For SPL and keeping stuff cool this is a brilliant idea. Please put a metal shroud around her and never be in the path. Rotational force is huge (ruffly the mass triples when spinning), got keep you alive and well to see further advances! Been watching since the start, keep it pounding!!
@nathanbulle57822 сағат бұрын
@@stopdusty420 If I die to a rotary sub I will consider that a death of dignity!
@ROY-yz9lb5 сағат бұрын
if possible, you can add rubber washers or sleeves around the screws of all the moving parts, it may reduce mechanical noises and try to reduce the weight of those moving parts, which are moving linearly to create bass. I know this will mostly be used for Low-frequency bass, but why not make it more efficient... keep it up, brother ...
@user-vr5cq7fc6d20 сағат бұрын
Highest frequency is?
@burak138220 сағат бұрын
If we're talking about subwoofers, we wanna know the lowest
@nathanbulle5782Күн бұрын
Lowest frequency is 11hz
@creeperhaed126723 сағат бұрын
Damn i gotta build one quick
@zane812Күн бұрын
Lows around 15 hz?
@nathanbulle5782Күн бұрын
@@zane812 lower I think
@nathanbulle5782Күн бұрын
This also sounds really good if you try speeding it up 2x but you have to download it and speed it up manually to increase the pitch as well
@skatebunch3084Күн бұрын
Nice 🦾🦾🦾
@paulosebresos7864Күн бұрын
You should make a tutorial on how to make one, maybe release 3D printing files? I’d really like to make one. Sorry if this is so much to ask.
@nathanbulle5782Күн бұрын
@@paulosebresos7864 I actually did do this. If you look at the other videos on my channel (not very many maybe like 10) you will find a tutorial on how to make one and a link to a Google drive containing all the 3D files
@burak138220 сағат бұрын
@@nathanbulle5782 True. I got 90% inspired by your design, but had to edit all of them to fit my speaker and motor properly. Still sounded like a shit, cus there was a lot of vibrations everyehere 🤣 But it made my final exam ✨👌
@Triangle1234Күн бұрын
Can we get a video of it playing on your rotary sub?
@nathanbulle5782Күн бұрын
@@Triangle1234 yeah of course, but this video will always sound better on your system since it's the original audio
@just__pizza5639Күн бұрын
Can someone explain how this is working/what is Happening in comparison to a normal sub?
@PonletsКүн бұрын
fucking youtube silenced the audio lameee
@user-wp9zz3lf1v2 күн бұрын
That's one bad ass speaker 😮😮
@VentureWelding3 күн бұрын
Play "Mandrazo - Say my name" you'll thank me later 😂
@souvenirshutterphotography40373 күн бұрын
a HouseWoofer
@rufeeen4 күн бұрын
We are going to experience the jump from high/mid/low to high/mid/highlow/lowlow.
@alexbusoni4 күн бұрын
a great way to ventilate the room and dance)))
@Enigmaticpower5 күн бұрын
Теперь сабвуфером можно не только волосы поднимать, но и постричься
@cichrift90655 күн бұрын
Lol you can get more bass and better sound with one 10
@nathanbulle57825 күн бұрын
@@cichrift9065 not at 10 hz lol
@DrewAk495 күн бұрын
So what is the point of this? Car is not vibrating any more than it would with the 15 alone and trunk open. So just wondering what is the point of adding this?
@nathanbulle57825 күн бұрын
@@DrewAk49 these work better in a building
@ctrlaltdel025 күн бұрын
Got a question. Do you compensate torque to keep rpm's constant or let them drop with higher signal amplitude?
@nathanbulle57825 күн бұрын
@@ctrlaltdel02 the torque becomes a little more with higher amplitude but the speed still drops a little
@ctrlaltdel025 күн бұрын
@@nathanbulle5782 what do you use to control how much power is aplied to motor vs signal amplitude. Got a hunch it isn't linear vs frequency and amplitude because two times louder is four times power as far as I remember. So to get constant speed there needs to be waaaay much power aplied to motor at peak of signal amplitude.
@nathanbulle57825 күн бұрын
@@ctrlaltdel02 there are special types of motors that do it better than the one I'm using but those motors are much bigger. Mine kinda does it automatically, it's a brushless skateboard wheel motor
@thomasstegelmann6 күн бұрын
In welcher Richtung wird die Luft geblasen? Wenn dann muss der Subwoofer mit dem Ventilator interagieren.Anstatt die Luft in den Kofferraum zu blasen muss die Luft aus dem Kofferraum herausbeschleunigt werden damit das einen vernünftigen Bassreflexeffekt ergibt. Schon mal was im Gegenlaufprinzip ausprobiert? Wie bei einer Druckschallkanone.
@nathanbulle57826 күн бұрын
Rotierende Subwoofer blasen Luft in beide Richtungen mit der gleichen Frequenz wie der erzeugte Schall. Es ist der Art und Weise, wie ein herkömmlicher Lautsprecher Luft hin und her bewegt, sehr ähnlich, mit der Ausnahme, dass ein rotierender Subwoofer dies mit viel größeren Luftmengen tun kann, da es sich um einen Ventilator handelt. Ich habe darüber nachgedacht, nach dem Vortex-Cannon-Prinzip etwas zu bauen, das ich gerne einen Quantenlautsprecher nenne. Ich bin mir nur noch nicht sicher, wie ich das machen soll. Ich bin mir sicher, dass, wenn ein Vortex-Quantenlautsprecher entwickelt würde, dieser deutlich höhere Amplitudenwerte erreichen könnte als normale Lautsprecher. Leider denke ich, dass ein Vortex-Kanonenlautsprecher ziemlich verzerrt wäre, da die Schallwellen eher auf kräftigen Luftstößen als auf präzisen Luftbewegungen basieren würden.
@blakebernard52846 күн бұрын
Incredible
@wuntyful6 күн бұрын
10:43 wtf was that??
@brandonsbikes6 күн бұрын
Does it work with the trunk closed? So that you can drive around and bump it? Seems pretty awesome but maybe some kinda dampener or rubber bands around the end of the linkage to eliminate the clatter...
@musicmusic36467 күн бұрын
She was super clean when she leveled out. Almost there!
@Alexzsyy7 күн бұрын
7:15 thats just straight up a 5000w sub or sm thatss amazing tbf coming from a rotary sub
@sb-cg3zq7 күн бұрын
Can they be used outdoors or does it have to be a room
@nathanbulle57827 күн бұрын
@@sb-cg3zq can be used outdoors if put in a very large box
@audio_phil9 күн бұрын
It would be more efficient if you mount a little tube around your rotary sub to better move the air in the direction. Like on a tube ventilator
@user-vr5cq7fc6d9 күн бұрын
Am just thinking. What if used as a normal speaker😅
@kristabulle63359 күн бұрын
Support innovation! Better vids and products can be available. Support, support, support 💙
@kristabulle63359 күн бұрын
Thanks!
@nathanbulle57829 күн бұрын
@@kristabulle6335 lol, since when did you start watching my videos? 😂😂 JK your the second person to give a super thanks!
@kristabulle63359 күн бұрын
@nathanbulle5782 I like watching them in succession. I'm always excited when you put out a new video and you're chill about mistakes and malfunctions. Every invention has to be constantly improved and practice makes perfect 👌
@kristabulle63359 күн бұрын
Nathan would love to be able to bring this and some of his other projects to everyone asking, but it's going to need $$$ backing. He funds everything himself, currently. Not asking for money, just letting y'all know ❤
@kristabulle63359 күн бұрын
Thanks for all your positive feedback! On behalf of Nathan, it means a lot. The design suggestions are great! Years before getting a degree in mechanical engineering, he was building stuff like this. He’s come out with stuff before others cornered the market on things like bluetooth headphones that vibrate with the bass. He’s designed many things before even stepping foot in any schooling program. He’s on the spectrum and his mind works in ways I'll never understand, but make no mistake, if he had the capital to start a business, these would be perfected, designed, manufactured and available to everyone interested. Don't hate, cuz this kid is truly amazing!
@kristabulle63359 күн бұрын
Wild! I'm clueless about these things, and I'm still not entirely sure what purpose a rotary subwoofer plays in regards to music enjoyment, but it's fascinating. I'll contact Nathan directly. He'll be like "ok, I've explained many times" 😂
@scottmiller302510 күн бұрын
Would have liked to have heard it with the trunk shut
@HandyRandy320010 күн бұрын
I hear the fan more than anything else
@sameerp860110 күн бұрын
Air pass not bass😂
@alejandroaguilar903811 күн бұрын
WHY DO YOU HAVE THE TRUNK OPEN ??? NOT GOOD
@nathanbulle578210 күн бұрын
@@alejandroaguilar9038 rotary subs need infinite baffle to operate so the trunk needs to be open
@alejandroaguilar903811 күн бұрын
IF THE FAN WAS STRONGER THAN WOULD THE LOWS ???
@nathanbulle578210 күн бұрын
@@alejandroaguilar9038 yeah
@kellypg11 күн бұрын
Bro what phone are you recording with? That bass came through very nicely. Got my windows in the living room rattling 😂 I need to put together one of those rotary subs
@nathanbulle578211 күн бұрын
@@kellypg dji gimble camera. I'm glad it sounded good for you because it didn't sound very good for me
@kellypg11 күн бұрын
@@nathanbulle5782 In all fairness I'm comparing it to most basshead videos that are straight distortion or overlayed music to hide the distortion 😂 but seriously, it sounded fine, man.(My further opinions are worthless and take them with a grain of salt)I feel like a little more detail into the install and info on the sub beforehand would make it more digestible for new viewers.
@kristabulle63359 күн бұрын
Agreed. Is there a better way to watch/listen to your videos? The product is so powerful, it drowns out some of the dialog. I'm assuming we're still in the trial and error phase. How long can it run like that? Less than 10 minutes, apparently 😂😂. "Friend" your statements of the obvious Crack me up, "bro"
@junkerpain25111 күн бұрын
😕😕😕😕
@Anyone70011 күн бұрын
This style of woofer has tremendous drawbacks, but its just so damn cool. Ive wanted to make one for a while but I dont want to start cracking plaster in my house. Easier and safer to get a 24in sub
@captainchicken898311 күн бұрын
I need one as a radiator fan lmao, badass stuff! reminds me of that hydraulic cooling fan that can reverse rotations
@Hazzo8812 күн бұрын
Hollar at Noctua on blade design.
@nathanbulle578212 күн бұрын
@@Hazzo88 what do they make the blades out of?
@Hazzo8812 күн бұрын
Call up Noctua have them design the blades!
@Chris-uj3dh12 күн бұрын
Do mp3s, streams, and other compressed formats remove frequencies that low? Are you playing from a lossless file format?
@nathanbulle578212 күн бұрын
@@Chris-uj3dh the files I'm using are literally just mp3s recorded from KZread
@nathanbulle578212 күн бұрын
@@Chris-uj3dh no fancy stuff
@ivander15112 күн бұрын
@@nathanbulle5782try using lossless formats like FLAC or AIFF (if you use apple devices)
@CarAudio.MGreece12 күн бұрын
Does it do good at spl numbers? Or will a normal sub same watts do better
@nathanbulle578212 күн бұрын
@@CarAudio.MGreece because it's in a car a 15" has about the same spl
@solrshawn12 күн бұрын
You should try not to be a jerk to your friend, whom we don't know the name of because you didn't even introduce him.
@nathanbulle578212 күн бұрын
@@solrshawn he said his name was "friend" if you were actually paying attention
@solrshawn12 күн бұрын
@@nathanbulle5782 he was being sarcastic, and I am unsubbing.
@nathanbulle578212 күн бұрын
@@solrshawn you can do whatever you want
@kristabulle63359 күн бұрын
It's not that big a deal. Nathan and "friend" are good. Resubscribe!!!
@frisco159413 сағат бұрын
@@solrshawnyou are definitely over 40 and tell poor min wage workers “i’m not giving you any more of my business” with a comment like that
@dogtime119812 күн бұрын
Thannks for sharing, I built an entire subwoofer room. It made resonate the building. The rotary did not broke hopefully. I presented this during the 2024 rietveld academie graduation show. Thanks mate for your videos!
Пікірлер
For SPL and keeping stuff cool this is a brilliant idea. Please put a metal shroud around her and never be in the path. Rotational force is huge (ruffly the mass triples when spinning), got keep you alive and well to see further advances! Been watching since the start, keep it pounding!!
@@stopdusty420 If I die to a rotary sub I will consider that a death of dignity!
if possible, you can add rubber washers or sleeves around the screws of all the moving parts, it may reduce mechanical noises and try to reduce the weight of those moving parts, which are moving linearly to create bass. I know this will mostly be used for Low-frequency bass, but why not make it more efficient... keep it up, brother ...
Highest frequency is?
If we're talking about subwoofers, we wanna know the lowest
Lowest frequency is 11hz
Damn i gotta build one quick
Lows around 15 hz?
@@zane812 lower I think
This also sounds really good if you try speeding it up 2x but you have to download it and speed it up manually to increase the pitch as well
Nice 🦾🦾🦾
You should make a tutorial on how to make one, maybe release 3D printing files? I’d really like to make one. Sorry if this is so much to ask.
@@paulosebresos7864 I actually did do this. If you look at the other videos on my channel (not very many maybe like 10) you will find a tutorial on how to make one and a link to a Google drive containing all the 3D files
@@nathanbulle5782 True. I got 90% inspired by your design, but had to edit all of them to fit my speaker and motor properly. Still sounded like a shit, cus there was a lot of vibrations everyehere 🤣 But it made my final exam ✨👌
Can we get a video of it playing on your rotary sub?
@@Triangle1234 yeah of course, but this video will always sound better on your system since it's the original audio
Can someone explain how this is working/what is Happening in comparison to a normal sub?
fucking youtube silenced the audio lameee
That's one bad ass speaker 😮😮
Play "Mandrazo - Say my name" you'll thank me later 😂
a HouseWoofer
We are going to experience the jump from high/mid/low to high/mid/highlow/lowlow.
a great way to ventilate the room and dance)))
Теперь сабвуфером можно не только волосы поднимать, но и постричься
Lol you can get more bass and better sound with one 10
@@cichrift9065 not at 10 hz lol
So what is the point of this? Car is not vibrating any more than it would with the 15 alone and trunk open. So just wondering what is the point of adding this?
@@DrewAk49 these work better in a building
Got a question. Do you compensate torque to keep rpm's constant or let them drop with higher signal amplitude?
@@ctrlaltdel02 the torque becomes a little more with higher amplitude but the speed still drops a little
@@nathanbulle5782 what do you use to control how much power is aplied to motor vs signal amplitude. Got a hunch it isn't linear vs frequency and amplitude because two times louder is four times power as far as I remember. So to get constant speed there needs to be waaaay much power aplied to motor at peak of signal amplitude.
@@ctrlaltdel02 there are special types of motors that do it better than the one I'm using but those motors are much bigger. Mine kinda does it automatically, it's a brushless skateboard wheel motor
In welcher Richtung wird die Luft geblasen? Wenn dann muss der Subwoofer mit dem Ventilator interagieren.Anstatt die Luft in den Kofferraum zu blasen muss die Luft aus dem Kofferraum herausbeschleunigt werden damit das einen vernünftigen Bassreflexeffekt ergibt. Schon mal was im Gegenlaufprinzip ausprobiert? Wie bei einer Druckschallkanone.
Rotierende Subwoofer blasen Luft in beide Richtungen mit der gleichen Frequenz wie der erzeugte Schall. Es ist der Art und Weise, wie ein herkömmlicher Lautsprecher Luft hin und her bewegt, sehr ähnlich, mit der Ausnahme, dass ein rotierender Subwoofer dies mit viel größeren Luftmengen tun kann, da es sich um einen Ventilator handelt. Ich habe darüber nachgedacht, nach dem Vortex-Cannon-Prinzip etwas zu bauen, das ich gerne einen Quantenlautsprecher nenne. Ich bin mir nur noch nicht sicher, wie ich das machen soll. Ich bin mir sicher, dass, wenn ein Vortex-Quantenlautsprecher entwickelt würde, dieser deutlich höhere Amplitudenwerte erreichen könnte als normale Lautsprecher. Leider denke ich, dass ein Vortex-Kanonenlautsprecher ziemlich verzerrt wäre, da die Schallwellen eher auf kräftigen Luftstößen als auf präzisen Luftbewegungen basieren würden.
Incredible
10:43 wtf was that??
Does it work with the trunk closed? So that you can drive around and bump it? Seems pretty awesome but maybe some kinda dampener or rubber bands around the end of the linkage to eliminate the clatter...
She was super clean when she leveled out. Almost there!
7:15 thats just straight up a 5000w sub or sm thatss amazing tbf coming from a rotary sub
Can they be used outdoors or does it have to be a room
@@sb-cg3zq can be used outdoors if put in a very large box
It would be more efficient if you mount a little tube around your rotary sub to better move the air in the direction. Like on a tube ventilator
Am just thinking. What if used as a normal speaker😅
Support innovation! Better vids and products can be available. Support, support, support 💙
Thanks!
@@kristabulle6335 lol, since when did you start watching my videos? 😂😂 JK your the second person to give a super thanks!
@nathanbulle5782 I like watching them in succession. I'm always excited when you put out a new video and you're chill about mistakes and malfunctions. Every invention has to be constantly improved and practice makes perfect 👌
Nathan would love to be able to bring this and some of his other projects to everyone asking, but it's going to need $$$ backing. He funds everything himself, currently. Not asking for money, just letting y'all know ❤
Thanks for all your positive feedback! On behalf of Nathan, it means a lot. The design suggestions are great! Years before getting a degree in mechanical engineering, he was building stuff like this. He’s come out with stuff before others cornered the market on things like bluetooth headphones that vibrate with the bass. He’s designed many things before even stepping foot in any schooling program. He’s on the spectrum and his mind works in ways I'll never understand, but make no mistake, if he had the capital to start a business, these would be perfected, designed, manufactured and available to everyone interested. Don't hate, cuz this kid is truly amazing!
Wild! I'm clueless about these things, and I'm still not entirely sure what purpose a rotary subwoofer plays in regards to music enjoyment, but it's fascinating. I'll contact Nathan directly. He'll be like "ok, I've explained many times" 😂
Would have liked to have heard it with the trunk shut
I hear the fan more than anything else
Air pass not bass😂
WHY DO YOU HAVE THE TRUNK OPEN ??? NOT GOOD
@@alejandroaguilar9038 rotary subs need infinite baffle to operate so the trunk needs to be open
IF THE FAN WAS STRONGER THAN WOULD THE LOWS ???
@@alejandroaguilar9038 yeah
Bro what phone are you recording with? That bass came through very nicely. Got my windows in the living room rattling 😂 I need to put together one of those rotary subs
@@kellypg dji gimble camera. I'm glad it sounded good for you because it didn't sound very good for me
@@nathanbulle5782 In all fairness I'm comparing it to most basshead videos that are straight distortion or overlayed music to hide the distortion 😂 but seriously, it sounded fine, man.(My further opinions are worthless and take them with a grain of salt)I feel like a little more detail into the install and info on the sub beforehand would make it more digestible for new viewers.
Agreed. Is there a better way to watch/listen to your videos? The product is so powerful, it drowns out some of the dialog. I'm assuming we're still in the trial and error phase. How long can it run like that? Less than 10 minutes, apparently 😂😂. "Friend" your statements of the obvious Crack me up, "bro"
😕😕😕😕
This style of woofer has tremendous drawbacks, but its just so damn cool. Ive wanted to make one for a while but I dont want to start cracking plaster in my house. Easier and safer to get a 24in sub
I need one as a radiator fan lmao, badass stuff! reminds me of that hydraulic cooling fan that can reverse rotations
Hollar at Noctua on blade design.
@@Hazzo88 what do they make the blades out of?
Call up Noctua have them design the blades!
Do mp3s, streams, and other compressed formats remove frequencies that low? Are you playing from a lossless file format?
@@Chris-uj3dh the files I'm using are literally just mp3s recorded from KZread
@@Chris-uj3dh no fancy stuff
@@nathanbulle5782try using lossless formats like FLAC or AIFF (if you use apple devices)
Does it do good at spl numbers? Or will a normal sub same watts do better
@@CarAudio.MGreece because it's in a car a 15" has about the same spl
You should try not to be a jerk to your friend, whom we don't know the name of because you didn't even introduce him.
@@solrshawn he said his name was "friend" if you were actually paying attention
@@nathanbulle5782 he was being sarcastic, and I am unsubbing.
@@solrshawn you can do whatever you want
It's not that big a deal. Nathan and "friend" are good. Resubscribe!!!
@@solrshawnyou are definitely over 40 and tell poor min wage workers “i’m not giving you any more of my business” with a comment like that
Thannks for sharing, I built an entire subwoofer room. It made resonate the building. The rotary did not broke hopefully. I presented this during the 2024 rietveld academie graduation show. Thanks mate for your videos!
Please play something by young dolph lmao