Next Video Will Come Out Next Wednesday When We'll Resume Our Multi-Upload Schedule! As Always Expect It At 2:30pm EST! IMPORTANT: To Those Unaware, Discord Has Deleted Our Server And It Would Appear The Accounts Of All Our Members As Well. This Is Unfortunate, But I Call It A Good Awakening To The Fact We Shouldn't Waste Our Time With This Service. Questions Can Be Posted Here Or At The USofZ.com

@user-kt8yp5ho2y

5 жыл бұрын

Oh boy, I can't wait to see your new video. By the way, can you make a video about what if Poland won the WW2 and What if China won the Sino Japanese War in 1937?

@giannimatteo9196

5 жыл бұрын

Why does every single one of your videos have a fucking awful flag as the thumbnail

@AT-vs7ho

5 жыл бұрын

So I'm not sure whats up, but I've got my volume cranked up to 100% on everything and I can barley hear this video. everything else on youtube is super loud.

@Benjamin-Franklin

5 жыл бұрын

@@giannimatteo9196 If you don't like it there is an exit Right over there

@fduranthesee

5 жыл бұрын

What if Jeb Bush won the 2016 election, bringing back the Bush Dynasty and forcing America into the Please Clap era?

what if the entire British Cabinet was assassinated in 1992 by the IRA destroying Downing Street

@lukeg6017

5 жыл бұрын

Mathieu Leader goodbye Ireland

@monroecorp9680

5 жыл бұрын

Mr Z do this one, FUCKING DO IT

@iGabenewell

5 жыл бұрын

1991*, if you're talking about the mortar attack, also seconded.

@mikeoxsmal8022

5 жыл бұрын

@@lukeg6017 no the ira is not ireland

@irishbrother4289

5 жыл бұрын

Luke G lmao

Eurogang here before the video gets blocked

@BucketPukes1969

4 жыл бұрын

VPN?

@user-go3jv8rw7i

4 жыл бұрын

Michael Thomson what country are you living in?

@jakegalvin6946

3 жыл бұрын

Still hasn't been blocked

@erikthomsen4768

3 жыл бұрын

@@UCs8rKLLoW435fDJqyFT1kug So how is your fear of Europeans holding up? Nobody has touched this video. I am from a country where you would apologize if you condemn someone of something they didn't do. But I suppose we could all start hating each other like idiots. But am not that international. Same goes for you @@UCBusCBn6f9ypFvd0-hRtzgg

@31ll087

3 жыл бұрын

I am legit from Ireland and can watch it.

Great video my friend

@jakegalvin6946

3 жыл бұрын

Will you do videos on Ireland?

@hoppy5359

3 жыл бұрын

@@jakegalvin6946 he did

What if George Lincoln Roswell & Roswald Mosley teamed up?

@dalegribble7939

5 жыл бұрын

I wanna see that

@heathjohnson2698

5 жыл бұрын

The world would be saved

@fristnamelastname5549

5 жыл бұрын

YES!

@Sephaos

5 жыл бұрын

Please?

@JoseGonzalez-hp9uy

5 жыл бұрын

Whos rosewell?

I was not luck that saved him it was his American citizenship that saved his life

@jakegalvin6946

3 жыл бұрын

American citizenship did save de Valera

@jwil4286

3 жыл бұрын

So the British were scared of backlash from executing a criminal?

@purplepumkinater5465

3 жыл бұрын

@@jwil4286 yes

@jwil4286

3 жыл бұрын

@@purplepumkinater5465 huh. I thought the British after WW1 were at the peak of their power. guess they saw the writing on the wall that America would overtake them.

@sachemofboston3649

3 жыл бұрын

@@jwil4286 He was a revolutionary not a criminal

Finally, a alternative history based on Ireland

@Ihatebritain

11 ай бұрын

Ye

@markeustace199

Ай бұрын

definitely check out the Kaiserreich alternate history animated videos, there's now one set in an alternate history Ireland

Might I add though, at the time of partition, you often found many of the most Anglicised areas in Ireland being around Dublin (generally along the east coast) and there were still areas north of the border that were Gaelic-speaking, and more culturally Gaelic than some parts of the south - believe it or not. It so happened that the north had a majority of unionists and the south had a majority of nationalists. Looking deeper into Irish history and it gets even more complicated 👍🏻

@InfernosReaper

2 жыл бұрын

That is usually how these things work. If there was a clean divide, then the 2 parts would've more easily been able to go their own ways

What If Ireland Became Fascist? England: *tea time stops*

@sorcererberoll4641

4 жыл бұрын

/Love/ /Peace real shit

Fianna Fáil is pronounced “Fee-nah Fall” and Fine Gael is pronounced “Fee-nah gale”. That’s not even near the hardest pronunciations in our language, we have some odd grammar rules!

@jakegalvin6946

3 жыл бұрын

I will never fully understand the Irish language but they have some weird pronounciations and grammar rules . E.g if you were to directly translate 'bhí mé sa scoil 'it would be was I in school but with the weird rules in Irish it turns into I was in school

@markroche9812

3 жыл бұрын

The Fianna Fáil mispronunciation I could handle, but “Fine Gael” actually hurt to hear hahah

@bothi00

3 жыл бұрын

@@markroche9812 tbf a lot of people pronounce fine gael (knowingly as well) the way he did as well and refer to them as that.

@John.McMillan

2 жыл бұрын

I can pronounce and mostly speak and understand enough Gaelic from all isles to hold a conversation, But I cant read or write fucking anything, it all absolutely escapes me.

@calibvr

2 жыл бұрын

Well, it was romanised from ogham & the changes kept happening

What if the Soviet Afghan war never happened What if Ireland became protestant P.s. it's pronounced fianna fall

@eoinharrington2692

5 жыл бұрын

@@goodluckgorsky3413 I feel like that's just a what if 9/11 never happened in disguise

@hiiamnicehiiamnice5697

5 жыл бұрын

Its feena fall thats how is Prounced

@eoinharrington2692

5 жыл бұрын

@@hiiamnicehiiamnice5697 yeah ok the first a is unstressed so you can say either

@jibrilly

5 жыл бұрын

It's actually pronounced Feena foyle, uncultured swine

@eoinharrington2692

5 жыл бұрын

@@jibrilly of course , my apologies

What if lenin was shot dead during his first assasination attempt in January 1918 and therefore the Soviets never signed the Brest-Litovsk treaty? If someone have good ideas about this topic let me know.

What if emperor nero lived What if Britain stayed roman What if Rome fell earlier

@martychisnall

5 жыл бұрын

Kevin Hixson what if the Britannic Empire survived

@siyarg.4900

5 жыл бұрын

What if other European countries never tried to conquer England is possibly a much bigger question, the English tribes would still be pure Celtic and would probably get along very well with the Irish tribes

@kevinhixson1586

5 жыл бұрын

@@siyarg.4900 yeah interesting question but I'm pretty sure they would have just been a larger Ireland/Scotland or even more interesting because there still mostly pagan the Teutonic order conquers them instead of prussia

Pew Valera dieing early would have so many other repercussions. After not getting executed in 1916 he was an important participant in the War of Indipendence.

To be real, being so close to Spain, Ireland would likely opt out of the Axis, seeing it as too much a risk to join, just like Spain did.

@Op37373

7 ай бұрын

Yeah, the civil war was still on people's minds just like Spain

De Valera wasn't released due to backlash. His sentence of death was commuted to life in prison because he was a US citizen and Britain didn't want to cause a diplomatic incident. He was later broken out of jail by Michael Collins. Interestingly he was half Spanish with De Valera being an anglicanised Spanish name as opposed to an Irish one.

@johnkeating4221

6 ай бұрын

DeValera was s foreigner whereas Michael Collins was a true Irish man committed to his oeoole

@tempejkl

3 ай бұрын

@@johnkeating4221Connolly was also fully committed, yet a foreigner

@johnkeating4221

3 ай бұрын

@@tempejkl Connolly was a Socialist with social aspirations. Being Scottish he was also like the Irish of the Celtic race.

@GAMER123GAMING

2 ай бұрын

@@johnkeating4221 Scots arent celts

@johnkeating4221

2 ай бұрын

@@GAMER123GAMING Why not.

Great video, the pronunciation of the two leading parties are: Fianna Fáil - Feeyana Fall (meaning; Soldiers of Destiny) Fine Gael - Finah Gayle (meaning; tribe of the gaels)

@jakegalvin6946

3 жыл бұрын

Everyone I know says feena fall and finah gayle

Just saying, O'Duffy wasn't a fascist, this isn't like a technicality thing, he just wasn't. He wanted an alliance with the fascist powers to take back our land, but he wasn't. Gearóid Ó Cuinneagáin and his party were actually fascist, if anything O'Duffy was closer to Peron, Metaxis, or any of the other Military strongmen or politicians propped up by the army. Take a look into him, he was quite left leaning, even if he was staunchly anti-communist

@Tamalegooch

5 жыл бұрын

flamingeskimo 11 like Franco or Chiang Kai Shek

@flamingeskimo1136

5 жыл бұрын

@@Tamalegooch yeah, both believed in a free market with a strong government

@TheIlluminatiDetect

4 жыл бұрын

How was he left-leaning? Yes, Ó Cuinneagáin and ná Ailtirí were fascists, but I find the claim that O'Duffy wasn't a fascist to be eyebrow raising at the least. You're the first person I've ever seen to claim that

@dreamypunx

2 жыл бұрын

based

@eagleowl833

2 жыл бұрын

"He wanted an alliance with the fascist powers to take back our land" Oh no we got a irish person defending fascists because they can't come to terms with the fact that the northerners chose to stay with the uk 😑

Roses are red I belong in the Hague what if cholera killed more than the bubonic plague video 2

@nolol135

5 жыл бұрын

that's a pretty shitty situation lmao

@Cjnw

5 жыл бұрын

O'Normie

@kingdomofbird8174

4 жыл бұрын

@@nolol135 well it's bad But because people is bigger That means Fewer percentage (%) will die

@Perririri

2 жыл бұрын

*G E K O L O N I S E E R D*

They would likely take a tip from Spain and be as neutral in war as possible

In the early stages of WW2 the Irish had some ties to the Germans. This ended in 1942

@damonmaddox3173

5 жыл бұрын

Thanks

You're so quiet in this video. Put up the volume on your mic!

@BigMan-gr8re

5 жыл бұрын

Thats what I said last time but ooohhhhh no

"be free and be Irish" That's me after too many drinks

@blacknwhitegaming

4 жыл бұрын

Share a glass o' Guinness

You do realise that only 6 of the 9 counties of Ulster make up Northern Ireland ,, Northern Ireland is not ethnically english , the planters were mostly Scottish , You glossed over so many things .

@topman8565

5 жыл бұрын

@Straight White British Protestant key words planters and 50%

@mick2141

5 жыл бұрын

Some day, everyone on the island will realise that we're all Irish, some just have different backgrounds than others.

@catherineconlon453

5 жыл бұрын

@Straight White British Protestant Yes but Brian Boru came close and without English intervention it probably would've happened centuries earlier.

@catherineconlon453

5 жыл бұрын

@Straight White British Protestant On top of that even without a country Ireland was linked by culture and blood something that the English damaged significantly.

@Gamenetreviews

5 жыл бұрын

Straight White British Protestant Maybe just linked by unanimous hatred of the English. I mean did the Brits really see the Irish as racial equals when they let them die in famines or refused one man one vote until the 1960’s.

Just wondering but could you explore what could have happened if the Irish won in any other rebellions ( 1916 included ) , the anti -treaty Ira won the civil war , Michael Collins wasn't assasinated , Diarmuid Macmurrough didn't get the Normans to invade Ireland , Brian Boru didn't die during the battle of Clontarf and what would have happened if the Romans invaded Ireland .

What if the Mughals were defeated by Hemu, the last Hindu king of India?

Devalera was actually let go because he was an american citizen and the british were fearful of starting tension between america and britian

Eamon de Valera was spared because of his American roots and the Brits didn't want to be seen executing an American.

Good video! Some noteworthy mistakes,but is a step up in quality to some of your more recent alternate histories.

What if Primitivism replaced Communism?

What if Ireland became *NazBol* 🤔

@tempejkl

3 ай бұрын

reddit ideology

love the photos really adds depth Z

What if Owain Glyndŵr was successful in the Welsh War for independence in 1415!

What if the Mongols discovered America by going through Russia into Alaska? Or What if the Rurikids stayed true to Rurik's original goal and never adopted Slavic culture and religion instead trying to Germanify the region?

@tritonewt3344

5 жыл бұрын

Reminder that Rurik was Finnic

@joseph-medicis

5 жыл бұрын

Aztec khanate time

@chaosmorris5865

5 жыл бұрын

@@tritonewt3344 No he wasn't, he was Swedish and served in the Varangian Guard.

@khaganofturanistan8753

5 жыл бұрын

Mongols would either ignore or transfer knowledge of the new land around but would not do anything, the mongols had no need to colonise nor did any other asian power, as europeans only started to colonise in the first place due to the fall of constantinople. region would remain majority slavic with a very large germanic minority, comparisons to pre ww1 baltics can be made here.

@chaosmorris5865

5 жыл бұрын

@@khaganofturanistan8753 I mean just their presence alone could drastically change the new world, from an early introduction to dieses to the native populations, to the early reintroduction of horses into the Americas.

Ever consider doing what if Spain joined the axis.

@dchenkin02

2 жыл бұрын

Spain actually did send fifty thousand soldiers to join the German military. Spain simply did not formally declare war. because it was decimated by the Spanish Civil War and lacked sufficient infrastructure to mount an effective military against France or Great Britain in 1939.

You always put in consideration and thought as to what these things would bring and what paths could be made.

For the new sequel of the video, can you please make a video What if Poland won the WW2, What if the Italian army was so good in WW2 and What if China won the Sino Japanese war in 1937?

What if Napoleon defeated Russian Empire? What if Arabs won at Battle of Tours? What if Mexico won American-Mexican war?

@patrickweber8750

5 жыл бұрын

What if the Irish Rebellion of 1798 was successful?

@napoleonbonaparteempereurd4676

5 жыл бұрын

Europe would be mine... Until Russia declared war on me again in 1813

@patrickweber8750

5 жыл бұрын

@@napoleonbonaparteempereurd4676 I know with mine Ireland would have sided with you.

@napoleonbonaparteempereurd4676

5 жыл бұрын

@@patrickweber8750 I had an Irish Legion in my Grande Armee, I even designed their uniforms

@MatijaCG

5 жыл бұрын

@@RandomVideos66 I know, but I'm talking about France forcing Russian Empire to sign a peace treaty.

Love to see this video expanded on

Those pronunciations are something special. Thanks for that.

I wonder what would have happened if the Irish Rebellion of 1798 was successful?

@BelcarrigFarm

3 жыл бұрын

Colonial empire time

You’ve just earned yourself a subscriber.

Only reason I live in USA is because my great great grandpa had to flee Ireland because he fought alongside Valera

I didn't know I could be sexually attracted to an alternate history video.

The video's so quiet lmfao Can we get an volume boost?

I feel like most of his alternate histories with borders since around his hoi4 games.

I can tell you the regime would have likely been gone by the late 80s to early 90s due to the stagnating quality of life, international isolation with only a few allies like China, South Africa, Portugal, and Spain, and Israel, and the level of political and civil repression combined would trigger protests that would bring Ireland in to long term instability. I say this o’Duffy’s dogmatism and idealism and Crossgrave’s meekness would doom the regime to overall stagnation. I can say this with some confidence because the Estado Novo under Antonio Salazar suffered a similar situation, which ended in a popularly backed military coup which brought in multiparty democracy. That being said, Ireland would emerge today with a decent quality of life comparable to that of the rest of Europe, but would be left with the fiscal instability of countries like Greece, Italy, and Spain

@michaelhalsall5684

2 жыл бұрын

Today's Ireland has a strong ecomony with a lot of overseas investment due to favourable tax policies. The Republic has wisely stayed in the European Union and maintained a neutral political position and kept out of overseas conflicts too.

@tempejkl

3 ай бұрын

China? You do know China is communist? They have never supported facists, although they did support the Khmer Rouge (although it was mostly the US/CIA) before they found our about it.

It's pronounced feena fall and fina gayle and you don't leave the "De" out of de velara

De Valera wasn't executed b/c he was an American citizen, not because of luck

Could you please do I video on what India would be like now if there was never a British Raj?

@Perririri

2 жыл бұрын

PewDiePie, the Emperor of T-Series!

What if the provisional government under Admiral Dönitz was allowed to "exist" after WWII

What if the South and Latin American nations united under a fascist Federation in World War II?

@benjaminjackboot6409

5 жыл бұрын

I would love to see that...

@dchenkin02

2 жыл бұрын

Latin America would have devolved into civil war based on historic conflicts between the wealthy White minority and the majority non-White poor population.

Sounds good. Where's the time machine?

@Perririri

2 жыл бұрын

Property of Stewie O'Griffin

I have alwayscontemplated about this subject, as Socialist and member of the Irish Labour party its really interesting. Love the channel xxx Btw just a small point, your pronunciation is fully understandable lol but here it is... Fine Gael (Fine is not like the English "Fine" in Irish its literally pronunced like its written. The name means "Clan of Gaels") Fianna Fáil (Fee-ana Fau-il) meaning "Soldiers of Destiny") Its a small thing, Keep the videos coming x

@PeoplesProtector

5 жыл бұрын

@Liam CYou're wrong. It is now a fully independent party with its own ideals and beliefs. Labour is a Socialist and Social Democratic party, Fine Gael is a Conservative and Christian Democratic party. Completly different sides of the spectrum. Absolutly the Labour/ Fine Gael coalition in 2011 was a huge mistake. But it will never be repeated. These organisation's are completly different from each other. Sinn Féin is pretty left wing too, but sometimes allies themselves with Fine Gael in the Dáil. Although Fianna Fáil claim to be an opposition party, they are in an invisible coalition with Fine Gael, they are of the same ideology and have same position on everything. Labour is incomparable with the main parties, especially with Fine Gael.

What if the USSR never abandoned Marxism-Leninism? I.e., what if the Anti-Party group successfully ousted Khrushchev and Bulganin replaced him?

@tempejkl

3 ай бұрын

Bulganin? Why specifically him? Why not Molotov or Malenkov? I am not critiquing you, just curious

Before video prediction: ireland will go fascist and become extremely successful, and germany will win world war 2. Let's see how this matches up, I'll edit in 15 minutes Edit: this is much better than I thought it would be! Spain, italy, and Ireland as the fascistic powers, and sharing many cultural things. This is a great video.

Here's an interesting rabbit hole - look into how the British played a key part in how and why the famine happened. Its largely been covered up but basically the English needed the food the local population produced as serfs. They worked the land that their British overlords allowed them to farm and live on and confiscated it to send to Britain leaving the native population with not only none of the food they grew but no help whatsoever. Its really astounding that people think the Irish population was ONLY eating potatoes and the potatoe blight starved them! If you believe that i want you to try a diet of only potatoes for a year and see what happens to you!

Me:**sees video** Also me: looks good Also Also me: **clicks video**

What if the Axis was a group of Romance peoples? (Fascist Spain, Fascist Italy and Fascist Portugal, with Fascist France as a minor)

A mick can dream right?

@fristnamelastname5549

5 жыл бұрын

Or fight. But I guess you need Alcohol of that one....

Btw Fianna Fail is pronounced like Feen-na Fall and Fianna Gael is prononced Feen-na Gale.

I’m Irish and Fianna Fáil is pronounced “feena fall”

I heard the word 'syndicalist.' Wilhelm, get the Reichspakt

If De Valera was killed that early a lot would change, Michael Collins would probably survive the civil war.

The North was primarily ethnically Scottish, actually, and are known as the Ulster-Scots, or Scotch-Irish in America

@tempejkl

3 ай бұрын

Definitely untrue. The Scots didn't come in significant enough numbers to be a majority. They bred with some of the local catholics and then segregated themselves. There's no ethnic divide, only a cultural and religious one.

Can tell your reading American history. Ulster Protestant culture is Scottish not English. The Irish didn’t turn out in ww1 to get a better deal... they did it because Irish home rule was still within the uk. They still felt this was their fight, at least many of them did.

As an Irish man I love this

As an Irish person I found this scenario very interesting and learned loads of new things but I could see Ireland joining the axis and being an invasion launch pad or harbouring German fighter jets and u boats

Its no mistake or coincidence fascism grew in so many different nations, it speaks to the soul in a way capitalism and communism never will

@IronPiedmont

5 жыл бұрын

Very true. Especially if forms of Fascism are able to manifest in places like Mexico with National Synarchism and Brazil with Integralism.

@lastwolflord

5 жыл бұрын

The problem is it's not lasting. Unless you can have a forever war economy.

@David-cj8wv

5 жыл бұрын

You’re thinking of capitalism. You don’t need war for fascism, there are 0 fascist governments yet we’re constantly at war. As Oswald Mosley said, the biggest reason for war is a struggle for markets

@dalegribble7939

5 жыл бұрын

@Joe Smith plus most of the ideas of authoritarianism being a constant and fascism are a lie the main reason that fascists use the ideas of authoritarianism is in order to forge a new generation ready for the natural state which often means a state that is more in line with a people's nature on average most people's are not 14 iron-fisted authoritarianism all the time authoritarianism in itself for us is going to be temporary it's only there to get rid of what has led our world into ruin

What if South Africa kept its nuclear weapons program?

De valera survived because he was half American

The pronunciation tho 😂

Watched on my Xbox n liked this video half way threw. I opened my phone to comment after. Even though your Gaelic is bad I like your historic take. Btw I don't speak Gaelic. My grandma did though

I don't think the allies would have tolerated a fascist state on their back door worse case bomber command flattens an Irish city as a warning or just invades and not in a nice way

@michaelhowze8198

3 жыл бұрын

They wouldnt your right

@frankyboy8513

3 жыл бұрын

the tolarated franco until when he died in the 1980's and spain litterally shared a border with france an allied state so no i think they would have

@somerandomperson3970

Жыл бұрын

@@frankyboy8513 Britain isn't France

I did this in Hoi4 the other day. I conquered Britain. Italy then left the Alliance and I conquered them. The US never got to join and France was an easy victory. I turned on Germany. I then United the rest of Europe before using Puppet Canada to invade the US. Still fighting for it.

Pronunciations; Fianna Fail = Feena Fall Fine Gael = Feena Gail

@BelcarrigFarm

3 жыл бұрын

@novax the greens are weak Pbp are communist

11:37 A slightly older Jim Hopper.

What about Collins does he still die as without de velara forcing him to go to the negotiations he wouldn't have signed his death warrant he could easily have both

What if George Lincoln Rockwell ran and won the presidency in 1972?

@MonsieurDean

5 жыл бұрын

www.bitchute.com/video/V5su7s7yX2qC/

Hey Monsieur Z, please do a video 'What if Europe became a united country' (Not only EU countries, all European countries)

CELTIC-SPHERE.

What if Tibet was Fascist?

Pft britain would basically be a landing point for Germany or would be like spain

This was an astoundingly detailed and fascinating video. I would ask you, though -- please, please look up pronunciations. It's three minutes of your life -- a drop in the ocean compared to the work you have put into researching this essay.

Hitler took advantage of Irish nationalism and Irish fascism because of their hatred for the British . But Ireland remained neutral throughout the war. Nevertheless, there was a small fascist, even a smaller Nazi following in the Emerald Isle. We should thank God that no such movement ever took hold in that country. Ironically, Hitler had spoken highly of Britain and the British Empire. He had always dreamed of an Anglo-German to combat the Bolshevist menace from the East.

I’m pissed you got kicked off Discord. I saw your website and looked over your pledge. I am a Catholic Patriotic American who believes this country is the greatest nation in the history of the world. I despise Socialism, Fascism and all Tyranny such as that. Am I a worthy person to join up?

@MonsieurDean

5 жыл бұрын

Absolutely pal. Welcome to the US of Z.

@tempejkl

3 ай бұрын

the US is an evil empire and socialism is the system that frees you

Even with Ireland and Germany working together they wouldn't be able to land anything on British soil

what if japan join the central powers

Actually the Protestants in the North were mainly Scottish not English which is ironic since the Scots had originally come to Scotland from..... Ireland

@raymondhaskin9449

3 жыл бұрын

No. They didn’t. The ancestors of Highland Scots were Pictish. Lowland Scots were a combination of Anglo Saxons and Britons - none of those groups originated in Ireland. The opposite is actually true, since the inhabitants of Northern Ireland were named historically as ‘Cruthin’ (the Gaelic name for the Picts) so the Northern Irish actually originated from Britain.

@markshakespeare5146

3 жыл бұрын

@@raymondhaskin9449 Incorrect. The Scots migrated from Northern Ireland to "Scotland". The Highlanders were a mixture of Picts and Gaels and were described as Irish by Lowlanders as late as the 18th Century. Although you are correct in that emigration to Ulster was mainly from Lowlands. Therefore I was incorrect but not for the reason you stated.

@markshakespeare5146

3 жыл бұрын

The Cruthin being Picts has been debunked by the vast majority of credible historians.

@raymondhaskin9449

3 жыл бұрын

@@markshakespeare5146 Cruthin was the Gaelic name for Picts. How has that been debunked? Lol

@markshakespeare5146

3 жыл бұрын

In medieval Irish writings, the name is variously spelt Cruthin, Cruithin, Cruthini, Cruthni, Cruithni or Cruithini (Modern Irish: Cruithne). It is thought to relate to the Irish word cruth, meaning "form, figure, shape". The name is believed to derive from *Qritani, a Goidelic/Q-Celtic version of the Brittonic/P-Celtic *Pritani.[4] Pytheas referred to the old P-Celtic name as 'Pretannia', which was later latinized as Britanni, the Roman name for the Celtic Britons.[5][4] It is suggested that Cruthin was not what the people called themselves, but was what their neighbours called them.[6] The name Cruthin survives in the placenames Duncrun (Dún Cruithean, "fort of the Cruthin") and Drumcroon (Droim Cruithean, "ridge of the Cruthin") in County Londonderry,[7] and Ballycrune (Bealach Cruithean, "pass of the Cruthin")[8] and Crown Mound (Áth Cruithean, "ford of the Cruthin") in County Down.[9] These placenames are believed to mark the edges of Cruthin territory.[10] Relationship to the Picts Early Irish writers used the name Cruthin to refer to both the north-eastern Irish group and to the Picts of Scotland.[5] Likewise, the Scottish Gaelic word for a Pict is Cruithen or Cruithneach, and for Pictland is Cruithentúath.[11] It has thus been suggested that the Cruthin and Picts were the same people or were in some way linked.[2] Professor T. F. O'Rahilly wrote that the Qritani/Pritani were "the earliest inhabitants of these islands to whom a name can be assigned".[12] It has also been suggested[by whom?] that Cruthin was a name used to refer to all the Britons who were not conquered by the Romans - those who lived outside Roman Britain, north of Hadrian's Wall. Other scholars disagree, pointing out that although Cruthin was used to translate Picti into Irish, Picti was never used to translate Cruthin into Latin.[13] Professor Dáibhí Ó Cróinín says the "notion that the Cruthin were 'Irish Picts' and were closely connected with the Picts of Scotland is quite mistaken"[1] while Professor Kenneth H. Jackson has said that the Cruthin "were not Picts, had no connection with the Picts, linguistic or otherwise, and are never called Picti by Irish writers".[14] There is no archaeological evidence of a Pictish link and in archaeology the Cruthin are indistinguishable from their neighbours in Ireland.[15] The records show that the Cruthin bore Irish names, spoke Irish and followed the Irish derbfine system of inheritance rather than the matrilineal system sometimes attributed to the Picts.[13] Relationship to the Dál Riata Dál Riata was a Gaelic kingdom that included parts of western Scotland and northeastern Ireland. The Irish part of the kingdom lay in the middle of Cruthin territory. Historian Alex Woolf has suggested that the Dál Riata were a part of the Cruthin, and that they were descended from the Epidii.[6] References in the Irish annals By the start of the historic period in Ireland in the 6th century, the over-kingdom of Ulaid was largely confined to east of the River Bann in north-eastern Ireland.[16] The Cruthin however still held territory west of the Bann in County Londonderry, and their emergence may have concealed the dominance of earlier tribal groupings.[16] A certain Dubsloit of the Cruthin is said to have killed the son of the High King Diarmait mac Cerbaill in 555 or 558, and Diarmait himself was killed by a Cruthin over-king of Ulster, Áed Dub mac Suibni, in 565.[17] In 563, according to the Annals of Ulster, an apparent internal struggle amongst the Cruthin resulted in Báetán mac Cinn making a deal with the Northern Uí Néill, promising them the territories of Ard Eólairg (Magilligan peninsula) and the Lee, both west of the River Bann in County Londonderry.[16] As a result, the battle of Móin Daire Lothair (modern-day Moneymore, County Londonderry) took place between them and an alliance of Cruthin kings, in which the Cruthin suffered a devastating defeat.[16] Afterwards the Northern Uí Néill settled their Airgíalla allies in the Cruthin territory of Eilne, which lay between the River Bann and the River Bush.[16] The defeated Cruthin alliance meanwhile consolidated itself within the Dál nAraidi dynasty.[16] Their most powerful historical king was Fiachnae mac Báetáin, King of Ulster and effective High King of Ireland. Under their king, Congal Cláen, they were routed by the Uí Néill at Dún Cethirnn (between Limavady and Coleraine)[18] in 629, although Congal survived. The same year, the Cruthin king Mael Caích defeated Connad Cerr of the Dál Riata at Fid Eóin, but in 637 an alliance between Congal Cláen and Domnall Brecc of the Dál Riata was defeated, and Congal was killed, by Domnall mac Aedo of the northern Uí Néill at Mag Roth (Moira, County Down), establishing the supremacy of the Uí Neill in the north. In 681 another Dál nAraide king, Dúngal Eilni, and his allies were killed by the Uí Néill in what the annals call "the burning of the kings at Dún Cethirnn". The ethnic term "Cruthin" was by this stage giving way to the dynastic name of the Dál nAraide. The Annals record a battle between the Cruthin and the Ulaid at Belfast in 668, but the last use of the term is in 773, when the death of Flathruae mac Fiachrach, "rex Cruithne", is noted.[2] By the twelfth century it had fallen into disuse as an ethnonym, and was remembered only as an alternative name for the Dál nAraide.[19] The Pictish Chronicle names the first king of the Picts as the eponymous "Cruidne filius Cinge".[20] Modern culture In modern times, some Unionist writers in Northern Ireland-in particular Ian Adamson-have seen the Cruthin as an ancient reflection of their own northern separatism and affinity with Britain. In his 1974 book Cruthin: The Ancient Kindred, Adamson argues that the Cruthin settled Ireland before the Gaels; that the two groups were at war for centuries, seeing the tales of the Ulster Cycle as representations of this; and that many of the Cruthin were driven to Scotland after their defeat in the battle of Moira (637), only for their descendants to return to Ireland in the 17th century Plantation of Ulster. This narrative was conclusively shown to be false in the landmark 2017 publication of the “Irish DNA Atlas,”[21] which sets out in great detail the genealogical history and modern day makeup of the British

Only criticism on this channel is UP YOUR SOUND. it’s very hard to hear you.

What if the 2nd French Empire won the Franco-Prussian War? Or perhaps what if the Paris Commune succeeded?

But what if: *Scandinavia never developed separate Nordic cultures? One Norse language and one Norse culture.*

It's pronounced f-eena fall and fina geal

@blackacidgaming5672

5 жыл бұрын

And it is also pronounced "liars amd thieves"

@Westmeath21

5 жыл бұрын

@@blackacidgaming5672 you prounonced "sellouts and traitors" wrong

wheres this 3:32 picture from?

Does this mean Michael Collins Lives?

If Ireland became Fascist, it would still be majority Irish-European and Catholic today, not allowing the termination of babies, sodomy marriage, etc. It would also most likely have very little to no unemployment, homeless people, etc.

@bcf2608

2 жыл бұрын

True but this is the same for all europeans country. Even brits.

@conorbyrne7684

Жыл бұрын

Look at Spain

@feasogachsionnach1872

5 ай бұрын

Ireland would be better off regardless, despite the extremely skewed views held by many today, but that's life.

what if Ireland was a greater power and so the united kingdom would feel threatened by the power and not declare war on Germany, we could see a union like Europe except all fascist.

@martychisnall

5 жыл бұрын

Daniel DuVernay and how is that different from the current European Union?

4:48 Exactly.

Can you you do what if Brazil became a superpower please.

As a Irishman, I approve of this video! 👍