Feel free to discuss who you believe the guard is. Just keep it civil. This topic can get pretty heated on both sides are I’d prefer if it didn’t get so heated here. Also I’m just noticing this now but for some of this I say stuff like “I don’t see that in this way” which isn’t really that fair or a good argument. So basically what I mean what I say that is “it’s a possibility but I’m not to sure about it” hopefully that makes sense Update: I believe Hudson is the protagonist now Stuff I missed (will be added on to) - another Henry debunk. Orville’s line “No matter how many times *they* burn us”. If The Fright Guard did burn the place down then Henry cannot be the guard as he already burned William in FNaF 6. They implies more than 1 person (in this context) - another piece of evidence for Hudson. Scott said that frights would fill in blanks from the past, the FNaF 3 protagonist might be one of these blanks - Hudson accidentally killed his mother, not step father

@quillllly

4 ай бұрын

I think I always figured "they" was referring to Henry and Michael, because while Mike didn't actually burn down the building, he did seem at least complicit in it. It's a bit of a stretch, but so is using one neutral pronoun as proof of a theory...although really I'm just in denial because I like Henry being the guard -_- realistically it probably is Mike heh.

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

Really good counter argument

@ttr2583

4 ай бұрын

"They" can also just be a general statement. It's possible TOYSNHK just doesn't know *who* burned Fazbear's Fright. "No matter how many times he burns us" kinda draws attention to the wrong places too

@sebastianszyrwinski9325

4 ай бұрын

​@@zetorocks811You are wrong in your theory, more than once 1 SammyCEO makes no sense and Sammy doesn't exist in gi continuity 2 Stage 01 is Freddy's, not Fredbears, because Stage 01 has the same clouds as Freddy's from 1, which was the original Freddy's in 1985, when MCI was committed. 3 Hudson makes no sense, there are no Phantoms in history other than Cjica Springtrap is already in Fazbears Fright from the beginning, which contradicts the games where Springtrap was only found before 2 night. It also doesn't make much sense for it to be anyone other than Mike. 4 Cassie's father doesn't have to be and probably isn't Jeremy Fitzgerald, there's nothing much in common between these two characters.

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

@sebastianszyrwinski9325 okay

"Also, Henry being the guard kind of goes against his character arc of doing nothing for years, then trying to fix everything after being inactive for so long" I disagree, in fact I think that's why Henry being the guard actually works decently well. If Henry is the FNaF 3 protagonist I think the implication is that he didn't really know about the animatronics being haunted or anything, and that seeing his old business partner walking around as a corpse inside a bunny suit is what made him start to look into stuff. I think this works really well assuming that FNaF 3 happens shortly before FFPS. The biggest problem I have with Henry being the guard is like, why in a million years would he want to work at a horror attraction based around his franchise where a bunch of children, including his own daughter, were killed. That aside though I do personally think Henry is the guard, but I also haven't finished the video yet :p so maybe my opinion will change in the next 20 minutes >:3 P.S. What's wrong with MoltenMCI :(

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

MoltenMCI is a good idea it was just handled poorly. I actually like it I just think the way it was told could have been handled A LOT better.

@novustalks7525

4 ай бұрын

The whole reason Henry did a second fire is because his first failed

@GermanFFreddy

4 ай бұрын

There s nothing wrong with MoltenMCI, it works, it fills in the blanks, there is proof in FFPS, HW1, and it has some merit in TFC. personally I believe it, if you do great, if not, to each their own.

@quillllly

4 ай бұрын

@@novustalks7525 Yeah! I think the FNaF 3 fire was kind of a panic reaction. He had more time to plan and make sure nobody escaped in FFPS since he was past the initial shock and panic of seeing springtrap for the first time.

@donkeykong6426

4 ай бұрын

what does MCI mean??

I'm a bit sceptical. we still don't know 100% in which year FNAF-3 takes place. since phone dude calls phone guy's tapes "prehistoric" it's safe to assume that quite some years have passed. they treat the events from FNAF-1 and FNAF-2 almost like legends from "once upon a time".

I think it’s Michael because the phantoms are based on FNAF 2 minus Chica, she’s based on FNAF 1. I also agree that Michael is Fritz Smith and Mike Schmidt because of the odor and tampering with the animatronics. but I think Henry is the the guy that told Phone Dude about the safe room in one of the locations. I do agree that Hudson is phone dude. But my theory is Hudson didn’t have a bad life with his father and was a fan of Freddy’s and wanted to bring the thrill back to everyone as a horror attraction and get everything they need to make it horrifying but his journey ended shortly by William/Spring Trap.

Hudson could be Mike's pseudonym for FNAF 3.

I think it's either Mike or Hudson, all of the other theories don't hold much weight imo

I definitely think Jeremy is tape dude from fnaf 3 and got Michael the job which is why he has a friend like demeanor when talking to Mike if he was the fnaf 3 protag

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

Yes I like that, is a fan of Freddy’s after all

11:18 The sprits are there (in part) the suits are in FF they're hanted objects Or MoltenMCI alter S with Golden Freddy attaching to Springtrap like Andrew did being how theyre there in FNaF 3

Great video, I really like how you put forward evidence and its implications.

I believe the Frights Fiction theory, where the Frights books are in-universe books made by Fazbear Entertainment. Similar to Goosebumps, some of the stories are just horror shorts while others are based on how people in the universe interpret FNAF lore and real life events. In that sense, Hudson and What We Found would be their interpretation and or coverup of what actually happened in FNAF 3

Great video, make more long form content like this if you are able and willing to. It will bring more attention to your channel and I think you deserve more. I can see you being big like rye toast, ozone, ids fantasy, etc. keep up the good work🎉

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

That’s the plan. With the shorts on the side to bring attention to the longer form content 🙏🙏🙏

How can Jeremy Fitzgerald be Cassie’s dad? He’s 99.9% the bite of 87 victim as phone guy tells him to be near the animatronics during his dayshift, the animatronics are fine around the kids so the victim has to be an adult. When a human gets their frontal lobe bitten off, they are in a vegetive state, are unable to solve problems or tasks, and have a massive reduction in creativity. Cassie’s dad is shown to be very capable of solving tasks in help wanted 2 and can move therefore he can’t be Jeremy Fitzgerald. Jeremy is most likely dead at that point in time. Anyway, nice vid dude, I agree that Mike is the frightguard too.

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

Well I think he is because Cassie’s dad is heavily implied to be the Bonnie bully from FNaF 4 and the child who possesses Bonnie is named Jeremy. So basically there could be a connection there. Furthermore there are actually 2 frontal lobes. The right one is responsible for actual movement and while the left is for speech. If he lost he’s left he should still be able to get around I think. Also in HW 2 memories play a huge role in the story and there is a trophy called “Remember Jeremy”. If Jermey had memory loss problems after the bite this trophy could be saying “do you remember, Jermey?” and not what most people think it means which is “do you remember that guy Jermey”. I also believe he is the same Jermey from HW1 and he returned to the Pizzaplex because he wanted to stop Glitchtrap. A lot of people think that Jermey killed himself but I disagree. I think that Halloween mask Tape Girl talked about that a lot of people think was literally his face was a Vanni mask. This is why throughout the HW2 the characters ask us what makes us so special, basically what made us so special we could escape Glitchtrap’s control. Now him being HW 1 Jeremy does explain the Bonnie and Jermey connection without him being FNaF 2 Jermey but I still think it’s a possibility So basically he might not be FNaF 2 Jermey but I do think he is HW1 Jermey 100%

I actually think there's an argument to be made with What We Found being an explanation for the phantoms. Obviously, Dittophobia does a very similar thing with the nightmares, who are also hallucinations and even stories that are game-tangential like The Man in room 1280 and GGY consist of new protagonists even if they're interacting with characters we know of, typically to give us a different perspective. And a new protagonist, in particular who contrasts the original one in FNAF 3, is particularly good for this story. Hudson has a lot of trauma even by horror protagonist standards and outside of the fire thing, it causes the phantoms to appear and act differently from the game showing that they're tailored to the person, however they're linked to springtrap in some way. This can then be used to work out our protagonist in the game itself as well as stopping the story from retreading too much old ground.

Sorry if this is a little disjointed, I'm writing this quickly at work. One other thing that I use as evidence as Mike being the protagonist of 3, is a quote from the big theory livestream after FNAF 4. That big one where Matt Pat and a few other theorists came together and Scott kept on putting hints and stuff on his webpage. Well one of them was "4 games, 1 story" and I personally see that as confirmation that you play as the same person in all the games (with the exception of 6 out of the 7 nights in 2)

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

The with that though is that the games are still one story even if we play as someone else in each game. It’s still about the missing children and William

I think that Mike and William wouldn't recognize each other because William is springtrap now, and Michael is a walking purple skin suit. I've always thought that William and Mike were on the same side and they just don't recognize each other with Michael probably thinks that springtrap is just another animatronic and William thinks Michael is just another person, they don't recognize each other

Its mike because fnaf wasnt supposed to make it past three and all of the previous guards were retconned to being mike after 4

@Nicholas-vm6mh

4 ай бұрын

Exactly

Actually, in FNAF AR, we know who exactly the protagonist is. The protagonist of it is the player themselves, like if I play it, then I would be the protagonist, or if you did, you would be

Fire Video

We see Withered Foxy’s arm in the parts box, maybe the rest of him is just in there Also the “personal” thing is from a gameplay perspective, not a lore thing. Also also, I wouldn’t consider Scott’s perspective for What We Found because he didn’t write it. Andrea Waggener wrote it, she usually writes a lot of the important short stories.

2:48 now, this isn't a hate comment. I love this video and it's really good. It's just that, if most of the evidence for this character being the fnaf 3 guard is coming from the assumption that he's cassie's dad, then the theory doesn't stand well on it's own. If this theory was true (which i think it is) it would be good. but from what we actually SEE in the games, there's not enough concrete evidence for this connection. (again, this isn't hate, i love this video)

Hey so just putting my 2 cents in quickly (note this is with my bare bone knowledge of the games and 0 knowledge of books and lore or watching the video so take it as a grain of salt) I'd find it find weird that if the FNAF 3 security guard is mike especially POST scooping, now if what I think happened to him in the scooping room is.. what that happened then I find it weird he experiences phantoms and especially issues with oxygen and breathing if the in-game mechanics are to be taken literal. If he is a walking corpse that has no organs left or still a walking corpse, why would ventilation be such a issue?

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

He sighs in his monologue in Sister Location so he can still breathe. Also it’s implied that he heals after a while

Personally I don't think Michael is Fritz because I think he likely would have been a bit too young at the time it's possible but you could argue that since the Phantoms at least a few of them are the withered animatronics it's possible that Mike saw them when they were operating back at the original Freddy's

In my honest opinion, Mike being the fight guard makes the most sense to me. Mostly, because of the phantoms and he would have actually lasted all of the six nights. For Hudson though, I see him as a parallel to Mike from FNAF 3. Although, I can see the idea that at first Hudson was the guard then mike took his spot because, Springtrap is a new person from Hudson perspective and is trying to kill him. Also, I could be wrong since, I don’t own any of the Freddy file but, aren’t they wrong about some stuff? (Probably not as badly as the encyclopedia)

I think FrightGuard is Mike because I always look at it from a FNAF 1-4 perspective. Bach then, even if we didn't realized it, we could've solved that FoxyBro is Mike Schmidt. So since he was the only main character that we were aware of at that time(because the other 2 guards didn't have a backstory unlike Mr. Schmidt, not to mention the possibility that he could actually be one of them), it would make more sense if Mike was the one we were playing as in FNAF 3 rather than a random guy. It would also complete his character arc because he redeemed himself by freeing the spirits when he played those minigames(or at least that's what I think the role of those is in order to get the good ending).

I think frightsguard is most likely Michael. The security logbook most likely occurs during frights given that its pages clearly show the fnaf3 office. I don’t believe the fnaf3 office is based off of the logbook, I think the logbook is distributed by Fazbear frights given that it’s filled with games and activities rather than being a real security logbook. Frights most likely handed it out to their fake guard just to keep him busy and to the guests it’ll look like he’ll be filling out a logbook.

w comeback

Mike is definitely the fright guard in my opinion.

bro i wanted to know this for alot of time

I believe what we found take place between night 1 and night 2 of fnaf 3

"1 4 5 and 6" Dance with me in my backyaaaard boi That aside, nice vid ❤

Probably Michael Afton I mean he's literally the protag in every other game from 1 to 6 assuming he's Fritz from FNAF 2 not to mention the fazbear fright book heavily and I mean pretty much confirmed that Michael is the FNAF 3 protag oh and um also in the survival log book we see FNAF 3's office and a Foxy wearing a badge and the Foxy parallel's Mike further confirming he's the FNAF 3 protag do I need to say more? I wish it was a different guard but sadly it's most likely Mike I will be honest I do wish that Springtrap was Michael and the guard was Jeremy it opens up more twist and could have given William alittle more boost in character but at the same time having the killer get trapped in his springlock suit is cleaver

Who is the main protagonist security guard name from five nights at freddy's 3

1:50 I got jump scared.

henry 100% did not cause the fright fire because in ucn Toysnhk says through pigpatch “I will hold you here i will keep you here no matter how many times THEY burn us” afton was burnt twice and the they means the same person didn’t cause both fires and if the fright guard burnt frights it can’t be henry

I wouldve liked it if you went more in depth on Henry, since he very heavily implies he knows about Follow Me. Otherwise, good vid!

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

I honestly don’t see what Henry knowing about follow me has to do with him being the guard? Can you explain?

@InfalliblePizza

4 ай бұрын

@@zetorocks811 sure! the basic idea is that Henry goes through FNAF3, he either hallucinates or maybe dreams about Follow Me, then burns down the place after seeing that Springtrap is William, and also the killer in the MCI, prompting him to burn down the place. Under any other guard theory, its not clear how Henry would know what happens in Follow Me.

Mike schmidt vs hudson foster

@william5356

Ай бұрын

How many main protagonists in fnaf 3

I love how smaller theorists are getting attention for their amazing videos, keep up the good work

The character encyclopedia says Michael has an appearance in FNaF 3, and the only humans on screen are William/springtrap and those kids "Mangle's Quest", so by process of elimination, the player character is Michael Afton.

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

I’m pretty sure Michael doesn’t have an entry in the encyclopedia

@GermanFFreddy

4 ай бұрын

Sh-t, you're right. It just felt weird how one of the main characters in the entire series isn't in the book, I read it, but it was so long ago, I just looked it up on the wiki, yeah, sorry for the misinformation...

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

@@GermanFFreddy it’s good

13:53

Henry Emily could just try to be putting us or whoever goes through his recordings, off the trail. I mean, with an ex-partner like William, Henry would have to be ten steps ahead of us and his ex-partner. So, why would he incriminate himself on some recordings about being the nightguard when he suspects William Afton, us or anyone working for the Freddy Fazbear chain could get a hold of his logs and destroy them just to save the restaurant? Maybe too much of a conspiracy since most of my theories are usually wrong.

Fun fact in the Fnaf cookbook there is glamrock freddy’s fully loaded hotdogs, and in the fnaf 3 office there’s confirmed to be a hotdog that was eaten every night by the protagonist (could also be a old hotdog) and there’s an older version of the cookbook where it was Roxanne fully loaded hotdogs but then they changed it to Freddy, which is weird, if you bring into account that Freddy’s usually coincided with Henry, then I’d like to say it’s a pretty good chance that it is Henry in fnaf 3 but that’s only if you believe the cookbook it might have Lore in it or that just a stupid theory that I had in the shower. Im tired.

@Tiad27

4 ай бұрын

I don’t actually believe this is just want the cook book to have something lore relevant

9:30

it's michael afton.

Dude you're completely wrong, William Afton is the nightguard in fnaf 3.

Jeronimo stilton

Unless Hudson is Michael, I don't think he's the guard

Hudson accidentally killed his mother 👩

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

Oh thank you

@Unknowncameraman15

4 ай бұрын

@@zetorocks811 no problem

What if we are playing as phone guy in Fnaf 3

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

He died in FNaF 1

@revdawg

4 ай бұрын

this made me chuckle

@WaimeaMonster24

4 ай бұрын

It is debatable whether he died in fnaf 1 or not because in nightmare mode, he says that the safe rooms are being sealed, which is something that happens after William dies

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

@@WaimeaMonster24 actually they would most likely be sealed after the MCI to hide evidence

Henry always made the most sense

@Nicholas-vm6mh

4 ай бұрын

Michael always made the most sense.

@novustalks7525

4 ай бұрын

@@Nicholas-vm6mh Michael doesn't make sense

@Nicholas-vm6mh

4 ай бұрын

@@novustalks7525 then you must not understand.

@novustalks7525

4 ай бұрын

@@Nicholas-vm6mh I do understand it. And the very next game chronologicaly is proof that it was henry

Mike is the guard

What's his last name for hudson.

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

Foster

@william5356

4 ай бұрын

@zetorocks811 Hudson Foster

@william5356

4 ай бұрын

@zetorocks811 Hudson Foster

@william5356

4 ай бұрын

@@zetorocks811 Hudson Foster

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

Yep

your vids are great but please!!!! lower the volume of your transitions its very startling

@HeavyontheDis

4 ай бұрын

I agree with this- great video, but your voice audio is so low that we need to turn it up to hear you and the transition noise clips the volume heavily which detracts from the points you’re making and is difficult for people with auditory processing issues. If you’re able to adjust that would be amazing!

Mike in my opinion couldnt be the ightguard cause he was a literal zombie

Just some old guy thugging it out in their most excitement he had in years. Time to mess with this thing then on the last night everything burns he just starts doing that fresh prince looking around the empty house scene then runs out of there. Buys granddaughter oversized bonnie plush retires forever. Springtrap didn't even know who that was he was trying to get a checkmate while the guard is dunking on all his attacks.

0:23 Pizzeria Simulator:

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

That falls under “it’s just obvious”

@RedKitten64

4 ай бұрын

@@zetorocks811 Got it, I would say it’s never shown who the guard was in that game, but it made sense after I heard William’s lines.

The spring locks suits don’t get lured by children. It’s William that does. I personally don’t like your theories because your evidence doesn’t ever really make sense. Plus at times you seem to lack knowledge of the lore/gameplay mechanics

@zetorocks811

4 ай бұрын

The spring lock suits follow sounds “For ease of operation the animatronics are set to turn and walk towards sound, giving an easy and hands free approach, to making sure the animatronics stay where the children are, for maximum entertainment/crowd pleasing value.” This is what I meant. I forgot to put the quote on screen in the video

@quillllly

4 ай бұрын

I think the idea that William can be staring at you through a window only to go "ooh squirrel!" When he hears a child in the other room is ridiculous, but ignoring that, the phone calls outright state that it's the suits moving towards sound cues as a not so subtle tutorial. I obviously don't mind people getting stuff wrong, but leaving such a harsh comment WHILE getting stuff wrong just makes you look silly.

@revdawg

4 ай бұрын

ur fucking funny dude

22:56