For more on this topic, Dr. Edith Humphrey goes through various views in Catholicism and Protestant communities (including Anglican and Methodist) and compares these with each other and with the Orthodox mindset, with more detail than this discussion. The link to her book is below! ⬇ www.amazon.com/Scripture-Tradition-Really-Studies-Theology/dp/0801039835/ref=sr_1_1?crid=C0W0WHBTGITK&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.Z-1oyVIRmBK2EGPUBe6ywHHooprCGtSj3JKgowMatVC1hwQMxUyp231xusgfrm5jjPth-xhrKfsrW7IY1IwxTRBIMTHqO-T-nnDcvs2EfdgSzNY3KiUuW0gFeT5OVJh57jEFFC9YAuf4tCfK6S0mOCL_xsd804dPRM4y3QZUIrI9q9utByM8674ssR_hFt_b.qCXP7G1zMCUb-qwFeYfqhridb81uV4-YMCTAmYwKjjo&dib_tag=se&keywords=Scripture%20and%20Tradition%20Humphrey&qid=1718382966&sprefix=scripture%20and%20tradition%20humphrey%2Caps%2C108&sr=8-1&fbclid=IwZXh0bgNhZW0CMTAAAR3myUKfQIc8SCILkwnAZcaph0vdnVtZ1LW_qz--ZyWGMF3-g-J7paKWtoo_aem_AQvLkb1G7rPCCykvv-rbR_7oU0eDHqZuel1aAZxrygv3PvxrNqjtG6YSdqDIlVuaw2D0eqbDaGNy3s7oc3lTj-oo

I love hearing from Dr. Humphrey, she's a gem who deserves more exposure.

@TheTransfiguredLife

18 күн бұрын

She's special! ☦️

Saint Cosmas of Aetolos preaches: "I read about priests, and about impious, heretical and atheists; I searched the depths of wisdom; all faiths are false; this I understood to be true, that only the faith of orthodox Christians is good and holy , to believe and be baptized in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. This I say to you now in the end: rejoice where you are orthodox Christians, and weep for the impious and heretical who walk in darkness

One of my favorite channels as someone who’s leaving Protestantism for orthodoxy

@TheTransfiguredLife

18 күн бұрын

Thank you! We appreciate it! ☦️🔥🔥

@TheTransfiguredLife

18 күн бұрын

If there's anything you want us to address in the future let us know. May God bless you on your journey towards Holy Orthodoxy!

@steventripple4765

17 күн бұрын

@@TheTransfiguredLife honestly you guys have covered everything I’ve really been seeking answers for 🙏 I am coming from a reformed Calvinist background, really looking forward to the future videos, may god bless you both 🙏

@jaredalfred965

17 күн бұрын

Same here.

@ninasaabiyeh926

14 күн бұрын

Very good questions!

Glory to God! What an episode! That went way too quick! Please do have Dr Edith back to speak on her other book as well that she mentioned she had elsewhere, as it sounds like a really good topic. Thank you for putting this out there 🙏

@TheTransfiguredLife

4 сағат бұрын

Glory to God! You got it brother! ☦️

Excellent discussion! Maybe you could have Dr. Edith on again for a discussion on CS Lewis.

@TheTransfiguredLife

18 күн бұрын

Thanks for the idea! We would love to have her again she's great! ☦️

@matty31272

18 күн бұрын

Yes please!

As far as the 'by whose authority ' topic, as someone who was formerly Protestant and now Orthodox, when you hold to sola Scriptura, you are then saying that you yourself are the authority. There is no getting around that fact.

@Bible-Christian

16 күн бұрын

Not correct. The Bible had the authority. Not catholicism. That is Nowhere in the Bible

@huntermunro5003

14 күн бұрын

@@Bible-Christian What defines a true believer of the faith?

What a wonderful interview!

@TheTransfiguredLife

17 күн бұрын

Thank you!! ☦️☦️☦️

It’s amazing very interesting topics 😊🎉

Good video. I would disagree with her interpretation of the Catholic view on Sacred Tradition and Scripture. We certainly consider the view of elevating aesthetic or form to the level of sacred tradition if it holds no affirmation from the Magisterium clarifying how the aesthetic and form comprise Sacred Tradition, else fall into a for of idolatry. So we see Sacred Tradition, Scripture, and Thr Magisterium WITH the Pope as the foundation of our faith.

@regis_red

16 күн бұрын

Yes, and it’s also as if we wouldn’t ask if this or that conflict with Scripture (@32:44) when in fact we do, and it’s a concern that she doesn’t seem to know that. Also I was curious to see what doctrine she thinks Catholics added but finally it’s just the papacy, really. Because the truth is Catholics never added anything that wasn’t already there in one form or another. Interesting that it comes down to the big difference between Catholics and Orthodox (besides the Filioque).

@maxellton

14 күн бұрын

@@regis_red "If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church. And if he refuses to listen even to the church, regard him as you would a pagan or a tax collector" Mathew 18:17. So which Orthodox church should you go to?

@acekoala457

6 күн бұрын

​@@maxellton According to St. Ignatius, who was taught by St. Peter and St. John the Evangelist, the whole of the Church exists within the Bishop. So you go to your Bishop.

☦️☦️☦️

See: Concise Overview of the Critique of Jesus of Nazareth- D.C.S.

Is there a Bible you all recommend?? I am a Protestant but looking into the orthodox faith. Or is there a book that helps translate the Bible I have to Greek, so I actually know what words are actually used? Thanks for your help!

@TheTransfiguredLife

13 күн бұрын

The OSB is a safe option (Orthodox Study Bible). I recommend the EOB. You will appreciate this bible. ⬇️ EOB: The Eastern Greek Orthodox New Testament: Based on the Patriarchal Text of 1904 with extensive variants a.co/d/03P19Uxb

@cherylketcherside2459

13 күн бұрын

@@TheTransfiguredLife thank you so much!

Catholic here...and for me..catholic is the true church....the tomb of saint Peter is in Rome basilica of saint Peter..

Tradition is a delivery. Deliver the delivery is like ‘mailing the mail’. We get hung up on the word tradition and it’s a flawed English translation.

@edithmhumphrey2254

18 күн бұрын

"Tradition" is a perfectly good translation of paradidomi and paradosis. It is the pejorative connotation given to it by some Protestants that is flawed. And Tradition is not simply delivery but also reception: it is a two-way process.

@deekay2680

18 күн бұрын

@@edithmhumphrey2254 this is true. Unfortunately the taint given by Protestants has ruined it. It’s almost like we need to go back to the Greek & school them- which you did here- and give a full lesson on the Greek text. Even the notion of ‘something delivered & received’ seems to be lost w/ protestants. The same root word was used when Christ was ‘delivered’ to Pilate. The word ‘parade’ comes from the same root & It gives a very visual image. Protestants- when taking all different sects into account- have so many different ‘traditions’ & you did a good job of explaining them. The Revival movement tried to return to ‘the original’ but ended up with even more- SDA,JW, COC, Mormons, etc. Now Hebrew roots is another. Boggles the mind.

This is why defending tradition as authority always seems sus. They spent a bunch of time on how the written word can be corrupted or misinterpreted. With the written word we know what changed and we can go back to verify if someone abused the scripture. With tradition you can’t. Every argument against the written word can be used against tradition and it is ten times worse for tradition. Every time tradition is argued there is lots of equivocation of the use of the term tradition. She mentions the different usages of tradition and then proceeds to not distinguish them most of her talk. Yes, there are positive usages of tradition in the Bible, but all are in context of their present time. When Jesus talks about traditions what is he talking about? Man made traditions that are added to the scriptures, these he describes as a burden and they can even take people away from God. Many of the traditions of today are clearly man made and in addition to the written word.

@TheTransfiguredLife

13 күн бұрын

"They spent a bunch of time on how the written word can be corrupted or misinterpreted." Where did we spend a bunch of time discussing the corruption of the written text? "To an Orthodox Christian, Tradition means the Holy Bible; it means the Creed; it means the decrees of the Ecumenical Councils and the writings of the Fathers; it means the Canons, the Service Books, the Holy Icons, etc. In essence, it means the whole system of doctrine, ecclesiastical government, worship and art which Orthodoxy has articulated over the ages [Timothy Ware, The Orthodox Church, p.204]." Tradition is easy to defend because it has been taught by the Fathers and is a historical reality. What's "sus" is those that reject it yet call themselves Christian.

If your church is the true church then you should have the tomb of the apostle..

@blackbette07

7 күн бұрын

Huh?

Jesus condemned tradition. They often got in the way of God's commands~

@hannahbaker3080

17 күн бұрын

Traditions made up by men, not traditions full stop

@deidrebuzbee5466

16 күн бұрын

Jesus condemned the traditions of the Pharisees..'the traditions of men'.. That is not the same thing as the Holy traditions of the Church that was taught to the Apostles by Christ Himself, and later Paul compelled the Church to hold fast to them in 2 Thes. 2:15 .

ALL denominations are man made including Catholic, Orthodoxy, Protestant, etc...

Don't forget the Traditional Catholics! We're not all adherents of Vatican I and/or II.

@airpodman1259

14 күн бұрын

Why are you catholic if you reject the Vatican councils? If the pope can be in error when leading an infallible council then your whole system falls apart.

@CatETru

13 күн бұрын

@@airpodman1259 Why? Because the Church has been infiltrated from within. By whom exactly? Well, I will leave that up to you to investigate. They had tried for centuries without success. After World War 2, things changed though. It is still the One True Church (The Seat of Peter) run by a few corrupt men. Hence there are Bishops and Cardinals leaving and organising their own traditional masses that stay true to Sacred Tradition. So, yes I am a traditionalist, not a fan of modernism in the Church. That's it really.

Look who's calling the kettle black. Satan himself.

Only the Holy Bible and Jesus are infallible so tradition when placed next to the word sacred is blasphemy

@CenterPorchNP

15 күн бұрын

Let me ask you a question. Since the first 200 years of the faith didn't have anything but the OT, how was Christianity taught? By Tradition. Even Paul says so. And you owe your NT to the church. You're welcome.

@julz.c

14 күн бұрын

the New Testament wasn't compiled together until 325 A.D. by the Orthodox Church :) They were just letters and separate books. And even in 2 Thessalonians 2:15 (NKJV) it says: 15 Therefore, brethren, stand fast and hold the traditions which you were taught, whether by word or our [a]epistle. (which means that not all traditions were written down in the letters, but were taught by word of mouth)

@michaelbledsoe4355

14 күн бұрын

@@CenterPorchNP Tradition is fine but its not HOLY and Perfect

@michaelbledsoe4355

14 күн бұрын

@@julz.c Tradition is fine but its not HOLY and Perfect and infallible