The 'Low Regret Rate' argument is so incredibly disingenuous - There is NO long term data on these horrific interventions being performed on children. DERANGED.

@andrewjoyner4133

4 ай бұрын

I think that argument is based on a study from about 2016 and it was still very early stages then. Plus I heard that there was no real reliable follow up on transitioners to see how they were doing or if they were happy with their situation.

He was in his forties, does not make it right for children.

@lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559

4 ай бұрын

And it doesn't make him a woman orcmean that he belongs in women's spaces.

@gabychats

4 ай бұрын

Exactly, he can do and live as he likes, carry on. But we need to protect women’s spaces and all children’s rights.

It's a MAN

@LunaC...

4 ай бұрын

He's an autogynophile

@marekklimczyk4042

3 ай бұрын

The other worry is the man who wants to pluck it?

@lockleaze

3 ай бұрын

No, it’s a man with a necklace on! Get it right.

No psychiatrist worth their salt would talk about affirming care. You don’t affirm peoples beliefs, you treat their conditions.

@Lucerne13

4 ай бұрын

The problem is the activists have worked hard to ensure this is no longer classed as a condition.

@cyclicozone2072

4 ай бұрын

100% this. Psychology has been ideologically captured. I believe they think they’re atoning for their past sins (lobotomies, classifying homosexually as a mental disorder, etc) by being overly PC. The irony is history is not going to look kindly on “gender affirming care”. They’re just adding to their already lengthy rap sheet.

Im i woman, i dont have an essence of being a woman im just a woman

@nikobellic570

4 ай бұрын

Thank you

@mariaf4396

4 ай бұрын

me too

@lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559

4 ай бұрын

Your essence is female though, because you are female. Robin's is male. He actually cannot have an 'essence of femaleness', because he'll never be female. The closest he'll ever get to it is 'confused essence of male'. He is simply a man who is convinced he is something that he's not.

@Adam-sd2ow

4 ай бұрын

I'm just a man, no male brain, just a male.

@antichris78

4 ай бұрын

Most people would say this, myself included. The trans lot would probably say that makes us all non-binaries!

He did it in his forties and said he would have done it in his twenties, thats an adult Children should not be medically transitioned ever, fullstop

That blokes a proper mess. State of it.

@nikobellic570

4 ай бұрын

Publicly practicing his cross dressing fetish completely undermines anything he says. Everyone understood this like 15 years ago

Oh god, not that hulking great bloke in a dress Robin White.

@nikobellic570

4 ай бұрын

She's smoking hot, you bigot

so you think a higher pitched voice has no authority and sounds silly, so you’ve kept your deeper male sounding voice…

@wolfhugs2221

4 ай бұрын

Misogyny. It's always misogyny.

@SheridanM-dc1nk

4 ай бұрын

@@wolfhugs2221 spot on. All of these men who call themselves women are misogynists, and an enormous proportion of them simply have a fetish.

I certainly wouldn't use the word 'care' alongside the phrase 'gender affirming'.

@catwoman7462

4 ай бұрын

It's the polar opposite of care.

@Gingerblaze

4 ай бұрын

@@catwoman7462 everything about gender theory is about inverting the meaning of words to manipulate peoples ability to think clearly.

" the other side is all toxic " " let me start by poisoning the well when Helen is not here to call me out " 😂

@lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559

4 ай бұрын

Hasn't he also sued someone who refused to play along with his dellusions? He's a creepy, dellusional bully.

he was a legal adult, and not a minor.....big difference in outcomes

Hips and knees are in no way reasonable comparison to your genitals. There over a 1000 families are suing the Tavastock clinic that sure sounds like a lot of regret to me.

2:43 so women with high pitched voices aren't taken seriously in court? The misogyny leaks out.

@lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559

4 ай бұрын

He's not a woman though, is he? What he really means is that MEN with high-pitched voices would distract their audience. Somewhere in there, Robin knows the truth of what he is - a dellusional man. That's what's leaking out.

@fionacarroll5562

3 ай бұрын

It's true. We are not taken as seriously as men.

@wolfhugs2221

3 ай бұрын

@@fionacarroll5562 useful to know that's what a barrister believes.

@snowflakemelter1172

3 ай бұрын

A 6" burly man with a high pitched voice isn't taken seriously is what he means.

The insistence that others have a gender identity is ridiculous.

All credit to the interviewee but he says he felt uncomfortable having to present to the world as male. The difficulty is that even post-transition, he still does present to the world as male. I'm sorry but it's true. Instead of presenting as male, he now presents as a male in a dress. It may feel different for him and he may feel more aligned to his desired gender and I'm pleased if that's the case. But it simply isn't reasonable to expect others to ignore the evidence of their eyes and ears. Plus this is an adult. Most people are not bothered by what adults choose to do. But children are a different matter.

Irrelevant. Andrew should have asked his guest to acknowledge mistakes in diagnosis, social contagion, the alarming rise in trans numbers. The harm being done, the fast tracking, the lack of questioning, the 'trans fixes all your mental issues' lie, big pharma corruption, medical mal-practise. With so much at stake mistakes MUST BE PREVENTED. As far as numbers of regret. I can imagine many dare not admit what they have done to themselves and struggle on in misery. Because to admit it may lead to self deletion.

@gabychats

4 ай бұрын

Well said!

Robin didn't show up cause he believes in the debate, he just wants the attention.

@lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559

4 ай бұрын

No, I suspect he's starting to worry, because the tide is turning, and the bullying tactics of trans activists and their refusal to discuss the gaping holes in their ideology, make them seem even more unreasonable and unhinged. Robin thought he'd turn up and get a few lies in, to try to muddy the waters. As a bloke in a frock who is convinced that being a confused male makes him a woman, he doesn't have any credibility to begin with.

CLASSIC AGP!

How do these blokes have no shame????

I get it that he transitioned as an adult... but recent years (last 10 years ish or longer depending on one's home country) trans and gender confusion has been focused on children which has resulted in MASSIVE increases in the number of children identifying as the opposite sex and thus massive increases in puberty blockers and cross sex hormones being used on them. Many childhoods are being sacrificed

That’s a man, man!

Unfortunately, organisations such as Mermaids are preaching gender stereotypes. And the comparison with hip surgery is simy bizarre

the problem IS NOT with adults who can give consent. the problem IS with the tranzing of children who cannot give considered consent or understand the ramifications of what they are almost forcibly consenting too. and I AM NOT an effing essence, jeezus h christ, I AM a biological woman, i don't have to declare myself to the world, the world can see me for what i am, a woman

My concern isn't what adults choose to do to their bodies, it's the children who are pressured into surgery to suit adults' world views or political stance and the lack of safeguards to prevent it.

@thinkingoutloud7425

4 ай бұрын

Absolutely.....

@lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559

4 ай бұрын

What about these men invading women's spaces and sports, and trying to police the language we use to refer to them? Doesn't that bother you?

@79Clochette

4 ай бұрын

Of course. However I am also concerned about the doctors taking advantage of these adults

you ain’t gonna regret it until you get to wanting children, or have menopause 30 years too early, or get cancer from the untested drugs, or just change your mind. when did this dislocation and dissociation with body parts move from being incredibly rare to this now? insane.

Once you chopped it off , your not sticking it back on again. That may explain why there is not a lot of de transition. There affectivitly is NO WAY to go back. Which is one reason why it should be serious and long term process and NOT how it is done now.😮

@Gingerblaze

4 ай бұрын

Why should it be done at all? The longest study out of Sweden, demonstrated no improvement long term and an increased self deletion rate 40 times higher than the general public plus additional physical health issues caused by the "treatments" themselves.

Robin only spoke about the rate of regret in people who had surgery, he forgot about the ones who didn't have surgery, but may have had hormone treatment.

Robin....so mentally unwell it's just so sad. He looks desperately unhappy.

More and more young kids are detransitioning, this speaks for itself. If these children who are having this pushed on them, went to therapy first for a few years, you can bet your bottom dollar that most of them wouldnt go near this surgery. Its a trend these days to be trans amongst kids, its not gender dysphoria, its peer pressure and a trend. Thats why the first port of call for any child who gives into peer pressure, should be to see a therapist, not be pushed to have their body mutilated.

How does “low levels of regret” map on 42% of them removing themselves from the census?

The problem with saying the regret rate is low is that those figures are probably 5 or more years out of date. This has become a craze, the number of supposedly trans children has increased hugely. Well done to GBNews for sensible discussion, basically giving someone airtime to explain without being shouted down. RMW strikes me as a sad person, having to turn yourself into a travesty of a woman in order to quell inner demons isn’t good. I wonder if research is being done into how to help such a person without resorting to surgery. Of course extremists would call that conversion therapy, and get it banned.

He says there should be a debate but 33 proves that one side doesn't want a debate

At least someone turned up and had the debate for a change. Have to give credit for that as it’s more than Stonewall or WPATH have ever contributed, even though stonewall gets millions every year.

@wolfhugs2221

4 ай бұрын

The reason they don't is because the slightest scrutiny and the whole idea collapses. The best hope they have is that it stays in the shadows and put activists into organisations behind the scene.

@lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559

4 ай бұрын

It's a pity he lied about Helen though. She has always said that trans ideology, rather than trans people, are the problem. That said, bullying, misogynistic creeps like 'Robin' ARE the problem. They belong nowhere near women's spaces or sports. A dellusional man does not a woman make.

"GENDER IDENTITY?" Trans (male-to-female) guest Robin: "An essence of male or female...maleness, femaleness...not a particular thing but maleness or femaleness." What? Okay, let's try again from WPATH definition of GENDER IDENTITY: "GENDER IDENTITY [refers to] a person's deeply felt internal intrinsic sense of their own GENDER." Starting at Gender(?) and circling back to Gender (!!!). That should be clear now, that "GENDER IDENTITY" is "sense of [one's] own GENDER." P.S. He's a "barrister." Autogynephilia should have been at least mentioned for males, barristers or otherwise.

@wolfhugs2221

4 ай бұрын

Agreed.

@francishooper9548

3 ай бұрын

Gender identity is a term at least popularised by the monster John Money if not invented by him. It is part of the language of the cultists and should be avoided if at all possible.

It's interesting that Robin talked about all the "things" he went through as part of his transition. One of the biggest concerns with current gender affirming care is that it skips so many of those necessary steps.

Detransitioners are becoming more and more common with the rise is these surgeries, so you can expect the rate to increase significantly over the next few years.

The FIRST boy to be treated by a doctor (called Dr.Money incidentally) killed himself after years of misery

@francishooper9548

3 ай бұрын

His brother also died of an overdose. Money was a psychologist who believed that paedophiles , or as he termed it, minor attracted persons was a normal variation of sexual interest. He was a supporter of castration for all males and believed children should be sexually active from the age of 3. A true monster.

No. Just no.

5:50 - ‘deeply felt intrinsic internal definition of their own gender’, this is what has opened up ‘gender’ to be whatever crazy thing you can imagine, and we’re supposed to bow to every delusion. You are a man or a woman, and Robin is most definitely a man.

@wolfhugs2221

3 ай бұрын

It's akin to a religion, where if you say you don't believe, you're a heretic. If you look at trans groups on social media, the violence in the memes shared is constant.

Helen Joyce's book Trans, affirms the rights of Trans people and those who legitimately experience gender dysphoria. The issue is the medicalising of children and the loss of rights for biological women. The trans activists, many of whom are not trans are a very aggressive group. Joyce calls this out too.

The only people being followed up and answering surveys are the people who are happy with their gender reassignment, and the data is out of date. The true rate of detransitioning in 2024 is reckoned to be between 25% and 33%.

Get a load of this guy.

He had it done so he supports it. He also gives a number for regret rates. I don't believe they do follow up 5 years post surgery. I think people who detransition don't go back to the clinic where they're were seen. Why would they?

@wolfhugs2221

3 ай бұрын

Richie, the detransitoner interviewed later, said that had he returned the clinic, he would be recorded as a F to M transitioner instead of the reality, a male who transitioned to female and regretted it.

I note he/she doesn’t tell us who was included in the survey or how many were questioned. These things matter as much as the findings. It would be easy to select your study sample to reflect the outcome you want.

Makes me SOUND a bit ridiculous.....😮😮😮😮😮 Beam me up Scotty.

Imagine the dude in women locker rooms...

so a bloke comes on and tells us misery loves company

@wolfhugs2221

3 ай бұрын

Well put.

'Maleness....Femaleness'. Nothing vague about that.

Some people feel there's a god, so does that make it fact? And should everyone be forced to go along with it?

It’s bizarre to see him making up studies on the spot.

A hip replacement is needed because the hip is damaged, unlike an already healthy body that transitions, for a so called scientist he doesn't know that you can't compare like with unlike. To use ones own experience and generalise it to everyone else is akin to comparing the whole world to yourself, or measuring the whole world by your own life. It's narcissistic, because it doesn't seem to understand that every life is unique. Trans people are not carbon copies of each other, and neither are gay or heterosexual people carbon copies of each other. The easiest way to understand the self evident that I have outlined is to get out of yourself.

@Adam-sd2ow

4 ай бұрын

He said he left that job because of how he was treated, must've been when scientists still believed in biological reality.

Hip Replacement , that now is what life is reduced to , Thank you Lord for giving peace and a half decent life after much pot hole dodging, I shall sit here quietly awaiting my Hip Replacement.

When les dawson used to wear a dress it was funny. Im not laughing any more.

Quite simple, those who affirm gender care and all medical professionals involved in the process should be held accountable if they get it wrong.

"If evidence is the right way forward" in his words, why did he choose a physical modification when he had a mental problem?

A very respectful interview. No histrionics . This person did not make his transgender experience into a hostile debate. 😊

Essence is Dior or Chanel 🥴

Ironically, given Robin's opening line, Helen Joyce is against ad hominem. Anyway, it's a great and entirely predictable shame that Robin appears to have no idea what's going on, no supporting evidence, just his own experience of making a choice in his early forties.

So he just said that gender has everything to do with secondary sex characteristics... which makes gender a biological construct and is directly tied to sex because ssc have everything to do with sex and nothing to do with gender(if we use the concept of gender that is used today).He said it himself... has nothing to do with the social constructs of gender norms/clothes/behavior/roles but everything to so with how one looks. Appearance is sexed and not gendered.

He needs to look at getting his teeth sorted before anything else. How yellow!

@errin-mp1zy

4 ай бұрын

Well, come on, he really isn't bothered how he looks.

What a beautiful woman Moira is. She embraces all the best traits of womanhood and feminity. I sure do try to emulate this lovely lady. And the best thing about Moira? She is out there fighting like a lady trojan for children's well-being. Under Moira's watchful, lady eye, no child is going to be butchered. I feel so secure knowing there are Moiras in the world. Unlike those dreadful other 'women' trying to genocide confused children. Looking at you, Helen, Kellie, Joanne, etc.

20% of attendees at Tavistock are suing . Thats evidence. The hip replacement is an utterly stupid and desperate comparison.

... at last an attempt to discuss a controversial problem from both sides temperately and in good faith. Some factual assertions might need questioning, and should be, but just think of the other subjects which generate rancour which would benefit from such respectful debate.

@matthewrowe9903

4 ай бұрын

Nice sentiment but this was an outlier the Trans actavists are mostly a nasty abusive agressive cult there is no debate with them we either give them everything they want or else

He keeps his male voice as it holds more gravitas in a courtroom than the high-pitched, squeaky, 'feminine' voice he mimicked and then said no one would take him seriously if he sounded like. Rather than a lack of courage or openness from his side of the debate being the reason why no other trans advocate invited came on the show, it is a woman, a tireless fighter for women and children's rights in this debate, who is blamed for why his friends didn't show up. He, then, is immediately a hero just for showing up. So sick of this classic mansplaining and women-blaming. Is there any way we can 'trans' away the mansplaining reflex? Now that really would be progressive.

This never fails to get to the point when a mother works so hard to carry a baby then even work harder to go through labour then baby is born low and behold gender revealed at birth girl or boy they can reveal gender in the womb these so called professionals make a mockery of the whole entire finding out your pregnant carrier of your baby and the birth of a fabulous journey of bringing this wonderful life in the world what a farce so a innocent baby knows its trans at birth in the wrong body how ridiculous does that sound as parents were supposed to protect a child till 18yrs by law until they can make their own my up

So a 'trans journalist has looked at the report, and has hundreds of criticisms, who would have thought that. "An essence of being a male or female" in a gender constructed society is contradiction personified.

Robin White cites Erin Reed‽ 😂

Just another bloke in womens clothing. Island of Dr Moreau?

State of Rob… respect to Doyle for trying to engage intellectually

Listening to detransitioners is crucial in all of this. Ritchie Herron has said that he thought those who had been on puberty blockers actually 'passed' less than those who have never taken them. For him to say that is hugely significant.

Look like someone with problem

1:23 the debate is toxic and difficult for cis people to participate in

I love how he brushes over the lack of detransitioner data. Ex-Tavistock doctor Dr Az Hakeem is on record as saying that the data isn’t even collected, so we have no idea of the true numbers. What’s worse, if you’re a detransitioner and go back to the clinic to fix issues, they count you as a gender affirming care/trans success as they’ve ‘fixed’ your issue! Madness!

Robin put her arguments coherently, whether or not you agree with her, and Doyle treated her with respect by listening and following up with sensationalism-free questions.

But what he said and had done he consented for himself this is about putting kids on pubity blockers as young as 7 how does a 7 year old know what they want when there 40, how many 7 year olds want to be a princess and by the time there old enough change there mind, this is final.

Not sure what the point of having Robin Moria White on is? She transitioned in her 40s whereas most if not all the issue with the WPATH leaks have to do with the medical transition of minors.

Not the first "intellectual" to be wrong. In making men and women interchangeable we don’t expand our vision of the person, but severely reduce it. Childhood is no longer a time of dependence and innocence. The proper role of parents is no longer to protect children’s innocence. Good parenting means giving children guilt-free opportunities to explore their sexuality. Sexualising children is wrong.

Jesus Christ!!!! Comparing gender surgery to a hip replacement and he was a 'scientist'!!!!!!!!

Hes wrong about the regret

This bloke in a frock is delusional.

🤢🤢🤢

"Your previous guest Helen Joyce described trans people as a terrible problem in a sane world" "I think I've probably got that quote a word or two wrong" So what did she actually say then? You're using what she said to justify why medical professionals won't talk to him but can't actually remember what she said 🤷‍♀️

For them to match you have to be able to define what your gender identity is though beyond feeling. I can say i feel sick, but it's because I've eaten too much chocolate.. where is a the because..?? you already know your sex so your halfway there... All I'm hearing is my gender identity is whatever I say it is, whatever I want I'm an adult so I get. They are coming across like children who are demanding to stay up past their bedtimes, while the parents are saying you've got school in the morning..!!

🤨

Odd ball. Or two.

That's a man

We All need to come to CHRIST

@user-yy5di3qg5u

4 ай бұрын

Why?

@snowflakemelter1172

3 ай бұрын

Whats It like there living the 12 th century?

This was a good conversation

This whole eunuch subject needs investigating, this is horrific.

He’s forgot to put his trousers on, the fool.

syntonic mental illness is so very...syntonic. even in big professional wealthy blokes.