Lets not forget that the age Mcdavid is now, Crosby missed 2 years with concussions. So we never got to see this version of Sid. Yet we still compare them.

@elijahhartle749

Жыл бұрын

Probably would’ve been the best version of Crosby too

Sidney Crosby's jersey number 87, is actually his birthdate. August 7, 1987, or 8/7/87.

Just so ya know, after Seixeiro made that asinine statement about Crosby's deterioration, Crosby went on to immediately Win back-to-back Cups, 2 Conn Smyth (playoff MVP) awards, a Rocket award for most goals, he captained Canada to World Champions including the MVP of the tournament.....someone had some egg on their face.

Edmonton is fast losing its window with McDavid. Crosby has brought home three Stanley cups and gold medals. They are both generational talents but it is a team sport.

Theres a 10 year gap between when crosby came in the league in 2005 and mcdavid in 2015. Both of them are the best players of their generation. Id say McDavid is more of special player because his skating and how fast he thinks the game, there are other players whose skating is similar to mcdavids but the difference is mcdavid is the only one whose feet hands and mind can all work at high speeds.

@dawsonfarrell3950

2 жыл бұрын

There is only one thing that matters. Who has more cups. Crosby. Not to mention 2 olympic golds where he made the Golden Goal in 2010. McDavid is a great player, but crosby has more thinking ability and more prestige.

@hellomotoCoop

2 жыл бұрын

@@dawsonfarrell3950 by that logic maroon > mcdavid. Also the olmpic gold is an even worse point as the nhl hasnt been to the olympics since mcdavid entered the league so its not possible for mcdavid to have it

@dawsonfarrell3950

2 жыл бұрын

@@hellomotoCoop a team award such as the Stanley Cup means more than points or goals...

@hellomotoCoop

2 жыл бұрын

@@dawsonfarrell3950 so 1 of maroons cups is worth more than mcdavids multiple 100 point season?

@dawsonfarrell3950

2 жыл бұрын

@@hellomotoCoop The end goal is the cup. McDavid cannot seem to get his hands on one. Sidney Crosby got one when he was 22 and captained that team aswell. McDavid is 25 and still no cup. You can't argue which one is better. Crosby in his prime is better.

You need to look up the best andrei vaselesvky highlights.best goalie in the league the past 5 years or more.he will easily go down as one of the greatest ever

@wendelsaunders7547

2 жыл бұрын

He's working on that goat status

@jebus2382

2 жыл бұрын

Think they’ll show the 7 goal game

Crosby was McDavids idol growing up. Crosby is 87 bc he was born in 1987, McDavid is 97 bc he was born in 1997

I’m a huge Penguins fan, and Crosby fan. I can tell you that right now at this point in their careers, McDavid is a better player. However, I do believe Crosby is still an extremely elite player in this league. His production has dipped slightly but he has adjusted to play a different style of game. McDavid will go down as one of the best players of all time, just like Crosby will. I don’t think it’s so much about comparing who is better (Similar to Kobe vs Lebron, or MJ) but just appreciating the amount of skill and style both players have that bring people in to become fans.

@davidgoaternak8683

2 жыл бұрын

Respect this opinion as a oiler fan we are both spoiled with great players 🙌

@maximus11400

2 жыл бұрын

Crosby is the best two way player to date.

@chelious1973

2 жыл бұрын

I don’t think McDavid is the better all around player. Crosby definitely is. He is the better 200ft player. If we are talking about both in there primes? Well that is different. Crosby used to be just like McDavid before he got older and changed his game. There ppg at the same age was almost the exact same. 1.42 to 1.4.

@guymajor7103

2 жыл бұрын

@@chelious1973 I agree with that Crosby has sacrificed points to be so sound defensively!

Crosby has been so dominant in different facets of the game. He's honed his craft and is considered elite or near the top in so many different asepcts of the game. The mohawk turns, backhand shot, deflections, puck protection, passing, hockey IQ, strong shot, and he's got an insance work ethic that helped him get great at these things. I want to see where McDavid is at as he gets closer to 30. I don't think his ability to generate off the cycle and in dirty areas is as good as Crosby. Generating off the rush, sure, McDavid wins, but Crosby was also dangerous in that capacity as a young buck. I just think that today's players are getting faster and faster that McDavid's greatest asset won't hold up long into his 30s. Crosby is still the same killer robot going on 35 years old.

@guymajor7103

2 жыл бұрын

Agree Crosby can score a thousand different ways and he still a very relevant player !

@rippy3846

2 жыл бұрын

So true

@tombarr949

2 ай бұрын

Fun fact: Guess who is the all time leader in short handed goals with 73 and who has 4 shorthanded goals. I will give you a clue, their numbers are 99 and 87. The point being is the Great Ones kill penalties. Another fun fact for those who think past the narrative, 87 is featured in the "Conn Smythe Shift" video...as the primary victim. The Kid was dusting snow off his pants more than once during a 5 on 3. He wasn't better than the generation that included 40, 5, 55, and 30 on that shift.

@zachw4027

2 ай бұрын

@@tombarr949 The expendable foot soldiers kill penalties these days. Guys you can afford to lose due to blocking a shot, not your stars . Much easier to put Gretzky out on the PK in an era where stick technology was limited, and he could outskate 95% of the league. Now, even the weakest shooters can hit 80 mph with ease on their shots, and the worst skaters in this era would keep pace with Gretzky given the benefit of an extra man on their side. What happened to 40, 5, 55 and 30 one year later though? Aw man, they got the upperhand on a 20 year old kid, and then got beat by him a year later... and never got back to the finals again.

@tombarr949

2 ай бұрын

@@zachw4027 Expandable foot soldier like Gretzky, Reinhart, Marchand, Aho, Benn, and that expendable McDavid kid? PK is largely hockey IQ including anticipating where the puck is going. Gretzky was well known for being a few steps ahead. Also consider that the top hockey talent was concentrated amongst 21 teams in Gretzky's day. Gretzky would do just as well in this era as he would have strength and conditioning coaches, nutrition, medical and other things the modern skater does. Detroit should have won 2009 but all the leagues favoritism toward Pittsburgh was solidifying as the fat flightless ones had 4 top 2 picks and a number 5 while Detroit had picks 171, 210 and 257 on their top lines. High picks like 5 and 30 were not top 50 picks. Please go watch "The Conn Smythe Shift" and tell me how great 87 is at 5 on 3 and picking his panties off the ice. Also let me know who has more class...by far...40 or 87.

In hockey it's called stick handling.

Check out “Battle of Alberta”, Edmonton Oilers vs Calgary Flames, it’s pretty much like Lakers vs Celtics back in the day. One of the greatest rivalries to watch.

Mcdavid is the most dynamic offensive player, while Crosby is the most complete player in the day today. Crosby is top 5 all time, mcdavid has to win some cups before he can be in the convo

You were so close… the handling with the stick, that’s what we call stick handling lol.

A must see is Sidney Crosby edgework. It's crazy the amount of skating ability that he has and that video will showcase it

Yo! Just got your channel recommended a few hours ago and I’m hooked! I’ve been a hockey fan for life and so seeing someone new to the game react to hits and goals and saves, especially hilarious reactions like yours, has got me rolling with laughter 😂😂 If I may, I think your reactions to one or two, or all, of these: worst fails, dumb moments, bad injuries, would be super entertaining! Keep up the grind 🤩🤩👍

@alanrogers2957

2 жыл бұрын

I’ve been binging his videos too 😂

Crosby’s career is winding down and McDavid is only about halfway through but if you watch the games you’ll notice Crosby’s got tremendous skills that will breakthrough at certain moments during the game but I’ve never seen anything like the way McDavid completely controls the game it looks like he always has the puck on his stick. For reference the average top line All-Star player will have the puck on their stick a total of about 30 seconds in the entire game, with McDavid I’m not sure the exact number but it’s gotta be different it just seems like he always has it. I grew up as a huge Crosby fan tried to play like him when I was out on the ice but McDavid is taking the game to a whole new level ,his skills are so ridiculous it doesn’t even make sense how he moves out there

@luvdvno

2 жыл бұрын

They dont call hi mcjesus for nothing. He s the most alien like human there is in the league. Period.

@mysh8988

2 жыл бұрын

I totally agree with this whole statement like every word you said was true

@zachbrown210

2 жыл бұрын

You also have to take Crosby's backchecking and defense into consideration. He's one of the best defenders in the league. I don't know if I've ever seen him do something blatantly obvious bad defensively. He seems always be grinding and it's also crazy that he runs that team. If he doesn't play the team doesn't win

@zachbrown210

2 жыл бұрын

I guess right now I'd take McDavid bit if it was the same years drafted I'd take Crosby. 3 Stanley cups and enough trophys to fill a house

@sz7313

2 жыл бұрын

Crosby is a more complete player, still. He's lost half a step in terms of speed, but he is so smart, and such a hard worker in both ends of the ice. But yes...McDavid is the second most purely skilled player ever, in my opinion. Mario Lemieux was something to behold when he was healthy. If he had been healthy for his whole career, he would have numbers approaching--if not exceeding--Gretzky.

Connor came about a decade after

@yojustmatt

2 жыл бұрын

Gotcha

@jaydengroom7798

2 жыл бұрын

@@yojustmattYou are also correct when calling it handling. It's just stick handling and puck control.

They are so utterly different, they really arent comparable.

@gordanblansky7137

2 жыл бұрын

Bro what?

Love the channel so far!

Bro I’m loving this content

It depends what you mean by "better". On any given night, both players are capable of doing great things. At this point in their careers, Crosby is in his mid 30's so of course McDavid is a better purely offensive player being 10 years younger. However when it comes to many other aspects of the game, Conor still isn't there....and maybe never will. Defensively, puck protection, grinding down below the goal line...and most importantly - leadership. Sid has led his team to multiple cups, not to mention Gold medal...whereas McDavid hasn't shown the ability to inspire his team to higher levels.

@elijahhartle749

Жыл бұрын

Crosby doesn’t have a single weakness in his game

The Stanley cup finals began last night. The Colorado Avalanche vs Tampa Bay Lightning. Colorado won the first game of the best of seven. 4-3 in overtime. Even playoff hockey moves fast. You might want to watch the first period of game two and see what you think.

@AzaliFinrandi

2 жыл бұрын

Great game too

love your nhl videos💪🏼💪🏼

@yojustmatt

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you bro, I appreciate that💯

When someone's good at handling the puck, they got silky hands or dirty stickwork. Also I just love to watch when McDavid/other guys show off they edgework skills.

Btw the penguins won the Stanley cup that year that analyst was talking about crosby and how “he isn’t good anymore”

@AzaliFinrandi

2 жыл бұрын

Love how Crosby lives rent free in people's heads even to this day though.

Good video ! You should watch part 2, it’s a lot better

crosby has been playing since 2005 but is still rly good meanwhile mcdavid has been playing since 2015 and is easily the best player right now and will be one of the best ever

One thing that has to be considered is that Crosby was one of 4 top 2 picks the Penguins received in four straight years including the second winningest goalie of all time (and still counting) and there was a 5th before that four year strech. Crosby played on a loaded team and scored a lot from cherry picking at the back post.

react to cale makar, hes 2nd best player in league behind mcdavid but hes a defensemen and only 23, hes in stanley cup finals right now and hes the front runner for playoffs mvp too

@Tanmoy49

2 жыл бұрын

Idk about second best, but definitely top 3. I think I’d still rank McDavid and Matthews above Makar, but it’s definitely close.

Ultimately the question will come down to the future, and we will have to wait to see.....Can McDavid match the decorated career of Crosby? Again, we will wait to see. He certainly has the potential to do so. An important factor for McDavid will also be his General Manager and Coach. Can they put together a great team around him, like the Penguins did for Syd? Can the coach get the best out of their players? I hope so....Would be fun to watch, just as it was watching Crosby.

As a penguins fan, i do believe that Crosby was the best player of his time from about 07-19. But, now McDavid has taken that spot. I grew up in the crosby/ovechkin era but its just that the game of hockey is evolving and so are the players. Yes, Crosby was the best for about a decade and a half but Crosby is getting older and closer to his careers end and McDavid is in his prime, probably not even yet. I have no doubt that once Mcdavid gets closer to the end of his career, there could be another player whos actually better than him, for example, right now in the 2023 draft there is this kid named 'Bedard' and right now as far as i know hes being considered one of the more exciting prospects in recent history. I still believe that Crosby is still one of the best players in Current NHL and in NHLs history and i also believe that Mcdavid for sure will be too... he pretty much already is.

@vedantbhalla2571

2 жыл бұрын

I think that for a time, Ovechkin was better than Crosby, but Crosby is just more consistent

@MACK0142

2 жыл бұрын

@@vedantbhalla2571 Ovi has by far, been not only the greatest scorer of his time but possibly ever. But, overall I see Crosby as the best of their era. And actually, Ovi has been the most consistent, as his body and motor are unparalleled. He has rarely missed any time in his long career due to injury. On-the-other-hand, Crosby missed the majority of his peak playing years with Concussions, so For Sid to have produced at such a higher rate AND to have won as much as he has, I think gives him the edge. Though, in the end, I still think Ovechkin will be the single greatest scorer in NHL history.

@vedantbhalla2571

2 жыл бұрын

@@MACK0142 That’s a fair point, I just saw Ovi as a guy who was just above average (referring to his point totals, not goals) for several years, before returning to his stardom. Crosby’s been pretty amazing his entire career. But he’s most likely gonna go down as the best goal scorer in history

You got to watch trevor zegras, he is just insane

Mcdavid is great but til hes a 3x stanley cup champion and got a olympic gold medal winning goal in overtime i still got crosby as the 2nd greatest canadian hockey player

@AzaliFinrandi

2 жыл бұрын

Amen to that

The guy that said crosby isn’t elite is the skip bayless of hockey

If were putting this into basketball terms, I would say Crosby would be MJ, He has 3 cups which is a lot for the nhl. McDavid would be Kobe, basically a younger image of Crosby just faster, has all the same skills and in the regular season is the best player the last few years by a longshot but hasn't proven himself in the playoffs. I would also throw Ovechkin in there as Shaq, could compete for mvp every year in his prime, most dominate goal scorer and has a huge physical prescience on the ice. All 3 could be considered top 5 of all time on the NHL depending on who your talking too. I would say gretzky would be comparable to kareem, most dominant player of his time and has records that will most likely never be touched.

Definitely watch NHL the most electrifying playoffs goals. Any part is amazing

Scf is a 7 game series

That last goal on crosby highlights was mcdavid lol

You NEED to watch an Alex Ovechkin Vs Sidney Crosby video, that’s the best person Vs person rivalry in hockey history, or just watch an ovechkin video, he’s the greatest goal scorer in history.

Crosby came into the league much earlier and has been no question the best player for the last 15 years, Mcdavid is probably one of if not the most skilled player of all time, comparing careers the level of winning crosby has had will most likley be more than mcdavid ever reaches (unless mike smith goes), but what speaks volumes for me is the question of asking would you rather have crosbys last 3 years of his career for mcdavids last 12 or however many so really settles the debate for me. Crosbys on a whole nother level as of now

"the handling" = stick handling the moves = "dangles" I enjoy the vids. Carry on!

NHL Finals are going on. game 3 tonight. you should definitely just check out a period foe yourself live. good vids man!

Hey Matt i like the hockey videos you make they send Great. I wanted to let you know hockey playoffs and basketball playoffs are similar they both do best of 7 series

The Stanley Cup finals are a series, yes. A best of 7 series. Game 2 is tomorrow. Colorado vs. Tampa.

Crosby still has it. sure, he may not be as fast, but he mis still putting up numbers and is tied with ovi for points all time. Crosby is still a force to be wrecken with.

to answer your question at the end about the Stanley Cup, yes the SCF is a series just like the NBA Finals, best of 7 series! but if you think McDavid is a godly skater combined with the way he handles the puck, you should react to Cale Makar...defenseman for the Colorado Avalanche (in the Stanley Cup Finals currently!). Makar is bar none the best skater in the league and he's even younger than McDavid! Always enjoy your hockey videos!!

@AzaliFinrandi

2 жыл бұрын

All hail Cale!!

There is a lot more amazing players to react to but you sould definitely react to these players: Nathan McKinnon, Nikita Kucherov, Cale makar is a really good player but he hasn’t been playing for a while so there might not be many plays, Patrick Kane, YOU NEED TO REACT TO TREVOR ZEGRAS YOU WILL ABSOLUTELY POOP YOUR PANTS WITH WHAT HE DOES!!!!!! And Andrei Vasilevskiy is a goalie but he has amazing saves he’s problably the best goalie in the league and Carey price is a great goalie.

@User-e9k

2 жыл бұрын

Next video gotta be reacting to Trevor Vegas I won’t spoile it but he does this one play you would never imagine what a PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!

I like both players because their Canadian hockey players but I have to cheer on Connor McDavid more cause I'm from Edmonton

Crosby was ends to use effort to make plays where am David uses speed and skill to get leverage or just blast by

I have to say, McDavid is so skilled. Offensively, he's the best rn hands down, and I'm a Pens fan. But man wind Sid up and watch him go to town in the defensive zone. I've never seen a forward (other than Bergeron) show that much skill in the defensive end.

The Sid vs Ovechkin narrative is way more interesting than the Sid vs Connor one. half of Sid’s career was in a different era. but Connor created the new era.

I think McDavid is up there with Mario for the most talented hockey player ever. the things Connor does is just insane, and I'd probably say prime for prime Connor edges Crosby out by just a little when it comes to offensive skill set, and connor will probably end his career with more points than when Sid ends his... But imo at the end of both there careers, sid will be a greater player. he is just a serial winner and hockeys greatest winner of all time, not to mention his defensive skill set, which is leaps and bounds above Mcdavids, and how much of a leader and team player sid is. To me it's clear Sid will be greater than McDavid, but it's all opinions, we'll have to see once both there skates are hanging up

Just wanted to also comment how much I appreciate these reactions to hockey but especially McDavid, because take it from me, a person who’s also a complete sports nerd(I Watch 100 hockey games a year about 60 to 70 basketball games, a dozen football game, MLB playoffs and a bit of a Fairweather soccer fan,I’ve also played hockey and basketball my entire life love both sports hockey slightly my number one but I really do love basketball) McDavid is the number one athlete in the world right now and it’s completely getting slept on by mainstream media outside of Canada, The last time a professional sports athlete separated themselves from the number two like mcdavid has would probably be Tiger Woods if you consider golfa sport(I don’t I see it as tremendously skilled but not a sport). , Certainly the last time a top team sport athlete. Has separated themselves from the competition the way McDavid has was probably prime Michael Jordan. LeBron’s great but you always felt like except for a few years of his career there were always a few guys in a league that could challenge him for MVP any given year,That’s not the case for McDavid. Crosby’s career is nearly done and McDavid already has twice as many scoring titles. I don’t see anyone in MLB or American football that’s dominant on the level of McDavid I think you could argue Giannis in basketball is maybe on that level but trust me he’s not the cerebral athlete McDavid is. (Btw I love Giannis,Will always root for him and think that what he’s doing for sports in general is absolutely great staying in a small market and showing up-and-coming superstars that there’s more legacy to be had if you win in a small market, then building superteams and piling on luxury cities, I do hope some of this mentality will rub off on other superstars across sports like McDavid when it comes time to potentially resign) I saw Hockeys popularity take noticeable spike around 2006 when the last generational talent Crosby and Ovechkin were drafted in the league, it pains me to say it as an Oilers fan but the truth is if McDavid played for any American team hockey would take a quantum leap in popularity in the states just cause he really is that dude he’s so entertaining/dominant. The only reason McDavid isn’t getting credit as at least in the argument for a top three athlete in the world right now is because 1. Hockeys less popular to begin with, and 2. He plays in small market Edmonton, where even the Canadian media wants to ignore us. There’s one goal of McDavid you reacted to but I’d like to add a bit of context to it was a breakaway goal against the flames where he picks up the park from a standstill In his own end and just accelerates all the way down the ice by the time he hits the halfway point of the ice he’s clocked out going 38.5 km per hr, So basically 10 km above the speed limit in a school zone, unless you’re counting NASCAR or Formula One no athlete has ever performed their sport at the speed that he is it’s really incredible, I know it’s on skates but the guys going significantly faster than prime Usain bolts top speed

@nostressnostress9367

2 жыл бұрын

Significantly faster than prime. Usain bolts top speed but it’s really like if you would imagine a competition where you were to say here Usain Bolt you’re gonna do your hundred metre dash but you’re gonna have to perfectly control a ball dribbling or a hockey stick and ball and cross them over at top speed by the way when you get to that hurdle maintain complete control don’t look at the ball while going that incredible speed, That’s really what’s so impressive About what McDavid’s doing he’s in complete control breaking ankles while going 10 km over the speed limit in a school zone

I respect both but crosby is still the best well rounded player his puck protection to his edgework to his deflections and tips and his general knowledge and iq and even defense. Where you see mcdavid his skill is crashing the net with speed and drawing the goalie too far in his net i agree mcdavid is talented without a doubt but if we are talking about the well roundedness of a player its crosby without a doubt.

3:10 it is called handling! Stick handling and puck control

crosby is better all time and still plays amazing today even for his age. Mc david owns the league right now and he's been better for the past couple years. But crosby has dominated and played well for all of his career and he's owned the league along with ovenchkin for a decade and he's multiple rings. Crosby is definitely better no question but Mcdavid is a up and coming player who could maybe take that spot

Do the part 2 Matt

drafted 10 years apart. the game has changed a lot since crosby was drafted compared to when mcdavid was drafted

Id take McDavid (at his height) to win a scoring title. Id take Crosby (at his height) to win a championship. I think McDavid is the better pure offensive force and Crosby is the better all around 200ft hockey player.

Go back a ways and check out Pavel Bure " the Russian Rocket". He was insane and played when defenses could grab and hold. If he was in his prime now. Man it would be like AI out there

Crosby is like the LeBron of hockey, if it's game 7 and you can pick anyone to be on your team most people would pick crosby

The next must react to players are Nathan MacKinnon, Cale Makar, Connor Bedard and Trevor Zegras. MacKinnon is undoubtedly a top 4 player right now behind only McDavid, Matthews and Makar. He’s probably the fastest player in the league when he gets the puck. Watch his top 10 career highlights and then look up his goal vs St. Louis this year because it’s too recent to be on his highlights but is probably his best goal ever. Cale Makar is only 23 and is already the best defenceman in the league. He’s basically the McDavid of defence it’s insane. MacKinnon and Makar are both on the same team right now and currently have a 1-0 series lead in the Stanley Cup Finals. Makar has the potential to be the best defenceman ever. Connor Bedard is the next up and coming generational player. Every 10 ish years there’s a prospect that starts to gain attention from like 10 years old and up. The last two were Crosby and McDavid. Bedard is still only 16 and is too young to get drafted yet. Trevor Zegras might have the best puck skills in the league. He was just a rookie this year but his highlights will make you laugh with what he can do with the puck. He’s not on the same level as the other guys and likely never will be he just has insane puck skills.

as far as offense goes mcdavid has the edge, but crosby’s 200ft game is unmatched and his pure strength is hard to beat

Yup Crosby has been around long time, but he’s also done a lot, has a few rings already, gonna go down as one of the greats. McDavid is just half way, hasn’t been blessed with the greatest head office to build a good team around him like Pittsburgh did for Crosby.

McDavid is younger and faster but Sid is amazing. Sid has 3 Stanley Cups, 2 Gold medals in hockey, 2 World Cups. McDavid has yet to win any of those. Sid is more of a playmaker than McDavid. He’s great at possession and passing where as McDavid’s speed is his weapon. You just shouldn’t underestimate Sid. He can do it all.

Replying late, but Crosby is 36 now and is having one of his best years, even if the team isn’t. He has more goals this year than McDavid (although fewer assists) and he even got a hat trick.

Playoffs is exactly like basketball finals

Look at some stars for the future bro! Thomas Hertl, Juraj Slafkovsky, and Andrej Svechnikov ( though he is allready a bit older)

Perfect current NBA/NHL player comparisons would be: Sidney Crosby-Lebron (undoubtedly the goats of their generation, mid 30’s and still dominating) Ovechkin-Steph Curry (greatest shooters/scorers of all time) Mcdavid-Giannis (young with tons of potential, already the best in the league)

The nhl playoffs are exactly like the nba playoffs. Four seven game series.

he tried to say as a canadian we cant hate cosbly. im canadian i never liked him but i know how great he is, and mcdavid is candian too. i was alway an ovechin fan

Crosby is a top 5 player of all time , McDavid might be better offensively but there’s levels to this and Crosby is on another level

I would also say crosby

McDavid passed Crosby as the best all-around scoring forward the last couple years, similar to Auston Matthews passing Ovechkin as the greatest goal scorer in the game currently

Crosby has been in the league since 2005 and is coming into his last years in the NHL. McDavid has been in since 2015 and still has a long career left.

Both amazing players but Crosby is like the Jordon of hockey and he is better in my opinion

You should react to Tom Wilson biggest hits.

You should do NHL broken bones

Please react to Matthew Tkachuk. He is a sneaky rat with his hits and a great player. you will really enjoy his between the legs goals

There is a 10 year gap from 2005 ti 2015 when mcdavid got drafted

Crosby is Kobe and Mcdavid is Lebron. Crosby has been clutch his whole career. Scored the Gold Medal OT winner. But McDavid is something we have never seen, but Unproven so far.

I would say crosby

Man react to Marcus Blakely highlights he's an import San mig coffee mixers..I'm sure you'll stand on your chair.

Two different eras of players.

Been a Penguins fan for a while and will admit Crosby struggles at times for sure!!!! but when he's on he is on!

Crosby #87 born in 1987 McDavid #97 born 1997. Overall talent both off the charts. Crosby yes past his prime. Speed goes to McDavid but hockey IQ to Crosby. Team play also to Crosby. Both in prime? MVP to Crosby…he’ll bring the cup. As of yet McDavid no cup. Crosby sees the whole ice, knows where everyone is. Both awesome so the debate will go on.

Crosby is a top 5 player all time, Mcdavid is the best player in the world head and shoulders over everybody. Crosby came into the league in 2005 and Mcdavid came into the league in 2015

McDavid is in his prime and Crosby is probably a couple of years from retiring. I don’t find the comparison even fair this far into Crosby’s career. And you know what Crosby has done that McDavid has proven (so far) he can’t do? Lead your team to Lord Stanley’s cup. - a Rangers fan.

OK great. Now you need to react to CALE MAKAR. The best defenseman in the league. He is like Mcdavid, but playing defense. His team ( Colorado) lead 2-0 the stanley cup final mainly because of him. The dude is a modern day "Bobby Orr". ( Orr is consider to be the best defenseman of all time. )

every round is a best of 7. 16 teams.

Look simple, we had Gretzky/Lemieux which compares to the MJ Status then we had Crosby/Ovechkin which compares to Lebron Status and right now we have Mcdavid/Matthews which are futur hall of famer. So basically McDavid is like the new crosby and then Crosby was the new gretzky if that makes sense

Crosby excells at to many intangiables, He's a leader, He is a winner, He's down in the Dirt when the Game gets Rough, He is more of a magician with the Puck. McDavid could maybe EVENTUALLY be as good on a career basis but I have to say ( at equvilent ages ? ) Sid Crosby hands down.

watch the video "Montreal Canadiens | Road to the 2021 Stanley Cup Final" or highlight (recent video) "Carey Price's Saves"

Crosby is the lebron of the NHL without the cup losses

You got handling right lol it's called stickhandling

You'll love Pavel Datsyuk

Watch Crosby vs ovechkin the end of an era

the NHLs "messi vs ronaldo" would be Ovechkin and Crosby time of who was better.

Pls react to pavel bure his highlights are crazy

Crosby is a top 5 all time, McDavid will be in that conversation, too.