Really enjoyed the live action, but this was done WAY better in the anime! Our reactions to eps 36-37 are out now on Patreon! www.patreon.com/carlie_and_ange

@gaara_of_the_desert1118

5 күн бұрын

Glad to see live action originals not stuck with the mindset of "my first experience is the best by default."

@leowankenobi6582

5 күн бұрын

1. Manga 2. Anime 3. Live action

@motivationalburst

5 күн бұрын

so you get to "the walk" :D

@melvinmacaulay711

4 күн бұрын

In the one piece community we refer to Kuina as Down D Steps lol instead of like a Monkey D Garp or Monkey D luffy or Marshall D Teach or any of those with D in their name

@gaara_of_the_desert1118

4 күн бұрын

@@melvinmacaulay711 Those names are spoilers.

"I'm hungry I'm going to sleep" is actually a very old joke in my country 😂 if you're too broke and don't have anything to eat you just go to bed and sleep so you don't think about how hungry you are.

@Tien1million

5 күн бұрын

Also to preserve energy.

@mateussoares3569

5 күн бұрын

that is not a joke dude kkkk, is real, you sleep o not feel the hungry and reserve your energy

@kasagure.

5 күн бұрын

sleep for dinner exists in every culture 😂

@cocofirebird

4 күн бұрын

Exactly what my mom told me to do sometimes as a kid. Funny thing was, I did it every time mindlessly😂.

@Daniel-ik7tu

4 күн бұрын

Im currently on that phase and maybe never came back

Dont worry Ange. In an old interview Oda was asked if the One Piece was something immaterial like family bonds and Oda replied "No, I Hate That Kind Of Thing. That's like the ending of The Wizard of Oz, which I watched when I was a kid. Adventuring that long, and having the adventure itself be the treasure, is really dissatisfying. Those kinds of stories are impossible. It feels like, 'I've gone on this long adventure, so give me the treasure!'" So it is an actual treasure, we just dont know what.

I cant wait to see Carlie crying again at Sanji's backstory

@ammahdgrant

4 күн бұрын

And nami's... And almost any other backstory after it...

@memeswey

4 күн бұрын

robin...

@AheaJen292

4 күн бұрын

@@ammahdgrant I know this far in the future but Law and Corazon 🥲

@AheaJen292

4 күн бұрын

@@memeswey Brook's 🤧🥲😢😭

@TheOctaviusLee

4 күн бұрын

@@ammahdgrant now that I've watched the anime after the live action, I don't think the live action did nami's backstory justice, it hits WAY harder in the anime

This was the episode where I started to like Usopp because he brought the coffee tumbler with him 😂 that’s so random but funny 🤣

@Loliston

4 күн бұрын

He's so freaking casual about it too, love it so much

im addicted to this channel and this anime rotation, Avatar, HXH and One Piece, too much greatness

@MonkeyDUchiha56

4 күн бұрын

I can't say about HXH n Avatar, (they're aslo great) but One Piece is in whole another level especially after episode 300, you'll be obsessed with this show and every charatcers.

Down d. Stairs 😭

@anqeetbhusal5760

5 күн бұрын

😂

@nimo_ku

5 күн бұрын

Still cant believe down d. stair killd her

@arvinsim

5 күн бұрын

The Will of D!

@rafaelmedeiros7847

5 күн бұрын

​@@arvinsimworst enemy 😂

@RichardVision

5 күн бұрын

🤣

Why I like Zoro’s back story is they tell you how awful accidents can easily kill great people or potential people even if they’re strong.

@nimo_ku

5 күн бұрын

Though cant believe she died

@Jojirius

5 күн бұрын

Accidents can kill you even if you're strong, but taking multiple bullets to the chest will never kill you even if you're weak. One Piece is a world of contradictions - yet it makes us laugh and cry anyway!

@Triattt

4 күн бұрын

"potential people" creatures that have the potential to become a person. *Insert misogynist joke here*

@visoth7791

4 күн бұрын

Super minor spoiler warning (for Ange/Carlie): . . . . People only die in flashbacks. Point further proven with this episode.

@Orochi8Strange

4 күн бұрын

@@visoth7791 hm? what about....ehm certain flaming hot young man?

"Is the one piece real?" Someone might have something to say about that in a few hundred episodes 👀

@Incrediblerach

4 күн бұрын

Hahaha I was just about to say the same thing 😂

@gddbrothers2002

3 күн бұрын

🏴‍☠️🐋🐻‍❄️

The One Piece isn’t "the friends we made along the way" Oda said he doesn’t like this cliche. Imagine investing in a 1000+ series only for the OP to be that dumb, people are gonna RIOT😂 Also people who caught up have a slight idea what it may be from the hints we are picking up.

@humanoidfrog4645

5 күн бұрын

As a manga reader who's caught up, you're gonna have to tell me ngl

@phobic1818

5 күн бұрын

😂😂​@@humanoidfrog4645

@leonardogallo9126

5 күн бұрын

@@humanoidfrog4645 clearly a corkscrew /s -maybe?-

@luisdanielvega99

5 күн бұрын

i dont understand this types of comments like they are in ep 19 bro, nobody that reaches 500 eps of one piece will think the one piece is friendship.

@Shiftarus

4 күн бұрын

I dont think it will be "the friends we etc etc" but I DO think it will be something that in the end only serves as a giant gag. A punchline to a gigantic joke

As you can imagine there are a loot of storys and backstorys in one piece. And the beauty of it is everyone has their own favourite one. Subjectively i think untill this day they get better and better and better

Moments/Episodes like Gaimons are not really filler per say. They are very much made with intent. These moments are there to showcase character traits that the crew have. Luffy saying "no" when it came to giving the treasure show that he is very empathetic to a person who is passionate about their dreams. This is why Gaimon says "Straw Hat you're a really great guy" These small little moments are what build our characters and show what they are all about in small ways that build up over time. People complain about the Live Action being so short for this very reason, because theres not enough time to really highlight their personalities and show how they interact with each other, episodes like this do exactly that. One Piece fans LOVVVVVEEE just moments where the Strawhats can just interact with each other in silly low stakes situations like this. As the story goes theres less and less time for these moments so they are often looked upon fondly.

FYI - Johnny and Yosaku was omitted in the live action, similarly to the kids in Usopp's island. So you definitely shouldn't remember them.

A wise old man once said "THE ONE PIECE IS REALLL"

In the one piece world, humans can live up to at least 141 years old. confirmed in an SBS. So Gaimon still has a life to look forward to

@Maxpain350

5 күн бұрын

At least? There is only one person at that age and that's the oldest human we know

@Armaggeddon95

5 күн бұрын

Should we really be using Kureha as a standard for humans? 😂

@TheAll_Memes

5 күн бұрын

@@Maxpain350 but we have never seen people die of old age. Most of the 'young' people die from unidentified diseases

@Maxpain350

5 күн бұрын

@@TheAll_Memes we see old people struggle in there life, like whitebeard, even Kureha everyone was joking about her age means that it's not common to reach that age

@paulcallahan7727

5 күн бұрын

Wanna know the secret of my youth?

The One Piece is real❤️‍🔥

@YouAreBeautiful8

5 күн бұрын

Can we get much higher?

@xdrago5602

5 күн бұрын

@@YouAreBeautiful8 so hiiiiiiggghhhhh

@ArnafBh

2 күн бұрын

@@YouAreBeautiful8 Yep so so highh

I get that people found the live action fun, and I know you enjoyed it and it got you into the anime, but the anime does literally everything better. They added so much stuff to the live action that didn't need to be there, and took out a lot of these moments that needed more time and emotion to be fleshed out, and to me personally, it robbed the story of a lot of its soul.

@MindSamurai94

23 күн бұрын

This this absolutely this!

@dustyacer

22 күн бұрын

i dont think absolutely everything, there were a few moments i did like more in the LA, but they just werent that significant. I personally enjoyed Zeff a lot more, and also LA did follow the manga backstory rather than censoring it. There were also a lot more small moments. But yes i agree anime is better in 95% of other places.

@sohilanime8577

20 күн бұрын

true bro

@bru6176

5 күн бұрын

and manga is even better

@shreyassali2291

5 күн бұрын

not to mention, it spoiled the surprise of garp

it's kinda funny to me that in this story people get thrown at mountains destroy half of it from the impact and still don't die and then there's also kuina who died from a simple fall from the stairs. It's just such a contrast lmao and she wasn''t even weak child she trained and was pretty strong.

@tranatkikomi6873

3 күн бұрын

That’s just it. There are people strong as an ox who have died to the simplest of accidents or illnesses. And there are weaker people who have come out of some pretty serious things with nary an issue. That’s how life can be.

Down d. Stairs is here😢

NOTE: basically the story of Gaimon was set before the arc of Usopp, the only difference its that they added "after" including Usopp in the story, Gaimon still also one of the fav characters that the author made and he still appears in some merch XD

@Skaasi

3 күн бұрын

gaimon made an appearance in the latest chapter 😅

@skyuru

3 күн бұрын

@@Skaasi yes and cover stories but very, very, very rarely.

Appreciate the uploads guys ❤😊

Ange has never been broke. The best way to avoid hunger is to sleep through it.

mann!!!!!!!you don't know what is coming ahead........pure fun.......I still dont know how they're gonna do it in live action

i feel like right now it is fine since you guys have been introduced to very few characters but later on you guys should just give luffy and zoro a fixed position and make a top 5 without them because otherwise they will never leave that section in whole of 1100+ ep.

25:06 As Edward Newgate said: cmon you know what he said

@boitaho

4 күн бұрын

Can we get much higher?

Yeah, that's what happens when you get so much more time to dedicate to a section like Zoro's backstory. They had to cut a lot of the background and try to boil it down to the absolute essentials. I think they did really well in the live action for the restrictions they had.

I just started one piece cuz I thought why the heck not Ive watched supernatural (lengthy show) just got up to ep 7 so cant wait to see where it goes I'm having such a laugh rn:) you 2 kinda inspired me to watch it if I'm being honest so thanks💜🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

When people tell you Oda has “pretty good foreshadowing” that is an understatement 😂 Oda does foreshadowing like nobody else! So much that when you watch a new arc you feel like rewatching the series again, it can completely re contextualise certain things that have happened previously. I love One Piece for this reason, the world building, characters and lore are the best out there. This is why One Piece is my favourite story of all time.

They did it. They made it to the stretchy question.

Kuina and Zoro are the kind of polar opposites: One was a victim of cruel fate, a promising life cut short. The other is a defier of fate who refused to die despite the odds.

Don't worry, it's not a spoiler, Oda said already he won't do a "it's the friends along the way" in the end. That's HxH message if anything

Look forward to seeing your next episodes reactions!

Can’t Wait to see you guys meet Sanji in anime 😂 He built different

I recently got Luffy's drawing of the jolly roger tattooed on my arm at a house party XD I love the three rows of teeth

"Every part of Luffy stretches". "It is inappropriate." "Luffy will get all the girls" Man man man........ I just leave it here for record.

SBS @ 25:50

"Is the One Piece real?" I know just the guy you can ask

congrats for reaching episode 19, only 1100 episodes left to catch up with us .

11:01 the right question.

god i love your guys' reactions. you are both so funny which makes whatever youre watching even more funny. im glad you liked zoros backstory

Fun fact for you guys, there is 2 easter eggs from Gaimon episode in LA. The grass sculptures in Kayas Mansion, and a portrait in the Baratie

Can't skip the We Are cover. So good!

My new favorite KZread reaction channel 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻

@CarlieAndAnge

23 сағат бұрын

Appreciate you! ❤️❤️

the live action definitely had to cut a lot out of the backstory, but loved yalls reactions

One of the things I missed in the live action was Luffy and Zoro sharing the same brain cell. I hope we get more of that in season two. Zoro almost always knows exactly what Luffy’s thinking before anyone else does, they both share a mindset of “act first, think later,” and they’re frequently dumb in the same way. Luffy’s a lot more gullible than Zoro and obviously they have very different temperaments, but there’s so many times during the anime/manga that they’ll both do or say something and I think “yep, they’re the same person.” 😂

loved the intro cover

Actually, Oda said that the One Piece is a physical treasu- You know what, I think Patreon gang gotchu on this one.

Fun facts, there is a photo of this island in the live action :3 really great

Johnny and Yosaku Dawgs rise up! I love when side characters get to tagalong with the straw hats for a little while to get some commentary from outside the actual crew. Johnny and Yosaku were the two characters I was most disappointed about them not being included in the live action but I get it. They're not important to the overall plot but I enjoyed those two goofballs while they lasted.

I have watched over 20 reactions to the live action series. So far, I haven’t seen any one of the reactions who found Zorro’s backstory bad and you even said it’s terrible. in the live action. I can’t agree with that. It was short but even in the anime it’s really abrupt. it’s meant to be like that. if that was bad, I think your backstory standards are really high. Anyway, keep up the good work.

7:32 Zoro and Luffy thinking the exact same thing is not really a running gag but I do love it when it happens.

Remember that A LOT was cut from the anime/manga to make the live action. Johnny was one of them.

This is just an Appetizer, i will look forward to see your reaction to how different the Anime is from the Live-Action. Also, Gaimon is just one of many that Luffy will effect by meeting them.

It would be nice if you guys could do a review of the arcs after finishing Arlong Park.

@CarlieAndAnge

5 күн бұрын

Not only that, but we’ll do a comparison to the live action as well

@yolurozo9761

4 күн бұрын

That would be cool​@@CarlieAndAnge

Hello Carlie and Ange I watched another channel's OP reaction yesterday, they were harsh and disliked the episodes (what a bad taste) so I was glad to watch you today. You healed my OP FAN heart a little bit😬

@the-A-and-the-Z

4 күн бұрын

On the episode itself, there is still debate on whether Kuina fell downstairs or was murdered (there is even a famous mème of a "Down D. stairs" character, expected to be the culprit, please don't search for it as it may be a spoiler). Some of those who think that Kuina died in a tragic accident also claim that, thank's to this rather unceremonial death, zoro learned how life can end in an instant which contributed in forging him as a character and a swordsman, you might see that once you will get to know him more.

25:04 "is the one piece real?" you might ask?

The strongest of Zoro's childhood; Down D. Stairs

I think when kid Zoro was "crying" he was actually sleeping but like in 10x speed or something LOL at least that's what I thought

"Is the One Piece real?" *cue thousands of people shouting at their screens*

The more you know about OnePiece, the more u understand the Gaimon episode 18.

[spoilers in the final paragraph] A bit more of Kuina and Zoro's backstory was released in the Q&A much later. It's generally assumed the author wanted to intclude Zoro's origin in the main story nad was building to it for a long time but eventually he didn't manage to do so so he disclosed a few things in the Q&A and confirmed a couple of fan theories with that. It also kinda fit's Zoro's character not to really be interested about his past and ancestry as that's not in his character. Zoro and Kuina come from the couple of immigrants of the island of samurai. Both come from an aristocrat faimy that coruled it and are distantly related. Zoro is not aware of any of that.

I'd love to see a Opening reaction to one piece like you did for Fullmetal, but we would have to wait like 7 years for that 😂 Watching it now could be a minor spoiler (you dont see that much besides the additional crewmembers actually...) but it could also be very entertaining to listen to your theories...

So many people either forget or don’t really think about the fact that Gaimon literally says to buy the world itself. Luffy being the richest man on the planet isn’t talked about enough among the fan base. Being pirate king is one thing, having a royal family or starting a lineage and being recognized as nobility etc etc. But enough money to buy everything up is wild.

Man I got chills . Never realized it until now. Oda just revealed Luffy's true dream on this episode. The biggest spoiler 🤯🤯🤯

I literally cannot wait until June 30th😭😭😭😭

Johnny and Yosaku were not in the live action, so don't worry Ange, you didn't forget anyone (this time) also, Zoro is my favorite character, and always has been, i am caught up and current with the anime, i am watching your reactions as a way of rewatching/remembering stuff from earlier episodes/arcs

@GreenTeam-re3jy

4 күн бұрын

I personally find johnny and yosaku really annoying definitely the weakest part of one piece to me

@vRED13vTTV

3 күн бұрын

@@GreenTeam-re3jy they are around for one reason only, which we see in Arlong Park

I think everyone thinks it's the friends we meet along the way (even just briefly), until a certain point (nothing specific) when we don't think so lol...

Imagine Gaimon joining the crew lmao. Going through the Grand Line and all the future shit with GAIMON of all people cracks me up.

@inquisitive6786

5 күн бұрын

Gaimon, Brook and Chopper woulda been a great trio and you know it

@MarioPrimePlays

4 күн бұрын

@@inquisitive6786 maybe if Gaimon ate a devil fruit I’d agree lol. Gaimon’s probably high on the antics but he needs to up his hands.

@inquisitive6786

4 күн бұрын

@@MarioPrimePlays Gaimon doesnt need a fruit to be a cool character on the ship. Powerscaling is cancer.

Y'all are right. The live action just didn't pull off the Zoro backstory, and the anime did a really good job. The bar was set too high lol

The parallel of Zoro climbing the well, and his backstory done likewise, it was done in a good directorial way. Longtime anime fans loved it as well, sure some moments like the whole community aspect was missing, thats a downer. Not knowing how she died, was one to one with the manga, her falling down the stairs was an Anime addition. So LA only guys did not like how it ended, and so felt that the backstory was weak.

Don’t worry Oda confirmed the One Piece is a tangible thing

Is invincible s2 on the patreon?

24-25 can't wait

WE NEED MORE ONE PIECEEEEEEEE

Are y'all gonna react to the other two animes from the big 3, Naruto and Bleach at some point in the future?

I haven’t seen anyone mention this but Kuina’s death is a bit controversial in the fandom because “Falling down the stairs” is a Japanese expression to hide a death by suicide/domestic violence. 🥲 Regardless her death was still a sudden and tragic event for Zoro 😢

@tranatkikomi6873

3 күн бұрын

It is not either of those things and people always mentioned it. It’s just people trying to give extra to Kuina’s death which ruins what Oda was going for. She fell down stairs and died as a result. Life is fleeting. Life is fragile. And losing his friend/rival/goal to something that simple makes Zoro more aware of that.

@paulromero2937

3 күн бұрын

It is not

I dont know if this was intentional but in the live action, even that it wasnt mentioned how Kuina died, they actually put an easter egg on how she died during the battle of Zoro and the two subordinates of Kuro on episode 4. There is a scene where Sham (the green haired cat pirate girl) stole the Wado Ichimonji (Kuina's sword) from Zoro and then following up by falling down the stairs, which simply resembled how Kuina died (this is more believable to be intentional because of the fact that they changed Sham's gender into a girl)

THE ONE PIECE! THE ONE PIECE IS REAL!!

love your reaction guys so much i also want u guys to react to bleach or naruto along with one piece if possible after HxH

14:15 You will have to wait another 20 years for that answer :P

i feel like anges favourite might change after a hundred eps, especially after during eps 100-200

Both Sanji and Zoro are my favourite characters. I just can't choose one and i can assure you will gonna love both characters but in a very different way since both characters are very polar opposite but both have such a likeable personality. Live ation Zoro seems kinda edgy and not so funny but anime Zoro is whole package of daddy and also very funny. And, about One Piece treasure being only friends you make along the way is kinda cap since Oda already confirmed it as tangible thing and you may kinda guess what it could be after going through episode to episode or arc to arc. Even we manga reader do not know exactly what it is but we can guess this now at least. Hope this is not spoiler😅 Anyway love that you guys enjoying it. Every arc is like journey and you guys will feel that you are also with them together on their journey like strawhats. Enjoy the ride and hope you get more one piece fans as subscribers. GOOD LUCK!!

As a longtime fan of the anime and manga, I thought the live action was ok. I don't think they did too badly; just that they sometimes made changes that made me feel like they didn't really understand the personalities of the characters. Especially Luffy. What annoyed me the most was that they took one of Luffy's best traits (to me anyway) and completely erased it so that they could give him a 'justification' for why he decided to help people. I loved the fact that Luffy doesn't need that sort of thing if he decides that someone is important to him. Maybe you'll see the difference when you get to Arlong Park... Or maybe you won't notice it at all 😅. It just bothered me personally...

They say she died falling down the stairs getting a wetstone to shapen her blade. If I was Zoro I would blame myself for that deat because she needed that wetstone because of me.

THE ONE PIECE! THE ONE PIECE IS REAL!!!!!!!!

Zoro and Usopp backstories both got pretty rushed treatment in the live action, but mostly out of necessity. Lack of Johnny and his partner are similar. Once you finish Arlong Park and catch up to where the LA left off you'll understand exactly how much stuff was cut/reworked/compressed to get down to 8 episodes.

25:05 oh boy......

Down D Stairs claims it's first victim

One of the weirdest writing moments that she just dies. Youre left more ok? Than actually being sad

The live action was fantastic. However, it did and will continue to have the issue of condensing the story. This is its greatest challenge as the world gets more and more expansive and complex the further into the series you go.

ahh i see you met the goat gaimon

Down.D stairs the strongest character in one piece

Yeah, one piece is REALL

this will be even more interesting and to be honest one piece anime is much more detailed and in depth in terms of story and characters... you will really like it.. continue the reaction

There is A LOT that was missed in the Live action. though it was created well there is just a lot about the live action that doesn't come close to the anime XD

Ill hype it up more. It's fucking crazy in the grand line.

lol loved the live action as a fan! For sure! But expect the anime to be better in many ways ofc! The live action is honestly fanservice for me Fr

You guys would LOVE hajime no ippo day 5

It says that this video was released 2 hours ago, yet I'm seeing comments made 3 weeks ago 🤨

Unfurtunately Johnny wasn't in the live action. By the way his another reason that "HITS YOU 3x HARDER" in the anime 😊