The worst choice for the 49ers was trading up for Trey Lance, they just got away with it because Purdy was a one in a million over achiever.

@footballholicstt

Ай бұрын

Luckily those 1sts were all end of the first round selections so I don't think the decision was as bad as it could have been.

@graysonschutzman4853

Ай бұрын

@@footballholicstt You dont think with 3 first rounders you could of gotten a single extra player that could of put you over the razor thin edge last year or traded one or two of those picks for a proven useful player

@hansolo9868

26 күн бұрын

@@footballholicsttcope harder

Gotta agree with u on Saquon Barkley. When you get a really good player and and there's still just no window for that guy to contribute to a playoff run, u know u just had a bad plan. Drafting a bust can just be bad luck, but with Saquon the Gmen had good luck and it still had no chance

I would say Green Bay’s worst decision of the past decade would be not firing Dom Capers sooner. There is no excuse for Capers as DC to not get fired after fielding some of the worst defenses during the post Super Bowl window. It probably cost the Packers like 4 additional Super Bowl appearances.

There's something weird and dumb with the editing,mic quality,and everything is so odd...yet it somehow works...

@footballholicstt

5 күн бұрын

Name of my autobiography 🤣

I disagree. I think your team trading up for Tray Lance is one of the worst trades of all time and I think it’s a miracle it hasn’t sunk your team honestly.

Wrong on the Saints. Their biggest mistake was drafting Trevor Pennington. They passed on Tyler Smith and Tyler Linderbaum and even going on the defensive side by passing on Jermaine Johnston II.

@footballholicstt

Ай бұрын

A mid 1st rounder is rarely a decade ruiner. Obviously you want the dude to succeed. But I don't think it is devastating.

As a Cardinals fan, without seeing where we are on this last, the worst decision of the decade(and I'm guessing by decade you mean last 10 years) would have to be not taking the starters out of the Eagles game in 2015 where Tyrann Matthieu got hurt in the closing moments of the game which was a blowout at that point. #2 would be not standing pat at #15 in 2018 and taking Lamar Jackson instead of trading up for Josh Rosen.

You gotta define "the decade" here. Is it 2015-2024? The 2020s?

HOW IS THE BIGGEST MISTAKE FOR THE 49ERS NOT TRADING 3 FIRSTS FOR TREY LANCE TO PLAY 4 GAMES LOL

GB's biggest mistake, which still happen, is either being way too slow to correct mistakes, like the firing of bad coaches or coordinators OR it's the inability to fix the defense. For example Joe Barry. He was NOT fired. No, this woefully underperforming DC was allowed to coach out his contract and just not re-signed. Or GB has been trying since 2010 to fix it's defense and has failed, it's poured in every 1st round pick for 14 years (except Love in 2020) and eight of Matt Lefleur's nine 1st round picks into the defense and has yet to field a better than average defense (best was 14th I think). The last time GB had a top 5 defense- they won a Super Bowl.

@footballholicstt

16 күн бұрын

That's a solid pick, they do keep coaches way past expiration date

Chip kelly getting gm powers was the worst thing that happened to the eagles the wentz deal was signed early so it wasn’t that terrible that’s why they could move off so quickly

@footballholicstt

5 күн бұрын

That's a good one. But I don't think they win the Super Bowl without Chip getting rid of some of the players he did (even though he was an objectively awful GM)

@xNotRealx

3 күн бұрын

@@footballholicstt definitely not howie became hungry once he got his power back I think about that all the time what if chip Kelly was never hired would we have won haha

If your a Niners fan and you dont think firing Jim Harbaugh for Trent Baalke was our biggest mistake of the decade (let go in 2014), you probably actually are a Niners fan and have repressed that memory to the point where it doesn't exist for you anymore.

@footballholicstt

15 күн бұрын

Jim was going regardless, even if he survives that power struggle. Jed was going to fire him. That is a solid pick though.

@blastechee-3546

14 күн бұрын

Agreed this was the same owner/GM that had 4 different HC in 4 consecutive years. I believe this is the only time this has happened in NFL history (I did not look it up).

I disagree on the Packers because that was a player error, not a team error -- the problem wasn't having Bostick on the field, it was that he decided to try to play hero instead of play his correct assignment. If Bostick just did what he was told (which was to block and NOT try to go for the ball), Packers probably recover that kick. I would instead say it's one of two things (and both ultimately connect to the 2020 season): 1. Drafting Kevin King. Obviously it's hindsight but the Packers had better options; TJ Watt is the obvious one, but even if they were determined to go DB (which was probably reasonable based on their roster), Budda Baker went a couple picks after King and would've been a much better selection at that pick. If they don't draft King, maybe that position gets filled by someone who doesn't get burned by Scotty Miller and/or doesn't commit a needless PI penalty at the worst possible moment. 2. More directly, not going for it on fourth down in the 2020 NFC Championship. Not only did this cost them the game, it most likely started the fracturing of the relationship between Rodgers and the team. Don't get me wrong, I think the Packers ultimately moved on from Rodgers at the right time, but 2021 and 2022 could've been smoother in the process. (Maybe they don't have to give him that big contract in 2022, for example.) Honorable mention, hiring Mo Drayton as a special teams coordinator. If that 2021 team has even a reasonably competent special teams coach, they probably at least make it to the NFC Championship -- and Sean McVay has never beaten Matt LaFleur.

@footballholicstt

15 күн бұрын

The 4th down for the NFC championship is a solid pick. That move was a head scratcher

Well, maybe Yt won't delete _this_ comment. What Carr was doing in those games was Correcting Pete Carmichael's Errors. This is why Dennis Allen, doing the One Thing I've ever seen him do right just stood on the sideline & allowed Carr to do this. He knew that Carmichael was inept & allowed Carr to do this & what do you know, the last 3 weeks of the season the offense clicked. I don't think most people realize how NFL teams are structured. It would require Full Mutiny to correct problems caused by play-callers. Did you not _see _*_HOW upset_* Bellichick got with Jones over him seeking help outside of Matt Patricia? When there's no one in ownership holding the coaches accountable, the players are screwed. We just saw the Eagles go from contenders to a laughing stock because of this & it's like the next second you forget play-calling & coaches exist. You _just singled out Matt Patricia _*_as a terrible play-caller & coach_* but you think what, Pete Carmichael was good?

As a fellow 49ers fan the Thomas pick still hurts … I am tired of everyone saying we had Mahommes on the board … No we didn’t we just signed Garropalo and he still hadn’t lost or been injured and was just made the highest paid player in the NFL. Thomas had a lot going against… Dude lives in a closet and losing his sister broke him mentally. He seemed like a great teammate always involved with the team but I solely attribute his failure to losing his sister …

@footballholicstt

11 күн бұрын

We didn't have Jimmy as QB yet.

I disagree with the Eagles one. Signing Wentz was a good deal that didn't immediately off the intended way, B U T!, Wentz had value at tha point so the Eagles traded him quickly ang were able to parlay that into two 1rd picks that gave up Devonta Smith and Jalen Carter while keeping our 1st rd picks.

@oleonard7319

18 күн бұрын

no Wentz was a horrible waste of money. He was an out of control narcissistic egomaniac. Who had to be the center of attention even when it was detrimental to the team.

Entertaining video man! I do say though, I think an organization's worst decision drafting a player is unfair. No one knows at the time of the draft who's gonna be good or bad

Yeah, whoever decided Commanders should be fired from future PR opportunities. Red Wolves wouldve been so much cooler. Well anything wouldve been much cooler. Changing Redskins, a legendary franchise to nothing. I get the sensitivity need or want to change but come on now.

I mean if the Niners Drafted Garret we may not have gotten Bosa…

@footballholicstt

11 күн бұрын

I think there is a solid chance we still grab Bosa, that team was really bad. I don’t think Garrett would have made a huge difference

I think that the Todd Gurley extension ruined the RB value market

@footballholicstt

11 күн бұрын

I don’t think it was the final death knell but it definitely was a part of the reason RBs don’t get paid anymore

Very entertaining video, loved the Chip Kelly shot 😆🤘🦅🦅🦅

@footballholicstt

Ай бұрын

Thanks, appreciate it. That clip made me laugh and I had to put it in

@legoguru3000

Ай бұрын

​@@footballholicstthahah yeah, desean Jackson and shady talked about him recently on their show

The worst decision of the decade the 49ers made is both the reason the niners are good again but will never be good enough to win a Lombardi: Kyle Shanahan. Shanahan had the opportunity to go to Mahomes pro-day. He skipped it. His philosophy vs Demeco Ryans. Kyle didn't choose a QB and build a team around him like Ryans did. Texans were a playoff team in Ryans first year as HC. Kyle's record was so bad for so long that it took Brock Purdy to get it over .500 and keep it there.

@footballholicstt

14 күн бұрын

I will be honest I’m not the biggest Kyle Shanahan fan either. Coaching takes a bit of humility and he doesn’t seem to have it. It makes him better than average but I fear he has a ceiling. He also doesn’t learn from his mistakes.

@michag4337

13 күн бұрын

The issue with the 9ers is they have to beat mahomes. Like let's just be honest here, if Kittle (loved this kid since his cousin HKC announced he was coming to iowa) doesn't get that PI to end the first half, the 9ers probably win that bowl with Jimmy G. Last year if Greenlaw doesn't get smited by god they probably win that superbowl. Atlanta was in no way his fault, even with Matty Ice taking a sack, and fumbling, if the falcons come out in the same defense they played the first half in the pats never have a shot to come back. I'll never forget (as a brady fan from the time he was as michigan, don't @ me, it still feels dirty as a dyed in the wool hawks fan) hearing moss say "I got my money on the goat, cause dan quinn has lost x number of games he's had a y or more lead in, because he comes out in prevent to try and hold it." and that is exactly what he did. So you can not like shanny, i get that, he's like night mode cliff kingsbury, but he's not the reason. 2 wonk plays and dan quinn using madden to call plays is why shanny has 0 rings instead of 3.

Dude, you even showed it. Olave pulled off that 9 route.

7:21 Believe it or not, I remember football fans saying this was a terrible trade for the Eagles. Which baffled me then and obviously baffles me a lot more now.

@footballholicstt

14 күн бұрын

I was on team it was a fantastic move. AJ Brown is an elite WR

@Phinal_Flash

14 күн бұрын

​@footballholicstt Trading a fragile Sam Bradford who nearly gave up on the team for a first round pick. I doubt many teams would have passed up that situation.

trading amari cooper for dallas is another bad one

Rams fan here. I don't consider paying Todd Gurley a mistake. He's a running back so it wasn't like the deal crippled them that much in terms cap space plus the extension was done in the last year of his rookie contract so they didn't have 'many years of control' outside maybe the franchise tag. And Todd is such a good guy. I'm happy he got paid. The REAL biggest mistake of the decade was hiring Jeff Fisher. As an LA native, I didn't root for the Rams until they came back so to me (and LA) it was only 1 lost season but still...

@footballholicstt

14 күн бұрын

Fisher was hired in 2012, this wouldn't work for the premise of the video. Maybe keeping him past 2015 was the biggest mistake of the decade

Lol i love trubisky

You gotta at least honorable mention signing Blair Walsh for the Seahawks. He was already mentally broken when he got signed on.

@billhicks808

Ай бұрын

Not just that, he was originally broken in front of the Seahawks. The organization had a front row seat and still ignored it.

Bro I could've done without the Brandon Bostik or however you spell his name crap for the rest of my adult life😂😂😂

Washington’s name change didn’t affect the team or their success in any way.

@itztrue2

Ай бұрын

i mean.. they haven’t had any success this decade anyway. so i think bad logo is valid

Atlanta has been spiraling ever since 28-3. We tried to pretend everything was okay for far too long. Matt Ryan damn near duplicated his production from his MVP season, and it went for naught because we never addressed our evermore gaping holes on defense. We were 1-7, with Joe Burrow and Tua Tagoviola at the top of the draft board, and Matt Ryan starting to show his age. Better try to make a mad dash for the playoffs. Oh that wasn't obviously far too little far too late? Better bring the coach who couldn't get the team to rally until it literally couldn't matter back again. "Hey everyone, it's fine! We have a running back now!"... apparently Todd Gurley's knee was suddenly going to realize that it was back in Georgia and the arthritis would have just stopped dead in its tracks. Reliving 28-3 every week until Quinn got fired was not fun. Yup. That's right, Blank, we're just a tight end away from contention. Better lock him up as the highest drafted tight end ever and never ever consider throwing the ball in his general direction. Oh... you... finally decided to consider a successor for Matt Ryan? And at the top of your list... a guy who hasn't played in nearly 2 years and might be facing prison time. Did you forget how we came about *getting * Matt Ryan? Congrats on blowing your load- now we have to replace him out of THIS draft stock. So confident in this pick that we didn't even consider starting him. How the fuck did we only get eliminated on the final week while actively ignoring all of our playmakers? Whatever, just fire Smith out of a cannon, please? I wonder who our next coach will be. We're interviewing these top guys multiple times... The guy we replaced with Arthur Smith? He's coached 1 good season. Apart from that, he's who you hire to win the Tank Bowl. Penix... I get that we want an insurance policy for Cousins, especially how qb play has been since we fucked ourselves out of Matt Ryan, but if we're that concerned about it, why did we throw him that bag? This is overcorrecting if I've ever seen it.

@footballholicstt

28 күн бұрын

I’m sending you virtual hugs.

49ers would not have gotten the first pick in 2017. I looked it up it if 49ers lose out go 1-15 same as Browns. Tie breaker is team that had the lower opponents strength of schedule. Browns .448 number 21. 49ers .554 number one. So the Browns were the worst team against the easier schedule. If I am wrong correct me. But yes wishful thinking for Myles Garrett and you know Lynch trying to build the 2002 Buccaneers strong D-Line would have taken Garrett. 2017 Shanahan did not need a QB he had Hoyer and drafted Beathard so Lynch/Shanahan had QB solved. I have NEVER seen an organization say ok lets go get our franchise QB 5 YEARS into the regime before, until the 49ers did it, and then 49ers did not get franchise QB in 2021. 2017 the 49ers could have had the one that just beat the 49ers for another Super Bowl. The Bryce Young outlook anytime in the draft QB's are taken 1-2 overall one is good and one is not, or both are not. I have looked up this situation. 1994, 1998, 1999 (3), 2012, 2015, 2016, 2021 (3), 2023, 2024 (3). Not saying QB were never good but for team drafted them no. One good one not or both not. Never are both good. So yeah Bryce Young......

I knew Wilks is gone after the first half of lions game. Defense played decent in the SB but they won’t recover what Wilks has done

@footballholicstt

Ай бұрын

Wilks was such an awful DC. Made our elite defense look horrible

hey man good video but please crop the youtube videos that you use as b roll. it just kinda takes me out of the video and distracts me. also, if you want, adobe has this AI software that makes your audio quality super nice.

The worst choice for the 9ers is choking every year when it matters 😂 How do you go to a Super Bowl 3 times in the last 15 years and you choke EVERY time hell how do you go two times in 5 years and choke both times to the same team 😂😂😂😂😂

@footballholicstt

23 күн бұрын

Yeah sucks for those 49er fans (Slowly sobs knowing I'm a 49er fan)

@HalooINC

15 күн бұрын

Its honestly probably a large Football Gods debt we owe for all of the 80's and a good chunk of the 90's. Our debt was due and I'm hoping one of these Super bowls it turns out we've paid it off and we actually get one for once. (Also I'm coping hard, I'm an addict judge me if you must)

I'm honestly surprised that the Cowboys have been as good as they have been in spite of the organization's bad decisions. They've routinely zigged when they should have zagged. Say what you will about McCarthy (which I echo as a fan), but he's still been better than Jason Garret was, and the team has gone 12-5 when Prescott is healthy. At least the Cowboys don't have Shanahan.

@footballholicstt

15 күн бұрын

It is amazing how consistent they’ve been the past decade, considering all the turmoil. However I think that changes this year, I think the bill is gonna come due.

The saints gotta be paying Taysom Hill any money. There was absolutely no point in paying a gadget backup QB any money (and they PAID him).

@footballholicstt

Ай бұрын

Honestly we could just say what Mickey Loomis has done to the cap should be the number 1 problem, they could have reasonably gotten out of the problems before paying Carr. Now they are fucked.

@ahjuxue2121

Ай бұрын

@@footballholicstt LMFAO! Iono, that man has somehow continued to work magic to keep payin' folks lol!

@1001011011010

29 күн бұрын

Taysom Hill plays around the field on numerous positions. He's on the high end for a TE but he's not just a TE, really it isn't that bad.

@ahjuxue2121

25 күн бұрын

@@1001011011010 taysom hill is a QB by position and does not do enough to deserve that pay lol! only the saints are payin' a QB to do that

I dont blame Bryce Young for being a "bust". He was put in a horrible position.

Bostic was not supposed to catch that

@footballholicstt

Ай бұрын

Which makes it so much worse, he was only supposed to block

@LoveThe3rdGate

Ай бұрын

​@@footballholicsttYes but worst decision of the Packers? How? That was Bostick's stupid thinking lol, not the Packers Bad pick brotha

@Hashishiyah

Ай бұрын

​@LoveThe3rdGate It's a team sport. He's a part of the team. It wasn't a bad pick.

@LoveThe3rdGate

Ай бұрын

@@Hashishiyah It's a huge stretch lmao, by this metric then the Cowboys pick with Ezekiel is bad because you can argue the "Dez Dropped It" game is worse because Dez decided to risk going for the TD instead of securing the ball Dumb pick, the reality is he should've went with his initial pick of "Packers didn't go all in for Rodgers' final years"

@Hashishiyah

Ай бұрын

@@LoveThe3rdGate Wym? The cowboys are still paying Zeke back for that 2020 deal, and they gotta pay him more since he resigned. Thats definitely worse than one lost game, considering all the games they could have won if they had the money to pay another good player instead of a washed up running back. Maybe they wouldve even beat the Packers for once.💀

Eagles passing on Metcalf and jefferson

you wiffed on the saints. That was on olave. Carr was expecting a double move because there was no safety over top. Olave missed it. As peyton manning says "If the qb misses that bad in the nfl, it's almost always on the receiver." If Olave stutters and goes that's a huge gain, if not a TD. Carr also pissed off his oline...which was the worst in the NFL. I'd be fucking furious too if i had my ribs broken 3 seperate times because my oline was that bad. You mentioned a list of receivers who didn't like him...they were all dog water. Adams LOVES carr, and he's the only HoFer who carrs had, so i'd say Carr isn't the problem, it's shit teams. It's hard to take a football channel seriously when you can't break down the coverage before giving a skip bayless esq shit take though. Like if you throw the ball 15 yards past a receiver who was breaking on a streak, and there is no defender near it...that means it was wide ass open and the receiver fucked up. That's mid high school/ d2 colllege level analsyts.

@footballholicstt

13 күн бұрын

You are in bargaining right now. The five stages are brutal.

Dallas - paying Dak so much......a few things you said weren't even bad. They should have switched to Andy Dalton or Cooper Rush. Philadelphia - not making Gardner Minshew II their starter. That's even worse than the Wentz deal. N.Y. Giants - too dysfunctional - but I don't think Saquon was worst Washington - should still be the Redskins Detroit - dumbass trying for a 2-point conversion 85 times when the extra point takes them into overtime Green Bay - sticking with Aaron Rodgers when he has choked in the playoffs since the Super Bowl (they don't beat the Patriots) Minnesota - not giving Kyle Sloter a chance to start Chicago - drafting Caleb Williams #1 - he'll be a bigger bust than Ryan Leaf New Orleans - not giving Taysom Hill the QB job when Drew Brees retired Tampa Bay - agree Carolina - starting Bryce Young over Andy Dalton - pure stupidity (just like Dallas) San Francisco - trading up for Trey Lance instead of sticking with Jimmy G. (because they could have still gotten Purdy without losing all that draft capital) Seattle - agree L.A. Rams - agree Atlanta - paying Kirk Cousins so much (and drafting Penix) - kinda two-for-one Arizona - Kyler Murray, by far

@kred792

Ай бұрын

I don't think the Niners wanted Lance at #3 overall (could have had him at their original draft spot), I think they wanted someone else (maybe Mac Jones) and then in the course of the offseason, realized that whoever they wanted at #3 originally wasn't worth that high of a pick and panicked into taking a glorified High School QB (Lance). I agree it's their biggest mistake and both the GM Lynch and HC Shanahan would likely have been fired if not for Purdy.