Video dimension

Video dimension

Hey there, I make videos about my objectively correct takes on anime. Hope you like the content!

PS: If you want to work with me you can hire me as an editor here
www.upwork.com/freelancers/~0174eaf6e348a4daa7?viewMode=1&s=1044578476142100540

How Eren justified genocide

How Eren justified genocide

IM NOT READY

IM NOT READY

Is murder always evil?

Is murder always evil?

Пікірлер

  • @CromwellEdonis
    @CromwellEdonis4 сағат бұрын

    ‘There is no right or wrong in war.’ To the outside world, Eren is a monster, but to the Eldians. He was a hero.

  • @fatedzero1039
    @fatedzero10395 сағат бұрын

    I'm confused about the part where the founding titan will be pass down in royal blood, they have the vow renouncing war right? how can they defend themselves with the partial rumbling

  • @bsherder
    @bsherder10 сағат бұрын

    Oh dude it sounds like you have no idea what the anime market is like. The amount of fan service as you put it, is nothing compared to other anime. I also hate to break it to you but anime is not meant to be watched in public. I thought the 4 hour thing for failing the quest was bs too, but at the same time i wasn't gullible enough to think he was actually sprinting the whole 4 hours. You said it also had no stakes and explained why but your reasoning is flawed. Yes he does get angry and it helps him overcome his limits but the same could be said for many anime. Obviously the series isn't going to have him die a few episodes in, so you know he will overcome it. The same goes with most anime.

  • @maximebenamou3332
    @maximebenamou333223 сағат бұрын

    Did bro just say just hair me out? 💀

  • @creamcity1893
    @creamcity1893Күн бұрын

    No even if Eren is stopped by his former comrades…they would have been neutered against their will, still genocide. Eren brought his friends peace for their remaining lives and that’s a fact. Without Eren doing what he did, the genocide would have happened…might as well take care of YOUR PEOPLE first.

  • @alexisskelton9174
    @alexisskelton91746 күн бұрын

    In the end it comes down to kill or be killed. Fight and you have a chance to live or do nothing so lose and die. Now we know that if Armin had been in charge instead of Eren it would have been the end of Eldians. I’m surprised to see so many people talk about Eren as the devil incarnated when in reality he took all the right decisions for his people. It shows how the people of today have become weak.

  • @feedthebig9707
    @feedthebig97076 күн бұрын

    Eren wasn’t wrong

  • @eternallucifer7709
    @eternallucifer77099 күн бұрын

    Change "justified" with "explained" and you are right. Eren did not justify genocide, he made it understandable.

  • @rob2540
    @rob254010 күн бұрын

    Eren is a angel of death for paradise and a demon of death for the rest of the world.

  • @Imstilllita
    @Imstilllita15 күн бұрын

    And other see him as our king (I’m others)

  • @nacktack
    @nacktack16 күн бұрын

    what about the music

  • @adrianguth
    @adrianguth18 күн бұрын

    The question is, What do you do if everyone else want to erradicate from existance no matter what, your people? The only solution is always a bigger menace. just like in watchmen, just like in SNK

  • @its_Criminal1
    @its_Criminal119 күн бұрын

    I feel like both did things right and the fact that our issue was who's better when both are peak is a testament to the quality of the show. But I have to give the edge to wit. Their ODM scene are very easily the best scenes I've ever seen in anime asthetically. The eyes on the characters are beautiful too and the titans have that hand drawn amazing look. Tho the colossal looks much better in mappa's version. Overall I feel like Mappa's style fits the darker theme of the late show very well. So I'd pick wit but there's a lot of value to be found in mappa's animation too

  • @odralebazerimar9084
    @odralebazerimar908419 күн бұрын

    Wit gave the show a more majestic look. Mappa made the show look like it lost its charm or appeal. Like the end of the world or something. Mappa even needed the guy that drew Levi fighting the Beast Titan in S3 to draw the ending scene where Levi dodges a bunch of things in the air to throw a thunder spear while Mikasa slices Eren’s head off.

  • @Icantthinkofaname475
    @Icantthinkofaname47520 күн бұрын

    6:02 Bro, 4 years for one season💀 The whole time skip took place.

  • @user92xhy369cj
    @user92xhy369cj23 күн бұрын

    hahaha ymir founder chick XD

  • @Iluvutoo
    @Iluvutoo23 күн бұрын

    Solo leveling was made by an edgy 12 yr old kid

  • @frogglen6350
    @frogglen635024 күн бұрын

    Its easy to say Eren did nothing wrong when you aren't a victim of genocide

  • @minhchinhhoang8669
    @minhchinhhoang866925 күн бұрын

    Wit are not focusing in average frame while mappa does you but i prefer mappa art style as i like the consistent quality. About coloring and contrast overall i would choose wit but the 3rd frame of eren eyse in 3:06 i still choose mappa as it look more edgy and realistic and suit the vibe of cruel world and full of drepession as u can see in eren eyes, full of angry and no hope

  • @marvelboi3416
    @marvelboi341626 күн бұрын

    Did you made a video already comparing the artstyle of Vinland Saga between Witt Studio and MAPPA when it comes who is better?

  • @SimaoSantos10CTAV
    @SimaoSantos10CTAV28 күн бұрын

    Honestly I love wit, but I do like mappa more simply because wit just looks overall goofy and childish mappa captures the more intense aspects this show has to offer, not just in the artstyle but in the cinematographic point. If only they had more time

  • @NecromancyKing170
    @NecromancyKing17028 күн бұрын

    I didn't know titan in mappa were cgi

  • @TheTAB56
    @TheTAB56Ай бұрын

    Zeke's plan could work in the following way , let me know if I'm wrong tho, The ackerman was a good point, but it is very very safe to assume that the founder is way stronger than ackerman blood, after all, when Eren made his announcement about war to the whole world ,even Levi was brought into the Path's world, So let's say the Ackerman gets Euthanized too So, Zeke will die in 1 year or less as he had beast for 12 years now, 13 is limit, Currently in the entire world there are only 3 Eldian with Royal Blood, Zeke,Historia,And the Child of historia born on day of Rumbling. We all know Founder's powers need Royal Blood to Unlock, So when you said the entire eldian race has to agree for this plan to work ,that isn't actually true Zeke dies in 1 year ,so he's out, remaining royal eldian in the world is 2 now. Zeke just needs to convince historia that , you keep the founder for 13, then let your baby keep the founder for 13 , thats 26, and after 26 both historia and the baby would die,cause curse of ymir, so there is no more royal blood, then the founder will randomly go to a Non Royal Eldian, cause there is literally no Royal blood eldian left. And without the royal blood, a common eldian guy(grisha) no matter holds the founder for how long ,cant really do shit, let alone Revert the euthinaztion. So key point is ,convince historia and her child, Everyone needs to keep Historia and her child Safe for the first 26 years , so that Marley doesnt attack Paradis ,takes the founder , kidnaps a royal blood , feeds the founder to a common eldian back on marley and make the common eldian now with founder touch royal blood(either historia or her kid) Best way to prevent is ,zeke still has 1 year left right ,he should use wall maria's titans for Rumbling Show off and that ought to keep Marley away from Paradis for 50 years or so, and we just need to hold of for 26 years ,once they historia and her kid dies , with no royal blood eldian left in the world and no way to access the founder ,i say give the founder to marley and do whatever the fuck they wanna do ,cause eventually after 70 or 80 years all eldians gonna die and after that every single generation will be war with humans only ,no titans, ig so, idk bout the halluciginea ,that shit just doesnt die. Ig when the last eldian dies after 70 or 80 years ,who as the last living common eldian would ofc inherit the founder, after that dies, there would grow another tree ,just like in case of eren's grave? Could be, but yeah this is how Zeke's plan could perfectly work, and personal opinion, with a bit of persuasion,for the greater good zeke can convince historia.

  • @TechnicalSoldex
    @TechnicalSoldexАй бұрын

    I hate what eren did but when I ask myself the question: My family dying Vs Everyone Else dies I would definitely choose the first without any hesitation. Similar to what Eren did, he decided wiping out the rest of humanity just to protect those he knew.

  • @-kenjo-421
    @-kenjo-421Ай бұрын

    Its simple: wit studio was great but it took too much time and effort for them to do it so mappa was chosen to replace because they could animate in a shorter amount of time with the help of cgi, and less details, frames. They could do more in less time and thats what mattered for the bosses who wanted anime as fast as possible

  • @ashwangushkia
    @ashwangushkiaАй бұрын

    Mappa did a really good job considering their animators got worked to death

  • @AlastorChannel
    @AlastorChannelАй бұрын

    Mappa did the best they could, but Wit animation is better.

  • @Naomi-gr7fm
    @Naomi-gr7fmАй бұрын

    I remember reading the ending chapters live and having this feeling of, "Ummm wtf is this???" I was a HUGE AOT stan for years. I would not stfu about it on social media in terms of what I was keeping up with. The first season of the anime is what got me into reading and keeping up with the manga. I was shouting its praises for the writing. But nah I gotta pretend that ending is not real to cope. I feel like too many people worry about being nice and feeling like an asshole if they criticize an author's creative work. (Or they just lack compositional literacy).

  • @wettoaster34
    @wettoaster34Ай бұрын

    the reality of war is that nobody’s actually in the wrong

  • @lucasscoz6090
    @lucasscoz6090Ай бұрын

    the big point for me is the it shows how stupid racism and historical divide(dont know the right term) is

  • @tochukwuudu7763
    @tochukwuudu7763Ай бұрын

    Wit was better.

  • @SBaby
    @SBabyАй бұрын

    6:27 - I hate that quote. It's just a fancy way to say there is such a thing as acceptable losses. And only the insane believe in acceptable losses. Plus, by that logic it means everyone trying to save the baby at the end was a villain, because a true hero would've sacrificed it for everyone else. See the problem? A true hero doesn't need to sacrifice anyone else because they are enough. Since I don't care too much for that quote, here's another one. "I wanted to be a hero! I wanted someone to respect me... It's all my fault! Your mother was eaten by a titan because of me!"

  • @CloudDieStrifende
    @CloudDieStrifendeАй бұрын

    No? The sacrifice of the baby would have saved nobody. And of course there are acceptable losses. All the soldiers who died against Nazi Germany prevented far bigger losses due to Mass genocide so...

  • @SBaby
    @SBabyАй бұрын

    The Rumbling is a real global deconstruction (no pun intended) on how nostalgia can be toxic. Even after seeing the end of the series, I'd still say that Marley had this coming. Does that necessarily justify what Eren did? Probably not. But a god's standards of right and wrong differ vastly from a mortal's standards of such. And it's clear that at the end of the series humanity didn't learn its lesson even after the massive spanking that Eren gave them and that this will happen again, possibly with the complete extinction of humanity this time.

  • @DD-zh4by
    @DD-zh4byАй бұрын

    This is not even a question. Mappa's sock puppet theater exposed the final season's bad storytelling by removing the spectacle entirely.

  • @nix2455
    @nix2455Ай бұрын

    Eren did nothing wrong. They didn't have to hate him, they didn't have to hate his people, they didn't have to try to kill him or his, but they did, so he defended himself.

  • @Runeforged
    @RuneforgedАй бұрын

    “Dramatic exit” hehe. I c wut u did thar

  • @Nekrist._.
    @Nekrist._.Ай бұрын

    Hitler had no choice... Stalin had no choice... Putin had no choice... Reiner had no choice... Annie had no choice... Zeke had no choice... Eren had no choice... Ymir had no choice... You see, no one has a choice, right? Right? For 2000 thousand years Ymir could not free herself, could not get her will, destroy the power of the titans... Not because she loved Fritz, not because she was “forced” to become like this, but only because the pathetic person simply remained the same pathetic. There is nothing human in Ymir or Eren, only pathetic people who had "no other choice..."

  • @CloudDieStrifende
    @CloudDieStrifendeАй бұрын

    Was Hitler under attack by everyone when he started the war? Was Stalins Homeland in danger during his Mass Murder? Was Putin under attack? No no and no

  • @robertsutton1295
    @robertsutton12952 ай бұрын

    Paradis: "We can't/won't Rumble." Marley: "Excellent! Now DIE and give us all your land and resources!" Paradis: "Okay, then we will/can do the Rumble" Marley: (forms Global Alliance) "OH SHIT!! Die and give us all your land and resources!" Paradis: Well...shit. RUMBLE!

  • @nic4090
    @nic40902 ай бұрын

    It’d cool if they did a remake of this series with WIT

  • @Yashone
    @Yashone2 ай бұрын

    It's not just to save paradis, there's more to it. he wanted to wipe everyone ever since he learned humanity survived outisde walls. the world hatred towards them only made eren justify his actions. A small scale rumbling is enough to save paradis. but with that eren can't get his freedom, which is an empty land with no people. That's why eren did rumbling.

  • @CloudDieStrifende
    @CloudDieStrifendeАй бұрын

    Huh? How would a small scale rumbling save anyone? If anything just like we saw, the alliance would see this as a declaration of war. And even IF they stopped there: They already developed weapons that can kill even Titan Shifters. It wouldn't be that long (maybe one or two hundred years) until the alliance would be able to annihilate the rumbling.

  • @bronzeanon985
    @bronzeanon9852 ай бұрын

    don't you see? even in this comment section we're a group of people with different opinions about this issue. Don't you find it probable that the same applies for the Marleyans? i understand that the Marleyan people of power keep punishing Eldia for their far far past but what about the common human? we keep talking about Marleyans as if they're all a single organism with a single brain when that is way way far from the case. You think Eren is right? Even when he went on the other side undercover and saw the every day people living their lives he didn't think for a second that they deserved to be spared. He is still a boy with too much power. He could have lifted the curse of the titans by having Mikasa kill him thus proving to Ymir that she can have a will of her own as we see happen by the end of the story, he did not *have* to annihilate the world to ensure Paradis' safety, that was only for his own selfish attempt to find closure. He did not care about the Eldians, that was simply an excuse to gain supporters. There were Eldians on the land of Marley for crying out loud!

  • @Master_stupid
    @Master_stupid2 ай бұрын

    mike death was horrible and zeke like i will bring peace sees a soilder take his odm gearfor NO FUCKING REASON YAY, I CAN DEFFINTLY ASK OTHER SOILDER OR JUST SNEAK IN THE SCOUTS

  • @moonlitstories8983
    @moonlitstories89832 ай бұрын

    You should totally make a video about Jujutsu Kaisen :)

  • @PainPeaceProsperity
    @PainPeaceProsperity2 ай бұрын

    Eren is the villain and you can try and say it however you like. Boohoo I grew up a certain way, boohoo the truth was t what I expected, grow up! We wanted to disarm and kill Hitler for doing it and I’m sure he had his reasons. Now we can accept it because we’ve seen this guy’s pov the entire time? And lol ik this just an anime but if this were real we can’t act like this is okay…and btw he did have a choice. Do just like King Fritz did, and choose PEACE. Just take out the outer layer as a deterrent, ofc it won’t last forever but a simple threat from King Fritz kept Marlyians at bay for a long period of time. Just saying…genocide is never justified no matter what you tell yourself. And yes I can understand a persons reasons and/or predicament and still disagree or dislike the actions. Just like Hange. Btw again I’m not aggressive at all, I’m just passionate about this certain topic, I love the anime btw.

  • @Warmaker01
    @Warmaker012 ай бұрын

    Stopping Eren was the wrong move. The hatred of Eldians / Paradis was never going to stop. You see this failure when time flies and Paradis is literally being bombed and destroyed. Their civilization is wiped out and the remnants of cities remain with plant overgrowth. Because there's nobody left to rebuild. They're wiped out.

  • @vladimirlenin843
    @vladimirlenin8432 ай бұрын

    Eren killed billions just to achieve the same effect as Zeke's plan Which is the annihilation of paradian

  • @jokerpilled2535
    @jokerpilled25352 ай бұрын

    Nah Paradis survived. Everyone else died.

  • @GokuSolosAnime
    @GokuSolosAnime3 ай бұрын

    I wish there were no deadlines in anime industry

  • @DaveSkylark111
    @DaveSkylark1113 ай бұрын

    If you substitute Paradis for postwar Japan it starts to get real weird.

  • @alenasuvorova1340
    @alenasuvorova13403 ай бұрын

    The biggest problem with MAPPA is their errors in face/upper body anatomy. Maybe charachter design became more manga-like, but after 3 seasons the contrast between sharp WIT faces and bloby MAPPA faces was too distracting. Otherwise MAPPA animators deserve better schedule and rewards for their titanic work.

  • @-S4T
    @-S4T3 ай бұрын

    i think the fact that wit did season 1 2 and 3 and mappa did the rest was a really good combo because it really puts us into perspective, how since season 4 things gotten harder and not like a "peaceful fight" against titans. Because the enemies aren't titans, they are humans