I tried to teach Said's great nephew how to roll cigarettes once. Looking forward to this video!

@k.e.1760

Жыл бұрын

Hahaha!

@josepha133

Жыл бұрын

This might be my favourite comment on youtube ever

DUDE I love your summaries so much as a dyselxic it helps me understand the readings much better thank you!

@epochphilosophy

Жыл бұрын

Same.

I just wanted to let you know that I have listened to this video on Podcasts for the last couple of days because I had to talk about orientalism in my oral exam to gain my degree. And YES it worked! Thank you so much!

Very brief and clear introduction to orientalism!! I also watched your other videos for my exams and they helped a lot, so thank you❤

Thank you so much David, this has spring-boarded my learning and understanding! Wonderfully explained! Thank you for your channel.

I have watched some of your explanatory videos. They are very clear to understand. Thank you 👍🏻

Great job as always, David!

I hope you grow exponentially! Thanx a lot for your efforts and for putting out such quality content!

Perfect video! Thank you!

Thank you for your explanations

Hi. Could you please make videos on the 8th 10th 11th chapter of the book schools and styles of Anthropology...

Hi David! You have got this remarkable talent to explain these complex concepts with an enviable clarity and trenchancy. Can you please give me some insight on how the ordinary students can develop this spirit and what are the sources that they need to exhaust for developing a brick by brick structure of these ideas.

There are some massive lapses, contradictions, and empty spots in Said's application of his own idea. In the intro to one edition of Orientalism, Said claims that "the Orient" was (and is) only exploited and colonized because of oil, which wouldn't have happened if it had been, say, fruit. I went back and read the sentence several times, wondering if it was really possible that Said is ignorant of the history of the United Fruit Company or if I was just missing something. I would say for sure there's a Latin America-shaped hole in Said's analysis of colonialism and imperialism. Would recommend anyone reading Said also read Galleano to get a big missing piece of the puzzle.

@jeremiahzoric6091

Жыл бұрын

Very interesting, why do you think it is that Said ignores Latin America? He seems like a very intelligent man but I feel as though he paints the entire western hemisphere in a brush just like he is accusing them of doing with the orient

@areebzaidi7506

9 ай бұрын

Maybe while talking about the Orient, geography DOES play a part and he wilfully ignores Latin America and excludes it as a part of the Orient, which of course would still be a lapse in his judgement.

@Ko0okieeZ

8 ай бұрын

@@jeremiahzoric6091He’s from the middle east and speaks Arabic, so it would make sense that the middle east would be his main focus

The French Orientalism appeared in Egypt during the Napoleonic war with the amount of scientific and academic knowledge and tools before bringing the military according to Said.

Have you read Said!

Good videol

❤❤❤

5:55

Thanks for this comprehensive video. Don’t you think when we see British colonisation of America through the lense of Orient vs Occident polarisation, those 13 British colonies in America stand at the pole titled “ ORIENT”? Though America lies in the WEST, it was also colonised, suffocated, and prejudiced for decades by British/ Occident. Doesn’t that clearly makes America an Orient?

@jaideepsingh4395

4 ай бұрын

The american natives could come under the orient, but modern americans surely dont fit that definition, and since natives hardly have a presence today, it makes little sense to include america in the orient.

Said is widely respected but he ignores the reality namely that the orient is I Dian’s and the far east. Islam is not orient it is very western This is a grave error.Who fought the crusades , both are offshoots of Judaism with minor differences Both were justifications of genocides and theocratic terror that despised critical thinking . For a few hundred years the terror was pertrated by Christians and later by moslems . Said totally ignores history as it relates to theocratic mindset, of concerting everyone . This why he did not like Naipaul

Great explanation! But one thing I want to say is that Taiwan is part of China, not an independent country.

“For him the Orient doesn’t exist” you sure about your statement?

So long winded to start...

OK, let's see if he's doubling down...(watching)...he's not! Yaay! Let's listen some more...(watching more)...he's describing how the construction of the Orient applies everywhere else Europeans want to consider to be morally or otherwise inferior! Good! Oh no! He did it again! 3:40. He's talking about the "near Orient" -- "It is a little bit slippery" -- he's babbling about Arabic and Islam now, he's complaining about Said again! 4:26 He's asking us to watch the same video again! Where only he says what he just repeated! "Said is sloppy." The subtext for this is that our philosopher is working on his PhD!!! How long will he be doing that? Ah God! 4:28. It's over, he's back on track with Said's original concept again. But he seems to be convinced that this is not Said's insight??? But somehow his own? Is it because Said is an Arab? Perhaps it's not a case of possession by Orientalism, maybe it's a mental nervous tic of some kind. 6:00. Now he's explaining Said perfectly in Said's own words, explicitly showing how fundamentally insane it would be for a philosopher who has read Said to imagine that there is a real Orient. Yet there is no apparent self-awareness. Strange. One gets the idea that no apology will be forthcoming. (watching and listening about the white-Christian imperialist project, mutating from its religious form to its white Christian nationalist racist colonial form)...(listening about alienation and its promulgation through propaganda)...(military aggression)...(capitalism leaves no alternative) 13:09 "I think that democracy's good" -- well, now, there's a comforting statement -- is our man quite alright? So I guess he really did double down. It seems almost involuntary. No apology seems possible. What are the problems with the geographically untidy Said? That can only be guessed, unprofitably one hopes. PS. I would request Franz Fanon next. Here is a documentary about Edward Said and his experience as a Palestinian refugee: kzread.info/dash/bejne/aqya0a1tmZeblNY.html

@dangerousideas5356

Жыл бұрын

bodied

@SeekingApatheia

Жыл бұрын

What is going on with this comment

@numbersix8919

Жыл бұрын

@@SeekingApatheia The supposed problems or objections with Said locating or not locating the Orient geographically... it's the same in the longer video. I would very much appreciate a full explanation of where Said supposedly erred. Or at least an indication of where in the text of orientalism I can see an example of how Said supposedly has gone wrong with his own idea.

@jeremiahzoric6091

Жыл бұрын

@@numbersix8919 Said stated that the oreint is really just something that originated in the mind of the west correct?

@AvgustGeorgi

Жыл бұрын

Apology? Did someone eat your baklava?

The little seal baby stuffed animal 🥲Also thank you so much, these reviews have saved my life in my literary theory class this semester!