আমি সহমত হামিন ভাইয়ের সাথে। সবগুলো কথাই ভেবে দেখার মতো।

Knowledge is something which can't be taken from anyone. Mr. Hamin is absolutely nailed it. And I do agree about the word "Bangla" it should be Coke Studio Bangladesh...

গুণীজনই গুণীজনকে চেনেন। হাসান ভাইয়েরা কথা বলার জন্য ধন্যবাদ... ❤️❤️❤️

@imdadchowdhury6653

Ай бұрын

হাসান ভাই কে

@CricketFreak71

Ай бұрын

@@imdadchowdhury6653 ভাই, আপনার মনে হয় রক মিউজিক নিয়ে কথা না বলাই বেটার। আর্ক, হাসান ভাই কে যদি না চিনে থাকেন তাহলে ভাই বাংলা ব্যান্ড জনরা টা আপনার জন্য না...

@engr.hasnatchowdhury4384

Ай бұрын

হাসান ভাইকে যে চিনে না তার মমতাজের গান নিয়েই পড়ে থাকা দরকার। ব্যান্ড কিংবা রক মিউজিক তার জন্য না।

@CricketFreak71

Ай бұрын

@@engr.hasnatchowdhury4384 ঠিকই বলেছেন ভাই। ভাগ্য তার সহায় ছিল না। নয়তো একটা সময়ে উনি বাচ্চু ভাই, জেমস ভাইয়ের থেকেও উপরে এক নম্বরে ছিলেন...

@MrProtikiub

Ай бұрын

@@CricketFreak71এইসব নাম্বারিং কি আপনার বানানো নাকি অথেনটিক কোন সোর্স আছে?

ভাইয়ার কথা গুলোর সাথে সহমত পোষন করলাম। হামিন আহমেদ একজন লিজেন্ডারি শিল্পী। উনার মূল্যবান কথা গুলো বিবেচনা করা উচিত।

Spot on. Ei jonnei amader Coke Studio hit or miss. Unfortunately beshi bhaag e miss.

Thanks Hamin vai for your honest views. I hope Arnob vai will take advices. Say for example the Bappa vai was singing Tagore song when he himself has many popular songs. It should have been done by Sadi Mohammed or Kaderi Kibria. Now even Sadi Mohammed passed away. And I also agree that coke studio Bangladesh should be the name of the programme.

Coke Studio Bangladesh howa uchit chilo, not Bangla - Respect for you for saying it out Loud

সত্য কথা বলার জন্য ধন্যবাদ 👊✌️

Vai this is called legend. he was 100% right about the name Coke Studio Bangladesh. now it doesn't make any sense and no identity. When legends talk they talk like legend and this is what Hamin Sir commented about Coke Studio Bangla!!!

কোক স্টুডিও এর গান দুদিন চলে তিনদিনের দিন পচে যায়।তাহলে বুঝতে হবে গানের মান। নাসেক নাসেক এখন কজন শুনেন?

@SaadmanSalahuddin

Ай бұрын

Unfortunately Nasek Nasek tai best chilo. Onno gula mone rakhar moto na.

@saju3791

Ай бұрын

exactly.... I don't know whom to blame... audience is clapping, producer is getting paid, industry is getting profit.

5:53 এর পরের কথা গুলো মারাত্মক। একদম মনের কথা বলেছেন।

absolutely agree with Hamin Ahmed.

100/ Agreed.well said bro !

Hasan vai er kotha bolar jonno dhonnobad

১০০ ভাগ ঠিক কথা। কোক স্টুডিও বাংলাদেশ না হয়ে বাংলা কেনো হলো ????.....উনার সকল কথা ই একদম ঠিক.....!!!

হামিন ভাইয়ের কথা গুলো ভাল লেগেছে

CS PAKISTAN is highlighting their languages other than urdu and punjabi this season. So, what was wrong in us showcasing on languages of our region that are not mainstream???

হামিন আহমেদ স্যার সঠিক কথা বলেছে

well said!!

Thanks hamin bhai

Agreed. Well said brother. 👍

You are absolutely right Hamin Bhai

Spot on @ hamin vai.

Hamin Bhai Thank you

খুব বেশি সুন্দর হয়েছে

Sohomot Hamin Bai ❤

Spot on!

I agree with him totally. It should be Coke studio Bangladesh. Though in my opinion it's good to recreate our root songs sometimes.

I agree on the last fact

Mr. Hamin, you are wrong through and through. CS pakistan had done episodes with the likes of Abida Parvin, Rahat Fateh, etc. Are they pop singers? They had also collborated with musicians of other countries like Turkiye, etc., so why can't we? It's been announced that we have collaborted with multiple countries this year, not just India, so please relax.

@kobitachannel6047

Ай бұрын

নাম change করে coke studio Bangladesh রাখেন। অন্তত এই কথাটা তো ঠিক।

@amarkagojpati1825

Ай бұрын

@@kobitachannel6047 na thik chilo na. Choto chintar Manush ER choto chintar prokash chilo.

@user-tz1kj7ip5k

Ай бұрын

আপনার কথার মধ্যেই প্রমাণ হয়, আপনি নিজেই একটা ছোটোলোক। কিসের নলেজের বড়াই করেন, ভাই। কয়টা ব্যান্ডের কনসার্টে সামনে থেকে দেখছেন ​। হামিন আহমেদ কে চিনলে এটলিস্ট এই কথাটা বলতেননা। আরে ভাই, ভুল কি বলসে। উনি তো শুধু কোক স্টুডিও বাংলাদেশ নামকরণ করতে বলসে। ইন্ডিয়া তে তো কয়েকশো ভাষা আছে। তাই বলে কি সেইসব ভাষার নামকরণে নিয়ে কোক স্টুডিও করসে?? কোক স্টুডিও ভালো কিসু দেওয়ার নামে লিটারেলি একটা ব্যবসা আর ভন্ডামী শুরু করসে। এভারেজ বেশিরভাগ পুরনো গানে তিলকে তাল বানানো হইসে। 😂😂😂 @@amarkagojpati1825

একটা কথাও খারাপ হয় নি সব সঠিক এবং যুক্তিযুক্ত

Well said hamin bhai

একদম 🙏🙏

কোক স্টুডিও নিয়ে কোন কথা হবে না,বাংলাদেশের মিউজিক কে অন্য লেভেলে নিয়ে গেছে কোক স্টুডিও।

Fully agreed

His 100 percent right

Coke studio Bangladesh ! Hamim bh is correct ..

Hamin bhai router er wrapper plastic ta khulen.

I think Hamin Bhai has rightly pointed out what has been echoed by so many Bangladeshis from the start of this nonsense. The fact that the show should have been called Coke Studio Bangladesh instead of the farce that they decided to name. I also agree with the fact that they should have started with established songs and try and make contemporary renditions rather than establish themselves as "intellectual" music producers. There was no need for this force-fed propaganda, art should always be free of that nonsense.

ভাইয়াদের ডাকে নাই এখনো, জন্মদিনের গান গাইতে।

@kobitachannel6047

Ай бұрын

ভাইয়ারা পুছেও না

@sonoffreedomfighter5319

Ай бұрын

হামিন ভাইদের সমপর্যায়েও কেউ নাই

ajob moto kotha talent hunt amra bujhi na? Ornob ja kortache ta amader ashol bangladesh er porichoy hasan bhai ki ekai ache koi james bhai re to akhon obdi ane nai. eta aholey aste aste agabe system way... jei track gula banglar oitijjo segula agey jabe etai sabhabik.coke studio pak super hit hoiche bidhay baki sokol desh e geche r tader system o tai chilo pakistani folk song gulo beshi kora hoiche. kotha buijha bola uchit.

ভাই পাকিস্তান কি করছে সেটা আমাদের ফলো করার দরকার কি

@ehsaan55

Ай бұрын

He didn't say so, just made an example. And Coke Studio is originally Pakistani and that's what it got the popularity and franchises in different countries.

India খুব কালচারড সোসাইটি, হামিন ভাই?!

@hypocritehippocampus5479

Ай бұрын

Gaan er culture er kotha bolechen. Thik e bolechen.

Aan dek, shob thik hoye jabe.

He is son of kamal das Gupta. Elegance family.

like ....

এই ধরনের সম আলোচনাই দরকার। ঝাকজমক পূর্ন কিছু হলেই যে সেটা সফল বিষয়টা তা নয়। পাকিস্তান কোক স্টুডিওর ভিউ বেশি হলেও সমালোচনার শিকার হচ্ছে কারন তারা ভিজুয়ালাইজেশন এখানে মূল বিষয় হলো সুর। আমাদের বাংলাদেশে ভাল সিংগার নাই যারা হাই নোটে গাইতে পারে কিন্তু ভাল যন্ত্রশিল্পী আছে। যযন্ত্রসংগীতের অনুষ্ঠান হলে বাংলাদেশ সেরা।

There is only one point to agree with hamin ahmed is that the name should be Coke Studio Bangladesh, not bangla.

Coke studio onek bhalo bhalo gaan korse ebong popularity o paise. But shob e copy kora amader habit hoye gese. Amader originality koi?cinema gaan shob e copy.

Lastly, Mr. Hamin, how many episodes did Coke Studio INDIA do highlighting BANGLA that they would invite us to join the party?? Their focus has been mainly north; i don't know if that will change or not. But we named it Coke Studio Bangla to uphold the greater regipn of Bengal because BANGLADESH is only 50+ years old, but BENGAL, BANGLA, BENGALIS have been around for over a thousand year if not more. And of course, there could have been copyright claims as we saw with some songs. Bottomline, territorialism might work in some cases, but here we are celebrating the commonness of language and culture. When coke studio Pakistan drops a punjabi song, indian punjab also dance to it. So, come out of that narrowness and think global, think big.

@bhoboghure7393

Ай бұрын

And in season 3 they have brought out a legendary song OBAK BHALOBASHA hoping they will cover more songs like this up ahead

Pritom hasan is serving justice to coke studio bangla, tho yes bangladesh howa uchit chilo .

Vaiya Beshi Jolcea tai na 😅

True, should have been Coke Studio Bangladesh not Bangla.

@GreysDen

Ай бұрын

বাংলাদেশের ইতিহাস অনেক ছোটো, বাঙালির ইতিহাস হাজারো বছরের। শুধু ৭১ থেকে আমাদের সংস্কৃতির জন্ম না। নাম ঠিক ই আছে, স্বীকার করেন বা না করেন।

Coke Studio Bangla has done more highlighting unknown gems and our forgotten culture than any of these people or show has done. It's easy to sit on your couch and criticise other people's work but every music video comes with 100+ talented people behind em. So unless you can do better, sit down, stay quiet and move along. People like these with guitars think they know all about our culture and what is or isn't worth people's attention. It's pathetic that he criticises Coke Studio Bangla for highlighting Shaotal and people of other ethnic backgrounds.

@OHRStudio

Ай бұрын

Bangla band music has an enriched history and place in Bangla music and also it has become an inseparable part of our Bangla culture. And Hamin sir's along with Miles' contribution to that can't be underestimated. Coke Studio is bringing new faces and the songs are getting short term hypes. But I find myself rarely to listen to their songs from previous season. Whereas I listen to songs of Miles, Souls that were created even 10 years before my birth. Songs from 30-40 years back. And people still appreciate those. Anyome who will look at the bigger picture won't be able to say such thing. They not only know about culture but created an era. Also his mother Firoza Begum mam was one of the most promiment Nazrul geeti singer and father Kamol Dasgupta even gave tune to many songs Kazi Nazrul Islam wrote. Department of Music, University of Dhaka gives scholarship every year to the brightest student and a renowned musician of the country every year that is in her name. Without this family our culture would look different. This is where their place is.

হাসান,আর্ক

Coke Studio Bangladesh chai ......

হুদা প্যাচাল

Nepotism ছিল আছে থাকবে ✌️✌️✌️ 🫡🫡🫡

@amarkagojpati1825

Ай бұрын

SHOB kisur moddhe dhormo na tanle chulkay tai na??? Arnob babur moto eto Kom somoye EI platform daar koranor murod apnar Hamin saheb DER chilo na, bujhchen??? Joggo Manush KE shomman ditey shikhun, tar dhormo na DEKHE. Aajke pakistanai rao proshonsha korche JE CS BANGLA parallel ey chole ashche, AAR apnader moto KISU ondho bekti ra hamlacche.

কোক স্টুডিও বাংলাদেশ হওয়ার কথা ছিল এটা ঠিক বলেছেন।

আমরা বুঝি কিন্তু কিছু বলি না!বলতে পারিনা শাসক দল যার যা ইচ্ছা তাই করছে।

নোলক বাবু, বারে বারে স্ট্রোক করছে। তার শরীর খুব খারাপ। সে হারিয়ে যায় নাই।

Arnob needs higher level guidance from people like Hamin/Bachcchu.

@sadmurshid5135

Ай бұрын

Absolutely. So that we can get another Hamin, Shafin and so many other bullshit who only stay under past. What Arnab made using CSB is absolutely right thing. Can we make more? Obviously, CSB trying. Can he(Hamim) bring change. I don’t think so. See the last 20 years.

পাগলে কি না বলে ছাগলে কি না খায়

In Pakistan the overall responsibility of Coke Studio was given to a famous, successful and experienced musical-band called Strings. Since Strings was a successful band, they knew how to make Coke Studio successful. Coke Studio Bangla shoulder get a facelift starting from changing it's name to Coke Studio Bangladesh. Secondly the overall responsibility shoulder be given to an experienced & successful musical-band like Miles, Souls, Feedback etc. and not to an idiot like Ornob. Mr. Ornob had only one good song, he was not a successful musician, how can he make Coke Studio successful ?

@TanvirAhmed-gh1en

Ай бұрын

Yes you r right.Rohail Hayat the famous keyboard player of Vital Signs was the first music director of Coke studio Pakistan. After few years Strings played a role as music director. Till now Coke Studio Pakistan is the most famous n successful platform

@syedali4097

Ай бұрын

@@TanvirAhmed-gh1en You are correct . Rohail Hayat himself was a successful musician and founded Vital Signs which was an extremely successful pop band. He represented Vital Signs in the early years of Coke Studio because by that time Vital Signs had unofficially disintegrated. He was successful, knew how to be successful and helped Coke Studio to become successful before handing over the baton to another successful band the Strings.

Coke Studio Bangla's performance has been perceived as substandard compared to its Pakistani counterpart. The compositions lack the innovation and depth that have become synonymous with Pakistani Coke Studio, and the choice of singers has also faced criticism. This disparity highlights the challenges Coke Studio Bangla faces in achieving the same level of artistic excellence and audience engagement. Improvements in musical arrangement, selection of talented artists, and overall production quality are necessary for it to reach the high standards set by Coke Studio Pakistan. Hamim bhai is so true saying clearly, why is it not Coke Studio Bangladesh? I could say lacking confidence and unsophisticated background in music put us here.

মুল কথা ভাইয়রে ডাকে নাই, ভাইয়রে দিয়া একটা গান করাই দিলে সব সহি শুদ্ধ হয় যাবে।

@amarkagojpati1825

Ай бұрын

Ekdom e tai 😂😂😂

@Sayhansajib

Ай бұрын

Ekdom, Vaie ai kothataye vainga koynai

@shourabkhan1268

Ай бұрын

তোমার মত Idiot এর মাথায় এই কথা ঢুকবে না, তোদের মত লোক এর Aukat ও নাই এগুলা বুঝার

@ReadulIslam-im7fu

Ай бұрын

আপনি হামিন আহমেদকে চেনেন না,তাই এমন কথা বলাটা স্বাভাবিক।

@kishor591

Ай бұрын

উনার সম্পর্কে আপনার কোনো ধারণা আছে?! উনাকে ডাকতে কেন হবে? যতোসব ফাউল ধ্যান ধারণা নিয়ে থাকেন

Bad vibes! Musicians/music are universal not territorial. 👎

অর্নব বাবু থাকলে এই রকম হবেই।

@amarkagojpati1825

Ай бұрын

Tai naki?? Arnob babur mela dosh, bujhlam. Tou ja ke apnar Hamin saheb lagche tar JE Baba HINDU ebong SEI hishab ey uni o Hamin babu, seta janen ki???

@ziaulhasan9030

Ай бұрын

@@amarkagojpati1825 বিনা দাওয়াতের মেহমান হাজির। এক কাজ করুন আপনার লেগে থাকলে আমাদের পাসপোর্ট থেকে জাতীয়তা বাংলাদেশ বাদ দিয়ে বাংলা করে দিন।

@amarkagojpati1825

Ай бұрын

​@@ziaulhasan9030sure, APNI jedin apnar ta palte Pakistan Kore neben, sedin ami o paltey BANGLA Kore nebo. No problem at all.

@amarkagojpati1825

Ай бұрын

​@@ziaulhasan9030 ONDHO GOWAR ER MOTO SHOB KISU TE DHORMER RONG DEYA KE AR JAI HOK, SHIKKHITO HOWA BOLE NA. OBOSSHO SE KOTHA BOJHAR MOTO SHIKKHA APNAR NEI, TAI JUKTI DIYE UTTOR NA DIYE FAU KOTHA BOLTE ESHECHEN.

@amarkagojpati1825

Ай бұрын

​@@ziaulhasan9030AAR HA, JATI KONTA, SHOMPRODAY KONTA, JATIYOTA KAKEY BOLE- EI SHOB GULO NIYE EKTU JENE ASHUN. APNAR NIJER E UPOKAR TATEY.

হামীম ভাই একেবারে সঠিক কথাই বলছেন, কোক স্টুডিও কে নষ্ট করছে অর্নব আউল ফাউল গান দিয়া এবং সেই সাথে হাবিযাবি মিউজিশিয়ান দিয়া।

Coke studio is doing alright so far Mr. Hamin... You guys can't produce anything for us last 15 to 20 years.. Now it's time to explore new generations creativity.. Stay positive they're doing great job so far.. Coke studio Bangla is a pure music... Whole world appreciating our music..

@habibzakariaanup2443

Ай бұрын

Hamin bhai said some technical points regarding Coke studio Bangla...pls go Through again this video....

@amarkagojpati1825

Ай бұрын

​@@habibzakariaanup2443Hamin is absolutely wrong about the coke studio being pop oriented only. CSP had done episodes with rahat fateh ali, abida parvin, etc.....are they pop singers?? And this season, CSP is highlighting regional languages like Sindhi, pashtoon, etc. So, what's wrong if we highlight our regional languages be it shaotali or chatgaiya??? What Hamin is spewing is personal grudges, nothing more.

@shourabkhan1268

Ай бұрын

Where is your new generations creativity ? দুই তিনটা ইংলিশ বইলা ভাইবো না খুব বড় কিছু করে ফেলছ😊

@ChowdhuryMohammadTanvirUlIslam

Ай бұрын

you are right

@ehsaan55

Ай бұрын

You surely have missed the point. You're only talking about the reactions from the people and their appreciations, he has rather spoken the technical perspective. Coke Studio Bangla is only focusing on the traditional music that's what he said, but our musical culture is much more than that and you gotta accept it. Well, if you say he's talking about his rock band music, well still there's many more options we can bring to the world. Can you name any Lalon, Hason Raja, Abdul Karim, Nazrul Giti song that Coke Studio Bangla reproduce? That's what this guy talked about, versatility. Focusing onto only Shaotal and Chakma doesn't claim that it's our music is all about. And, stop get into the hype of reaction videos from different countries, cause we all know majority of them are fake reactions, why they do so! And, personally I never support Coke Studio Bangla instead of Bangladesh.

He is right

Coke studio Pakistan is the best I'm agree with Him why not coke studio Bangladesh...... Our culture was perished day by day When this generation will understand this it's become so late But they will understand one day

coc studio বাংলাদেশ না দিয়ে বাংলা দেওয়াতে এটার জন্য দায় অথর্ব অর্নবের দাদাতো তাই

hamin ahmed & naqib khan era asole singer na...musician bola jay...

Coke studio fake the music

কোক বয়কট করেছি তাই কোক স্টুডিওর গানও শুনবো না

ekdom thik khotha

Telapoka ekta pakhi r Miles ekta band

@mohammadsazeed3347

Ай бұрын

ভাই,আপনার কমেন্ট এর বিনিময়ে একটা নোবেল দিতে চাই।কিন্তু রাস্তা খুজে পাচ্ছি না।আপনি সিদ্ধান্ত নেন কোন রাস্তায় নোবেল নেবেন

Stop Coke studio , support Palestine