The gifts on their hands (painting, box, puppy, etc) are for people who are not with them anymore since they didn't value the time they spend together and now the EXO members regret that these people are not with them anymore, that's why they try to turn back time to see their loved ones again (mv only shows Sehun's girl) but the time needs to pass and in the end she isn't really there. (If you watch EXO's MV 'Sing For You' you will have a great surprise since the mv talks about the same thing but about friendship).

@milindawilson9175

4 жыл бұрын

If it only shows Sehun's girl then who is the girl that Tao turns back time for and is the one that is standing in front of him that we see her legs? I think the girl isn't a specific members girlfriend, but she is supposed to represent all of their girls. She is only a memory so you see her walk up to Tao when he turns back time and you see Sehun standing there when the girl disappears as time is sent back to the present because it's just a memory of the girl that is a manifestation of all of their relationships, and what they wish they could get back, even if it was only for a moment. :D

@almirarey2779

4 жыл бұрын

@@milindawilson9175 What she meant was, every EXO's member has their own girl. So Tao turn back time to make everyone saw their girl again. But the MV only showed Sehun's girl. Cause there is no way all of their girls show up in the MV. Its a matter of duration, etc.

"I swear Chen they turned up your voice so it could have more of an impact " Chen: yeah~~ I died 😂

@jigeumeunsonyeoshidae3414

4 жыл бұрын

Lmao

@Ray_Byun

3 жыл бұрын

fuck yes, I laughed so hard when he was complimenting chen the moment he paused it, and then when he olayed again, chen coincidentally sing "yeah~~" ahhahahaha

CHEN: a.... Ben: don't even start with me with that kind of energy I'm gonna die

@oyimangs2921

3 жыл бұрын

Ha3 story of every exol

the lyrics are basically explaining how they regret the way that they behaved during their time in a relationship with ___. they state how they were selfish and never appreciated the person or relationship the way they were supposed to. basically, a "you never know what you have until it's gone" song. and in the lyrics, they bring up how they wish they could go back in time and change how they acted. *lyrics:* I try to find you, who I can’t see I try to hear you, who I can’t hear Then I started to see things I couldn’t see Hear things I couldn’t hear Because after you left, I received a power I didn’t have before The selfish me, who always knew only myself, yeah The heartless me, who didn’t even know your heart Even I can’t believe that I changed like this Your love keeps moving me Just by thinking about it, I can fill the world up with you, mm~ Because each snowflake is each of your tear drops The one thing I can’t do is bring you to me I wish I didn’t have this useless power anymore... The selfish me, who always only knew myself The heartless me, who didn’t even know your heart Even I can’t believe that I changed like this Your love keeps moving me I stop time and go back to you I open your page in my book of memories, oh~ I am there inside I am with you A very small and weak person, your love Has changed (all of my life), everything (all of the world) Oh~ I didn’t know how thankful your love was, oh~ I thought it would stop once it ended, oh~ But every day, I’m fixing myself to want you I think my love will endlessly continue I stop time (Oh! now I will) And go back to you (go back to you) I open your page (Oh! Again today) In my book of memories, oh~ I am there inside, oh~ ... Inside that winter I try to find you, who I can’t see I try to hear you, who I can’t hear...

@shinnthant5248

4 жыл бұрын

Ben need to see this comment 💝

Please react to EXO Universe

@floramorgan6112

4 жыл бұрын

yesss ma favouriteee

@loveitftw

4 жыл бұрын

Yes holy fuck yes! we need!!!!!

@husnulkhotimah6942

4 жыл бұрын

Ofc yasss

@pkumsy

4 жыл бұрын

Also the b-side

@elenabunny9631

4 жыл бұрын

Yes please

Please react to exo's song " first snow " It is really suitable for this weather and called it this name in relation to the first snowfall of every winter season for every year and it was trading for 6 years in a row since its inception

@jejealhussaini5581

4 жыл бұрын

Asma Chouiter one of my favorite songs

@asmachouiter2689

4 жыл бұрын

@@jejealhussaini5581 same 😍💗

@diorjuneawne9290

4 жыл бұрын

blasted out first snow on speakers last December 1st and it was my second year doing that 🎄❤

I dont know if you noticed but Xiumin made it snow (his power is frost). thats why the medallion shined😊

@seosuhui

4 жыл бұрын

OMG ur right I just noticed OOHH AWESOME

“if its EXO, im probably gonna love it” me: YES, YES YOU WILL🙌

4:02 Ben: *pauses at Chanyeol* *Long silence* YOU ARE PRECIOUS TO ME!!

"I can't get over that puppy, that puppie's name is Kai" It sure got me smiling... Kai is a Bear, nini bear n he loves puppies...

If you watch the Mandarin version of "Miracles in December" you will see that Luhan takes over for D.O. Luhan was the second main vocalist in EXO-M. Chen and Luhan are both EXO-M members so they sang the Mandarin songs, and to round out the vocals Baekhyun subbed in as an EXO-M member. :D You should check out the Chinese version to hear how beautiful it also is in Mandarin. (In the Korean version you see D.O., Baekhyun and Chen as the singers because they are EXO's main vocalists and they are all native Korean -- even though Chen is a member of EXO-M. To round out the vocals SM decided they needed all three of them to create the right blend of their voices and harmonies. In the EXO-M version they put Luhan in the mix because, as the only native Chinese one of the trio, it would be pretty weird if they didn't use the main vocalist from the Mandarin sub-unit in that version of the song. Plus, Luhan is the only one of the three that speaks fluent Mandarin.) EXO's winter albums are their ballad albums, so all of their winter songs are really beautiful. You should check out all their winter songs. Up until last year, EXO released a winter album every year and that album was the complete opposite of their other album from that year. But last year and this year they didn't have a comeback until really late in the year, so I guess SM decided a second album in the winter would be too close together. Which makes me sad because I really look forward to their winter albums because its a totally different side to EXO then what we get in most of their other songs. If you noticed in this MV, Xiumin was the one that made it snow. Xiumin has the power to control ice/frost/snow, so any time something has to do with these weather elements they will focus on him. In the MV you see Xiumin in the red sweater and the black vest with the lapel pin that is shaped like EXO's logo, step outside and look up at the sky and at that moment it begins to snow. It is thought that the members' powers are tied to their emotions so when Xiumin is sad or melancholy, he almost can't help it and he will make it snow. And as you also saw, Tao is the one that turned back time and then instantly brought time back to the present again, because he has the power to control time. The snow was falling in reverse at one point because Tao was rewinding time. Then you see everything pause for a second and the snow starts falling down again when he brings everything back to the present. You also saw during this MV that there was an eclipse. Eclipses effect the members powers and it is also where they gather strength, etc. This even happens in live performances. You will see instances of them using their powers to even control things that happen on stage during live concert performances. Suho makes it rain on stage, Xiumin will make it snow, Chanyeol will control fire, Chen will control the thunder and lightning, Baekhyun often makes the lights go on and off, etc. If you keep this all in mind when you watch any of their MVs or live performances, its kind of fun to search for the instances where they are using their powers. In some MVs and songs the members use their powers more than others, but at least one member will use their powers in almost everything they do, it just might be more subtle some times than others. So its just another element of EXO's performances that make watching them unique. "Miracles in December" is a kind of breakup song that is about how the holidays makes you nostalgic for that loved one that you are no longer with. It makes you remember all the good times and makes you wish you were together even though you know, deep down, you are better off now that you have broken up. All the gifts are supposed to be what they would have given to their girlfriends if they hadn't broken up before the holidays. "She" was a different girl for each of the members, and "she" was not meeting any of them, she was a memory of a past relationship that was no more. That's why Tao turns back time for a moment to relive being in the relationship, but then quickly returns to the present because he knows deep down he is better off and that you really can't go back in time and expect to fix everything in the relationship. That's why they are all sad and crying because they are heartbroken. I like to think, for example, that the puppy was probably going to be a present for Kai's girlfriend, but now that they have broken up, it just reminds him of her. its kind of a bitter sweet memory. :D If you look up the lyrics you will see what I mean. It is also often thought that the "girl" that EXO sings about and/or the one you see in their MVs is a manifestation of the heart of the Tree of Life. That is why the members are always trying to protect the girl or are talking about being in love with the girl but knowing that they are bad news for her, etc. Everything EXO does ties into their storyline, so when you think of the girl as part of EXO's origin story you might be able to see parallels to their mission and an even deeper hidden message in their songs and MVs.

*"there will never be a day when I listen to a Bae note and I don't get tingles down my spine. This man and the power that he has over me."* Same, Ben

So basically the song is about a relationship that ended and how they are realizing they didnt realize what they had when they had it. They thought it was all good but it wasnt for her kinda thing. It compares the snowflakes to her tears and lyrically its absolutely beautiful. Oh and the other version is the Chinese version because at the time this was released they were still actively promoting as EXO-M/EXO-K

ok but when he asked "what's on the canvas?" the only thing i could picture is that crocodile drawing Kris did on that chinese show i'm- 🤣🤣🤣

@exois9223

3 жыл бұрын

I literally choked when he ask what's on the canvas 😂 we all can imagine what in it 😂

The basic jist of the lyrics is they’re missing someone who isn’t with them anymore and remembering their time together. They regret being selfish and not appreciating that person’s love, so they’ve been working hard to become better. 😭 Probably the saddest Christmas song in existence, but I love it so much.

"Look, two puppies!!" 😄 Yup Kai is really so cute, tho tbh we as a fandom (and EXO themselves) have agreed he's a teddy bear, cuz he's big and cuddly. But puppy works too😊

BCD- the holy trinity of exo... Blessing our ears n brains with their blended voices...

just so u know, when Tao turn back time, the snow also is going up and not down anymore. Also! When xiumin touch the 'badge' , it's his power of frost so that's when the snow falls :) EXO and their superpowers are just so fucking cool. The best concept ever

THIS SONG IS STILL ICONIC, THE 0T12 FEELS OMG😭

VOCAL POWERHOUSE, EXO

This song is my go-to for EVERY. CHRISTMAS. Its THAT good 😔✊🏻💗

2019 without exo's winter album is really sad. OT12 😭

The song (lyrics) has a deeper meaning that can't be explain really but in the MV, you see the boys were supposed to meet someone (in the MV it's the girl) so they were shown getting ready and when Tao stopped and turn backed the time, everything else aside from them were rewinding, that explains how the female was back infront of Sehun, meaning she came back but then she disappeared, it was just them hoping for someone or something to come back.

Being EXO-L from 2012 I always cry when I hear this song and watch this MV. It's a beautiful song and it hurts.( Thank you for the reaction!

there are 2 versions, korean and Chinese. In the Chinese mv, D.O is replaced by former member Luhan

"The puppy's name is Kai" HAHA DEEEAAADDDD. My thoughs exactly!

If he liked this he needs to see exo-what is love

@zahrasadeghi5668

4 жыл бұрын

Yes yes what is love is one of the very first songs... I still love it as much as 7year ago.. 😭😭😍

My favourite winter song ever 💕

Exo are Kings of not for kidding ... exols love you boy 🌚💕I like you

THIS SONG IS THE REASON CHEN IS MY BIAS HIS VOICE KILLS ME 🥺✨🤩

I love EXO and also I love you Ben💕

"I try to find you,who I can't see I try to hear you,Who I can't hear.."😭😭😭

Finalllllllllly I was waiiiiiting for EXO reaction 😍😍

song talks about a man who recalls with nostalgia the relationship with his former girlfriend and his desire to return to it, but cannot do so because of the shame and guilt.

You aren't gonna read this since this is late. But that piano was a one of a kind custom made for baekhyun.

One of my all time favorite songs...the vocals, the emotions, I just can’t...

EXO have 4 winter mini albums, and their 4th one called Universe is one of the best kpop albums out there you should defo check it out! Also where’s the Red Velvet psycho reaction??

His Reaction when he say u r precious to me ! to me ! 😂

EXO = Quality Truly the King of Kpop. Certified!!!

Ohhh ben ive been waiting for this omg 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍

YAAAAAS! I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS! THANK YOU BEN!

I was so shook when I realized that the reason the girl was walking forward was because time was reversed.

Omg my baby shared a video! AND THIS REACTION IS TO MIRACLES IN DECEMBER OH GOD, thank you so much. I love you babe

You have a looooooot of exo winter songs to react to

First Snow by Exo is also one of their christmas. This song is amazing everytime the first snow in korea drops, this song rises again in the charts! Same as Miracle in December!!

watches as Ben starts melting as Chen starts singing 2:44

Finally yaaaaaay.

This one of my favorite song from Exo, its kinda like bring back memories . This song have 2 vers, korea and mandarin. And some exo-l make eng vers from this song and make a cover , you can check it out. Thankyou so much for react this, its really good song that you want to share to everyone🙏

this song is one of my favorites to break me, really is so beautiful and their voices omg every time i heard this song i cry so hard

Thanks for reaction to this song🙏that is so emotional,I love it so much💕

Hey Ben, I know it's kind of not as helpful of me as it would be if I just explained what I know, but I think you should watch one of those versions on KZread where they have the song with both Korean and English lyrics together, so you can understand it a little more... And as for the part with Sehun, I think it shows two possible endings that could have happened in his story; I guess the lesson is that time is precious, and we should try our best to spend it in meaningful ways with the people we love

Miracles in December is literally EXO asking if they can have some 'miracles in December' so that they would be able to see someone who was so dear to them that they can no longer see. It's like seeking every (im)possible way to have another chance to see someone you've wasted your time under appreciating their presence because now that they're gone, you realized what they really mean to you.

Thankuuu so much for reacting to this ,it's one of their bests 💕💕 and my favorite

For some reason, EXOs Christmas songs are heartbreaking. This one, Universe and Unfair are examples. Anyway, here's the English translation for MIRACLES IN DECEMBER... I try to find you Who I can't see I try to hear you Who I can't hear Then I started to see things I couldn't see Hear things I couldn't hear Because after you left I received a power I didn't have before The selfish me, who always knew only myself The heartless me, who didn't even know your heart Even I can't believe that I changed like this Your love keeps moving me Just by thinking about it I can fill the world up with you Because each snowflake Is your each tear drop The one thing I can't do Is bring you to me I wish I didn't have This useless power anymore The selfish me, who always only knew myself The heartless me, who didn't even know your heart Even I can't believe that I changed like this Your love keeps moving me I stop time and go back to you I open your page in my book of memories I am there inside, I am with you I am with you A very small and weak person, your love Has changed (all of my life) Everything (all of the world) I didn't know how thankful your love was I thought it would stop once it ended But every day I'm fixing myself to want you I think my love will endlessly continue I stop time (oh now I will) And go back to you (go back to you) I open your page (again today) In my book of memories I am there inside Inside that winter I try to find you Who I can't see I try to hear you Who I can't hear

Your reactions are so cute! I'm watching all your EXO's reaction videos. 😍

this is such a good song!!

Psycho please🙏🙏🙏

@electro262world.4

4 жыл бұрын

winter garnet +++++

Very few reactors do this song. I'm so... ♥

I WAITED FOREVER FOR THIS REACTIONNN 😭😭 Thank youuuu AND JUST IMAGINE THAT LIVE PERFORMANCE IS 100% BETTERRRR 😩❤

HeRe mE ouT : What is love by EXO 😉😉😉

Man i really like your reactions for exo, you didn't missed any point Love your reactiona, from Jordan ❤️

This song make me cry :")

no one : ben : (pauses the mv, looking at chanyeol in total silence) *"YOU ARE PRECIOUS TO ME! TO ME!"* I still got chills whenever watching this mv, reaction or not

Could you react to Jonghyun’s Before Our Spring? I don’t know how other Shawols feel, but I just think it would be a great way to remember Jonghyun’s legacy. It is a beautiful song and one of my most favorite kpop songs of all time.

YASSS IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS SONG TO BE REACTED TO!!! I LOVE THIS SONG!!!!

Thank u ben❤

I was actually waiting for this... Since u were reacting to all those k pop Xmas MVs I knew you would react to this tooo

Finally reacting to this 💜

I recommend you to watch the concert version, Ben! Their voices filled up the stage gorgeously!!

I remember hearing this for the first time, I cried SO much :'D

when ben paused it with kai and the puppy, he literally said: "look two puppies! they're so cute". im like: yES THATS OUR NINI KAI

the three boys sang a live version of this last year at the end of year shows it was incredible and def worth checking out

Thanks for your reaction ❤❤❤ This song is fantastic and always be in people play list in winter forever 🤧 EXO IS KING VOCALS 👑👑👑👑👑👑

Oh my god u reacted this on Christmas eve I really wanted you to react to this ......😩😩😩😩😩😩❤❤❤❤🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺thanks ben!!!!!!!!!

owh still the most beautiful christmas song ever 😌

More exo

I'm always waiting for you to react to EXO. Glad that you did :) Thank you. Please react to them more. I love your reaction.

soooo emootionaaalll

Eric Nam says this is his favorite Christmas music. I whole-heartedly agree with him; it's mine also. Not a Christmas song, but Exo's "My Answer" is another beautiful ballad. D.O, Baekhyun, and Suho are the trio in it. D.O is my bias and Bae is one of my bias wreckers. But we don't get to hear Suho's beautiful voice featured enough, so that's another reason to love "My Answer".

I cry every single time I watch this MV

Miracles in Dec. and Don't go are 2 of my fave songs plus CBX Paper Cut

This song moves my feelings

welcome to kkaebsong.i feel u bro.bacon bias is something

you should read the lyrics it's so beautiful!!!!!!!!!!!!!! every word of this song is beautiful and every word that Chen sings in the song would make soooo many people cry!!!!!!!!!!! I cried the first time i read the lyrics

I really love it when you react to exo because you remind me myself

My wish has been granted

This is the winter album of Korea. Guess what? Im crying again.

Finally ♡♡♡♡

React to exo live diamond+coming over+run this+drop that +power It is all in one video

It was a winter song that's why the background is in ice..

When Baekhyun sing i feel gooseflesh ❤

MY COMMENTS ACTUALLY WORKED IM CRYINGGGGG BEN I LOVE AND APPRECIATE YOU SO MUCH BRUV

tbh this is one of the few kpop songs that can make me cry whenever I listen to it

Just so you know, every mv from EXO have a korean and chinese version :) at least they used to have one but for Obsession they didn't Thank you for reacting to them

.... Those were the days!

Just read the lyrics😭😭😍

This gets me everytime. 💔

Thanks to react to mv♥️♥️

"who would've known that all it would take to kill me is some of my favorite singers looking at the camera and singing" Me every time I watch this mv

FINALLY!!!!