This documentary didn't mention about the history of the region during ww1, which is important. Prior to ww1, the whole region was ruled under ottoman empire. Then, between 1914~1917, Britain asked the arabs, who had been living under the ottoman rule in this region, to fight against the ottoman empire. Britain agreed to create a unified-arab-kingdom (from Syria in north, to Yemen in south) basically most of western middle east, if Britain&arabs won. Well, the arabs agreed, and the British-arab coalition fought and won against the ottomans. But instead of keeping the agreement of a unified-arab-kingdom, Britain, created many different arab countries (as can be seen today), and then, gave part of Palestine to the Jewish people. All of these events occurred by 1917. Known as the British duplicity, of course this created a messy situation there after for both sides.

@jehdmahdi5959

7 ай бұрын

Edited: This documentary only looks at the symptoms, rather than the root cause of the problem!

@Stratioti11

7 ай бұрын

@@jehdmahdi5959 the truth hurts..

@teegees

7 ай бұрын

Exactly! This part of history is obviously downplayed if not completely ignored by British and even American historians, for obvious reasons. The British government’s action (at the time) is arguably the root cause of the entire conflict, and the oppression and eradication over time of the Palestinian people. But that being said it is the American government’s military aid to Israel that has been the unequivocal factor in this oppression and eradication.

@eugenegilleno9344

7 ай бұрын

This is exactly what was implied in Lawrence of Arabia, David Lean film.

@ferney2936

7 ай бұрын

If all the arabs all really wanted a single unified country, then why didn't they merge all their countries together into one after WW1? Also, Britain didn't make promises to the arabs- T.E. Lawrence's boss in Cairo, an army intelligence officer, suggested that he make this promise to motivate the small bands of arabs he wanted to influence to rise up & fight against the Ottomans. In effect, a man with no authority made promises to a few tribespeople whose support he needed at the time. Cynical, yes but very far from a country making a formal treaty with another country. After WW1 Britain definitely did squabble over the dead carcass of the Ottoman Empire for reasons of Imperial self-interest, as did France and Italy.

A wise man knows that the land belongs to no one. We belong to the land and should take care of it for the short time that we are here.

@angelacahill9460

7 ай бұрын

Exactly.

@LucyHowell-wb6nu

7 ай бұрын

The Bible states explicitly that Israel was given to the Jews by God. Since everything in the Bible is true, this is as well.

@AlasdairBLean

7 ай бұрын

Indeed

@angelacahill9460

7 ай бұрын

@@LucyHowell-wb6nu he specified "wise" man, which excludes the fundamentalist religious fanatic, such as yourself.

@serenitya7239

7 ай бұрын

Do you own a home/land? Would you be okay if you had a home/land in your family for generations then some other group of people came along & said - hey, my great great great great grandfather lived here 2000 years ago so we are taking the land, and if don't leave we will imprison, torture, and kill you & your family & neighbors,?

It's super refreshing to get an older perspective on these issues

@HeilIsrael

18 күн бұрын

It’s not an “older” perspective. It’s a historical perspective that isn’t fake liberals repeating generic out of context stuff. Deceitful at best, and oftentimes contains outright lies.

For people who only have surface level tiktok knowledge of this conflict, even those of us who have forgotten the nuances that subject matter scholars can bring to the forefront, this historical account is an important part to understanding the issues surrounding the conflict.

@avibhagan

5 ай бұрын

there is nothing nuanced about 1917-1948. Britain and the UN gave away , someone else's country, to as reparations for the crimes of Europe ! There is no nuance. Israel was armed to the teeth and committed ethnic cleansing in 1948, and the West began a propaganda campaign to sanitize what they DID. The Zionists murdered anyone who refused to leave in 1948. That was legally considered genocide . The UN green lighted genocide and ethnic cleansing , and blamed the victims for the crime of "refusing to go quietly". There is zero Nuance here. White Supremacy, Lying and Propaganda and Western Hegemony isn't nuanced at ALL ! It only becomes nuanced IF you try to sanitize your misdeeds.

@ZechsMerquise73

5 ай бұрын

@@avibhagan Do you even know what nuance means? You're saying that there are no small details involved in the conflict.

@ZechsMerquise73

5 ай бұрын

​@@avibhagan Israelis are not white supremacists. Most Israelis are not white at all. They embraced the -entire- Jewish population of Ethiopia. Even if they have bias by skin tone, that is different from white supremacy. White means Western and Northern European. Most Jews, even living in western Europe, are not natively from western Europe. They are mostly Semitic, which is like an Arab. The British and UN doctrines weren't about reparation for European crimes. The British ones were a way of splitting up the Ottoman Empire, a Turko-Arab state. Jews in WW2 were not given Israel by the UN, they rebelled against the UN mandate. And they certainly weren't being given British land as a reparation for something Germany did. How can you get so many things wrong in one comment?

@superbigidiot

4 ай бұрын

@@ZechsMerquise73 To my knowledge the Zionists didn't rebel against the UN partition plan. They didn't like some aspects of it, such as Jerusalem being an international zone. Relationships between the British and Zionists had corroded long before 1947 and to me seemed better afterwards. I'd argue shipping Jewish refugees to Cyprus probably caused more tensions between the West and Zionists.

@israelrealhistory

2 ай бұрын

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂​@@ZechsMerquise73

As an American with no particular affiliation in this conflict, I have to wonder, why, in 1982, there were no representatives of the Palestinian cause that were interviewed?

@Asma_Mushtaq

7 ай бұрын

I had the same question, but watching this 'documentary', I'm beginning to understand why; you don't include the oppressed perspective in a propaganda film against them. Simple.

@thomasmaughan4798

7 ай бұрын

"there were no representatives of the Palestinian cause that were interviewed?" My understanding is there was, and still is not, a Palestinian *nation* or government. Unlike the Jews, which are a distinct culture and ethnic identity, what exactly is a "Palestinian"?

@xavierdaume2757

7 ай бұрын

@@Asma_Mushtaq Oppressed ?? WOOWW ¡ But from what I see the oppressed had no problem destabilizing with a civil war a country that was not theirs by expelling the Christians , and I mean Lebanon. I believe that you also contribute with your propaganda.

@sbakernyc5761

7 ай бұрын

​​ @thomasmaughan4798 Arabs that inhabited the land known as Palestine. Pretty simple. Palestine has been known by that name for over 2 millenia. If you want to blame anyone for the randomness of the Middle Eastern Map, blame the British and the French, not Palestinians. Of course its hard for Zionists to blame Britian, because without their Balfour Declaration, Israel as we know it wouldn't exist today. And you say Jews had a distinct culture? Um what? Even among European Azkenazhi Jews, the culture was vastly different between a Polish Jew and a German or French Jew. Mizrahi, Sephardic and Bukharian Jews also all had different languages, cuisine, music, and even religious practices. Pretty ridiculous and factually incorrect to say there was a universal Jewish culture prior to 1948

@lennydee3538

7 ай бұрын

They refused to be recorded because of their beliefs

It’s ironic that such supposedly holy lands are filled with so much hatred.

@paulschweizer7696

7 ай бұрын

The irony is that they worship the SAME god.

@richardmarino2732

7 ай бұрын

​@@paulschweizer7696 Actually, they both deny Jesus Christ.......a huge reason for the constant bloodshed

@greggibbs8641

7 ай бұрын

It's because of the argument from the true God Almighty and all the false gods. This area will never have peace until the Prince of Peace comes back.

@elizabethmanzo692

7 ай бұрын

​@@paulschweizer7696No😅😂😂 No they don't 🤦‍♀️ The stinky head towels worship some imaginary demon called Allah 👀🤢🤢

@askywa

7 ай бұрын

Where is holy, devil will attack it the most

The documentary doesn’t show the records of the population and landownership in 1880-1918-1944..those older statistics can be found in Ottoman and also in British archives..under the Ottoman rule around 1880s, Jews had 25k population and less than 1% registered land ownership , in 1917-18 they only have 1% landownership..until 1944, in 30 years, Jews gained only 6% landownership under British Mandate..so UN plan gave them 55% of the land..giving a minority that big portion of land (due to promises written in Balfour Declaration) is not fair..and the land given to Jews (Zionists) was not empty ..there were inhabitants muslims christians and other middle eastern people..how on earth you think it is ok to tell people leave your land, move somewhere or we will force you to move ..who accept this ? The documentary also doesn’t mention in these 30 years under the British Mandate, Jews, they were given weapons and military training, tons of aid and money funded by US and British..even the first terrorist organisations in the soil of Palestine like haganah, irgun, lehi formed by with the help of US and the Brits ..the whole idea, establishing a Jews state started with Zionist terrorism then after 75 years, this state turned in to an apartheid state..people should see this, they, zionists turned into Nazies ..

@jro7815

7 ай бұрын

Because the Jews were kicked out of the area multiple times, and they also were experts in using different Pseudonyms and identities to avoid being attacked. Are you really that ignorant of history?

Thank you for all your hard work to make this sort of content available. I appreciate you!

@DavidHoffmanFilmmaker

7 ай бұрын

Thank you for the support. David Hoffman filmmaker

Odd that this documentary makes no mention of the 1917 Balfour Declaration. Wasn’t that a critical milestone that set so much of this in motion? Otherwise, an informative documentary.

@ewantaylor4478

7 ай бұрын

Did it mention the Deir Yassin massacre?

@Gargeler

7 ай бұрын

Guys😂 cmon, chill, this still is nobody’s land, it’s still the law of conquest, the the conqueror will have rights on the land

@crcanassr

7 ай бұрын

The Balfour declaration not only promised a Jewish Homeland, but also includes language as to the effect of respecting the property, religion beliefs, and customs of the population already living in Palestine. But there is much more behind the Balfour declaration orchestated by Loyd George, then British prime minister. Britain had already promised that land, that then was part of the Ottoman Empire, to an arab independent state. This was done to get the arabs to raise up to fight the Ottomans. The Balfour declaration was a promise, and so was the arab independent state. Promises only, because Britain had already signed a secret treaty with France and Russia parting the Ottoman Empire. For Russia, access to the Mediterranean, meaning a Russian domination of Istambul. For France, Lebannon, Syria, and part of Palestine. For Britain, the Irak oil, Southern Palestine, and the Sinai peninsula to protect the Suez canal. The treaty does not mention a jewish homeland or an arab state. Both, Jews and Arabs were mere peons of British policy. Perfide Albion at its best.

@milkrvr4088

7 ай бұрын

@@Gargelerif that were true America would take over the world

@marymarlow3646

7 ай бұрын

@@crcanassr Leaving aside the history for a moment, what I finally understand is that Israel resists the 2 state solution because it has eyes on more of the Palestinian land, a greater Israel. Peace may come if Israel is forced to accept living within its current borders and the Palestinians get a contiguous state of their own. Surely peace is worth it.

I remember hearing about this since grade school (was born in 1975). What I have heard, in tiny bits and pieces as an adult are the communities where Christians, Muslims, and Jews live side by side, NOT ONLY IN PEACE but as brothers and sisters, defending each other. We need to hear more of these stories!!!

@bhumane8178

7 ай бұрын

Yes its true but hidden.

@OG-ps2su

7 ай бұрын

Then British said hello

@johnflesner8086

7 ай бұрын

As long as people believe in myths it's not going to happen.

@M-hl2qs

7 ай бұрын

Brith leftover mess.. constant war in midlle east too mostly leftover mess leftover brith mess..

@user-cd9gk7lj9p

7 ай бұрын

I asked the computer. Who gave Israel the land?

At the end of the day, it can hardly be contested that a citizen of the UK promised land away that wasn't theirs to give to another race of people. When that people moved in to this newly promised land, they pushed out the people that were already living there. They were massacred, horrible things happened for generations and continues to this day because one person's home was violated and given to another. I don't think that's something you ever get over. This story sounds VERY VERY familiar to what happened in the west and the americas. The most revealing part is that in both cases it was the same types/groups of people that did the displacing (Europe, UK) any one else pick up on that?

@johnkumah3095

7 ай бұрын

For thousands of years the Assyrians, Lebanese, Syrians, Egyptians and Persians have been living with the Israelis as neighbours and know they lived on that land. Why do you think they don't want to accept this? My answer is Islam. The Quran says strike the Jews wherever you find them. They don't want to accept the Jews on their own land. These countries I have mentioned have been where they're for thousands of years, why can't the Jews also live there for this long? The fact that circumstances moved them from that land for a period of time doesn't mean they can't return there. If all these countries were Christian majority countries they would've happily welcomed them back, especially considering the tragedy that happened to the Jews in WW2. When you've lived in s place for thousands of years and your neighbors know it and yet won't admit it all because of some evil ideology they follow.

@donaldcoleman514

7 ай бұрын

The land don't belong to neither of them Ezekiel 36 5 therefore thus says the lord I have spoken in my burning jealousy against all the nations and against all edom and who is in the land today edom let's continue who give my land to themselves as a possession it will be peace in the land if the thieves that stold it leave Israel/ Jerusalem / Australia/Egypt/ this country USA are all stolen land and it's my first amendment right to say so the dogs need to go back where they come from

@karlar8648

7 ай бұрын

Yes, I see it. And yet they still have the land that God gave them without anyone trying to take it from them. All of this that is happening an to come, I'm leaving it in God's hands. I can only keep praying to Him and praising Him. Love is the key to it all.

@vhawk1951kl

7 ай бұрын

Who old you that "itizen of the UK promised land away ," and why do you believe them? Promised which or what land away?

@vhawk1951kl

7 ай бұрын

Who told you that an Arab(which Arabs?) uprising defeated the Ottomans(which ottomans?) (in what area?) and why do you believe them? Whom are you calling "Arabs"?

I’ve watched your film archives for a while and I had to do a double take at the view count! It’s good that you maintained this informative and well made content for young viewers today that want to be informed, instead of just seeing a headline.

@alanatizura6765

7 ай бұрын

your right, but the issue is not about the sufferings. if you asks about the intensity of sufferings of the Jewish people. THEY ARE THE ONES SUFFERED AND HAS EVEN SLAUGHTERED TO PIECES AND WAS REPEATED AGAIN AND AGAIN.. and if you want to know who the real settlers of ISrael. let me share that to you now. THE TIMELINES... The land of Israel has been populated by the Jewish people since 2000 BC. Here's the timeline, in case you didn't realize that it is their homeland, as designated by Lord Jesus Christ. 1900 BC: Abraham chosen by God as the Father of the Jewish Nation. 1900 BC: Isaac, Abraham's son, rules over Israel. 1850 BC: Jacob, son of Issac, rules over Israel. 1400 BC: Moses leads the people out of Egypt and back to Israel. 1010 BC: King David unites the 12 tribes into one nation. 970 BC: King Solomon, son of David, builds the first temple structure in Jerusalem 930 BC: Israel is divided into two kingdoms, the Kingdom of Israel and the Kingdom of Judah. 800s BC: The rise of the prophets, God's messengers. 722 BC: Kingdom of Israel is conquered by Assyrians. 605 BC: Kingdom Judah is conquered by the Babylonians. 586 BC: Solomon's Temple is destroyed by the Babylonians. 539 BC: Persians conquer the Babylonians and take control of Israel. 538 BC: The Jews return to Israel from exile. 520 BC: The Temple is rebuilt. 450 BC: Reforms made by Ezra and Nehemiah. 433 BC: Malachi is the end of the prophetic age. 432 BC: The last group of Jews return from exile. 333 BC: The Greeks conquer the Persian empire. 323 BC: The Egyptian and Syrian empire take over Israel. 167 BC: Hasmonean's recapture Israel, and the Jews are ruled independently. 70 BC: Romans conquer Israel. 20 BC: King Herod builds the "second" temple 6 BC: Jesus Christ is born in Bethlehem 70 AD: Romans destroy the temple After that, the people were captives to the Romans, Byzantines, Arabs, and Crusaders. Through all of these events, the Jewish people continued to live in Israel. There were more or less of them, depending on the centuries, but there was never a time when the Jews didn't live in the land. They stayed, they built their communities, they raised their families, practiced their faith and they suffered at the hands of many outside rulers, but they always kept their faith. It is what sustains them, even now. In 1948, the UN established the State of Israel, the nation of Jews. Don't buy the Palestinian lies that they are entitled to the land. It simply is not true. God will also provide a way for his chosen people to live in Israel, as He has for thousands of years. Pray for the people of Israel.

@thomasrussell4674

7 ай бұрын

Same here another long running David Hoffman fan! Kudos to him for getting some of the viewership he deserves.

Hard to understand why this discussion starts only from the British mandate in 1920 and ignores the 1916 (secret) Sykes-Picot Agreement where the French and the British divided these middle eastern Arab lands between themselves despite the fact that neither Britain nor France had any right or basis for claim to these lands, and the fact that these lands were promised to Hussein to be Arab lands in respect to Hussein's overthrowing the Ottoman Empire. Also omitted is fact that the Zionist Lehi terrorist organization (that later morphed into Leumi) strongly allied themselves with nazi Germany in WWII and actively fought against Britain even after the end of WWII. This is well-known and uncontested history that is very easily found in Wikipedia articles on the respective topics.

@radium05

7 ай бұрын

What are you smoking dude.. Lehi into Leumi? You mean Etzel? A whole different organization. Not a change in the name. And allied itself with Nazi Germany?!? Sure. Uncontested fan fiction maybe.

@hectormata449

7 ай бұрын

Oh what a tangled web the Brits n France did weave only to deceive all …only for their selfish benefits. The unresolved issues and continuous horror of that region may never be resolved amicably.

@Notpoop906

7 ай бұрын

because it's not relevant

@deltasquared7777

7 ай бұрын

​@@radium05Lehi (militant group)..referred to its members as terrorists[19] and admitted to having carried out terrorist attacks....Lehi split from the Irgun militant group in 1940 in order to continue fighting the British during World War II. It formed an alliance with Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany blieving that Nazi Germany was a lesser enemy of the Jews than Britain, Lehi twice formed an alliance with the Nazis, proposing a Jewish state based on "nationalist and totalitarian principles, and linked to the German Reich by an alliance"...In April of 1948, Lehi and Irgun were jointly responsible for the massacre in Deir Yassin of at least 107 Palestinian Arab villagers, including women and children. ... In May 1948, the government of Israel inducted Lehi and Irgun activist members into the Israel Defense Forces...Yitzhak Shamir, one of the three leaders of Lehi after Avraham Stern's assassination, argued for the legitimacy of Lehi's actions... On May 14, 1948 the establishment of the State of Israel was proclaimed followed by the establishment of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), and the absorbing all military organizations into the IDF [including LEHI as well as Irgun} was started... On June 1, an agreement was signed between Menachem Begin and Yisrael Galili for the absorption of the Irgun into the IDF. ... .in 1947, "the British army in Mandate Palestine banned the use of the term 'terrorist' to refer to the Irgun zvai Leumi ....Irgun Zvai Leumi.... In June 1948 its last commander, Menahem Begin, established the Herut movement adopting the IZL's emblem [partially clenched fist still being used]...Following Israel's Declaration of Independence, Prime Minister and Defense Minister David Ben-Gurion issued an order for the formation of the Israel Defense Forces on 26 May 1948, the order was made legal by the cabinet on 31 May.; two other Jewish underground organizations, Irgun and Lehi, joined the IDF

@BriarHood

7 ай бұрын

Ah, wikipedia. The bastion of truth!

I'm Aramaic. Why doesn't anyone talk about the Aramaeans who have lived there for thousands of years? They were tortured and sometimes slaughtered by Jews and later by Ottomans. Things weren't going well for them among the Europeans either. Nevertheless, thousands of Aramaeans still live in Jerusalem, Bethlehem and the surrounding area today. They were not left alone among any of these peoples. Today I spoke to my relative there. They are never mentioned!

@tendjinn

7 ай бұрын

Much like the Druze, Mandaens, Yezidis and many others, Aramaeans are largely unknown to people outside of the nations and areas where there are large populations. In context of Israel/Palestine, the world's understanding has been simplified to the larger players and even there we have over simplified. You could write entire tomes on just the point of views of religious and secular Jews on the subject of Israel and how they differ even on just the formation of Israel. That being said, we have the internet now and people like you can and do have a voice and story to share. Some will listen while others won't but it's a tool to reach out that we never had before.

@MrNajibrazak

7 ай бұрын

Acknowledging your argument would blow almost everybody's argument out of the water. Palestine is supposed to be inhabited by Arabs all along. You should not exist from the gist of it. Personally as an Asian i think the Western world today sanctioned racism against the original people of the land of Israel by allowing Pro Palestinian rhetoric of exterminating the Jews and any which would dispute their historic claims. the Pro Palestinians demands a genocidal agenda to achieve it means if actions speaks louder than words while the UN is the enemy of the real people of Israel.

@pollypurree1834

7 ай бұрын

You aren't related to those people anymore than today's Egyptians are related to Ancient Egyptians. The Aramaeans no longer exist. The Jews are the only people who still exist from 3,000 years ago and, btw, they still look the same

@theylovelies951

7 ай бұрын

@@tendjinnDruze are arabs that converted to Judaism because Muslim didn’t like their esoteric practice….they are probably spies these days because they can easily infiltrate Muslim Palestinian groups because they look like them and they can speak Arab

@theylovelies951

7 ай бұрын

@@tendjinnand also the Druze helped the Zionist to fight against Muslim since 1907

Fascinating to review this 1982 snapshot of events and analysis. Puts the contemporary events and analysis in an eerie and sad perspective. Like the old Peter Paul and Mary song said " when will they ever learn..."

@zapkvr

7 ай бұрын

How many roads must a man walk down? Forty two.

@obedirect5491

7 ай бұрын

a song covered by Earth Wind and Fire: Where Have All the Flowers Gone.

@Movie_Trailers101

7 ай бұрын

To understand this better go back in year 620s CE when muslim caliphates first set feet on those lands.

@vhawk1951kl

7 ай бұрын

What leads you to suppose that some mythical " they" can, or wish to, learn"?So long as men (human beings ) understand nothing of the machine with which whatever they or you are coated, of course you would expect them to be the slavees of their functions , just as you are. *Why* are men (human beings)as they are?How would you set about discovering that if you had sufficient time and resources? Wjere would you start?Some might sugestthat you start with the various functions with which their mechanisms are endowedand exavcctly ho the work, unles you were given a user's manual when you first started living on this planet, and you can start with the verbs you and others use, verbs being so-called doing words, because the machanism that coats whatever you are can*do* all sorts of things, which is to say that it has various-(how many can you count?) functions or what if does. or can do. Which of their)howwmany?) functions and verbs take part in their periodic bouts of trying to destroy oneanother's existences?Don't just bewail( thereis one verb) them, study them, and one way to do that is to look at their language or particularly its verbs; they kill one another because they(killer or killed) do what?-look at the verbs they useamd the verbs dpoing or function words that you use; which verbs do you use about yourself most often? Nh you're right it's far to much bother to study to learn anything about you are creatures similar to you; far simpler and more attractive to go in for sanctimonious sentimentality as did Peter Paul and Mary and what does that feed? Everything that you or I or men generally, do, feeds omething, drs it not? What is being fed. There is an old red Indian story in which a wise elder tells a younger that he has two wolves in him, one black/dislikeable and the other white'/ likeable; you might care to look it up to see if there is any sense in it, but why bother? Are not your various functions also wolves?

@fallasleep9472

7 ай бұрын

@@Movie_Trailers101 No, this isn't a religious issue but rather an issue that started with Balfour declatration, my friend. A geopolitical issue. No muslim is going to say Jews never lived in Palestine, there were always jewish palestinians there, but not zionists.

This land for Palastines and my grandmother and my grandfather lived their until the 1948 when the war happened they escape to nearest place gaza

@spiridhulahaderi3792

6 ай бұрын

Yes,even me that im not Arab but Europe i know the history,Palestine was Called,there is no israel,that land belongs to Palestinians like it or not the other party who only lie and do crimes

My grandmother use to go on vacation in Lebanon, she always said it was most beautiful place. She always cried.. watching this it makes sense now!

@jeffsmith2144

7 ай бұрын

Until the 'religion of peace' practically invaded it and stank the place out with their medieval actions.

@qazwsxqaz3163

7 ай бұрын

Арабский Палестинский Конгресс (А.П.К.) - был образован в 1920 как орган, руководящий националным движением арабов Палестины за независимость, отмену мандата и против "Бальфура декларации". В 1921, после массовых арабских демонстраций, приведших к вооруженным столкновениям между арабами и сионистами, А.П.К. выделил арабскую палестинскую делегацию воглаве с Муса-Казим пашой Хусейни, выехавшую в Лондон для переговоров с министром колоний Уинстоном Черчиллем по вопросу о статусе Палестины. Делегация А.П.К. требовала образования в Палестине национального правительства. Черчиль отклонил это требование под предлогом, что "на данной стадии оно помешает осуществлению обязательств Великобритании перед еврейским народом". Переговоры 1921-22 завершились предъявлением "Черчилля меморандума", который был конгрессом отклонен. В сентябре 1923 Англия А.П.К. предложила образовать "Арабское агенство" по типу "Еврейского агенства". А.П.К. отверг и этот план. После арабского восстания 1929 в Палестине А.П.К. направил в марте 1930 новую делегацию в Лондон, требуя прекращения еврейской миграции в Палестину, издания закона о защите арабских крестьян от сионистских земельных экспроприаций, установления демократического правительства Палестины с пропорциональным представительством национальностей. Английское правительство отвергло эти требования, как проитворечащие мандату и декларации Бальфура. Еврейское Агенство (Е.А.) - организовано на основе ст.4 мандата на Палестину как "публичный орган для советов и сотрудничества с админитсрацией Палестины в экономических, социальных ипрочих делах, касающихся установления еврейского населения Палестины, а также для помощи и участия в развитии страны". По тексту мандата таким агенством была принана сионистская организация. В 1929 в состав Е.А. вошли крупные еврейские капиталисты США, формально не принадлежащие к сионистской организации, и Е.А. было выделено в особый орган, продолжающий находится под сионистским контролем и проводящий сионистскую политику. Во главе Е.А. до конца 1946 стоял Вейцман. Арабские организацие Палестины неоднократно протестовало против наделения Е.А, правительственными функциями. Английское правительство отвергало эти перотесты, как "необоснованные" (Черчилля меморандум). Е.А. располагает крупными капиталами (Еврейский национальный фонд и фонд колонизации). В 1942 Е.А. приняло "Балтиморскую программу", требующую: 1) создания в Палетине чисто еврейского государства; 2) создания в Палестине еврейской армии; 3) неограниченной еврейской имиграции в Палестину; 4) передачи хозяйственного развития Палестины под контроль Е.А. Барух Бернард Маннес (р.1870) - госдарственный деятель США, член демократической партии. Барух составил себе крупное состяние биржевыми операциями. В годы президенства Гувера (1929-33) Барух, будучи финансовым советником президента, выступал против установления дипломатических отношений с СССР. На одном из заседаний комиссии ООН Барух заявил, что США не откроют секрета атомной бомбы до тех пор, пока другие страны не уменьшат своих армий до размеров полицейских сил.

@daomingjin

7 ай бұрын

Zionisim is the problem.

@Lakshyam9

7 ай бұрын

​​@@Jennianneryes and no one talks of these displaced Christians. It is always about 'displaced Mudlims'. This victimhood is disgusting and ironical.

@Lakshyam9

7 ай бұрын

​@@anyawaleofondoIslam will end soon. Then you can laugh more, you maniac.

I am Anglo-Saxon and live in England. I can't sleep at night thinking that an Italian will turn up with his mafia chums and kick me out of my house because Romans were here before Anglo-Saxons.

@TheFertoledo

7 ай бұрын

🤣

@roncardenas2963

7 ай бұрын

Romans were really Nordic Vikings. Thors hammer is far reaching.

@bearcatXF

7 ай бұрын

​@@roncardenas2963In the words of John McEnroe 'you cannot be serious '.

@bearcatXF

7 ай бұрын

There is by definition no England without the Anglo-Saxons. The Romans had abandoned Britain by the time the Germanic tribes arrived in the 5th century. But even if the Romans returned the next month, week or day they'd have no more right to the island than if they were arriving for the first time. The world belongs to those who will fight for it. The proper response if anyone shows up at your door aiming to "kick you out" is to promptly apply lethal force to them. But then I'm a terrible barbaric Anglo-Saxon/Germanic who's been living in America for 400 years.

@truthvikingborz1599

7 ай бұрын

We Vikings,did what we wanted with Saxons...poor warrior,s

Trick question.. Land is for everyone. No one owns anything, we are here temporarily to feel and experience.

@linguaphile1871

4 ай бұрын

Exactly, foreign Jews who came should have integrated when my great granpas had them in the first place!! They chose the hard way!

More attention to pre-1948 would have been more enlightening than the post 1967.

Don’t care who’s land you think it is!!!! Live in peace!!!!

@aishahzaharahbintiali1097

7 ай бұрын

Exactly. Life is so Short. All that happen because they dont come to the round table. For 70 years they dont ve peace. Stupid leaders.

@humaafandi8894

7 ай бұрын

There can never be peace when one occupied the other

@Uda007

7 ай бұрын

No problem. Just return the land to Palestinian. Simple.

@aishahzaharahbintiali1097

7 ай бұрын

@@Uda007 well thats the perfect action. Who ever support Israel are also hooligan. Its all said in the Islam Holly book al Quran in its chapter mentioned the stubborn Israel. Israel even Killed many prophets before. What ashame!!!

@whakatu4life285

7 ай бұрын

yeah, you think like that right up till someone comes and pushes you out of your house/land.... see how peaceful you feel then clown

What shocks me the most as an Australian "that lives in a bubble",is that this conflict hasn't stopped in all these years. How sad that generations have grown up knowing nothing else. I do realise this happens globally, daily, but hearing that babies were killed intentionally in cots really gets me. The kind of hate it would take to be able to do that to a cute little kid is mind blowing to me. I truely feel sorry for everyone involved in this. I wish them Peace Oneday.

@MN-53

7 ай бұрын

The 40 babies story is false It's propaganda to make the public opinion on the Israeli side It's not a conspiracy theory They literally didn't give any evidence Just said that it happened and the western media intentionally spread it as if it's true

@tornadofay

7 ай бұрын

no babes or children were killed, reports coming out today that it was fake news by Israeli reporter and there are no proof on it.

@user-nn1lw3mk5l

7 ай бұрын

The babies being killed is an unverified story, there’s no proof of witnesses. The babies being pulled out from under rumble lifeless and scarred are on camera however, the proof is right in front of our eyes

@eemoogee160

7 ай бұрын

Peace in the Middle East and Free Assange!

@MN-53

7 ай бұрын

@@judithmiller7308 Are you this naive?? Why did you believe israel and Western news ? Hamas denied it, and oren ziv, a news journalist who was there, denied it So gullible

They say its complicated and they weren't kidding. Another excellent piece David.

Thanks for this ,its not a standard anti jewish documentary, thanks....

I gotta say its kinda weird to have a documentary on this issue without interviewing a single palestinian from what I can tell. Lots of folks saying "I was in Palestine/ Lebanon/ Jordan and my impression was X" but no actual first hand interviews.

@NeonAstralOfficial

7 ай бұрын

its early 1980s people didn't have iPhones, at the time they reported on news domestically too without interviews.

@Joel-xf5mc

7 ай бұрын

That’s because it’s pro Israel propaganda. Not the worst I’ve seen, but obviously bias.

@Jartisann

7 ай бұрын

in those days, English wasnt probably widely spread, so they wont expect to interview Palestinians, let alone ask them questions in English...

@gaoaibai6243

7 ай бұрын

"Palestinian"? You mean a typical Arab living in Israel right? Or do you mean a Turk as they were the ones who ruled the land back in the days but by the 80s I doubt there are any Turk left in the whole region tbh.

@The_Ballo

7 ай бұрын

It's just a bunch of Zionists spouting narrative

“Why is it that on June 4th 1967 I was a Jordanian and overnight I became a Palestinian?” “We did not particularly mind Jordanian rule. The teaching of the destruction of Israel was a definite part of the curriculum, but we considered ourselves Jordanian until the Jews returned to Jerusalem. Then all of the sudden we were Palestinians - they removed the star from the Jordanian flag and all at once we had a Palestinian flag. When I finally realized the lies and myths I was taught, it is my duty as a righteous person to speak out”. ~ Walid Shoebat, a former PLO terrorist

@mimielibokun8230

7 ай бұрын

Does it mean the jews were the inhabitants of Jerusalem before the Jordanians turned Palestinians arrived.

@northwind8821

7 ай бұрын

Walid Shoebat is already exposed as a liar and fraud, even by CNN.

Thank you very helpful, especially whats going on lately

Very well put together documentary.

A very Devastating and Dire situation! NO human suffering should be happening, on any side!

@lightningbrigade4722

7 ай бұрын

Your comment made my day. Thankyou.🙏

@expressoevangelism80

7 ай бұрын

As long as Islam hate the Jews, Satan will have a theatre prepared for war. It’s been written about for over 2000 years. It’s all coming to the big finish sooner or later.

@godssara6758

7 ай бұрын

Tell Hamas to stop attacking and stop using Palastinians as human shields

@thomasmaughan4798

7 ай бұрын

"NO human suffering should be happening, on any side!" Alas, suffering exists. Some thought should be given on what to do with the situation as it exists, not as you wish it existed.

"In former days the struggle for existence was chiefly a struggle against nature, today it is primarily a struggle against other human beings." - Kirby Page

@KatieAdler

7 ай бұрын

I tend to think the human threat has been greater since the get go.

@4th_Disciple

7 ай бұрын

All lies, same as what the European colonisers said about Africa, Australia and America. There was no civilization here just wilderness and we "settled" here. In reality European colonisation always championed systematic genocide. European colonisers after wiping out natives always claimed this is my country despite the fact they came there on a boat.

@marshallking-ls1lz

7 ай бұрын

Bless you man

@joeshmoe7967

7 ай бұрын

@@KatieAdler Yea, as soon as there was more than 1. Turmoil ever since.

There was always someone there before you. The only solution is equal rights for every citizen, no matter their race, gender, religion, etc

@vhawk1951kl

7 ай бұрын

What is or how do you define a right"without resort to cognates and synonyms, descriptions and examples and other forms of circularity? You are about to discover that you have absolutely no idea what a " right" is and cannot begin to define a " right"without resort to cognates and synonyms, descriptions and examples and other forms of circularity.

It is a dumb question, "Whose land is it?" Under what legal justification were hundreds of thousands of people who owned homes, farms, businesses, schools, etc. deprived of these possessions? The issue was that they were not of the correct ethnicity. Those of the desired ethnicity were allowed to come from foriegn lands and take possession of the land, homes, farms, and businesses that had been owned by the undesireables. But there is no legal justification for this travesty, and there never will be. Here in the USA we hear all the time about how the illegal state of Israel has "the right to defend itself," but what we never hear is that Palestine also has the right to defend itself.

@mrow7598

7 ай бұрын

When is one defending one self include mass murder of civilians, raping of woman and kidnapping? What did those party goers do to the Palestinians? When Israel created their county in their version of their declaration of independence they state all people living on this land are welcome to stay. The Palestinians didn't have to leave, they could have stayed and lived in peace if they wanted to. Many Arabs live in Israel as Israeli citizens in government, police, army, etc. But no these people quickly started the 3 NOs, no peace with Israel, no recognition of Israel, no negotiations with Israel

@amchristie8894

7 ай бұрын

There was nothing there but rocks and rubble, just like Australia. The Jews made it into something valuable. Now the Terrorstinians want it back.

I am appalled and saddened that 40 years after this documentary the conflict still continues and innocent lives are ended in the most horrific ways.

@MrNajibrazak

7 ай бұрын

it is more appalling when u realize all ancient texts blows all modern Pro Palestinian arguments out of the water. Especially in the Quran; Surah al Maidah 19 -21. Israel belongs to the Jews.

@hartley81848184

7 ай бұрын

@@elwiamsch2228the conflict stops when God stops it…. Forever

@SUEELLENELASALI

7 ай бұрын

@@hartley81848184 EXACTLY what just happened in Palestine it was the creator HE IS getting ready to give Palestine back to the Palestinians BY FORCE! If not this year it will next or by 2027!

@havnfun412

7 ай бұрын

Maybe if the 20+ Arab nations would take these Arabs in, and leave the 1 Jewish nation alone, there would be no fighting.

@tubedude54

7 ай бұрын

It would end if the people in Gaza would oust Hamas.

I’m a 33 year social studies teacher (World History) and I’ve never seen this (probably 8mm). This is an excellent resource. I’m likely going to use this to talk with my students tomorrow. Showed this to my World History class this morning and had a great discussion about the current crisis. It was remarkable how many of the things that were talked about in this documentary are still true today.

@MrDirtclodfight

7 ай бұрын

Please do! My 7th. grade history teacher went in depth about the causes of wars, it made seemingly "ancient" history personal and relevant. Mr. Noonan, loved that guy. Aced his class✨💯

@hypno5690

7 ай бұрын

And remember that it's your job to teach students how to think, not what to think.

@TheMoonDejesus

7 ай бұрын

I hope you also find one that doesn’t come off as such clear propaganda. I don’t have a dog in the fight but this screams agenda.

@TheMoonDejesus

7 ай бұрын

It kind of scares me that a teacher of social studies doesn’t have discernment to see this as heavily biased and thus not likely a reliable telling of this history.

@hypno5690

7 ай бұрын

@@cs5384 let's get real, if there were more Palestinian viewpoints you would still say that there wasn't enough, and then move onto your real point which is that Israel is evil and "there's no bias just good and evil". Snoreee

Thanks for sharing!

😢😢😢 sad to see young children being trained as soldiers instead of playing sports, music ,farming.

If people want to understand the history of what’s happening in Palestine I strongly recommend that they read an anti Zionist historian like Ilaan Pappe, an Israeli Jew who ended up having to leave Israel for exposing the truth of its historical origins.

@shenandoah7875

7 ай бұрын

It’s also good to read pro-Israeli historians because both sides of this story are propagandized. I tend to believe the anti-Israeli side is a bit more propagandized.

@albertwesker2050

7 ай бұрын

@@shenandoah7875because it is. All you have to do is follow history and how Jewish people have been treated around the world. It’s absolutely insane how leftists will say to Americans “there is no such thing as a border to a country and to have one is fascism” then go on to celebrate Hamas and Arab extremism.

@strategymythbuster910

7 ай бұрын

​@@shenandoah7875 i believed zionis is a propaganda.. if you wanna occupy, take referendum from gazans.. not barbaric actions...

@hispoiema

7 ай бұрын

The bottom line for me is God telling the Jews that they will possess the land and it gives the dimensions in the Bible.

@garylake1676

7 ай бұрын

Diving into the detail will just send you down rabbit holes. Monotheism lies at the very heart of this conflict.

"The dust" will never settle in the Middle East. That territory has been conquered and reconquered with regularity for millennia by various powers, factions, crusades & countries. Maps of the Levant have changed so frequently that cartographers of the region are well employed indeed.

@DavidHoffmanFilmmaker

7 ай бұрын

Thank you for the support Fred. David Hoffman filmmaker

@alchemistkingdickinson2256

7 ай бұрын

@@DavidHoffmanFilmmaker Kaduri meet Prince of Peace 11/04/2003. I am the one who made contact with Kaduri by email and showed him modern prophets and evidences he became conscious of that lead to him knowing Messiah was present in flesh. Bibi must meet Prince of Peace who is key stops Russia and all war murdering etc Maybe yad like to make a film which will manifest Prince of Peaces human face to humans; which is only thing can stop killings war!?!

@twstephanie50

7 ай бұрын

Yes it WILL settle in the not too distant future.

@The_Lord_has_it

7 ай бұрын

@@twstephanie50 and the Glory of God will be evident for ALL to see. God bless Israel.

@crashyburnymit4080

7 ай бұрын

​@@twstephanie50it didn't settle for 70 years. When is that future ? Another 70 years, 100, 200?

Thank you again for the excellent video.

Another great video, Mr. Hoffman.

"Whose land WAS it" does NOT matter... What matters is "who is the winner". No country in this world owned their land from the beginning. All countries were someone else's land at some point.

@_____J______

7 ай бұрын

China will grow larger!

@CreativeArtist-py6xw

7 ай бұрын

@@_____J______if allowed to

@thomasmaughan4798

7 ай бұрын

Agreed.

@ericscaillet2232

7 ай бұрын

Baring the Eskimos...

@thomasmaughan4798

7 ай бұрын

@@ericscaillet2232 "Baring the Eskimos" But do that only in midsummer so they don't get as cold as they stand around naked.

I think this documentary glosses over a lot of things... The Arab uprising defeated the Ottomans in the area with a promise from the British that the land they liberated would form an independent Arab nation. Then the Brits reneged on the deal to create a Jewish homeland, so that was disreputable. And for instance, the Peel Commission partition, which looks pretty fair at first glance, actually gave the best arable land to the Jews. A lot of the "the Arabs are just being obstinate" presentation in this video seems to be glossing over some pretty serious disreputable actions...

@NaderNabilart

7 ай бұрын

Thank you. I learned a lot from this comment

@stevecarson4162

7 ай бұрын

Did you miss that Israel is *surrounded* by "independent Arab nations"? How many do they need? Of the territory that USED to be called "Palestine", MOST of it is now part of Jordan. The Golan Heights were taken by Syria, and Gaza was taken by Egypt. Yet somehow, the people calling themselves "Palestinians" (which was never a country) only want the small part of the territory that was given to Israel, and which it has been developing and irrigating since 1947. Why aren't they demanding any of the rest of that land "back"? Because the "independent Arab nations" hate *each other* almost as much as they hate the Jews. (BTW, I've lived in Israel, where there are Christians, Jews, Druz, AND Arabs who all live and work together. Last I looked, there were a dozen Arab members of parliament in the Knesset.) "Being obstinate" is a fair description.

@gustavagenbacht6600

7 ай бұрын

YES. THANK YOU.

@mybestideas1

7 ай бұрын

By nature, Arabs and Islam are violent. On the other hand Zionists inserted themselves in this situation/land and were never accepted. They either need to be two states or Jews need to leave to wherever they came from.

@thescorgon5964

7 ай бұрын

So you are saying that deserts and swamp are good land ?

Thank you for the perspective

Thank you for your project that brings a valuable perspective on the development of "Palestinian" nationalism, leadership, and militancy.

@DavidHoffmanFilmmaker

4 ай бұрын

Thank you Frank. David Hoffman filmmaker

…..At 81 , I remember most of these events , but I can’t say I always understood the reasons for them ..thanks for this documentary ..so much time has passed and nothing has been settled between these people who are actually brothers ..cooperation between these tribes would possibly benefit both …such a shame that they’re both so stif necked and stubborn …Peace would be such a relief , not only to them , but to the world ..

@dededubois3241

7 ай бұрын

...most countries deem Jewish settlements built on land Israel occupied in 1967 as illegal. Israel disputes this and cites "biblical" ties to the land, but an Oxford University scientific study declares all Jews to be wholly of European origin and not originally from the Middle East at all. The origin of the Ashkenazi Jews, who come most recently from Europe, has largely been shrouded in mystery. But a study suggests that they derive largely from Europe. Though the finding may seem intuitive, it contradicts the notion that European Jews mostly descend from people who left Israel and the Middle East around 2,000 years ago. Instead, a substantial proportion of the population originates from local Europeans who converted to Judaism, said study co-author Martin Richards, an archaeogeneticist at the University of Huddersfield in England.... So not really "brothers"...

@Chris-vs9le

7 ай бұрын

What an underrated comment!

@melvynobrien6193

7 ай бұрын

THE CHOSEN PEOPLE WILL NOT SHARE "THEIR" LAND WITH "HUMAN ANIMALS."

@Jay-bp1yx

7 ай бұрын

@@melvynobrien6193can tell this person didn’t watch more than 2 minutes of the above documentary

@SueShpak-dd4bq

7 ай бұрын

Israel was more than willing to live peacefully with them. It's the Palestinians who do not want to live peacefully with Israel. They've hated Israel all their lives they've hated the Jews all their lives and has always wanted to wipe them off the face of the Earth.

I appreciate the neutral view, you try to have in massive subjects.

@Sam-zy5ck

7 ай бұрын

Neutral? You have to be paid to write this.

@Schmidtelpunkt

7 ай бұрын

It is always one side presenting the facts. The truth is, that this is a clusterf*ck which goes so far back in history, that each side can easily present the facts in a favorable way for themselves. Which is made worse by the profiteers of war on both sides, which use that to stir up the dirt. This makes it just the more interesting to see different points of view getting displayed.

@remodesu

7 ай бұрын

Neutral?????

@Absolute42

7 ай бұрын

I’m nearly halfway in and haven’t seen a single representative of the Palestinian. Putting the blame on the other side is not neutrality because it is does in a soft voice. Read Rashid khalidi

@melgarezuniverse1217

7 ай бұрын

David Hoffman,Emanuel sivan,david Sidorsky,Michael walzer..all sionist 💯👈🏾...i let you figure out the rest🤔

I seriosly hope all people in the comment section expressing sadness at the situation do actually pick a side at this point. We have to avoid another holocaust situation at all costs.

Scary how this is so relevant to this day.

The more things change, the more they remain the same. In December of 1982, I was headed to Beirut on a US Navy ship. The 23rd of this month marks the 40th Anniversary of the bombing of the US Marine barracks that took the lives of 246 service members.

@MariaEngstrom

7 ай бұрын

It was a very effective way to make USA stop occupying Lebanon.

@locket0730

7 ай бұрын

And who attacked them

@82spiders

7 ай бұрын

Remind me. Why were there US Marines in Beirut? As a show of force? I forget, or never knew.

@ABIGD0NK3Y

7 ай бұрын

​@@locket0730.... pretty sure it wasn't Israel

@dependablepaul

7 ай бұрын

@@locket0730 Islamic Jihad took credit but the courts said it was Iran.

This seems to skip over a lot of important facts … And seriously favours one side of this conflict over the others. It’s like watching a movie for 5mins and picking villains

@s.durbar1294

7 ай бұрын

ditto

Thank you for this! I never knew this! Im starting to understand way more about the middle East and what's going on with the Palestinians and the Israeli! They completely invaded the Arab! They were forced out!

If two fight in blood for the land then neither deserve the land. You shall walk alone in darkness until you can walk together as brothers on the same land.

So much better than modern day docs in the style of Frontline. No tricks of threatening music, grave voiceovers or darkened shots. Just straightup information. I mean there is music, put it is light and not overbearing.

@GLG-mf2ev

7 ай бұрын

Your not pale nor isreal so. Your opinion doesn’t count

@stormriderkaos

7 ай бұрын

@@GLG-mf2ev Well the "rest of the world" is getting tired of this issue and the death and destruction and instability it brings. I'm in favor of forcing a solution. Two states, some compensation, forced relocation, the end.

@SnakeBush

7 ай бұрын

thats Propaganda dude

@franklin519

7 ай бұрын

​@@stormriderkaosYes, I'm hoping that would work out but it probably won't. I'd at least give it a shot.

@stormriderkaos

7 ай бұрын

@@franklin519 There might still be skirmishes and terrorist activities but if the major powers (and some of the Arab world) stood by those new borders, it would at least end the apartheid and offer the possibility of more peace.

Some people will become very rich as a result of the misery caused by this conflict. The weapons sellers & those who will make money from reconstruction after each conflict have no interest in trying to develop a last peace.

It is an excellent documentary. We should learn from it for betterment of our present and future, but not to claim old territories and disturb current order. If we go this route, then the natives of Australia, US, and many others should be accommodated equally, which is impractical if not impossible.

@vhawk1951kl

7 ай бұрын

Have you any way of verifying or falsifying anything in what you call "an excellent documentary"? For all you know it could be bullshit or pure invention from end to end could it not? What makes it "an excellent documentary and would you call it"an excellent documentary" even if it was no more than gossip and hearsay , belief and guesswork, form, attractive content complete crap?How might you go about verify ing or falsifying any of it r anything in it supposing you broke the habit of a lifetime of pasively believing everything you are told? Almost all of what is called or calls irae lf history is belief based on gossip hearsay and guesswork. One of the great weakness of men(human beings) is that they are pasively credulous faute de mieux

@xatreason

6 ай бұрын

Giving the land back (even merely from a climate change perspective) to the indigenous people should ALWAYS be the goal/action, even if it can’t be fulfilled a 100%. Look at where not doing so has gotten us

The name Syria-Palaestina was given to the Roman province of Judaea in the early 2nd century AD. Urban legend says Emperor Hadrian, in the wake of the 132-135 AD Bar Kokhba revolt, renamed that region, from Judaea to Syria-Palaestina. But the name "Palestina" for that region had been used by the Greeks for centuries before that, and the term had a strict geographical meaning, like Transylvania or Gallia Cisalpina. The non-existing - at that time - Muslim Arabs had nothing to do with the etymology of those names. The Arabs came much later in Palestina, as military conquerors and immigrants, bringing Islam with them, converting or exterminating the local Jewish, Christian, Zoroastrian or pagan populations.

@nikkigrey2020

7 ай бұрын

👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾thank you, the truth

@bryanfridley8543

6 ай бұрын

“ Before the Sufis, in antiquity there were some who were vegetarians, followed a practice of being "initiated into the Mysteries of the Kingdom of the Heavens" by a living teacher, and during their meditation practice repeated several sacred names that correspond to various inner regions. Their goal was to spiritually ascend through several heavenly realms in order to return to the timeless Supreme Being in the highest realm. Some called this Being "The Nameless One". There are references to inner Light and Sound. There are also references to a Kal Niranjan type being, a false god or negative power called "the Demiurge'. Several Sant Mat authors have written books about the Gnostics and the parallels between Gnosticism and the Path of the Masters. One of the Gnostic scriptures called "Pistis Sophia" contains many beautiful hymns and prayers. Though reincarnation is mentioned as a reality, the goal of salvation was to liberate souls from material captivity, reincarnation, the wheel of fate, and go back to God again. Souls were given the ability to mystically travel via the Holy Stream of Light. In Pistis Sophia (the Book of Faith-Wisdom) Christ says, "Seek, all of you, after the Light, so that the power of your soul that is in you may live. Do not cease seeking day or night until you find the mysteries of the Kingdom of Light, which will purify you, make you into pure Light and lead you into the Kingdom of the Light." Discover why these writings got purged from the Western world during the Fourth Century. Tune in as we celebrate the sages of Judaism, Neoplatonism and Pythagoreanism that helped to give birth to all of these amazing spiritual movements of antiquity such as the Essenes, Sethians, Mandaeans, Ebionites (mentioned in the Book of Acts, the Hebrew Christians lead by James the Just -- "Christianity before Paul"), Valentinians, Manichaeans, Cathars, and other groups that once represented "cousin" schools of spirituality that have much in common with living paths of today such as Kabbalah, Sufism, and Sant Mat.” kzread.info/dash/bejne/kZuTscexfZvFmdI.html

Throughout human history land belongs to those strong enough to take and hold it. Nothing has changed in the past 30,000 years.

@NaderNabilart

7 ай бұрын

Your idea of ownership is comically simple. Where's the law? Justice? Morals? If you can't defend your home against intruders that doesn't make it their home legally.

@PershingDriver

7 ай бұрын

@@NaderNabilartI was writing about Nations. Laws exist inside of nations as for justice and morals … nice words for things that do not exist in the real world.

@NaderNabilart

7 ай бұрын

@@PershingDriver so you haven't heard about international law? Human rights? War crimes? You're so funny

@ayobelnaggar4728

7 ай бұрын

Oh really!! So why is israshit keeps calling for daddy america to help lol

@martycarmichael3885

7 ай бұрын

True statement. It doesn’t matter what you have if you’re not strong enough to protect it someone will take it away.

Your first speaker...said Palestinians were mainly in the hills, I think. In the documentary 1920: The Other Side of the Palestinian Story (Al Jazeera) which I watched yesterday...there is a completely different picture. In the last quarter of the 19th century - this is just one example that I wrote down - through Jaffa grain was exported to Egypt, Rhodes and Dubrovnik; cotton to France and Ismir, antiques an religious gifts tp Istanbul , Italy, Portugal and Spain, Jerusalem exported to Egypt, Italy, Greece, through Gaza. Gaza imported rice from Egypt, textiles from Istanbul, glassware from China and much more. "It was a false claim that Palestine had no people, only some Bedouins and farmers who had no civilisation or agriculture." Please do look at it. I'm only half way through as it is very long. Jane Soole, Dorset, England.

@jav03_

7 ай бұрын

this is false and extremely wrong to assume. if you look to recent history of Palestine under the ottoman empire and under the British there were many palestininas living there. there were schools, universities, cafes, women harvesting olive trees and the ethnic Palestinian clothing. There was tradition. many jewish people at the time had Palestinian passports. the Palestinians had been living there for 100s of years. and if you think it was desolate that is a wetern mindset not everyone needs to build massive cities a lot of our history is from the old way of living in asia and other places. it may seem simple to you but it was respectful and mindful of our planet, it was peaceful. and then some man named Arthur balfour decided to create a jewish state because Europe did not want to account for their heinous crimes to the jewish. israel was not even the first destination they considered, they also considered Argentina, and at the time British occupied uganda. Most jewish people in Israel are askhenazi jews their ancestry is traced back to Europe not the middle east unlike the mizrahi jews (amongst others) they are settlers. a history over 2000 years ago cannot be applied to this modern era, that makes no sense. the Palestinian people had to fight off crusaders and now the settlers. they never stop fighting for their ancestral homes and villages where their families have resided for 100+ years

@TheJTcreate

7 ай бұрын

Thats not the claim that was made. No one ever said there was no civilization or trade in the area. This video was referring to Palestine Region before the Zionist migration started in 1890 to 1917. Western Palestine has always been a pathway of migration and trade up and down the mediterain cost, from eastern Europe to North Africa. But fact!! in 1800, there was only 250,000 inhabitants in all of Palestine region which was 5 times larger before the Mandate that divided it. A lot of that lives east of the Jordan river as, alot of the western lands, swamps, marshes and coastlines was unsuitable for farming. That is a trifle, especially since an area like New Jersey has over 1 million. By the time the 1900 came rolling around, the population barely hit 500,000. Again that is a trifle for a land mass 5 times the size of new jersey. Almost 80% of the inhabitants were farmers, living outside of Jeruseleum and Hebron. 7% of that population was Jewish, about 22% were christian and they mostly lived in Jeruseleum and Hebron. The Arab population exploded between 1900 and 1920. Some of that was from legal and illegal migration. Some of that was improvements in medicine which improved the survival rate of mothers giving birth.

@fallasleep9472

6 ай бұрын

@@jav03_ Thank you for the clarification. Some of these people think just because there weren't any huge metropolis cities in Palestine it means it was empty. May I ask which books or videos you watched on this?

It's Israel's ever since king David.

Excellent, Thank You for Your Truth!

I saw the morning It was shattered by a gun Heard a scream, saw him fall, no one cried I saw a mother She was praying for her son Bring him back, let him live, don't let him die Do you ever ask yourself Is there a Heaven in the sky Why can't we get it right Cause we all live under the same sun We all walk under the same moon Then why, why can't we live as one I saw the evening Fading shadows one by one We watch the lamb, lay down to the sacrifice I saw the children The children of the sun How they wept, how they bled, how they died Do you ever ask yourself Is there a Heaven in the sky Why can't we stop the fight Cause we all live under the same sun We all walk under the same moon Then why, why can't we live as one Sometimes I think I'm going mad We're loosing all we had and no one seems to care But in my heart it doesn't change We've got to rearrange and bring our world some love And does it really matter If there's a heaven up above We sure could use some love Cause we all live under the same sun We all walk under the same moon Then why, why can't we live as one Cause we all live under the same sky We all look up at the same stars Then why, tell me why can't we live as one

Who owns anything depends by how far back you want to go

@randylahey2242

7 ай бұрын

more like who is currently stronger:D

@haqq1

7 ай бұрын

By this logic shouldn't the White Europeans in North America just jump off to the Atlantic ocean since the land belonged to the Natives for 100 thousand years??

@pamela5568

7 ай бұрын

True, how far back you want to go is part of it. Also, who conquered who along the way.

@user-ok4il2ty6i

7 ай бұрын

​@@haqq1native americans were not the first population to arrive in america

@robertely686

7 ай бұрын

I identify as a Prussian and would like to start a series of wars to recolonize Germany, Poland and Russia. Did I also say that my people were chosen by God?

Thank you. Very sober and clear explanation.

Thank you for clarification.

So Britain felt they were entitled to divide a land because they felt they owned it. Even though the people were asked if they agreed to part of their country being given away and said NO, they were portrayed as being difficult the United Nations made sure it would happen. Was anywhere else ever considered? Why would anyone want to live in such a violent area?! There was NOWHERE AT ALL?

@crawdaddy6969

7 ай бұрын

The area was ruled by the Turks. The Arabs hated the Turks. The Brits won the war and divided the area as the saw fit. At the time oil was a rather new thing in the middle east and the Arabs were barely out of the sand.

@deserttortoise2227

7 ай бұрын

Self Determination, the idea that the people get to choose their government and country, is not a British value. It's inherently an American value as demonstrated in the Declaration of Independence and Woodrow Wilson's 14 points. The British rejected the 14 points and believed in an older philosophy of natural law and right of conquest, basically whatever army controls the territory sets the rules regardless of what the inhabitants want. Otherwise they would have no logical basis for controlling India and Canada. Self Determination became the dominant ruling philosophy in western civlization after WWII and is part of the UN charter, but is currently under threat. Both Russia and China have explicitly rejected self determination in favor of right of conquest as demonstrated in both Ukraine and Hong Kong.

@melvynobrien6193

7 ай бұрын

@@deserttortoise2227 Russia is taking traditionally-Russian land back, and China is recognized internationally as the rightful owner of Taiwan. The Jewish SETTLERS are land thieves, with no moral or ethical right to occupy Palestine. It's western governments who have rejected the right of Russians in western Ukraine to self-determination. Get your facts straight, instead of spewing pro-western propaganda.

@gucci9566

7 ай бұрын

Behind this land they are constantly loosing their lives for years although knowing that life is alloted once.But simultaneously Israel is grabbing their territories since long and it has no end.why Super powers can't help them to sit and decide their boundaries.

@717shred

7 ай бұрын

The Brits backstabbed the Jews for Arab oil, and the fact the British were antisemtes to begin with. Jordan is in fact the defacto Arab side of the Mandate obviously but the Muslim Arabs want to keep Jews in Dhimmitude.

When we can realize, as a whole human community, that every person has the right to live in safety and without fear, so many of the world’s problems will be solved. Unfortunately, humans are innately self-serving and opportunistic; too many people think they’re better and more deserving than others.

@Harnas31

7 ай бұрын

Most people realize it. The problem is those who kill peace-makers.

@profriday

7 ай бұрын

Your right to live in safety and without fear can only be guaranteed by your force to defend it.

@fritz1990

7 ай бұрын

As former Navy, I've been in many countries. Always got along great with the people there. It was always the governments that were the problem.

@t-babyyupressed2906

7 ай бұрын

You Hit It Right On The Head 😢

@irisbaez1972

7 ай бұрын

Your comment if full of contradictions. If we were humans then we will never be like you just said at the end. WE ARE NOT HUMAN YET, that's why you last sentences.

I miss this level of discourse in modern media. We are all so dumb now, myself included.

FROM THE RIVER TO THE SEA, PALESTINE WILL BE FREE 🇵🇸

@rotemaviaroor

7 ай бұрын

Not gonna happen

It’s sad to see how many people are completely ignorant of the history of this land. This is one of the best videos I’ve seen explaining this topic, thanks David.

@isaalmisry6187

7 ай бұрын

LOL, What crap.

@Hc_Paisano

7 ай бұрын

You’re right, it’s finally time for the muslim invaders to be driven out

@berniefynn6623

7 ай бұрын

"As I lived in Palestine, everyone I knew could trace their heritage back to the original country their great grandparents came from. Everyone knew their origin was not from the Canaanites, but ironically, this is the kind of stuff our education in the Middle East included. The fact is that today's Palestinians are immigrants from the surrounding nations! I grew up well knowing the history and origins of today's Palestinians as being from Yemen, Saudi Arabia, Morocco, Christians from Greece, muslim Sherkas from Russia, muslims from Bosnia, and the Jordanians next door. My grandfather, who was a dignitary in Bethlehem, almost lost his life by Abdul Qader Al-Husseni (the leader of the Palestinian revolution) after being accused of selling land to Jews. He used to tell us that his village Beit Sahur (The Shepherds Fields) in Bethlehem County was empty before his father settled in the area with six other families. The town has now grown to 30,000 inhabitants". - Walid Shoebat, an "ex-Palestinian" Arab -

@Ese361

7 ай бұрын

​@@isaalmisry6187We wuz lol you goofy afrocentrics are funny

@CommonSenceGUY79

7 ай бұрын

@@Ese361 @isslmisry6187 was right, this is crap!! In ancient times Israel/Palestine/Canaan {whatever you choose to call it} were a part of Egypt, at which time, Egypt was known as Kemet! The only thing that separate's Egypt from Israel is the Suze Canal which was built in 1859-1869, that's what the 1947 war between Egypt and Israel was all about, Egypt wanted its land back!! {btw, you can google this, it's not hard to fine} #2} The Arabs and Europeans came to Africa as invaders, in fact it was the Europeans who changed the name from Kemet to Egypt after the European invasion!! #3} What you see in Egypt/Israel today is Modern-Day, it's not Ancient! #4} For example, same thing happened in America, the Natives Americans were either killed or put on a reservation, and their land was stolen!! Critical Thinking is not your cut of tea! But 👌now you know.

I have a set of 1898 encyclopedias and in the entry for Jerusalem it says that the population of 1897 showed that it was 25 percent Muslim, 25 percent Christian and 50 percent Jewish. I have left this comment on other videos and was challenged as to the accuracy. A double check confirmed it was. I was very surprised my self.

@brushwolf

7 ай бұрын

The Jews have been the dominant faction even prior to Roman occupation.

@hydra8845

7 ай бұрын

But what was the population demographics of all of Palestine at the time?

@VioletSmith-ff6bs

7 ай бұрын

Very interesting statistic! Mass Jewish migration to Palestine started in the late 19th century due to the Zionist movement fueled by Theodore Herzl and others. Of course, the rest of Palestine, namely the countryside, was likely mostly Palestinian

@johnwright291

7 ай бұрын

@@hydra8845 that I couldn't discover. The encyclopedias were top of the line for the day. They are very detailed and cover a lot of the current events of the time. Fot example they have several pages in fine print on the Armenian Turkish situation. A lot of people don't know that a lot of Armenians were killed by the turks before 1915. I will have to dig further into the Palestinian situation. The whole area was considered Palestine at the time. The encyclopedias were a 6 volume set but I only have 4 which I got for 1 dollar. They are fascinating and surprising.

@ThatKraZeeKanuck

7 ай бұрын

I have heard this stated before as well. In the whole area there were more Jews than arabs and muslims but those two were more nomadic on the land. This may have something to do with the reason they chose certain land areas

One of the most important qualities of civilized people is the recognition that our current situation may extend back many years to a time that predates us. In recognizing that, it is important to reach solutions that will provide a lasting peace where people can begin to rebuild their lives. It bothers me greatly that my own government has a history of breaking treaties with the indigenous people of this land. But I can only do my best to ensure that during my time here, I will speak out against any policies that treats people unfairly. We should all be striving to be better than those of our ancestors. We should be learning from the past so that we can end the suffering of conflict and restore the hope of better times ahead.

@vhawk1951kl

7 ай бұрын

Perhaps you do not quite grasp that civilised means no more and no less than living in cities or perhaps tending so to do and absolutely*nothing* else

@vhawk1951kl

7 ай бұрын

"Us" being you and who else?-Your imaginary friend?It's none of my business who wants to get the living shit kicked out of them by the Israelites, who - over the years, have become adept at smiting all and sundry, and there is a particularly good reason not to seek to interfere with their smiting with which those who have read the book or sen the film "On the Beach"will be familiar.

@vhawk1951kl

7 ай бұрын

Clearly you do not understand that " civilised"(sic) means no more and no les than living in cities or tending so to do. From the safety of being behind city walls those dwelling in cities have the time and opportunity and safety to indulge in all sorts of monkey business such as all that good/evil, right/wrong, morality/ethics mumbo jumbo which constitutes their famous religions that serve to weaken and stupefy them. Our" situation being the situation of you and which specific identifiable interlocutor find yourselves? Yeah, right. You are what? -Some insignificant little clerk/shopgirl and "us" being some sort of convocation of such creatures? Being myself a mouse(nothing and nobody) who smites whom where and why, is no more any of my business than it is that of some convocation of insignificant little clerks/shipgirls like you titch.such swagger and such amour propre from one so feebleimpotent, insignificant and of course purely ephemeral. I can't really enisage those with many guns ships and other means of destruction an intimidation inviting any insignificant little clerks/shopgirls or mice like me to their famous 5 O'clocks, can you. The fact of the mater inso far as any facts can be divined is that the israelites have got smiting sunsry arabites and arafites down to a fine art, which doubtles accoubts for their wholly justifiable contempt for the smitten, out of whom the Israelites have had little difficulty with kicking the living shit for some time if sundry scribblers and swaggering wiseacres are to be treated as accurate sources of information. At one time the smitten were able to call upon the support of foreigners that at one time were in a position to supply them with devices capable of making life slightly les like a pianola for the Israelites when it came to smiting their neighbours, but those days are gone, so no more Migs and Sams for Mustapha and co, but who knows?

"In your seed all the nations of the earth shall be blessed " Gen. 22:18 said GOD to Abraham over 4,495 years ago. In Genesis 32:28 Father Abraham's grandson, Jacob - here God changes his name from Jacob to ISRAEL which means "Mighty with God" "Pray for the Peace of Jerusalem, they shall prosper that love thee" Psalms 122:6

This has to be the "grayest" subject matter I've ever encountered. I literally change my mind with almost every book I read on the subject.

David Hoffman always disseminates useful and insightful information when times are tough, shows us how useful it is to preserve and document our history. Sadly, many platforms today will either hide or take down footage of conflicts; it's something that should concern us all.

@nmnm6057

7 ай бұрын

“The media's the most powerful entity on earth. They have the power to make the innocent guilty and to make the guilty innocent, and that's power. Because they control the minds of the masses.” ― Malcolm X. (No Israeli babies have been killed this is a propaganda from the occupier to allow them committing war crime against Palestinians children)

@_artorical_

7 ай бұрын

Because this is pure Hasbara.

@jamesryan7684

7 ай бұрын

@@_artorical_ It can't be all wrong. What parts do you disagree with?

@karyne826

7 ай бұрын

And alter books..

@joyces2222

7 ай бұрын

If we don't learn from documented history, what's that saying ?

Very good documentary. Sad what happened to Lebanon.

The land belongs to palestine. Its not complicated. Isreal was taken unrightfully and unfairly. Theyve been oppressed ever since. No surprises theyre angry

A part of the soundtrack of my life of 61 years has been the ongoing Arab-Israeli conflict. It was fascinating to go back 40 years to this snapshot of the situation at that time, and to realise that although details on the ground have changed, the fundamental problems are much the same as they ever have been. Fascinating, and also depressing. The Hamas attack brings back so many unwelcome memories of past iterations of the same old, same old story.

@edwardschmitt5710

7 ай бұрын

Yes. Warring factions prevent jobs and industry, which leads to youth anger, which causes a cycle of ignorance and violence. I'm 53. My friend's Marine Corp brother was in Beirut when the barracks got hit.

@sandman0123

7 ай бұрын

Similar age, same thoughts here.

@bubbajones4522

7 ай бұрын

Both sides in this conflict are evil racist religious zealots. The zionists who think their race is chosen by God above all others, captured Palestine, pushed the native population off the land into ghettos then claims innocent when the natives fight back. On the other side of the fence, well they are just as evil and racist. Support for either side goes against the values and principles on which America was founded.

@bartdrennon1764

7 ай бұрын

Except this is the most disgusting and evil attack on Israel ever. The intent was to kill as many children as possible.

@HappinessIsAJourney

7 ай бұрын

History repeats itself.

In our time we have seen the most devastating wars ever to afflict humankind. Millions of widows, widowers, and orphans have been left to grieve for their loved ones. At the 1991 Madrid Middle East peace conference, Yitzhak Shamir said: *“I am sure that there is no Arab* *mother who wants her son to die in battle​, just as there is no Jewish mother who wants her* *son to die in war.”* Will there ever be a world without war?

@candiceloyy1967

7 ай бұрын

When the Almighty God Lord Jesus Christ returns

@super1media

7 ай бұрын

@@candiceloyy1967 Yes, the Son of God has been appointed by his Father as King, to soon bring an end to all war and suffering here on earth. At that time the Lord's prayer *'thy Kingdom come'* and *'thy will be done on earth as in heaven'* will have been accomplished. All the prophetic signs he gave his followers while on earth, point to the nearness of that wonderful time.

@jamesfreeman2258

7 ай бұрын

This world will no longer be, a new world will exist by Almighty God, and His Son Jesus will appear in the air, and Jesus will establish His Kingdom on earth. Then there will be no evil, no hate, no stupidity. This will last for 1,000 years. Then Jesus will fight all those who denie Him and evilness itself for the last time. The liar will be thrown along with all nonbelievers into the Lake of fire. Then a new Jerulsalem will come down from heaven, and where once there was a sun, moon, stars the new world, the City of God/Peace will be the place of God himself, Jesus and the Holy Spirit. God will Himself be the Light of the workd, and no longer will evilness be allowed. I have explained but not throughly all the facts leading to a world where there will be no wars, rapes, violence, death etc. This world is full of hate, wars run by males. Until God comes back the Second and final time, males will contunie to justify their evilness.

@behonestwithyourself3718

7 ай бұрын

​@@candiceloyy1967don't hold your breath

@arthurhunt642

7 ай бұрын

I see religion as being one of the biggest, if not the biggest reason for war everywhere in the world today. I'm an atheist and I detest religion of any kind. Trump and the Evangelicals are tearing our country apart. Hitler was Catholic, as well as being insane. Without religion, I think we could all get along better.

Excellent summary of recent history. Most people have no history of their own country, let alone the complex history of the Middle East and the even longer history back into ancient times.

It belongs to whoever has the will to keep it.

Logic: the thief captured your house and kicked you out. After sometime you gather strength and fought back and drove out the thief. Now the magic happens. The thief goes to the police & court against you. The judge says the other to vacate the house and give it to the thief as he was living in the house for a long time and hence it belongs to him. The judge also punished the house owner for fighting back with the thief.

@dishdog215

7 ай бұрын

Bad analogy. Everyone had tbeir own house in this region. Then several families, each with their own homes, formed a "homeowners association". Others did not want it, so they decided to slaughter their neighbors, but got their asses kicked, and were then chased to neighborhoods further away, because all they know is hatred and violence. They are jeolous that the first group lives free and has success, while they still sleep with goats

@APJade

7 ай бұрын

you gotta have bigger gun than the thieves thas the moral of the story

@philliprobinson7724

7 ай бұрын

Hi. Read the Biblical book of Joshua to see who the first RECORDED thieves were. Cheers, P.R.

@phillyphil1513

7 ай бұрын

per the wisemen: "You don't negotiate with a Thief in your house, no (if you're going to negotiate with anyone) you only negotiate with the Undertaker to take the Thief away..."

@monetgity3422

7 ай бұрын

@@philliprobinson7724 my neanderthal ancestor lived somewhere that is currently belong to someone else is not a valid reason to kick them out of their houses

Was waiting for Arab scholars to describe their experience. Wondering why the Arabs were expected to negotiate giving up their land because someone else wanted it. I know I wouldn't give up half my home because someone claimed they wanted it because their book said so.

@chankwaichoi1

7 ай бұрын

they did NOT they were FORCED to very much like how the RED INDIANS in amrica n ABORIGINES in australia were FORCED to give up their LANDs AND got themselves GENOCIDED

@ladytamara1503

7 ай бұрын

That’s because the people negotiating the land knew that it really didn’t belong to the Arabs😂

@aemk6129

7 ай бұрын

And that is why freedom and democracy are so important to protect…

@Frost-uy9me

7 ай бұрын

The Jews are the indigenous people of Palestine the way the blacks are the indigenous people of South Africa! "Who can challenge the rights of the Jews in Palestine? Good Lord, HISTORICALLY IT IS REALLY YOUR COUNTRY..." Yusuf Diya al-Khalidi, Arab Mayor of Jerusalem, 1829. Three facts about Palestine you never know: 1. There has NEVER been an independent state of Palestine, nor an Arab state of Palestine. 2. The name "Palestine" comes from the Romans who renamed "Judea and Samaria" Syria Palestine to punish the Jews for their revolt against the Romans ... before Islam even existed. 3. Palestine Arabs today are not indigenous. They are "ethnic Arabs," and the vast majority of them come to the land with the Islamic conquerors in 634 CE.

@mariamansour8445

7 ай бұрын

@@ladytamara1503 umm? They were the indigenous people of that land. It’s pretty clear and uncomplicated that this land belongs to the Arabs. Whether Christians, muslims or Jews a jewish state was not supposed to exist.

Can i use parts of this video.??

@DavidHoffmanFilmmaker

5 ай бұрын

You cannot without my permission. Email allinaday@aol.com with your request. David Hoffman filmmaker

😢 and years later here we are.😢

It always surprises me that in these documentaries you never get to hear the Arab side of things. Why?

@kelseydion4334

7 ай бұрын

I was thinking this myself and then I realised, western media really doesn’t actually know. I’m from the US, but I’ve lived over here in UAE for ten years, also married to an Arab Muslim. It’s a totally different point of view when you’re looking at the history and sequence of events and NOT just seeing from a western self-interested point of view. Custom, culture, beliefs these are big factors in the decision-making and dynamics. Almost all of that left out in this documentary. It’s very much an outsider point of view and that’s very often wrong. Good catch.

@vhawk1951kl

7 ай бұрын

When you speak of "the Arabs" or " the Arab side" whom exactly do you have in mind? You have not the faintest idea?-No surprises there.

@AynChat

7 ай бұрын

Have you searched the Arab side of the story using another language than English? Speaking from religion perspective, a lot of interesting stuff from both stories of their holy book of Judaism and Islam. Seems that the story branches off somewhere after Abraham settles in Canaan. From Judaism, then famine in Canaan, Israel goes Egypt, and Moses back to Cannan. Then big part of the Israelites were eliminated by the Assyrian Empire except the tribe of Judah (Jacob/Isreal son, grandson of Abraham) which may be the Jews? Then Roman Empire Jews were exiled and somehow Christianity was born around that. So, from a religion pov, Jews can have their god-promised land story. From Islam, it said that there was no child born by Abraham with 1st wife, so the 1st wife got him a 2nd wife. Gave birth to Ishmael and 1st wife was jealous and banished them to desert (according to Judaism), but Islam said that that was not the end of the story. The mom and son travel far south, and when the son suffers from thirst, the mom goes through seven mountains to find water. Here came a miracle, an angel came and made a spring with the heel. And the spring is Zamzam and the mom and son made a small town called Mecca, yep the one Muslim used to go for kaaba. Later Abraham came and built kaaba with this 2nd wife of his. Guest where Arab descent from? Ismael. So, here goes the interesting part. According to Judaism, god's contract with Abraham continues with Isaac. While Islam also claims that god signed a contract with Ismael. So both seem to be self-proclaim rightful owners of this god-promised land. Didn't know if this is true or not might still be far from the story but too much hard work for my lazy ass to internet digging.

Imagine an agency coming to your house and telling you the relatives of the people that lived there 1,800 years ago are not only moving into your house, but that you are being moved to: 1. a small corner in the cellar and 2. a portion in the middle of the attic.

@marilynrigsby6874

7 ай бұрын

Many countries have been through this, including America.. this is what causes Wars !! GREED..

@originalkingalpha5116

7 ай бұрын

...and now a word from The Native American People.🍿

@deeppurple883

7 ай бұрын

I totally agree. We have it in Ireland. I believe most people want it to stay this way. If it's a equal democracy then it has a chance. ✌️☘️

@ID-8491

7 ай бұрын

Imagine being wrong. Your simplistic idea of what happened is based on false premises. Arabs did not own the land. There were no Palestinian Arab country there. Ever. You can't say that Arabs were governing that land because they didn't. Arabs owned some of the land privately. Guess what. They owned less land then Jews. There was a partition and Jews were allowed to have their tiny country too. On the land that has been once called Judea and Samaria. British mandate was composed of Trans-Jordan and Palestine. Arabs got whole Trans-Jordan and majority of Palestine. The "Palestinian nation" was not a thing in 1948. Arabs did not view themselves as such. Look up copies of Arab press from that period if you think that i lie. Day after Israel was proclaimed, armies of 5 Arab countries attacked the Jewish state. 700000 Arabs fled because of the war. Arab League promised them to wipe Israel from the map and to drive Jews into the sea. Arabs lost that war and lost large parts of land too. That's how things works in every part of this planet. See why your statement makes no sense? Ps. Are you are going to tell me that Israeli Jews came from Europe? Would that somehow make them "fake Jews" or something? About half of Jewish population of Israel consists of Mizrahim (and their descendants) who used to live in Arab countries and Iran. They were forced to leave in 1948-1949. Roughly 900000 people expelled by Arabs and Iranians. They never been to Europe.

@SohoJoe202

7 ай бұрын

They’re not the relatives the Ethiopians are

What's with the edit at approx 18:05?

22:11 - this part was very important to today's situation in Israel and Gaza.

For the sake of mankind and future generations to come, every country needs to live peacefully, respect for each other and their religions, no conflicts, hunger for control/power, corruption, revenge and war. With this, a country will be safe, prosperous, strong economy and better living conditions for its citizens. On a side note, I live in a small country consisting of multi-nationalities, racials, cultures, religions, ethnicities, languages and yet we respect each other and live in harmony with our neighbours. We're taught from young at home, in schools, society and communities to do so. We have a church, temple and mosque located within the same district. Our Government always emphasize on fairness, justice and equality for all races and religions.

@jessikapiche6097

7 ай бұрын

That is only as good as there is enough ressources for everyone (and space). Once land become scarse, and ressources too, then, the story start to change and sometimes, very rapidly.

@emilyl1094

7 ай бұрын

@@jessikapiche6097 You're right. Luckily, we're a small island country and we could reclaim land on the sea for more housings and commercial buildings. We have no natural resources so everyone has to be educated/skilled and work hard to help build our nation and economic growth. Hope that this war will end soon or else all the civilians will suffer the most.

@Kathryn-qs1tb

7 ай бұрын

It sounds wonderful.

@emilyl1094

7 ай бұрын

@@Saranu34567 What you are saying will complicate and cause problems within the country. Religion and Believe is a very sensitive subject. I don't know about other countries but for mine, each religion has its own followers. People don't usually speak bad of each other's religion and force or coerce someone to follow/convert into another religion unwillingly. There are also many free thinkers. As I said, we should respect all religions and cultures so as to maintain peace and order within the country.

@boomatie8073

7 ай бұрын

You are absolutely correct, In Our country every creed and race find a place under love and respect to all religions beliefs.🙏✌️✌️

If young folk can’t find something to live for they will find plenty to die for, reminds me of the system in the North of Ireland.

I like this one. Great find

"...A plague on both your houses!..." and on Brittania as well for the duplicity which planted the seeds of this modern obscenity.

Excellent film and footage! Thanks for the documentary, David.

@HOLYLANDBELONGSTOISRAEL-sj5mx

7 ай бұрын

Prophet Mohamed (P.B.U.H.) did not built a Mosque in the Israeli Holy-Land but led prayers on Prophet Solomon's holy floor (P.B.U.H.) in the israa-miiraaj heavenly journey with all prophets behind him for prayers thus honouring lakum deenukum waliya deen terms. Prophet Moses Torah (P.B.U.H.) to co-exist with Prophet Mohamed's Quran (P.B.U.H.). Someone show this message to INTERNATIONAL MUSLIM BODY to honour GLOBAL-PEACE for all. Caliphate Omar did greatest mistake ever to forcefully built a Mosque inside Israeli HOLY-LAND under Torah's faith direction (The Western Wall). Prophet Mohamed (P.B.U.H.) did informed of aamul fitnah where Muslims will furthermore divide into violent-sects which Caliphate Omar has brought disasters into the Israeli Holy-Land. Knowledge without skills are all useless. Prophet Mohamed (P.B.U.H.) did not built a Mosque in the Holy-Land. Caliphate Omar did and ignored lakum deenukum waliya deen to the Torah people of Prophet Moses (P.B.U.H.). Holy Quran is clear on the owners of HOLY-LAND which Allah did written to the Israeli People after crossing the OCEAN from Pharaoh's arrests. Please pass this message to INTERNATIONAL MUSLIM BODIES to fix this ongoing madness in the MUSLIM WORLD.

@lamartinezola8507

7 ай бұрын

Whose land is America, for native Americans or European thieves?

@CrystalHotSauce1

7 ай бұрын

@@lamartinezola8507 big difference there Lamar. Natives are free to travel and buy land as they please. It was fought for. Palestinians are not allowed to leave the Westbank or the Gaza Strip whatsoever, not even to travel to other countries freely unless they escape somehow. They are surrounded by countries that signed the treaty not allowing them to. These people need to be free. They are prisoners on their own land SMH

@jaminova_1969

7 ай бұрын

@@lamartinezola8507 It belongs to the Natives and the European settlers who won the Revolution. And be thankful for the American's who defeated France, Spain, and King George because we are Citizens protected by the US Constitution and Bill of Rights and not subjects!

Thank you so much for this document. And for the contextual description!

@opinion3742

7 ай бұрын

You got to get your propaganda where you can!

@ohman3915

7 ай бұрын

@@opinion3742 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Despite whose it was first, everything, everywhere always belonged to the powerful, who were strong enough to take it away from the weak.

9:37 Dudes got some slick lookin sun glasses...

4:32 The documentary sums it up perfectly at this time stamp. There exist powers that do not want peace who will do anything to prevent it. They would rather un-alive themselves and others rather than compromise due to dogmatic cultural and religious differences. 😢 😞

@Juliet475

7 ай бұрын

Oh, please! Abraham lived approximately 2950 BCE, THE EXODUS, was 1500 BCE. There was NO PALESTINE! THE EXACT area that in called Pallestine was inhabited by the Philostines, that. Were not MUSLIMS. It is theBSame exact area today, while the 12 tribes settled from around Tyre to Edom, mostly around the Red Sea. FROM 1000BCE -925 BCE was known as ISRAEL. THE PHILISTIA STILL LIVED IN THE EXACT SAME AREA. 740BCE -722BCE was under Assyrian Captivity, 597BCE under Babylonian Captivity. The Philistines still lived on the Gaza strip. Jews returned 537BCE. 500-400BCE FIRST APPEARANCE SCYTHIAN PEOPLE. 333 BCE THE GREEKS ARRIVED. 300BCEwas the rise of the Partian Empire east of the PARTHEON EMPIRE THE. BIRTH OF JESUS 6-1 BCE.. 6CE BIRTH of Roman-Judaen Province..Jump to 70 CE Roman destruction of second Temple From 70-385CE Province of Roman Empire, first called Judea, after 135 CE called Palestinia. Then we jump to 689CE and MUHAMMAD. Israel then under Muslim control after. For a great reference read The Four Series books by William M.Thompson D. D. PUBLISHED IN 1882. HE was an English Christian Missionary, and the books are his accounts. I have an original copy of "SOUTHERN PALESTINE and Jerusalem". The Muslim occupation attempted to destroy Judiism and their whole history. Serious study of Muhammad was not suggestive of violence. It was his neice who introduced that. Imagine if ISRAELIS began to occupy MECCA, since it is story relates it was created by Abraham and his son Ishmael, and then rename it and hold it hostage? That would end VERY BADLY. And, it is not the whole MUSLIM population that wants Jihad. Prayers for all our safety in the days to come. New York City is already preparing for threats of Jihad. This is not what followers of Jesus would be doing, yet the broadcasted Islamic call last night in NYC was absolutely a threat to surrender to Islam or be dead

@jen0718

7 ай бұрын

Bingo.

@mrnumba154

7 ай бұрын

Why should outsiders come and just build a state.

@stokedmtb333

7 ай бұрын

@@mrnumba154 I do not pretend to know anything about this particular situation. My comment is an observation of human suffering that results from the inability of people to compromise. There are no winners. This will never end unless people compromise at some level. What I do know is that our western corporations profit greatly from weapons and ammunition sales to BOTH sides. Our media is owned by these corporations and perpetuates the conflict on behalf of monetary gain while hiding the humanitarian crisis this bloodshed creates. It is truly sickening and beyond disgraceful. 😞 Imagine children fighting at a playground while others sell them weapons to destroy one another…all while being told lies…it’s madness.

@Lifelongloser

7 ай бұрын

It’s not that they don’t want peace though is it ? They don’t want peace if it means they don’t get what they want most . I’d be the same. If I believe I am the rightful owner of something very important to me and I have a gun then no one is taking it from me . Americans defend their property with guns why shouldn’t others ? And I’m not taking my morals from other people.

Imagine as John Lennon once said. I don’t quite yet understand politics but Looking at the map there is plenty of land for everyone. If we lived in harmony as God intended surrounding countries could give over to Israel and give Palestinians their freedom and homeland back. A utopia that mankind seems unable to grasp and I fear will destroy me,my family and my school friends 🙏🙏🙏🙏

@robertstone9988

7 ай бұрын

For 10,000 years it's been the same rules no matter where you go on the globe the land belongs to whoever is presently holding it if someone comes and takes it then it's now there's. Every poor person who's had their house snatched by an invading Army at one point was part of the invading Army snatching it from someone before them

@hargisP2

7 ай бұрын

John Lennon was a quack. You fail to realize that God owns the land and Promised it to Israel, no one else. The land is not to be divided. Those that have tried to divide it have had harsh rebukes from God. The Bush family suffered great damage to their property in storms. Clinton’s suffering other problems. And soon God will come and settle the matter once and for all. The Jews will have a part of God’s rule on earth.

@damianketcham

7 ай бұрын

They want the Jews out of the historical Jewish homeland. There were no “Palestinians” per se until Rome called it Palestine to disenfranchise the Jewish people that lived there. Israel has tried to negotiate.

@wintercook2

7 ай бұрын

@@robertstone9988 So true. One of Hitler's greatest inspirations was the US's treatment of Native Americans. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict seems utterly intractable. With the communication, information, and education available today you'd think we could get past the "might makes right" law of the jungle. We are a pugnacious, violent species . Fight first, then think. Blessed are the peacemakers. I don't see how they can manage this one.

@lennychorn147

7 ай бұрын

​@robertstone9988 Very true. But in this particular issue, there are some very important facts missing or glossed over. Prior to WW I, there were more Jews living in the region than Arabs. When the Ottoman empire took control of the region, they renamed the region Palestine, after its biblical name for the region. Palestine was never a nation. Originally, all of Palestine was supposed to be returned to the Jews. That kept getting reduced. The entire crisis and current situation was intentionally orchestrated by the surrounding Arab nations.

Great background and the reason for compromise should not be a so predictably unfortunate