过了N年来看回这个视频，惊讶的是有好多负评，说什么只会尖叫啊用力过猛啊没灵魂啊有的没的。。。我想批评者是忘了这是个现场表演，不是录音室，这种欧美化的表演能如此被一个华人歌手完美演绎是多么难得的事，我在现场的话绝对会被震慑，第一名当之无愧。

@elagua77

6 жыл бұрын

2018 年still amazed at her performance what a gem,shining at the stage, nothing compares to you

@jellykappa

6 жыл бұрын

那些酸民很雞蛋裏挑骨頭阿😂什麼尖叫大喊是歌曲的表達方式阿說的好像很簡單似的不見得它們能喊?難道大家都要唱它們那些簡單口水歌就是好歌手?笑死人

@user-vd5vd4le6w

5 жыл бұрын

对

@christy0176

5 жыл бұрын

知道為什麼嗎? 這叫看不得人好, 特別是那些同年齡層又一事無成的

@yupin1867

4 жыл бұрын

表演結束後，張杰說很少有20初頭的女生可以完美控制這樣的歌，那次的我歌評分的人還有之前被淘汰的歌手一起，gem拿下第一名，就可以知道現場聽起來絕對驚艷的不行

看了昨晚的我是歌手, 來回味一下十年前就已經登峰造極的真正歌手.... 紫棋快來救場啊啊啊啊啊啊啊啊啊啊啊!!!!

@ncp2827

Ай бұрын

她已經拿過我是歌手的亞軍了，沒有必要再回來。而且她在開巡演，根本來不了

隔了差不多10年又再來聽，竟然和當初聽時的感覺一樣：驚艷，厲害，絕對是一絕，無人能及，她的天賦，她的能力，她的才華真是當今少見，且她不断進步，不斷創新，不斷突破，真是世上難得少見的猛人，鑽石巨星！她值得更多人關注和愛戴！❤

跟本我是歌手，你是第一名，第一這位老伯只懂唱山東，湖南， 外省鄉下歌，好像賣藝請D唔同樂器人上來，但跟本不是他彈，跟GEM比唱功，音樂藝能力差很遠，GEM天生就是天才，13歲已作到高水平歌，能唱，能作，能彈，能rap，全能歌手，所以紅全球有原因， 香港人之光！

我剛剛聽完2024我是歌手兩位歐美歌手的表演，所以想起Gem,過嚟聽翻她十年前這神級現場表演

臨場發揮歌藝淋漓極致 過程流暢一氣呵成專業自信 台風自成一派感動人心舞台上皇者

因只得不足兩天要重新準備這一首歌，更要第一個唱，一開始的表情是最沒自信，但有如即興的演繹，反而唱出了亞州歌手少有的投入，結果感動了全場觀眾。

有實力會唱歌的人才極多 歌壇競爭激烈 分析鄧紫棋能在短時間 如日中天吸引廣大人氣的原因是具備以下條件 有漂亮可愛外型 人見人愛的笑容 有很好的音質 有多數人接受的音色 有寬廣的音域 有獨特的發聲 音場共鳴好 聲音辨識度極高 能用不同聲調唱不同歌路 唱功一流 體型與音量形成極大反差讓人驚奇驚豔 越多反差就會有越多驚奇 能融入音樂中所以能感染聽眾 有樂器才藝有創作才華曲曲動聽 在舞台上有讓人感覺好心情的能量 綜合以上條件與自信所以在舞台上魅力四射無人能敵

@user-og5tv8mq2u

7 жыл бұрын

我覺得你的分析才是厲害的@@

@user-mc5ct4so7p

7 жыл бұрын

我是老樂迷只迷音樂 很喜歡一個歌手鄧是第一個 能吸引長輩的歌手很少這也是鄧的優點 多數人對於喜不喜歡大都說不出理由 你認為我分析厲害也表示你的思考能力很強

@user-og5tv8mq2u

7 жыл бұрын

黃廷光 我只有很簡單的喜歡她的整個人和歌聲…還有給我的感覺。覺得她很棒

@lineya-jk1ey

6 жыл бұрын

豬豬兒 而且又會自己作詞作曲

看完歌手2024過來的

GEM 天才22歲好似老牌歌手，而 音韻能力用恐怖來 形容！神級香港之寶！

2020年还有人会来听吗？百听不厌有没有！！真的太tm上头了

@user-ke1th3iy1c

3 жыл бұрын

我我我~

@mansangyiu2854

2 жыл бұрын

2021還在聽，太好聽了

@thankyou888

3 ай бұрын

2024❤

簡直是人琴合一，天才歌手全能音樂人，厲害，什麽歌都能發揮超強唱功。

华人歌手能唱成如此高水准已经是非常难得，32个赞👍👍👍 都是Alicia Keys的歌，另一个歌手就差强人意，真是没比过都不知道阿GEM的厉害😍

刻意的攻擊留言是有目的,可以不理. 如果你覺得不好聽~自然會退走~找別的自己喜歡的歌. 她唱得好不好~ 最少在現場觀眾已投出了手中的一票. 這樣都不好聽的話~~無言~各有所愛吧. 個人覺得香港出了一位未來創作/舞台巨星. 23歲的她,可能性還有更多.

@yuedu618

10 жыл бұрын

确实她还很年轻，路还很长。但别把话说太早，什么巨星不巨星的。单纯论演唱，容祖儿的唱功超GEM几个班～～我听过ｊｏｅｙ的演唱会，唱功非常棒，声音控制能力很强，岂是刚出道３，４年的ＧＥＭ可比。要说天后，香港乐坛的一姐也是香港的大牙肉。再说到这个节目，ＧＥＭ的选歌都很小心，没有敢挑战特别经典中文歌曲，这也掩盖了她的缺点。而几个大牌，包括上期的黄绮珊和这期的唯韦都有挑战邓丽君的歌，而韩磊也成功演绎花房姑娘，ＧＥＭ呢？我听过ＧＥＭ早年的一些Ｌｉｖｅ，唱得真是不敢恭维。。不过她比以前进步很多，这倒是事实。还是让时间来证明一切吧～～

@sdsho884

10 жыл бұрын

yuedu618 GEM的早期~~的歌~~~呵呵 ~ 小朋友時期嗎???你可能有病. 今天她~22~23歲~ 創作了多少歌曲~ 容不下天后22-23歲時~ 是什麼情況. 十場競演~ 場場不同~ 在沒觀眾不認識同支持下~ 由第一場到第十場~ 入總決賽. 叫容大姐上去我是歌手玩玩~不要說名次~ 捱到6場~3節先說吧~ 別人已証明可在中國受到觀眾喜愛~ 容不下天后做到先說吧. 還有~容小姐是才女嗎??? 怎同GEM比較~不懂創作,級數不同了吧. 想看更好的質素同音效~LETV看吧~

@manli9039

8 жыл бұрын

+sds ho 👍👍👍

@acetang8623

8 жыл бұрын

+sds ho +1 👍👍👍👏👏👏

@acetang8623

8 жыл бұрын

+yuedu618 真心希望如你所言，讓容天后上我是歌手第4季，-顯十年歌后的風采！今年巨基第六場出局了，如果她唱出更好成績，則香港人幸甚啊！

極具霸氣的演出，整季內她最高難度一首，同時處理vocal(坐着的)和piano, 揮灑自如的巨肺唱功，且要和伴奏樂配合，無懈可擊！

确实有着東方人的外貌，西方人的声音，中西结合的感覺

感染力極強！聴到我雞皮疙瘩！嘩，她現場唱得不比原唱者差啊；我是香港人，我為妳感到自豪！

小小身體里到底有多大的能量，氣場如此強大！

吉杰在當年快男也唱過Falling，所以看GEM能用這腔口彈唱此曲，當場目定口呆起來。

@acetang8623

8 жыл бұрын

+Elegant TSE 多謝你提醒，我也聽了吉杰的版本，也算不錯；但吉杰聽到 GEM 的現場版本，也知不是一個檔次！同樣，吉杰聽到張杰唱無情的情書（第七集）的時候也是這個表情！

声如其人，很直接的一位天才歌后！厉害！

超強的唱功

發揮得淋漓盡致,完全沒有怯場舞台皇者!

邓紫棋超牛逼这句话我说得好累。。但是！还是要说！！！ 邓紫棋好牛逼！！！！！！！

听她唱了那么多首的英文歌，这首唱的是最动听的。。。😍😍

@mole7590

4 жыл бұрын

所以第一名

唉，都是因為gem,我才看這節目，沒有你，沒意思了。

@kimfokyap4663

5 жыл бұрын

+1

@kaichi4647

4 жыл бұрын

+1

哇塞太会唱了亞洲女歌手恐怕是無人能比。

後段的一氣呵成令人吃驚!

Holy crap that voice control is superb, god level. I saw some comments comparing her with shila and others but man you can't deny GEM has the best control. Even famous singers can't control it so well. Simply amazing.

@suziesaranghae1928

6 жыл бұрын

#AGREEEEEEEE !!!!!!

@ericlin9646

5 жыл бұрын

Simply agree fully

@royrepie61

2 жыл бұрын

Yesss she is.... has amazing voice in her is a special gift from the Lord 🙂👍

看了10期，她的唱功好好，多类形的歌都唱得好好

She is falling. She is shouting from her soul cause she get hurt. Don't you try to understand what she want to sing instead of comparing. She is not shouting at all. Sometimes she hits the high notes with a sharp voice sometimes she sings gently with a soft voice. This makes the audience cannot breathe and feel it was breathtaking. This truly present what "love" is. If you still focusing on the high notes at the beginning then of course you cannot get any message from this song.

@acetang8623

8 жыл бұрын

+100 👍👍👍👏👏👏

好好聽 每聽都必起雞皮疙瘩！ ⬇️2020年還在聽的點個讚👍🏻

OK, I'm just pissed off here. All those haters that complain that she is yelling/screaming, first of all, it's called BELTING. And screaming with technique isn't bad too for your information. Screaming is a vocal technique, a style. For example Jay Hawkins, James Brown all sing with this style. So please, haters, don't put a negative connotation with screaming. It only shows the lack of knowledge you have with different types of music. As a Canadian Chinese, I think she did fantastic. What she sang was different, but in a good way. Honestly, after 我要我们在一起 this is my second favourite rendition because she sang her heart out. Those who complained about her performance, this is an American song so duh, of course it's gonna be different. Arghhh... Your lack of knowledge literally pisses me off SO much. It's like 2 in the morning, and I'm suppose to sleep but seeing people like this-I can't. I hope this somehow changes your view.

@jasperoesa

6 жыл бұрын

Betty Bear LOL

@suziesaranghae1928

6 жыл бұрын

LOL!!! Agree #Betty Bear ..... excuse the haterz....they are still learning how to listing to English Verse of G.E.M singing..... she rock for a beautiful china lady... #WeHeartHer .... islander loved it! stay humble G.E.M....

@helenhe350

6 жыл бұрын

So true the knowledge of the haterz are just so l..

@bigbangchui1686

6 жыл бұрын

Haters gonna hate

@blodbotina

5 жыл бұрын

looks like you're ....... faaaaaaaaaaaaaaalin' ... out with the YT community. the ignorance, the trolling, nothing ever changes.. i joined in 2005 and in fact it's only gotten worse

無懈可擊，唱功超卓！

邓紫棋好有魅力

呢首歌我覺得係GEM 喺呢個比賽裏面演繹得最好嘅一首,沒有之一

说真的，感觉这期节目一半的舞台是她的👍

@user-hc5mn3in9n

6 ай бұрын

佢就係為舞台而生😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉

紫棋，係我心目中永遠都係第一名個啦😘😘😘👍👍👍👍👍👏👏👏👏👏

才22歲就如斯逆天實力

根本就是天后级

For my opinion, GEM not showing off to the audience... because this song is Europe country's culture...GEM is good to have the attitude and feeling in sing this europe song.. i support GEM... XD

霸气十足的表演！A flawless performance!

雞皮疙瘩！疙瘩雞皮！好聽到灵魂都飛出去。

超好聽 自彈自唱

She is so dynamic and creative.

就是喜歡個子小大的很有力量，有點霸氣，有點跩但又可愛

高衝雲霄、氣若游絲～厲害～～～

我自從看了我是歌手才認識Gem真驚歎香港竟然有一位這麽了不起的歌手，但卻不能在香港樂壇紅起來反而在更大的大陸樂壇發光發亮真是替她高興，正所謂此地不留人自有留人處。大陸音樂市場的潛力不知大多少倍，這就是塞翁失馬焉知非福。 Gem的現場表演真是超精彩無論唱功及功架十足，以過去20多年內香港歌手簡直無出其右，中英文歌曲皆唱得無懈可擊。以她的年紀若非天賦加上其後天努力很難有如此好的現場表現，她每場的表演亳不怯場而且非常懂得帶起現場觀眾的情緒及共鳴，最厲害是每場拼盡全力毫不欺場實屬難得。

@totolihkg2979

Ай бұрын

你能不能別乱说 当年在香港已经在红馆开完个唱才去歌手的

2016年聽，感覺沒變啊！仍然那麼棒！😁

@vickychin6647

8 жыл бұрын

不會厭啊😊😊

不停重播13-26秒，太震懾人心

好厉害啊！鸡皮疙瘩都起来了

I just keep on falling in love with GEM, there’s never any falling out of love with you. Such a goddess, the most amazing voice of any singer ever to Grace this earth. Nobody compares to her, no one can come close to her vocals, she brings such emotion to her songs, truly amazing.

Good song ! She is just a 22 years old girl. Don't set her standards too high again and again. No one can sing perfectly, no mistake before becoming a superstar. She will improve herself in the future.

Ah, her voice is amazing. I would buy her album. She can sing anything.

Excellent performance, she deserved to be No.1 this week. Well done, GEM !!!

This is my fav song and i kept listening like 100 times. LOVE YOU SM GEM

她的斗志是那么的吸引人！

這麼可以這麼好聽！大愛

She is addictive, I enjoyed her singing and stage presence over and over again for a long time now.

2018有人嗎

@skyanita1976

6 жыл бұрын

有啊

@jellykappa

6 жыл бұрын

yes

@antonychang6368

5 жыл бұрын

+1

@010213345

5 жыл бұрын

2019都要来了😆

@user-eh5tc7zk5x

5 жыл бұрын

2019還生存

I loved this the first time i watched it and, after many years, this is still so good.🖤

Her performance always gave me a "WOW" impression! Excellent interpretation of Alicia Keys - Falling! 得冠军可说是实至名归.

So Good .... GEM is showing her power of singing .... not many singer can do this

@billshun3963

5 жыл бұрын

martin kwok you can say that again

instead of comparing we should just enjoy the talent of this girl

2018 is coming，anyone still listening? Hope I'm not alone~

@elagua77

6 жыл бұрын

Cullen Louis one more

@alailai8004

4 жыл бұрын

JAN 2020

Essa garota tem a voz mais limpa e bonita que já ouvi na vida!! Muito perfeita!

2017 依旧感动♥♥

It's amazing how she can manage to sing different types of songs.

这首歌本身的旋律一般，但是超级考验唱功！GEM做得很棒！

If you don't like the song, just don't listen to it. She was singing what she wanted to show to her audience, and she enjoyed doing it. That is her style. Don't expect everyone sings the same song in the same way or with the same style.

I must say that the new arrangement of the song is so good (considering this is a singing competition), stormy but works as well. G.E.M. is very talented and the audience have some good taste to rank her No.1 in this episode.

@shitlahamchat8934

10 жыл бұрын

no good at all!

@michelleyue370

2 жыл бұрын

its been 8 yrs omg time flies.

鄧紫棋好久不見了 你的185條以上的歌我都聽過了

The 'Falling' sung beautifully by GEM. I like it so much. When i hear this, she reminds me of Charice, a singer from Philipines. Both have a great vocal range. Please sing your voice to the world. Please educate the world with your voice. She is the true competitor for Shila. Shila needs to learn and study what GEM capable of, and poke on her weaknesses. Has to play the game smartly. Anyway, congrate GEM for a standing ovation performance! Love from, Malaysia.

2018回来怀念以前的紫琪

@Rac__1208

3 жыл бұрын

紫棋*

let me tell you something, guys. I heard shila and GEM and they're both very talented and both good singers. GEM can controll her voice very well and is also technique brilliant. Shila also sings amazing, but the difference is, GEM's voice is more powerful and Shila sing with soul and can touch hearts. It's a question of taste. I personally like music with soul, but that's just an opinion. So don't hate and just enjoy the great music.

@MrPizza063

9 жыл бұрын

gem is really amazing I love her vocal range and her songs.. and she can really tingle those ivory's huh

@user-ir4sv6dd5d

5 жыл бұрын

樓主中文翻譯: (伙计们，让我告诉你一件事。 我听到了希拉和创业板，他们都非常有才华，都是优秀的歌手。 创业板可以很好地控制自己的声音，技术也很出色。 Shila也唱得很神奇，但不同的是，GEM的声音更强大，Shila用灵魂唱歌，可以触动心灵。 这是一个品味问题。 我个人喜欢带有灵魂的音乐，但这只是一种观点。 所以不要讨厌，只是享受美妙的音乐。)以下google翻譯

永遠愛妳不変

邓紫棋，2018年我的偶像！！！

Oh my goodness how can she released this energy out in her tiny body! Awesome!!!

越来越有国际范儿了，这种才是能拿的出去的歌手！棒！

CANT STOP LISTENING!!! GEM is an amazing singer 😍

2018再看还是如此震撼和喜爱。整个演唱零缺点，唯一可指出的是那一句"先声夺人"，也不知道要说"潤土"哥多想出风头还是说电视台有多给他面子让他多上镜

2023，一首歌值一張門票 ❤❤❤😊

Excellent job... one of her best performance...

How stunning! Both her looking and performance.

我们缅甸都是妳的歌迷

7.1 又来听 👍👍👍👏👏👏

@user-dj8dc4kg7l

8 жыл бұрын

赞啦

@ling7524

7 жыл бұрын

每天都來聽

She can belt it out with emotions. SIMPLY pulled off the song AMAZING! ! !

Wow, Outstanding!!!! ⚘⚘⚘And so pretty too!!!!

such a powerful voice....good job GEM.

When I was 17 I love this song so much! Thank you, GEM, you bring this song to me and perform so great!

Gem is overall not just a great diva singer but overall a great performer!! It's quite incredible while watching her performance you can just capture her emotions. IMO all her songs are at her best and its been great to watch her sing her songs in Chinese and fluently in English. Like she had said over her Piano sessions(interview), if she wasn't introduced to the piano then she wouldn't had never started singing. she started really young and now so successful at her young age.

She's pretty and powerful voice 👍👍❤❤❤👍👍

She has got so much control. Good job!

She should make an english mini album.. PERFECT 💯✨👍

Better than the original!

@3dbatman126

7 жыл бұрын

+1

wow Technically speaking she is better than AK by miles 👍

GEM the best

Gorgeous! Excellent! Marvellous! 👍👍👍

I some body come to me and say I should give up my life for her I will do it . I am your die hard fan

u guys can not compare how she sings with how alicia keys sings through this performance. Gem is singing this with an anger mood ( well, its because his boyfd just left him without even officially informing Gem...her boyfd is also a singer from taiwan, also quite famous ). Anyway, i love how GEM interprets this song.

@list67

10 жыл бұрын

personnally I think she dumped her boyfriend for good 4 yrs ago and never dated since. She is only interested in her career and her rising fanbase. Did you honestly believe everything that they said about her?

@shirleethepooh

10 жыл бұрын

She may not have been singing in an angry mood. Remember last week they had that cake for Han Lei because it was his birthday. His birthday is in October and the news about Gem and Yoga's break up just came out recently. Maybe they have broken up a long time ago.

She is the best ever. Hong Kong represent, I don't care what you all say she won by miles. Bias all the way, come at me haters.