When Ramah wasn’t raised from the dead, I thought the writers were reinforcing for us believers that God doesn’t heal everyone. It is a mystery we don’t understand- why some are healed and others aren’t. God sees the whole picture; we don’t. It is incumbent upon us not to be offended but continue to believe God is good even when He doesn’t answer our prayers the way we want Him to.

@trustinJesus_only-_

Ай бұрын

Exactly. God is always good and his ways are higher than ours ❤ I'm so grateful he hasn't always said yes to my prayers because he's helped me to seek him more.

@aracelibasilio7672

Ай бұрын

Well said. I agree with you and that is really the point of this episode.

@ImogeneHortense19541abcd

Ай бұрын

it was a made up idea that was overly brutal, nightmare material.

@trustinJesus_only-_

Ай бұрын

@@ImogeneHortense19541abcd when you watch someone get killed in real life, you realize life is messy and that it doesn't always go in your favor. It sucks but by processing it and grieving it you understand the fragility more and hopefully you respect it better. That's my opinion on it 😊💜

@lynnekelley7545

Ай бұрын

Yes, the same way he didn't heal Little James, when he asked. That scene in Season 3 Episode 1. It was heartwrenching to watch Little James, who contended that he wouldn't be as effective as the others due to his malady. It was good of them to be consistent.

Thank you so much for this video! I didn’t have questions about why Jesus didn’t raise Ramah, I had questions on why she was murdered in the first place, and this video has perfectly explained that. Thank you! Two things I’d like to say: 1. I’m not affiliated with the show, but from my understanding of the Lord and the Word, it made perfect sense that Jesus didn’t raise Ramah. I would’ve actually been shocked if He did, because it really was not yet time. Remember that the only person He’d raised at this point was Jairus’ daughter, and only very few people knew about it, and He strictly warned them not to tell anyone, not even the rest of His disciples. They all thought He’d gone to heal a sick girl, they didn’t know she had already died. This is because if it became known that He could raise the dead, more people would’ve believed He was truly God, and that would’ve caused such a stir among the Pharisees and His ministry would’ve been interrupted. Remember in John’s gospel, He raised Lazarus when He was wrapping up His earthly ministry. And after He raised him, His fame went off the charts, and that was when the Pharisees actually started plotting to kill Him. God is God-centered. His will is always priority over anything else. If Ramah was killed in private, it would’ve been different. But she was killed publicly. Jesus definitely hated to see Ramah die, but if He raised her, His ministry would’ve ended prematurely. 2. I’d like to give more insight to the story of the blind man, and why Jesus healed him the way He did. Back then, it was Jewish custom to spit on the ground when walking past a blind beggar. So, Jesus spitting on the ground, forming clay with the soil, and healing the man with it was His way of making a message out of His mess. He used what was used to mock him to heal him.

@karinrempel5862

Ай бұрын

Well that’s pretty cool! Thanks

@gtennier

Ай бұрын

Well articulated & helpful. Thank you!

@marshakimball3029

Ай бұрын

I was told that the Jews believed the spittle of the first born male had healing properties… I really don’t know if that is true or not. Im in hopes that someone can clarify that.

@glorytothealmightycreator

Ай бұрын

In the blind man case, it's much more than you wrote. It's a spiritual meaning too. Scriptural meaning. Now new age spiritual meaning

@neperson7647

Ай бұрын

Did you know that this story of the blind man being healed brought a whole tribe of people to salvation. They understood in their culture when he did that, that he was truly their savior. I think it's cool that you know about the original context of what Jesus did, but also, I think as the scripture says that his ways are higher than our ways, and his thoughts are higher than our thoughts, that Jesus probably did things with many things in mind. Also, it is exciting that God can use things we may never see as important ourselves to change the lives of others through it. God Bless!

Jesus didn't intervene in the death of John. We blame God when it is people who impose their own will on another person/people. STOP BLAMING GOD for the evil people do to one another. Either you have free choice or you don't.

@cathijones4397

Ай бұрын

Yes, He gave us free choice and then we blame Him when we mess up. Wow! We're a sorrowful lot! We need !! Him.

@deepthi262

Ай бұрын

Thank you so much for reminding me about John. Really big big thanks. I was thinking about this a lot since the episode was live. And my mind and heart were struggling a lot. Thank you🙏

@68868s

Ай бұрын

Because it was prophecy. Jesus fulfilled all the scriptures that pointed to what He would do. He came into this world with a mission, and Praise God, He did all that was written about him in the old testament. If He had not, we would all be on our way to Hell. It is not a party place, but a place of endless torture.

@kimartist

Ай бұрын

Good point Ally!

@beeg693

24 күн бұрын

We certainly do have free will. I have been gifted with dreams which showed me that people do indeed have free will. God and Jesus know what you are going to do before one chooses to do that thing.

I don't nick pick everything when I'm watching the chosen.... I'm enjoy the episode.... best Series Ever! I watch the chosen's round table...

@savvychipmunk2228

Ай бұрын

yes if it's nit picked people who need to see Jesus as a real human and real God may be offended

@ShortCakes

Ай бұрын

Sharing a different perspective....it is not nit picking, rather gems of wisdom. No different than Scripture! There is a WEALTH of knowledge to discover. The TRUTH sets you free! So many miss it! Believers and followers of Yeshua will show themselves studious and eat of its fruit. Shalom!

I prayed to get pregnant as we’d struggled for 10 years. My baby sister was pregnant. (In 2014) she was five months pregnant I found out that I was pregnant soon afterwards and prayed to keep the baby. But at 7 weeks I miscarried and chose to carry my dead baby for several months. I didn’t want the surgery or the medication. No medical intervention. I prayed the LORD would bring my baby back to me…and let my baby’s soul return to me. But he didn’t. He had even given me a dream before I got pregnant that “my time had come” but he did also show me a dark time. That’s why when I saw the positive pregnancy test I prayed to keep my baby. And for a while I thought he would . But he sent 3 people in my life to tell me I would never hold my baby. And he told me before I miscarried that he would take my child. And I begged him… I pleaded with him. He didn’t allow us to hold our baby. And I struggled for 4 years with this! I had to come to realize that the LORD is good. No matter what! In the good times and the worst of times. And loss is a theme in my life. It’s never easy. But I can’t stop giving him praise. Even when he takes away. I don’t know why he doesn’t always heal. And I have all the faith in the world. But his ways are beyond ours.

@chrisquiett1776

27 күн бұрын

That's rough. I'm sorry you had to go through that but I'm glad you didn't lose your faith. It would be nice if we could see the bigger picture but since we can't we can only trust in God and his just judgment. God bless

@bridgetmullett4809

25 күн бұрын

I love your faith.

@guerrieri95

25 күн бұрын

Your Bby Is In Heaven ❤❤❤

@lorikeffer6339

25 күн бұрын

Yes, God's ways are beyond ours. However, in my three decades on this earth, I have learned at least two reasonable explanations about why miscarriages happen. These may or may not be helpful right away, but maybe sometime later on, they will be helpful. First, I belive that God takes unborn babies to spare them from having to endure some terrible fate had the children lived, thus also sparing the surviving family members from suffering with them. Second, I believe that God wants allow the babies He takes before birth to grow up in a better, safer environment than what we all have here on this Earth for now. It'll be much easier for those babies to adjust to the ultimate culture shock that we older people will endure for a while when we go to Heaven to live for great while. I also believe that God's family is a lot bigger than we could ever imagine.

@Evelyn-zg9gp

25 күн бұрын

At 28 I had a miscarriage at that time my marriage only lasted 5 months I don't want to be hitting no more so now at age 64, I have no one no family no husband no house nothing but God and alone with no one so I feel your pain because I always remember my child's birthday every year I experienced the sadness and cry several times a year. I pray you are still young enough to get pregnant again. 😭

This is a TV show. It’s based off the Bible , but it is not scripture. The Bible does not tell every single detail which they try to fill in the show. And if I’m not mistaken, they have explained this. I believe if you know your Bible, you will be able to discern what is scripture and what was filled in, in the show. I love The Chosen. I think they did a great job.

@jazzyjen5083

Ай бұрын

I agree completely!!!! They repeat time and time again the show is not scripture and is not a replacement for scripture. We are suppose to watch alongside understanding the Bible for a reason.

@Mir_Nohti

Ай бұрын

It isn't just that it isn't scripture: THEY CHANGED THE VERY NATURE of Jesus. He never refused a healing. False Jesus by character assassination.

@shelleyvanover

Ай бұрын

I agree and I love to read biblical fiction too! 😀

@marilynwebb8003

Ай бұрын

Me, too! Great answer. People seem to forget how many times the Bible has been translated.. hundreds. And they are still coming out with a "new" version . There are thousands of papyrus that were not included in the first Bible because it wouldn't been thousands of pages long . We have what Heavenly Father needs us to have to believe in His Son and in the Holy Ghost. I follow the King James.

@lini8

Ай бұрын

Agree!

This episode was brilliantly written. Loved every moment of it. The Lord does not always answer our prayers with a “yes.” but He can be there with us in our pain and grief.

@donaldwilliamfry

Ай бұрын

You were okay with the portrayal of Jesus in this scene? He seemed out of control and out of touch, something the gospels never show at any level.

@reginapontes5672

Ай бұрын

I disagree ​@@donaldwilliamfry

@68868s

Ай бұрын

You are right, the Lord doesn't answer every prayer, He doesn't answer the wrong prayers! But when it comes to healing, that is a different story. Do you know the word of God? Have you even read it? You are wrong. Read the book of Matthew and underline every place in which Jesus healed, raised the dead, and delivered people of demons. Jesus came into this world to bring the good news, He was the physical year of Jubilee. I have read the scriptures for over 50 years, I read the Bible every single day. I stand on His word and follow Him. He leads me, heals me, delivers me, NOT Dallas Jenkins. This movie is a sham, it is leading people in the wrong direction. Read the Bible, read it and your eyes will be open.

@donaldwilliamfry

Ай бұрын

@@reginapontes5672 You disagree based on what? Where in Jesus being shuffled away and in his sudden awareness that Rhema was killed while being shuffled away did it show Jesus in control? And why was it Peter coming up with the only exit plan while Jesus seemed too caught in the moment to understand what was going on around him? I have given several reasons for my thought..."I disagree" seems a bit shallow.

@donaldwilliamfry

Ай бұрын

@@68868s The Bible says that there are "sicknesses unto death" John 11:4 Certainly God can and does heal many. We are, however, still in our "bodies of death" and will eventually get sick and die. The timing of that is in God's hands.

We are all believers, set-apart followers of Yeshua and this show is ONE of the many ways the Holy Spirit talks to our hearts, to have discussions with each other, to pray together and ultimately seek God by reading the Scriptures. "It is not your job to feed the 5000 but to provide the loaves and fish" - Dallas Jenkins. God will do the rest, trust Him. The Chosen is a historical drama based on the life of Jesus, it's not perfect but very good. A blessing to watch and learn. Amen.

@kristiwilliams1051

Ай бұрын

Even God can't pull things out of thin air. He has to start with something. Even in Genesis, it is shown that in the very first chapter, He has His voice to command the Earth to be formed.

@68868s

Ай бұрын

Not is is NOT AT ALL PERFECT AND IT IS NOT AT ALL FACTUAL nor is it actually based on the Bible, the Word of God and He, God, takes it seriously when it is misquoted or used for the purpose of leading people in the wrong direction. Read your Bible.

@chk859

22 күн бұрын

@@68868sit is bringing many to the Bible and Jesus in His own words said that those who aren’t against Him are for Him and ultimately Our Creator and Heavenly Father. Nothing can replace The Holy Bible, but as the world implodes many new paths are opening up to beckon more and more who are blind to God’s messages. God certainly works in mysterious ways. As does His Son. 🙏 This is just my humble opinion. 🙏

When Rayma was killed, my heart stopped, and I sobbed so hard as if she was my sister. I Love this Show and all who make it. They have brought this to life for me and hel me to understand more.

@AllThingsNew1723

7 күн бұрын

Rayna is not a character in the scriptures. This is adding to Gods already perfect Word 🙏

When Christ wont heal. I had an experience recently where I have been asking and asking and asking for God to heal me. He spoke to me in a deeply profound way that he would not heal me until I had learned what I needed to from my struggle. I repeat, God was not willing to heal me, could he? Yes he has all power. Our suffering serves a purpose, if faith isn't our problem something else might be. In the chosen there have been three instances where Jesus did not step in to heal, Little James Eden and Simon Ramah and Thomas. I hope you understand the reason God allows suffering even if we ask to have it removed. Ask and you will receive is a true principle, but the timing of when we are answered depends on when God in his omniscience knows we really need that healing.

@abbykittle5058

Ай бұрын

But, for Little James, it wasn't for him to learn a lesson; Jesus didn't heal him to be a testimony to others that he's kept the faith even though he's going through a disability. Not everyone who has chronic illness or disability is an immature Christian. Sometimes, God doesn't heal for the sake of those around us, that they may see our faith through the trials. I myself have experienced a ton of health issues, and it's made me think I'm an awful Christian, and that's why I'm suffering. But, God doesn't just grow us through pain, He allows it to point others to Him as well.

@nickma71

Ай бұрын

Jesus died for your sin, in your place. He was raised from the dead. If you believe this and confess you shall be saved. I don't know that you believe, as you think he came to balance your check book, and you seek after other signs.

@user-hd5ew9tb8d

Ай бұрын

Thank you for your "word of knowledge" because I am struggling with the same type of issue...health problem that doctors have been incapable of taking care of... thanks

@guardianzforzion

Ай бұрын

@@nickma71 I'm a bit confused how you got sign seeking from my comment.

@nickma71

Ай бұрын

@@user-hd5ew9tb8d The miracles in the 4 gospels pertain to Israel and their earthly kingdom. They were never told by a prophet they will die and go to heaven. They will be resurrected into a glorified body (born again). We will live forever in Christ. This is what he told Paul, the apostle to us gentiles. 8 Concerning this thing I pleaded with the Lord three times that it might depart from me. 9 And He said to me, “My grace is sufficient for you, for My strength is made perfect in weakness.” Therefore most gladly I will rather boast in my infirmities, that the power of Christ may rest upon me.

All the Apostles suffered in one way or another. They were persecuted and killed. So suffering isn't something we will not face. In this world we will have trouble but fear not He has overcome. Our treasure is in heaven. Through all my suffering I have grown closer to the Lord in my faith in Him. Whether I live or die I know in Whom I have believed. They overcame by the Word of their testimony and they loved not their lives unto death.

@ricklaine6583

Ай бұрын

Until one has experienced true hardships,,one can only talk about it,,it's easy to say,,very ,very hard to go through it,,one absolutely won't make it without our LORD AND SAVIOR JESUS CHRIST, (GODIN THE FLESH)!!We put our trust in him,we lean on him,we believe in the PRECIOUS BLOOD OF THE LAMB,,we know,,that we have eternal life the instant we believe and not just recite, or parrot, if you will,,a prayer.THE PRAYER DOES NOT SAVE ANYONE,,TOTAL BELIEF IN OUR PRAYER TO THE FATHER IN THE NAME OF JESUS DOES!!! ""WE ARE SAVED BY GRACE ALONE THROUGH FAITH ALONE IN CHRIST ALONE,,PERIOD!!!!

I believe this wonderful episodes purpose was to teach us this “the Lord giveth and the Lord takes away. Blessed be the name of the Lord!” Suffering requires faith. Those who were angered with this episode are likely to be angry at not having Jesus respond to their searching and suffering the way they want Him to.

@Minime163

13 күн бұрын

As someone whose had a chronic illness all my life I say by all means pray to be healed by all means but also pray for acceptance of God's will for you this worked wonders for me dealing with my illness. Illness is hard but its has its blessings too, it let's us see that there are people suffering more than us and it can give other people around us hope if we handle it properly, wheather their suffering illness or other hardships.

I do NOT understand why Thomas, when he saw Quintus raging at the crowd, chose to walk with Ramah right by Quintus?!? Quintus was CLEARLY unstable and carrying a double-edged sword-and if protecting Ramah from harm was Thomas’ priority, then he made the worst possible decision. Picking any direction AWAY from Quintus would have been the better and most logical choice, and then Thomas and Ramah could have met up with Jesus and the disciples at another location. Making a bee line to Jesus, while spiritually correct and praiseworthy, needed to be moderated with tactical sense. 🙄

@sherrylabtec

25 күн бұрын

sometimes in the heat of the moment...logic flees ...and you do not think clearly...only emotionally...which is what he was doing...

@kristymerrill2496

25 күн бұрын

This action on the part of Thomas also confused me, but then, if Thomas believed getting Raman to Jesus as quick as possible, I can understand his having blinders to the terrible danger. I did like that Quintus looks horrified by what he’s done.

@KittyCatAddict

24 күн бұрын

Yeah, I thought they could have done that better. Maybe the crowd- since they’re all pushing and such accidentally shoves them into Quintus’ space and he reacts. Or everyone’s running around and Quintus draws his blade as they’re passing them lashes out. That would have made more sense.

@jillijane9793

24 күн бұрын

It is a TV show.....

@nblumtm

17 күн бұрын

This portion is fictional to make a point.

In the Christian East, the Church Fathers tell us that a man born blind was one born without eye balls. The Lord did not anoint with mud; the Creator of all took dust and his spit to form working eyes. That’s the miracle of the Blind Man. Too bad the idiom in Greek is not understood in English.

@freddurstedgebono6029

Ай бұрын

Interesting, referencing Genesis

@esjaymac

Ай бұрын

That is so cool!

@valeriewalker954

Ай бұрын

Thanks for that.

@PaintDanceLive

Ай бұрын

Excellent share, thank you for this incredible detail!!🤍

@Lou-eye

Ай бұрын

I heard about that in the 90's, the creation of new eyes was awesome.

Brandon, breaking down the Greek meaning of words and positions as well as the Hebrew is essential to understanding the scriptures. We read in English, and the way it was Originally written and then translated can lose powerful meaning. You are doing a great service to this. Now as far as the “poetic license “ in the Chosen , I do believe it is a dramatic way of making not only Jesus, but also the disciples real to us in 2024. Real people with real drama in our lives that we turn to God to cure, but not always trust enough so we take matters into our own hands. Sometimes God answers NO because it is NOT in his plan for us and what is in that plan is more important. We only see the little picture, and as Paul wrote to the Corinthians through pain comes growth, be joyful even when it hurts, knowing that Gods plan for you is Great.

@williamivanko7198

Ай бұрын

I needed your comment. Thank you. THANK YOU! Ramah's death wasn't just the death of a person. It was a metaphor for answered prayer. "It wasn't her time", to be with Thomas or the time for Thomas to be with her. The sundial gift was so very much an analogy - very symbolic and figurative. For God had a much bigger plan for him. The Lord our Father answers ALL prayers. But sometimes the answers to those prayers are different than the answers we want. God knows best. We need to trust in Him more. Even though it may include some very painful situations.

@ziodavide1206

Ай бұрын

God’s plans are so wonderful! I’m in Texas but met a Heart doctor yesterday from the City in India that Thomas lived in and based out of when he did his part in Mark 16:15. We never know how having Rama in his life at that point in his ‘walk’ might have affected his decisions, but God did!

@RobT07

Ай бұрын

Brandon takes a little “poetic license” himself.

@contentedspirit9022

Ай бұрын

Yes, I believe also that this was something that related to Thomas and his ministry as a disciple. Thomas was one who doubted the most and seemed to, at times, put Ramah as more cherished and important as Jesus. I could be totally wrong, but it almost feels like Jesus may have known that Thomas needed to learn and grow in his faith so he would be able to carry out his mission as a disciple. We often only reach out and grasp on to Jesus more during our most difficult times, especially when our plans don't work out, or tragedy strikes, leaving us lost and wondering what our purpose is, and how we can go on. I'm thankful that I can't see what's ahead, and know that if I will just draw close, let go of my own determination, ask for His guidance, and trust Him, that He will get me where I'm supposed to be.

Eden and Simon Peter’s baby died in the womb. Now Thomas has lost Rema. The entire Christian walk is full of struggles. I DO know how hard it must have been to actually have Jesus standing there but God won’t let him heal her or keep Eden from having a miscarriage. All I know is we aren’t to question Gods ways. Ever. No matter what. THATS hard but I trust His will for my life and once you make up your mind on that you cry, grieve and talk to Him through it until it doesn’t hurt so much. And I’ve been through a rape. Trust me. I get it!

@peppywood01

Ай бұрын

God has blessed you beyond measure!

@tloren6148

Ай бұрын

Please be sure to read the gospels to get a true depiction of Jesus. Many things depicted on the show are not scripturally accurate. I would hate for you to get a wrong impression of our wonderful Heavenly Father by how he’s being portrayed on this show ☹️

@annemarie748

Ай бұрын

There are struggles all through our lives , correct, everyone has them. But our Faith pull us through our Lord carries us when we can hardly walk for sorrow or pain. He will never forsake us. Alleluia This TV show is great I LOVE IT I realize it has brought many people to enquire about Jesus our LORD and Savior through the bible. We must pick up the bible and read it for ourselves to understand the depth of Jesus and Gods love for us. I pray people read for themselves , KJV of course

@humbleberean

Ай бұрын

Yahuah gives and He takes away, Yet still will I praise Him! He will always have a greater purpose for what He does or doesn't do in all of our lives. "In your patience posses your soul".

@jazzyjen5083

Ай бұрын

Yes!!!! That was the point of this plot!!!! Everyone complaining about scripture needs to understand there are concepts within Christianity that aren’t in the Bible but are big enough that a huge show like the Chosen really should address. You also have a fair amount of Atheists watching that specifically reject God for this reason so this is also meant to reach them. Not everything is about scripture

Once again, thank you for your excellent teaching. Whenever you teach, the light goes on.☀

Wow! Thank you for this breakdown - explanation and insights - context and understanding is so powerful! Now let me go STUDY and re-watch this episode! This is so good! This quote came to mind, "If all you see is what you see, then you do not see all there is to be seen" - Pastor Tony Evans Thank you Thank you Thank you again!

This episode was powerful 1. Jesus came to do the will of the Father, he even prayed if it be possible for the cup to pass from Him. Even when it wasn’t He submitted Himself to the will of our Father. The very beginning sets the mood for this episode, that while we may not receive answers to our prayers at the moment we may want them, they will be answered. David at the beginning mentions that they will be united with their child, which is majestic to know that we can be united as families once again and see God.

@68868s

Ай бұрын

Because He was all man and all God.

Good job, Brandon! I learned a lot. One of your best videos. Compared to some of the other posts on here, I have never watched "The Chosen", but I will tell you that the information explained in this video is some of the best I have ever heard without oaying thousands of Dollars to sit in the lecture hall at a university.

Thank you for breaking this down the way you have. Though I've been a Christian for a long time I've still got so much to learn and especially about how understanding the cultural background of the times of Scripture gives us greater understanding. Love the teaching you, The Snipe Life and Grafted bring to us, and the way it challenges us, myself included. Praying that God would help me better put my faith and what I'm learning of Him through His Word into practice daily.

Thank you for your insight on Quintus and Ramah. Quintus had clearly lost it, but it helps to understand why.

One of the greatest reasons Jesus came was to return us to the proper interpretation and upholding of the law. This episode was so great!

Perfect! I love the way how it was explained. I'm learning. I think the Pharisees really don't understand Jesus. ❤🙏

This season has been amazing. I have been in tears for the love of these characters. ❤

Thank you for opening up the history. What you revealed gave me a deeper understanding.

Thank you Brandon. I look forward to listening to your break down explanation after each episode airs. It helps me understand signs or messages I might have missed. I really appreciate you doing this.

Thank you Brandon. I appreciate the support you give us helping explain everything bible. Your channel has been a blessing for me!

Thank you for the additional information about the show!

Your insights are beneficial and food for thought and further examination. Thank you!

For all of us that Known the Gospel, there is no need to explain, Dallas did an excellent job, and even what is not in the bible makes sense to the story.

@donaldwilliamfry

Ай бұрын

I know the gospel well. My issue with this episode had more to do with the portrayal of Jesus. I left a detailed explanation above.

@theeternalsbeliever1779

Ай бұрын

So tell us where the biblical Christ ever told someone to rely on what their heart told them.

@PaintDanceLive

Ай бұрын

Dallas is pushing the envelope and not in a good direction with how ep 3 ended. No one should assume how Jesus reacted to such a brutal act of violence. I'm not on board & never will be. Creative rogue writing of this measure is disturbing, and has an agenda.

@katierucker2870

Ай бұрын

@@theeternalsbeliever1779 It’s sad people don’t realize that this show has watered down the true Biblical Jesus. Yes, Jesus ate with sinners but He always called out their sin. Another problem is that they make this “Jesus” of the show more into our image instead of making us into His.

Loved the Episode and loved your recap Brandon. Rhema was lovely. We will all miss her smiling face. Yet, it's a tv show so we know that in reality, she is alive and well. Shalom to all.

@deniselanglois6193

Ай бұрын

Yes she plays a lesbian on NCIS Hawaii 😞

Thank you Brandon. You always come through to help me understand many details in this series and most of all the Bible. God Bless you for your great knowledge.

This episode is wonderful! I love the show and what it brings The breaking down of an episode episode helps me greatly. Please bring more 🙏

Wow, that historical context helps so much. Thank you!

im already greatful that there are people who made this story of Jesus happen despite many issues, we have our own bible to know whats fiction or not...i do not expect perfection from someone else coz i am not perfect too

Thank you Brandon for explaining this video. Ramah will be missed. My heart breaks for Thomas. I couldn't understand why Jesus didn't heal her. They were so in love. Great episode.

@marilynwebb8003

Ай бұрын

I think we needed this to see the pain Thomas went thru, and did not deny Christ.. did not leave Him. It is a direct message to all of us... Rely on Christ, especially when it's hard.. He will never leave you. I felt this was necessary. In 2 years, our 47 year old son died, then our first great grandson, my sweet sister, then my darling husband and Eternal companion . I have that blessing of knowing exactly where they all are and they are very busy bringing the Gospel to those that died before knowing Christ.

Another nice commentary from Brandon.

I totally missed that ending and had to watch it again. WOW!!! I could not believe that!! I was screaming at my TV WHY!! I was so mad.

Probably setting up the doubting Thomas scene for later.

Great session, Brandon. Thank you.

I’m not perfect but am so glad I knew all these scripture references that were spoken! I understood so much more because of it!

This was excellent! Thanks

Your work is wonderful Pstr. Robins,, thank you so much!

I just had a gut feeling this written wrong. I understand that they have to add some to what is in the Bible to make a story but this putting Jesus in situations we have no idea how he would react truly. So with that being said, I love the show and feel like it has brought me closer to Lord. Just this seem like they got this one wrong.

@467076

Ай бұрын

Thomas and Rama were already married, this entire relationship progression in the show was just a fiction for entertainment. I really hope you’re reading your Bible and not using this show as evidence. You’re a fool if you do. Edit: I got caught up, Rama is not in the Bible, she's just a portrayal of Thomas "actual" wife. Although I don't know much else.

@donaldwilliamfry

Ай бұрын

@@467076 Understood. But how Jesus was portrayed seemed out of character with the Bible and with even The Chosen. I left a detailed response on why I was uncomfortable with it above.

@467076

Ай бұрын

@@donaldwilliamfry I've seen others say the same. But realistically how is anyone going to know exactly how Jesus was or even what he did or didn't do? Did he ever do anything like this? Probably not but how would we know. I mean look at how God was in the old testament? In the Old Testament people died by just touching the ark of the covenant but this is too mean for God to do? Or look at when he walked on water, he basically called Simon a fool for having little faith. If people had read or read their bible they would be able to separate the two and be like, "they we're already married so this is clearly not true." That's just me though. I know that's not how other people are.

@donaldwilliamfry

Ай бұрын

@@467076 Since it is fiction based in fact, comparing what they did in "The Chosen" to how the Bible portrayed Jesus is fair game. The Bible never even hinted at Jesus being not in control, and in fact, showed the exact opposite. That is a major break with a presentation the authors have numerous times have said is consistent with the intent of scripture.

@PaintDanceLive

Ай бұрын

I agree with you whole heatedly! I'm so glad I didn't see this in the theater, I would have been so very disappointed. It's the reaction that was assumed Jesus would have, and it was not in character. Also it doesn't make sense that Thomas would have put himself in danger to go search for his beloved Rhema only to walk her right by the sword of Crazed Quintus!! Where are the Rogue elements of creative carte blanche taking this series, and what is the agenda??! Episode 2 was so great and now this!?

“Jesus” in the episode also looked as if he lost self-control. Unaware of the cost coming with the scene he helped foment that ultimately led to his reservation in hearing one of his devoted disciples. It made “Jesus” look like he was unwilling to reconcile the situation, rather he rationalized his inaction with her eventual resurrection. Yet, “Jesus” did resurrect the little girl and will later resurrect Lazarus. Not sure this scene is consistent with the broader narrative. Plus, this internal Roman discord would probably not have happened. Instead, the crowd would have been controlled at spear point and formation. I say this episode was way outside of biblical and historical norms.

@deb9806

Ай бұрын

Dallas said Jon wasn't sure how to play that scene and I saw that. It just didn't flow well. It seemed off to me and I think that is why Thomas moved me on her body but I didn't cry as I did with Mary Magdeline, Matthew, Nicodemus, etc. It seemed contrived and I've seen at 65 way too many of these scenes. We know Jesus can't cure all but he did in the Bible over and over again.

@sarahmclaughlin9157

Ай бұрын

This is whaf I didnt like about it. Jesus looked like it was a loss of control, not that she died. Also so inaacurate, something like this would have caused a revolt possibly. It was terribly done. I could buy that she got sick and died but this was too Hollywood.

Everyone is upset about Rama being killed. Could there be a different ending like Rama's father forbidding her to leave and go back to Jesus? But if you read the Bible, Peter is the only one with a wife. So Thomas being married would not be in sync with what was in the gospels. Remember, some liberties about some things may be taken, but Dallas is staying with what is in the bible.

Very helpful! Thanks.

Thank you for the explanation. Very helpful

I've been wondering about the "sign of Jonah". Thanks for explaining that to us!

There are many Martyrs who died for the sake of following Jesus! Even today! This episode shows that even being a follower has pain and death, however this death is only in the flesh. We have eternal life. We are supposed to walk, giving our lives to god daily! Dont you know the cost of being Christian? We have been purchased by his blood to be vessels to deliver the good news.

@donaldwilliamfry

Ай бұрын

Martyrdom, with the exception of John the Baptist, simply is not shown in the Gospels. This is a post-Pentecost theme. This death was out of place as was the demeanor of Jesus. It seemed to show Jesus out of control of the situation and placing his disciples in harm's way while being oblivious to this until after the death of Rehma. The disciples seemed to be herding a shell-shocked Jesus, looking more like Biden handlers than Jesus' disciples.

@Monica-zt6yl

Ай бұрын

@@donaldwilliamfry You just lost any credibility you had with your ignorant last sentence. And no, I'm not a democrat.

@donaldwilliamfry

Ай бұрын

@@Monica-zt6yl But you are one who "cancels" like a pro. You appear to be "woke." Sorry, I don't play that game.

@Royal-94

Ай бұрын

@@donaldwilliamfry you assume way too much about this guy's politcal views based off a Bible Series

@donaldwilliamfry

Ай бұрын

@@Royal-94 It was an analogy...a word picture to capture what I am saying. It was not a political statement, simply the person who is most identifiable in a leadership role who needs to be protected from himself. Perhaps it is you who are projecting politics into the statement?

Thank you for sharing

This is really great, Brandon!

You still didn't explain why Quintus killed Ramah. She was never a direct threat to Quintus. She must have been in the wrong place at the wrong time.

@artgalleryandcraftsbydeb9135

Ай бұрын

Yes he meant to kill Thomas.

@candicefrye4463

Ай бұрын

Frankly, I think he was out of control at that point. I don’t think he specifically was out to kill Ramah. But he was out to make a statement. She just, as you say, was in the wrong place at the wrong time. Just my opinion.

@judithkepner9657

Ай бұрын

I think he was drunk. Remember he took that woman’s wine outside his office?

@lorikeffer6339

25 күн бұрын

@@candicefrye4463 I share your opinion.

@Angellosa

22 күн бұрын

He didn't want to kill anyone, it was an accident.

For My thoughts are not your thoughts, Nor are your ways. But we shall continue to put our Trust in You.❤

i don't think quintas killed her on purpose i think he was aiming for thomas knowing he was one of the followers. remember In the Bible, there is no clear indication of whether Thomas was married or single. The only direct reference to his marital status comes from a passage in Matthew 19:27-30 that is often interpreted as Thomas being unmarried. There is no other information available on whether Thomas had a wife or not. However, some sources suggest that Thomas was skeptical about having a wife due to his parents' unhappy marriage, and he grew up with a pessimistic disposition. Learn more:

@EJ-gx9hl

28 күн бұрын

I blame Thomas for her death. How could he not see Roman soldier with large sword in hand and he decides to pass by right in front of him

@suebaxter301

28 күн бұрын

@@EJ-gx9hl actually there are indication in the bible that thomas was never married or had a wife, learned this on the chosen sleuth youtube, when he was going thru the episode and showing the warning of the roman solider losing his mind and lost it. or maybe it was brandon, they both seems to have connection to the chosen series

Thank you Brandon❤❤❤

Phenomenal!! God bless all of you!!

Oh Brandon u r so good at explaining from Hebrew perspective!! Thank u again❤

@humbleberean

Ай бұрын

We today ourselves have the power through the Ruach to understand the scriptures in Hebrew. This was and will be in the Kingdom the true language. Pray that Yah will give you understanding when you read the scriptures and start from the beginning (Genesis) and He will start to open your eyes to His Truths.🙏

Once more I have to thank you Pastor Brandon taking the time to dissect every episode of The Chosen. You make a great teacher. You make us read between the lines but also to understand what’s between the lines. Thank you for taking the time to prepare the explanation of every episode and air it right after it airs on TV ✝️🌹🇨🇦

Thank you. This was a good study.

Wow thank you that was a great messg e and you did a good job explaining this.

Thank you

Thank you, this is a good video. 🙏🙏🙏

Loved the explanation, but still doesn't cover why Thomas just decides to bump into Quintuss so recklessly in the middle of a crowd

@debrakeeler2816

Ай бұрын

Watch the after show for this episode on The ChosenApp. Joey explains why he decided to do this as an actor….

@467076

Ай бұрын

Probably because at the end of the day it’s still entertainment lol I love this show, it’s awesome but this did not happen. Rama and Thomas were actually married and their relationship progression in this show is fiction. She did not die from a Roman. I didn’t feel sad when she got killed because I’m like, “this actually didn’t happen” the creator was just trying to show a different message, he said it in his live.

@donaldwilliamfry

Ай бұрын

@@467076 But the message was out of place as was the depiction of Jesus in this scene.

@467076

Ай бұрын

@@donaldwilliamfry I feel like now you're asking the creator to basically think like you. Look at how many denominations we have but everyone wants this creator to think like you. That be like me saying, "well the creator isn't Catholic so I should avoid this show for that reason." It's entertainment, and how would I know what Jesus would or wouldn't do?

@44seewjay

Ай бұрын

@@467076Ramah isn’t a Biblical character at all. None of scenes “happened”

Best explanation ever!🤩

The storyline with Raimah made complete sense to me. We are ALL Gods children and He does say NO We are merely human and will never fully understand. That said I expected something like this because 1). The storyline needed to reconcile fact that Thomas is never said to have a girlfriend or wife anywhere in the Bible. 2). The loss of Raimah easily makes us understand how Thomas becomes “doubting Thomas” 3) The unrest this shows leads into other Biblical events such as a Zealot uprising and a storyline with Barabbas.

Thank you, Brandon, for explaining the meanings of abolish (misinterpret) the law and fulfill (properly interpret) the law. I have wondered about that statement of Christ Jesus’ for some time. Now it makes sense!

Aw, why'd they have to kill off Rhema? Not necessary. Nowhere is it written that Jesus ever withheld healing either, unless it was from lack of faith. He should have healed her, would have been much closer to scripture. She was good actress and likeable character too.

@gloriareyes441

Ай бұрын

They couldn't add healing her because that is not biblical

@commonlysensible

Ай бұрын

They could have made it that she couldn’t give up her family and decided to go back…

@johns7530

Ай бұрын

@@commonlysensible Yes, better idea!! : )

This episode was very personal for me. I went to the theater to watch. 2023 was a year of extreme grief for me and my family. We lost my only two adult grandchildren 5 months between their deaths and on Christmas day the man I was to marry that helped me thru died. No, this part ( Thomas and Rahmah) isn't biblical, but it helped me.

Once again Brandon great explanation of this episode. This episode really touched home for me. My son lost his life in Iraq in 2018 I never questioned God it increased my Faith in God. Losing a child is the worst kind of loss. God was with me then like he is now. I will always be faithful to him. Great breakdown Thank you

@jonbird6566

Ай бұрын

I struggle to understand your level of understanding and acceptance. I never went to the battle, but I was in the military and saw many brothers lose their lives overseas. I felt so guilty that I was not allowed to go myself. I sat back here and could not help in the fight, and could not be there to save those that died. Maybe I would have just been another casualty, but maybe I could have saved those who ultimately died. Why wasn't I allowed to be there? I should have been, and that eats me up every day

@annemarie748

Ай бұрын

God Bless you Cythia

@lisaderuzzio5639

Ай бұрын

@@jonbird6566 Hi Jon, bring this question to Jesus in deep prayer. Try not to over think it. Do not live in deep regret. God’s ways are far beyond our way’s & understanding. If need be, share your struggles with a holy pastor, priest, counselor. Get the help you need. Trust in God! Do not despair! I’ll pray for you too.

@grcleve7053

Ай бұрын

🙏

@lighthouse5891

27 күн бұрын

May God continue to bless you and surround you with His Peace.

The issue here is the games being played with Jesus' CHARACTER. I'll repaste the comment I made elsewhere here: Even as a Catholic, I've always defended the Chosen for their creative liberties from the attacks of others, some of whom are Catholic, but I cannot defend this episode. Nope! This was incredibly in bad taste, not because Rama died but the way these people seem to just casually project their own very flawed character traits onto Christ. I can defend Jesus choosing not to heal Rama (perhaps), but I cannot defend him standing there watching her die from a distance and not even giving her a single word of comfort as she died, not kneeling over her, closing her eyes, praying for her as she transitioned to the other world, assuring her that he would make all things well and this was not the end, and kissing her forehead as she died. He. Was. Her. Rabbi!!!!!!! If he had prayed then opened his eyes after getting the "Not this time" from his Father, then comforted her this way, it'd be sad but still in keeping with his character. But the way they did it feels like a Hollywood gimmick for shock value. Heck, even our flawed, sinful priests know how to comfort a dying person better than the Chosen's Jesus did in this episode! Did Jesus behave like Rama's spiritual Father or even her Rabbi in this episode? Nope. Think of Aragon comforting Boromir as he died after sacrificing his life to save the hobbits at the end of the Fellowship of the Rings. That's how a good and holy person treats a dying person. They don't stand at a distance and watch them go as if they're a stranger watching the scene of an accident by the side of the road. The Chosen had Our beloved beautiful Lord behaving like the Priest and pharisee he warned about in his parable of the Good Samaritan instead of like the Good Samaritan, and this with his own dying disciple! Not even a stranger beaten by thieves on the road. Honestly, shame on them! They injected their own character flaws onto Jesus in this episode and had him acting in a way contrary to how the Bible and even their own show has portrayed him. Rama was his disciple! She left her own Father and everything to follow him and he became her spiritual Father, killed basically for him in this episode, and yet he reacts worse than even a basic friend would react. I'm not angry about her death. I'm angry about the gimmicky nonsense they seem to be getting up to with Jesus' character. What Priest did they consult for this episode? They claim they consult theologians, pastors, and priests. All I can say is if the Priest okayed this episode, knowing the work priests regularly do with the dying in hospitals and other places, shame on him, too! Someone elsewhere said, given we've already done this before with Little James and Peter's baby, what was the point? It's like they saw it worked before and just can't be creative? Another comment under another video suggested they could've had Reyma married off by her Father to another, richer man. She would not have returned to Capernaum but sent a letter to an eager, hopeful Thomas telling him she had seen her Father's wisdom and chosen to go with it and allow Thomas to follow Jesus and hoped he would understand. Jesus would've accepted this and not agreed with Thomas about "doing something." Then this would've been about Thomas's broken heart and Jesus loving him back to Spiritual health instead of Jesus being portrayed like a bad shepherd

@johns7530

Ай бұрын

Yep, you are right. Nowhere is it written that Jesus withheld healing from anybody apart from lack of faith. If it were true to character he would have healed her. Totally unnecessary murder that is nowhere in scripture. I'm all for some creative freedoms but not if they're basically making stuff up out of thin air that isn't particularly inspiring or well thought out. Having said that, I think The Chosen has a large audience and has almost undoubtedly brought at least a couple people to Christ, so it's hard to argue with that outcome. I think it is still a net positive even if I agree with your points.

@kennethdoughty644

Ай бұрын

Jesus wept over Lazarus.

The lord has blessed 🙌 me with a great imagination 🙏. When I watch the chosen that's what I see is image but I hear the words of the Bible his words my God. Johnathan does an amazing job delivering these scriptures he keeps my attention steady.Before I started watching this show my heart was dead 💔. Now 4 years later I'm feeling and hearing my God's voice and understanding better then I ever have. I know I'm far from being with one in the Holy Spirit,as God my witness I will get there 🙏 in Jesus precious name amen 🙏 🙌 😊

Thank you!

I didn’t notice this rushed scene at all in the movie. Even in this replayed scene, the murder isn’t obvious at all. I just was so baffled that Rhema was dead later on when I watched later scenes. You mean Quintus just randomly stabbed her of all people in the crowd?

SHALOM!

Thx

Thank you so much for all your deep explanations Brandon!

@dargostvolos614

Ай бұрын

he would have he always did in the bible

I love your channel, very informative regarding biblical/historical topics. Thanks for that. Regarding The Chosen episode, while I understand your point...I fell it was unnecessary, the killing of Ramah was more for shock value than anything (alas G.O.T. or those shows where they make you like a character just to kill it next season). I think was a mistake for many reasons, first I really doubt Jesus would allow that to happen in his presence...second, why you'd kill one of the few women characters in the show (seems sexist to me and by the reaction of some unbelievers), she's loved by everyone...the story about her romance with Thomas has been building through the 3 seasons, for what?, we've learned a lot about the marriage traditions of the time...Now, I really loved how they handle "little" James not being healed by Jesus, but this looks like overreaching...there was no need for that, the show is great as it is, no need to add shock scenes just for have something to talk, which is what you (the creators) want, but the point should be about Jesus and not about what He (supposedly) didn't do regarding His closest friends and followers.

Thanks!

Wonderful

Thank you for this explanation it's helped bring the word to life for me. During the Episode I was hearing or thinking they was never a Rama, and when she died ‭ John 6:39 NLT‬ [39] And this is the will of God, that I should not lose even one of all those he has given me, but that I should raise them up at the last day. ‭John 6:39 KJV‬ [39] And this is the Father's will which hath sent me, that of all which he hath given me I should lose nothing, but should raise it up again at the last day. But in the last moments of Rama it looked like Thomas loved her more than anything and in the previous episode Jesus said you should love me more than anything and anyone. So this looked to me like Thomas journey of shedding his past and anything that could potentially hold him back from giving Jesus his all as we know he went onto preach the gospel in Asia etc. They was a scene where Rama saw a pregnant woman with her husband walking by and itwas like a little revelation to her of how she would have to stop walking with Jesus if she wanted a family.

I like the humor scenes 😂

I knew there had to be some resolution to the Thomas / Ramah arc. It was well done, if hard to watch.

i think they made this scene to explain why Thomas was so sceptical when he heard that Jesus has risen from the dead. But whatever the reason is, in my opinion it was wrong to let a symphatic person die which we know since 4 seasons. The Jesus from this Series refused to help her, that's not my Jesus from the Bible..My Jesus said: "While I was with them, I kept them in your name, which you have given me. I have guarded them, and not one of them has been lost except the son of destruction, that the Scripture might be fulfilled." John 17,12 I have no problems with creative freedom, but i have a problem portraying a character which contradicts clear the biblical one.

Wow you are incredible 👍

I love The Chosen so much. Much of our faith has been misunderstood by thinking the Law is done away with. Jesus upheld the Law and it is still in effect today.

Thomas told Raman to leave and go with Jesus and the apostles. She stayed, not obeying, and it cost her, her life. Many times we ignore warnings and God’s leading, and it can be quite costly.

That was a tough episode. But Ramah’s last words to Thomas are a lesson that Jesus spoke in the Gospel According to Matthew. Anyone who loves their father or mother more than me is not worthy of me; anyone who loves their son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me. Whosoever does not take up their cross and follow me is not worthy of me. -Matthew 10: 37-38 It sounds harsh, but it is a testament of faith. To focus on the LORD and to not be distracted. True faith is true love 🙏☀️

@annemarie748

Ай бұрын

Wow yes that scripture worries me .....Do I love my parents or my children more than JESUS? I love everyone. I worship My LORD give thanks to my LORD cant wait for our Blessed Hope, but is that enough? Oh boy 'avision' you stomped me

@avisionthroughchrist

Ай бұрын

@@annemarie748 Our faith is a blessing to the LORD in return for His mercy, grace, and patience. Jesus describes love not as choosing favorites, but as something that is nourished within so that we can fully love others. Going back all the way to the Books of Moses, the relationship between God and His children have always been a work in progress. Such as a garden or a temple, our faith to the LORD should continually grow through our days regardless if we get what we “want” or not. God’s will, not ours. Seek first the kingdom of God and his righteousness, and all these things will be added to you. -Matthew 6: 33 That is the short version lol But to answer your question, Yes you are enough 🙏☀️ Allow your faith to be an example and a testimony to your family. And never underestimate the power of planting a seed ✨

@kennethdoughty644

Ай бұрын

It's hard enough telling the Gospel with out explaining All These things.

@theresak4343

24 күн бұрын

@@annemarie748 Avision has no power to stomp you; it's the Word of God that has all the power; we are all just fellow sinners and messengers.

Hey, could you please be careful about showing spoilers on your KZread cover video pictures? I unfortunately got spoiled on Ramas death because I missed the livestream was going to watch it today with my family. I love your video breakdowns but not everyone has or is able (like in foreign countries) to watch this episode.

@ML-ni1tk

Ай бұрын

same. i saw his thumbnail and instantly new 😭

@MLMingus

Ай бұрын

the news has been out since winter.

When Jesus broke down being told Lazarus died, he cried because he knew he would raise him!!!! He knew it was the beginning of the end. His father's plan would NOW be done. My heart cried for his human side. King of the Universe, Holy Father your so is coming home to you after forgiving our sins. I BELIEVE!!!

Why is it important for individuals to consider both the negative and positive aspects of life before making decisions? Well, if we only look at one side of life it's like looking only one way before crossing a two-way street. Life has two sides just as a two-way street does, ignoring either side is not recommended. Would you cross a two-way street relying on faith or looking only one way before crossing it? If we choose to cross a two-way street without looking or looking only one-way before crossing it shows that we are willing to jeopardize not only our own life but others as well. Making life decisions based on assumptions is considered a gamble. Sometimes we may not have time to question some decisions but most of the time we do. If we refuse to question decisions especially if we have time to do so shows that we are not interested in being the best that we can be and are willing to gamble away our life or another...

An interesting point is made by the question posed to Jesus. This man was born blind. The question: “Who did sin? This man or his parents that he was born blind.” The implication is that he, as a spirit child of God, could sin before he was born. Hence, there is a place spirits exist before they are born and have choices to obey or disobey. Jeremiah 1:5 seems to back that up. Eccl 12:7 says at death the spirit returns to God who gave it. Acts 17:29 We are the offspring of God. Once we understand this concept the purpose of life takes on a whole new meaning. As Paul says, we can become joint heirs with Christ in Heavenly Father’s kingdom.

I'm not normally nit-picky about racial inferences because God is ONE! However, the pic of the Queen of Sheba coming to Solomon looks like an Anglo woman from Sweden and not an African Queen. lol Btw, The Chosen is really generous with an accurate racial balance full of color and the power of unity. I think its amazing how Dallas Jenkins has created an image of what a colorless society looks like. Shalom.

I recently found out that the word “Remah” (which sounds really close to Ramah’s name, also idk what language it’s in or if I spelled that correctly) actually means “sword”. They named her “sword” bc she died of a sword. *AAAAA-*

Thank you for the great content! I have a question I hope you can answer. Between Seasons 3 and 4, I've studied a good bit on Jewish traditions including some of the Talmud. So I now am shocked to hear Rabbi Akiva, one of the big names of the Talmud but nowhere in the Bible, mentioned so much in Season 4. I'm sure he was there all along but I just now noticed. So my question is, do we know anything about the role Rabbi Akiva played in the historical indictment of Jesus? Was he a member of the Sanhedrin? Were any Pharisees on the Sanhedrin at this time? Oops, I guess that was more than one question. Any insight is appreciated!

This reaction by people has taught me something. We are still unwilling to blame ourselves for the wicked acts of the world, sin in other words. We blame God for everything and think that Jesus who like us was human can stop everything and every harm to everyone at anytime with no consequences or heartache. Jesus I’m sure was exposed to many corruption and death through his ministry and I’m sure everyone wasn’t healed or saved.

Deep Message ❤❤❤

Could you please tell me where the information is about abolish and fulfill! Thank you

I love this video.. but mac and me?