At GolfBays we try and give you the latest impartial news, reviews and information regarding golf simulators, so you can decide what equipment best suits yours needs.
Thanks for this video . Big discrepancy on new driver I bought for me at Golf Galaxy on Track Man 4- vs GC3 - 27 yard differential at its worst and average of 10+ yards on 10 shots. I call GGalaxy and asked if they juiced the Trackman with attitude but they said and showed me “no”, and even allowed me to bring the GC3-and hit some more to compare the two basically recreating this video. To be fair though-GC3 was within 3 yards +/- on PW and 8 Iron shots and has been accurate with all irons really. Also there’s the fact that : GC3 - $7k Trackman 4 -$22k so you get what you pay for but don’t trust driver data …period.
@petrusclassic20 күн бұрын
Any solution to reduce the distance between the screen and the wall? Maybe one mattress on the back ?
@michaelbentley574223 күн бұрын
Have you compared the Flightscope X3 with the Mevo+ Pro?
@europeanprogolftour3628Ай бұрын
the spin rates on the GC 3 are very suspect? 620 on the toe shot and on the push shot and then the one you hit with a heel TM was 3273 , which is probably correct and then showed only 1840 on GC3. Too bad the GC3 doesn't show strike location. Be great if you could test them outside to see the real flight. Great work and good swing!
@lauraharley4368Ай бұрын
Hey there, Looks amazing and such great tips. Can I please ask how you fix your padding to the side walls? What kind of hardware are you using for that?
@privateusername2222Ай бұрын
What’s consensus on the club data with ST+? I worry that inaccurate club data is worse than no data, especially for someone using this to work on their swing…
@crazyhands911.2 ай бұрын
what distance from hitting area to screen are you working with, and distance from hit to mevo+?
@robertreilly35042 ай бұрын
Just buy a ST+ and save money. TM also has a delay in shot to show and GC3 doesn’t seem any more accurate.
@oscarrice57872 ай бұрын
Promo`SM 🙏
@ryanuhazie2 ай бұрын
Which one would be better for hitting into a net in the backyard? Or even the rapsodo MLM (not the 2pro). ? Thanks!
@nickhulsing97642 ай бұрын
Your video confirmed what I am seeing. When I go to my pro for a lesson, we are working on flattening and club path. The trakman path data is far more accurate than Skytrak+. With my ST+, path will read 4 to 6 degrees in-to-out. But when I hit on Trakman, I'm lucky to register a 3 degree in-to-out. So I think ST+ is very good for $3,000 but if you happen to need very accurate club face/path data, it is lacking
@glennmartin70992 ай бұрын
At 7:15 how do you get the ball flight to switch to the landing zone view halfway through the flight? That was super cool!
@Kaspgolf3 ай бұрын
I thought it came out in 2019?
@nickhulsing97643 ай бұрын
How far away from the screen is your Skytrak+ setup? I think I’m under the misconception that it needs to be further back than it really does.
@breeze7873 ай бұрын
Looks very nice. My setup looks genuinely home made.
@nellynelson93874 ай бұрын
Would love to see a comparison on club path data. I had a lesson the other day on a trackman and trackman had me in to out 2 degrees and gc3 had me out to in or neutral. I am over the top at times so gc3 seems more likely correct?? And with regards to spin on trackman if its italicised got to.take with a pinch salt. Even though low spin high launch on foresight is over achieving. Rct test would be great too. Thanks
@MichaelSurrento4 ай бұрын
Great comparison…how far from ball to screen are you set up with SkyTrak?
@collin282825 ай бұрын
Awesome video, thank you for posting this. Which device would you recommend for an indoor garage setup? I currently have the Garmin r10 and it struggles inside, fails to pick up a lot of shots, wondering if the Rapsodo would be an upgrade. Thanks!
@eddycangolf5 ай бұрын
Great and efficient swing. Did you purposely buy the spot light for Trackman? Also, did you notice a difference in ball speed/club speed without the spotlight for Trackman?
@shawnkovlaske28455 ай бұрын
So I'm building a garage in spring and putting in a golf simulator, that Grey padding on the side shaped Like a diamond!!!! Where can I find that.... great video you answered all my questions
@arpanbirjudge72425 ай бұрын
HI, just an off topic question. I'm building a home simulator and I really like how you have designed the enclosure walls. Do you mind sharing what size foam thickness is used in the enclosure and is it leather over it? Thanks
@user-yv7ns4eb9w6 ай бұрын
Where is part 2 ?
@dexbackcountry82056 ай бұрын
I have some thoughts about your comparison. I have trouble with the discrepancies between the two devices. First of all I would appreciate more discussion about the setup of each device. Are both devices level and where are they positioned? Are they both calibrated? Secondly have you tried evaluating two trackmans against each other to see if there are discrepancies between them. Likewise for for the Skytrak. This would give some reassurance to their consistency. Thirdly, can you tack a larger sample of shots and only compare shots with the same swing speeds. Then take an average and then compare. I know I’m being particular here, however your comparison is important to me in if intend to invest in one of these devices.
@guillaumesg50016 ай бұрын
Hi, very instructive video. Thanks. What would be the distance remaining from the steel bar to the border of the screen when tightening with these bungee balls ?
@golfbaysofficial6 ай бұрын
it would be around 10cm with the bungee stretch
@BatmanTC6 ай бұрын
9:05 nah, I’d argue the rapsodo was still more accurate on the driver bc the first 2 numbers were very close, obviously a misread on the 3rd, while the carmín was all over the place on all 3 shots
@waldorf94456 ай бұрын
Do you intend to do this test again but with RCT balls? They make a huge difference to accuracy for both these launch monitors so would be interesting to see
@blackstaticband6 ай бұрын
did you use the silver dots on the balls when you did this test? My Mevo+ worked best with them on the balls indoors
@user-sz3vl1mx9g6 ай бұрын
I will do your 500sub what you will gove me i am from india
@Robert_austia6 ай бұрын
😂😂 Christmas == waste of money 💰 Ban Christmas
@xThePHINIXx6 ай бұрын
Is that a man sized Minecraft screen? I need one. Idc I need one. Edit : for anyone wondering I do realise it's a projector
@AD-jc9sj6 ай бұрын
Brilliant video. Would like to see the Garmin r10 comparison with them both! Thanks
@cloud47316 ай бұрын
club head speed should be differrent cuz GC reads at the first touch of the ball and the club head, TM measures at the time of maximum compression of the ball. So GC always couple of miles faster. but the ball speeds are very much the same. every unit has its own pros and cons. Good vid cheers!
@HalfCab180_7 ай бұрын
Come on! This clearly shows the limitation of TM indoors. You did not once mention the real disparity between the spin rates on that 54 wedge. Almost 2000 backspin off. That is a huge difference. The italics on the TM number means it is estimating the spin - i.e. guessing. Huge weakness of TM indoors regarding spin and spin axis. The difference in carry on the driver has to due in part from Foresight's notorious "low spin boost" on driver. Anything lower than 2200 spin, Foresight gives a boost which is not seen in real life.
@firstname20726 ай бұрын
It actually shows to me how inaccurate gc3 can be more than the limitations of trackman. You’re telling me he carried 350 yard drives? 😂 trackman seemed to be much more realistic.
@oliverbaddeley92737 ай бұрын
Yes interesting to see toe and heel data with the gc3 compared to trackman with the driver
@stevenjakub7 ай бұрын
So glad I found this video. Immediately subscribed! You answered a lot of my questions regarding how to get that professional finish hiding a DIY mounted screen. One question I still have is how do you have the upholstered pieces mounted to side walls?
@BestGolfer-sj4np7 ай бұрын
Very accurate and similar data with only 50yds of carry difference on a driver😂
@schop7 ай бұрын
Looks great! How much space do you leave behind the screen?
@golfbaysofficial7 ай бұрын
30 cm 👍🏼
@rodmarshallpga45717 ай бұрын
Surprised so many KZreadrs do comparison videos whilst not using the recommended balls that the manufacturers specify. Pointless exercise.
@gjrcars58357 ай бұрын
Could you compare the club path and attack angles between Mevo+ and Trackman? would be really appreciated - thanks
@steven-gerrard7 ай бұрын
What was that mis read at the end ? I have a ST+ and constantly get terrible path misreads
@stevenkoutstaal7 ай бұрын
5 yard carry is not a lot for your gap wedge??
@tgcgolf15657 ай бұрын
Looks great , brilliant advice
@davidvaninwegen10157 ай бұрын
Great video! How wide are the mdf padding pieces on the sides to hide the bungees?
@davidvaninwegen10157 ай бұрын
Also, how did you attach the side pieces to hide the bungees. Did you upholster the piece and then attach it to the frame?
@johnlee-eo1qt7 ай бұрын
Great video Harrison,
@golfbaysofficial7 ай бұрын
the MDF padding is 10cm wide, those specific ones in our bays were made with the padding already in them, however you can but the tiles on top of the mdf as well.
@davidvaninwegen10157 ай бұрын
@@golfbaysofficial Thank you! How did you attach that piece to the frame? Did you screw it from the back or glue it to the front? Thanks for your help!
@golfbaysofficial7 ай бұрын
we screw it in from the back
@davidw29347 ай бұрын
How far do you typically hit your 7i? The garmin's numbers were close, but 25 yards further than the MLM2 pro. Noticed the same with driver but not as bad. Overall MLM2 pro seems more accurate.
@fettmund90777 ай бұрын
Pretty sure this video is showing the screen being installed upside down. The top velcro tabs aren’t that long on the top, just the bottom.
@justinjewitt4587 ай бұрын
Could you review the little Mevo at the side of the trackman , mine seems very accurate with every club apart from driver with spin numbers been really high 3000/4500
@theboywonder97 ай бұрын
Just need a spare 5k now! Not really DIY is it? This is a basically a flat pack set up.
@damiensmith83517 ай бұрын
What are your thoughts on the skytrak+ vs the mevo+?
Пікірлер
Thanks for this video . Big discrepancy on new driver I bought for me at Golf Galaxy on Track Man 4- vs GC3 - 27 yard differential at its worst and average of 10+ yards on 10 shots. I call GGalaxy and asked if they juiced the Trackman with attitude but they said and showed me “no”, and even allowed me to bring the GC3-and hit some more to compare the two basically recreating this video. To be fair though-GC3 was within 3 yards +/- on PW and 8 Iron shots and has been accurate with all irons really. Also there’s the fact that : GC3 - $7k Trackman 4 -$22k so you get what you pay for but don’t trust driver data …period.
Any solution to reduce the distance between the screen and the wall? Maybe one mattress on the back ?
Have you compared the Flightscope X3 with the Mevo+ Pro?
the spin rates on the GC 3 are very suspect? 620 on the toe shot and on the push shot and then the one you hit with a heel TM was 3273 , which is probably correct and then showed only 1840 on GC3. Too bad the GC3 doesn't show strike location. Be great if you could test them outside to see the real flight. Great work and good swing!
Hey there, Looks amazing and such great tips. Can I please ask how you fix your padding to the side walls? What kind of hardware are you using for that?
What’s consensus on the club data with ST+? I worry that inaccurate club data is worse than no data, especially for someone using this to work on their swing…
what distance from hitting area to screen are you working with, and distance from hit to mevo+?
Just buy a ST+ and save money. TM also has a delay in shot to show and GC3 doesn’t seem any more accurate.
Promo`SM 🙏
Which one would be better for hitting into a net in the backyard? Or even the rapsodo MLM (not the 2pro). ? Thanks!
Your video confirmed what I am seeing. When I go to my pro for a lesson, we are working on flattening and club path. The trakman path data is far more accurate than Skytrak+. With my ST+, path will read 4 to 6 degrees in-to-out. But when I hit on Trakman, I'm lucky to register a 3 degree in-to-out. So I think ST+ is very good for $3,000 but if you happen to need very accurate club face/path data, it is lacking
At 7:15 how do you get the ball flight to switch to the landing zone view halfway through the flight? That was super cool!
I thought it came out in 2019?
How far away from the screen is your Skytrak+ setup? I think I’m under the misconception that it needs to be further back than it really does.
Looks very nice. My setup looks genuinely home made.
Would love to see a comparison on club path data. I had a lesson the other day on a trackman and trackman had me in to out 2 degrees and gc3 had me out to in or neutral. I am over the top at times so gc3 seems more likely correct?? And with regards to spin on trackman if its italicised got to.take with a pinch salt. Even though low spin high launch on foresight is over achieving. Rct test would be great too. Thanks
Great comparison…how far from ball to screen are you set up with SkyTrak?
Awesome video, thank you for posting this. Which device would you recommend for an indoor garage setup? I currently have the Garmin r10 and it struggles inside, fails to pick up a lot of shots, wondering if the Rapsodo would be an upgrade. Thanks!
Great and efficient swing. Did you purposely buy the spot light for Trackman? Also, did you notice a difference in ball speed/club speed without the spotlight for Trackman?
So I'm building a garage in spring and putting in a golf simulator, that Grey padding on the side shaped Like a diamond!!!! Where can I find that.... great video you answered all my questions
HI, just an off topic question. I'm building a home simulator and I really like how you have designed the enclosure walls. Do you mind sharing what size foam thickness is used in the enclosure and is it leather over it? Thanks
Where is part 2 ?
I have some thoughts about your comparison. I have trouble with the discrepancies between the two devices. First of all I would appreciate more discussion about the setup of each device. Are both devices level and where are they positioned? Are they both calibrated? Secondly have you tried evaluating two trackmans against each other to see if there are discrepancies between them. Likewise for for the Skytrak. This would give some reassurance to their consistency. Thirdly, can you tack a larger sample of shots and only compare shots with the same swing speeds. Then take an average and then compare. I know I’m being particular here, however your comparison is important to me in if intend to invest in one of these devices.
Hi, very instructive video. Thanks. What would be the distance remaining from the steel bar to the border of the screen when tightening with these bungee balls ?
it would be around 10cm with the bungee stretch
9:05 nah, I’d argue the rapsodo was still more accurate on the driver bc the first 2 numbers were very close, obviously a misread on the 3rd, while the carmín was all over the place on all 3 shots
Do you intend to do this test again but with RCT balls? They make a huge difference to accuracy for both these launch monitors so would be interesting to see
did you use the silver dots on the balls when you did this test? My Mevo+ worked best with them on the balls indoors
I will do your 500sub what you will gove me i am from india
😂😂 Christmas == waste of money 💰 Ban Christmas
Is that a man sized Minecraft screen? I need one. Idc I need one. Edit : for anyone wondering I do realise it's a projector
Brilliant video. Would like to see the Garmin r10 comparison with them both! Thanks
club head speed should be differrent cuz GC reads at the first touch of the ball and the club head, TM measures at the time of maximum compression of the ball. So GC always couple of miles faster. but the ball speeds are very much the same. every unit has its own pros and cons. Good vid cheers!
Come on! This clearly shows the limitation of TM indoors. You did not once mention the real disparity between the spin rates on that 54 wedge. Almost 2000 backspin off. That is a huge difference. The italics on the TM number means it is estimating the spin - i.e. guessing. Huge weakness of TM indoors regarding spin and spin axis. The difference in carry on the driver has to due in part from Foresight's notorious "low spin boost" on driver. Anything lower than 2200 spin, Foresight gives a boost which is not seen in real life.
It actually shows to me how inaccurate gc3 can be more than the limitations of trackman. You’re telling me he carried 350 yard drives? 😂 trackman seemed to be much more realistic.
Yes interesting to see toe and heel data with the gc3 compared to trackman with the driver
So glad I found this video. Immediately subscribed! You answered a lot of my questions regarding how to get that professional finish hiding a DIY mounted screen. One question I still have is how do you have the upholstered pieces mounted to side walls?
Very accurate and similar data with only 50yds of carry difference on a driver😂
Looks great! How much space do you leave behind the screen?
30 cm 👍🏼
Surprised so many KZreadrs do comparison videos whilst not using the recommended balls that the manufacturers specify. Pointless exercise.
Could you compare the club path and attack angles between Mevo+ and Trackman? would be really appreciated - thanks
What was that mis read at the end ? I have a ST+ and constantly get terrible path misreads
5 yard carry is not a lot for your gap wedge??
Looks great , brilliant advice
Great video! How wide are the mdf padding pieces on the sides to hide the bungees?
Also, how did you attach the side pieces to hide the bungees. Did you upholster the piece and then attach it to the frame?
Great video Harrison,
the MDF padding is 10cm wide, those specific ones in our bays were made with the padding already in them, however you can but the tiles on top of the mdf as well.
@@golfbaysofficial Thank you! How did you attach that piece to the frame? Did you screw it from the back or glue it to the front? Thanks for your help!
we screw it in from the back
How far do you typically hit your 7i? The garmin's numbers were close, but 25 yards further than the MLM2 pro. Noticed the same with driver but not as bad. Overall MLM2 pro seems more accurate.
Pretty sure this video is showing the screen being installed upside down. The top velcro tabs aren’t that long on the top, just the bottom.
Could you review the little Mevo at the side of the trackman , mine seems very accurate with every club apart from driver with spin numbers been really high 3000/4500
Just need a spare 5k now! Not really DIY is it? This is a basically a flat pack set up.
What are your thoughts on the skytrak+ vs the mevo+?
What size sim box is this in the video?
Very nice... Thx!