын
Goes to show republicans don’t want to coexist with democrats simple as that.
@oldranger64911 күн бұрын
ADJUSTING STATELINES is Hogwash. it started sometime around the turn of the century with the populist movement and this came out two or three times since then. There are four major legal hurdles and short of a civil war it ain't going to happen. the last time a major county pulled out of a major state was West Virginia that was a civil war. there's too many hoops to jump through. It's *BS and it's not even original.
@luisduron272212 күн бұрын
Update
@luisduron272212 күн бұрын
2024
@luisduron272212 күн бұрын
2024
@luisduron272212 күн бұрын
2024
@ClassyKai84312 күн бұрын
I literally saw an RFK ad put up as an ad for this video
@Cybernaut55113 күн бұрын
This didn't age well in 2024.
@Cybernaut55113 күн бұрын
Grand interview, encore!
@franzjosef772813 күн бұрын
East Oregon is Idaho.
@janewhite57215 күн бұрын
It's time to get rid of the two wings of the same party which gives no option other voting for the lesser of two evils. Why vote for any evil 🤔 why not vote for the greatest good. Jill Stein seems a sane choice.
@SharonO-cu1yp16 күн бұрын
U R.A BIG CRIMINAL U NEED TO GO. TO PRISON U R MAKING EVERYONE IN THE US R GETTING MAD
@Dankenshmunken-dv8mg16 күн бұрын
You’ve forgot the purple states
@slibertas199618 күн бұрын
Wrong. For a time Justin Amash was a libertarian in the house.
@MyLove-uj8zi18 күн бұрын
End Qualified immunity! They should be held accountable for abusing citizens...
@shellimendoza733219 күн бұрын
Tuck frump! Vote blue 💙
@emmyo667820 күн бұрын
So sad. Trump is not fit to lead anything or anyone. 😤
@williamreid671521 күн бұрын
America has through much of its history accepted immigrants. The recent efforts by the right wing to demonize immigrants has been counterproductive. It has been the free acceptance of immigrants, Mexicans, Canadians, Irish, Chinese, Moslem, Jewish, that has allowed America to not just survive but thrive and remain a superpower.
@valerietorreggiani997321 күн бұрын
Biden continues to overcome a really bad stammer!
@valerietorreggiani997321 күн бұрын
What a fool to advertise a test that primary children. It probably was easy, it’s for little children.
@Axeman42821 күн бұрын
Trump is right about one thing and that’s when he said most of the people he was speaking to probably will have a hard time passing it. 😂😂😂
Пікірлер
than here
yes yes yes yes if we want this kind of rule we will go back to europe which rt now is more free tgan here
If they made coalitions, wouldn’t that… kinda bring us back to square one?
Make such a video about India.
Some parts of this video were good. Maybe the best was showing evidence that for outlier groups, their cultural, rather than their economic, policies are the most important in determining which party they'll vote for. However, this video ignores so many things that it's frankly ridiculous. 1. It is essential to look at voting procedures, which can broadly be divided into two groups: winner-take all (first-past-the-post) OR something like proportional representation or ranked choice voting. Ignoring how the former favors two main parties is lazy. Simply adding 2 more parties to the US will make almost no difference if winner-take all (first-past-the-post) is used to determine the victor in single-candidate constituencies. 2. There is plenty of coalition building that takes place in US politics as well as in other "two-party systems". It generally focuses on intra-party rather than inter-party coalitions. In the US and other "two-party systems", there is a great deal of intra-party coalition building. 3. Mentioning Mike Pence as any kind of national leader is just plain stupid. He has never had any national following. He was chosen as a nothing-candidate to be vice president. Mentioning him as a possible leader, even in a hypothetical case, shows us the low quality of the poll and research that this video relies on. 4. The four main political currents that this video mentions are, in fact, represented in various ways by the two main US parties. There are all kinds of regional variations: a left-of-center candidate in New York or San Francisco is not the same as one in Alabama. This is often obscured by the intra-party coalition building that inevitably takes place in "two-party systems". 5. The video constantly confounds "parties" and "candidates". The video says, "There is no one to represent these two groups," which is false. It is true that the center of each of the two main parties is not in the upper left or the lower right quadrant, but in the US, people vote not for a party but for a candidate, and there are, contrary to what this video claims, many candidates in each of these two quadrants. This is especially true for Democrats who are, by national standards, more conservative than the party as a whole. This also used to be true several decades ago for Republicans who were more liberal than the national average for the GOP. The contrast with the UK (the home country of the narrator) is relevant here. In the UK system (and more generally in Westminster type and parliamentary systems as a whole), for elections to the legislature, people vote for a party, not for a candidate. This is one reason why often candidates can be shifted from one constituency to another. It's also why, in general, prime ministers are elected indirectly (as is the case with the US) than directly. Generally, it is the party in the legislature with the majority or plurality of seats which is asked to form a government. Many Europeans themselves are unaware that they have indirect elections of their prime minister; they mistakenly believe that the US does (via the Electoral College) but that they have direct elections of their head of government. In general, they do not. The narrator ignores that there is a considerable degree of variation in the US even among the same party. The system of primary elections is one means that tries to bridge this deviation from the stated, official platform of a party and the actual politics of candidates on the level of the local constituency. It allows people in that constituency to choose as their candidate from among people with a wide range of positions. The narrator, by constantly confusing "party" and "candidate" (a confusion which would be less of a problem in a system like the UK's where there is less intra-party variation than in the US, and far less of a problem in European parliamentary systems with proportional representation, where there is even less intra-party variation, but more inter-party variation), continually sees gaps and absences ("there is no party for this quadrant of political values!!!"") when there are, indeed, candidates for those various combinations of liberal and conservative, economic and cultural.
Not buy themselves and the answer is simple water, both states are desperate for water.
Form two or three new States where the citizens can be properly represented and therefor gain their Constitutional rights. These three new States would help balance the diversity of State land masses as well as having each new State consist of similar local geographies so their special interests can find representation at the Federal level. Don't loose the opportunity presented by a new Federal restructure to accomplish this overdue restructuring. The East Coast is made up of many smaller States while the West has much larger States. This needs to be re-balanced for fair Federal representation of the People. Idaho could take on or give up land as needed to find an optimal outcome. Currently the people living in these areas have no effective representation and are therefore economically compromised by no fault of their own. Fixing this problem is long overdue and should be sponsored at the Federal Level as part of it's authority to Regulate Interstate Commerce, which is an enumerated responsibility.
Yes, let's have 5 parties, but make sure they're headed by the same idiot leaders we have now. This will surely solve something, not actual problems, but something.
I would vote for the Nationalists haha
The conservative, hard working, people of Oregon are sick and tired of paying taxes to a controlling government who "hates" them and "their way of life" The purple hairs in Multnomah County needs all the taxes from conservatives to construct Gov Kotex's new California. Everything from our water, gardening, cattle ranching, and our 2A rights are constantly under attack. Javier Milei, President of Argentina said it best "They will use your very own taxes to destroy you and your way of life". Phuk Kotex and her ilk. They are in "control" and will likely roadblock this endeavor to join Idaho. Were like a mother of 3, being raped in our beds at night by an illegitimate government. We are being suffocated in Oregon and warned to be quiet. We cant defeat the ballot printing commies in Multnomah County who use Mail In ballots to remove any equity of the people. WE MUST STOP MAIL IN BALLOTS IN OREGON
I love how they talk about the PSLs complicated history but don't talk about how the AIP has ties to the Silver league party which was fascist party funded by the literal Nazis in the 30s 🙄
I'm waiting for something like this in Minnesota, where a "greater Minnesota" or "Wester Minnesota" statehood has been talked about. The Twin Cities of Minnesota are overwhelmingly Democrat, the western two thirds of Minnesota is overwhelmingly Republican.
No way Trump “aced” this test. 😂
Trumps readin from a Q-card! Notice he looks to his left quickly. He he he!
If he pass that test how come he can’t answer simple questions when he is interviewed
Stating that the Democratic party is left from a European perspective is pretty laughable. What a joke that the equivalent to Merkel in the USA is called left
we would need rank choice voting
Let's tell the truth. Women are realizing it adds no value to their lives to go from taking care of themselves, paying their own bills, pursuing their interests, and enjoying their communities to becoming domestic slaves for men- to clean up after them, raise their kids, have no time for lives or interests of their own anymore, and often STILL having to work full-time jobs. And then after they waste their best years doing all of that, men leave them for younger women and fight them in divorce courts. That's ON TOP OF living under a late-stage dystopian crapitalist empire that has absolutely no safety net and refuses to even provide basic things in return for our taxes like healthcare and affordable housing. Yet people are still confused about why birthrates are falling? 😂 Make it make sense.
That would be terrific for Eastern Oregonians who ae GOP Conservatives and completely disagree with the radical,, liberal, Leftist, communist Western Oregon POV.
Voting works when all votes are counted, but that has is not happened in recent years. Problem we have is our government will not and can not investigate vote fraud from within the government system which is corrupt. Corruption is embedded in government. Corporations get their mandates from their creditors and not We the People.
Not a chance. Those people might wanna have a little right wing racist utopia, but not happening in my lifetime!
I live in in Oregon and I’d vote for becoming part of Idaho
Idagon.
Oreho.
Right, so the voters aren't a factor. This is really enriching 🗑️
big surprise republicans want to take away peoole’s rights who don’t think like them
😮 that would literally be the MOST STUPID thing America could do… if Texas or California succeeds from the nation it will leave everyone including Texas and California hyper vunrable to attack from Russia and China. America needs to get its head out of it butt, and open its eyes to our external threats from abroad.
now this is interesting I have heard many times that Texas has long age Paid there taxes to become its on its own this may be but the problem in the costs of governing among other things interesting is it not???
This is why we have the Electoral College, I believe it should be taken to the country level to better represent the United States population.
Goes to show republicans don’t want to coexist with democrats simple as that.
ADJUSTING STATELINES is Hogwash. it started sometime around the turn of the century with the populist movement and this came out two or three times since then. There are four major legal hurdles and short of a civil war it ain't going to happen. the last time a major county pulled out of a major state was West Virginia that was a civil war. there's too many hoops to jump through. It's *BS and it's not even original.
Update
2024
2024
2024
I literally saw an RFK ad put up as an ad for this video
This didn't age well in 2024.
Grand interview, encore!
East Oregon is Idaho.
It's time to get rid of the two wings of the same party which gives no option other voting for the lesser of two evils. Why vote for any evil 🤔 why not vote for the greatest good. Jill Stein seems a sane choice.
U R.A BIG CRIMINAL U NEED TO GO. TO PRISON U R MAKING EVERYONE IN THE US R GETTING MAD
You’ve forgot the purple states
Wrong. For a time Justin Amash was a libertarian in the house.
End Qualified immunity! They should be held accountable for abusing citizens...
Tuck frump! Vote blue 💙
So sad. Trump is not fit to lead anything or anyone. 😤
America has through much of its history accepted immigrants. The recent efforts by the right wing to demonize immigrants has been counterproductive. It has been the free acceptance of immigrants, Mexicans, Canadians, Irish, Chinese, Moslem, Jewish, that has allowed America to not just survive but thrive and remain a superpower.
Biden continues to overcome a really bad stammer!
What a fool to advertise a test that primary children. It probably was easy, it’s for little children.
Trump is right about one thing and that’s when he said most of the people he was speaking to probably will have a hard time passing it. 😂😂😂