Worst Umpiring Decisions in AFL History

Спорт

These are some of the worst umpiring decisions in AFL history.
"Signal To Noise (CC-BY) by Scott Buckley" is under a Creative Commons ( cc-by ) license
Music promoted by BreakingCopyright: • 🕰️ Mystery Music (No C...

Пікірлер: 271

  • @JohnHenrySMH
    @JohnHenrySMH11 ай бұрын

    The Ben Keays one is the worst by far. But there's another one from this year, also with the Crows. Inside the last 30 seconds of play, with Collingwood up by two points, Jordan Dawson was smashed in the face by a Collingwood player about 30 meters from goal. Umpire didn't call a free for high contact, probably costing Adelaide the win. AFL had to put out a statement saying that the umpire was wrong and that Dawson should have been given the free.

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    11 ай бұрын

    Yes, hoping to do a part 2 which would definitely include this umpiring decision, thankyou for the suggestion

  • @TLenny

    @TLenny

    11 ай бұрын

    ​@@Kaleen_YT mate you could have about 400 parts with the way the umpires are now days...

  • @Lukeobi

    @Lukeobi

    11 ай бұрын

    Mate it’s the block

  • @Anonymo637

    @Anonymo637

    11 ай бұрын

    Buddy, the umpires make so many calls like this like every year three teams miss the finals due to these sorts of decisions

  • @LucUltraRWB

    @LucUltraRWB

    11 ай бұрын

    @@Kaleen_YTpart 2? LFG

  • @theflyingdropbear2009
    @theflyingdropbear200911 ай бұрын

    one of the worst decisions was when Josh Jenkins kicked a "goal" but upon closer inspecting, it actually hit the post, it cost Port a chance to play for finals that season, what makes it even more ironic now, is that it was the same umpire that stupidly called Ben Keays' goal a behind for you guessed it, "hitting the post" for close calls like that, there really should be a compulsory score review, the technology is meant to be there to prevent human error.

  • @darrenmiles-morland8038

    @darrenmiles-morland8038

    11 ай бұрын

    With all of the commotion that's gone on about the Crows being potentially robbed of a finals berth after being on the wrong end of the Ben Keays goal umpiring mistake, everyone (Crows supporters in particular) seems to have forgotten that Adelaide got the rub of the green in their favour with that Josh Jenkins decision when replays showed that the ball clearly hit the post.

  • @Chilli_FPS

    @Chilli_FPS

    11 ай бұрын

    @@darrenmiles-morland8038but the difference is we admitted it shouldn’t have been. Jenkins said to the whole crowd on mic it hit the post. Sydney acts like they won it properly

  • @JohnHenrySMH

    @JohnHenrySMH

    11 ай бұрын

    Yeah but the difference there was that the umpire wasn't sure, so went upstairs for the review. In that case the tech wasn't good enough to detect it hitting. So the umpire did the right thing, but the technology let them down. Even now, the only reason we all assume it probably did hit the post is because Jenkins told us he thinks it did. With the Keays one, the footage is definitive, but the same umpire for some reason didn't send it upstairs. I suspect that there has been pressure put on the goal umpires to not hold up the game with pointless reviews, I'd love to hear his side of the story. Best solution is to make it so that if the ball hits the post but still goes through, then it counts as a goal. If it bounces back in play then it's a behind, or just play on, which I think is a better idea because it could advantage the attacking team more than a single point would.

  • @supaskiltz9877

    @supaskiltz9877

    11 ай бұрын

    @@darrenmiles-morland8038no one has forgotten that, it’s all I see come up, I don’t think we should be arguing or calling it Karma tho. Instead we should cause more commotion as the umpiring and technology hasn’t gotten better all these years later. I think the Crows fans advocating for compensation are dumb, I’m a Crows fan and that’s just not gonna happen and even so bad umpiring decisions ruin games at the end a lot. We should however as AFL fans realise how bad the state of the game has gotten with umpiring and the 30 fps technology that we can seem to never make the correct call during critical moments while every other sport has no problem with that.

  • @theflyingdropbear2009

    @theflyingdropbear2009

    11 ай бұрын

    @@supaskiltz9877 Referring to the last paragraph, that in itself is the problem, the AFL has enough money to throw around to make the technology better. This is the technology that should have improved, as the system hasn't gotten any better since it was first implemented. which is sad, because all the other sporting codes have score review systems that are far superior to the AFLs. I think instead of the Crows (the team I support) seeking compensation, they should be voicing a means to implement improvements in not only the technology but also when and how it is used, with one potential idea being that players can initiate a score review. for a professional league like the AFL, the standard is simply nowhere near good enough. I would hate to see it happen in the Grand Final, that would force the AFL to act if it were to happen, a small part of me hopes it does happen.

  • @hotkeyafl
    @hotkeyafl10 ай бұрын

    Good channel mate. Well researched & presented.

  • @JacobisIncognito
    @JacobisIncognito11 ай бұрын

    Another one u forgot was round 2 2021 Geelong brisbane. In the last 30 seconds in Brisbane’s forward half, there was a scramble between both sides and Isaac smith contained possession of the ball. He then got tackled and clearly threw the ball, but the umpire didn’t call it.

  • @tolgaalgin4689
    @tolgaalgin468911 ай бұрын

    that Papley one against the Pies still baffles me to this day

  • @ungabunga88

    @ungabunga88

    10 ай бұрын

    Doesn’t baffle me. It makes perfect sense, chuck on your AFL ceo hat for a sec and think what would be a better business outcome, 2 vic team grand final or Sydney vs Geelong? AFL needs Sydney to perform so they can compete with NRL.

  • @PaladinCasdin

    @PaladinCasdin

    10 ай бұрын

    Papley cops high contact from the attempted spoil. So it's actually a free both ways, the umpire just let the mark stand rather than ball it up.

  • @masontroyadams3534
    @masontroyadams353411 ай бұрын

    Keep up the great videos mate, you should make a video reflecting on the AFL season before the finals start if you can. Btw what's your footy team? Just curious yk

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    11 ай бұрын

    Glad you're enjoying the videos. Also thanks for the idea, I'll definitely consider it. I go for Sydney.

  • @MrJohnonymous
    @MrJohnonymous7 ай бұрын

    2009 GF St kilda v Geelong. Tom Hawkins open goal hits the post and still awarded a goal. The rest is history 😢

  • @Aunini

    @Aunini

    5 ай бұрын

    Too soon 💔

  • @davet5273
    @davet527311 ай бұрын

    Good video man. Would’ve loved to have seen the one of Howe taking on a tackle and then laying on top of the ball in the goal square in that gf final. That was a huge one in the last qtr that they missed

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    11 ай бұрын

    Appreciate it mate.

  • @konner5213
    @konner52134 күн бұрын

    When the umpire called for Robbie Gray to play on after he took a mark inside 50 and was given less than 15 seconds instead of the full 30 seconds and in the 2014 prelim against the hawks where Port should have been given a free kick inside their forward 50 (which would have been the match winner) was not awarded because the afl wanted a vfl premiership yet again.

  • @LucUltraRWB
    @LucUltraRWB11 ай бұрын

    Aye blew up! Can say I was here haha Love how you used the Adelaide Vs Sydney game. One of the worst decisions by far. Should’ve added that Geelong Vs Brisbane game Amazing video again, wow, keep it up!!

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    11 ай бұрын

    Thankyou, means a lot!

  • @Yongsterrr
    @Yongsterrr11 ай бұрын

    I remember a Essendon vs Freo game at Docklands. Freo's Matthew Carr had a shot on goal but missed, however he was bumped late which would mean that Carr had the choice of having the point or taking a set shot for goal. The umpire was supposed to ask Carr on what he wanted, but the umpire went to the Essendon player instead. I think there's a video around here somewhere.

  • @mattevo13aus

    @mattevo13aus

    10 ай бұрын

    kzread.info/dash/bejne/e594sMSgf5q4g7g.htmlsi=tajFV_3zHBrM5icQ

  • @Aunini

    @Aunini

    5 ай бұрын

    That was an all-timer 😆🤢

  • @mcdonalds5972
    @mcdonalds597211 ай бұрын

    Adelaide vs Fitzroy, 1991. The only time I will ever say an AFL game was rigged. The last two minutes was absolute dogshit umpiring to get Adelaide over the line.

  • @whatthe3131

    @whatthe3131

    9 ай бұрын

    🤣🤣🤣

  • @schoolgamer9592
    @schoolgamer959210 ай бұрын

    Good Video. I Saw the Ben Keays Incident. That Was So Bad How That Was a Behind!!

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    10 ай бұрын

    Appreciate it.

  • @seandarcy1813
    @seandarcy181311 ай бұрын

    2001 Prelim Ess vs Haw - Goal umpire's decision of touched on the line is reversed by a field umpire 40 metres away and is given to Essendon's Lucas as a goal.

  • @kelstra1997
    @kelstra199711 ай бұрын

    I completely agree with the sentiments expressed in the video. Our game continues to improve in leaps and bounds but the one aspect that has gone backwards is the umpiring. I will never be convinced that game has ever needed three umpires let alone the four that we have now. After all, for over a hundred years we only had one. There are so many occasions where there is clearly a conflict between the umpires on whether a free kick is warranted for a particular incident and often as not the umpire furthest away is the one who prevails. Looking at the terrible incident in the Adelaide game where Ben Keys' goal was called a point, if you look at the video there were at least two umpires right behind the kick and it's inconceivable that they didn't see that it was a goal. After all, the players from both sides saw it and reacted accordingly so why not the umpires who then should have called for a review? The 2018 Grand Final is the one that really gets me however. Clearly it was a free kick to Bruzzy Maynard. There is absolutely nothing that gets me more annoyed than when games are decided by the umpires and there have been many of those.

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    11 ай бұрын

    very well said.

  • @theflyingdropbear2009

    @theflyingdropbear2009

    11 ай бұрын

    yeah with four umpires on the field you'd expect the umpiring to get better, not the other way around, but sadly that is the case, I would also argue that as more rule changes occur and as the game speeds up, the worse the umpiring gets. AFL House has a degree of blame for it as well, considering the fact that in some weeks they are telling the umpires to crack down on different matters during the game, really what AFL House has to do in the off-season, is instead of focusing on rule changes and looking for ways to speed up the game, is focus on getting the umpiring up to scratch. for a professional sport to not have umpiring up to an acceptable standard, is simply not good enough, maybe it is time for the AFL to put in place a DRS-like system in place, as well as allowing for players to instigate a score review as well, it might slow the game down a little, but it might be healthier for the game itself, and it might even force to umpires to change a quite a bit as well.

  • @timothyhill6879

    @timothyhill6879

    11 ай бұрын

    ​@@theflyingdropbear2009 most of the examples given in the video are 50/50 at worst, certainly not worthy of being called "the worst decisions ever." I'm not saying that there aren't any howlers shown, but most of the examples are actually correctly adjudicated. That being said, I agree that there is potential for improvement and that a review system might have merit.

  • @LGTALKSFOOTY
    @LGTALKSFOOTY10 ай бұрын

    Ben Keays goal was a goal I was there and as an Adelaide fan this puts me in tears. The umpires need to stop making excuses and start calling stuff properly.😢🤬😭🤬😭🤬😭🤬🥺 👇like

  • @itwasagoal
    @itwasagoal11 ай бұрын

    Tom Hawkins "goal" in the 09 grand final was right up there too

  • @darrenmiles-morland8038

    @darrenmiles-morland8038

    11 ай бұрын

    Sharrod Wellingham got awarded a goal in the 2011 Grand Final that clearly hit the post too. Did you forget that one? Just as much as a howler as the Tom Hawkins one in 2009, but possibly the square-up for Geelong.

  • @gggumball

    @gggumball

    11 ай бұрын

    interesting thing with that though, Hawkin's "goal" hit the post but no one realised until a few minutes after play, that "goal" in the 2011 grand final, everybody knew the moment it happened.

  • @AndyTheRoo
    @AndyTheRoo9 ай бұрын

    In addition to the not 15 metre kick in the Geelong vs Sydney game, it took the boundary umpire a good extra 3 seconds to actually call the ball out of bounds aswell because he thought it was a mark.

  • @TheBlockBoss-mx7zo
    @TheBlockBoss-mx7zo11 ай бұрын

    You forgot - Petraccas ‘point’ v Carlton - Jezza Cameron mark and goal which were out of bounds - Tom lynch ‘point’ V Brisbane last year

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    11 ай бұрын

    Part 2 coming soon?

  • @Tosicc567

    @Tosicc567

    11 ай бұрын

    That point in the richmond elim final was a confirmed point to be fair, a bunch of angles came out after that showed it was pretty clear

  • @tderfhytguhjiug

    @tderfhytguhjiug

    11 ай бұрын

    Petracca's point was due to inconclusive evidence, meaning they had to go back to the soft call. Even on replay it looked like it could've been touched, so it's hard to blame the umpire for their soft call. Not one of the worst umpiring decisions of all time imo.

  • @maxshiraz3447
    @maxshiraz344711 ай бұрын

    1997 Semi Final Adelaide V Geelong. The whole match was one bad umpiring performance to get the Crows over the line, culminating in the Leigh Colbert mark controversy.

  • @cutupaquarterjugofwater4708
    @cutupaquarterjugofwater47089 ай бұрын

    Hate the crows but that ben keays one was a shocker. Having said that he's not the greatest kick and that was probably one of his best lol

  • @Mankyweb
    @Mankyweb11 ай бұрын

    Sydney seem to feature a lot, getting looked after by the umpires. Suspicious, no wonder ive always hated that club

  • @whitemamba0312

    @whitemamba0312

    11 ай бұрын

    swans have probably been the most done by this season in umpiring besides that last game lmao

  • @chadchadderton

    @chadchadderton

    11 ай бұрын

    @@whitemamba0312 I'm not saying they've been the most looked after, but they aren't remotely close to being the "most done by this season"... like at all...

  • @matthewlay9221

    @matthewlay9221

    11 ай бұрын

    Do you remember the 2016 grand final? It was the worst umpiring I've seen and it wasn't one decision, it was a whole host of poor umpiring decisions that went the way of the dogs. I think the guy making the video is featuring sydney alot because he's bitter towards sydney after the loss

  • @ungabunga88
    @ungabunga8810 ай бұрын

    AFL high ups would’ve been pissed if Sydney didn’t make the grand final and instead it was collingwood Geelong 2 vic teams. No money or business In that.

  • @fartexplosion4480
    @fartexplosion448010 ай бұрын

    My dad used to be an SANFL umpire. These are just my opinions based on what he told me about the (SANFL) rules 1. Robert Findlay is a bad umpire. Always has been. He's always the weakest link in every field umpire lineup. Malceski was being tackled and had nowhere to run, you're right 2. Yeah, no comment on that one. Butler did break the dissent rule and I guess that's a legit 50, but you can't blame him. 3. It's a borderline 15m, but umpires should always pay marks in borderline 15m calls. If you're not sure, stay off your whistle. The Rowbottom one is really hard to pick up since he's in the middle of the pack, so I can forgive that slip up, but not the Cameron one. 4. The Crisp one is actually a good umpiring decision. Crisp handballed the ball away at the very last second. The problem with ANZAC day clashes is that the players are influenced by the crowd since more people turn up to the Essendon Collingwood ANZAC day clash than any other game during the regular season. The Guelfi one was a bad call, however. Stephenson didn't dispose the ball before the ball hit the ground, so... (Also, just from my memory, the worst umpired game I've ever seen was the Adelaide and Collingwood game this year) 5. The Keays one... yeah, that's the worst in recent memory. The ARC system should always be used with set shots that hug the post in the dying minutes of the game. The ball didn't deviate from its spin, so why the goal umpire didn't use it is beyond me. Goalie cost Adelaide a spot in the finals. Maybe it's God punishing Keays for getting the Fritsch cut for his hair. 6. This one's hard to pick up because Moore looks like he just fell over backwards at first glance, but the field umpire's sights should have been in the contest. 7. Maynard was held. Maybe it's God delivering divine justice for Sampi in the 2005 Grand Final? There's actually one (in)famous call you missed: Josh Carr was lining up for a goal once and just before he kicked it, he got hit by Ty Zantuck and his kick went all wonky and missed for a behind. The umpire was supposed to ask Carr if he wanted to take the set shot again for a chance at 6 points, but he asked Zantuck, the one who gave away the free, by accident. Zantuck said "Nah, nah, it's fine, I'll just take the point" and that's how Zantuck got away with barrelling a player lining up for goal

  • @earrapemusic5737
    @earrapemusic57373 ай бұрын

    Coming from an umpire myself, a lot of the "Missed" decisions stem from the AFL`s interpretation of the rule. For example, some Holding-the-ball free kicks are played on for the sake of the flow of the game. Unfortunately, all this does is increase decent towards us and create double/inconsistency within the game.

  • @mr.cheese.balls100s
    @mr.cheese.balls100s2 ай бұрын

    Possible Theorys To Why: 1. Maybe you could say that he was just kinda standing around and not really wanting to get rid of it. 2. That was a terrible decision. 3. Since Jezza took and mark and kinda slid on the ground, umps might have gotten confused on where he took the mark. 3.5. I guess the ump also didn't want to start more controversy with the crowd or something... 4. That was also a terrible decision. 4.5. Ump prob didn't see that. 5. Umpire mistake. 6. Umpire probably thought he was faking it. 7. He was sort of half blocked out of the ball (maybe umpire felt bad for West Coast) 7.5. That was probably because he had to slow down because he was running backward. These are just my assumptions

  • @PaladinCasdin
    @PaladinCasdin10 ай бұрын

    The Tom Papley mark is partly the correct call. Paps pushed Moore, yes, but he also copped a pretty heavy knock to the head from the spoil attempt (obvious from the footage used in this video). Since it's a free going both ways technically it should have been a ball up, but since Papley also marked the ball, the umpire let it stand. Another recent one was Cameron's handball receive and goal while out of bounds and surrounded by umpires. Also the entire 2016 grand final was one big terrible umpiring decision.

  • @RBoy12Gamer
    @RBoy12Gamer10 ай бұрын

    As a Collingwood supporter looking back that Essondon game what preeetty bad 😅

  • @nickqxl3541
    @nickqxl35416 ай бұрын

    Daniher didn’t actually make Crisp lose the ball. He took him to ground by the waist and crisp then handball’s it

  • @athlonen
    @athlonen6 ай бұрын

    Interesting how "AFL History" barely covers the past 5-8 years, as there were plenty of umpiring brainfarts prior to a lot of these. That said, outside of the Keays' incident this year, I'd rate Sirengate over all of these, let alone Tom Hawkins receiving a handball while he was out of bounds and kicks a goal from outside the boundary line.. I want to say that was in a Grand Final as well.

  • @joelshanahan7580
    @joelshanahan758011 ай бұрын

    2022 round 1 Richmond Carlton- dochertys 50m pen, stood on the mark didn’t move, no interference yet still got a 50 for nothing, worst call I’ve ever seen to date, won them the game

  • @Jack.dempster
    @Jack.dempster10 ай бұрын

    Ben Keays one a crows supporter myself it is completely not okay. Crows needed that goal if they won the crowds would have gotten bigger meaning the umpire gets paid more........?

  • @klokar21
    @klokar215 ай бұрын

    The umpires have been pretty desperate to give buddy that premiership at Sydney, the umpires have fucked over Geelong when Sydney played them multiple times and they did it to Collingwood as well. I hope all Geelong and Collingwood fans can sit happy though knowing Sydney got thrashed in 2022

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    5 ай бұрын

    i don't know about that

  • @nikkipedro
    @nikkipedro10 ай бұрын

    When Jordan Clark was tackled he actually got his foot to the ball, effectively kicking it as Butler tackled him. The umpire was right to call play on, on this occasion.

  • @WorldLinc
    @WorldLinc11 ай бұрын

    The Dumb sheed one was the worst one in the video

  • @01Grytz
    @01Grytz11 ай бұрын

    poor collingwobbles hopefully they lose by one point by a wrong umpire decision in the grandfinal this year

  • @stephenrossi1918

    @stephenrossi1918

    11 ай бұрын

    We gotta get there first. 😅

  • @Zakariyyahyland2007
    @Zakariyyahyland200711 ай бұрын

    U forgot Zac Bailey Tackle on Blicavs holding the ball not called right in the goal square round 2 2021

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    11 ай бұрын

    Saving that for part 2

  • @darrenmiles-morland8038

    @darrenmiles-morland8038

    11 ай бұрын

    Zac Bailey landed on Mark Blicavs' back when he tackled him to the ground. It was no different to what happened with Cam Mooney when he fell onto an opposition player's back after tackling him to the ground in the 2010 Qualifying Final when Cameron Ling got disallowed a goal late in the match which would have put Geelong in front and potentially won them that match. Everyone focuses on Blicavs disposing of the ball incorrectly when having prior opportunity. No-one ever notices that Bailey falls onto his back after tackling him to the ground. The umpire may have been undecided which way to call it. Perhaps play on was a fair enough call in that instance.

  • @Zakariyyahyland2007

    @Zakariyyahyland2007

    11 ай бұрын

    @@darrenmiles-morland8038 even the afl admitted that it should’ve been holding the ball tho

  • @TheOJC123
    @TheOJC12310 ай бұрын

    I’m amazed this video doesn’t go on for 1 hour because their are so many

  • @nspiredwellbeing
    @nspiredwellbeing6 ай бұрын

    Nick Malceski is intially under no perceived pressure and waits for the Carlton player to move toward him before backing over the line. Jordan Clark actually kicks the ball, albeit just hits his boot which is all he needs to do under the laws.

  • @michaelgerhardt7130
    @michaelgerhardt713010 ай бұрын

    Have to be the fantom hitting of the post for the crows. I watched the game not knowing this was going to happen. I hope the goal ump got fired.

  • @zayburnell
    @zayburnell11 ай бұрын

    The showdown 2018 was controversial

  • @TimothyTempleton69
    @TimothyTempleton6911 ай бұрын

    “Absolutely gobsmacked!”

  • @stackhou3e26
    @stackhou3e2610 ай бұрын

    think the richmond review against brisbane should be in here. the crows one only kept them from playing finals the tigers one cost them a potential grand final, only team that even looked like beating the cats last year!

  • @user-qf7fz8os8j
    @user-qf7fz8os8j11 ай бұрын

    even though i am a freo fan in the background brandon walker is tripped but still that was ball

  • @PlushMOelmoalexcatboy
    @PlushMOelmoalexcatboy11 ай бұрын

    Good video SPECKIE

  • @Luckduckten
    @Luckduckten10 ай бұрын

    100 percent the ben keys one my dad told me that the umpire was fired for the rest of the year im so angry obout the dawson one aswell

  • @patrickmilner4149
    @patrickmilner414911 ай бұрын

    I dont understand how you can call an obvious goal a point.

  • @twitchyryno
    @twitchyryno7 ай бұрын

    why does the music make me wanna cry...

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    7 ай бұрын

    Haha

  • @Surfsaus
    @Surfsaus10 ай бұрын

    What a bloody disgrace the Keays non goal was. Cost the crows finals. If you want to see the most biased umpiring ever seen have a look at how the umpires favoured Richmond in the 2017 Grand Final. Truly disgusting.

  • @leighreganarblaster9852
    @leighreganarblaster985211 ай бұрын

    Your Wong that umpire decision didn’t Upset the whole of South Australia because most likely didn’t upset the Port , Adelaide Power fans go power

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    11 ай бұрын

    true

  • @zayburnell

    @zayburnell

    10 ай бұрын

    I'm a poet fan and I thought that call was a disgrace and wrong

  • @blackmoon34785
    @blackmoon3478510 ай бұрын

    If you do a part 2 you should add trac vs carlton

  • @johnnyhotbody1313
    @johnnyhotbody131311 ай бұрын

    Would love to see a video on the umpire's bias towards non-Victorian teams mostly SA teams Port and Crows.

  • @hawkers94

    @hawkers94

    11 ай бұрын

    surely you jest...SA teams get an armchair ride. It is like having another player!

  • @afez2752

    @afez2752

    11 ай бұрын

    Both Adelaide and Port are in the top 8 ratio of FF and FA. South Australian supporters are salty that the AFL didn't come from SA and allow Port to be so dominant it was boring. As well as if you do the math FF:FA by state SA has the best with SA then NSW, Vic WA and last Queensland.

  • @footyflamez7455

    @footyflamez7455

    11 ай бұрын

    SA and WA

  • @Anonymo637

    @Anonymo637

    11 ай бұрын

    What are you on. Port has the worst free kick ratio I the comp and the Crows are 13th

  • @Anonymo637

    @Anonymo637

    11 ай бұрын

    Yeah WA get it bad too

  • @lukeandboyanabuchanan865
    @lukeandboyanabuchanan86510 ай бұрын

    How did you make your own KZread channel

  • @CrossroadsDemon
    @CrossroadsDemon10 ай бұрын

    Sydney must have a secret pact with the umpires. Look at how many times they’ve been saved

  • @Youtubemodsarewanks
    @Youtubemodsarewanks10 ай бұрын

    You may as well put up the infamous Gary ablett snr "mark"

  • @custarddragon9349
    @custarddragon934910 ай бұрын

    the goal umpire not calling fir a score review 100% the worst

  • @vSnippi
    @vSnippi10 ай бұрын

    im pretty sure the second clip, his boot scrapes the ball thus making it bounce off awkward

  • @bodhimontague
    @bodhimontague11 ай бұрын

    Frickin Rioli, we could have one that GF

  • @Want0nS0up
    @Want0nS0up10 ай бұрын

    The Adelaide decision should have been given a goal, and the time consumed in the meantime, been added back onto the clock. Centre bounce to follow. I am definitely not an Adelaide fan, but on that occasion they were robbed.

  • @kevindally4551
    @kevindally455111 ай бұрын

    Ben Keys goal would have to take some beating.

  • @chadchadderton

    @chadchadderton

    11 ай бұрын

    wasn't even the worse missed call by the AFL/Goal umpire at that end of adelaide oval. the josh jenkins showdown 45 debacle was significantly worse lmao...

  • @gtfigc259
    @gtfigc2599 ай бұрын

    Geelong and Sydney was disgraceful that was a mark all day if that Sydney's they would have payed that

  • @samysull333
    @samysull33311 ай бұрын

    if you actually slow down the jordan clarke decision you’ll see that he actually kicked it. elite decision from stevic.

  • @lankylorry95

    @lankylorry95

    11 ай бұрын

    No the ball dropped on the ground then started bouncing

  • @chadchadderton

    @chadchadderton

    11 ай бұрын

    @@lankylorry95 no, the ball hit the side of his boot. it was an ineffective disposal, but a disposal nonetheless.

  • @samysull333

    @samysull333

    11 ай бұрын

    @@lankylorry95 what’s the point in lying to yourself about it? it’s very clear once you slow it down.

  • @libbyhilhorst657
    @libbyhilhorst65711 ай бұрын

    The crows one I was at the game

  • @officialHbTcs
    @officialHbTcs11 ай бұрын

    Maynard wasn’t blocked. They are both wrestling each other

  • @Bennythejet93

    @Bennythejet93

    11 ай бұрын

    Blocked or played on take your pick

  • @officialHbTcs

    @officialHbTcs

    11 ай бұрын

    @@Bennythejet93 neither? Sheed took the mark. Rioli and Maynard both wrestled behind where the ball was actually marked.

  • @Bennythejet93

    @Bennythejet93

    11 ай бұрын

    @@officialHbTcs lol good one.. Maynard was blocked and sheed definitely played on simple as that

  • @officialHbTcs

    @officialHbTcs

    11 ай бұрын

    @@Bennythejet93 okay cooker

  • @chadchadderton

    @chadchadderton

    11 ай бұрын

    rioli prevented maynard from making the contest... that's an objective fact. now under AFL laws at the time, it should have been deemed a block. bygones are bygones i guess

  • @CASHFLOW0900
    @CASHFLOW090019 күн бұрын

    Collingwood robbed of possibly 2 grand finals & a record for most grand final wins due to bad umpiring

  • @user71738
    @user7173810 ай бұрын

    U said that the whole of SA was mad u forgot port exists

  • @guavacadoII
    @guavacadoII11 ай бұрын

    1:28 this isn't a free because Rowbottom was saved by the siren. Also, how you could make a list of bad umpire decisions and not include Bailey's non HTB call against the cats in 2021 is ridiculous.

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    11 ай бұрын

    Will be in Part 2

  • @mlpbahs
    @mlpbahs11 ай бұрын

    Gws vs carlton round 3. Stole the giants momentum and basicallly gave carlton a free 4 points which could cost the giants finals

  • @RysterialProductions
    @RysterialProductions10 ай бұрын

    Maynard was not a block. You can very well tell the eagle is looking up at the ball.

  • @Hotdogman580
    @Hotdogman58011 ай бұрын

    That Ben Keays one is horrible

  • @SOmoeononononon
    @SOmoeononononon11 ай бұрын

    Its just VIC Bias that Swans Feature so much

  • @ungabunga88

    @ungabunga88

    10 ай бұрын

    Interstate bias is real, particularly nsw

  • @morsrom156
    @morsrom15611 ай бұрын

    Cogs dissent in Carlton vs GWS was a pretty bad call

  • @crashwoahcoot6478
    @crashwoahcoot6478Ай бұрын

    Jeremy Cameron wasn't paid the mark because it was touched, if you weren't death you'd understand that. Also, Maynard engaged with Rioli, Rioli had his eyes on the ball so where's the block? How about when Howe should've been pinged for holding the ball but wasn't in our goal square and then Collingwood kicked a goal? That could've robbed West Coast the premiership. Do you like making yourself look stupid? Because you wouldn't have made those examples if you don't.

  • @spionic9
    @spionic910 ай бұрын

    Dom Sheed’s goal was the worst and so was Tom Papley’s

  • @odinxsonn5055

    @odinxsonn5055

    9 ай бұрын

    stay ad, collingwood supporter

  • @ErikLidums-of5ek
    @ErikLidums-of5ek11 ай бұрын

    The crows vs swans

  • @ErikLidums-of5ek
    @ErikLidums-of5ek11 ай бұрын

    It wasn’t even a behind

  • @Bluberre2.0
    @Bluberre2.010 ай бұрын

    Rarer than Essendon winning a finals game huh,bro probably said that because he goes for north or west coast

  • @Trainaddiction512
    @Trainaddiction5129 ай бұрын

    1:59 That isnt a bad decision. Jack Crisp clearly disposed the ball about a second after he was ran down.

  • @Charlie_Pitts
    @Charlie_Pitts11 ай бұрын

    I wouldn’t call the Maynard block one of the worst of all time, it’s definitely there but it’s not as obvious as some of the other ones

  • @jaidynr87

    @jaidynr87

    11 ай бұрын

    I think it’s only considered because it won the eagles the granny

  • @timothyhill6879

    @timothyhill6879

    11 ай бұрын

    @@jaidynr87 That's always been my take on it. Everyone knows what he was trying to do, but Rioli did basically everything right to get away with it - be in the vicinity of where the ball will be landing (holding your ground), eyes on the ball, and made a movement towards the drop of the ball as it landed to simulate a genuine attempt at a mark - which he would have been able to take if Sheed wasn't there. He was 100% doing it to block Maynard out, but he could genuinely claim to be holding his ground for a contested mark. If he doesn't do any of those things, the umpire is paying a free kick for a block. Rioli simply did it well enough to get away with it.

  • @robmac5086
    @robmac508610 ай бұрын

    I have been saying this for a few years now, THERE ARE NO RULES, NO DESCENT CAMERAS, go back to our basic game and stop worrying about Gather Round GILLION!!

  • @footyflamez7455
    @footyflamez745511 ай бұрын

    0:07 why’d u add that. Dom sheed only took1 foot of the ground and both Maynard and roili were blocking each other. Collingwood lost that on there own

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    11 ай бұрын

    just what I thought of the situation

  • @yez

    @yez

    11 ай бұрын

    @@Kaleen_YT I agree with you. Maynard was blocked and rules are rules, and even a step off the mark shouldn't be allowed.

  • @footyflamez7455

    @footyflamez7455

    11 ай бұрын

    @@yez I’m so confused. Kaleen said he agreed with me but then u said u agree with him but u said the opposite of me, pls help me out I’m lost lol

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    11 ай бұрын

    no i meant what i said in the video was just what I thought of the situation

  • @footyflamez7455

    @footyflamez7455

    11 ай бұрын

    Oh ok 😊

  • @roblincduck
    @roblincduck9 ай бұрын

    4:20 that was nothing but an uneducated umpire that should learn what a 'block' is

  • @odinxsonn5055

    @odinxsonn5055

    9 ай бұрын

    wasnt even a block buddy boy, rioli was there first, had his eyes on the ball, simply going for a contested mark, get over it.

  • @veinzthetechguy
    @veinzthetechguy11 ай бұрын

    wheres port v geelong rnd 21

  • @Ntrelo
    @Ntrelo10 ай бұрын

    The Ben keays one by far

  • @odinxsonn5055
    @odinxsonn50559 ай бұрын

    2022 freo v kilda, you can see the first one gets very slight boot to ball but the second one didnt dispose of with legitimate time, look closely before callling it a bad umpiring decision yeah

  • @Zakariyyahyland2007
    @Zakariyyahyland200711 ай бұрын

    3:40 I still don’t feel like it was a push tbh

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    11 ай бұрын

    Well I go for Sydney aswell haha so just want to assure you its not a biased opinion

  • @Tosicc567

    @Tosicc567

    11 ай бұрын

    Yeah I always thought it was pretty damn soft and side on, more of holding is ground which you're allowed to do

  • @Zakariyyahyland2007

    @Zakariyyahyland2007

    11 ай бұрын

    @@Kaleen_YT fair enough

  • @Thebeast_brothers
    @Thebeast_brothers2 ай бұрын

    0:23 naaahhhhhhhhh 💀 He did them dirty lol

  • @russe19642
    @russe1964210 ай бұрын

    That Willie rioli one,he was the only one of the two facing the ball,he's allowed to stand his ground and was in the contest area for a mark. So get over it

  • @odinxsonn5055

    @odinxsonn5055

    9 ай бұрын

    YES FINALLY, SOMEONE WHO DOESNT HAVE HALF A FUCKING BRAIN

  • @Lukeobi
    @Lukeobi11 ай бұрын

    The block by far

  • @odinxsonn5055

    @odinxsonn5055

    9 ай бұрын

    ur high, u pies fans are so quick to criticise everyone else, but are completely oblivious when your team does the same thintg every game

  • @liverpoolbedwars1287
    @liverpoolbedwars128711 ай бұрын

    Grand final

  • @rancidsteve9689
    @rancidsteve96894 ай бұрын

    Horrifying.

  • @esf1407
    @esf140711 ай бұрын

    That Essendon not winning a final isn’t funny

  • @bigpotato2354

    @bigpotato2354

    11 ай бұрын

    Pretty funny to me

  • @Jackpot18.

    @Jackpot18.

    11 ай бұрын

    Funny af

  • @JC_Edits_Official

    @JC_Edits_Official

    11 ай бұрын

    PREETY funny to me so cry about it

  • @lukeslayer

    @lukeslayer

    11 ай бұрын

    You're right, it's HILARIOUS!

  • @leesmith5065
    @leesmith506510 ай бұрын

    Notice alot of these are Sydney and Collingwood keays on was horrible I was at the game we were getting thrashed and came back everybody but the umpires saw it as a goal.

  • @stevesalkas9128

    @stevesalkas9128

    10 ай бұрын

    Syd owned by afl

  • @bigdogrobbo3810
    @bigdogrobbo381011 ай бұрын

    Ben Keays was the worst!

  • @bussieboy7064
    @bussieboy706410 ай бұрын

    Ben Keays first and papley second

  • @asher4219
    @asher421910 ай бұрын

    Sydney get away with it so much

  • @phoenixfolvig551
    @phoenixfolvig551Ай бұрын

    Stop roasting Essendon

  • @klutchKlaus
    @klutchKlaus11 ай бұрын

    Great video 👏 Crom robbed

  • @Kaleen_YT

    @Kaleen_YT

    11 ай бұрын

    Appreciate it KlutchKlaus, yes definitely

  • @d.ccricket181
    @d.ccricket18111 ай бұрын

    Tracc vs Carlton

  • @LclcFanLclc

    @LclcFanLclc

    11 ай бұрын

    Yeah that was a point

  • @d.ccricket181

    @d.ccricket181

    11 ай бұрын

    @@LclcFanLclc This is why they don’t let anybody talk

  • @CJ-cn6hq
    @CJ-cn6hq11 ай бұрын

    Ben keays one has to be the worst

  • @LclcFanLclc

    @LclcFanLclc

    11 ай бұрын

    Yeah that was a point

  • @LoffyElite

    @LoffyElite

    11 ай бұрын

    @@LclcFanLclc don't think so😢

  • @chadchadderton

    @chadchadderton

    11 ай бұрын

    not even the worse goal umpiring mistake at that end of adelaide oval... not sure how it can be the worst in history given that knowledge...

Келесі