0:26 - 0:53 I am drop dead fascinated by how you made these two animals sound just like one another. You have a serious amount of talent! Also, I'd love to hear a T-Rex honk :P

That final sound is Way more terrifying than the roar my goodness! This video is immaculate

@aaronsalvador8943

11 ай бұрын

Isn’t dangerville’s recreation of this much more scarier?

@Kaidhicksii

5 ай бұрын

@@aaronsalvador8943 Heard that one before. Not really, though it depends on perspective. Dangerville's recreation, unsettling as it was, ultimately just sounded like some low-frequency sounds coming from far off, not belonging to any immediately recognizable source if you didn't know what you were listening to. This guy's on the other hand sounded like an actual animal that was breathing down your neck. It felt like it was right there.

@aaronsalvador8943

5 ай бұрын

@@Kaidhicksii but no offence isn’t the trex’s syrinx supposed to be much deeper because the syrinx is an evolutionary trait after all

5:54 Sir, this is scary as hell and congragulation for that! I'm glad you have made this video to discern what science doesn't tell us about what dinosaurs sound like.

"Animals like the Tyrannosaurus communicate in deep frequencies that humans can barely hear." ... "A T-Rex cannot hear human screams..." Well, that escalated quickly! Jokes aside, I had been looking for something like this for a while. I'm tired of hearing the same old stereotypical *mammalian* roar coming from a *reptile* very closely related to *birds.* When I first found this, I was hoping that it would be at least a little different than the roar everyone thinks a t-rex made. I was surprised to hear the sounds in the video, which were much more reptilian/avian than the stereotypical roar. I'm very happy to know that we are at least starting to move away from the boring roar that is always used in media, and getting more closer to knowing what the t-rex *actually* sounded like. And for creating this wonderful video and practically busting the roar stereotype, I applaud you. Thank you.

5:54 My God! Tyrannosaurus Rex may be my favorite animal, but that sound is absolutely terrifying. It doesn't just strike fear into your soul, but it demands respect. And the T-Rex sure as hell has my respect!

"Unlike color, sound is always a necessity" hard disagree. Color and patterns evolve for signaling and camoflauge behaviours. In social animals the evolutiom of color and patterning played a role in identification of individuals, sexual dimorphism, and display. It's not just natural selection which drives evolution, there's also sexual selection, of which display structures are a result and reinforcing factor. Further, when it comes to plants! We can know what color their leaves are based on their chloroplasts and light they receive. We know that plant ovums use bright colors and designs that stand out, and smells, to attract polinators. We know that mature ovums invest lipids and carbohydrates to make their fruit appealing when their primary dispersal method is by animal. We know they us bright colors and foul tastes (or poison) in their fruits to discourage certain animals from eating their fruit. And we can trace these evolutionary steps far back through prehistory. Likewise with vision, with color and patterning. Taste and smell too. Difficulty in approximating all aspects, including vocalizations, range from difficult to near impossible, though some are certainly less difficult than others and it is very safe to make some broad reaching general and nonspecific assertions based on current evidence. Tl;dr color and patterning may be more difficult to calculate, but it's equally a biologically necessity.

@StudioMod

Жыл бұрын

Very fair point. Should have chose another way to illustrate my point there.

@CarlosPrGr

Жыл бұрын

I totally agree

5:54 NOW THAT WAS GOOD! That sounded extremely intimidating and very convincing for a T-REX sound! Hearing this with the volume turned up on your Bluetooth, you can also feel the rumbling and vibration as you can hear feel the breathing as it sounds like it's very close to you!

@Kaidhicksii

5 ай бұрын

I was listening to this with my Bose headphones turned all the way up to 100, and uh,... oh boy...

@garrettriddle4139

5 ай бұрын

​​@@KaidhicksiiYeah like imagine if it was up close in person and you can feel this violent vibration rumbling coming down and ready to pick you as food.... "SHIT"..... Imagine hearing it outside your house....😱😱😱😱 Or maybe hearing outside your sleeping tent.

Sentence error at 2:49, sorry I was fighting off a horde of angry donuts.

5:54 Holy shit.. this is beyond terrifying.. Sounds like a demon animal from hell, or an extraterrestrial being coming to get you

@Kakaragi

2 жыл бұрын

Virgin Jurassic Park roar vs Chad Scientifically Accurate T-Rex sounds

@WhyTho525

2 жыл бұрын

@@Kakaragi Is it wrong if I like them both?

@Kakaragi

2 жыл бұрын

@@WhyTho525 No* But at the same time it's often important for fact to get more precedence over the fiction, otherwise we would be living in a world where we only know misconceptions. And for T-Rex and other dinosaurs, it's about time that we let go of the notion that they roared like mammals because that's simply not true anymore

@WhyTho525

2 жыл бұрын

@@Kakaragi That is correct, and I absolutely agree to an extent. I mean if a Live-Action movie adaptation of a game like Dino Crisis gets made, they pretty damn need to use accurate sounds as the story revolves around time travel. Stories like Jurassic Park actually have an excuse as the dinosaurs shown in the Film were basically hybrids, having mixed genes of the actual creatures and modern day animals like frogs (for example the InGen Dilophosaurus has frilled Lizard and possibly spitting cobra genes). Most of them still look like the animals they're supposed to be, while still having an interesting creature design (the Tyrannosaurs, the raptors and basically 90% of the animals in the OG trilogy). While some just look outright terrible (looking at you Fallen Kingdom Baryonyx). Even in the original novel, Dr. Henry Wu is fully aware that InGen’s dinosaurs aren't the 'real deal' and insists on continuing research to recreate the real dinosaurs (wether it is out of his ambition to improve his skills a geneticist or if he actually wants people to see the real dinosaurs is left ambigious). The problem the films have is that in the original movie potrayed it's dinosaurs as if they were the real beings and not genetically modified subspecies of them and most of the sequels follow that, Dominion is trying to fix this but it still imperfect (time and space travelling Giganotosaurus killing a T.rex, Moros coexisting with Giga and T.rex, Pyroraptor being a bit too large, Atrociraptors looking more like Kenner JP Utahraptors ect.) Although, if they made a remake of JP and have more scientifically accurate dinosaurs, I'd be pretty damn happy.

@Grandmaster_BigTank7

Жыл бұрын

😂😂😂

A few questions here 1. 3:45, when you say T. rex spent most of it's life as a smaller hunter/scavenger what do you mean, since T. rex was big? 2. Were all T. rex sounds made with it's mouth closed? 3. If T. rex honked would it be like a goose?

@StudioMod

2 жыл бұрын

1. Trex had a large growth spurt after a few years, that if it survived to that point, would drastically alter the animal’s size and behavior as a hunter. This is why they have small arms. Up until the final growth spurt, their arms were proportional. 2. Probably. 3. Those sounds are included in my latest Dinosaur video. You should take a look.

Fascinating! I hope to hear more work done on the sounds of dinosaurs in future, I love to listen to them.

Awesome!!! Really tense and felt like an actual animal.

Dude, its scary how you can actually feel the vocalisations with headphones.

Very cool! Thank you- this was really enjoyable.

So far, the most unsettling depiction of the voice of the giant tyrant lizard king that I've yet heard, and I felt it more than I just heard it.

Awesome job man! Thank you for The new knowledge!

ah yes, the fear of not being able to hear more than perhaps footsteps and feeling your ears pop. im terrified

Now this is WAY MORE Terrifying compared to the Jurassic Park T-REX Sounds. It's so realistic!

@goryspirit

10 ай бұрын

It made my dog bark and growl. LOL

Incredible video. Are there any zoos where I can see this amazing animal?

This is horrific. I would not survive even feeling the sound. I would pass away. However, great work here. It is a good educated guess based on the pitch studied by Clarke and the vocal capabilities through cross reference of known biology and it’s decedents. Hopefully our 3D modeling technology will become good enough to simulate audio production with skin tissue, it may be the closest we can get to replicating the sounds they could make. We just recently found a mummified Nodosaur, so hopefully we will determine exactly which vocal organs were at the disposal of those in it’s genus.

Outstading work! TY!

This is really interesting and it would be quite terrifying. Correct me if I’m wrong so they can’t hear humans screaming and with there frequency we are lucky if we could hear them unless of course that last sound I’m assuming is when Tyrannosaurus is right on top of you. I love Jurassic Park T-Rex but I love even more the real science and attempts at finding out what they truly sound and look like. It is quite creepy because thanks to Jurassic Park if I were living during the ages of dinosaurs. I’d be in trouble and obviously I wouldn’t do the “stand still don’t move.” But, as someone who does wildlife photography I depend on sound I used to be a hunter and now I take pictures but still hunting in a way but you learn to really listen good to sounds. For example, I live in the north west and there are mountain lions here and some people don’t know this heck I didn’t know for a long time but they make a little sound that is very similar to a bird chirp (look it up) it’s scary because you wonder if you’ve heard a “bird” and maybe it wasn’t but the thought of potentially not hearing an animal approaching especially a large one like the Tyrannosaurus make it even more scarier but also forces us to give it more deserving of respect and title of the nickname “Tyrant-Lizard King”. I’d love to see a video of someone trying to figure out raptor sounds because that would be interesting. Thank you for sharing this!

Id love to see more of these!

I think I'm going to record and download some of these fantastic sounds!

Holy shit, that super low frequency grumbling made my headphones vibrate a bit, that is scary

This damn gold of a video gave me really BAD Goosebumps tbh its much scarier to hear these sounds then roars screams and Giants footsteps i am full on out about to crap my self this is beyond horrifying and my Lord I don’t want to know the work you put into this video bc it prob was what days weeks maybe months? Idk i have no clue on how audio/sounds work

Thank fuck Dinosaurs are gone cuz that ending sound of the video made me wee a bit lol

@NoOne-kr4jc

10 ай бұрын

lmao

I am curious about something... Is it known or surmised what the atmospheric pressure and/or the mix of gasses were back then? Helium sure changes a persons pitch when a breathing it.

Would be nice to ear this in a video with a Trex moving like from a jp scene or documentary

@StudioMod

2 жыл бұрын

Half this channel is already devoted to that.

Good job

Truly fascinating. Was this all accomplished with audio manipulation, or were you using physical modeling software?

I heard that it would’ve sounded like alligators and crocodiles

If I remember correctly, wasnt the t-rex sounds from the original Jurassic Park film made by a Crocodile in Gatorland Florida?

@StudioMod

7 ай бұрын

A baby elephant and a lion also I believe.

Ok you do make a good point, but i gotta ask… which species of birds and reptiles would, could and should be used for the Tyrannosaurus Rex, Velociraptors, Oviraptors, etc.

@StudioMod

2 жыл бұрын

Any that do not have a syrinx. Dinosaurs have not been thought to evolve them like modern avian dinosaurs. Some likely had a pseudo syrinx or a proto-syrinx, meaning you could probably replicate their sounds by data cleaning a proportionate vulture honk. New World Vultures do not have syrinx. They do have a larynx, but birds can’t make sound with it as it lacks the rigidity to produce noise. Dinosaurs used air exchange (hissing) and honking/bellowing to produce communication. Modern avian dinosaurs leading back to the original avians likely produced a specific set of sounds to specifically communicate within their own species. This is why birds sing today. Our modern dinosaurs typically come from the noisiest dinosaurs available at the time. That’s not to say dinosaurs were noisy, it’s just all we have left to examine of them. Think of a rhino or a giraffe. These animals seldom make noise. It would be more like that.

@tyrexdudesforever2020

2 жыл бұрын

@@StudioMod Thanks man, i appreciate your advice, been a while since i commented you on this video. Oooh and one more thing, do you think you can collaborate with Dangerville to further the realistic animal sounds in his What would it REALLY Sound Like Videos, just giving you ideas

@tyrexdudesforever2020

2 жыл бұрын

Hey Mr. Studio, why are you not answering me, i was just asking if you want to collab with Dangerville so you can both learn and compromise on how the Dinosaur would really sound like, it’s not that completely hard, please answer me.

@ExtremeMadnessX

Жыл бұрын

​@@StudioMod Not all modern birds could chirp, cassowaries, ostriches and emus also don't have larynx and made truly terrifying reptilian like sounds.

Not a long, drawn-out roar, but a low menacing growl...

Hi, is it okay to give your video and channel a shoutout on social media, like Instagram?

@StudioMod

2 жыл бұрын

Of course! I'd really appreciate it :)

Good job bro. Saw ya link in that dino survival game discord. Hope ya get on their team!

@ukan1527

2 жыл бұрын

Which game would that be, might I ask?

@SlightlyCivil

2 жыл бұрын

@@ukan1527 i dont remember. Left that server a while ago

My non university/college mimd things trex may have sounded like this but also maybe like alligators and modern birds??? Like a mix of??? Idk, I just love dinos

Can anyone explain me why I can't hear almost anything? All I get is bird chirping, a deep bass sound (similar to Jurassic Park's T-Rex footsteps) in Clarke's exposition and a muted groan at the end. Is it because of the frequency, by any chance? Or that's what I'm supposed to be hearing? I'm in my 40's, btw.

As a human we'd probably feel this animal just existing...

💯👍

Cool, dangervile is just some random lady mixing random animals lmao.

0:41

Whatchu say Rexy dear?

thanks for the explanation, but I have to call out the irony. This is a video about sound animals make, that we have to read about. lol

5:55

wait, wouldn't it have made more sense for a rex to have hearing that was more adapted to detecting sounds made by it's favored prey?

@StudioMod

Жыл бұрын

No. The Rex had the largest olfactory cavity in an animal that has ever existed. Second in terms of proportionality when compared to modern American Turkey Vultures. They could smell and detect dead animals for up to like 50 miles.

@inkvixen3141

Жыл бұрын

that doesn't exactly refute my point. When hunting, it helps to have all your senses as sharp as they can be; attuned to the hunt. Having ears that were better adapted to communicate with other rexes wouldn't be as helpful as hearing their prey better.

Hi studio i have a question what's your opinion on Quetzalcoatlus vs Trex fight on Prehistoric planet 2 and the other epesode where the Trex effectively hunt an Edmontosaur on ambush, the narrator stated that T-Rex had pads on their toes so they can walk silently and ambush their prey effectively he also stated that "They usually ambush their prey"whats your take or opinion on this? I asked you this because you said in your live and your comments that a Trex can't ambush cuz of its sheer size, smell and the noise it makes. Here's the link incase you didn't watch it yet quetzalcoatlus vs t rex : kzread.info/dash/bejne/rIt70M56gda4kag.html Trex hunting scene : kzread.info/dash/bejne/pm2EvNqJmsyam9Y.html

@StudioMod

8 ай бұрын

Tyrannosaur cannot ambush prey. There's no cushion in the world that could mask their presence. They smell and inhabit densely packed woods.

Can listen to sounds of an alligator an get an idea.

Do not record or DownLoard lol

Damn, is this still very accurate??

@StudioMod

Жыл бұрын

Yes. The most accurate produced Tyrannosaurus sound arguably ever produced. Workshopped and advanced upon by research started by Julia Clarke.

@itsdamochiman3542

Жыл бұрын

@@StudioMod Huh...but, what about that recent dino vocalization study you did??

@StudioMod

Жыл бұрын

@@itsdamochiman3542 Same sounds were used for both. I took some further liberties with the new one, furthering the idea. This is the core study.

@itsdamochiman3542

Жыл бұрын

@@StudioMod Oh, ok I see. I respect that. I hope we get to see more vids like this for all the dinosaurs we see in the Jurassic Saga. I think you'd do wonders for the modders of the Jurassic World Evolution games who'd mod the dinos to be more scientifically accurate. That is of course if you wanna do it Lol

ok the Whale and Bird noise are reversed to eachother

@StudioMod

Жыл бұрын

What?