This videos is so confused. Building Bikeways and increasing Green space is NOT what 15 minute cities are about. Are you moving destinations closer to the home? Schools, workplaces, shopping, recreation? Then you're "15 minuitizing" the city. Anything else, is not that. The status quo is we're too far away from things. That's what people are hoping to change.

@MrEkzotic

2 ай бұрын

Yes, people packed into cities on top of one another are much easier to monitor and control.

@KK20191

2 ай бұрын

@@MrEkzoticSo are homes packed next to each other or cars packed next to each other. I remember that car companies had run propaganda saying that highways and strodes are the way of the future. You people are so funny 💀

@tsvetoslavpopov261

2 ай бұрын

​​@@MrEkzotic that's what i was waiting for the whole time. Finally somebody will monitor my health and safety so i don't get robbed or get heart attack and die on the street and they can control those thugs and mobs

@MrEkzotic

2 ай бұрын

@@KK20191 In other words, there will be no suburbs. People will not be able to choose where they want to live. Why do you want to be controlled?

@MrEkzotic

2 ай бұрын

@@tsvetoslavpopov261 I'm assuming that's sarcasm. I hope it is.

Living in a city must be a nightmare. Constantly surrounded by subhumans.

Imagine hating a walkable city. SMH

@MrEkzotic

4 ай бұрын

It's not the walkable city that we hate, it's the agenda behind the walkable city.

@CChrist-mh4mk

4 ай бұрын

@@MrEkzoticyou’re a cultist that has no facts on their side.

@PedroParko

4 ай бұрын

Imagine hating native Americans and not leaving usa

@MrEkzotic

4 ай бұрын

@@PedroParko Imagine American Indians fighting each other over parcels of land instead of building a country capable of defending itself.

@CChrist-mh4mk

4 ай бұрын

@@PedroParko that makes literally zero sense.

One of my roommates is one of those kooks, he brought up "15 minute prisons" and it took about 3 minutes of research and facepalmimg to embarass him enough to never bring it up again. This is the "do your own research" crowd.

@edmunddantes7097

4 ай бұрын

Even if you trust, verify.

@PedroParko

4 ай бұрын

So support police unions???

@colettefoy5961

4 ай бұрын

Can’t wait for one of those ‘kooks ‘ to be proven correct. Bet you followed EVERY covid rules and are fully vaccinated . Hmmm ‘do your own research’ 🤣🤣🤣

@TheTrueOnyxRose

4 ай бұрын

@@PedroParko: That’s irrelevant.

@PedroParko

4 ай бұрын

@@TheTrueOnyxRose says the white man to the minority, please explain how unions for cops are good

The amount of utterly naive ppl in these comments omg

It's not a concentration camp. Or a gaza style open air prison. You can leave and go to other parts of the country. You can still drive to places in these concepts. It's just a return to the block neighborhoods that places used to have a little over a century ago. It's a bid to make good public policy. Not to cater to cars and whatever industry that lonbied the hardest recently.

@NatalieRath

4 ай бұрын

Remember a lot of conservatives are funded by the fuel industry. 😂

@Charles-js3ri

4 ай бұрын

@@MrEkzotic Do you have any sources to cite? That could be a nice thing to have. A fantastic claim requires fantastic evidence.

@fity_4696

4 ай бұрын

Ole Joe Rogue the "What If " guy.

@JonathanMorris777

4 ай бұрын

@@MrEkzotic I am glad you put that in quotes because I am sure a sensible person like you didn't actually believe any of it. Until everyone has to carry a smartphone by law wherever they travel, that idea isn't going to work. Also you'd need to be visible to a camera for facial recognition, which still isn't 100% accurate by any means. Plus our incompetent Government wouldn't be able to build such infrastructure without it costing billions and probably never being completed. And for what gain? To totally destroy our economy? It's absolutely ridiculous. Now, yes, I can see congestion charges that impose a fee on entering more towns and cities becoming a thing.. even for EVs (they might be greener, but they still add to congestion) and that will encourage more people to use public transport, walk or cycle, but our economy relies on freedom of movement to work (generating money) and for retail/leisure (spending money).

@steveparris

4 ай бұрын

​@Charles-js3ri I don't know the lack of walls. 😂 You can't make the stupidity of fear mongering up.

I sort of live in one. The whole city isnt this way but the part I live in is. I think it is because this area of the city is 100 years old. This neighborhood back then was also its own city before it got incorporated into the bigger one so it has a lot of its own infrastructure. I am minutes walk away from a library, zoo, college, food, grocery, convenience store, gas station, fire department, park, bars, and a lovely bike path along the river. I am very thankful to live here and it is so nice to walk where I want ro.

@JusticeAlways

4 ай бұрын

Sounds nice! I live in the country...the nearest store is 12 miles away. But it is very peaceful and quiet. Reckon there are trade offs... 👍

@UCCHANGES

2 ай бұрын

Souns beautiful

@richardgregory3684

Ай бұрын

_ I am minutes walk away from a library, zoo, college, food, grocery, convenience store, gas station, fire department, park, bars, and a lovely bike path along the river. I am very thankful to live here and it is so nice to walk where I want_ You might but I bet most peopel in your city aren;t. It would be crazy to build a college or zoo or fire station every few miles. A big city would end up with dozens of them. And youlittle local stores - I bet they have way higher prices and far less choice of goods than a large supermarket because a big store is far more efficient thanks to economies of scale.

@mimdr7

Ай бұрын

Andcwgat about the ficus l credit system? You don’t follow THEIR rules you get points taken off.. you won’t be able to travel. It’s China… soon you’ll be caned!

@comraderamirez9866

Ай бұрын

@@richardgregory3684 You don't have to build a college or zoo every few miles, that's not how it works. The idea is everything you need, plus some extra amenities, should be within 15 minutes walk/cycle/public transport of where you live. So shops, pharmacies, GPs, bars, restaurants, cinemas etc. The whole point is that you are no longer car dependent, you do not rely on your car to live. You do not need to visit a zoo every week to live. Those will obviously be few and far between, but they should have good public transport links or you can drive to them if need be, but in your day to day life you do not need to rely on a car to shop, work or reach basic amenities.

Seems like an odd random thing to be against.....oh no people can walk to work and where they wanna shop easier and NOT have to drive everywhere? The horror. But hey these guys here 45 seconds of something and if its not actively hurting some group it must be bad i guess

@MrEkzotic

4 ай бұрын

And you hear 45 seconds of something and you think it's a great thing.

@edmunddantes7097

4 ай бұрын

@@MrEkzoticSo what are the cons?

@MrEkzotic

4 ай бұрын

@@edmunddantes7097 The cons are loss of personal freedom and anonymity, being fined for driving outside of your designated area, being recorded 24/7 with facial recognition to calculate your social credit score. It is being done in Oxford: "People do not realize that residents will only be allowed within 15 minutes of their home address, and violators will be fined. For example, under the new proposals, if any of Oxford’s 150,000 residents drive outside their designated district more than 100 days a year, they could be fined £70. In addition, the government will track and control your every movement through your smartphones & facial recognition technology..." That is just the beginning. They are selling it on "convenience," but it's really about control.

@edmunddantes7097

4 ай бұрын

@@MrEkzotic @MrEkzotic 1.Personal freedom-people already live in cities. That's a real thing, not a new concept so not sure what you mean there. 2.Being fined for driving outside designated area- Not a real thing. It hasn't happened once. That was just a thing made up by somebody, try to find just one instance of it actually having happened. 3.Recorded 24/7 w/ facial recognition & SCS- That is a thing in China. Not in any of the other places where this already exists. However, that applies to ALL of China regardless of anything. 4.Violators will be fined and confined- From a completely different bill that regulates traffic of motor vehicles at certain times. People are free to use public transport or non vehicle means of travel. 5. Government tracking-Ever since the Patriot Act that's already been a thing. Has literally nothing to do with 15 minute cities and everything to do with government overreach. So right now they already have control of power grids, water grids and can cut off control of cell towers. They can close highways, main roads and other city exits. What aspect of a 15 minute city would make it easier?

@MrEkzotic

4 ай бұрын

@@edmunddantes7097 Again, go to the official Oxford City Council website and read about the 15 minute city, it's all there in black and white. And you have to try to understand, sociopathic.authoritarians don't push everything all at once, they do it incrementally. If you study history and psychology, it's very easy to predict what's going to happen. I knew the Patriot Act would be used to spy on millions of innocent American citizens. I knew people would be strong armed into taking an experimental drug. I knew January 6th would be used to smear all Trump voters. The bureaucrats in government view you as an enemy, not as one they are supposed to serve. Go read the published documents.

If you don’t want to live in a walkable city, then don’t!

@bobbobbington3615

3 ай бұрын

Deal!

I'm forced to drive a mile to the store down the street because the speed limits are too high, there's no shoulder. I've done that walk in the winter when I can see if there are snakes in the ditch. 😂😂😂 we don't have to change entire towns, just make traveling accessible for people who aren't in autos.

@JusticeAlways

4 ай бұрын

Bicycle riding is fun! Great exercise too! 👍

@lilacghoste8366

3 ай бұрын

Living with cope i see. Remain backward i guess.

@chunkemonke398

3 ай бұрын

But really though? The fact that you need to travel a mile when I could walk down the block to get a gallon of milk.

@ShinyMew151

3 ай бұрын

What city or town do you live in where this is a thing?

@scruf153

21 күн бұрын

@@JusticeAlways agreed but e bikes are funner

Massive Urban Planning has a history of disasterious results.

@alanwatchesstuff

4 ай бұрын

why do you act like theres no massive urban planning now?

@CChrist-mh4mk

4 ай бұрын

Your entire life exists because of massive urban planning.

@ricardocantoral7672

4 ай бұрын

@@alanwatchesstuff There's nothing occuring that reaches the level of what they did in the 1960's which ultimately hurt way more people than it helped. You have public works projects going on, sure. That's not what I speak of.

@ricardocantoral7672

4 ай бұрын

@@CChrist-mh4mk It exists in spite of urban planning.

@CChrist-mh4mk

4 ай бұрын

@@ricardocantoral7672 LOL. No.

I work for the railway. Do people think that they're just going to shut the railway network down, close roads and put up walls around every city? I mean, seriously, do they believe that - because I've read people saying just this. A cycle lane means they're going to turn every city into a prison! Hasn't anyone gone to a city and walked around to enjoy the sights? People literally go on holiday/vacation to see other cities around the world and most likely you used public transport or walked during your time there. Nobody locked you in and said you couldn't leave did they? This has to be one the more crazy conspiracy theories, and I work in a place called Welwyn Garden City - one of two garden cities built in the 1920s and literally had a mix of houses, parks, industrial areas, schools, a hospital and shops. 15 minute cities existed 100 years ago! Still no wall or borders 100 years on..

@hildegardvonbingen9092

4 ай бұрын

Well If they put up thousands of facial recognition cameras which they did at places like NYC remove most of the Motor ways except for supply routes and Public Services, than you can't really Go anywhere without Public Transportation. And when they've completely digitalised your id with your biometrical data all your movements and actions will be constantely monitored and evaluated. Then they don't have to close down the rail roads, it's sufficient to Just Block your digital id from using Public Transport or at least some routes Or you get fined or can't buy certain things anymore or lose access to certain Public Services.

@johnathin0061892

2 ай бұрын

It is easy to believe because it has already been done.The Soviets literally did that to West Berlin in 1961.

communites. full functioning equanimity. for. All Communities Healthy life. It is a great place to thrive

As someone who is shaping my next home purchase on walkability, I don't get how anyone can hate on a 15 minute city. I prefer biking to work but the route there is treacherous at points. I like the idea of being able to get groceries, entertainment, and have good public transit options connecting areas that are self-sustained, multi use, and walk friendly. Its insane that something can be a half mile away from you but you have to drive because the sidewalks are inadequate or not there at all due to roads.

@MrEkzotic

4 ай бұрын

"People do not realize that residents will only be allowed within 15 minutes of their home address, and violators will be fined. For example, under the new proposals, if any of Oxford’s 150,000 residents drive outside their designated district more than 100 days a year, they could be fined £70. In addition, the government will track and control your every movement through your smartphones & facial recognition technology..."

@edmunddantes7097

4 ай бұрын

​@@MrEkzoticWhere does that quote come from? Would like to read more.

@CChrist-mh4mk

4 ай бұрын

@@MrEkzoticLOL. You got tricked by the far right.

@balthorpayne

4 ай бұрын

@@MrEkzoticBro, WHERE DID YOU GET THIS FROM! You love listening to people who think anything and everything is about control. Your quote says "Proposal" which means its written somewhere. Can we get a link?

@CChrist-mh4mk

4 ай бұрын

@@MrEkzoticwhy won’t you tell anyone where this quote is from?

Joe Bogan heard of this 2 minutes ago so of course he's against it.

@edmunddantes7097

4 ай бұрын

Alex Jones probably explained it to him.

@PedroParko

4 ай бұрын

Tbh it stems from white Supremacy

@Blu3Purple

2 ай бұрын

And you want to force people living like that lol

It really is about designing cities around people instead of cars. That doesn't mean you can't visit your favorite restaurant across town 🙄

@holzmann-

4 ай бұрын

"It really is about designing cities around people instead of cars" We can design both. Yes, I agree there's nothing wrong with this concept but I feel like this video is creating a non-existant opponents so leftists can win their argument

@allergy5634

4 ай бұрын

@@holzmann-It absolutely isn’t. There is a massive conspiracy theory around 15 minute cities.

@mattfrue2698

4 ай бұрын

@@allergy5634 yup. You will eat zee bugs and like it.

@juanitagonzalez8333

3 ай бұрын

Will see about that😂

@allergy5634

3 ай бұрын

@@juanitagonzalez8333As someone who lives in a 15 minute city, this comment is accurate.

Why are people against this? This sounds great. When I went to myrtle beach, I spent the majority of the time walking to places.

@soulpowerful

4 ай бұрын

Wake up! This is just the beginning

@plaidpanda

4 ай бұрын

​@@soulpowerfulI sure hope so!

@Noctem_pasa

4 ай бұрын

Because they’re conflating being ABLE to do everything within a 15 minute radius to HAVING to do everything within a 15 minute radius

@EhRage67

4 ай бұрын

Because those people are dumb

@M.J.212

4 ай бұрын

​​@@soulpowerfulThe Narrative Fallacy (also, the Fable; the Poster Child) The ancient fallacy of persuasion by telling a "heartwarming" or horrifying story or fable, particularly to less-educated or uncritical audiences who are less likely to grasp purely logical arguments or general principles. Reductionism: (also, Oversimplifying, Sloganeering): The fallacy of deceiving an audience by giving simple answers or bumper-sticker slogans in response to complex questions, especially when appealing to less educated or unsophisticated audiences. Scare Tactics (also Appeal to Fear; Paranoia; the Bogeyman Fallacy; Shock Doctrine [ShockDoc]; Rally 'Round the Flag; Rally 'Round the President): A variety of Playing on Emotions, a corrupted argument from pathos, taking advantage of a emergent or deliberately-created crisis and its associated public shock, panic and chaos in order to impose an argument, action or solution that would be clearly unacceptable if carefully considered. The Slippery Slope (also, the Domino Theory): The common fallacy that "one thing inevitably leads to another." The Worst-Case Fallacy (also, "Just in case;" "We can't afford to take chances;" "An abundance of caution;" "Better Safe than Sorry;" "Better to prevent than to lament."): A pessimistic fallacy by which one’s reasoning is based on an improbable, far-fetched or even completely imaginary worst-case scenario rather than on reality. This plays on pathos (fear) rather than reason, and is often politically motivated.

I literally was born and live in a town in the UK where most things are in 15 minutes and it's something I've taken for granted. It's not bad guys, it's made life so much easier to not own a car, to get plenty of exercise from walking, green space (or in my case a beach!) AND get a local community or at least access to one. I genuinely don't know why you'd object to this unless you have a pathological connection to being an angry paranoid person. 🤷🏼‍♀️

@beth8775

4 ай бұрын

You described these nuts perfectly.

@goberianchloex3646

4 ай бұрын

It’s because most places won’t get a large green area or be near a beach

@gracielasaenz9300

4 ай бұрын

less cars less petrol for distance great trains. ❤️ UK.

@scruf153

21 күн бұрын

@@goberianchloex3646 I live 8 miles from lake martin in Alabama two back roads and I am there by bicycle/e bike takes 25 35 minutes rolling hills

As someone who live in a city where Schools, Grocery stores, Hospitals and Parks at walking distance I can assure you that "We are not living in a prison" Even the school I go to was an nearly an hour drive from my home. We didn't have "restrictions on where we can move or not"

@tribaltreegoat

3 ай бұрын

Im personally happy that my city is decently walkable with resturaunts, stores, and my house being able to be walked to in only 30 minutes, with only a part of the city cut off

Timothy Murray - 11 year old honor student arrested, put in solitary confinement for 3 days- Brownsville, Tx. Please bring attention to this poor child's plight. It's unbelievable that not only the school but the prosecutor are violating this kids rights.

and Europe has a fantastic transpiration system. We on the other hand do not!

@JusticeAlways

4 ай бұрын

My nephew moved to Germany 2 years ago...because of the "situation" in the US. He said he hasn't drove a car at all. He also said life is better there...and decided to stay.

Imagine being against having your child care, school green park and doctor within a 15 minute walk. Imagine screaming that the government will block you from leaving in a country where they won't even ban guns where 30k+ people have died from gun violence in 2023. I can only imagine it's because the US is afraid they can't actually walk for 15 minutes.

@elliotwilliams7421

Ай бұрын

if you cant imagine why other people do, you are thick and shouldnt be in the conversation

Never ever heard of a "15 minute" city being mentioned by numerous conservatives or libertarians. I think that was just an honest concern by Joe Rogan .

Some people do things like regularly practise sports, imagine wanting playing hockey and not being able to easily drive to the rink with your kit. Or having to pay to pass through an area to access a stable where you keep your horse. Restricting movement to push a 15-minute concept (as it's suggested to be implemented in the UK) is bad.

The problem with driving a car in a big city is there's NEVER ANY PARKING.

@alanwatchesstuff

4 ай бұрын

why should people tear down the city just for you to park?

@JusticeAlways

4 ай бұрын

@@alanwatchesstuff There you go....correct! I'm just making my point... I love riding my bicycle. 👍

Some people just want to sit in their car for 40 mins to get to work 😂

@scruf153

21 күн бұрын

and 30 mins of that trip is not moving

Intellectual laziness forces people to reduce every subject into politics (liberal vs. conservative) without understanding what that subject means. This result in people opposing their own interest just because it is the "other side's" idea. Also see affordable Healthcare.

@MagicBus-ct7fe

4 ай бұрын

yes it's because it's asshols from the other Side making this idea based on political reasons. Obviously this here is communist garbage

@Currymaxxed

3 ай бұрын

@@MagicBus-ct7fe Bolshevik regime 2.0 incoming. The "you know whos" are winning again

You are under control as to where you can go. That is government overreach.

As a person who can no longer drive; this would appeal greatly to me.

Joe Rogan in the clip said he’s against mandates to stay in a particular area not what you have defined as a 15 minute city. This video is nonsense straw manning

@CChrist-mh4mk

4 ай бұрын

So he’s making up a problem that doesn’t exist.

@TeitySprinkTTV

4 ай бұрын

@@CChrist-mh4mk You’re absolutely right no country in history has ever restricted the movement of civilians. 🤣 lol… I think u need to do some research bud.

@CChrist-mh4mk

4 ай бұрын

@@TeitySprinkTTV LOL. There is nothing stopping the US from doing that right now.

@TeitySprinkTTV

4 ай бұрын

@@CChrist-mh4mkyou are very confused my man. U just said the problem doesn’t exist now ur saying it could exist but doesn’t which if true WOULD ABSOLUTELY BE A PROBLEM!!! Imagine not even being able to coherently articulate a POV. Wow… 6th grade level.

@TeitySprinkTTV

4 ай бұрын

@@CChrist-mh4mkso to reiterate: Joe pointed out the problem of governments wanting to restrict movement and how that could be dangerous if implemented. He did not argue with the concept of making essential goods and services easily accessible.

The problem is wealthier parts of the cities will have better infrastructure than lower income areas.

@CChrist-mh4mk

4 ай бұрын

That already exists.

@PedroParko

4 ай бұрын

​@@CChrist-mh4mkwe get it you hate BLM and black people who don't agree with Bernie sanders

@CChrist-mh4mk

4 ай бұрын

@@PedroParko hey, it’s the person who is pretending to be Native American. HI!!

@bruingold

4 ай бұрын

..and the city will over tax and penalize all other residents with increased fees to support the growing welfare programs

@beth8775

4 ай бұрын

That is a policy choice, not an inevitability.

I living in Finland, 1 hour travel to city center but all services that i need are close to me. I can get food products and all shopping done in 15 minutes if include walking to store and back to home. Pharmacy is 3 minutes walk away and library too. Petrol station is 10 minutes walk away, but i do not need those services because public transport work well. Hospital is 30 minutes walk away, but if i use bicycle takes 10 minutes to get there. Safety is good too, no violence, gangs or American style police. Last time i saw police was maybe 4 months ago. No homeless people. Schools are near too, 3 minutes walk away.

@JusticeAlways

4 ай бұрын

Yay Finland! My mother was born there...Vipori I believe is the town. She has told me so many great stories about Finland. God I wish I was living there now! 👍

This is how you know that anyone who actually has a brain in this camp are unserious. The most popular neighborhoods in any city have the highest walkability

@mediterraneanworld

Ай бұрын

THe most expensive part of Houston, near the downtown, is a perfect example of that! I am sure this is the same experience in many large American cities - the near town or downtown has become the place to be as people flee the suburbs.

I live in a suburban part of Maryland with no car and I am loosing my mind. I need to find a 15-minute city to move to ASAP!

They don't want people to get exercise? I mean, walking is good for health, right?

@MagicBus-ct7fe

4 ай бұрын

for 15 minutes??? Not at all

I live in Alabama I bicycle commute I lean 92% conservative on most things and I love the idea of 15 minute cities in my city most everything is within a 10 mile radius one of the biggest state parks in the country for RVs and on one of the largest man made lakes is only 8 miles from home

@mediterraneanworld

Ай бұрын

It is ridiculous that this is politicized, but unfortunately and this is done by the right using everything to create an outrage factor. Being conservative is not auto right-wing... There is noting more American than 15 minute cities as that's what snall towns were and even the original design of cities before the suburbs! Even older suburbs are much more urban than the ones of the last 40 years.... There are lots of older cities int he South that are 15 minute cities - like San Antonio, New Orleans, much of Houston, etc...

I just got a job a half mile from my home and it's delightful. During December I enjoyed seeing all the decorations on my walk. During the recent crappy weather I could get to my job, by my spouse couldn't get to theirs just 8 miles away.

The 15 minute cities are a concept that isn't really thought through. I mean what about all those people working in the big cities commuting from the Region? The City is already densly populated and expensive to live in? Would you want all those commuters to live there as well? Or would you Just cut Them off? I mean both solutions don't seem practical. And What about the supply lines? You would still need Roads for Trucks to Support so many people living in a small area.

@valleyofiron125

4 ай бұрын

Rail into and out of cities. Access for delivery trucks is built in. This is how they make nice cities in Europe. It is funny that so many people are afraid of 15 min cities. Please understand - the cities we live in that are choked with traffic and unwalkable were the result of top down control- parking minimums, very restrictive zoning that did not allow offices and housing to be near each over, highways on top of highways.

@scruf153

21 күн бұрын

half of american cities were torn down for the automobile and people who live in the suburbs are loopy crazy and uninged most do not even know there neighbors or never met them think living somewhere for 20 years and not knowing who your neighbors are welcome to america

It creates handy little "villages" within a sprawling urban environment. "butbutbut...FREEDOM!" To do WHAT, precisely? "To, uh, er, um, go where you want to go..." And this is denied anybody, HOW, precisely? "What if somebody wants to shop or work someplace else, huh?" What's stopping them? *crickets*

@susyguima

4 ай бұрын

What stopped you from going wherever you wanted during lockdown? Think again.

@johngordy8071

4 ай бұрын

@@susyguima Consideration of others, dear chap. Sorry to hear how badly inconvenienced you must have been...

@susyguima

4 ай бұрын

@@johngordy8071 yah going for a walk or a drive was really unconsiderate. 🤦

@johngordy8071

4 ай бұрын

@@susyguima If you insisted on going unmasked...

@susyguima

4 ай бұрын

@@johngordy8071 😂😂😂

next question is : whos funding " nowthis impact"?......always follow the money

@Currymaxxed

3 ай бұрын

So many people are eating this all up. History is lost to these people. Bolshevik regime 2.0 incoming

@nishiljaiswal2216

3 ай бұрын

@@Currymaxxedall cities were 15 minute cities before the car

@Currymaxxed

3 ай бұрын

​@@nishiljaiswal2216 My issue is not with the cities. It is with the potential for control they usher in. And we have the car now. We also have face tracking software and digital footprints. I am for infrastructure being built around humans but you have to consider the costs. And if you listen to anything they say at WEF 15 minute cities are just one step in a big plan to centralize power. Enjoy living in a cyberpunk Bolshevik state

@turtleman9295

2 ай бұрын

⁠@@CurrymaxxedYou should be worried with the control governments have now with car-centric communities. What happens if the government blocks off roads? What happens if the government shuts down gas stations? Your argument makes no sense.

@quackywhackityphillyb.3005

2 ай бұрын

@@Currymaxxed you realize they can just put a camera in your car... and a gps....

People are against this because oil industry's pay them to be against this .

@JusticeAlways

4 ай бұрын

And car companies And insurance companies And auto tag tax collectors And tire companies (You get the drift) 😂

@jasonlee8156

4 ай бұрын

@@JusticeAlways I get the drift. And its' a grift 😄

@JusticeAlways

4 ай бұрын

@@jasonlee8156 👍😁

@bloodnwine

4 ай бұрын

Winner winner Chicken Dinner!

@Premenyc

3 ай бұрын

Or they live in places that are constantly under funded and already destroyed… thats a ridiculous idea. Your basically trapping people where they spawn.

Conservatives Love gasoline and such

@scruf153

21 күн бұрын

conservative living in central Alabama I do not own a car I cycle and walk 365 days a year

I don’t think conservatives that humans have lived in 15 minute cities for centuries. They were horse drawn carriages and eventually cars but most people just walked where they needed to go

@jasonlee8156

4 ай бұрын

Well these conservatives must be stupid.

"Imagine a city where everything you need is a 15 minute walk or bike ride away". You can imagine it all you like, but it is impossible. You're not goign to have a hospital, college, university, large supermarket, veterinary practise every 15 minutes. It makes absolutely no sense to build a dozen small hospitals in a large city and a business liek a vet needs a bigger catchment area than peopel within a 15 minute walk to be viable.

They are buyed by big oil company

@mediterraneanworld

Ай бұрын

good heavens that grammar!

@dandeluxe8731

Ай бұрын

​@@mediterraneanworld But you still managed to understand what she's saying

To be honest. We have a lot of these cities in the Netherlands. Using/parking a car is made crazy expensive in the last 15 to 20 years. Parking now is around 7 dollars an hour and you can't drive SUV in some parts. So yes. There is some thruth to the stories. Tyrannical no, but yes limiting in options to actually move around freely without paying the price.

Try doing this in South Central or Compton.

@beth8775

4 ай бұрын

Policy shifts that create opportunities for the people who live in those communities to open small businesses aimed at meeting the needs of their own community? Sounds like a great way to reduce poverty and improve safety and quality of life for all involved.

This is pure propaganda…. WEF even tells you YOU WILL OWN NOTHING AND BE HAPPY 🤡

If that were true they wouldn’t be closing airports

This is how hunger games started

I like the idea. I am concerned about rural areas too.

@JusticeAlways

4 ай бұрын

I live in a rural area...a 90 year old neighbor (lives about 1 mile from us)...gets around using a golf cart.

@francescaking6187

4 ай бұрын

@@JusticeAlways I live in one also. The problem with walking cities is that the resources are more focused and often surrounding the capital. State governments often send more resources to areas near them. Unfortunately, those that lack financial resources, social networks and services, or educational opportunities are left behind. Thanks for your comment! 🙂

@scruf153

21 күн бұрын

@@JusticeAlways good way to ged around

@JusticeAlways

18 күн бұрын

@@scruf153 Yes! (The 90 yr old lady has recently passed away...😕 ) 👍

It is called fencing and hearding ,like cattle ...this is what happens when the dictators get into city government

The problem is that to accomplish that they have to expropriate massive amounts of people.

Most cities are already 15 minutes to get what you need. They have bike paths in Phoenix and guess what………… nobody uses them

@proteinchips

3 ай бұрын

Are there legitimate bike lanes or are they bike gutters on the side of the street where you are at risk of being hit by a motor vehicle? Are these bike lanes consistently maintained or do are the constantly blocked by people who think it is a parking space? Is the path made out of materials resistant to collecting heat?

This is like being afraid of supermarkets because you think "everything you need in one stop" means you're going to get locked in for the rest of your life.

@RiversRun597

3 ай бұрын

😄😂 nailed it!!

@bobbobbington3615

3 ай бұрын

So.... the permits are just a feature?

Bill Gates will say you get a bug 🐛taco You get a bug 🐛 bug burritos for everybody!!!

Where I live this plan restrict you to 3 pieces of clothing per year, meat forbiden, diary product forbiden, 1 trip every 3 years with a 1500km maximum distance, car forbiden. Thats why people are against that.

@rgprosucctions1704

13 күн бұрын

Source?

These cities already exist. In fact Tokyo is almost a 4 minute city.

Sorry but you cannot put Joe Rogan and Dr. Peterson opinion on the matter as equal. One is a show hoste with no real education or concrete knowledge on the matter and there's Dr. Peterson, philosopher, as studied human behavior, had is own practice and is a former professors in psychology.

“I hate change” - all conservatives

@beybladebaby

4 ай бұрын

Progress? Improvement? Change??? (banshee screams)

@MagicBus-ct7fe

4 ай бұрын

" we hate good life " Leftists comrades

@CChrist-mh4mk

4 ай бұрын

@@MagicBus-ct7fewhat you just posted makes no sense. LOL

@MagicBus-ct7fe

4 ай бұрын

@@CChrist-mh4mk no it does if you understand it in details. We have a saying and if you listen to conservatives channels you have probably heard this " live in the pods and eat the bugs " . We say this as a mockery of the left. Leftists care about cheap life rather than a good life.

@ImperialKnight86

3 ай бұрын

That is true. Very definition of conservatism

This isn't anything new. This was the way neighborhoods were back when I was young. Born in '51, my grade school and high school was in walking distance, clothing stores, grocery stores, drug stores, bakeries, manufacturers, library, churches of every denomination, taverns with food, cafes, restaurants, 5 public grade schools and 3 parochial schools, hardware store, barber shops, beauty shops, key shop, shoe repair, confectionaries, parks, ice cream parlors, movie theaters, gas stations, auto repair shops, dry cleaners, jewelry stores, pool hall, bowling alley, playgrounds, butcher shops, shoe stores, Doctors, Lawyers, Dentists, Police Station and I'm sure other small businesses providing a service, a lot in two story buildings where the family lived upstairs and the business was downstairs. These were all in walking distance. What ended them was the big businesses relocated to the county and then with more transportation came the shopping malls and eventually the small businesses went out of business because they couldn't compete and most people stopped patronizing these stores. But this concept is nothing new.

Yeah no this is dumb. It is a loss of freedom and it is not for everyone. I own land. My family owns land. It takes me 1.5 hours to walk from my backdoor to the end of our families property line. And thats me walking like i walk on patrol in the army. Im not moving slow. It takes me 8 hours to walk the entire property line. So why would i want to move to a 15 minute city? Like that to me is a serious loss of freedom.

@mediterraneanworld

Ай бұрын

Who told you that you have to move you boob?

@zivkovicable

Ай бұрын

So do you think the whole population of the planet can live with so much personal space? Anyway why does city planning concern you in the first place?

@brandondunnegan3890

Ай бұрын

@zivkovicable yes actually. There is enough land on this planet to where each 4 person family could get about 20 acres of land apiece. Now that includes all land including the desert and polar regions and mountains. So alot of people would die but still that would make even more land for everyone and that is only for everyone to have 4 person families. If you added bigger families to the mix that would give everyone even more land

@zivkovicable

Ай бұрын

@@brandondunnegan3890 So no room for agriculture..We all die..

@brandondunnegan3890

Ай бұрын

@zivkovicable no room for agriculture? 20 acres is plenty of room for agriculture. You can grow crops plus there's room for animals. Especially pigs or chickens. Also if everyone lives in 10 people homes that gives every home 50 acres of land.

The rich have invested hundreds of millions of Pounds / Dollars / Euros in brick and mortar in prime central locations. Their investments depend on the masses commuting to these areas to work and consume. The 15 minute-cities are a threat to their investments hence their opposition to it.

@elliotwilliams7421

Ай бұрын

no, 15 minute cities suit the rich the most. they can pay to avoid all the problems forced onto the rest of us. No more searching for customers, government has moved them onto your doorstep and in time segregation will occur meaning corporation's have less costs on wasted goods. they will have a set number of customers so they can plan better. if i was to design a city for corporations i would design a 15 min city which sacrifices the masses time and friendships to preserve profit

@brad5426

14 күн бұрын

​@@elliotwilliams7421what difference does it make in the end? You're still owned by a corpo. One is 15 minutes away the other could be an hour of travel away. Do you love being reliant on fuel sourced to you by the big oil tycoons?

@elliotwilliams7421

14 күн бұрын

@brad5426 itm not reliant, it just gives more opportunities in all walks of life. That's the difference. I can get up and go pretty much anywhere at anytime. In 15 min land that is not an option Will you enjoy being reliant on public transport and shops which are delivered to by vehicles using oil supplied by oil tycoons?

@elliotwilliams7421

14 күн бұрын

@brad5426 lose your job or want to quit? In 15 min land your work options will be limited unless willing to sacrifice time and money by travelling, difference is you are on someone else timetable and limited to what you can carry

@brad5426

14 күн бұрын

@@elliotwilliams7421 The point of 15 minute cities is individual self-reliance. If you lose your job apply for another. And if you can't do that in your area so be it. After all, it isn't like you already have travel hours at a time for work now. The point is that the 15 minute convenience will be there as opposed to never being in place to begin with, for people. And if we can cut travel time down and reliance on vehicles, why would we oppose it? My conclusion of your opposition is if you don't want the concept of 15 minute cities then you ultimately want to use a car that drives you everywhere around a country dependant on foreign oil interventions. Albeit you can use it at any given time, however its abundantly clear you can't _live_ without the car. We also have two legs God gave us that we can and should rightfully be allowed to use to get to services in a feasible space. And they can also be used at any given time, if the service infrastructure is in place. And the thing is you don't need to use transport within that 15 minute radius. Yes this lifestyle is ZERO dependency. I understand some things will still need to be travelled to via car or public transport, but less is ultimately the better.

what if i walk 20 minutes?

Its not that having things be close is bad. Its that being MANDATED to do or not do something or be or not be somewhere is inherently EVIL.

This is a pure strawman. We can have walkable cities. The thing is just - is public transport the solution? It would be good if America has more of those cities, but they also better be looking good. Savannah GA and Charleston SC would be wonderful locations for such.

How dare they take away my 90min morning commute

This is a prison.

The essence of socialism is where everyone is happy and prosperous. Anyone see how that turned out?

1:25 that’s Perú right there 😮 Javier Prado Avenue a long long time ago

All positive comments? Seriously?!

@RofiqueBegum

4 ай бұрын

It's a leftist propaganda site, what else would you expect?

@nishiljaiswal2216

4 ай бұрын

What is your argument against it?

@AnkaMara7940

4 ай бұрын

In my oppinion they are going to lock us down inside these 15 minutes cities, governments are not doing for our best otherwise there would not be wars, homlessness, imposing strange vaccinations, starvation etc there is enough of money and food in the world but someone doesn t want all people have it so they can control us all, so yes, I am sure they want to take our freedom away wrapping it in a fine paper, it is like cooking the frog slowly so it doesn t realize until it is late...

@turtleman9295

2 ай бұрын

@@AnkaMara7940The government can already lock us down in car-centric cities, being walkable isn’t going to make a difference to how much the government can control us. Also Grandma, learn how to type before you start posting takes on the internet, I could barely understand the slop you just commented earlier.

@AnkaMara7940

2 ай бұрын

​@@turtleman9295it is your problem if you are illiterate, I am not a native speaker of English so I am not supposed to be fluent at it, if you are one you should understand what is written, btw you English speaking people should have patience for other-languages-speaking-people since you imposed your language upon the rest of the world to be omni-spoken language...and also you calling me a grandma, without even knowing me, doesn't say anything about me but a lot about you and those who brought you up to be this way

I THINK YOUVE ALL PERSONALLY OVERLOOKED THE SUGGESTION OF MANDATING SOMEONE STAYS IN ONE AREA... THIS IS ABOUT CONTROL

@thebrunetteinroom7

Ай бұрын

Oh shut up. “COnTRoL” 🙄 “PriSOnS” bla bla bla. Yawn

I don’t drive, but I’ve lived in Madrid, Spain, Juneau AK, NorCal, and SoCal, as well as traveling to places like Rome and Florence. I must be in a walkable space, either a city center or a small town. Nowadays, I live in downtown San Diego, extremely walkable. Commuting is a waste of time. My bf now lives ten minutes from work; he said he should have thought of that years earlier instead of living in the land of the dead aka suburbs and all the $ that that costs.

@f.demascio1857

4 ай бұрын

I lived in San Diego for 13 years. By the time I left, I was questioning why I needed a car. My only reasons were to get to other surf spots with my friends and snowboarding. And Vegas. But barely. There were times when I would be driving out of OB, and realize I hadn't "left town" in weeks.

@piperhurtado4945

4 ай бұрын

@@f.demascio1857 that’s because we’re so spoiled for choice down here! The beaches, the restaurants, places like Balboa park, etc and the ability to remain active all the time due to sunny weather. You had to have saved so much money on gas too when you lived here. Walkable cities are wonderful.

If ur not seeing EVIL Empire, ur not thinking it through

If Joe Rogan and Jordan Peterson are against something, it must be really good. I support the 15 minute city concept.

How is it a limit of freedom? There’s nothing stopping you from going from one place to another, this is just eliminating the need to drive or have a car to get to places needed by communities, like grocery stores and doctors’ offices. Honestly that sounds great. Cars are expensive, and being able to walk anywhere you need to would be A) good exercise, and B) less expensive than owning a car, which can cost thousands of dollars over a period of years

This idea won't really do much except increase convenience for people. People will still ride their cars and motorcycles to their destination. How do I know? Because in Mexico we have towns (Or cities in some cases) that have everything you possibly need within a few minutes of reach and guess what? People still drive ICE vehicles, just because it works for some countries doesn't mean it will work for all.

I already live in one of these. Lol. Everything is 15 minutes or less from me.

@Blu3Purple

2 ай бұрын

You’re so special, you feel protected by the government. Aww

@scruf153

21 күн бұрын

@@Blu3Purple everything in my small city in Alabama is within a 10 mile radius I do not own a car I cycle and walk everwhere

Let's Get save today or we will wind up eating buged 🐛 🐛 Oatmeals .NOT MEALS ON WHEELS!

I love this idea. I wish I could have this where I live, but we have to drive everywhere.

No thanks! I love my rural area. Don’t want crime and certain people around me. Bears and wolves don’t kill you for 5 dollars.

duck 15 minute cities. no privacy. no yard for your own garden and for dogs to run around. i love my urban homestead

@baneofbanes

3 ай бұрын

Urban homestead is an oxymoron.

@queefgod420

20 күн бұрын

are you currently being forced to live in seattle? no? awesome, you still wont be forced to live in seattle. people need to take their antipsychotics jeez

They plan tonlimit yourbright to leave their will be a fee to leave with your car above a certain credit

I prefer live in rural area and even I still think there’s needs to be more cities like this

This pretty good idea and a work in progress 😊

How dumb is that argument, so what is stopping the government from doing that now, people try to be so smart and become dumb,

@Blu3Purple

2 ай бұрын

Your ignorance is laughable 😂

@weekscarr009

2 ай бұрын

@@Blu3Purple ok trumper

I only like where I live because it’s central to every city I don’t want to know people in my own town What about disabled or people with mental health issues If I was stuck in 15 minutes I’d be dangerous

Only conservatives would interpret something that's supposed to help people as a threat to their way of life.

@RiversRun597

3 ай бұрын

literally everything is a communist plot to them

@bobbobbington3615

3 ай бұрын

They've literally admitted they'll monitor you and require permits.

@dangerzone1106

3 ай бұрын

They monitor you, require permits, and the government will still be traveling wherever they want while you will be confined like a rat in a lab.

@turtleman9295

2 ай бұрын

@@dangerzone1106The government can already monitor you, and they already use permits, they’re called drivers licenses.

@scruf153

21 күн бұрын

conservative living in Alabam I do not own a car I cycle and walk everywhere everything is within a 10 mile radius

This doesn't actually sound all that appealing

The comments section seems to have missed something, or they didn't watch the whole video. Those against this type of urban planning seem to have the impression that residents would be locked into their respective areas without the freedom to travel elsewhere. I don't know if this is the case here, but that's what they're opposed to. And if that were the case, I imagine most people would be against it as that would represent a restriction of their freedom of movement.

@scruf153

21 күн бұрын

I live in a small city in Alabama everything is within a 10 mile radius Walmart is 2.5 miles from home WinDixie 1 mile lake martin 8 miles why own a car just to go singe digit miles

See examples in China with QR control to get in or out

@beth8775

4 ай бұрын

Then oppose authoritarians. Plenty of places enjoy both freedom and easy access to places they need to go.

Klaus swab and small haters are about to establish new world order

NO to 15 min cities!

@brad5426

14 күн бұрын

Why?

@elliotwilliams7421

14 күн бұрын

They are a bad idea

@Freedomforall9499

13 күн бұрын

@@brad5426 agenda 2030 and the WEF

@Freedomforall9499

13 күн бұрын

@@brad5426 agenda 2030 and the WEF (World Economic Forum)

@Freedomforall9499

13 күн бұрын

@@elliotwilliams7421 exactly!

americans bro i swear to God 😂

I want my 15 minute city!

This explains a lot. Immediately after the Lahaina wildfire, local news videos on KZread were flooded with "WEF" and "15 min city" weirdos.

@scruf153

21 күн бұрын

everything in my small city in Alabama is within a 10 mile radius including the biggest lake in the state

say the truth its jail. but outside. you knoq how the government is. "its to make it easier for people." but they always take that extra step.

Being taught to Fear anything new is standard operating procedure for right wing media. Fear and hate are simple and emotional not difficulty complex and logical.

@holzmann-

4 ай бұрын

While "progressives" fear the climate progressing.

@eggbirdtherooster

3 ай бұрын

⁠Ofcourse there is the “far right” card again.. the labeling and framing these days 😒 good luck with your Marxist communist 15 minute utopia.

asia already have this lol, should implement a subway city like tokyo

What do they want…things so spread out, you have to have a ton of cash to get to these places? Or die trying? They should stay in the countryside.