Пікірлер

• 
  @davidjnulud10 күн бұрын

  Love this bro!! So encouraging and inspiring for real

• 
  @jedidiahnulud848010 күн бұрын

  Luke 9:23 AMEN

• 
  @CindyWilfongАй бұрын

  Thought provoking questions that were well-laid out. 👍

• 
  @davidjnuludАй бұрын

  Excited to go back to multiple parts of this for sure

• 
  @davidjnuludАй бұрын

  Yoooo this conversation is awesome!!! Thanks for putting this together

• 
  @theofficialness5782 ай бұрын

  Your understanding of determinism is very very very well understood.

• 
  @fr7nkyval2 ай бұрын

  I appreciate it

• 
  @jedidiahnulud84803 ай бұрын

  Never saw the end design of the room tho

• 
  @jedidiahnulud84803 ай бұрын

  Noice

• 
  @velocityonyt20653 ай бұрын

  "Your envision of beauty will not be your reality at first" my favorite line from this video 👏🏼

• 
  @jedidiahnulud8480 Жыл бұрын

  4 years old 😮

• 
  @jennasilaggi6974 Жыл бұрын

  Proud of you!!! 🦋

• 
  @jedidiahnulud8480 Жыл бұрын

  I am Team FREE WILL, and that's my free will to choose that

• 
  @tsdbhg Жыл бұрын

  Please tell me any decision you make that is independent from external influence. 🤔

• 
  @garretnarjes782 Жыл бұрын

  Irrelevant. Lets say that a decision is 99.999999999% determined, and 0.000000001% choice. That means that choice exists. Any amount of choice... is choice.

• 
  @tsdbhg Жыл бұрын

  @@garretnarjes782 The only irrelevant statement here is your incoherent rambling about %determined & %choice. I never said that people don't have choices. The discussion is about if people have free will or not. Free will, in philosophy and science is the supposed power or capacity of humans to make decisions or perform actions independently of any prior event or state of the universe. If decisions aren't independent of any external influence, then that means they are deterministic and there is no free will. Any amount of external influence, no matter how small is evidence that decisions are dependent. I have never made a decision that was independent of any external influence. I have yet to meet anyone else that has. If you think you have or can, then by all means... state your case.

• 
  @jitteryjet7525 Жыл бұрын

  I think the issue is no one has successfully defined what is "free will". What does it even mean - to me it is like asking what the colour blue smells like, a type of poorly-formed question. The laws of nature do appear to be deterministic.

• 
  @ranyork7626 Жыл бұрын

  Whos Will?

• 
  @jedidiahnulud8480 Жыл бұрын

  🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

• 
  @garretnarjes782 Жыл бұрын

  The fundamental problem I have against a deterministic argument is that the universe isn't deterministic. At this point in physics, we have good evidence that La Place's Demon is impossible, especially when an information theory of entropy. The amount of information in the universe is increasing, and therefore it is impossible to make a complete determination of future events based on the past. Even if you had 100% complete knowledge of the current and past state of the universe, you would have limited capacity to predict the future because NEW information is being generated all the time. The universe may not be deterministic, but it could be random. To which, even if it is random I have another response. Our brain is product of physics. If the constant interactions within our brain is creating new information (thus making the future of our states impossible to determine), that means we ourselves are not deterministic. The question still remains though, do we have agency in the outcomes influenced by our brain. This begs the question of what exactly is the determining line between free will and non-free will. I would argue that it should first be predicated on how we identify the self. If for the moment we discard any non-material concepts of the soul and only examine the material identity, we would rely on the physical form to decide what is "you" and "not you". Your body, and thus your brain, would be the sole determination for what we classify as "you". Your brain has to rely on physics to function, but as I just noted, your brain is "you". And thus, if "you" are the source of the non-deterministic outcomes, then that to me would imply free will. We also need to make sure we aren't committing any sort of fallacy here. Do your choices have to ALL be free will in order for free will to exist? The answer must be no. Lets say I am presented with 100 decision points. 99 of them, the outcome is determined by outside influences, but 1 I decide entirely on my own. Does free will exist? Yes, it does. That one example out of a hundred proves it does exist. The ratio is also irrelevant. If I make 2 billion decisions as determined by outside influences in my life, and only one decision entirely on my own, it still conclusively proves that free will does exist. There were millions of people who played the Powerball lottery in the US last week, but only one person won. Does the winner exist? Yes, they do. If you (your brain) make one decision in your whole life that cannot be determined causally by outside forces (since any internal force is the self), then free will exists.

• 
  @AbstractMan1 Жыл бұрын

  If it’s deterministic, free will can’t exist. If it’s random occurrences, free will still can’t exist. If it’s a soul, a soul is fixed so free will still cannot exist. If god knows your future, your future is fixed and therefore you cannot have free will. You may ‘feel’ as if you have free will, but that only makes free will a concept of feelsies while determinism remains a reflection of realsies.

• 
  @garretnarjes782 Жыл бұрын

  @@AbstractMan1 What a stupid reply to me.

• 
  @AbstractMan1 Жыл бұрын

  @@garretnarjes782 cope

• 
  @WhoThisMonkey Жыл бұрын

  As darkmatter put it, it's like a tax collector telling you, that you have a choice not to pay your taxes, but if you don't, you'll end up in jail.

• 
  @AbstractMan1 Жыл бұрын

  That is not analogous to free will because the issue of free will has nothing to do with the consequences of actions but if you have the ability to even choose to act at all.

• 
  @WhoThisMonkey Жыл бұрын

  @@AbstractMan1 Go to hell if you don't follow the rules, or go to heaven and be my slave if you do. I choose not being stuck in such a quagmire and carry on with my life not being bothered by silly beliefs that don't have justification.

• 
  @8xnnr Жыл бұрын

  One thing leads to another. Your brain obeys the laws of physics. Anyway understanding no free will doesn't require much time nor deep thinking, it's pretty simple. Random doesn't equal free will Determined doesn't equal free will Everything has a reason for happening (not in a magical sense)

• 
  @WhoThisMonkey Жыл бұрын

  How can you possibly know everything has a reason?

• 
  @AbstractMan1 Жыл бұрын

  @@WhoThisMonkey a reason meaning causal link. The process of cause and effect.

• 
  @WhoThisMonkey Жыл бұрын

  @@AbstractMan1 How do you know everything has a cause?

• 
  @AbstractMan1 Жыл бұрын

  @@WhoThisMonkey even if you could prove some quantum sequence without a variable that causes it to occur, then it be left to pure randomness. And randomness is as confining as determinism is in that there is no room for free will.

• 
  @WhoThisMonkey Жыл бұрын

  @@AbstractMan1 I don't need to 'prove' anything, I've not made any claims. I asked you how you could have knowledge behind the claims you made. You have the burden of proof.

• 
  @samanthabravo2462 Жыл бұрын

  I really enjoyed your video! Keep going at it Franky

• 
  @jedidiahnulud84802 жыл бұрын

  Ending was sick

• 
  @fr7nkyval2 жыл бұрын

  Thanks bro

• 
  @velocityonyt20652 жыл бұрын

  Minority on minority racism? Damn we moving backwards huh, great video tho homie.

• 
  @fr7nkyval2 жыл бұрын

  That’s what I’m saying 😪 thanks bro

• 
  @danilettuce22822 жыл бұрын

  so proud of you!!! love this sm

• 
  @fr7nkyval2 жыл бұрын

  Thanks Dani💖

• 
  @jedidiahnulud84802 жыл бұрын

  Bro first of all, this was AWESOME!! I could tell how hard u worked on it bro, editing, script and everything 2nd: correct grammar is where does your happiness LIE 3rd: your subscribers need to know about the man at the end of the video and the story of what happened LOL

• 
  @fr7nkyval2 жыл бұрын

  Thanks bro 🥺 2nd: dang I guess that reading ain’t helping me enough 😪 3rd: lol I was literally standing there waiting for him to pass so I can film and he started snapping at me for no reason