1:50:53 I think Chomsky can’t stand this “chick” 😂😂😂.
@imagine9033Күн бұрын
What do the other states do differently than the NATO states. If you piss against the wind in NATO countries, you get to feel the tolerance of these states. How is that different from Iran or Iraq? 1:47:00
@imagine9033Күн бұрын
1:44:11 that “chick” almost mounted Chomsky 😂😂😂
@imagine9033Күн бұрын
1:22:10 global warming. 😂😂😂😂
@WalterFRC3 күн бұрын
Chomsky comes in at 19:44
@user-eg8hb8xt3j5 күн бұрын
Pretentious idiots . He once crossed a street …he once read a book …shut up
@ahmed4957Ай бұрын
Mr. Chomsky, you are wrong. Morocco did NOT invade western Sahara. Morocco regained its occupied land peacefully from Spain. Do your homework and read history. As a linguist, I respect your theory, but I was really surprised to hear you giving some wrong facts about Morocco. There is obviously an ideology behind your statement vis a vis Morocco, a country with deep roots in history. It's too bad it's coming from you. Ahmed from Toronto
@cheaze692 ай бұрын
Is this same Hart House that used to have a gun range????
@jamespickens30862 ай бұрын
lot of good babbling here say
@jamespickens30862 ай бұрын
lawful rights Maxim Sacrifice is the measure of credibility. one who is not willing to swear on oath on ( PERSIONAL) commercial liability for the truth of his statement and legitimacy of his actions has no basis to assert claims or charges and forfeits all credibility. and no to claim of authority
@robyn-ky1dz2 ай бұрын
And a few people come after me. Only a few no one has ever mentioned Chomskie 😂😂. I suppose we ALL knew when to get in our lanes 😂😂
@robyn-ky1dz2 ай бұрын
Chomskie brilliant.
@robyn-ky1dz2 ай бұрын
Always up for anyone who agrees with me 😂😂
@lesly91012 ай бұрын
A lot of introduction for someone who allegedly is in the ranks of an Aristoteles or Descartes...! Reminds me very mouch of a sectarian rally!
@KatyYoder-cq1kc3 ай бұрын
Cease and desist on malicious use of ai, all militia, all imperialist, communist. We are not your property!
@SaintFluffySnow3 ай бұрын
0:20:00
@shawnburnham13 ай бұрын
18:00
@marcellowoodford40483 ай бұрын
I just Ask - Why do these Great people Not LEAD us in Office instead of being Great Voices -albeit on the Side-lines? ! x M
@rayrocher68873 ай бұрын
Thanks for trying Noam, however, the government is the worse, corporate office business, Ford , Carnegie built USA business, not Marcy tweed, nor Hillary Clinton, she is psycho, wanted queen, Kings order people around, business has to sell
@user-cg1qq2er8x4 ай бұрын
Noah is such a nothing.
@mikeloomin24244 ай бұрын
yeah i'll just keep calling it Toronto
@danielmaloney9464 ай бұрын
Funny to hear her say that the only network that will talk to him is Fox News, but because it is Fox news, they must have sinister motives for doing so...and then she goes on about skepticism - of conservatives...blindspot?? As a Canadian, I can honestly say there is no less politically -savvy country on earth than Canada.
@danielmaloney9464 ай бұрын
Was met with hostility when he switched to politics? I wonder why. Could it be that he is an expert in the field of linguistics and not politics?:)
@thefinestsake16604 ай бұрын
As Professor Nom Chompsky said "Those who control the economic life of a country also tend to have overwhelming influince over state policy" -This can be summed up as "Those who control the economy can control the policy." This is similar to how Frank Herbert said "He who controls the spice, controls the universe." -Which, in turn, can, of course, most certainly be summed up as "Rich people got power." -As the professor implied, it can be simply summed up by the American elementary school adage "Money is power." Mathematically that is easily expressed as "m=p." This more importantly elucidates that since time is money and money is power, then power is time (t=m=p). This is a matter of transitive property. Since it is known that Money is fiat and Time is a subjective hallucination produced by the consciousness of one's ability to change and said effects of change, one must conclude that Power too is an illususory fiat- a hallucination of grandeur- a futile legacy in the face of a boundless yawning eternity full of all creation and destruction, forever and ever. 🍃 Or that's the gist of it.🌈⭐️
@TheEmmef4 ай бұрын
Great talk! I wish we would see this level of intellect in the media or politics. They all look like angry, rich children now.
@JAMAICADOCK4 ай бұрын
Basically we're no longer up for the revolution, like the left in other western countries threatened by fascism, we'd sooner die than fight. Because the western left is humanitarian, feminine, liberal and generally pacifist. Which one might argue is the superior leftism rather than the bloody revolutionary tumult of the French and Russian revolutions. but there comes crunch times in history wherein taking the high road is just not gonna work. Such as the US Civil War and the fight against fascism, sometimes there's no way to straighten things out peacefully and democratically. We could be approaching one of those crunch points in the very near future, But I'd say if the US is threatened by fascism, it would be a mistake to keep the country together. Let the Red States go their own way and then apply pressure from the outside, The Blue States can then look to form a new progressive union, including Latin America and Canada. In fact progressive leaning states have to come together globally to see off this new rightist menace. The nightmare scenario is, in trying to keep America together, the Right takes all of America, If the entirety of America falls to fascism, the world is truly fried.
@wyz98154 ай бұрын
with all the anti-human crimes that America committed and with all the lies manufactured before US attacked a country that didn't follow their will, still most western people buy into all the BS propaganda of US media. Now China become the biggest enemy of US, and see how many people swallow all those brainless lies and demonizing rhetoric against China uncritically!
@allrise30564 ай бұрын
"...like myself..." At a Linguistics talk with Noam Chomsky?
@scotthullinger46844 ай бұрын
Conservatism BUILDS society - The opposite of conservatism DESTROYS society. Call it what you wish. It's all the same in some fashion - - Liberals - Leftists - Socialists - Marxists - Communists
@gnupph5 ай бұрын
I swear, unless I explicitly search for his name on KZread I’ve never seen YT recommending Chomsky to me, especially this video.
@user-btmbangalore5 ай бұрын
I have fun reading comments in response to Chomsky's talks and lectures. Many are well read people, not all of them. I read a comment by one techie senior manager who thinks his long hours and long yeras of work entitled him to luxuries, some fame and excesses he has earned. He was greatly upset that an academic like Chomsky leading a 'competitively' far easier life gets to lecture on unfair practices of businesses, tries to preach ethics to them. He is completely frustrated that a guy like Chomsky could take away his stature as well his rewards. It is a bit nightmarish if you could see his point of view. It is funny in the sense that he could never ever comprehend the relevance of Chomsky, the guy has little idea we (academics) brought down kings who thought of themselves as irreplaceable, had everyone in awe, had bigger wealth than he could imagine. Some people are kids, his mathematics and code may be of significance, he best realize the code we write is beyond him or his team. 😅😅😅😅
@brcarter11115 ай бұрын
It is said companies like Amazon and Walmart cannot give their employees liveable wages because the business operates on razor-thin profit margins. Bullsh*t. From October 31 2022 to October 2023, Walmart's profit was $155,000,000,000 and the business has 1,600,000 employees. They could give every single employee an additional $31,250 dollars a year and still net over 105 billion in profits without increasing their prices at all.
@turbanheadless5 ай бұрын
bois, we might all look different. but we all live on the same planet and want and deserve the same things, we have to work together to overcome this bullshit of pepople
@majorblazer90555 ай бұрын
🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation: 00:04 🏛️ *The event starts with housekeeping requests, emphasizing turning off electronic devices and a photography ban.* 02:21 🎓 *Har House emphasizes its commitment to diverse programming and critical discourse, hosting events like today's lecture to engage in vital conversations.* 04:50 🗣️ *Linda McQu introduces Noam Chomsky, highlighting his impact as a prolific intellectual and critic of power, emphasizing his challenge to mainstream narratives.* 19:29 🌐 *Linda McQu praises Chomsky for exposing those in power, criticizing the elites, and speaking truth to power in the public interest.* 20:03 💼 *Noam Chomsky begins his talk, discussing the United States' unique significance globally and the influence of corporate interests on state policies.* 30:03 🏛️ *The Senate, according to Madison, was designed to represent the wealthier class and protect the minority of the opulent against the majority.* 32:31 💼 *In today's richest country, 20% qualify for food stamps, and real unemployment is at Great Depression levels. Economic conditions are worse for many than in the past.* 35:13 🔄 *Goldman Sachs, a key player in the crisis, benefits from government bailouts, demonstrates systemic risk ignorance, and is immune to the consequences of risky transactions.* 36:08 🌍 *Western powers, especially the U.S., resist authentic democracy in the Arab world to maintain their interests, despite public opinion in these regions.* 43:32 🔄 *Historical parallels between early 19th-century U.S. and Egypt illustrate how power dynamics and economic development influence global disparities.* 01:00:10 🌐 *Financial speculation and growth of financial institutions surged after dismantling regulations 40 years ago.* 01:01:00 💰 *Financial institutions' profits came from harmful and socially useless manipulations, contributing to inequality.* 01:02:48 📉 *State-corporate policies over 30 years fueled wealth concentration, resulting in unprecedented inequality.* 01:04:13 📈 *Tax policies shifted since around 1980, benefiting the super-rich, eroding earlier redistributive mechanisms.* 01:10:36 🏦 *Social Security defunding aims to privatize, benefiting investors, but risks undermining social solidarity.* 01:27:28 🌐 *Goldstone did not retract the report; he expressed a hypothetical change based on new information but did not alter the report's content.* 01:30:57 🤔 *The central issue in the Gaza conflict was whether there was a right to use force, not merely the right to self-defense.* 01:34:28 💸 *Shift in university funding, from public support to tuition, creates debt burden for students, shaping career choices and limiting public education.* 01:43:51 🇮🇷 *The "Iranian threat" is often overstated; official reports indicate low military threat, defensive strategy, and efforts to influence neighboring countries.* 01:49:32 🌐 *Chomsky views Hitchens and Harris as defending a state religion, supporting state violence in the name of secularism.* 01:53:00 🧠 *Noam Chomsky discusses morality and its connection to innate structures, drawing on the views of empiricists like David Hume.* 01:56:48 💼 *Chomsky advocates for short-term solutions like financial reform, citing the success of New Deal-type regulations and the need for reasonable health reform.* 01:59:29 📚 *Chomsky shares thoughts on semiotics as a broad field, expressing skepticism about its unity but noting specific interesting aspects like linguistics and animal communication.* 02:00:50 👏 *Chomsky reflects on past events and acknowledges contributions from institutions like Hart House in fostering discussions against the Vietnam War.* Made with HARPA AI
@JohnChampagne5 ай бұрын
ANYONE who is concerned about exploitation of workers may want to join a call for equal sharing of natural wealth. If people have a modest income separate from work income, they will have more latitude to leave any employment situation that does not appeal to them for whatever reason. If we charge high fees to industries that emit pollution, deplete resources or disturb / destroy wildlife habitat (as high as random polls say is appropriate for bringing impacts into line with what most people think is acceptable), the money collected would represent the value to the human economy of natural wealth. This is wealth made by natural processes, not human effort. It should be shared equally. The market would be more honest in representing costs. Profit would align with sustainability. It would be more fair. Every person (or every adult) would have the financial wherewithal to provide for their basic needs. No one would be threatened with becoming destitute upon leaving a job or decline a job offer.
@joelex79665 ай бұрын
Niam would very much prefer state sanctioned activities . He is a FUKN commie.
@theloniousMac5 ай бұрын
Shhhhh Noam. It will be over soon. While you’ve been trying to drag the wealthy down, capitalism has pulled countless families and individuals out of poverty. So relax. Go quietly.
@Archibald453 ай бұрын
Out of poverty? The majority is two paychecks away from homelessness. It’s all a giant bubble because of usury-debt based monetary system.
@louisesumrell63315 ай бұрын
You ninny!😂 The media doesn't call out the government because they are employed by the corporate elite who also own the government.
@aamir-hk8px5 ай бұрын
There are still good voices that are ready to side with truth and justice against all odds.
@marcosglazer82566 ай бұрын
Gostei da palestra, por favor com enfizema algo colateral?
@burhanahmed87676 ай бұрын
5 minutes into listening to this guy, a lot of world starts to make sense. Wish he would be an immortal.
@yougod72535 ай бұрын
He is part of the Cabal Beware. In reality he will lead you over the cliff because of his advanced age now.
@julir37546 ай бұрын
Great introduction. Very different, outside the usual protocols.
@imteazauck6 ай бұрын
😮
@jamoin43106 ай бұрын
I hate this self hating Jew more for every video more i get recommended from this idiot.
@alexpuerto3106 ай бұрын
YOU ARE NOT GOING TO HAVE PEACE, CAUSE IF YOU DO, THE ARM PRODUCERS WILL GO BANKRUPT... AND THEY FEEL THEY ARE THE GODS INDISPENSABLE TO THEIR SUBJECTS, YOU... SO GET RID OF YOUR GODS.
@mieterbeiratkopenhagenhof9206 ай бұрын
admireable, distinkt, radical and consequent, full scale transparent. WHOW!
@EricWarrenStruble6 ай бұрын
This is so relevant today
@ilmarinenvogel57126 ай бұрын
Let the speaker speak
@davemacnicol84046 ай бұрын
Hes smart but too smart. They want to defund SS because its managed horribly. Which he just admitted would be more sustainable under private management. And public schooling is the same but for a different reason. He neglects to mention the elites dont want to privatize it, they want to operate at the lowest tier, creating a population who doesnt think critically and cant succeed, therefore needing to vote for those who would provide government assistance. Either he is sincerely naive or cunning. Its not the former..
Пікірлер
1:51:29 what is that stupid b…… doing there?
1:50:53 I think Chomsky can’t stand this “chick” 😂😂😂.
What do the other states do differently than the NATO states. If you piss against the wind in NATO countries, you get to feel the tolerance of these states. How is that different from Iran or Iraq? 1:47:00
1:44:11 that “chick” almost mounted Chomsky 😂😂😂
1:22:10 global warming. 😂😂😂😂
Chomsky comes in at 19:44
Pretentious idiots . He once crossed a street …he once read a book …shut up
Mr. Chomsky, you are wrong. Morocco did NOT invade western Sahara. Morocco regained its occupied land peacefully from Spain. Do your homework and read history. As a linguist, I respect your theory, but I was really surprised to hear you giving some wrong facts about Morocco. There is obviously an ideology behind your statement vis a vis Morocco, a country with deep roots in history. It's too bad it's coming from you. Ahmed from Toronto
Is this same Hart House that used to have a gun range????
lot of good babbling here say
lawful rights Maxim Sacrifice is the measure of credibility. one who is not willing to swear on oath on ( PERSIONAL) commercial liability for the truth of his statement and legitimacy of his actions has no basis to assert claims or charges and forfeits all credibility. and no to claim of authority
And a few people come after me. Only a few no one has ever mentioned Chomskie 😂😂. I suppose we ALL knew when to get in our lanes 😂😂
Chomskie brilliant.
Always up for anyone who agrees with me 😂😂
A lot of introduction for someone who allegedly is in the ranks of an Aristoteles or Descartes...! Reminds me very mouch of a sectarian rally!
Cease and desist on malicious use of ai, all militia, all imperialist, communist. We are not your property!
0:20:00
18:00
I just Ask - Why do these Great people Not LEAD us in Office instead of being Great Voices -albeit on the Side-lines? ! x M
Thanks for trying Noam, however, the government is the worse, corporate office business, Ford , Carnegie built USA business, not Marcy tweed, nor Hillary Clinton, she is psycho, wanted queen, Kings order people around, business has to sell
Noah is such a nothing.
yeah i'll just keep calling it Toronto
Funny to hear her say that the only network that will talk to him is Fox News, but because it is Fox news, they must have sinister motives for doing so...and then she goes on about skepticism - of conservatives...blindspot?? As a Canadian, I can honestly say there is no less politically -savvy country on earth than Canada.
Was met with hostility when he switched to politics? I wonder why. Could it be that he is an expert in the field of linguistics and not politics?:)
As Professor Nom Chompsky said "Those who control the economic life of a country also tend to have overwhelming influince over state policy" -This can be summed up as "Those who control the economy can control the policy." This is similar to how Frank Herbert said "He who controls the spice, controls the universe." -Which, in turn, can, of course, most certainly be summed up as "Rich people got power." -As the professor implied, it can be simply summed up by the American elementary school adage "Money is power." Mathematically that is easily expressed as "m=p." This more importantly elucidates that since time is money and money is power, then power is time (t=m=p). This is a matter of transitive property. Since it is known that Money is fiat and Time is a subjective hallucination produced by the consciousness of one's ability to change and said effects of change, one must conclude that Power too is an illususory fiat- a hallucination of grandeur- a futile legacy in the face of a boundless yawning eternity full of all creation and destruction, forever and ever. 🍃 Or that's the gist of it.🌈⭐️
Great talk! I wish we would see this level of intellect in the media or politics. They all look like angry, rich children now.
Basically we're no longer up for the revolution, like the left in other western countries threatened by fascism, we'd sooner die than fight. Because the western left is humanitarian, feminine, liberal and generally pacifist. Which one might argue is the superior leftism rather than the bloody revolutionary tumult of the French and Russian revolutions. but there comes crunch times in history wherein taking the high road is just not gonna work. Such as the US Civil War and the fight against fascism, sometimes there's no way to straighten things out peacefully and democratically. We could be approaching one of those crunch points in the very near future, But I'd say if the US is threatened by fascism, it would be a mistake to keep the country together. Let the Red States go their own way and then apply pressure from the outside, The Blue States can then look to form a new progressive union, including Latin America and Canada. In fact progressive leaning states have to come together globally to see off this new rightist menace. The nightmare scenario is, in trying to keep America together, the Right takes all of America, If the entirety of America falls to fascism, the world is truly fried.
with all the anti-human crimes that America committed and with all the lies manufactured before US attacked a country that didn't follow their will, still most western people buy into all the BS propaganda of US media. Now China become the biggest enemy of US, and see how many people swallow all those brainless lies and demonizing rhetoric against China uncritically!
"...like myself..." At a Linguistics talk with Noam Chomsky?
Conservatism BUILDS society - The opposite of conservatism DESTROYS society. Call it what you wish. It's all the same in some fashion - - Liberals - Leftists - Socialists - Marxists - Communists
I swear, unless I explicitly search for his name on KZread I’ve never seen YT recommending Chomsky to me, especially this video.
I have fun reading comments in response to Chomsky's talks and lectures. Many are well read people, not all of them. I read a comment by one techie senior manager who thinks his long hours and long yeras of work entitled him to luxuries, some fame and excesses he has earned. He was greatly upset that an academic like Chomsky leading a 'competitively' far easier life gets to lecture on unfair practices of businesses, tries to preach ethics to them. He is completely frustrated that a guy like Chomsky could take away his stature as well his rewards. It is a bit nightmarish if you could see his point of view. It is funny in the sense that he could never ever comprehend the relevance of Chomsky, the guy has little idea we (academics) brought down kings who thought of themselves as irreplaceable, had everyone in awe, had bigger wealth than he could imagine. Some people are kids, his mathematics and code may be of significance, he best realize the code we write is beyond him or his team. 😅😅😅😅
It is said companies like Amazon and Walmart cannot give their employees liveable wages because the business operates on razor-thin profit margins. Bullsh*t. From October 31 2022 to October 2023, Walmart's profit was $155,000,000,000 and the business has 1,600,000 employees. They could give every single employee an additional $31,250 dollars a year and still net over 105 billion in profits without increasing their prices at all.
bois, we might all look different. but we all live on the same planet and want and deserve the same things, we have to work together to overcome this bullshit of pepople
🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation: 00:04 🏛️ *The event starts with housekeeping requests, emphasizing turning off electronic devices and a photography ban.* 02:21 🎓 *Har House emphasizes its commitment to diverse programming and critical discourse, hosting events like today's lecture to engage in vital conversations.* 04:50 🗣️ *Linda McQu introduces Noam Chomsky, highlighting his impact as a prolific intellectual and critic of power, emphasizing his challenge to mainstream narratives.* 19:29 🌐 *Linda McQu praises Chomsky for exposing those in power, criticizing the elites, and speaking truth to power in the public interest.* 20:03 💼 *Noam Chomsky begins his talk, discussing the United States' unique significance globally and the influence of corporate interests on state policies.* 30:03 🏛️ *The Senate, according to Madison, was designed to represent the wealthier class and protect the minority of the opulent against the majority.* 32:31 💼 *In today's richest country, 20% qualify for food stamps, and real unemployment is at Great Depression levels. Economic conditions are worse for many than in the past.* 35:13 🔄 *Goldman Sachs, a key player in the crisis, benefits from government bailouts, demonstrates systemic risk ignorance, and is immune to the consequences of risky transactions.* 36:08 🌍 *Western powers, especially the U.S., resist authentic democracy in the Arab world to maintain their interests, despite public opinion in these regions.* 43:32 🔄 *Historical parallels between early 19th-century U.S. and Egypt illustrate how power dynamics and economic development influence global disparities.* 01:00:10 🌐 *Financial speculation and growth of financial institutions surged after dismantling regulations 40 years ago.* 01:01:00 💰 *Financial institutions' profits came from harmful and socially useless manipulations, contributing to inequality.* 01:02:48 📉 *State-corporate policies over 30 years fueled wealth concentration, resulting in unprecedented inequality.* 01:04:13 📈 *Tax policies shifted since around 1980, benefiting the super-rich, eroding earlier redistributive mechanisms.* 01:10:36 🏦 *Social Security defunding aims to privatize, benefiting investors, but risks undermining social solidarity.* 01:27:28 🌐 *Goldstone did not retract the report; he expressed a hypothetical change based on new information but did not alter the report's content.* 01:30:57 🤔 *The central issue in the Gaza conflict was whether there was a right to use force, not merely the right to self-defense.* 01:34:28 💸 *Shift in university funding, from public support to tuition, creates debt burden for students, shaping career choices and limiting public education.* 01:43:51 🇮🇷 *The "Iranian threat" is often overstated; official reports indicate low military threat, defensive strategy, and efforts to influence neighboring countries.* 01:49:32 🌐 *Chomsky views Hitchens and Harris as defending a state religion, supporting state violence in the name of secularism.* 01:53:00 🧠 *Noam Chomsky discusses morality and its connection to innate structures, drawing on the views of empiricists like David Hume.* 01:56:48 💼 *Chomsky advocates for short-term solutions like financial reform, citing the success of New Deal-type regulations and the need for reasonable health reform.* 01:59:29 📚 *Chomsky shares thoughts on semiotics as a broad field, expressing skepticism about its unity but noting specific interesting aspects like linguistics and animal communication.* 02:00:50 👏 *Chomsky reflects on past events and acknowledges contributions from institutions like Hart House in fostering discussions against the Vietnam War.* Made with HARPA AI
ANYONE who is concerned about exploitation of workers may want to join a call for equal sharing of natural wealth. If people have a modest income separate from work income, they will have more latitude to leave any employment situation that does not appeal to them for whatever reason. If we charge high fees to industries that emit pollution, deplete resources or disturb / destroy wildlife habitat (as high as random polls say is appropriate for bringing impacts into line with what most people think is acceptable), the money collected would represent the value to the human economy of natural wealth. This is wealth made by natural processes, not human effort. It should be shared equally. The market would be more honest in representing costs. Profit would align with sustainability. It would be more fair. Every person (or every adult) would have the financial wherewithal to provide for their basic needs. No one would be threatened with becoming destitute upon leaving a job or decline a job offer.
Niam would very much prefer state sanctioned activities . He is a FUKN commie.
Shhhhh Noam. It will be over soon. While you’ve been trying to drag the wealthy down, capitalism has pulled countless families and individuals out of poverty. So relax. Go quietly.
Out of poverty? The majority is two paychecks away from homelessness. It’s all a giant bubble because of usury-debt based monetary system.
You ninny!😂 The media doesn't call out the government because they are employed by the corporate elite who also own the government.
There are still good voices that are ready to side with truth and justice against all odds.
Gostei da palestra, por favor com enfizema algo colateral?
5 minutes into listening to this guy, a lot of world starts to make sense. Wish he would be an immortal.
He is part of the Cabal Beware. In reality he will lead you over the cliff because of his advanced age now.
Great introduction. Very different, outside the usual protocols.
😮
I hate this self hating Jew more for every video more i get recommended from this idiot.
YOU ARE NOT GOING TO HAVE PEACE, CAUSE IF YOU DO, THE ARM PRODUCERS WILL GO BANKRUPT... AND THEY FEEL THEY ARE THE GODS INDISPENSABLE TO THEIR SUBJECTS, YOU... SO GET RID OF YOUR GODS.
admireable, distinkt, radical and consequent, full scale transparent. WHOW!
This is so relevant today
Let the speaker speak
Hes smart but too smart. They want to defund SS because its managed horribly. Which he just admitted would be more sustainable under private management. And public schooling is the same but for a different reason. He neglects to mention the elites dont want to privatize it, they want to operate at the lowest tier, creating a population who doesnt think critically and cant succeed, therefore needing to vote for those who would provide government assistance. Either he is sincerely naive or cunning. Its not the former..