"Sidious would wonder if darth bane would approve of gifting a lightsaber to a student. But then again Darth bane wouldn't of approved of getting your master drunk and then killing him. Sidious smiled" Just this line alone makes me love sidious haha so evil

Obi wan and yoda seem like the villains

@markildolsen883

4 ай бұрын

I’m happy I’m not the only one who thinks that

@DarthRenegade12

2 ай бұрын

Facts

@Vilgax00

Ай бұрын

Yeah,even ı feel that.

I love in this what if the Jedi are show as they are pitiful fear filled beings who are afraid of the slightest attachments.

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

This is their code after all; “There is no emotion, there is peace. There is no ignorance, there is knowledge. There is no passion, there is serenity. There is no chaos, there is harmony. There is no death, there is the Force.” I wonder if they all lived by it tho…

@99thJediWarrior

6 ай бұрын

@@starwarsquill I'd say Qui-Gon followed the Force more than the Code.

I doubt that Anakin would pull a Vitiate on an inhabited planet, that just seems too wild. He might try something like that on a planet with only animals and plants if he were unable to rebuild Momin’s designs or come up with a suitable alternative, though.

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Yea, i think you’re right. When I wrote that I imagined some crazy 70 year old Anakin lol

@deusvultcunt5786

7 ай бұрын

He does tho canonically using an ancient artefact to do the same thing in the star wars vr game he dies attempt to pull a vitiate

@Dragoninja26

6 ай бұрын

@@deusvultcunt5786 Well there's also the factor that that's canon Vader, while this is Anakin from a lighter, though still dark, "what if"

What if Palpatine got dementia during the clone wars?

@Balrog-tf3bg

3 ай бұрын

“Lord Palpatine, I have returned and built the army as you asked. The droids are ready and soon the clones will be. Now all that’s needed is to trap the Jedi” “Who are you and what is a Jedi?!”

The jedi seem more like an evil cult in this story corrupting young minds and such

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

I kinda got that idea from the Darth Plagueis novel where one of Palpatine’s friends try to get their son back after surrendering him to the Jedi. The son ends up rejecting the father and thanks him for being his progenitor (I can’t recall the exact details tho)

@theopportuneson699

7 ай бұрын

I wouldn’t call them evil, but the Prequel Jedi are a cult. It’s why they fell.

@matthewbarabas3052

3 ай бұрын

i think that was the point. what do you do when you exterminate a great portion of an organization? any organization? you radicalize the rest.

@Vilgax00

17 күн бұрын

I mean,only 2 of them involved. Rest is preety chill.

"Luke, did you ever hear the tragedy of Darth Sidious the dumb ?"

@andrewwilcke9378

Ай бұрын

luke: how do i learn to avoid idiocy? Anakin: Not from a jedi

The Revenge of the Sith PS2 game had an alternate ending where Vader won the duel and kills Palpatine.

@47k_HALO

4 ай бұрын

only ogs remember this..

Personally I think that if Anakin had told her all the things that he had hid from her about his actions and the fact that he feared telling her would end up driving away the last person he truly cared for, the even now little sister he loved, she would have understood why he did so an not blamed him for it. He very clearly still cares for her greatly and she would likely see that her leaving him again would likely fully drive him to the dark side, as while she never really believed in the Jedi order after they cast her out without hesitation, she still saw his fall as partially her responsibility for not being for him when he needed her most. She, like him, was always judged unfairly for her strong attachments which she always felt was unfair. Truthfully she likely had the highest potential of any clone wars era Jedi apart from Anakin, and while she could not match the grandmaster even after 20 years of training she likely could have easily matched all of the other masters on the council apart from perhaps Mace Windu. As shown on Mortis she also had a great deal of potential with the dark side as well and was essentially what I think Anakin would be like if he wasn’t the chosen one. Her conviction to follow him for the rest of their lives even knowing he was a sith would be fully cemented and she might have even delved into the dark side with him if that’s what was needed.

Need a part 2

Part of me is enjoying the inner conflict Anakin is having now. Anakin is more than aware of Palpatine's lies now and wants to be free of the acts he committed. If Qui-Gon could reach Anakin at all, it would be now. I could see Qui-Gon reaching Anakin and counseling him on coming clean to Ahsoka. Qui-Gon could get Anakin to see that he can be free for once.

Now THIS is more interesting! A story where, basically, all parties are in the gray rather than simply good or evil.

Ahsoka finds out the truth understands the darkside was ultimately responsible for his actions that Palpy groomed him as a child that Anakin does regret the Jedi deaths he was responsible for. He was so ashamed he never told her. He has spared Obi-wan and his children from death showing him is still a good man and has been trying to fix his mistakes. She falls in love with him, they end up having a child of their own and then the Vong invade and the Chiss and the Empire must fight for their survival. At this point all Jedi and force users are following Anakin in a balance concept of the force using both sides to effectively defeat the Vong. Certainly a great story I rather enjoyed it.

What if Anakin had a midichlorian count of 100.000

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Gotta look into that. Thanks :)

@randy3252

7 ай бұрын

@@starwarsquill np, also great story u told

@sn1524

7 ай бұрын

Force god from birth

@BogomilHristov-tm1iv

7 ай бұрын

@@sn1524yea, it’d be cool. Inexplicably using force push or even lightning (to show his affinity to the dark side) as a child when he gets angry or sad. It could be like the character who lacks control of their magical or unnatural powers and then Shmi contacts the Jedi or Anakin accidentally kills Watto as his first uncontrolled use of the force.

@thelanceshipment

7 ай бұрын

@@starwarsquillplease this would be cool

Hi Star Wars Quill can you please create a part Two to What if Anakin Skywalker Killed Sidious and became the Emperor?

This what if was fantastic! My only gripe with this what if is when bail betrayed anakin, seeing as there is actual peace with the empire under anakins rule it makes no sense. Slavery is abolished, no more cartels, etc.

@alpha34098

7 ай бұрын

Yeah, Bail could have done the right thing and tell Anakin the truth about his Children early on and that would be enough to make him stop his research and go and bring those two "Masters" down before his kids would be fully corrupted by the views of "Jedi" Yoda have envisioned and then raise the Children in a more balanced way (no longer focused in either Side of the Force completely which fits Anakin perfectly since he was once both a Jedi and a Sith)

@thelanceshipment

7 ай бұрын

@@alpha34098 great point

gotta be my favourite what if channel. you blend comics and movie lore in well, whilst giving an in depth description of why. which is good for people who are just starting to get into sw. likely one of my favourite what ifs ive ever seen.

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Thanks, man :) Really means a lot to me :)

@user-ke8nq8kh3z

7 ай бұрын

Exactly! Think i’m wanting to stay on this what if channel for more videos! The other channel are ok but not as good as this one! Keep staying true to the lore of books & novels my guy!

@Dragoninja26

6 ай бұрын

Yeah others are mostly good, but this one's great, only other I enjoy as much (though for different reasons) is Pente Patrol. This channel both makes references I appreciate as well as ones that teach me more details about lore I didn't know before, for example I hadn't heard much of Monin's story before these videos. It's amazing how expansive SW lore is

Finding this video again took me three days... jesus christ... it's one of the best theories I've ever heard and I just couldn't remember the title nor the channel

@starwarsquill

5 ай бұрын

Glad you liked the video, man :)

Personaly i think that anakin would tell Ahsoka of order 66 and his involvement in it, yes even the younglings as hew would probably think it would be better coming from him than her finding out on her own. I also think ahsoka would stick around after that to truly bring him back to the light.

What If Shaak Ti left the Order with Ahsoka What If Ahsoka and Barriss left the Order and joined Ventress

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Is Barriss alive in canon, btw?

@benjaminparker671

7 ай бұрын

@@starwarsquill IDK, this is a what if I'm assuming where both scenarios occur during the time of The Clone Wars before Ahsoka's departure from the Order.

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

@@benjaminparker671 I’ll look into it, man :) Thanks :)

@benjaminparker671

7 ай бұрын

@@starwarsquill The first scenario is where after the Jedi Temple Bombing incident, Shaak Ti leaves with Ahsoka anyways and the second one, Barriss doesn't bomb the Jedi Temple and frame Padawan Tano because Ahsoka convinces her to stop her from doing anything crazy, so they both leave the Order becoming disillusioned with the Jedi Council and joining Ventress.

Truly amazing stuff, as always! Anakin on this state would not just go full Vitiate, I think. He would probably try to look into what Momin said, about serving the will of the Dark Side. Perhaps he could go on in search of more knowledge, and end up finding Bendu in Atollon, having him struggle to learn from him as his knowledge in both the Dark and the Light Side made him a bit arrogant, but eventually realizing that the Center may hold the key to understanding the Force as a whole. There are many great ways to go about figuring this one out. I think the idea of Ahsoka losing her White sabers and trading it for a Yellow one is interesting, but the White blades represent what she is: an "enlightened" Light side, understanding that the Jedi's dogmatic view is flawed. As for Luke and Leia, as the story stands there is little you can do about them. Their characters in this timeline have been shaped so deeply by the Jedi's view that they can't really become anything else. They will always fail to see Anakin's actions for what they truly are: yes, self motivated, but good nevertheless. At this point it is clear that he has learnt from the past and that, while he is no longer a Jedi, he is far from being a Sith. Unless you decide that, in the end, Anakin must fall, they will be his doom. But, one way or another, Anakin has brought balance to the force: the Sith are no more. As a fellow fanfiction writer, I salute you for your skill!

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Thanks, man! Means a lot to me :) Yea, the Vitiate stuff would be a little too extreme now that I think about it. Also, thanks for suggestions on what could happen next, I’ve always found Bendu very interesting :)

@alpha34098

7 ай бұрын

Not by the "Jedi" i might add, but by Yoda's vision of what a Jedi should be in his eyes too old to see beyond the walls of the former Temple (for centuries) and so tainted by the Dark Side of the Force without even knowing it (all thanks too the fact that they the most affected by the Sith Shrine that is under the Temple due to their isolation from the galaxy as a whole). A kind of Jedi that the ancient ones would be so ashamed to look at

The burns did more damage than losing his limbs. No burns would be full strength chosen one basically. Real arm would have sith lightning.

Where are these amazing pictures of Ahsoka in like imperial armor coming from

This is the best version of this story I’ve seen. Great work.

@starwarsquill

6 ай бұрын

Glad you liked it, man :)

My personal thoughts on what would happen next? Anakin would likely find the entrance to the World Between Worlds on Lothal and use time-travel to prevent his fall to the dark side to begin with. He's already found the Lothal temple and given his extensive look into any option to bring Padme back knowledge of the World Between Worlds would eventually crop up in his searching and with the resources of an entire galaxy at his back he'd find a way to enter that realm and use time travel to correct his problems, most likely by going to some point in the Clone Wars before things went wrong to allow himself the most leeway possible and killing Sidious in the past adverting his fall which by the way he'd have zero issues at this point killing Sidious as has already been demonstrated.

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Yea, I think a video involving the World Between Worlds would be cool :) Thanks :)

What if the rule of two wasn't about back stabbing and betrayal? For example what if the sith Lord and sith apprentice were actually the sith king and sith queen. While there would still be backstabbing and betrayal this would potentially lead to stabilization vs a sith Lord getting deposed every 50/100 or so years allowing them to accomplish more

This is the best one of these I've heard very intricate.

So the jedi ruined his children by doctrinating them into unemotional robots, the jedi really were evil. There really was no good side in the clone wars. Anakin may have fallen to the dark side but they ruined his children.

@MrMichaelisaacs1

7 ай бұрын

The Jedi really were the evil ones in this story emperor Skywalker had actually brought peace to the galaxy but the old Jedi that couldn’t get past their stupid code decided to groom his children to try to destroy it.

Would still love a part 2

This is a really great What If! Would you be making a Part 2 to it? I think a great continuation concept for this is if Anakin does succeed in reviving Padme. How would she react to the events that have unfolded? Would she choose to live in exile with her children? Or, with Luke and Leia so detached and distant from family ties, decide to stay beside Anakin? Living out her foreseeable and perhaps eternal future- if Anakin is to discover immorality through the dark side- with the husband she adores? Maybe Luke and Leia could attempt to rise up once more but this time would be confronted with the reality of both their parents rather than just Anakin? Would this change the twins perspective or it would delve them further into their indoctrinated philosophy? Sorry for the long comment, but again, this is an awesome story! How do you go about choosing which What Ifs you’d like to cover? It’s a shame this doesn’t have more views, likes, and comments, but I’m sure you’ll get there with time. You have a nice talent for storytelling. Keep it up 😊.

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Thanks, man! Really means a lot to me :) I might make a part 2 at some point but not sure tho :/ As for choosing What Ifs, I’ve had a bunch of What Ifs in my mind for a while, that’s where I mostly draw from :)

@ecs-a-poet3

7 ай бұрын

@@starwarsquill No problem, man! Though, I’m not a guy lol. It’s all good though! I rarely comment on Star Wars What Ifs, but when I do and people respond it’s like: Thanks bro/man! I find it kinda funny and sweet cause they are being genuine lol. And oh that’s a cool process. Your story really had me thinking of where it could go to. I’m a writer and at the end I found myself just thinking how nice of an opening ending you made. It really gives a lot of possibilities for a Part 2 :). If you do make a Part 2, I’d love to see where you go with it. I’ve always wanted to try make a Star Wars What If myself, but would feel way too camera shy lol. So, props to you!

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

@@ecs-a-poet3 Oh, snap! Sorry about that! Also, I too was kinda scared to make videos at first but it’s really no big deal, you’ll do great :) Give it a shot :)

@ecs-a-poet3

7 ай бұрын

@@starwarsquill You’re good man! I don’t mind, it’s an easy assumption to make. I kinda find it flattering lol, trust me you’re good :). And oh really? I feel like that’s the case for a lot of people. I just don’t feel like I have the right voice for it. However, if I ever did, my first What If would be What If Galen Marek (Starkiller) was Sidious’ apprentice instead of Vader? Saw the idea and I thought it’d be really cool to delve into. I think the it has a lot of potential :).

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Make that video! Trust me, your voice would be fine! Just make sure the audio is clear, that’s all that matters :)

Broo this is so good

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Thanks:)

What if Anakin secretly picked up dookus lightsaber after killing him and used it to fight obiwan on mustafar , along with form 2. (Maybe he studied form 2 in secret after picking up the lightsaber)

@Dragoninja26

6 ай бұрын

That's a really interesting and unique way to change up the Mustafar duel, and doesn't have an obvious answer on what would happen to the story

I really love your understanding of anakin!! Most people like to make Anakin seem like he would devote himself to the sith completely and become a tyrant just cause even though he told padme he was using palps for power and nothing else!! You should do a what if he killed obi wan

Yoda and Obi-Wan were too stuck in their ways to accept the with and the dark side were part of the same force. And that Anakin was actually helping the galaxy

Amazing video! Here's an interesting idea: What if anakin found HK-47 after killing the tusken raiders, and repaired it?

@starwarsquill

6 ай бұрын

Thanks for the suggestion, man :)

@ScrepterWrites

6 ай бұрын

@@starwarsquill No, thank you if you make it. I'm quite eager to see where would that story go.

Great story, kudos!

if he did that than he would bring, peace and prosperity and justice to his new empire.

I demand more

This was very good

I really liked this video! Nice use of comic book lore and your visuals and subtitles kept me super engaged. Are some of the visuals custom art work?

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Nah, it’s all stuff I found online:) Also, I’m glad you liked the video :)

Ngl I would love a continuation of this one from the point it left off, since I think it could be done. Perhaps now since Bale and the kinds are in a "safe" ish location we could see them trying to form a rebellion with any remaining Jedi from before nightfall. Ben might be able to find a way to escape given the few people on planet, we could even see if Asoka could find out what happened with nightfall and have them either start a rebellion or try to confront Anakin and help them better reform to the light or a lighter grey (Since rn they very much are a dark grey haha). But yeah regardless I think the direction you took this was interesting. We don't get to see to many what if's that has Anakin (not Vader) be more of a grey force user post nightfall. Really enjoyed this one regardless if it continues past this point :)

This story may bring a huge twist in the jedi and sith orders kinda switching roles, with sith being pragmatic, maybe even kinda good, and jedi becoming sour and salty cult of assassins hell bent on brainwashing people. At this point, I think that after the battle, Anakin would tell Ahsoka everything. She was with him for decades. Practically half of his life at his side, and over half of hers. So, its not too unreasonable for Anakin to just say that he was manipulated by Sidius, and while being controlled he was forced to kill jedi, even the younglings. If he mentioned regret, I doubt that Ahsoka would blame him. Also, he may say that he feels no hate towards the other jedi and even allowed them to function publicly as if nothing happened, but the jedi are a source of endless hate and need for revenge against him. At that point, I think that Ahsoka would know enough to not dig any deeper into those matters, and Anakin might have found an opportunity to let go and finally accept that his designs would never reach a satisfying conclusion. And with time, he may even find another wife, or maybe find successor from another source. I doubt that he would train Ahsoka as his successor, considering that she wasnt much younger than him. At that point, he may even return to the jail on Mustafar, and tell Obi-Wan something in the sense that he pities him, that he´s just a mindless pawn of the jedi - a vengeful cult. And that with his actions he only managed to spread evil by bringing ruin upon himself (by effectively letting Satine die, and then following his branch of the new jedi order into ruin while being constantly pushed by the ancient vengeful relic called Yoda), and upon others (like Anakin himself). By summing up Obi-Wan´s life for him as an endless source of pain and misery, he may either want to break Obi-Wan´s will, or turn him to his side. Either way, its likely that his efforts would be successful. Obi-Wan´s reflection on his own life would really show that in the end he helped no one, and his actions against Anakin never brought anything positive, and even his other work for the jedi really only brought his life into this miserable conclusion. With this in mind, Anakin may try to use the newly turned Obi-Wan to gain trust of his children. Also, with his new methods, Yoda would not become a force ghost. And Qui Gon´s force ghost may even partially agree with Anakin, despite his despicable deeds in the jedi temple decades ago. In the end, Anakin really was manipulated and did things he never wanted to do. And once he was free of that manipulation, he has basically done the right thing. And with him taking the title of emperor, well, he has shown that it was the correct course of action, so its hard to blame him for that. Even his original intentions were benevolent in nature.

Also amazing art in the video

Would you be making a Part 2 to it? Its very good!

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

I’m not sure yet tbh :/

@zomcom11

6 ай бұрын

@@starwarsquillI think you should!

This feels like the rage and anger of Star killer mixed into anakin

What if Anakin was trained by Jango Fett as a bounty hunter?

What we expect when we start this video Anakin:*Beign a horrible tyrant that is cruel enough to make Palpatine look sane. What we got Anakin:Hey dudes! Empire is preety chill! Maybe you like join it or something?

Anakin should tell Ashoka about Order 66, the twins, and his actions while under Palpatine’s influence while he’s still ahead of everyone regarding his secrets during that time. It will definitely hurt their bond, but at the same time, the strength it would take him to do so will likely hold some weight as to how he’s changed for the better despite being seen as the Sith, how he’s achieved his own sense of balance. Maybe, at some point, he could tell the twins and Kenobi, make a case for forgiveness. But he will need to take responsibility for what he’s done and understand he can’t change what happened, and move forward with his life.

Also here is a scenario what if Palpatine was assassinated during the Clone Wars by some random third party that just didn't like him as a politician. Basically some random Senator in the senate with a big ego who has petty disagreements with Palpatine plants a timed bomb in Palpatine's office with the help of some hired goons while he is out of the place doing Sith things likely chatting with Dooku about something involving his plan this is midway thru the war by the way just for reference and right after he comes back the bomb goes off killing him and anyone else in the blast range. Now I know Palpatine is very clever but he's only smart compared to most characters in the setting whom are idiots, I mean really Sidious's only reason for success was he was smarter then people who were ignorant of the danger due to their own stupidity; the ability to speak does not make one intelligent as Qui-Gon once said and that can actually be said of a lot of characters in Star Wars I don't mean in terms of their knowledge and IQ I'm talking about people being stubbornly blind to the world around them. I mean Dooku flat out told Obi-Wan Darth Sidious was Palpatine and neither he or the council believed it instead doing what a moderately intelligent person would do and check and see if there was any truth to that rumor. Anyway I'm operating on the scenario's premise that it occurs, also Sidious's greatest weakness is his arrogance and superiority complex that blind him to his surroundings so I could easily see some disgruntled person with security access to his office and the money to acquire a powerful quality explosive put a timer on it and plant the bomb and set the timer while Sidious is out and be gone and by the time Sidious gets back the timer only has a few seconds left on it and he doesn't know the bomb is there and it goes off and he dies. Scenario set up what would happen from there.

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Thanks, man! I should make a video like that :)

@nobbyfirefly57

3 ай бұрын

Paragraphs

Okay, but what if he killed all the Mustafarians first, before going to kill Palpatine?

What a great video.

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Thanks, Nathan :)

@nathanlynch9634

7 ай бұрын

@@starwarsquill your welcome and I find this theory very interesting.

Awesome.

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Thanks!

Your stories are very good, but you need to have a richer collection of words. Instead of constantly saying Anakin, you could say Anakin, he, him, the chosen one, the apprentice, the new sith, the sith apprentice etc. Using the same word or name more than twice in the same paragraph is easily noticed and not smooth, and you’re using the same word like 10 times in a paragraph. I don’t want to hate on you, I just want to give advice.

Please dont will do ashoka betray anakin ;(

At the cell looking at the twins. "I am your father." They don't seem to care. "So, you'd slaughter me as your father without a care in the world?" Nods. "Does it matter I killed the Sith lord, made it legal to be a Jedi again and gave them back their temple?" Shakes head. "So you'd kill me just cuz Yoda said I was a Sith?" Nods. "You realize one of your teachers Obi Wan once told me only a Sith deals in absolutes. You have no thoughts of talking to me, see if I'll understand your side, just kill me based on what Yoda said calling me a Sith. You two are more Sith-like than I am." Two look at each other with 'oh-shit' looks. "Do you already realize at any time Yoda could have went back to the temple to try and convince the Jedi there to fight me with him. But knowing they wouldn't because it's insane, he'd rather brainwash my own kids from birth to fight me because they wont question it." Looks down at their shoes.

@kamirostorino9416

2 ай бұрын

Now we need the version of this story that this happened in the fight and the difference it made

I think Luke and Leia defeat Anakin because all of the have same potential

@kingchaos4255

7 ай бұрын

Can you make what if Luke time travel back in the time of revenge of the sith

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

@kingchaos4255 Thanks for the suggestion, man :)

Make him successful to rebuild Momin’s designs

The plot of this what it sounds like a Star Wars legends series Like visions but what If story

@starwarsquill

6 ай бұрын

Glad you like it, man :) Means a lot :)

The light within Anakin will end winning them over, Luke will see it and suddenly he will start to believe in redeeming him

What if Anakin had wings?

I could see order 66 get stopped or changed by Vader now I'm sure with even more training Anakin would use the lower ground to his own advantage watto do you think about dis ?

What if Thrawn joined the Separatists? Sev’rance Tann could convince Thrawn to join her and Vandalor in the Separatist Military. What if Maul was raised by Mother Talzin? What if Kina Ha trained Anakin Skywalker?

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Thanks, man! These are nice!

If anakin did revive padme probably doing a vitiate on a world without intelligent life at first she'd probably be angry and dislike the empire going to bail and her children. She'd show her children love and affection but it would not be returned with them treating her with indifference due to the jedi indoctrination causing her to be really hurt and then have an argument with bail about how her children turned out. After that I think she'd go to her family on naboo and would start looking into the empire seeing that anakin has destroyed the crime and slavery empires and purged the republic of corruption and even cancelled order 66 would probably cause her to reconsider the empire and anakin. So after a few months apart she'd return to anakin and become a leading figure and support him and the empire.

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

That would be a happy ending to the whole thing :)

@doomtitan1172

6 ай бұрын

​​@@starwarsquill Still sucks for the children though. 😒 😑

Ok so far wouldn't mind a pt2 maybe with WBW with anakin going back to get padme when all else fails

Part 2 please??

It seems to me more appropriate in this context that Ahsoka Tano should have been nominated Vice Emperor instead of Grand Moff.

@boxtank5288

6 ай бұрын

I mean that is EFFECTIVELY what Grand Moff is. Vice Emperor.

@Robert_Douglass

6 ай бұрын

@@boxtank5288 And what did Emperor Vader do with Mas Amedda? And would the Imperial Senate have had the authority to impeach the Emperor for it?

What if the mitochondria wasn't the powerhouse of the cell?

the emperor was a skilled politician from a wealthy family. I dnt if Anakin had the intellectual might of influence to rule the galaxy

Perhaps as a way to continue have the twins find a holocron of Revan to start fixing their minds of the jedi indoctrination

If anakin would pull a Vitiate, it would definitely be with a planet of only animals. Probably a planet uninhabitable to those not native their as well, so it wouldn't be a loss. Plus, given how everything turned out, even if Padme is upset at Anakin's actions, with what the jedi did to her children, and how Anakin made the empire as good as it is here, she'd probably get back with Anakin

Thank you. Killing your master that way is cowardly. Against everything the sith stand for. Sure, be smart and sneaky with your dealings and your business. Either your master dies of old age or you beat his old ass face to face when he turns old.🤣

Love this story it was amazing well I think ahsoka would probably leave him after she finds out what really happened I don't think she turn against him that being said Anakin might find the portal on lothal

@starwarsquill

6 ай бұрын

Wonder what Vader would’ve done had he discovered it…

@benjamincoats8301

6 ай бұрын

@@starwarsquill That's a good question and honestly depends on how far he goes back would he save his mom? Would he reveal to his younger self what would happen if he joins the Jedi order there'd be almost two decades age difference if he tried to bring back padme

What if Anakin, Obiwan and Ahsoka were turned to the dark side by the son on mortis and all of them left mortis corrupted by the dark side

What if in part 2 Ashoka learns the real truth of order 66 and Anakins betrayal of the order. So she then sides with Luke and Leia but also tries to convince them of the good in Anakin and that he’s a flawed man but a good one due to the good they did for the galaxy in part 1 that being said she eventually loses her white sabers and gets a yellow one thus fuffiling the dark side vision Anakin saw seeing as though Luke would eventually get a green saber and Leia another blue saber.

Or.....Anakin having two children alive begins to think of abandoning the dark side to instead start giving visits to them in hopes to try and connect with them. I personally can't see either of them not being phased in the least that he's their father, when those raising them also deceived them and kept that info from them. Certainly doesn't make Yoda much better. And even if they feel more closer to the force, Luke always believed in wanting to reach out to family and try to save him. Why is that not shown at all? They can't both be just Sith killing machines. They both are capable of personalities, here. Figures Anakin makes the whole galaxy great and people love him and Yoda still wants to kill him. I think if anything it made Yoda look as much of a pos as he usually is. Not surprised, it's actually quite fitting for him. Does make me feel sorry for Anakin, though. Once he realized Sidious's deceit, he ended up doing all the right things in the end, and it's still not good enough for the Jedi.

It’s not a force locus is called a force nexus

Tl;dr World between Worlds is used, but to Anakin's detriment I imagine Anakin would eventually rebuild the castle on Mustafar. However, it would be imperfect. Anakin would be able to successfully open the gate and bring Padme "back", but not really. She would be suffering. Anakin would refuse to let her go again however, keeping her alive despite her suffering. Meanwhile, the power of the imperfect gate would spread the dark side across not just Mustafar, but the entire galaxy, corrupting it worse and worse. Roughly a year would pass, and 99% of the galaxy would become unlivable, a barren cosmic wasteland of death and destruction as nearly every planet would become either like Mustafar or like Dogobah (depending on its climate, size, etc). The only safe planet left would be Alderran, the dark side kept at bay by Luke, Leia (who wouldn't stop training despite losing their lightsabers) and the force ghosts of Yoda & Ben, only able to appear on Alderran at this point. (If you've seen the Marvel: What If episode where Dr. Strange brought Christine back, thats basically whats happening.) Either way, Ashoka would eventually learn enough. She would never get the *full* story, but she would see that Anakin quite literally sacrificed the galaxy to resurrect Padme. Disgusted in Anakin, yet knowing she was not powerful enough to stop Anakin, Ashoka would flee to Alderran, only barely (as most of space has become dangerous, like that red cosmic storm surrounding Exagol in Ep 9). Ashoka, begging for the help of Luke & Leia would encounter the ghosts of Yoda and Obi-Wan. Realizing that Ashoka had truly been fooled, they would forgive her, and the ghosts, using their knowledge of the cosmic force would guide the three Jedi to Lothal, back to the temple where they all met. In this temple laid a portal to the World Between Worlds. They could use this to go back and prevent the galactic destruction, albeit at the cost of preventing Padme's resurrection. Luke, Leia and Ashoka agree, braving the harsh conditions to reach Lothal, which at this point would have also been reduced to a Mustafar esc hellscape, the only intact structure being the jedi temple. Luke, Leia and Ashoka attempt to reach the temple by landing near the temple, but would realize that Ashoka's ship had been damaged during the descent, she would unfortunately die in a sudden and abrupt explosion as her ship crashed violently. Luke & Leia, despite having no attachments, would feel some sense of sadness for death, the sheer amount of the dark side as well as Ashoka's brief positive interaction with them would be enough to slowly erode their emotionless exteriors. Luke & Leia would reach the portal gateway after some time. Exhausted, the two would, after some help from the ghost of Yoda, would be able to open the portal. Yet, this would cost the "life" of Yoda and Obi-Wan, the dark side too strong to maintain a connection to the living force. They were gone. Luke & Leia would travel the WbW blind, unsure of how to use it. They would see a portal of Ashoka, beginning her descent to Lothal. As of on instinct, the two would pull Ashoka out of the cockpit, "saving" her (in reality, they were the ones to cause her ship to crash, the only reason it crashed being its pilot suddenly disappearing). Luke, Leia & Ashoka would have a brief conversation about attachment. How they felt as if they broke the jedi code by saving her, how Anakin doomed the galaxy because of attachment, etc. Yet, Ashoka would counter, stating that without attachment, Anakin would've never saved Ashoka from her false accusation, Anakin would've never saved Obi-Wan several times during the clone wars if not for his attachment to Obi-Wan. Finally, Anakin would have never killed Sidious if Anakin's attachment to Padme wasnt enough to spur his wrath towards Sidious. The three would sit in contemplation, meditating. Eventually, through following the will of the force, they would find the right portal. Though, Ashoka would also find another portal, a portal where she sees Anakin in the Jedi Temple. Ashoka would be aghast, beginning to have second doubts, but she knows she must continue the mission, if not to save Anakin, than to save the Galaxy. (Also, regarding the yellow lightsaber, perhaps they use the WbW to grab lightsabers from different points in time. Luke & Leia grabbing their sabers at a point where Anakin had already safely stored them away. Ashoka, idk.) Luke, Leia and Ashoka would enter through the portal, mere moments after Anakin opened the imperfect gate (their arrival appearing as a bright light, matching the vision). Anakin would be livid, immediately knowing they were sent by the force to stop him. He hadn't found Padme yet, he couldnt bring her back yet! The four entered a monumental duel, their combined power shaking the very planet of Mustafar itself. Despite the potential of the three jedi, Anakin was almost at his full potential as is (only not so because of his cybernetics). Anakin would begin to slowly lose, before he'd draw on the power of the Locus, overwhelming the three jedi. Anakin would prepare to kill Ashoka, before Anakin would hear *Padme* begging him not to. Anakin would whip around, not being able to see Padme, but knowing her voice was coming from the Locus. Anakin would approach the Locus, trying to tell Padme this was to bring her back. Padme would refuse this, saying that she accepted her death long ago, its only Anakin that hasn't. Anakin would attempt to rebuttal, but Padme would essentially tell Anakin "don't throw away what family you have left to try and grasp whats already gone"... Anakin would have a choice, either let Padme go and save Luke, Leia, Ashoka and inadvertently the galaxy, or bring Padme back and then go kill the present versions of Luke, Leia & Ashoka to prevent a time loop. Anakin, seeing the pleadful eyes of Luke, Leia, and Ashoka especially, would *finally* learn the lesson to let go. Anakin would attempt to close the gate, but Momin, sensing his opportunity once again, would force the gate open on the other side. He would declare that he saw what Anakin could do with the gate, corrupting the entire galaxy, and he thought it was the most beautiful art he'd ever seen and would refuse to not allow that to happen. Anakin, willing to let go of everything he fears to lose, including himself, would say a final apology and goodbye to his children and Ashoka, before rushing into the open gate and tackling the spirit of Momin. Anakin would be trapped in whats essentially the Dark Side forever, but by doing so, would be able to (with the help and trust of his children) shut down and destroy the gate for good, Anakin accepting his fate, knowing he may never see Padme or his children again, but knowing he did the right thing in the end by giving them a future to look forward to. From here, Ashoka would assume the role of emperor, and with help from Bail, Leia, and Luke, would slowly reform the Empire into a mix of the Empire and The Republic, keeping what the people liked from both. Luke would slowly rebuild the jedi order, being the grandmaster, whereas Leia would serve as the middle-woman between the Republic and Jedi, so the Jedi dont fully join the Republic but still help. From here, I got nothing, but I hope you enjoyed reading this and I hope this is a satisfying conclusion. Part 2 maybe?

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

This is insane! Do you make What Ifs? You should totally turn this into a video!

@socialaccount0000

7 ай бұрын

​@@starwarsquill I have 0 video editing skills nor any experience with video editing software. I have alot of free time during work, so I just listen to videos like these and imagine similar scenarios when work is slow. I'd be more than happy to help with your next video, if you'd like.

I thought they didnt remember anything from mortis.

@starwarsquill

4 ай бұрын

Nah, they did. Yoda mentions it to Anakin in an Episode of Clone Wars Season 6.

@sirvantanite1307

4 ай бұрын

@@starwarsquill I was trying to look into it more, and apparently Obi wan looked at it more like a shared vision and partially doubted if it even happened. If that really was the case, then even if they remembered it to some degree, it'd be doubtful that they'd actually use it as part of their reasoning or that it'd hold any substantial claim in their decision making process. Also when looking up various outlets on it, Ahsoka doesn't remember herself specifically when she was possessed by the dark side. Probably because she was more so possessed then turned. In season 6, anakin and yoda brifely speak about qui gon and how anakin said he saw him, but said Obi wan and him thought that it was an illusion, a mind trick made out of our memories. In conclusion though they do remember mortis, but its clear that even if they remembered everything that they deeply doubted if any of it was real.

I am someone who is already inclined to view the Jedi as the worst option between themselves, the Sith and the Grey, so I find this story rather vindicating. In my mind you have painted Yoda, and to a lesser extant Obi-Wan as psychotic zealots unable to see that ultimately Anikan had done much more good than anything else.

Almost first

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Haha Thanks for checking out the video, man :)

@commanderpaladin

7 ай бұрын

@@starwarsquill love your videos! Keep going

@starwarsquill

7 ай бұрын

Glad you like em, Commander :)

Too bad the Sith didn’t completely destroy the Jedi.

@Vilgax00

17 күн бұрын

Just because 2 Jedi acted horrible,does not mean rest is evil. Even in this story most of them joined Anakin.

what if anakin was born female

What if Padame died and Anakin fell in love with Ashoka?

Another overly long video that ignores Dark Empire 2. The emperor has clone bodies waiting. The emperor would just come back and clap Anakin. Gotta remove Byss from the equation in order to make these alternate timelines viable.

I don't know... This one made a lot of the characters do things that were out of character for them. Anakin becoming a "just" leader seems a bit far-fetched given that how unstable he was at the end of Revenge of the Sith (And we see in the Obiwan series). Obiwan and Yoda going against an Empire that had reaccepted the Jedi and was actually working very well for the people also didn't make much sense either, as well as manipulating Luke and Leia specifically to fight Anakin when they could have used Luke and Leia to bring Anakin fully to the light instead. Also, I don't care of Luke and Leia were trained from birth, there's no way they would have been completely unaffected by Anakin being their father. Just because they're not trained to be attached doesn't mean they don't feel anything. It felt like Luke and Leia were being turned into the villains in this story. The story was interesting, don't get me wrong. It was interesting to see a version of Anakin different from other What If stories I've heard, and seeing some light come back to Anakin after he killed Sidious. I did like Anakin being a more fair ruler than Sidious, even if it felt out of character from how he should have been during this time.

If anakin would become emperor how would he ends slavery. I mean who emperor in human history ended slavery in earth? And how an emperor will do it in a galaxy even if he is a Jedi Because jedis also have hierarchies. When social hierarchies exist then there is not republic nor democracy. It is oligarchy. Even with Jedi council, even with former Republic without palpatine as in this galaxy credits-money had the outmost importance, hence the existence of trade union and planets helping both sides in clone wars. Man your points in politics and philosophy are so wrong.....

I realize this is fan fiction, and I applaud your creativity and story. However, there is just SO much wrong here. Even fan fictions have to follow certain rules. What a waste of a great story. Sorry