Definitely one of the better interviews I had to watch. It could had been more painfully scripted with a bunch of other nonsense in the mix where it looks like it was written by someone who never worked with a patient before but read a lot of text.
@Jakerocksteady3 жыл бұрын
3:11 Sunny D's next slogan.
@JoyJoy-ev1wq3 жыл бұрын
READ CAREFULLY .. Good day everyone out here i am here to share a message of greatness about a great Dr called Dr Abumere who helped me in bringing back my ex lover back he is very powerful and legit thank you Dr Abumere and am very sorry for doubting you i am for ever greatful his email address is ([email protected]) or Whatsapp him (+234 9021975055) thank you. facebook.com/Ex-back-101670001847903/
@audreylouise1233 жыл бұрын
A lot of 'righting reflex' used here.
@Tylerrl16643 жыл бұрын
Fruit will not make you fat. What a mistake. He should cut out eggs, meat, and other shit he’s eating instead
@janiscrawford77573 жыл бұрын
The screen text mislabeled at least two language behaviors. A question that starts with "how many" is closed, not open and "I understand" would not be coded as an affirmation.
@aimeelecours91014 жыл бұрын
Hello. I am creating an e-learning for doctors and therapists. We do not charge for our trainings. I would like to request permission to use this video. Do I need any special permissions to utilize this video in an e-learning?
@cozygamingandvideos39144 жыл бұрын
John should switch from fruit juice to Mountain Dew. John also needs to exercise more. I suggest boxing.
@WithFlavorCrystals4 жыл бұрын
1:56 "How Many Fruits and Vegetables?" is mislabeled in the text on the screen as being an Open Ended Question. It is closed.
@frederickwhiteside64154 жыл бұрын
To sum MI up in a few words: Motivational Interviewing is an effective way of talking with people about CHANGE. The doctor practiced a great deal of good peer support practices with his patient. Practicing Peer Supporters are open minded, empathetic, respectful, honest and direct. Peer Supporters facilitate change as well provide a natural place for social connection and social support.. At some points the doctor could have paced himself a bit more, but at least did not sound like he was reading from a poorly written script.
@bobbystrom5 жыл бұрын
This is brilliant. Clear and Concise thank you both.
@angel-amenet5 жыл бұрын
This Was excellent
@adamlowe70385 жыл бұрын
"Boy do I love that OJ"
@michaelaconley7985 жыл бұрын
this one really is pretty good.
@wolfumz5 жыл бұрын
MI is great, really powerful technique, but this is such a softball example lol. I use MI all the time at the drug rehab where I work. I had a client tell me the other day to go fuck myself and he doesn't care if he goes back to prison.
@knowhub6 жыл бұрын
I think the idea of this is not to determine the validity of fruits and juice, but the process. Yes, too much fruit juice is not good. Also, yes, you can gain weight with too many fruits. They are all sugars and when you have any type of sugars, you release insulin. If you take in more than what the body can keep up with, then what is not stored will convert to fat. Also, he does focus entirely on the juice and not the other meals nor talking about exercise, stress, sleep, etc. See, there is a lot that needs to be covered but that's not the intent of the interview. The intent is to show how to use the MI techniques to evoke a response.
@speak4mc6 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the video! Check out my channel for short videos that focus on the spirit of MI! #BeToday kzread.info/dash/bejne/rJ9qsZqoZpjbdrA.html
@kyracoach6 жыл бұрын
Good, but you can't take away something...they need to replace with a doable solution. The focus was on stopping the drinking of calorie laced juice. But now what? Sugar free is not the solution!!! How can they make water more appealing? Leave them with a doable alternative that is their choice. But not fake sugars.
@Songmorning6 жыл бұрын
I think a more realistic goal would have been for the guy to reduce his intake of orange juice to one or two glasses a day, rather than trying to cut it out completely. For one thing, he said he really likes orange juice, so going cold turkey would probably result in a rebound. For another thing, I don't think one or two glasses of orange juice would have a negative effect on his health--in fact, orange juice contains many nutrients and antioxidants that would be quite good for him in moderation. The doctor also could have explored what KIND of orange juice he's buying and consider whether there are more healthy options that he could buy. For example, he may be getting a brand of orange juice which contains added sugars, and he might be able to switch to one without that extra sugar.
@rkbrown20927 жыл бұрын
"Substitute with sugar free drinks!!!!" Why did the doctor not correct this statement by the patient. Sugar free drinks contain hormone disrupting chemicals. The fact that this doctor doesn't show any red flags to that... I would say he's working for the opposition. Good example of helpful questioning with hidden propoganda. Be discerning.
@1974GJH7 жыл бұрын
I caught that as well. 4 glasses of diet coke daily will insatiate his hunger and probably exacerbate his weight issues
@JasonJarred7 жыл бұрын
RK Brown lol wot
@littlethuggie6 жыл бұрын
The goal of the video is influencing change in the patient vs what you just did. A good Dr. doesn't "correct" the patient every time they say something false. You would never get anywhere, and no one wants an egotistical, pretentious Dr. (AKA, a dick).
@littlethuggie6 жыл бұрын
@ Greg H: Sugar-free drinks are generally not "healthy", but one is definitely exacerbating his weight issues (excess juice, fruit), and the other could make him hungrier and "probably" exacerbate his weight issues. One is definite, one is not. So, if your goal is weight loss, ditching the fruit will unequivocally work; ditching the sugar-free drinks depends on the patient and how it affects them, and whether or not they increase their caloric intake. You can be hungry all day, that's never made anyone gain weight; calories do.
@peacefuljourney48587 жыл бұрын
I loved how he ended the session.
@DavidHernandez-oc1oz7 жыл бұрын
He shared information about fruit juice vs whole fruit without asking permission or asking if the patient knew about any differences in calories between fruit juice and whole fruit to see what the patient might have known. If he didn't know the doctor could then ask permission to share the information with the patient. Still a good video
@BouncinBudda8 жыл бұрын
definitely going to incorporate the grading scale into my next MI! gReat video, very practical!
@MrMitchjos0008 жыл бұрын
The doc had a lot of "I" statements. Agreed with him at one point.
@MrMitchjos0008 жыл бұрын
I disagree that this is motivational interviewing. I thing the beginning is good. "I have a hunch" not quite motivational interviewing. Good skit though. Keep practicing.
@MrMitchjos0008 жыл бұрын
2:16 is where this becomes doctors opinion (fact) and not motivational interviewing.
@AllthingsRocco6 жыл бұрын
so the doctors shouldn't offer any facts to his patients?
@mjscarousal8 жыл бұрын
Great example of motivational interview, just wish the doctor was a bit more empathetic, he kinda comes off harsh at times and his body language could be better.
@EurekaLiveTV8 жыл бұрын
He needs to slow down on the OJ!
@erikrostamian86689 жыл бұрын
I'm surprised at some of the negative comments. I have seen and participated in a lot of MI role plays, specifically in medical setting. This one is actually very well done.
@carolinespec8 жыл бұрын
+Erik Rostamian I really liked how the doctor asked his patient so many questions and also how he asked permission to discuss the issues with his patient. What I also noticed that seemed different (not better or worse, necessarily) was that it felt a little sales-ish when the doctor was asking several times for the patient's level of commitment. It wasn't the words as much as the sort of high-energy, aggressive manner. I agree with someone else's comments that this sort of pressure can likely lead someone to tell the doctor what they think the doctor wants to hear rather than expressing doubts and fears. This, to me, means that if a person "fails," they are more likely to feel ashamed and not want to return. I think it would be preferable to be very encouraging (which the doctor was) and positive (which he was), but also a bit less emphatic and aggressive. That is the MI quality that I think people were commenting on. Then again, maybe I'm wrong. Definitely possible.
@MaureenDelage9 жыл бұрын
very good
@davekanegis80709 жыл бұрын
As one who has worked with young people for years, my question is does this video presentation sound like the typical interaction between a healthcare professional and a young person who is experimenting with or using alcohol? Does this resonate with anyone's experiences as to how an adolescent or anyone for that matter will respond to the type of intervention presented? The interviewer while sweet and non threatening was using a heavily scripted approach... even to the point of looking down at her notes at one point when planning to frame a question. I'd rather see the interviewer build a general rapport first and then move on to specific challenges the individual might face. Although clearly well intended, I don't believe that this video represents what occurs in real life.
@BlessedByGodsLove9 жыл бұрын
GREAT ! This is the format in a medical setting with regard to time! I loved it. Thank you!!
@kathlynnnorthrup-snyder10419 жыл бұрын
Sorry, this has some elements of MI, but many non-adherent MI elements and I agree with one of the comments from the UK- this conversation is much longer than needs to be and could have much higher MI adherent skills.
@kevinl9608 жыл бұрын
Like what?
@Kingricky7610 жыл бұрын
wow if i was the patient I would be freaking annoyed at my doctor!
@gingerobyn10 жыл бұрын
Even though 'the patient' offered a detailed response, 'how many servings of fruits and vegetables do you have per day?' isn't exactly an open-ended question. I'm also getting the sense that motivational interviewing in a medical context does not have the same purpose or flow as MI in a therapeutic context.
@1111Paiste10 жыл бұрын
This MI example sucked! It was NOT MI.
@1111Paiste10 жыл бұрын
This IS a terrible example of MI. The spirit of MI is totally out the window. He sounds judgmental, DOES NOT ask for permission when educating, the list goes on and on...
@bruceberger714011 жыл бұрын
Tons of directing, yes but communication...patronizing.
@bruceberger714011 жыл бұрын
This is awful.
@myoldvan119 Жыл бұрын
You're awful Bruce Berger
@bruceberger7140 Жыл бұрын
@@myoldvan119 this is not my video
@teresagraney268011 жыл бұрын
Natural fruit juice without the sugar or artificial sweetener will not make you fat, but fruit juice loaded with sugar and other sweeteners like those cans of sodas CAN!
@ewelsby111 жыл бұрын
Oh My God! Fruit does NOT make you fat!
@jth009911 жыл бұрын
Wow, this is bad.
@timmcmahon711 жыл бұрын
I feel his pain. "Boy, do I love that OJ!"... his face is priceless!
@petehaggard85393 жыл бұрын
Hahahahha
@Olan092 жыл бұрын
You could always make orange juice from fresh oranges. That's what we do in my house, any time we have orange juice.
@timmcmahon711 жыл бұрын
I hear ya, but this is an MI example. It elicits change in a therapeutic and empathy filled way.
@chucktrain1111 жыл бұрын
I am a Medic in the UK. This guy must be being paid by the word and not have many patients. Over here it would be fill out a food diary, cut out the juice and clamp down on your wifes shopping. 30 secs tops. Natch!!
@eamaples11 жыл бұрын
Way too scripted.
@pharmacyroyalty11 жыл бұрын
Be careful using the words "I understand," even if you do understand exactly what the patient is going through, try to use more reflective listening.
@amanda.jan37673 жыл бұрын
What would a better phrase be?
@brendareed50503 жыл бұрын
@@amanda.jan3767 it’s reflecting back using the persons words.
@mrnmibrc11 жыл бұрын
EtOH does not cause unintended sex.
@MissNairLovesHair12 жыл бұрын
Wow the Physician did an awesome job! This helped a lot. Thanks!
Пікірлер
Definitely one of the better interviews I had to watch. It could had been more painfully scripted with a bunch of other nonsense in the mix where it looks like it was written by someone who never worked with a patient before but read a lot of text.
3:11 Sunny D's next slogan.
READ CAREFULLY .. Good day everyone out here i am here to share a message of greatness about a great Dr called Dr Abumere who helped me in bringing back my ex lover back he is very powerful and legit thank you Dr Abumere and am very sorry for doubting you i am for ever greatful his email address is ([email protected]) or Whatsapp him (+234 9021975055) thank you. facebook.com/Ex-back-101670001847903/
A lot of 'righting reflex' used here.
Fruit will not make you fat. What a mistake. He should cut out eggs, meat, and other shit he’s eating instead
The screen text mislabeled at least two language behaviors. A question that starts with "how many" is closed, not open and "I understand" would not be coded as an affirmation.
Hello. I am creating an e-learning for doctors and therapists. We do not charge for our trainings. I would like to request permission to use this video. Do I need any special permissions to utilize this video in an e-learning?
John should switch from fruit juice to Mountain Dew. John also needs to exercise more. I suggest boxing.
1:56 "How Many Fruits and Vegetables?" is mislabeled in the text on the screen as being an Open Ended Question. It is closed.
To sum MI up in a few words: Motivational Interviewing is an effective way of talking with people about CHANGE. The doctor practiced a great deal of good peer support practices with his patient. Practicing Peer Supporters are open minded, empathetic, respectful, honest and direct. Peer Supporters facilitate change as well provide a natural place for social connection and social support.. At some points the doctor could have paced himself a bit more, but at least did not sound like he was reading from a poorly written script.
This is brilliant. Clear and Concise thank you both.
This Was excellent
"Boy do I love that OJ"
this one really is pretty good.
MI is great, really powerful technique, but this is such a softball example lol. I use MI all the time at the drug rehab where I work. I had a client tell me the other day to go fuck myself and he doesn't care if he goes back to prison.
I think the idea of this is not to determine the validity of fruits and juice, but the process. Yes, too much fruit juice is not good. Also, yes, you can gain weight with too many fruits. They are all sugars and when you have any type of sugars, you release insulin. If you take in more than what the body can keep up with, then what is not stored will convert to fat. Also, he does focus entirely on the juice and not the other meals nor talking about exercise, stress, sleep, etc. See, there is a lot that needs to be covered but that's not the intent of the interview. The intent is to show how to use the MI techniques to evoke a response.
Thanks for the video! Check out my channel for short videos that focus on the spirit of MI! #BeToday kzread.info/dash/bejne/rJ9qsZqoZpjbdrA.html
Good, but you can't take away something...they need to replace with a doable solution. The focus was on stopping the drinking of calorie laced juice. But now what? Sugar free is not the solution!!! How can they make water more appealing? Leave them with a doable alternative that is their choice. But not fake sugars.
I think a more realistic goal would have been for the guy to reduce his intake of orange juice to one or two glasses a day, rather than trying to cut it out completely. For one thing, he said he really likes orange juice, so going cold turkey would probably result in a rebound. For another thing, I don't think one or two glasses of orange juice would have a negative effect on his health--in fact, orange juice contains many nutrients and antioxidants that would be quite good for him in moderation. The doctor also could have explored what KIND of orange juice he's buying and consider whether there are more healthy options that he could buy. For example, he may be getting a brand of orange juice which contains added sugars, and he might be able to switch to one without that extra sugar.
"Substitute with sugar free drinks!!!!" Why did the doctor not correct this statement by the patient. Sugar free drinks contain hormone disrupting chemicals. The fact that this doctor doesn't show any red flags to that... I would say he's working for the opposition. Good example of helpful questioning with hidden propoganda. Be discerning.
I caught that as well. 4 glasses of diet coke daily will insatiate his hunger and probably exacerbate his weight issues
RK Brown lol wot
The goal of the video is influencing change in the patient vs what you just did. A good Dr. doesn't "correct" the patient every time they say something false. You would never get anywhere, and no one wants an egotistical, pretentious Dr. (AKA, a dick).
@ Greg H: Sugar-free drinks are generally not "healthy", but one is definitely exacerbating his weight issues (excess juice, fruit), and the other could make him hungrier and "probably" exacerbate his weight issues. One is definite, one is not. So, if your goal is weight loss, ditching the fruit will unequivocally work; ditching the sugar-free drinks depends on the patient and how it affects them, and whether or not they increase their caloric intake. You can be hungry all day, that's never made anyone gain weight; calories do.
I loved how he ended the session.
He shared information about fruit juice vs whole fruit without asking permission or asking if the patient knew about any differences in calories between fruit juice and whole fruit to see what the patient might have known. If he didn't know the doctor could then ask permission to share the information with the patient. Still a good video
definitely going to incorporate the grading scale into my next MI! gReat video, very practical!
The doc had a lot of "I" statements. Agreed with him at one point.
I disagree that this is motivational interviewing. I thing the beginning is good. "I have a hunch" not quite motivational interviewing. Good skit though. Keep practicing.
2:16 is where this becomes doctors opinion (fact) and not motivational interviewing.
so the doctors shouldn't offer any facts to his patients?
Great example of motivational interview, just wish the doctor was a bit more empathetic, he kinda comes off harsh at times and his body language could be better.
He needs to slow down on the OJ!
I'm surprised at some of the negative comments. I have seen and participated in a lot of MI role plays, specifically in medical setting. This one is actually very well done.
+Erik Rostamian I really liked how the doctor asked his patient so many questions and also how he asked permission to discuss the issues with his patient. What I also noticed that seemed different (not better or worse, necessarily) was that it felt a little sales-ish when the doctor was asking several times for the patient's level of commitment. It wasn't the words as much as the sort of high-energy, aggressive manner. I agree with someone else's comments that this sort of pressure can likely lead someone to tell the doctor what they think the doctor wants to hear rather than expressing doubts and fears. This, to me, means that if a person "fails," they are more likely to feel ashamed and not want to return. I think it would be preferable to be very encouraging (which the doctor was) and positive (which he was), but also a bit less emphatic and aggressive. That is the MI quality that I think people were commenting on. Then again, maybe I'm wrong. Definitely possible.
very good
As one who has worked with young people for years, my question is does this video presentation sound like the typical interaction between a healthcare professional and a young person who is experimenting with or using alcohol? Does this resonate with anyone's experiences as to how an adolescent or anyone for that matter will respond to the type of intervention presented? The interviewer while sweet and non threatening was using a heavily scripted approach... even to the point of looking down at her notes at one point when planning to frame a question. I'd rather see the interviewer build a general rapport first and then move on to specific challenges the individual might face. Although clearly well intended, I don't believe that this video represents what occurs in real life.
GREAT ! This is the format in a medical setting with regard to time! I loved it. Thank you!!
Sorry, this has some elements of MI, but many non-adherent MI elements and I agree with one of the comments from the UK- this conversation is much longer than needs to be and could have much higher MI adherent skills.
Like what?
wow if i was the patient I would be freaking annoyed at my doctor!
Even though 'the patient' offered a detailed response, 'how many servings of fruits and vegetables do you have per day?' isn't exactly an open-ended question. I'm also getting the sense that motivational interviewing in a medical context does not have the same purpose or flow as MI in a therapeutic context.
This MI example sucked! It was NOT MI.
This IS a terrible example of MI. The spirit of MI is totally out the window. He sounds judgmental, DOES NOT ask for permission when educating, the list goes on and on...
Tons of directing, yes but communication...patronizing.
This is awful.
You're awful Bruce Berger
@@myoldvan119 this is not my video
Natural fruit juice without the sugar or artificial sweetener will not make you fat, but fruit juice loaded with sugar and other sweeteners like those cans of sodas CAN!
Oh My God! Fruit does NOT make you fat!
Wow, this is bad.
I feel his pain. "Boy, do I love that OJ!"... his face is priceless!
Hahahahha
You could always make orange juice from fresh oranges. That's what we do in my house, any time we have orange juice.
I hear ya, but this is an MI example. It elicits change in a therapeutic and empathy filled way.
I am a Medic in the UK. This guy must be being paid by the word and not have many patients. Over here it would be fill out a food diary, cut out the juice and clamp down on your wifes shopping. 30 secs tops. Natch!!
Way too scripted.
Be careful using the words "I understand," even if you do understand exactly what the patient is going through, try to use more reflective listening.
What would a better phrase be?
@@amanda.jan3767 it’s reflecting back using the persons words.
EtOH does not cause unintended sex.
Wow the Physician did an awesome job! This helped a lot. Thanks!
Thanks for the post!