What if Sidious was a *split personality* from Palpatine. Aka, what if Palpatine *didnt know* he was Sidious?

@user-qr3fm8jy8s

2 ай бұрын

This is interesting

@xxibjrosek

2 ай бұрын

Agreed. Definitely interesting.

@diamondplayz2145

2 ай бұрын

This is interesting

@Spedyboi

2 ай бұрын

This is actually really good Hol up

@x-track5190

2 ай бұрын

Old Age schizofrenia hit him hard

R2 picking up Anakin literally made me cry

@MC-zr7hl

2 ай бұрын

I loved that part

@leonardohinojosa5416

2 ай бұрын

Same

@LOL10060

2 ай бұрын

Lol same here 😊

@snyper5150

Ай бұрын

I didn’t cry but, I agree. That was some real George Lucas shit.

@SuperJimelliott

Ай бұрын

I laughed when someone stepped on R2's front foot, his head hinged back, and they threw in an empty Starbucks cup.

Han and Vader: " This is where the fun begins!"

@skeetermagee2487

2 ай бұрын

🤣

What if Obi-Wan defended Anakin after he was denied the rank of master?

@jamesplunkett8912

Ай бұрын

I'm sure Anakin would feel there's still hope, yet with Obi-Wan's support in convincing the Jedi to make Anakin a Master after everything he's done for them.

@kennethnieves9283

15 күн бұрын

What if Count Dooku Was A Máster duelist of The 7 Lightsaber Forms before the phantom menace and he was on par with Yoda in lightsaber abilitys and force

Now this is an approach I did not expect.

@user-cb1ip4nn2p

2 ай бұрын

i love where this point started

The two best pilots in the galaxy working together to destroy a whole fleet of Tie Fighters was so awesome. Nice seeing Light Side Vader flexing his flying skills after Yoda helped turn him back to the light. And R2 saving Anakin at the end was so wholesome. Even after being separated for so long, they are still true friends.

@ProjjectDelta.

2 ай бұрын

The Two Best Pilots of two different Eras, proving their skills in an attempt to out preform the other in an "Friendly" fight against the Empire. Truly an spectical.

@garygood6804

Ай бұрын

Wholesome? * gag *

Ironic, his desire to save his family pulled him to the dark side, and now it pulls him back to the light.

@shadowchild8592

2 ай бұрын

The tragedy of Darth Vader the Careing.

@rachelprighel4409

2 ай бұрын

For his family

@Smilelolhehe

2 ай бұрын

The hero with no fear.

@kyledea187mdkjr5

2 ай бұрын

He is the chosen one after all

@rachelprighel4409

2 ай бұрын

@@kyledea187mdkjr5 exactly

Yeah you glossed over Vader's return to the light. You could have had him do some deep reflection, and finally realize his entire descent into the Dark Side was a lie. Han Solo and Vader getting into a stick-measuring contest was a riot!

12:57 I kinda wanted to see Anakin go to the Millenium Falcon and drop to his knees saying "What have they've done to you" then run to the Millenium falcon and start making repairs because _How in the Force has this ship not fell apart yet? Nevermind I'll fix it on our way to save Luke, you can take me later_ cue Anakin going full mechanics nerd on all of them while improving the Falcon. I think Leia would be the most taken aback by this, she was held captive, and tortured, in the Death Star under Vader, so seeing him just ramble on and on about ships like an over excited little kid is going to be like entering the Twilight zone for her.

What if Obi-Wan escaped with Luke and Leia from the Death Star.

Day 2: What if Anakin knew Palpatine was a sith in Attack of the clones?

@rachelprighel4409

2 ай бұрын

I did

@top_banananaplays

2 ай бұрын

But kept it quiet just to troll him? That's something for April fools

@RFDN0

2 ай бұрын

@top_banananaplays there are honestly many ways it could play out. Palpatine could either know or not know. Anakin could know he is a Sith Lord or just that he is a Sith. These are just the two easiest variables before we get into any real meat for a story.

@M54894

2 ай бұрын

@@rachelprighel4409what do you mean

@rachelprighel4409

2 ай бұрын

Exactly

This particular version of Yoda, a bit more believing in redemption, he is. Understand the true meaning of "forever dominate your destiny, the dark side will", he does. Not doomed to forever be in the dark, it is, but rather always the scars it leaves, there will be.

Vader wielding a white purified saber makes perfect sense, especially with the Vader redeemed design, with Vader in his full suit being white

What if Emperor Palpatine got dementia during the events of the original trilogy.

@darrellhall6622

2 ай бұрын

He turned into the US President in our time.

@tchao1995

2 ай бұрын

Ah, so no change to the timeline, then.

@Automaton2337

2 ай бұрын

@@tchao1995 I'm sure the timeline will change he could have Emperor Palpatine blow up an innocent planet imagine the public outrage against the empire that could help the Rebellion.

@tchao1995

2 ай бұрын

@@Automaton2337 yes! Something like Alderon That would really upset the Rebels. And then, maybe, he could try to blow up Yavin IV

@Automaton2337

2 ай бұрын

@@tchao1995 I'm actually talking about innocent planets that aren't remotely connect to the Rebels.

This Actually Could've Happened if Yoda didn't Just Condemn Vader to his Fate

What if Vader got over his depression and reached his full potential.

I love this. No one has done a story like this. That's why you are a great story teller. Thanks again for the hard work and dedication to your craft.

@thestarwarsgalaxy

2 ай бұрын

Thank you very much!

What if in the end of the phantom menace in Naboo during the celebration when the fireworks are getting launched. Palpatine gets killed by a misfire firework that takes off his head

@Butterandbacon

2 ай бұрын

😂🤣😂🤣

@RandomMackem3247

2 ай бұрын

Trying to kill palps in the dumbest ways possible are we? Why not just have a bounty hunter accidentally blow up palps in his ship thinking it was padmes

Sarcasm from Vader? ROFLOL.I love it.❤

I have 2 ideas. 1: what if Han was force sensitive? 2: what if shmee was a jedi/exile? I think the idea of a shmee who either left the order to protect and raise Anakin, or was a rogue Jedi outcast could make for an interesting story.

Here's a "what if" nobody has touched upon yet (or maybe they have. If so, I deeply apologize, I don't read through every comment) What if Padme purchased Shmi from Watto, freed her and secured employment for her on Naboo after Episode I

Your storytelling skills are insane, and the way you come up with these stories really seems like something that would actually be canon!

Would love to see “What If Anakin and Obi Wan Went To Mandalore With Ahsoka”, if you haven’t done it yet

@hgtrftfr

2 ай бұрын

Pretty sure that Pente Patrol Star Wars has done a vid on that. Also, I can't remember if this guy has done so

@rachelprighel4409

2 ай бұрын

Exactly

You could heal him and have him return as anakin truly

I loved the ending with Anakin and R2.

What if Han Solo was Anakin’s Padawan? That would be interesting I think. Han being force sensitive, and raised in the temple, then given to Anakin while Ahsoka goes to Obiwan.

This was awesome! Really cool idea having Anakin come back. I wanna see one where he does help the rebellion defeat the empire. Get a new jedi looking suit and all that lol

I really enjoyed this what if, I liked the idea of Vader keeping his old republic starfighter in case of emergency :D

As always: R2 IS THE GOAT

Definitely unexpected but a very welcome and well written story. Thank you.

@rachelprighel4409

2 ай бұрын

Your welcome

@OriginalMomo

2 ай бұрын

@@rachelprighel4409 wasn’t talking to you 😜…. Unless you’re SWG incognito….

Day 8: what is Anakin had a 12 inch….light saber

Well played I liked Vader turning back to the light and helping Luke rebuild the order and him hiding from the new republic. I liked Han and Vader competing in space flight

He lived AND was saved by R2?! Favorite fan fiction from you so far!

Man thanks for keeping Star Wars alive with your frequent uploads 🙏🏾

Assuming that the Jedi Starfighter have the hyperdrive and enhanced shield upgrades. Most likely the Z95 headhunter spare parts as it's the most common kitbash parts to install on starfighters.

What if Qui Gon Jin Dooku and Sifo Dyas started their own Jedi order

That was a great story. It was cool to see Yoda help Vader become Anakin again and fight alongside Luke, Han, Leia, and Chewbacca when they went to save Luke from the Emperor.

I love how you incorporate the comics in this

Day one of asking what if Jaesa Willsaam (light side) was in the Clone Wars? The idea is that shortly after Jaesa is recruited by the Sith Warrior, Darth Baras realizes the potential threat. He manages to capture her and freeze her in carbonite. After Darth Baras dies, Jaesa is never found and is eventually forgotten for the next 3000 years. Then, during the Battle of Christophsis, a tunnel to an ancient under city is discovered. Obi-Wan leads a squad of clones into the under city in order to gain a tactical advantage over the separatists. While here, to force leads him to a long forgotten prison. He finds Jaesa here and frees her. Shortly thereafter Jaesa rejoins the Jedi and becomes Obi-Wan's apprentice.

I've said it many times. This guy has the best What If stories. Awesome ❤🎉

I gotta tell you, brother your story this time had me in tears…. I think they were tears of joy…. but it was very cathartic. Thank you for writing that.

That was really originally and a new perspective of the story of Vader. And it's kinda logical, because the Emperor doesn't tolerate fulls or failures, and if we have to be honest, he had the idea to replace Vader from some time. Luke was the perfect candidate, and the only reason that Vader lasted so long as Palpatine's apprentice was the lack of good enough replacement. Mara Jade wasn't quite strong enough in the Force to directly replace Vader ( she wasn't week, simply Vader was on another level as pure power in the Force). And Mara's training and abilities was kinda differently oriented. I think that once the Emperor sensed Luke in the Force, he was determined to turn him to the Dark side one way or another. That's why Palpatine said to Vader in episode 5 that the son of Skywalker must not become a jedy ( not necessarily die, just not become a jedy).

Great story. But the R2 Anakin reunion was fantastic ❤😊

Your work is mostly legit. There, I said it. Now my inner super dork can stop saying, "Let me comment!"

@rachelprighel4409

2 ай бұрын

Okay then

What if cal Kestis never found the holocron and eno Cordova

What if Savage accidentally killed Dooku during their training?

Poor Hayden Christensen Skywalker general master sir

AWSOME STORY! This is a GREAT story. Keep coming up with these stories!

Your stories get better consistently. Thanks for the entertainment.

What if Cal Kestis made his way to Tantooine after Order 66 to hide?

Day 4 of asking: 1. What if Anakin started a Jedi Civil War? 2. (Inspired by an idea by Scott Braun, so credit him please) What if Padme was secretly a force user, trained by neither a Jedi or a Sith? (The story is the same until after Naboo is taken back. Anakin and Padme confess their feelings to each other in private, and that’s when Padme reveals to Anakin her force powers. Padme convinces Anakin to keep her force powers a secret, and to pursue their secret relationship. Later, Padme tells Anakin about her troubles with certain Senate members and starts sensing they are being shrouded by a dark fog by an unseen force, which could mean Padme starts catching onto Sidious, which she tells Anakin about, which starts to make Anakin suspicious of Palpatine. Past this, Padme always uses her force powers in secret, a secret only known by Anakin, and later Ashoka. As a result, Padme, Anakin and Ashoka secretly form their own order. Maybe to add something else, Padme senses Barriss Offee’s betrayal, so she and Ashoka catch Barriss and convince her that there are better ways than the Sith…) 3. What if Mace Windu, out of being jealous of Anakin and believing he should be the Chosen One, not Anakin, secretly studied Sith powers so he could kill Anakin? 4. What if Padme and Anakin adopted Ashoka after Ashoka left the Jedi order? 5. Part 2 of what if Padme Was A Sith Trained By Sidious 6. What if Anakin left the Jedi Order with Ahsoka? 7. What if Ahsoka was executed when framed for the bombing of The Jedi Temple (I think Anakin would know Palpatine was the one who ordered that execution, and since he would, he would end his friendship with Palpatine and leave the Jedi order and live with Padme. As a result, Palpatine is now no longer able to manipulate Anakin and has to find someone else to be his apprentice)? 8. What if the father didn’t erase Anakin’s memories? 9. What if Dooku was a double agent? 10. What if Ventress rejoined the Jedi order? 11. What if Ahsoka was a witch (not the type of witch as a normal female force user, I mean like an actual witch) with powers like shapeshifting, hypnosis (with her eyes), flight, etc disguised as a teenage Togruta?

@everythingproductions2004

2 ай бұрын

Day 5 of asking: 1. What if Anakin started a Jedi Civil War? 2. (Inspired by an idea by Scott Braun, so credit him please) What if Padme was secretly a force user, trained by neither a Jedi or a Sith? (The story is the same until after Naboo is taken back. Anakin and Padme confess their feelings to each other in private, and that’s when Padme reveals to Anakin her force powers. Padme convinces Anakin to keep her force powers a secret, and to pursue their secret relationship. Later, Padme tells Anakin about her troubles with certain Senate members and starts sensing they are being shrouded by a dark fog by an unseen force, which could mean Padme starts catching onto Sidious, which she tells Anakin about, which starts to make Anakin suspicious of Palpatine. Past this, Padme always uses her force powers in secret, a secret only known by Anakin, and later Ashoka. As a result, Padme, Anakin and Ashoka secretly form their own order. Maybe to add something else, Padme senses Barriss Offee’s betrayal, so she and Ashoka catch Barriss and convince her that there are better ways than the Sith…) 3. What if Mace Windu, out of being jealous of Anakin and believing he should be the Chosen One, not Anakin, secretly studied Sith powers so he could kill Anakin? 4. What if Padme and Anakin adopted Ashoka after Ashoka left the Jedi order? 5. Part 2 of what if Padme Was A Sith Trained By Sidious 6. What if Anakin left the Jedi Order with Ahsoka? 7. What if Ahsoka was executed when framed for the bombing of The Jedi Temple (I think Anakin would know Palpatine was the one who ordered that execution, and since he would, he would end his friendship with Palpatine and leave the Jedi order and live with Padme. As a result, Palpatine is now no longer able to manipulate Anakin and has to find someone else to be his apprentice)? 8. What if the father didn’t erase Anakin’s memories? 9. What if Dooku was a double agent? 10. What if Ventress rejoined the Jedi order? 11. What if Ahsoka was a witch (not the type of witch as a normal female force user, I mean like an actual witch) with powers like shapeshifting, hypnosis (with her eyes), flight, etc disguised as a teenage Togruta?

@everythingproductions2004

2 ай бұрын

Day 6 of asking: 1. What if Anakin started a Jedi Civil War? 2. (Inspired by an idea by Scott Braun, so credit him please) What if Padme was secretly a force user, trained by neither a Jedi or a Sith? (The story is the same until after Naboo is taken back. Anakin and Padme confess their feelings to each other in private, and that’s when Padme reveals to Anakin her force powers. Padme convinces Anakin to keep her force powers a secret, and to pursue their secret relationship. Later, Padme tells Anakin about her troubles with certain Senate members and starts sensing they are being shrouded by a dark fog by an unseen force, which could mean Padme starts catching onto Sidious, which she tells Anakin about, which starts to make Anakin suspicious of Palpatine. Past this, Padme always uses her force powers in secret, a secret only known by Anakin, and later Ashoka. As a result, Padme, Anakin and Ashoka secretly form their own order. Maybe to add something else, Padme senses Barriss Offee’s betrayal, so she and Ashoka catch Barriss and convince her that there are better ways than the Sith…) 3. What if Mace Windu, out of being jealous of Anakin and believing he should be the Chosen One, not Anakin, secretly studied Sith powers so he could kill Anakin? 4. What if Padme and Anakin adopted Ashoka after Ashoka left the Jedi order? 5. Part 2 of what if Padme Was A Sith Trained By Sidious 6. What if Anakin left the Jedi Order with Ahsoka? 7. What if Ahsoka was executed when framed for the bombing of The Jedi Temple (I think Anakin would know Palpatine was the one who ordered that execution, and since he would, he would end his friendship with Palpatine and leave the Jedi order and live with Padme. As a result, Palpatine is now no longer able to manipulate Anakin and has to find someone else to be his apprentice)? 8. What if the father didn’t erase Anakin’s memories? 9. What if Dooku was a double agent? 10. What if Ventress rejoined the Jedi order? 11. What if Ahsoka was a witch (not the type of witch as a normal female force user, I mean like an actual witch) with powers like shapeshifting, hypnosis (with her eyes), flight, etc disguised as a teenage Togruta?

One of my favorite what ifs

Fuckin loved this story, great as always. I might watch the stories after they come out but i always leave a like cause your stories are great and I'm glad you and ppsw do the videos, i can't be a part of the patreon cause I'm homeless and im sorry i wish i could help more

#3 What if Han didn’t survive the carbon freeze

@GodOfFuck777

2 ай бұрын

What if Han put Lando in Carbonite 4 his actions 🎬

What if Anakin became the Master of the order

Ok, so... why would Vader have a Jedi Starfighter of any kind? The Whitecloaks were decommissioned before the clone wars, Delta 7s were probably extremely rare at this point and the only people known to have flown the Eta-2 Actis were the Jedi and, for a very short time after Order 66, Vader, and as such would have all been scrapped. If anything, Vader would either be flying his personal TIE Advanced X1 or something he commandeered along the way. Actually, now that I think of it I could see this version of Vader being the owner of the N1 that in canon eventually ended up in Mando's hands.

I just wanted to let you know how much I love your videos ❤

I watch this stuff everyday you are an amazing story teller, thank you for all your hard work!

What if Kit Fisto survived order 66

Love Listening To Your Awesome, “What If’s” & Playing MineCraft 😁

Definitely not what i expected but it was grear!

What if padme gave obi wan the GWAK GWAK 3000?

This is a very nice written vid

I loved it! And I absolutely enjoy every single one of your videos thank you for trying your best to make these videos for us you are truly amazing.May the force be with and your channel ❤.

This is a great one!

You can do more og trilogies!

This was brilliant I really liked it

Love ur calming videos

Another amazing video like always! Keep up the good work!

Best one you have ever done.

Good work

Man i been missing a lot of comments but i want ya to know im still listening! Keep up this rate if you can ive been really enjoying it. Thank you for still keeping this up for this long and its been awesome to watch you grow.

I enjoyed this. Well done!

What if Padme joined the CIS

This was amazing thank you

Now don't hurt him master windu

@rachelprighel4409

7 күн бұрын

Do it master anakin Skywalker general master sir Hayden Christensen

@rachelprighel4409

7 күн бұрын

You have heard me chancellor palps

Such a wholesome and great story!

What if Chancelor Valorum stayed in office during Episode l; I watched episode l today

Great story nicely done - may the force be with you

This has to be one of your best

God I was crying when R2 saved his best friend. Hope 3P0 also had his memory restored to where he could reunite properly with his maker

What if Vader was killed when he was still adjusting to his suit

@mr.juniii5523

2 ай бұрын

Palpatine be like : i may have gone too far in some places.

Great work I really like it

very unexpected post, and a very unexpected and most welcomed plot twist=Another grand slam...:)) I was gonna say you didn't kill Obi-wan@Least, that was Lucas this time--hehehe ;p

@rachelprighel4409

2 ай бұрын

No way he won't die at all

@jonathanbranum8976

2 ай бұрын

hehehe--at this point of TSWG masterful retelling; strike me down Darth and I shall become more powerful than you can imagine, has already occurred. huh???

*What if Anakin and Shmie were never slaves*

Great story sir!!! That would really make a good movie as well

You know what question recently popped into my mind? If Yoda used the Mind Trick on someone, did Yodas speech pattern gets mimicked by whoever he mind-tricked, or did they retain their normal speech pattern?

I had a funny thought when Princess Leia married Han Solo. She just married a version of her dad Darth Vader in Han Solo.

I am picturing Vader with the rebels as part of a cast of characters in an 80s sitcom

I enjoyed your take .

Awesome. Loved it ❤

this was great!

These are the kind of "What If" scenarios that should have been done by Disney if a Star Wars What If series was done. There are so many possibilities centered around Anakin/Vader. One of my favorites is Luke managing to save his life after Vader becomes Anakin again and Anakin working with his son to redeem himself over the years while finally feeling a sense of family once he was finally accepted by the others, ultimately facing Abeloth and becoming one with the Force.

I loved this

Love the vids

Nice story. I liked it.

I would love to hear What If story that mainly involves Han Solo

After everything, Qui-Gon still believes Anakin is the chosen one (,:

Nicely done! Years ago; I wrote my own Vader redemption story. In it though; Vader and Luke were still on the second Death Star, and just be fore the station’s self destruct could take effect; this was when the Force would come over Vader’s body, and split Anakin from Vader, healing Anakin and making him whole once more; as Vader inhabited the armor before fading out of existence, armor and all. Anakin and Luke then leave the station just as it implodes, and land back on Endor. After the celebration on the moon; Anakin tells Luke and Leia everything, and Leia does forgive him; as she realizes he was Palpatine’s puppet all along, and everything he did; he did out of an misguided sense of love. This is when the Force resurrects Padme; Bail Organa and his wife Breha; Owen and Beru, and Shmi. Obi-Wan chose to remain a Force Ghost. Vader’s death reverberated through the netherworld of the Force, causing the Force to be balanced. Anakin and Luke first teach Leia everything they know about the Force; then establish an new Jedi academy on Coruscant, and enforce attachments, and teach that they are neither good or bad; it is the person’s choices that make them either.

Very nice touch with R2