Disney is out here taking notes ✍️ This live action was awesome and I can’t be any happier with it!! Great job Netflix 🙏

@Lupinemancer87

11 ай бұрын

Staying true to the source materiel and keeping the spirit of the show makes a galaxy of difference.

@ericv738

11 ай бұрын

Disney doesn't care and they aren't taking notes lol. They make billions. What they'll do is buy the rights/IP and replace all the writers and ruin the show, whilst still raking in the profits

@DocKrazy

11 ай бұрын

Yeah as far as I'm concerned credit goes to Matt Owens and Steven Maeda (as well as Oda himself) Netflix can go fuck itself for all I care

@troillandford7679

11 ай бұрын

Fr. People being diverse is actually canon

@Noname-xr4ql

11 ай бұрын

Disney's gonna learn to make more trash live actions of their cartoons because live action one piece was hyped.

I was also impressed with the arc they gave Koby; that seen where he talks to Garp about the hypocrisy of the warlords system is one of my favourite scenes. It shows how he would develop into his Water 7 glow-up when he eventually returned to the manga.

I can’t believe a criticism for it was “Stuck too close to the source material”. Nothing ruins an adaptation more than when the adapters think they can improve upon something they’re adapting plot-wise.

@statmaster1316

11 ай бұрын

and the best part is, Oda had a hand in the development so this was all mangaka approved

@troillandford7679

11 ай бұрын

IGN, I Got Nothing of value to say

I finished all 8 episode and all I can say is that I loved it, they changed some small things but it was really good.

@just_a_funni_guy3085

11 ай бұрын

It needs to change some parts,its an adaptation

@machina5

11 ай бұрын

​@@just_a_funni_guy3085 No shit

I liked the live-action villains: the acting and the kind of suspense/horror they gave the series that was different from the source material.

@troillandford7679

11 ай бұрын

arlong is don’t judge a book by it’s cover. His performance was actually solid

@taiwothomas5759

11 ай бұрын

@@troillandford7679his voice made up for his size, great performance, first time watching he genuinely had me shook

I find it interesting the issues you found because I had an opposite reaction to the Garp and Koby story line, I was so happy when I realized Garp would be chasing them because to me I felt like it was Weird Garp didn't ever even try to prevent Luffy from setting off and becoming a pirate, and his bounty poster and becoming 'wanted' only after he'd proved to Garp he understood the consequences and wouldn't give up on his dream just gave me this victorious feeling all throughout the ending scenes.

@SolitaryLark

11 ай бұрын

Yeah it seems to be more personal preference I like the Garp addition

@thatlemur6065

11 ай бұрын

I like the idea that Garp in this version is much more strict and serious is because he was present at Rogers execution. He was in charge of seeing his old rival and friend die and to stop the era of piracy but by allowing Roger to speak for as long as he did Garp unintentionally allowed the rise of the Great Pirate Era and is feeling guilt about it. In other words every death that has happened in the last 20 years by upstart pirates inspired by Roger is all Garps fault and he is aware of that.

@foranubis7561

11 ай бұрын

Totally agree with you, I agree with your Garp point. I additionally couldnt stand Coby here, especially the part where Garp says leave us he leaves but stands outside the door listening to what Mihawk and Garp are talking about after Garb called him out on it before saying its a nasty habit he had by ease dropping on someones conversation, it feels like they used Coby for fillers, like he sees Usopp and says he believes Usopp that pirates are at the mansion, goes to investigate and does absolutely nothing. Its probably just me but I couldnt stand Coby.

@royalfun1031

8 ай бұрын

The world is too small if Garp cares abt that

@The_dandy_zombie

8 ай бұрын

@@royalfun1031I mean not really? Garp raised him, it doesn’t make the world smaller if a grandfather whose seen the worst of the worst in the world decides to test his grandsons resolve. Mihawk being brought in through Garp made the world smaller, but Garp caring about his family enough to test his resolve does not make the world smaller at all.

I am glad that we were able to get a good One Piece live action series, I got to say their are some really interesting elements in the episodes that make me happy for all the work they did for this series. I do hope we get a season 2 and get to see Chopper, Vivi, and Robin appear that would be cool to see how they do the Arabasta saga. I would love to see a differences and easter egg video from your channel. I am hype for the next Manga vs Movies video~!!!

I love how Coby looks like Rustage with pink hair...

@dogegardner6714

11 ай бұрын

He always looked like Rustage to me. Little tiny Rustage.

@Pineapal

10 ай бұрын

Lmfao

I marathoned the entire show on the day it came out, and I was blown away by how good it was. Although I was hopeful that it would be good I was also cautious not to get my hopes too high. All I wished for, was that it would be good. That's it, just good. This was freaking amazing

I enjoyed watching it even if there were things that got changed to make it best fit. However I look at the live-action as being a proving ground for what worked out well and what didn't work out as well to help in the possibility of making a 2nd season.

i miss your Manga vs movie again please do it again! 🥺😫

@2Spookster

11 ай бұрын

New episode should be coming before Halloween 🙏

I think it's the most faithful adaptation based from my experience. More than Ashita No Joe(which is my fave), Rurouni Kenshin and Prince of Tennis.

Always a good day when Spooky uploads.

I have a friend who said this was gonna be terrible because it was live action and wasn’t even willing to give it a chance I’m glad this one turned out good

@Lupinemancer87

11 ай бұрын

I heard alot of that myself, they were convinced it would flop, and even went so far as to say they were looking forward to see it fail so they could say they were right. Well, guess what...

@-Mintyy

11 ай бұрын

It’s Garbage, literally not a single good thing about it. Hilariously bad

@Wuzzy-qp9kn

11 ай бұрын

​@@-MintyyThat's why it's number 1 netflix show in 80+ countries, okay 👍

@GoliathWarfare

11 ай бұрын

​@@-Mintyycope

@ruansasa289

10 ай бұрын

​@@-Mintyydamn, you are really new to the troll scene aren't you?

Luffy's powers do suffer due to budget limitations but they got a great actor for the role.

Roger didn't say it in the beginning. It was later on when they did a flash back. It showed more of what he said

It is so interesting how many people have the different opinion on the different actors but everyone like the show in general. Overall, I think the show did the great job.

The only reason I don’t see garp sending Mihawk issue is i see it as him using it as a scare tactic

funny, your thoughts about usopp are the same as mine about zoro. i thought jacob was amazing as usopp and mackenyu as zoro was just too sullen and reserved for east blue zoro, and i thought it was not because of mackenyu but more of a direction issue. they really had him just feeling way too distant and cool

I strongly disagree that the Fishmen should look like horrific monsters.

Can we talk how the Buggy actor was so good?

I saw that on Netflix recently. If you say it’s good… I’ll check it out. Thanks

Keep up the awesome work and videos 2spooky

Can't believe I wasn't subbed with this account! And yes, please, Spookster, do a proper Manga vs Movie on this

The condensation of the storyline was done smoothly, such as Garp's earlier appearance and meeting his grandson.

100% agree! Some of those changes really had me scratching my head. Especially the way they handled the fights.

Amazing review ❤

Can't wait to see Verona make his appearance in the live-action!

your the first AniTuber I followed in KZread! I miss you bro!

I would absolutely love to see more content about the live action one piece

Anytime Spookster himself talks OP especially the new live action it's a great time and I found it absolutely enjoyable and made me laugh so much plus the casting was so damn good and some changes were kinda good/kinda not but overall probably give it a 8/10 it broke the curse to me

Haven't been watching much anime as of late but i'm happy to report I watched (and enjoyed) this live action 😤

Now whe need a One Piece DnD adaptation

@ericv738

11 ай бұрын

No we don't.

Disagree with the fishmen, if you make them horrific then the viewers won’t be empathetic to their troubles and gripes. Imo they chose a visual language therefore they should continue with it

Just finished it! Soooo gooood

The only bad thing about this series at the moment is that i am afraid it will take long time to get a season 2

i liked it. It is probably my favorite live-action of an anime. kinda wish it was a bit longer since so of the time it felt rushed more episodes would have helped pace things out. really hope it gets more seasons would love to see how they try live actioning Chopper, Brook, and Franky since their pretty weird compared to everyone else that's somewhat human. while I agree more three sword style would have been nice i'm impressed the guy playing zoro pulled it off at all, always thought that was one of them no way that works in real life anime things

So happy to see more 2Spooky 😁😁

rly had fun watching this live action series. is it too much to hope n wish the folks behind any live action of one punch man n avatar r somewhere watching n taking notes from this series? They could learn a lot on basically how to not screw up a live action adaptation. One can hope….

I disagree about Usopp. He’s not supposed to fit in in terms of strength, but he had me laughing at the right moments. He made the show more charming and I look forward for him getting more impressive as a sniper

They did theses minor villains so well imagine how characters like don flamenco or black beard would be adapted

What is the name of live adaption on 1:36 mark?

Lol it’s so funny I was always medium about one piece live action, but I get excited about things like everyone else, meanwhile a few friends were like “I don’t think anyone expects this too be good” and “wow look at shanks, this is going to be garbage” and for the first 20 minutes every few minutes they would say “look that those guys” and “Zoro is the only thing that looks good here” as well as “everyone’s acting is terrible except Colby” too which I said basically “lol honestly it looks decent, kinda reminds me of an early 2000’s movie acting with really amazing camera work, and also yes Zoro looked good, and Colby was dope feeling legit” but after 20 minutes everyone was silent and watching the show, it was great!

Cant get over luffy's acting and the way he says "juan piece". Its like they didnt bother to correct the guy and just let it ride

@Bigboigoinlong

11 ай бұрын

The actor has an accent, he’s pronouncing it how he can. And also I barely even noticed? That is such a weird take to have.

@-Mintyy

11 ай бұрын

@@Bigboigoinlongnah it’s not weird at all, just like how he says “I’m gunna be king of the pirates” instead of “pirate king” it’s just wrong and cringe, dudes mannerisms are like a cringe cosplayer forcing himself to act like Luffy while failing miserably. The show really dropped the ball and no one will mention it bc of how much they suck off one piece.

@JPhillups1018

11 ай бұрын

@@Bigboigoinlong maybe he can try to act better? I dont even care that he has an accent the guy is just objectively bad at his job

Can you a 101 fact video ether for Hitman Reborn or Yu Yu Hakasho

I definitley think the show could go through all of one piece but it’s definitley going to be more differences as it goes alobg

Yyoo same rating as me and my noob roommate enjoyed the hell out of season 1. I'd be fine if they nailed Alabasta saga even if it got canceled after for how much the work and budget would have to go up from Skypeia onwards

The one complaint I heard about this series is how fans of the anime wanted to see a live action Nami wearing sandals but sadly they got a Nami who wears boots

It was surprisingly good. looking forward to more :) They could've done mihawk & baratie better, but eh.

13:24 What the hell is that thing from?

can someone help me out my question is should i watch live action series without watching anime???? please help

Instead of introducing Garp much too early, I'd have given Smoker the role of introducing us to some actually good marines and occasionally cutting back to him in Logue, taking care of business, introducing some of the philosophy of the world government and reacting to the emerging threat of the Straw Hats even before they actually arrive on Logue town. I think that would give Smoker a slightly bigger role and character instead of just having him randomly decide to chase down Luffy after Logue town, which would also be too similar to Garp's actions in season 1, making Smoker feel like Garp's replacement for season 2

The more I think about it, the more I realize that it was actually important for Roger to say the line. Like - the Show is called One Piece. The One Piece is continually referenced alongside the title of Pirate King. Maybe having Roger say the cryptic line himself would've been a good move. I think this mainly for new watchers - we don't really need the reinforcement, but placing that anchor point in the narrative for newcomers might have been a good idea

Roger didn't say the "in one piece" line in the manga. This was never meant to be a 1-1 adaptation, but a translation into realism.

Anytime Luffy got hurt by a punch, I just assumed they were using low level haki, which could make sense with a character like Arlong. In my mind, the villains were stronger, and not Luffy weaker. A manga reader might love Luffy flexing on the villains, but it might seem a bit lackluster to new viewers. And I don’t think I’d want the fishmen to be any uglier. They may have been villains, but their motives were very human. While One Piece live action wasn’t perfect, I still had a good time.

@2Spookster

11 ай бұрын

For me part of what early One Piece special was how figuring out how to find the natural weakness of the various devil fruit powers they encountered. Haki kind of ruined the beauty of that for the timeskip, and while haki is fun in it's own way I think keeping it out of the LA would be the move.

@constancestinson3918

11 ай бұрын

@@2Spookster Yeah, but it’s always been a part of One Piece; we just didn’t know it at the time. So I say keep it, and if we are lucky enough to get, I don’t know, a season 4, the casual viewer might say, “oh, that’s what that was.” You do have a point about haki making things a bit more convoluted, but it’s not like it’s not like it’s Dragon Ball XYZ Super levels of confusion, so I’m cool with it. I am admittedly a filthy casual, who has not read the manga, so take what I say with a grain of salt 😁

@nworder4life

11 ай бұрын

@@2Spookster They already showed Shanks using conquerors Haki on the sea king, so pretty sure they are keeping Haki in.

@SolitaryLark

11 ай бұрын

@@2Spooksterhaki ruined nothing and is basically mandatory to be included

@rustylee1836

11 ай бұрын

Yeah I thought it was weird that Spook wanted to make the Fishmen into hideous monsters, that doesn't fit with anything. 13:15 He dedicated over a minute to that odd topic and terrible idea.

Not sure why people say Usopp doesnt get any emotional moments to shine, i thought his "the pirates are here" scene at the end of ep 4 was a well-acted and heartbreaking moment.

I actually thought that Usopp’s actor made the character more like-able.

@rustylee1836

11 ай бұрын

Yes! So glad. They didn't let usopp ruin it :)

By the end of the Season, I wanted more, and like Oda wrote drawing Jimbei - Stop counting what you have lost, I felt satisfied enough. 8 episodes were 7.5 hours in total. 30 mins of content divided to Usopp's bravery, Sanji's inclusion, and Last ep's content would have made it perfect. And glad people got introduced to Koby this way, so that when they switch to anime, they won't hate him and drop the series entirely.

The actor for Luffy really hit it out of the park!

yess yesss

I'm watching it even tho I never watched the anime before. It's really good and I enjoyed watching it

the videos ain’t hitting the same without the old EDM intro

I'm happy with the adaptation for the most part. I would have liked them to have done an hour or so more time to expand the context of a few characters and scenes. Or I would have made each of the arcs be like a 2 parter.

I mean imagine if Gear 5 Luffy in live action will have him look like an actual cartoon like space jam, chip & dale rescue rangers and who framed roger rabbit.

eh, i kinda disagree on your take on the fishman. don't forget, they may be antagonists in arlong park, but, generally speaking, they are just normal dudes who want to get along with everyone else without getting discriminated against all the time. making them these grotesque monsters may have improved that one arc to some degree, but would have made it that more difficult to make them feel relatable and sympathetic for the rest of the series. so no, they made the right choice with making them look the way they do. although, as others have pointed out, what they could have done is improve the height of arlong and the rest a little in post. arlong especially looks just a little too puny to be a serious threat.

First 5 chapter were really hooking me up and surpassed my expectations, the changes were understandable. But as the Series went on some changes simply rubbed me the wrong way, such as: Sanji not seeing Zoro vs Mihawk, him taking such a back seat in "his arc", Nami not having the support from Nojiko and Genzo all those years (them actually hating her) and erasing any meaningful connection between her and Genzo. The Sh were a highlight, as expected, even though the script made it harder for them. I know the limited time affected many things but I just couldn't enjoy it that much at the end. Ig as long as it hooks other people to the franchise I'm fine with it.

I do agree this is a well done live action adaptation of One Piece. In fact I mostly like it and the "errors" are much less than the improvements. Errors worth to mention are for example that in this adaptation Buggy's feet can fly as well as the rest of his body when one of his main weaknesses is that her feet must stay in the ground or being held by someone else. Also and at the beginning during Roger's execution, the executioners halberds after piercing Roger's body just have blood in the tip, when it is expected they have stabbed him to death, which makes no sense since a few minutes later Alvida smashes the brain of a sailor. As for the "One Piece" thing Roger never says that name in his execution. The one who says One Piece in the anime version is a random man of the crowd. Roger final words translated to Japanese are: "My treasure? If you want it I'll give it to you. Find it! I have left all of this world in that place ..." he never said One Piece in that moment.

@machina5

11 ай бұрын

Buggy's feet have always been able to "fly", they just couldn't go higher than they would normally be able to go. We see them walking all the time.

i cant find sources to explain why Hatchan was taken out of this show. Just curiouus.

what is that outro song? can't find it on shazam

@2Spookster

11 ай бұрын

open.spotify.com/track/3bqJvzdbE4azvyGIQCrlMb?si=a5c8bcb6ea7640f6 Here you go!

Man you're willing to do a live action adaption of One Piece, but not make a 50 fact video about Bob Ross? (Pls make 50 facts about Bob Ross btw) 😔

@ericv738

11 ай бұрын

Fact one: His afro is glorious

The fact you say the should have made the Fishman look more like monsters just blows my mind. Like did you not learn anything from the Fishman arc.

ANOTHER ANIME VS MANGA VERY SOON U SAY??? 🥹

I wanna say that Luffy being nerfed is a strength rather than a weakness of the show. I genuinely think Oda has an issue with over powering his characters where he needs to just separate the characters constantly to avoid this issue. Where Luffy is off getting into hi-jinx while the weaker characters have battles because he’ll usually just overpower them, and then sometimes he’ll step in later and just win with no sweat. Overpowered characters are boring imo. He makes up for it with interesting characters/backstories (at least in the beginning of the series) and an amazing art style. But like this is why I don’t regard One Piece as highly as other anime/manga. There’s no stakes, the characters are too overpowered, he will (especially later in the series) sacrifice character development/a good story for a good fight scene, and makes the fight scenes way too long. Maybe the fight scenes being too long are more so an issue with the anime and not the manga. But I just got real tired of multiple episodes of the same god damn fight. Lmao he genuinely said at one point in an interview that he wrote a really good story with deep backstory that was interesting and then scrapped it because he thinks “young boys don’t want a good story, they want action.” Which is such a misguided take on his audience in general, and completely disregards their intelligence. It made me genuinely dislike Oda as a creator. He doesn’t write for himself, and he writes for such a shit take about what his audience wants. And that just makes me lose all respect for him. The highlights of the manga/anime and what a majority of people liked about the series was the heart and the story. The fight scenes were cool, but it’s not what made people keep coming back.

@SolitaryLark

11 ай бұрын

The anime massively drags out fight scenes. Not the best place to shit talk Oda but you do you

Thank you. Tekking101 and anime uproar is slacking

This show has no right to be this good. I was so sure to absolutely hate it, And now I'm in love....

🎉🎉

Loved how zoro's sord blend 😂

honestly the only gripe I had in his negatives was about the fishmen and their designs. making them more monsterous would go entirely against the role they play in the greater story

@SolitaryLark

11 ай бұрын

They aren’t more monstrous lol it’s just that something like them in real life is gonna be scary lookin

@statmaster1316

11 ай бұрын

@@SolitaryLark man they are already pretty scary looking as is. Making then even more scary looking like he’s suggesting just feels like it loses the intent of fishmen. It leans far more into the fish part than a balance of fish and man.

@SolitaryLark

11 ай бұрын

@@statmaster1316 oh yeah they don’t need to look more monstrous that’s not what I was saying at all. They are good as is.

@user-ei8it3nc4g

11 ай бұрын

They do hv a good side potray like the waiter in Baratie. It clearly shows us the world is grey, they are good & bad persons in every affiliation

Loved it for the mostly they messed up with Arlong and his defeat

I really loved the OP adaptation :D especially because I don't want to watch the anime and read the manga, as the art styles not really my cup of tea, although I always found the story very interesting 🙊

10:55 don't underestimate Arlong's blue haki

They obviously skipped some fights for budget reasons but they got the spirit of it down. Cant see the show going very far because some of the material is near impossible to recreate live action. Definitely looking forward to a couple of cool seasons though.

A live action anime and manga done right for once

I frequently got the feel of a wushu film from the live action One Piece.

to be honest iñaki is the weakest link by far. i like how he looks as luffy but he rarely delivers a good line.

Are you going to talk about yu yu hakusho live action

@2Spookster

11 ай бұрын

Probably. I am a big fan of Yu Yu Hakusho, so I'm willing to give it a chance and see if it's worth talking about.

Even though luffy is strong in anime-manga, he still needs his friends-crews-nakama's help in fighting other characters or the main villain of an arc.

Despite its flaws OPLA is strangely endearing. However, it doesn’t know how to calibrate its realistic violence scale with being campy and cartoony. The fishman gave me total 90s Power Ranger villain vibes. Regardless, the future seasons will be insane, i hope this show figures itself out.

Roger says he left his treasure in one place

13:29 lol what? Fish men are not monsters they should not be horrifying to look at. Super weird take.

This show is essentially pirates of the Caribbean One Piece Edition

Me being an overall hater of LA, I totally agree that this wasn't as bad as I expected it. It was good and fun, if one isn't an anime fan but tried they won't hate it at all, most problems arise with nitpicking especially if you're an anime and manga fan but it's overall better than most LA I've seen

Now with Koby yes at the start he was annoying, but the way you phrase it makes it seem like he still is which definitely isn't true. He grew so much.

Same but ussop was always useless and his nose is too short, zoro moments could be better especially him saying his name attack, and sanji needs his eyebrows zoro doesn’t insult him about it his eyebrows but sanji calls zoro moss head like common,

@SolitaryLark

11 ай бұрын

The eyebrows and nose are just not feasible they would look lovely like shit if included

BTW. Congratulations OPLA surpassing records set by stranger things 4 n Wednesday become trending no 1 Netflix show in 84 country. What A great hattrick for oda sensei

Roger only says "One Piece" in the 4kids dub. It's not said in the original japanese, the translated manga or even the non-4kids english dub.

For me the chase between garp and luffy It was all right but garp Still shouldn't have metup with lufy until later

Zoro during East blue was less serious than he got later on, so this portrayal is highly accurate

I don't like how they forgot certain key characters

What? I dont love koby early in the series but i dont hate him. He definitely grows on you later on the series