Get a high quality wallet, belt or MORE in the Rose Anvil shop here - bit.ly/44jXLNu

I can say firsthand, I haven't watched the video but I own these boots. I've worn them pretty much everyday for 3 years. They're on their second heel. I wore through the original heel pad until it was flapping off. Additionally, the leather in the heel counter area inside I have worn through. I use them to work on trucks, ride motorcycles, chop firewood, off roading etc along with everyday use. I condition them before every winter as we get snow here. Awesome boot, and I'll continue to wear mine until the upper fails. If you're interested, I could send some pictures of them if you'd like to see what hard wear has done to them over that time.

With winter coming, can you do a series into winter boots? Insulated boots with lugs for snow. It's really hard to tell what is cheaply made when serious winter boots have such a msrkup to begin with.

@isaachoffmeister4188

Жыл бұрын

Jk boots makes a really good fully insulated leather boot hand made in Spokane WA

@AW-hg3pc

Жыл бұрын

surplus german navy boots, the lambskin ones best 100 i ever spent

@tspamtyahoocom

Жыл бұрын

Great idea!

@Thundermuffin93

Жыл бұрын

I believe he did a video on them either last year or the one before specifically on winter boots.

@ashleydanielson3222

Жыл бұрын

@@isaachoffmeister4188 Why are there so many boots made in Spokane? I have lived here most of my life and never knew that until watching these videos.

Thank you for removing the laces instead of slicing them this time! I really appreciate your channel and the education it's providing me about footwear construction. Keep being amazing!

@bigmartin

Жыл бұрын

I thought I was the only one annoyed by the usual videos cutting through the laces 😂 MUCH better this way

@anthonyfrancis2374

6 ай бұрын

It may be because the laces are made of Kevlar on some Thursday boots and it's also a waste really.

Can you do a what’s inside on motorcycle boots? Would love to see how they’re constructed!

@pineapplesideways3820

Жыл бұрын

Glue and stitching im guessing

@pineapplesideways3820

Жыл бұрын

Flip flops yeah baby

@galvanizedgnome

Жыл бұрын

Leather and plastic

@zachmiller9175

Жыл бұрын

I'd particularly like to see some of the Alpinestars sneaker style boots, they're extremely comfortable despite being about as stiff as a 3/4 shank mountain boot, I imagine it has a pretty substantial plastic shank.

@zachmiller9175

Жыл бұрын

@@galvanizedgnome very useful comment, we all definitely learned something and you're not just spamming up the comments at all.

Don't knock 'made in Mexico' products just because it's not USA. Often, they have better craftmanship than stuff made in the states.

@centurionl

13 күн бұрын

Not when they're mass produced, though, and nearly every cowboy boot brand has them made in the same factories

Rose Anvil hitting it out of the park with these reviews. These boots and the Wolverine’s were always on my wish list to get chopped. It’s like he read my mind!

Where I think the Thursdays Logger really excels is for a dress boot that looks the part of rugged. And while I own many of the real work/rugged boots, I've been looking for something similar I could everyday wear for time at the Office. Thursdays Logger is a winner for me.

I got the logger based off this video and after about a year of use I gotta say this boot has been superb. As shown in the video, it handles wear and tear very nicely and the scratches do add some nice character to color of the leather. They took about a week of pretty heavy walking to break-in but are now very comfortable and fit well. Speaking of fit I would recommend a half size down from what you typically wear in sneakers. The only minor gripe I have is that I had an aglet on the laces break within about 2 weeks of purchase but thats small caveat in an otherwise great boot.

Love this new model. Definitely will add it to my wish list. Also, thanks for removing the laces before cutting the boot.

I love seeing the quality and care Thursdays put into the build. I was wondering about the women’s collection since you did a couple other women’s boots to see if there is a difference in quality. Great video!

Damn that’s really interesting. I’ve never been too impressed with the look of the1000 mile boots But to see that the American made Thursdays are just better built is crazy

@figsaregood

Жыл бұрын

Thursday sent him the boot to cut in half. Think they would make 1 really good pair for him and rest for the masses are filled with junk?

@Bayou987

Жыл бұрын

@@figsaregood no I wouldn’t immediately think that as I already own a pair of Thursdays that Westin cut in half and they seem identical. Do you have any evidence counter to that?

@billymurphy3

Жыл бұрын

@@figsaregood that would be some really bad business if he cut worn in boots and checked for these things in the future. It would be a risk for Thursday knowing this channel.

@jaythenihilist4689

Жыл бұрын

@@figsaregood I think it shows how much confidence they have in their product. I only own one pair so far. And I don't wear them for work. But Thursday will likely be my go to boot brand for now on.

@strengthandbulkMadness

Жыл бұрын

This video is pitting a logger boot vs 1000 Mile. A little unfair but Thursday Captain vs the cap-toe Wolverine 1000 Mile? I have both and the Wolverine fits better and has thicker leather. Wolverine 1000 mile seems better than Thursday Captain but good to have both.

I love how objective and informative these reviews are! So many reviewers will never go this in depth on products as it's just not worth the time and effort. This genuinely has influenced on what I want to buy for future shoes and boots. Bravo to the class, style, and meticulous effort to do all these tests. Reminds me alot of tech channels that really stress test their products while also give their objective opinion on the products. Nicely done and can't wait to see more reviews!

Back when this channel was young you used to tear apart one of the boot halves and always commented on the individual quality of the parts…stitching, leather, sock liner, etc. Can you do that again? I think it’s really interesting seeing how easily a heel block pops off or how many nails are used in the construction.

Recently picked up a pair of Loggers (thanks largely to this video) and I'm happy to report they seem to have made the top lift thicker and given it lugs, probably in response to this video.

Thank you so much for this video. I've been looking for a quality boot at a reasonable price. Something that also fit my style. I went and checked out Thursday and love their stuff. Ordered a pair and can't wait to start wearing them. I've actually found several pairs I'm planning on purchasing.

I really love Thursday boots. Whether they are made in Mexico or USA, they are excellent boots at a very reasonable cost.

I just got my pair of loggers after watching this video. TheLogger is the best boot that tbc sells. The leather is super thick and so is the outsole. The outsole is like 1/2” of vibram so it’s super padded when walking around the forefoot. I love any and all boots with a toe cap and out of all my Thursday boots these are my favorite for the simple reason of the leather, the Cuban heel stack, and the thick outsole. TBC definitely gives you the best materials your money can buy without it costing an arm and a leg. They are sexy, comfy, and nice Cuban heel. I was trying to compare the 1k mile boots vs the Loggers and I picked the Loggers because of the look, the leather, the heel stack and the fact it does have a shank whereas the 1k miles don’t have a shank. The 1k miles are well over $100 more and the quality is NOT there. I like the 1k mile boots too but they don’t have any with a toe cap in stock with a heel like the Logger. I have found that plain toed boots don’t break in as well and doesn’t look as good as cap toe boots worn in. I think the cap toe hides a lot of the creases compared to the plain toed boots. Just mo.

Just got a pair of Thurday dress boots. Best dress shoes I've ever had. Broke them in during a work trip in England walking 2-3 miles on cobblestone and slate streets/sidewalks, and my feet never got tired. Really worth the price of entry.

Thanks so much for the review🙌

Wow, this is the first Thursday boot I would consider buying. $285 is extremely impressive for the quality of materials, and I despise over-reliance on synthetic materials.

I bought the Vanguards a few years ago. Another made in USA boot from Thursday. I really like them.

@kosta2177

Жыл бұрын

Are they holding well? Because it is difficult to trust KZreaders about reliability. When the person has 20+ boots, it doesn’t matter how many years they have them, if boots are just waiting on the shelf and being used just twice a month

@Cimone90

Жыл бұрын

@@kosta2177 hey. I have two pairs of boots. Those Vangaurds and a pair of White's Boots Moc Toe. I wear them equally through the winter in Canada so the vanguards get worn quite a bit and through snow and salt. They still look great. No issues with the welts or soles or anything. I clean them about once a month and use venetian shoe cream on them. I actually like the way they look now better than when they were new and they just keep getting more comfortable.

@kosta2177

Жыл бұрын

@@Cimone90 thanks a lot for the response. I’m seriously considering buying them so the actual review from the owner is really helpful

I was waiting this video for over a year. Thanks

I suspect the Redwing Iron ranger would win this mid range competition. At $350 they come in under the $400 price ranger you are targeting. The only other real competition I can think of would be the Whites Millwood or the Whites Chore Boot.

@isaachoffmeister4188

Жыл бұрын

JK 300s?

I bought the Wingtip and the Captain a year ago and i must say, that these boots are the best that i have worn till this day. Great material for this price and the best comfort that i ever had. Looking for a next pair of the brand.

Love this new MITUSA list. Keep up the great work, Rose Anvil!!!

Good boots. Thank-you for saving the laces too. Interesting series.

Great video, and just for the record I trust you’ll put out honest content so please keep taking sponsorships that you feel good about like this one!

Thursday has been my favorite leisure boot company. First pair of boots I was highly impressed at the price point. I may have to check out these logger style.

Love the no crap disappointments you let out in this one, like the split pig skin luchesse boots. Lol. Excited for this series dude. Keep em coming.

Love these series you do, can’t wait for moctober! Got my first pair of boots because of that series last year.

Was interested in watching this as I bought a pair of these from Thursday a few years ago. This is my favorite boot for casual wear, glad to see it was money well spent! Very comfortable boot. I was going to say you should do Parkhurst next but I see they’re not producing in the US anymore.

Always thank you for wonderful boots information!!

Been waiting for this series for awhile!

Entertaining series! Looking forward to the next installment.

I love that style of leather on the Thursday Logger. Its beautiful yet rugged as hell and thick. Now if only the cap toe was real so I could use it when I'm working down low or on my motorcycle. The insole not being removable sucks but if its like the Mexico version at all it should be comfortable right out of the box. I definitely like it more than the 1000 mile boot.

@jlg395

Жыл бұрын

Just by chance, I bought a pair of Thursday Captains about five years ago, before anyone was talking about the brand. They have a fake toe cap, but honestly, the boots have held up extremely well. You can buy a pair of these and work and hike and do whatever the hell you want, and they'll last for many years. Don't read the nonsense online saying that you need crazy thick boots just to do some work in. The stitching will hold up and you'll be fine.

Looks like a solid effort. Thanks!

Just got my Vanguard color # 8 today! Really excited

Great video, loving this series!

Love the channel. Have you seen any changes in the construction after you cut them apart? Like adding a full sock liner to the 1000 mile, or adding better leather liners like in the Lucchese?

Get a bi-metal blade with around 14 tpi for your new bandsaw blade & get it in as wide of a blade that your saw is designed to use. That should quickly & easily cut through the boots & shoes you use it for while being able to safely handle cutting through the steel shanks.

I've been waiting for this! Thanks Weston.

After wearing them for 2 days the Logger is super comfortable and it doesn’t crease as bad as the Mexican made boot like the captains. I bought some Nick’s leather laces and it matches perfectly. I can’t wait until I can get the nap to show through. It’s definitely the best Thursday boots ever made. Definitely better than the 1000 mile boots or with any other boot under $400.

Another Successful Boot Surgery, good evaluation Doc!!

Ive had these for a month now and i love them. Great boot.

LOVE that you’re doing the snake bite test on the shafts!!!!!

Nice boot. Think i will look for them. Thanks for the review. Great content.

I have these same boots in the Vanguard. The upper is just a bit shorter, but not a short as a Chukka. I absolutely LOVE them. I own them and a pair of Presidents. The raised heel is a BIT different, but the construction of the boot is insanely good. I love boots, so I was looking at some others, SPECIFICALLY the 1000 Mile Boot. I am glad I came across your last video, because I don't need to spend money. I already have the superior boot and am happy with it! Also for me, they fit true to size. I wear an 8.5 in shoes and these!

I thought I was two days late for a new segment lol thanks for another well produced, informative and entertaining video.

For the price, I've no complaints. Comfy and stylish, I don't use them for rough work, got my Whites BHs for that.

Another great video Weston. Bring on the rest!

I’d love to see you do a tear down of Thursday’s women’s boots. Are they as good as their men’s?

I like it when you mention the fit and feel, be cool if you could mention those in the next ones. Even if its just like a half hours wear to get a feel for the toe box and flex etc.

I like the thursdays but I wish they would have used a vibram top lift and gusseted the tough a little. Also I want to see the JK 300 boots on this list

Those Thursdays look sharp! Love that leather.

I'm still in the 200 and under price range but if I can swing it I'll definitely take a good look at the American Thursdays. Good video.

I’m sold. Excellent review ! Thanks🥃

I was thinking, Wow! Cut in half expert was struggling to cut this boot without taking the laces off, this must be one hell of a boot. And then came the disclaimer about the band saw 👏

I'd love to see a video on $400 or less steel toe/composite toe work boots.

Another great video Weston, I love my Thursday Vanguard Made in the USA with the Horween Blue Indigo leather boot.

Hey weston! It'd be interesting to see what's inside "hunting" and winterized leather boots, like the irish setters by example!

Great video as usual! Solid comparison, and fairly-measured. Have three types of 1K boots, and like them all. It was the first, and maybe the only pair I have I bought new. I was always struck by the thinness of the leather outsole. I had Tulsa Shoe Rebuilders re-sole one pair with a fine pair of Dr. Soles outsoles, which increased their use and durability x 10. However, it’s undeniable that this Thursday has some great components, and that leather is gorgeous. I’m beginning to feel that waxed flesh is becoming my favorite leather in my boot corral. I picked up a pair of Wesco Warrens in INDIGO waxed flesh, which are a stunning pair of boots. Wesco suggests Leather Honey for a conditioner, which-as your advert for them says-“does not darken the leather” as much. I like this as I hate to see the leather on a pair of my boots lose their leather’s “depth” be lost to conditioner. I won’t let that happen with these Wesco boots, as the leather is just too pretty in Indigo. However, Thursday’s heel stack on this video is just looks abominable. That creepy texturing looks like plastic. If I copped a pair of them, I’d break out the sandpaper immediately. They’d look phenomenal “done up” like some of these swank-looking Indo-Boots, with that shiny heel/sole job they do!

I bought these boots because of your review. So thank you for that I'm very happy with them. I've heard a lot about Meermin on various review shows and I own a few pairs. They're a bit out of the way for you because they do really focus on dress boots, but I would say their rust waxy commander boot could be considered a competitor to this logger boot (full disclosure I now own both). Would love to see a breakdown of a Meermin boot on your channel.

U just helped me decide on these boots over the 1000 mile. Love you content man! How about the Sutro Alder Vibram?

I've owned these loggers for over a year and I like them a lot. My only complaints are with the identity confused design - like the fact that they have the dress style heel top lift, it is an 8 inch boot with no speed hooks, and as you can see at 8:27 they have no tongue gusset at all, so even though they have good waterproof materials and construction, if any water splashes on the laces it goes right into the boot. At least the heel and hooks can be fixed by a cobbler, not sure about the gusset though. Overall they are great materials and build quality, but I would change those few things if I had my way. The Whites Sawyer probably would have been better for what I wanted, for ~$100 more.

@Cupofgo

Жыл бұрын

Good to know!

Thursday makes a extremely good looking boot, I love their Chelsea boots

I'm excited to see the Origin boot analysis.

For this series please include Allen Edmonds Higgins Mill Chromexcel 🤙they are always on sale under 400

Huge fan of the MITUSA. As a broke forester this is very helpful.

Thursdays just the reasonably priced gift that keeps on giving

I hit my vanguards with Saphir renoveteur when i got them and they are amazing boots. Very comfortable

I got the thursday captain based on that tear down, and was going to get a second pair in another leather, but after seeing this I had to order a pair of these loggers. Really impressed with the leathers they use

@oscarbear7498

Жыл бұрын

This guy is a hell of a sells man, Thursday better be paying him good

@curtiswashington8536

Жыл бұрын

@@oscarbear7498 Thursday should focus on making their made in usa stuff as good as their made in Mexico stuff imo, the loggers had numerous QC issues

Grabbed a pair of Vanguards, love em'!

Thank you for the visual representation of the ranking. My favorite part of your older series videos was the recap video at the end to officially close the series and group all the good and bad in one spot for easy choice making in a boot purchase. (Maybe the group in depth recap could be on Rose Anvil 2 channel) It was because of all your videos that I made the best footwear choice of my life so far, in purchasing a pair of nicks builder pro about 5 months ago. Keep up the content, really enjoy these boot series.

I have both versions of the Thursdays Captain - the regular (made in Mexico) and the vanguard (made in USA) and I can fully agree. The few extra bucks for the vanguards is well spent money. The leather of the regular version is by no means a bad leather, but it's a bit thinner and tanned in another way. Also the soles on the cheaper ones had to be repaired three times already, since they use softer rubber that wears off faster and tends to detach from the tip of the toes over time. The made in Mexico boots are still in very good condition and will last me a few more years, but if you compare the money spent on those repairs then you'd be better off on just buying the vanguards. Both great boots for the price tho.

@CactusLuver77

Жыл бұрын

The Thursday-brand soles are garbage. I won’t buy another Thursday unless it has Vibram or a real Danite sole

Also love the top gear metal board with magnets haha

Can't wait to see the lap times of the other boots.

I have the French Roast Vanguard, which is Thursday's other American made boot. They look great and I love the boots. I think they will age really well. They can dress up but they also really have a quality and weight to them that makes them really feel like good boots. I think the Horween leather options for the Logger and Vanguard make them stand out from the Captain. And they come with fully leather laces and the waxed ones also. So you can use either.

@WaxySmooth

Жыл бұрын

Hi, how long have you had them and how often? I’m just curious how the proron insole is over time

@CH-uk1fr

Жыл бұрын

@@WaxySmooth I've only had them about 10 months now. I wore them at least a couple times a week during the colder months and maybe once every couple weeks over the summer. Insole ins't broken down at all really and they are comfortable for as long as I've worn them (probably a few hours at a time max). Though my feet generally are comfortable in most shoes.

I got excited when I saw the acronym… I thought you might be taking to my alma mater.

Love this series! Can you do a review of Thursday Vanguard French Roast? They cost $265 and are Horween Chromexcel. It would be interesting to see how they stack up to The 1000 Miles and The Logger.

Great vid Weston. I’ve owned a pair of these Thursday loggers since early 2020 and worn them ~4 times a week since. I know a lot of people hate that stacked heel look but I love these boots, especially how that waxed cacao leather wears in. My main 3 complaints are the fake toe cap, thin top lift and un-gussetted tongue (tongue slid to the side while wearing). After 2.5 years I just replaced the top lift with a thicker one, and fixed the tongue in place with a small rivet. They’re also my most complimented boots. Would recommend for casual wear.

@porkchopproductions0314

Жыл бұрын

What's the complaints with the stacked heel look?

@zachlepera3610

Жыл бұрын

@@porkchopproductions0314 It’s just something I’ve seen a lot in reviews of that boot. I guess some people don’t like the proportion of leather to small rubber cap.

I like the look and value of Thursdays. I've owned two pairs, but I ended up selling both because they are just super narrow and I never could get them stretched enough to be comfortable. I even contacted them about sizing before ordering and just never could get them comfortable. It was a shame.

@clintwilliams5026

Жыл бұрын

I had the same problem. The leather in the ball of my foot would stretch out perfectly but I needed to add kilties in order for my ankle to lock in comfortably.

@ShacklefordR

Жыл бұрын

I ended up going with their wide versions of the boots and went full size down and are pretty happy with it so far (almost wore it for a month now)... you may want to try them again :)

@phineaspoe1978

Жыл бұрын

@@ShacklefordR unfortunately, the wide seem to be limited to a few boots, and not the models I had. But I've since moved to boots without any foams in them like Red Wing and White's. I have a couple of Wolverines that I'm waiting for the sole to wear out on so I can rebuild them. They just don't have enough between your foot and the ground for me. I'd love them with an all leather construction like White's. And I'm interested in trying a pair of Trumans because they have an amazing selection of leathers.

@MadelnMachines

Жыл бұрын

What brannock foot width are you?

@phineaspoe1978

Жыл бұрын

@@MadelnMachines I don't know. I haven't been measured on a brannock device for years. I did the foot tracing and measuring for my White's MPs, and when I ordered my Perrys they had that. They put me in D width. I went to the store and got measured on Red Wing's automated system and also got placed in a D. My Wolverine 1000 miles are also a D. I contacted Thursday to make sure I was ordering the correct size, they asked about my other boots, I gave them the sizes of those, and then ordered based on their recommendations. The Thursdays were much narrower than anything else I own, even my Allen Edmonds Higgins Mills, which are also a bit narrower than the Red Wings, etc. I have since decided that, though Thursdays are a great value, I would rather have more expensive boots without all of the foam comfort materials inside that will eventually wear out.

the non-gussetted tongue is very weird to me. Also even if it's a "dress" logger boot the fake toecap is disappointing

Been waiting for this one

I'm convinced, totally grabbing some Thursdays! Thanks for the hard work and effort you put into making these videos man! Can you test the Ariat Moctoes for Moctober?

One you could add to this series, the Whites Hathorn Tracker. On their site it’s $380 or $390, but can be purchased through C-A-L Ranch for under $300(some sizes excluded)

Weston, you get better looking every video. Oh, and your videos are great too. Lol

Love the look of the Thursdays, just wish they had some wider size options.

Another solid video

The Frye Prison Boot is a great boot for this series. It claims to be a made in the US boot and they claim to be a heritage brand! Definitely consider it.

@Dzm79

Жыл бұрын

I will ask for the same boot.I have pair and they definitely not iron ranger rugged. They most be more like 1000 miles or those Thursdays. But yeah good call.

@jonkrier

Жыл бұрын

I actually hadn't even heard of the Frye Prison Boot. I like them! And I have actually had very good luck with Frye boots over the years. I'd love to see a Rose Anvil break down to see how they stack up.

@christopherferreiras6622

Жыл бұрын

@@jonkrier I'm happy you like them too! It's such a beautiful silhouette! I've heard these likened to the Iron Ranger but idk about all that honestly. Frye boots have never failed me either, though. I know they can be hit or miss depending on where you get them, or where they're made, but the made in mexico models from their site have been pretty damn solid for mainly city use. Bought a pair like 10 years ago and only needed one good resole. Still wear them today

@hixwithanx

Жыл бұрын

I've been watching Rose Anvil since pretty early on and have been surprised that Frye's haven't shown up yet. In fact, I can't even recall them being mentioned on the channel. Although few are made in the US nowadays, the Mexican-made ones are good. The Prison Boot and Arkansas Boot are just begging to be cut in half!

First of all, I’ve been loving this channel! So much great information and great vibes! So I’m picking up a pair of loggers and I was wondering what the difference between the Arizona Adobe and the waxed Cacoa. I chose the Arizona Adobe but after watching this video I’m starting to think I should have gone with the Waxed Cacoa. Is there a significant difference in durability between the two leathers? I’m pretty rough on my boots and want to make sure It last awhile.

Love my Thursday sneakers. The company definitely seems quality. But my Whites are my go to boots. Wouldn’t mind a nicer dress up style from Thursday

These boots look so cool!!!

These are the first ones I’d really consider buying

You can always test if its the orientation of the leather by doing another puncture test from the other side. As if it's puncturing from "inside" the shoe.

Dude another video same week? What a treat.

Could you try puncturing the same hide of leather from both sides? I suspect having to push through the intertwined fibres of the flesh out side makes it tougher to get to/break through through the grain side, while on the other the hand if you slice through the grain side, that fibre structure falls apart, possibly explaining why rough out would have a greater puncture resistance

@robertsandgren9389

Жыл бұрын

I agree and think I would explain it as the flesh protecting the strong fibres from the spike. Essentially "blunting the blow".

I like my Vanguards even if they are a half size too small. That combined with them being one of the hardest soled boots I have, I honestly don't wear em much anymore. The Diplomat however, is still a solid buy.

@souleater302

Жыл бұрын

I thought I was crazy for experiencing these same thing. I wonder if I'll ever truly break them in. Is there a drastic difference between half sizes? Mine fit great save for the heel slippage. I wonder if I get half a size smaller the issue good away but I don't want my tires squished. What do you think?

Love your channel! Subbed and addicted. Love Thursday Boots. Have several pairs. I have the U.S. made Vanguard version of this boot. Identical. But shorter. Incredible value at the price. Horween, wax fleshed leather, Vibrwm sole. Cuban stacked heel. Wore it yesterday. LOVE this boot! Keep up the great work with your videos!

@howyduinyall7653

Жыл бұрын

Hi, do you recommend a conditioner for this waxed rough out leather?

@shaynelaw9629

Жыл бұрын

@Howyduin Yall I'm sure you can condition these roughout leather boots, but I have held out. I have babied them a bit, but from what I have read, conditioning is less important and necessary for this type of leather than a more conventional chrome or vegetable tanned leather. I condition my other boots at least every 3-6 months, depending upon wear frequency.

Great review! Wonder if the other colors are just as durable in the loggers?