Thank you for this educational video, I have a dream to travel to Italy and come visit your shop !

Nice explanation, tks a lot, very interesting even if I actually play guitar!

That was really interesting, thank you!

I have stoped using F holes and instead ported the sides. It sounds fuller and much louder.

Hi Edgar.

Wonder which provides the best sound: f hole, c hole, or flaming sword hole?

There's an MIT paper that showed that the overall perimeter length of the sound hole influences the volume pretty directly. The F hole is a very efficient shape with a very large perimeter for a small footprint on the sound board. Thinking further on the topic, a standing wave with walls on either side will be in integer wavelengths of the sound, and standing waves with an open end will have an extra half wavelength. What this means is that having some open vibration essentially allows the instrument to have a lower base set of harmonics. It should also increase the volume because the edge of the sound hole will be vibrating substantially, putting a lot of sound in the air. Notably, the wings on the F holes go with the grain, which is much stiffer, so the effect is that the overtones produced are higher. You can see experimentation on all sorts of viola da braccia/ viola d'amore where there is more cross-grain vibration. That's also what is notable about the C hole compared to the F hole - the flexing happens across the grain on a C hole, and the cross-grain flexion is a lot less stiff. I also suspect it is less energetically efficient, losing more energy per cycle. This isn't always bad if you want to soften the sound.

@disqusrubbish5467

13 күн бұрын

Ha - I was about to post similar but you did a better job. The MIT guy researches acoustics in the ocean IIRC. He also says that f holes will be louder than circular of the same area. The sound happens in maybe the first 6 mm from the edge of the whole, and so there is a large area in a circular hole that isn't too productive.

@anthonyb5279

13 күн бұрын

Yea I used to believe that. There are better ways to port the instrument than on the face. leave the face solid.

@hellomate639

13 күн бұрын

@@disqusrubbish5467 This makes sense for a couple reasons (this is more conjecture than factual statement). One, like you mentioned, is the area. But the other one is the lengthwise holes maintaining lateral stiffness.

@riangarianga

12 күн бұрын

Thank you for pointing this out. I found the paper, after giving it a quick overview I think it's really worth reading.

@nickiemcnichols5397

12 күн бұрын

@@riangariangais there a link to this paper you can post for us?

Could you insert subtitles in Italian, or Spanish, or French? Thanks a lot

This is an R13 video. A lot of talk about f holes. No wonder the violin is a romantic instrument.