Why not have the Mystery Tour and Yellow Submarine as a single box? In fact, several of the earliest albums may need to be combined, as they would benefit from a remix but have so few outtakes to use (that's why Anthology used mostly live takes for that period). Combine Please Please Me-With the Beatles-Beatles For Sale and then combine Hard Day's Night-Help, and you'll have caught up with Rubber Soul. Including the singles, as you suggested. Happy New Year Tone, and thanks for all the good discussion!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Great comment John. Yes I did touch on the doubling up of albums in a set in my video about what we might get in 2023 for the very reasons that you suggest. In fact Giles Martin said recently that at the start of the Revolver project that they considered combining Revolver and Rubber Soul because they weren't sure they had enough outtakes etc. Anthology is always a good clue to how much additional good material there is as you point out. Thanks very much for this great comment and Happy New Year to you and yours .

@michaelharrington75

Жыл бұрын

They should combine the albums by year, along with the singles and EP's that came out in those years. 1963 'Please Please Me' and 'With The Beatles' + 'Love Me Do' (Single version), 'From Me To You'/'Thank You Girl', 'She Loves You'/'I'll Get You', 'I Want To Hold Your Hand/'This Boy'. 'Komm Gib Mir Deine Hand' 'Sie Liebt Dich'. 1964 'A Hard Days Night' and 'Beatles For Sale' + 'Long Tall Sally'/'I Call Your Name'/'Slow Down'/'Matchbox'. 'I Feel Fine'/'She's A Woman'. 1965 'Help!' And 'Rubber Soul' ÷ 'Yes It Is'. 'Bad Boy' , 'I'm Down', 'We Can Work It Out'/'Day Tripper'.

@jasonchilders9819

Жыл бұрын

I can see A Hard Day's Night and Help! being done together. I would also include the instrumentals from the Capitol editions (whether just in either mono, stereo, or both), just to complete the period. Put them on a separate disc if need be. On another note, I'd find a way to include the three tracks from the Capitol "Rarities" album as well as the different versions from "The Beatles Box" into the remaining sets.

@cyprusrodeo4658

Жыл бұрын

May I heartily recommend Prof Stoned’s brilliant remixes of the first 6 albums . He combines related singles and other stuff .His Stereo She loves you is astonishing ,

I believe that Magical Mystery Tour box set will come out in 2027. That will be the 60th anniversary. And then I think Yellow Submarine may come in 2028. Don't forget we have the "Carnival Of Light" probably come out in the Magical Mystery Tour box. (Paul has wanted to release that track for years and this will be his opportunity). And there is the extended version of it's all too much that George really liked.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

I agree that the most logical time to get these out will now be the 60th Anniversary , it seems a long time to wait but the most likely. Does that mean that you think that Please Please Me will be the next one to coincide with the 60th Anniversary next year? It would certainly be interesting to get Carnival of Light at last although I found it a tough listen when I heard it a while back. Thanks very much for a great comment.

@stereofidelic67

Жыл бұрын

I think they've given up on Anniversary re-issues and are now putting them out on a yearly basis under the 'Super Deluxe' banner.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@stereofidelic67 Yes Revolver didnt represent any anniversary. Got a sneaky feeling they might return to anniversaries this year what with it being the 60th for PPM & WTB

@WinkDaMan07

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel Wait a minute! You heard Carnival of Light?!?!?

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@WinkDaMan07 Ive heard something that said it was carnival of light although there are a few sources and nobody know which one is the real one. Apparently George stopped it from being included in Anthology 2 due to its poor quality

Happy new year Tone , and many thanks for all your brilliant videos through 2022 & I look forward to your videos for 2023 .

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much John. I'm glad you are enjoying the content of the channel and I thank you for your support. Happy New Year my friend.

Happy 2023 Tone. Thanks for this channel. This is really awesome

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Happy New Year Marcelo, thanks very much. Im very happy that you enjoy this channel and great to have you as part of it. Thanks once again

Happy New Year Tone! Your hard work in presenting us subscribers your fabulous videos are surely appreciated! Keep up the great work my friend!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much Tony. Im glad you're enjoying the channel and thanks for being a part of it. Happy New Year mate

Thank you 🙏 Happy New Year🎈

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Cheers Paul. Happy New year to you too

I'd like a Magical Mystery Tour one. As well as the regular album they could include the UK EP version with it.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Great idea Stephen. Thanks for your comment

Fabulous video Tone and thanks for all these great videos you have brought us. I would love a box set remix of the Magical Mystery Tour sessions. A Happy New Year to you and your family.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much James. Glad You enjoyed the video. I agree a MMT box would be fabulous, we definitely need it. Happy New Year to you and yours too my friend

Happy New Year, Tone! 🎄☃️🧨🎇🎅

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Happy New Year my friend

dont forget all the film music that never was released other than in the film , im talking about songs like Shirley's wild accordian ,jessie's dream, aerial tour instrumental plus the long version of flying which clocks in at 11:55 minutes long

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yes plenty of extra material about for a MMT SDE for sure Ralph.

Another great video Tone, so thanks for that. My personal opinion is that both will be bypassed for some time and that next up will be Rubber Soul. Having said that it could be a limited edition crate of singles, lol. Wishing you all the best for the New Year and please keep up the good work as your channel is like a breath of fresh air compared to many others!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Hi Peter, great to hear from you and hope you are well. Yes they are so ridged about releasing for anniversaries that I wouldn't be surprised to see MMT arrive in 2027 which is a long wait. I think the smart money is on Rubber Soul being next but because of this anniversary thing , I wouldn't rule out seeing Please Please Me as the next one to coincide with the 60th anniversary next year. Who knows? Thanks for your great comment about the channel and thank you for your support. Happy New Year to you and yours mate . Nice singles crate gag btw

Happy new year Tone all the best mate 👍

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Cheers Martin Happy New Year to you

Hello Tone, hope you had a good holiday. Enjoyed your thoughts on MMT and YS. Would of course love anything they give us and the album of MMT is fantastic, it was the first album I bought with my own money so would love some extras of that. Who knows Paul might look at it as the Broad Street of the Beatles catalog and ignore it.Looking forward to the new year and what surprises we might be getting from solo and Beatle items. Hope the new year finds you well. I sure enjoy all your videos and appreciate all you put into them. Take care!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Hi Sharon , yes had a great holiday thanks and I hope you did too. I just think MMT is just too good to ignore , especially in the album format. Interesting that it was the first one you got. I think with some decent of outtakes and demos etc and a great stereo remix of those great songs, it has the potential to be a really great box. Yes it could be a busy and expensive 2023 for us Beatles fans , well see. Thank you for your continued support of the channel and I always appreciate your comments. Have a great 2023 Sharon.

Thank YOU Tone, your videos and stories have been a pleasure and I look forward to a whole lot more fun in 2023!! 🙂 I'd be up for a remix/box set of 'Magical Mystery Tour' and 'Yellow Submarine' as you yourself say there is quite a bit of additional material that could be included. I absolutely adore Past Masters and play it pretty often, although I don't know if there would be any point bringing that out again unless there are any additional complete songs, demos or live performances we don't yet "officially" know about...

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much James. I'm glad you are enjoying the channel and I thank you for being a part of it and getting involved. Yes the additional material is always interesting, but for me the big selling point of these things is getting a good stereo mix of the albums and for me that would also include the singles and b sides that appear on Past Masters. Thanks as always for your opinion and comments. Happy New Year

@johndowling5850

Жыл бұрын

Tone, I really like your presentations. Good info brilliant humour about GH and EC, and the Seas. Wonderful.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@johndowling5850 Thanks very much John. Glad you enjoyed the video and the humour

I’ll just save up for the London Town and BTTE archive sets. Merry Christmas and a happy New Year!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Happy new Year my friend

Hi Beatley Tone, the pastasters are NOT an official catalogue, having said that I think MMT will get the remastering as its now an. accepted part of the Catalogue, "Past Masters" will not qualify unfortunately! 😑 Cool channel BTW.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

I agree re past Masters as I said in the video, its a compilation album, But it doesn't include singles and b sides that Id like to hear given the good stereo remix that they deserve , because what we have now as stereo mixes is not befitting the most important band in pop music's history. So they need to do something with those tracks. Thanks for your comment and Im glad youre enjoying the channel's content. Appreciate your comment.

Hello, thanks for this video, I am quite a big fan of the original Yellow submarine 1969 album, I particularly love the George Martin orchestral B side, and would love to see an deluxe version containing lots of extra George Martin material if there is any which I'm sure there is, anyway that's what I would like, cheers and keep them coming.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Im sure that there is extra soundtrack material and if YS got a stand alone box set, Im pretty sure that George Martin Orchestra stuff that was left of the original album would be included to pad it out Keith

Happy healthy New Year! I wouldn’t mind. Yellow Submarine box with more emphasis on George Martin somehow being incorporated at least once in a more elevated fashion. Maybe some video of his orchestra would help add to it. I This box is needed for the completest as far as the remastering goes. Whatever they do, the surprise of what we will get keeps us going!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Happy New Year to you, thanks for your interesting comment

I do think the next Deluxe treatment will be Rubber Soul. With the new Peter Jackson technology it opens the doors to hear the "early "Beatles as never before. I also think they'll release two albums at a time in box sets as mentioned. A Hard Days Night / Help, Please Please Me / With The Beatles you get the idea. Magical Mystery Tour and Yellow Submarine would work as a package. Then anything that hasn't been remixed with the new technology . Maybe call it " The 45's."

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Totally agree, with the PJ tech we are going hear those early albums like we never have before. I also think the doubling up of albums in a box may well happen. it seems like a good idea for those albums where there aren't many decent session recordings. The 45's good title. Thanks for this great comment.

@WinkDaMan07

Жыл бұрын

We’ll finally be able to hear She Loves You and From Me To You in stereo!!!!

Hi Tone, a healthy and happy new year to you! Very interesting thoughts about these albums. I also see a possibility for the combined super deluxe box sets as John Kratunis predicted or proposed. Especially for Yellow submarine, this would make sense since most of the "new" songs were recorded in 1967. For the early albums, combined SDE would also make sense, however Apple can melk the fans more with single box sets. It would be great to have proper remixes of the past masters songs, but a SDE for this appears unlikely to me. My guess for the next SDE is Please Please Me, maybe combined with With the Beatles. But we will see. In one year we know more.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Hi Armin, Happy New Year to you and yours my friend. Yes combined SDEs could well be the way forward especially in the case of MMT and YS - that seems a popular shout. I also have a sneaking feeling that PPM or and a combined 1963 set could be next because of the 60th anniversary - although most people will be hoping for Rubber Soul. Singles could continue to be included on the remaining sets, but that will still leave a gap for songs like remixes of Lady Madonna, The inner Light, Hey Jude, Revolution, Old Brown SHow, You know My Name , Ballad of J&Y - without a past masters set, these get missed so they really need to think it through

@arminzink1621

Жыл бұрын

@Beatley Tone's Beatles Channel I fully agree with that. These mixes deserve a decent new mix. possibly is also a past masters remix album without a SDE treatment at a later stage, e.g. 2026 for Xmas market. We will see.

They could bring out MMT as a remixed album with extras and the EP and Yellow Sub EP mono and remixed stereo with Across the universe as the 4 songs and Across the universe as they were thinking of releasing in 1969

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yes MMT with the 4 Yellow sub songs in a box works for me too

Hi Mate!!! Christmas we a good one yes thanks for asking!!! I think you are right Y they did miss these Albums!! Pepper sure was a good start. I like MMT a lot and would like to see a now one of it. I did have a VHS of the film in B/&W. But now I can't find it so win the new one dose come out I would like to see that happen too!!! YSM just might be a good one for a nice box set. Yes, I do like the re mix a lot on vinyl!! Ok just to do this different the Past Masters I would like to see a vinyl box set + a Video of the Album !! It is a lot to think about what is going to come out this new year. But I do think that this new year they need to do one for Pleas Pleas me!! Great video Tonny and happy new year mate cheers!!!!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Hey Brad, Happy New Year to you and yours. Definitely need a MMT box. Ive never seen the film in B/W as it was original shown on Boxing Day 1967. I must be weird and kind of defeats the point. Yes there should be loads coming out this year and I cant wait. ive got a sneaky feeling that PPM will be the next one because of the 60th Anniversary. Glad you liked the video and thanks as always for a great comment.

@beatlebrad5339

Жыл бұрын

You know you just aren't missing much. Win the Film goes to the George song Flying ....... Nothing lol B/W mate!!!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@beatlebrad5339 😂😂

@beatlebrad5339

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel :)!!!!

Happy new year 🎉

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Happy New Year Tom

Great commentary! I have always wanted the super deluxe Magucal Mystery Tour LP sans Penny Lane and Strawberry Fields PLUS The Inner Light and the new Yellow Sub tracks. I would accept (happily) MMT with what must be KILLER outtakes and a separate Yellow Sub Songtrack modern remix. Lots of YS outtakes and the Japanese mono Yellow Sub as well. Past Masters is a bit difficult to redo. I have the mono Past Masters triple LP, which would be hard to beat!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much, Im glad you enjoyed the video. Im all for combining albums in box sets as long as we get a good stereo remix of the album tracks and some interesting out takes, demos etc. I also have the Mono Masters album but this reissue project is more about good stereo remixes of the songs , because up to this point the stereo mixes are not great and there's no reason for there to be bad stereo mixes now, so I would still like all the songs that on Past Masters to get the remix treatment whether that's as an all encompassing album or split into the time period album sets , I don't mind. Thanks for a great comment

I think Past Masters is basically going to be phased out, since all those early tracks will eventually be divvied out as bonus tracks on future deluxe albums. Combining Mystery Tour and Yellow Submarine the most sense to me, but selfishly I’d like to have a vinyl package someday that puts the YS, ‘68, and ‘69 singles in a better presentation. I always listen to Yellow Submarine mixed with those singles, as sort of what I feel Capitol should’ve done instead of the Hey Jude and Yellow Submarine LPs. To me it presents those great songs in a way that doesn’t just feel like a “compilation” and would stand up amongst their albums

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

It does look like its heading that way for Past masters which I dont mind as long all of the songs that have been missed so far (like you say , the 68 and 69 singles) are included somewhere. I does look like a joint MMT and YS with singles we've talked about will work as a package and would be wonderful. thanks for you comment Manuel - makes sense to me.

@james-coxon

Жыл бұрын

What track list do you have when you mix the singles and YS? Sounds like something is like to listen to!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@james-coxon I think Manuel is looking at something that looks likes this - It's Only A Northern Song, All Together Now, Het Bulldog, It's All Too Much, Lady Madonna, The Inner light, Hey Jude, Revolution, The Ballad of John & Yoko, Old Brown Shoe, Get Back, Don't Let Me Down.

MMT already got a remix treatment back in 2012 for the re-issue of the film on Blu-ray. But you can only hear these new mixes by watching the film as they didn't release a stand alone song track album which was a strange decision.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yes and nobody wants to sit through that film every time they want to hear MMT. So yes definitely need this in an audio only format

Just a quick note on Past Masters, they could include Free As A Bird & Real Love on a “Remix Edition”. Imagine what could be done with John’s demo tapes with de-mix technology etc.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yes absolutely James. That would be amazing if they could make those John vocals better. Great shout

@WinkDaMan07

Жыл бұрын

And Paul and Ringo could finally finish Now and Then!!!

Fantastic vdeo again my freind. Love this episode and yes, i have been wondering the very same thing ragarding Tour, Sub and Masters. I personally think they should take the 4 songs and 2023 re-master/mix them and then... take the rest of the songs off the 1999 release and remaster/remix those to complete the Beatles portion of original songs and then.... remaster/remix the george martin orchestration instrumentals for a 2nd album in the deluxe package and finallly, outakes from say january 1969 sessions just weeks or days BEFORE the let it be rehearsals being they are so darn close together yes? i mean , how many songs from the get back sessions were actually written and recorded FOR yellow submarine album or whatever the lads had planned at that time just AFTER the white album ??? So, in essence we could have 3 full albums in a deluxe box set plus a book AND a 3D version of yellow submarine which was planned but never executed. Heck, with Mal A.I. they could literally pull that off so we could enjoy the 3D on our televions at home using paper 3D glasses inlcuded in the package !!! This is what i would do with that. As for MMT yes, i agree with you. Go crazy and release it but only after RUBBER SOUL which Giles has said will be the next project ( and one can see why). We are into 2023 starting at midnight and it will be 60 years since the Bealtes FIRST album came out and my guess is that they might just have to do a hard choice here between that and Soul OR put them BOTH out this year.... Could be an interesting year indeed. Again, love you man. oh , almost forgot. Past Masters is great but i dont think it can be made into deluxe box sets.... not like the other ones we are seeing anyway. Perhaps, a simple. A.I . treatment to improver sound but thats about it. Star Club 1962 is what peter jackson wants to do and he has aproached the lads about that one so again.... who knows what that might bring? WHEW, what a year this could be. Lets just pray the world dont destroy itself before we get these gems.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Brilliant comment. Im nominating you to become head of Apple !! Ive got a sneaky feeling that PPM might be next just because of the 60th Anniversary but you never know we might get both next year. Its certainly going to be an interesting (and expensive ) year for us when you consider all the solo releases that are also reaching 50th anniversary this year. Glad you love the channel thanks very much I really appreciate this comment. happy New Year to you

A few things I think they could do: - Magical Mystery Tour could be released in 4K, and they can just release it by way of a super deluxe edition. To make it different from the 2012 box set, the package could include a CD-sized replica of the EP: CD1 the 2012 mix (first time on CD!) or a new Giles Martin mix, CD2 the original mono mix. CD3 could include sessions tracks and new mixes of "Hello Goodbye," "Baby You're a Rich Man" and "All You Need Is Love". Additional bonus material on the 4K disc could include material from the era like a restored b&w version of the original "All You Need Is Love" broadcast and surround mixes of the EP tracks. - same treatment with Yellow Submarine...4K disc and four CDs. CD1 could be the original remixed all-stereo album ("Hey Bulldog" could really use the demix treatment), CD2 could be sessions, CD3 could be the full George Martin score, CD4 could be an EP that includes new transfers of the four mono songs from Mono Masters. - drop Past Masters and come up with a new compilation - with a new name - that collects remixed versions of the singles/EPs left off the super deluxe albums, maybe in a smaller package like the 1+ blu-ray set. If MMT and YS aren't happening, they can simply include it in the new compilation. It doesn't necessarily need to have new remixes for the post-Revolver albums since the 2015 mixes on 1 are already good; Sgt Pepper had the 2015 mix of "Strawberry Fields Forever, " for instance.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

A very well thought through post. I just wonder off they would include video material in any of these box sets as they haven't so far but I really like your ideas so Id love something like these. I agree the Past Masters needs a revamp, I never really understood why they were called Past Masters anyway lol. Bit of a nondescript name . Nice comment

@tapsilogic

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel thanks! re: video material - I was thinking the same thing, but the Sgt Pepper SDE did have some video material so it's won't entirely be out of place. They could also do the same with Help! but I think it would have more of an album-centric treatment (vs. MMT and YS being movie-centric), if that makes sense. If they do all of that, though...I wonder how they will treat AHDN in SDE format since - if I remember correctly - Criterion has the rights to the movie and they've already released it in 4K.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@tapsilogic Yes Pepper did , I'd forgotten that, so I guess you never know. Yes AHDN is already out in 4k. The thing is, that has not really been a set format for any of these boxes so far especially if you've bought the Lp box (the last 3 matched the CD version, but White album didnt and pepper didnt even have a LP box just a stand alone LP). That said, it would seem perfectly feasible for some sets to have films and others not. They will keep us guessing right up to the last minute. 🙂

They’ll be remixed/demixed, but they’ll be quietly dropped into their streaming catalogue as the “prime“ authorised version. The new mixes will become the quiet default on physical media and the original stereo mixes will be relegated to streaming only. I also have a hunch that when we lose the last of the four Beatles a trust will push every second of Beatles studio recording work into the public domain, but retain the masters for authorised versions. Giles Martin is understandably being coy about future projects to maximise his personal return, but Macca will be anxious to wrap up everything ASAP while he’s still here. A “Rubber Soul” box set could well be their last pay day.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Interesting thoughts, we will certainly see a glut of releases once Paul and Ringo are no longer with , just as we do when all important rock stars die, which is not necessarily a bad thing. Im sure we wouldn't have have the Lennon material that we now have had it not been for Yoko'd determination to keep John's name alive. Thanks for an interesting comment

The Capiphone project MMT/YS disc program features the six songs from MMT and all but All You Need Is Love from YS .The 8:00 It's All Too Much is on the Mono program,along with the true Mono mixes on the rest of the tracks.The Stereo on all tracks are true stereo.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Sounds great. What about things like Hello goodbye, Baby You're A Rich man and All You Need is love. Where are these covered?

@ronmartin4212

Жыл бұрын

The All you Need Is Love on the Roundup Vol.1 is the extended Mix on the mono.Thestandard mix is on the singles set.

@ronmartin4212

Жыл бұрын

They are all on Roundup Vol.1,along with Penny Lane(2:57 mix).Penny Lane's US promo mix is on Vol.2.

Excellent video. Great topic too. I believe someday down the road we will see a MMT super deluxe. Seems a real shame to skip that one. As for YS and PM, that is tough to call. I say go for the PM super deluxe and include the four tracks from YS as an EP on it. I see no point to remix the two other Beatles songs from YS or the incidental music from the B side. I’d have a really hard time shelling out for a YS box set. Though maybe they could tie the Yellow Submarine Songtrack in with it and give a completely different remix of it then any other remixes of those songs so far. Plus I’d love an official release of It’s all too Much with the extra verse like we hear in the film. Who knows though. Tomorrow Never Knows.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Dustin , glad you liked the video. I totally agree with you re YS, we only need a remix of those 4 tracks plus any out takes demos etc. It seems they are going down the additional EP route with boxes now so that will probably continue with the early albums with the singles with release dates closest to the albums included , but that will still leave some gaps like the 4 YS tracks Hey Jude, Revolution, Lady Madonna , The Inner Light , You Know My Name etc so maybe the easiest most consistent way to give us good stereo remixes of these songs is a past masters album as you suggest. its almost impossible to try and second guess what they are thinking because they have been so inconsistent in the past . Like you I would really begrudge laying out for a YS SDE. We'll have to wait and see. Thanks for your comment and Happy New Year mate.

@BeatleDustino

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel happy new year to you too! As I was reading back your comment it hit me. Your missing singles are all solved with a Past Masters SDE. All those are on PM. Plus they could tack on the “Yellow Submarine EP” with that box to clear up those four tracks. However, you do get a lot of doubles with the “EP” tracks done with Let It Be and Revolver. I guess we can’t win. But a few doubled up tracks won’t bother me.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@BeatleDustino Me neither. It seems the most logical solution

@BeatleDustino

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel as long as they stop tacking the EP’s into the other albums SDE’s.

Great commentary, Tone. The Magical Mystery Tour and Yellow Submarine tracks ( except for Bulldog ) are all from the 67 period, and belong together, as they were all recorded during the same time period. Substitute the three 1967 YS tracks, in place of Strawberry Fields / Penny Lane, and one would have a fine album.(Strawberry Fields and Penny Lane rightfully belong with the Pepper session, not with MMT. ) The 4 early 68 tracks ( Lady Madonna, The Inner Light, Hey Bulldog, & Across the Universe ) could be included as well, maybe as a stand alone ep or something. Lots of early takes and out-takes from the MMT/YS period that could be included. The full length "It's All Too Much" has never been commercially released. Would love to see it happen.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much, glad you enjoyed the video. Yes a combined MMT and YS box seems to be a popular shout, and that works for me too. What you describe sounds like the perfect way to deal with the missing 1968 tracks too. Are we able to squeeze Ballad of J&Y, Old Brown Shoe and You Know My Name in there somewhere to complete the catalogue? I would also love the full version of It's All too Much too. Thanks for a really great comment

@750drums

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel You pose a good question. How about if Apple were to release a limited edition package of non lp 45's and EP's, both in vinyl and cd , to cover the already released boxes ? That way we could have the ones you mentioned, as well as Strawberry Fields / Penny Lane, Hey Jude/ Revolution, that could be added to our box sets. Would be a nice way to complete the catalog . So many release Apple could do, but I doubt we'll see much.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@750drums I would welcome that as I don't have many of those singles on actual 7" vinyl. Nice idea

Thanks again for another great video Tone. And thanks for all the amazing content you have produced this past year! Surely with the world's greatest band, there must be a master plan for these releases. Surely they didn't just do the 2017 Sgt Pepper without a thought of what would come next? That is hard to believe, and it is also hard to believe that they would have any doubt as to how a remix deluxe box set of Pepper would sell. So I like to think that there is a plan for all the Beatles tracks to be remixed and we just don't know what that plan is yet. I do wonder whether they will combine Magical Mystery Tour and Yellow Submarine into one release and perhaps include the missing late-period songs from Past Masters on it (although these would have been much more at home on the White Album or Abbey Rd boxes). And I doubt very much whether they have enough out-takes to do much with the first few albums so I could see some of those being combined. I think it would be crazy to have to wait years for these. They should release everything remixed within the next couple of years in my opinion. Paul and Ringo are not getting any younger and their approval and input is critical! Also how did you get to hear Carnival of Light and can you point me in the right direction???? BTW what happened to your promised Once Upon a Long Ago video? I was looking forward to that!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Nick, glad you enjoyed the video. I agree that there is a plan now, I was just pointing out that it was unknown territory back in 2017 and I think that is proven by the fact that they didnt give a thought to MMT and went straight onto the White Album. Anniversary dates (or at least years) seem to be key to all these releases and seem to be the main driving force. Whilst I agree that combined box sets will probably be the way forward, I think its unrealistic to expect them to cover all these off in a couple of years and I'd be surprised to see more than one come out per year (unless they stick to individual boxes as per the anniversary dates). I think we're still a few years away from getting everything despite Paul and Ringo's advancing years and although their sign off is important, its not essential as we have seen many releases come out without a George or John's approval. My overall thought that there has been little thought from Apple. The lackadaisical approach seems to be ongoing with EPs with some boxes and not with others, outtakes for singles included without actually including the remixed single - that sort of caper. Carnival of Light - do you remember when Napster was a source of illegal downloading Im guessing around the year 2000ish. Where people would upload their music for others to download? I used to use that as a kind of try before you buy source and I heard it then and Im not sure I made it to the end of the track ! Once Upon a Long Ago - I wanted to end the year with something that had a wider appeal - its still on my radar and I'll get to it soon. Thanks very much for your support of the channel, I really appreciate it and Happy New Year to you and yours Nick.

@nicksyrett

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel Well, they released all the albums in 1987 together on CD (or were they rolled out... I cannot remember). And then released the remasters together (was that in 2009). So why spread everything over so many years. The remixes cannot take months and months. Bring them all out asap I say!!!! When did the changing of the guard happen at apple from Neil to the new guy? Was this mixed up in that I wonder? They released Strawberry Fields and Penny lane with Sgt Pepper so why not the later singles with their relevant Box Sets. It seems crazy to us, but there is likely a lot we don't know - even so it is hard to draw the conclusion that they didn't have a clear plan from the beginning, its only the greatest catalogue in Music history - come on guys!!! Carnival of Light - I wonder if you heard a fake or the "real" track. I thought it had been pretty locked down in the vaults and George H. wouldn't ever agree to its release. I am sure it is terrible, but I would like to hear it! They could release the new mixes without Paul and Ringo's approval but don't you think better to get those mixes done while we still have a couple of Beatles with us. Of the remaining albums (PPM, WTB, HDN, BFS, HELP, RS, MMT, YS) which one would you MOST look forward to as a remix???? I'd love to know!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@nicksyrett 1987 CDs came out in batches . First 4 came out together, then a gap then HELP,RS and Revolver. Pepper I seem to remember was released alone. Then it gets a bit hazy as to how many more tranches there were - doesn't really matter. 2009 came out as box set but as we don't know when work started on them , plus the fact that remastering is not as lengthy a process as remixing (which also includes mastering the remix) it doesn't serve any purpose to compare. Im pretty sure that demixing and remixing every track(as in guitar track, bass track etc) takes time to do it properly. It also assumes that those involved in the process - Giles, Sam various engineers are not booked for any other work apart from this project. There is the compiling of the book, the packaging , the manufacturing, etc etc etc . Im pretty sure that one per year is a reasonable time line. I would much rather wait and have these things done properly (which might be a first) than have them rushed out for the sake of it. Most fans don't have 1500 -2000 to lamp out on 6 or 7 box sets in one go either. All these things are considerations. To be honest, I don't find in the slightest bit hard to draw the conclusion that they didnt have a clear plan from the start - the evidence of that is pain to see. 'Here's the plan guys, we'll release the first four with a blu-ray, but then we won't for the 5th, we may come back to it for the 6th but maybe we won't'. And that's just the tip of the iceberg , Pepper no LP box , just a stand alone LP, White Album - album + Esher but no out takes in the LP box. I could point to at least 5 or 6 other inconsistencies but its late. Carnival of light - no idea if it was real or fake. I would probably say Rubber Soul as the stereo mix is awful and the songs are brilliant.

@nicksyrett

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel on reflection, I agree with everything you’ve written here! I wish you worked for apple… I’m sure you’d have had a better plan!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@nicksyrett I might even delay my retirement for that job 😂

Hi Tone, I think the best option for Magical Mystery Tour and Yellow Submarine is to release a 2CD/Blu Ray or DVD set. CD1 Remastered album/CD2 outtakes and Blu Ray or DVD of the film or alternatively a 4LP vinyl version with the film (not laser disc🙂). Also the Past Masters volumes should be treated as part of the Beatles cannon, but please don't let them remix the death out of Vol.1. Next box set hopefully Rubber Soul. Excellent video to finish 2022 on Tone. Here's to a busy 2023! Happy New Year to you and your family... Cheers

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Eddie, Glad you enjoyed the video. Are you thinking that both the films would be included in your set or just MMT. They have steered away from video in the releases so far, so personally I'd be surprised if they went down that route for these two. I am however in favour of combining the two albums into one box. Agree that Rubber Soul will be next but you never know, if they latch on to the 60th anniversary to could be Please Please Me. I guess we'll know soon enough. Thanks as always for your continued support of the channel and I wish you and yours a happy new year mate.

@eddiemiles7676

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannelHi Tone, They'd be two sets of CD1 album/CD 2 outtakes & film on either Blu Ray /DVD. The cheap option 😁. Yes, happy new year to you and yours. See you on the other side😁👍

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@eddiemiles7676 Ahh with you now. Cheers Eddie, yes the other side 🙂

Happy (almost) New Year, Beatley Tone! I raised the MMT-is-missing-in-action-SDE-wise issue in Beatlefan back when the White Album SDE box set was released, so, I agree with your comments regarding that. [and, the Yellow Submarine album by extension] IMAO, their having skipped an SDE box set covering the Magical Mystery Tour and Yellow Submarine albums is a **major omission** since that material is part of their legacy. In short, UMe/Apple have *not* given SDE-treatment to all non-Sgt. Pepper -related recordings made during 1967. In recording date order: -- Only A Northern Song, Magical Mystery Tour, Baby You're A Rich Man, All Together Now, You Know My Name (Look Up The Number) [its instrumental backing track only], It's All Too Much, All You Need Is Love, Your Mother Should Know, I Am The Walrus, The Fool On The Hill, Blue Jay Way, Flying, Hello Goodbye, Shirley's Wild Accordion [the latter song is heard in the MMT movie] Only A Northern Song, All Together Now, and, It's All Too Much are 1967 recordings that ended up on the Yellow Submarine album, first released in January 1969. (same goes for All You Need Is Love, which was also included on the Magical Mystery Tour album, which has been part of the worldwide Beatles' standardized catalog since 1987 when Beatles albums first began appearing on CD) Yellow Submarine (the song) was covered in the Revolver SDE, so, there is only one Yellow Submarine album (Side One) loose end: Hey Bulldog, which was recorded in early February 1968, but strangely *not* represented on CD6 of the White Album SDE box set along with the other 3 songs (The Inner Light, Lady Madonna, and Across The Universe) which were worked on during those *same* sessions of February 2-thru-11, 1968. [not very consistent, UMe/Apple!!] As far as the Past Masters collection goes, I personally do *not* believe that an SDE box set is necessary. Its contents are primarily singles and/or B-sides that should simply be represented in / rolled-into the appropriate album SDEs for which they're associated with via recording sessions. [The Beatles' recording sessions are pretty well defined/delineated] So, for example, We Can Work It Out and Day Tripper both belong to Rubber Soul, Yes It Is and I'm Down both belongs to Help!, I Feel Fine and She's A Woman both belong to Beatles For Sale, etc., etc. Cheers! Mike

@MikeE_Fab4

Жыл бұрын

P.S. I neglected to mention that, in the White Album SDE's CD6, the true single versions of Lady Madonna and The Inner Light were *not* included, just alternate versions. I hope that we'll eventually get remixes of those and other single tracks. [fingers crossed!]

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Hi Mike, Thanks very much for this really great comment. For MMT and YS to have skipped is a major omission I agree, and like I said I think the reason was that they were unable to produce them in time for the anniversary , which seems to be the primary reason why we are getting the SDEs. I hope we don't have to wait until 2027 for MMT to fit in with the 60th anniversary. because they seem so ridged about the anniversary issues, I wouldn't rule out seeing PPM as the next release even though the smart money is on it being Rubber Soul. As I said in the video, I think the singles will follow the format of Revolver and Let it Be by including them inside the boxes of the appropriate albums closest to their release date. However, although that works for the singles going backwards it still leaves some gaps that cant be filled this way - gaps such as Lady Madonna, Hey Jude, the 4 yellow Submarine songs, You Know My Name , Ballad of J&Y etc etc . I don't mind how they do this as long as we get a good stereo remix of all the songs that feature on Past Masters although at the moment, Im struggling to see a way that they fill these gaps without a Past Masters release . thanks again for a great comment and happy new year to you.

Regarding Yellow Sub, some might say why remix it when we already. have 1999's Yellow Sub song track? Well... that was remixed using all available 4 multi-tracks, containing 'baked-in' layered instrumentation. With this new de-mixing software, I'm certain even better mixes could now be made. A hint of this comes from A/Bing the song Yellow Submarine from the 1999 version with the new Revolver version - which clearly has far more separation.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yes totally agree. that was almost a quarter of a century ago and as great as those remixes were back then, Im sure we can improve on those now. And they only need to do the 4 Yellow sub songs because all the others from the songtrack will have been done under their respective album remixes

Hi Tone Another interesting video. I would love a MMT reissue . Not sure it will happen given we got the box earlier. The Yellow Submarine Songtrack album probably means no Yellow Submarine box although I really want to hear the longer version of it’s all too much. As for past masters, that won’t happen given we have had the singles box set and Long Tall Sally released in recent years. But like you I would buy them if they came out. Thought you were a bit hard on the George Martin side of Yellow Submarine. Yes it’s not the Beatles but the music was an integral part of the movie and was George Martins movement in the sun .

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Edward, glad you enjoyed the video. I see where you're going with this but YSS was remixed almost a quarter of century ago, tech had moved on and I'd like those 4 songs remixed using the Peter Jackson Tech. Same goes for the singles and b sides , so although you are right about the singles box, these tracks still have the awful panning on them and need to be remixed to give us great stereo imaging like we got n the Revolver remix. The long It's all too much would be a welcome bonus, Im thinking that they might give us a MMT & YS box combined. Maybe a bit harsh on side 2 of YS but , I dont have a problem with the incidental music pe-say, I just don't think it should be used to pad out a Beatles album. I always thought that they got YS and MMT the wrong way round, MMT was an EP and should have been an album and YS was an album that should have been an EP. Thanks as always for your contribution Edward. Happy New Year

@edwardrussell5989

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel happy new year Tone Look forward to more discussions in 2023

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@edwardrussell5989 Cheers Edward.

Hi Beatley Tone, and happy new year! I actually think that a Magical Mystery Tour Boxset would focus solely on the EP release and not the full album. My money is on a new stereo remix of the EP songs, despite the tracks having been remixed for the DVD/Blu-Ray by Giles & Sam in 2012. It'll be an EP sized box and contain outtakes and the original mono mix plus a lovely little book. I think Rubber Soul will get released next... but then possibly MMT. I know this is a bit controversial.... but I think Rubber Soul and MMT will be the last releases to focus on a single album. Beyond that i think they'll possible combine albums in one or two sets featuring new stereo mixes etc (using the new de-mix software). Anyhow that's me and my options for what they're worth, but like you I'm loving all of these recent releases. By the way I'm new to the channel and loving yer content Guv - keep it going. All the best from Liverpool!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Firstly thank you for subscribing and welcome to the channel and Im glad that you are enjoying the content here. I see where you're going with your prediction for a MMT box, but if they took that route, that would still leave us without a good stereo remix of Hello Goodbye, Baby You're a Rich Man and All You Need is love , so to do it as an album seems more logical to me. I think the smart money is on Rubber Soul being the next album to get the SDE treatment but they do seem very ridged about anniversary releases so I wouldn't rule out the next one being Please Please Me to coincide with the 60th Anniversary or as you suggest maybe a doubling up SDE with PPM and With the Beatles sometime next year. I guess we'll have to wait and see . Thanks for a great comment and best wishes for a great new year from me here in London.

Happy New Year! I agree why don't they just combine the Magical Mystery Tour and Yellow Submarine albums: Album 1 Remix Album Side A 1, Magical Mystery Tour 2, Your Mother Should Know 3, I Am The Walrus 4, The Fool On The Hill 5, Flying 6, Blue Way Jay + Bonus Track 7, Hello Goodbye Side B 1, Only A Nothern Song 2, All Together Now 3, Hey Bulldog 4, It's All Too Much 5, All You Need Is Love + Bonus Track 6, Baby, You're A Rich Man Album 2 Magical Mystery Tour album Mono Version Album 3 Outtakes and demos 2 LP Hey Bulldog EP (Mono) Side A 1, Hey Bulldog 2, It's All Too Much Side B 1, Only A Northern Song 2, All Together Now Also they could also release a special edition release of a 1968/1969 singles album of remix and mono versions of: Lady Madonna The Inner Light Hey Jude Revolution Get Back (7" version) The Ballad Of John And Yoko Old Brown Shoe Plus outtakes and demos of the songs excluding Get Back.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Sounds absolutely perfect. Thanks Matthew for this great comment

I would definitely love the box sets of magical mystery tour yellow submarine and past masters those would definitely benefit from the Giles Martin remix. One of the songs that could be used is the full unedited version of the song it’s all too much with the missing verse the third verse that’s missing on the yellow submarine Songtrack and album. and I would love to hear the song with no fade out whatsoever I would love to hear the song fall apart like you hear on different bootlegs and stuff and all of the different optics of magical mystery tour and yellow submarine could be used as well as the past masters stuff.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yes that would be great. It's all too much isn't one of my favourite songs but it would be great to have the full version

thank you so much! I thought I was the only one who was thinking about MMT deluxe remix... personally since "Strawberry Fields Forever" and "Penny Lane" were already done, I think maybe Giles should compile a whole new album consisting of remaining songs from MMT and the 4 original songs from YS soundtrack. Personally I think the original YS soundtrack makes me think of the US Capitol version of the "Help" album. Interesting how for once the US was right about MMT and the UK was wrong about the YS soundtrack. when normally its the other way around. lol

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Derek, glad you enjoyed the video. A combined box of MMT and YS seems to be the popular shout here and that would do for me. MMT definitely much better as an album of me and YS better off as an EP. Thanks for a great comment

Hi Tone hope you are well. My money is on Rubber Soul. You make some good points 👉 👈...I love MMT...and the 1999 mix of yellow submarine. I'm thinking could they collect them together in one set to flesh it out? That might be a better idea..Happy New year mate will be in touch intge new year!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Hi Marcus, I think most of the smart money is on Rubber Soul being next although they seem so ridged about anniversaries that I wouldn't rule out it being Please Please Me to coincide with the 60th anniversary next year. Doubling up of MMT and YS is a good idea I think, Id be happy with that too. Happy New year my friend

I'd go with the combined MMT and Yellow Submarine remixed album. A complete stereo I Am The Walrus, a full version of Its All Too Much and Penny Lane with the extra 7 notes. Most of the development tracks have been heavily bootlegged to better effect anyway. (The official versions always appear to be manufactured) Happy New Year Tone & keep up the good work.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Cheers Norman, Happy New Year to you and yours too. A combined box of MMT & YS seems to be a popular choice and m makes sense to me too

@ronmartin4212

Жыл бұрын

I mentioned the Capiphone project's MMT/YS program in comments here(Jan.11,2023)

@thehighllama8101

Жыл бұрын

I would also like to finally have the original stereo mix of Strawberry Fields Forever on CD. That original stereo mix was included on the original American MMT album release, as well as the original American 1967-1970 Blue Album release. In my opinion, the original stereo mix of SFF is superior to the 1970s remix, and it's much more faithful to the mono mix.

@ronmartin4212

Жыл бұрын

The Capiphone project combines both-in mono and stereo!!

My hope, not prediction, since Apple is impossible to predict even when it looks like they are following a pattern, is that we continue going backwards with the super deluxe editions. Rubber Soul-Please Please Me. (Although if they want to jump around and release Please please Me and With the Beatles in ‘23 for the 60th anniversary, I won’t mind) And then in ‘27 (which sounds so far away but is less time then when these box sets started) we get a ‘67 60th anniversary box covering all the MMT and YS tracks recorded that year as well as other tracks left of the Pepper box (I’m looking at you Carnival of Light) As for Past Masters, I think the time has come for a new 2 cd 3lp complete singles collection, all the UK singles on one album which has never been done before. Just a new compilation of the original UK singles, maybe Free as a Bird and Real Love as bonus tracks ala the vinyl singles set from a few years ago,with all new remixes (goodbye German versions, wwf version of Across the Universe etc, you should always have been on something like the Anthology anyway) Since the boxsets for the later albums have outtakes for the singles even if they don’t have remixes of the actual singles themselves, and it looks like starting with Revolver they are including both remixes of the singles and outtakes, it looks like the outtakes will be covered so instead of a deluxe box, just continue including the outtakes for all the singles on the relevant box sets and put the remixes on the new compilation. It’s been over 20 years since 1 and there is a whole new generation of Beatles fans out there so it could be a great seller. And I honestly think a new compilation containing all the UK singles A and B sides is long overdue. But as long as those early albums all get a box set, I’m down for whatever!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Brilliant, brilliant comment Joe. Your suggestion for an album full of the remixed singles (include Free as a bird and Real Love) is the best I have seen so far - I love it and whatsmore, it sounds totally logical. If we then get the outtakes sessions for these on the relevant album box set closest to the single release date all boxes are ticked. As you say, Apple are so unpredictable, just as you think they are following a pattern they do a U-turn so its very hard to second guess where they are going next. Rubber Soul seems to be where the smart money is on the next SDE but they seem so ridged about anniversary releases that it wouldn't surprise me if the next one is PPM or a PPM/WTB combined box for 2023. We'll have to wait and see. The '67 anniversary box also works for me . An excellent , well thought through comment Joe, Thank you

I feel that with the Revolver Box set the format for future album releases has been set : to include remixed stereo album, album of outtakes/ different versions etc, the original mono album and an EP of singles released around the same time but not on the album. It’s a good format so I wouldn’t complain, it would mean we would have a new Beatles release every 1/2 years to look forward too.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yes I agree the precedence has been set and I think they will go down that route too Andrew. However that still would leave some gaps like the 4 Yellow Submarine tracks . they could cover this off with a combined Magical Mystery Tour and Yellow Sub box that included those songs as the EP. That works for me. Thanks for your comment

@andrewmills509

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel I like the idea of the combined MMT and the 4 songs from Yellow submarine release . I kinda feel the songs from YS haven’t reached the prominence they deserve , particularly Hey Bull Dog” a great song and what I consider one of George Harrison best and most underrated songs “it’s all too much”. Thanks for putting these videos out Tone they are really good.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@andrewmills509 Yes Andrew, that works for me too. Hey Bulldog for me is one of the forgotten gems. Thanks very much for this comment,I really appreciate it and Im glad you are enjoying the channel.

Magical Mystery Tour became excepted as an album in 1976 when EMI released it on Parlophone and the box set was 2012 not 2009. I first got MMT on album about 1974/75 on the apple label.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

I also picked it up originally on an Apple label - for me in 1976 but it was an import. The LP box set was 2012 but the CD remastered box set including MMT was 2009 as stated in the video Trevor.

@trevorbrown2813

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel I was talking about the Magical Mystery Tour box set with Blu ray and DVD with the EP. In 2012 Wires crossed there. I know 2012 had the release of remastered stereo Vinyl set.

Interesting ideas re a knotty problem in the re-issue program for Apple & co. I agree with others re a MMT US album version so we get the likes of baby you’re a rich man and hello goodbye + YS “new” songs and personally for completeness I would like the George Martin film score on that (remixed but no out takes thank you !). Still not ideal I know but would please me. Thanks for a great set of videos btw

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Hi John, yes the consensus seems to be a combined MMT and YS box and that sounds like a good idea to me too. As long as everything gets covered I will be happy. Thanks very much for this comment, I'm glad that you are enjoying the content on my channel. cheers

Happy New Year Tone! Is it really necessary to do Magical Mystery Tour, Yellow Submarine and Past Masters Super Deluxe Box Sets? Probably not. But speaking as a Beatle completist the answer is a definite YES!. I want it all, even if I do have multiple duplicate copies of the same stuff. If you look at the Purple Chick and Secret Garden Sessions boots there is plenty enough material for Magical Mystery Tour and Yellow Submarine to go around. I'm with you though, Yellow Submarine Songtrack should really be the Super Deluxe Box rather than the original album. My guess is Rubber Soul with be the next Super Deluxe Box set but I really don't mind which album gets the next treatment. I love them all and I'll buy them all! I'm just eagerly waiting now, when if ever, we will get John Lennon's Sometime In New York City Ultimate Mix box set. So disappointed not to get it at Christmas. Hopefully in January?

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Hi Bob, For me, the big selling point of this whole project is getting a good balanced stereo mix of these amazing songs. It's crazy that in this day and age that we still have left or right panning on stereo recordings of pop music's most important band. We should now see , album by album this being rectified but that also includes the singles and b sides from the past masters set - so for me all this stuff as box sets with extra material is essential - although Im ok with them doubling up albums in the same box, like say PPM and WTB in the same box. I also think Rubber Soul will be the next one but I haven't ruled out that they might go down the 60th anniversary route and go for PPM next. I guess we will know soon enough. For me also the non-appearance of STINYC has been the biggest disappointment of the year. let's hope we see it early in 2023. Thanks very much for you support of the channel this year, and I wish you and yours a very happy new year.

Hello, hello..all good wishes,,from me to you,, For the next year..lg Ellen from Germany ✌❤but looking that later..but like it..

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Happy New Year Ellen

Interesting topic. What I believe they should do is: Leave YS alone. The 1999 songtrack is an outstanding album. Huge Improvement on the 4 main songs plus the other songs as well. MMT: They (Apple Corp) may do this at anytime. The can use the 2017 mixes of SFF / PL taken from Sgt Pepper and title them 2017 remix. The rest can be titled New Remix. My opinion: we need Past Masters. I do agree with you that Lady M & HJ (plus the B sides) should have been included on TWA. As well as BOJ&Y / OBS on Abbey Road. But it's too late. Just call them New Remix on Past Masters Deluxe. PW / Rain can be titled 2022 Remix. I agree they will include DT/WCWIO on Rubber Soul deluxe. With Help! Deluxe, they will have Yes It Is, Bad Boy, I'm Down. For Beatles For Sale, they should have IFF/SAW. A Hard Day's Night, include the Long Tall Sally EP. With The Beatles included SLY & IWTHYH with their respective B sides. Please Please Me include FMTY / TYG. Just have the year it was originally remix with the title of the song. That's how I would personally like to see it. Can't wait to see what happens. 🍏 🎸🎸🥁🎸

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Lon for a great comment. It's fun to speculate what might happen. Unfortunately Apple have gone about this whole project in a haphazard way which leaves holes that need filling. I agree YS Songtrack is a superb mix but it was almost 25 years ago and the tech has moved on, so I'd like two see just how far they can improve those songs (the 4 YS songs only) maybe a combined box with MMT would fit the bill what with these two being the least recognised as albums - its a kind of good fit. I would like to see a past masters hut I think they will carry on with singles /Eps included in box sets as you have laid out - again this leaves the ones they missed from 68 and 69.

@lonmaness6222

Жыл бұрын

I kinda like your idea about Possibly release YS & MMT deluxe. You were right, they did go about this haphazardly in the beginning. What SHOULD have happened is released PPM deluxe on March 22, 2023, call it the 60th anniversary celebration. It's too late. Then should have done WTB deluxe, release date Nov. 22, 2023 (60th anniversary)... and so on down to Rubber Soul deluxe release on Dec 03, 2025 60th anniversary. Oh well. Like the Rolling Stones song, "You Can't Always Get What You Want" 😊 we'll see what happens 🍏 🎸🎸🥁🎸

I've come a bit late to the party but I think a Super Deluxe Box Set for Magical Mystery Tour/ Yellow Submarine plus the Non-album singles 1967 to 1970 would be just what we need although I won't hold my breath. It's clear that EMI/Apple now put quite an emphasis on vinyl releases as well as those on CD so I think the running time on an LP side needs to be considered. I've therefore come up with two remixed stereo albums: Disc One has the six MMT songs plus Hello Goodbye on side 1 (22:32) and the four 'new' Yellow Submarine songs plus All you need is love and Baby you're a rich man on side 2 (22:13). I've dropped Strawberry Fields Forever and Penny Lane from the original Capitol album but remixed versions of both are on the Sgt Pepper deluxe box set. It simply isn't possible to combine the original 11 MMT album tracks plus the 4 new Yellow Submarine tracks on a single vinyl LP without compromising the sound quality. Disc Two in this set has all the UK singles from 1967 to 1970 except All you need is love / Baby you're a rich man / Hello Goodbye / I am the walrus (as these are on my proposed Disc One) and Something / Come Together (as these are on the Abbey Road deluxe boxset). Vinyl enthusiasts disappointed that Strawberry Fields and Penny Lane won't be on the new Magival Mystery Tour/ Yellow Submarine album will at least have them in the same boxset. So this proposed Disc Two has 12 tracks - the 1967 and 68 singles on side 1 (22:35) and the 1969 and 70 singles on side 2 (21:14). Has anyone else noticed that we've already had outtakes of most of these singles on the various boxsets? The only one of the 12 tracks on the proposed Disc Two that we've had no outtakes for in the super deluxe boxsets is You know my name (look up the number). Clearly, the CD versions of the above Discs One and Two will not be constrained by the vinyl records running time. So CD Disc One could have the MMT album in it's original running order followed by the four 'new' yellow submarine tracks (or all six Beatles tracks from the Yellow Submarine LP, or even the whole of the Yellow Submarine LP (75:54 - if you think CDs should be curtailed at 74 rather than 80 minutes then just omit the repeat of All you need is love)). CD Disc Two could have the 12 tracks set out on vinyl but could also include All you need is love/Baby you're a rich man and Hello Goodbye/ I am the walrus and Something/Come Together - these six tracks add 22:18 to the vinyl record's running time of 43:49 - so you could even add the four tracks from the 1966 singles to give a CD with all the Beatles singles from 1966 to 1970 - which would come in at 76:15. I haven't compiled a detailed list of outtakes as in some ways it's a question of what EMI/Apple are willing to release but, as I said earlier, many of the Beatles' singles from 1967 to 1970 already have some outtakes on earlier deluxe box sets (clearly I've nothing against additional ones though). So outtakes of Strawberry Fields/Penny Lane are on the Sgt Pepper boxset, outtakes of all four tracks from the 1968 singles are on the White Album boxset, outtakes of Get Back/Don't let me down and Let it Be are on the Let it Be boxset, while outtakes from Ballad of John and Yoko, Old Brown Shoe, Something and Come Together are on the Abbey Road boxset. Consequently, the outtakes for my proposed boxset should concentrate on the tracks where we don't have any on the boxsets that have already been released and these are: the six MMT songs, All you need is love, Baby you're a rich man, Hello Goodbye and You know my name (look up the number). Some such outtakes appeared on the Anthology albums, but these are nearly 30 years old now and I'm sure a revisit would pay dividends if no other outtakes present themselves. In my view a Blu-Ray version of the newly mixed Discs 1 and 2 is essential (preferably in stereo, 5.1 surround and Dolby Atmos versions). Perhaps this should include original mono versions. Whether CDs or even vinyl disc versions of the mono versions of these discs should be included is also something worth discussing. One of the beauties of the above proposal is that it means that all of the Beatles original output from 1966 to 1970 will be on one or other of the boxsets (Bad Boy was originally released on Beatles VI in the US in 1965). Consequently, it opens the door for the earlier Beatles output to be put out on just three boxsets: one for 1963 (including Love Me Do/P.S. I Love you), one for 1964 and one for 1965. I don't for one moment think that EMI/Apple will do this as they'll be out to get the maximum income from putting out boxsets based on individual albums but some of these will be pretty thin e.g. With the Beatles where very few outtakes seem to exist as tapes have been wiped. One last intriguing thought: an essential on a With the Beatles boxset would be She Loves You. Does the technique that Peter Jackson employed on Get Back for separating instruments mean that we might be able to get a true stereo version of She Loves You?

@user-do5yx8uj2o

Жыл бұрын

Sorry, when talking about which tracks any outtakes should concentrate on I accidentally missed out the four 'new' tracks from Ywllow Submarine. These should, of course, be included.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Brilliant post and well thought out. I like your idea very much and it's a shame that Apple never put as much thought into as you have. However like you, I wouldn't hold my breath while Apple come up with such a logical solution but if they did, this sort of line up would be really great. thanks very much for taking the time to put it all down John.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

no problem I guessed

Yes it does sound confusing and something to think over.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Doing my head in thinking about it 🙂

I think they'll continue with going backwards till they get to PPM imop. I'm agree with you, Yellow Submarine 1969 album would be a waste of money. I think they may include remixes of the non album songs in the box sets in the corresponding years. Like you suggested they would include We Can Work It Out/Day Tripper on Rubber Soul. I think they would make more sense then remixing Past Masters imop. I would like to see MMT remixed but like you suggested it may not see it till '27 unless they interjecte it somewhere.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yes I think think they will continue with the EPs or just include the remixes of the singles on the appropriate albums but that will still leave a gap for the singles that they have missed that should have been in the White Album and Abbey Road boxes so who knows how they will deal with those? Thanks for your comment Ken and I wish you a Happy New Year

The problem with these sets is their inconsistency in what they include. Past masters would have to be selective, since several of the tracks have already been remixed and/or had outtakes released on various sets. Most, if not all, songs on the 1 album were remixed in 2015(?) and a lot of those were on Past Masters. As far as MMT, two songs have already been remixed for the Sgt Pepper box set and some also for the 1 album. I don’t look for any of these to be given that treatment, anytime soon. Their other albums from their early years will probably be done before these will, so it may not be done until the 2030s. But, who knows?

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yes the inconsistency. I alluded to that in the video, how they seem to be thinking about these sets on the hoof and not having a fixed plan at where they were going with this. The evidence of this is things like ballad of J&Y and Old brown shoe getting outtakes on Abbey Road but no remix of the single. By Let it be that policy had changed and they moved to the EP format. I expect they will continue with the EP format going backwards to PPM which could if they wanted cover everything that was on PM vol 1 but when they get to the end there will still be singles and B sides that haven't had the remix treatment so how do they mop those up? They will keep us guessing no doubt . thanks for a great comment

Hi just watched your latest video. I can't see us getting a Deluxe Magical Mystery Tour Album. Due to it actually being an AMERICAN ALBUM. And the Yellow Submarine the last pressing (that you've shown) is actually a better pressing of the Original. I can't us getting that too in a Deluxe Box Set either. Rubber Soul, we've been given clues.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Well although MMT was an American album, it has been part of the Canon since 1987 when it came out on CD as part of the Beatles on CD series and was also included in the 2009 remaster series , so I don't see that as a reason to ignore it. Some great songs on it that deserve a proper stereo remix. We'll have to wait and see eh

Hi Tone, I think Yellow Submarine would be better combined with MMT in Beatles Movies box. I got Revolver for Xmas and love it. I also managed to get a copy of McCartney Lyrics book on EBay for £30, it hasn’t arrived yet. What are your thoughts on that book. Also I am looking to buy the McCartney Legacy book which came out just before Christmas. Will you be getting this in the New Year? Happy New Year and best wishes for you and Mrs Beatley Tone

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Hi Andrew, The problem with a movies box is that because these 2 movies are already out there in good shape, people who have them will complain about having to pay for them again to get the new music. A combined MMT & YS box of the music seems to be the popular shout here and that works for me too. McCartney Lyrics is a really nice book, hand written lyrics stories about the songs - some you will have read before others maybe not. Because it was a pore xmas release last year the price of this dropped dramatically after xmas but £30 is still a good price. McCartney Legacy I have had on pre-order since March 1 2022 and it still isn't here yet. there is some issue with printing in the UK so Im still waiting . Every other country seems to have there already and I have had no delivery date from Amazon yet. However because of the delay I bought the audio book. Im around 200 pages in and its utterly brilliant - probably the only book on McCartney's life and music anyone will ever need. Don't even think about it - get it! Happy New Year to you and yours too mate.

@Holywell88

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel yes I will get the hardback book as soon as it becomes available. I think it probably is an essential purchase. It’s funny isn’t it? , you think you can’t hear this story any more without repetition and then a completely new perspective arrives. I can’t think of anything else that has been analysed in such detail and yet new facts arrive almost weekly

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@Holywell88 It really is superb. I will do a proper review as soon as mine arrives

In the rumor mill, I heard that Peter Jackson’s is going to start a new Beatle project. I don’t think it’s going to be Magical Mystery Tour but you never know I’m thinking maybe he wants to tackle A Hard Days Night thanks.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

I heard that it could be the Star Club Hamburg tapes - now there's a challenge. that old rumour mill keeps on rolling eh

I was looking at the box set of singles that was released a few years back, they were remastered and maybe they considered that to take the place of the past masters set. Not sure, like you said it is a tricky situation.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Did they just use the remastering that was done in 2009? For me getting good stereo remix of these singles , especially the early ones is the real selling point for me. Mono is great but we should have great stereo mixes in this day and age. Tricky indeed, they need to think it through properly.

@sharonevans6864

Жыл бұрын

On the Beatles web site they were released in 2019 and it said newly remastered from the original tapes so looks like it was after the 2009 update.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@sharonevans6864 Thanks for the extra info Sharon

These albums all have overlaps with existing box sets. Can’t see any of them happening.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Overlaps of maybe one or two tracks, but that still leaves 40 odd songs without a decent stereo remix so I hope you're wrong

The Yellow Submarine remix sounded amazing.....

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

I agree, it's very good but almost a quarter of a century old so imagine how those songs could sound using today's tech

@knockedoutloaded279

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel Tru but i dont want them improved every 20 years? bit worrying,,,I thought 2009 versions wud be the end, but now we will have deluxe versions of every album....

@knockedoutloaded279

Жыл бұрын

the anthology remasters / remix in 2025 will be amazing, Did live at BBC 2 sound much better..

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@knockedoutloaded279 This is the most important catalogue in pop music's history, so we should be able to hear it in its best possible form wouldn't you agree? Remember, they can put out what they like, but at the end of the day its always our decision whether or not to buy it . We are always in charge not them.

@knockedoutloaded279

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

I've always found that Magical Mystery Tour (American album) was superior musically to Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band and indeed more Psychedelic/Summer of Love than Pepper. I mean Penny Lane, Strawberry Fields Forever, I Am the Walrus, The Fool on the Hill, All You Need is Love, Hello Goodbye, Blue Jay Way, so many gems equal if not superior to what Pepper has to offer.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

You know, that is something that has occurred to me too. It's a tough one because Pepper feels like a complete album and by that I mean that it flows and the whole thing together is bigger than its individual tracks . But if we take those songs out of the album and assess them individually, only A day in the Life would make my top 20 beatles tracks whereas , I am the Walrus, SFF , Fool on the Hill would be in that top 20. So I totally get what you're saying here

@frommetoyou1981

Жыл бұрын

I certainly see your point. 'Magical mystery tour' has the advantage of being compiled that way but when i was younger, so much younger than today... i thought it was superior to Pepper.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@frommetoyou1981 On some days for me , it still is 🙂

@renaud_c_h

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel That is very true. I think the magic with Pepper is that it works so well as a whole that I find it hard to take the songs away from the album. If push comes to shove I could only take away A Day in the Life, Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds and Getting Better.

MMT should be remix with extras...Hope SINYC comes out...

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

I agree on both counts

What's screaming out to me as overdue is a compilation of the best of the solo Beatles. Getting the Beatles back together if you will. This has to come out one day if they can get around any legal obstacles and maybe after Sir Paul is gone for good. It would have to be a multiple CD set. I've got it down to 6 at the moment.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Great idea. I think as you say, there could be many legal obstacles in the way not least how you determine how many songs from each Beatle goes on it. Obviously John's solo career was very short and the other 3 have far more .material to chose from. I wouldn't like to be the person deciding what goes on the set and what doesn't and if you've managed to whittle it down to just 6 CDs , you've done very well.😂 Great comment though.

@normansaunders6891

Жыл бұрын

A solo mash up along the lines of "Love" (or even "Stars of 45") would be an interesting option.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@normansaunders6891 Sounds great but not sure if something like that is even possible

@gettinhungrig2

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel Thanks Beatley Tone. Not a problem for me finding enough John songs. The quality is so great I always end up having too many. John's late 70s period can be topped up by Lost Lennon Tapes and Dakota demos. Some of John's best work was never released (reminds of his comment the Beatles best work - live in Hamburg - was never recorded). The ratios should be roughly in accordance with the Beatles recording career so that it sounds like a Beatles album. So it should be John at least in the ascendant, followed by Paul, with George (including Wilburys)and Ringo's ratios increased substantially.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@gettinhungrig2 Ok yes understand the ratios rule. Might put something like this together soon- thanks buddy

In April we have the 50th anniversary of the red and blue album and could release it with remixed songs. I doubt it.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

No I don't think so either as far as remixed tracks but as I suggested in my video about what could come out in 2023, I wouldn't be surprised to see a re-release of both compilations on coloured vinyl next year

@trevorbrown2813

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel But they have been out on coloured vinyl twice if my memory serves me well. But to have them both together in a box set remixed with tracks not yet released as remixes. Maybe put B sides on there to pad it out instead of releasing past masters. With a nice book.

I created a fantasy ad for MMT/YS ep Super deluxe. Did you see it? Im hopeful. Kinda, that it shows up

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Sorry no I cant see it. Where should I be looking ?

With the beatles

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Not sure what this comment relates to

I see MMT as a Pepper second LP

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yes I agree. Its a great album and probably more 'summer of love' than Pepper

If they are going down the reverse route then surely Oldies But Goldies should be next up, or is this also not considered canon ?

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Oldies but Goldies is a bit different I think because it's a compilation album and I don't think comps are part of this remix project. Once all the songs that feature on that album have been remixed through the various albums that supply that album , we may see a re-release at some point although because all the tracks except bad Boy feature on the red album, the album has kind of lost it's importance. Good point though and thanks for your comment

How about it called Magical Mystery Tour with tracks from 1967-69 deluxe box set. 🤓

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Hmm maybe they would need to work on the name but as far as the material included on it as you suggest, it works for me

Hi, Keep it simple. One BOX PPM & WTB ONE BOX BEATLEMANIA (AHDN, BFS & HELP! ONE BOX RUBBER SOUL ONE BOX MMT & YS 4 boxes, so 4 years to go. But ..... in what order?

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yes that's nice and simple and the order who knows. Smart money seems to be on Rubber Soul, but I have a feeling they may go back to 1963 and do a 60th anniversary box. Whether that will cover both PPM and WTB we'll have to wait and see but that makes sense to me. But what happens to the A & B sides of singles for the boxes that have already come out, like Lady Madonna, The Inner Light, Hey Jude, Revolution, Ballad of J&Y, Old Brown Shoe, You know My Name - we haven't had remixes of any of these yet so it will be interesting to see how they handle those Thanks for your comment

I dont think we will see a 'Magical mystery tour' box set anytime soon. The Beatles didn't approve of Capitol messing around with the albums did they and I personally don't consider it as an album - because it never was in the UK. I would love to see a box set for the EP but that too seems unrealistic as they would no doubt want to 'beef it up' so knowing that selling appeal and money will be considered - if it does see the light of day they will lean toward the capitol/cd release. I think they will focus on the rest of the core catalogue first and then maybe 'Magical mystery tour' & 'Yellow submarine' last.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

I think you're right that MMT and YS will left until the end but Im pretty sure that we will get a box of the album for MMt. It was finally released as an album in the UK in 1976 and was part of the 1987 Beatles on CD releases , when they first put out all the beatles albums on CD. It was also included in the all the box sets from 2009 onwards so we did now consider the album to be part of the core UK catalogue now (also the reason why SSF, Penny Lane, Hello Goodbye weren't included on Past Masters ). I just want a decent stereo mix of everything and I might start stamping my feet if I don't get it 😂

@frommetoyou1981

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel i'm Splitting hairs here - as much as i love it - and when i first heard it i had no idea it wasnt a proper album but 'Magical mystery tour' is not an album to me. The Beatles never intended it as an album - but as it has been released as a (compiled album) as you say and if i was treating it with the same regard as 'Rubber soul' and 'Revolver' for example... i dare say id rank it only behind 'Abbey road' and 'The White album'.....because it is that good... fab-ulous!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@frommetoyou1981 For sure With SFF, Penny Lane, Walrus, Blue Jay Way, and Fool on the Hill its a little belter

Past Masters have been remastered 2wice...

@nothingisreal8618

Жыл бұрын

They haven't remixed them though.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@nothingisreal8618 Exactly

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yes but Im talking about a stereo remix not a remastering Jason

Leave it alone, go for the DONGTRACK, the BEST.BEATLES ALBUM REMIX .....1OO%!!!!! KE.N

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

yes the Soundtrack is fantastic but almost 25 years ago. It can even better now I think

here is a make believe g and t for you

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Cheers :-)

Does Sgt Pepper remix sounds better..?

@nothingisreal8618

Жыл бұрын

A lot better to my ears.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

The Stereo Remix from 2017, is the best stereo mix of the album we've ever had to my ears

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@nothingisreal8618 I agree

I’d really like MMT but I won’t hold my breath. They couldn’t even do the Let it Be Blu Ray DVD correctly and give the Beatles fans what they deserve. The DVD set could have contained so many extras. I understand that was Disney but it always seems like Beatles fans always get the short end of the stick.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

No don't hold your breath because you might have to hold it until 2027 😂 Yes they cocked up with the Get Back DVD but we have had some great stuff released over the last 5 or 6 years too wouldn't you agree? Apple are far from perfect, but they have got a lot of things right as well

Don’t diss side two of the yellow sub …. There are no holes in my education

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Those tracks are ok in their rightful place...as long as that place isn't on a Beatles album 😂

In my opinion no to a yellow submarine boxset. Don’t think it’s worth it for 4 songs

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

That is my view too but i still want those 4 sings remixed using PJ’s tech, so those tracks need to be included somewhere along the line. Thanks for your comment

Revolver remix was a disaster,,,,worst of the bunch so far. I hope any future projects are better.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

For me the Revolver remix was the best to date. Finally getting rid of the terrible panning of voices on one side and instruments on the other is what most fans wanted from a new stereo mix and should be the number 1 priority for future releases as we go through the earlier albums. Thanks for your comment, but sorry I disagree. What didnt you like about it?

@stevena9305

Жыл бұрын

Ok how about simply dropping the 1969 YS album completely and build the box set around the 1999 YS Songtrack album and the restored film DVD/Blu-ray. Add the missing four songs, some out-takes and possibly the GM orchestral stuff in separate discs, plus a big book and there you have it!