看完三位歌手，给我感觉是: JYP跳得最帅，Jacky唱得最骚，黄至列整体表现，看了最爽。

Hwang Chi Yeul is awesome! I have been his concert for several times. He is a walking CD, used to perform 30+ songs in his solo concert for solid 3 hours+ ! While singing & dancing at same time, he is still right on key ! A superb, sexy & sunshine singer ! BRAVO !!

I have watched Hwang Chi Yeul live singing this song 'Honey'. He sounded exactly the same as is in the video.

JYP這麼強難怪會要求他的藝人也要有現場演出的實力

這首是 JYP 作詞、作曲、編曲和演唱的歌~ 後來才有其他人和其他語言的翻唱

黄致列演唱会2到3个多小时的唱跳，音准，体力，耐力，歌声穿透力，感染力都一级棒，因为他每天都运动，肺活量很大，可以说是现场王。

Hwang Chi-Yeul is an amazing live performer. I've seen his concert several times and addicted to it. Most of his concerts lasted at least 3 hours, with plenty of dance songs and his performance was consistently great from the very first song till the last song. Awesome.

黃致列是舞者出身，後來專研唱歌成為教導練習生的聲樂老師，是舞蹈跟唱歌都努力精進等待機會的藝人，直到「我是歌手4」在中國火了一把才紅回韓國！他在「我是歌手4」絕對唱現場，但錄播的節目是一定會經過後製才會播出的，但光看現場觀眾的反應就可知道現場效果有多炸裂！🥰🥰

@susannac4839

6 күн бұрын

可能唱得太好太完美😂 所以令Rozette老師難以置信！黃致列在我是歌手的每集都不同形象，由第一集被裝扮得老成持重，其後就像役齡生長越變越年輕，難怪老師認不出他就是唱默的那個kid😅

@anailian8217

6 күн бұрын

黄致列的演唱会可以证明一切

Jyp is a legend, trend settler, creator, and entrepreneur. Imagine how many popular songs he creates and the dance he choreographed that shapes todays K-pop, i think he is one of most creative person alive.

I went to hcy's concerts several times. Trust me, he sounded exactly the same as in this MV.

Great！兩位都是令人尊敬的大前輩，各有千秋👍🏻 黃致列在參賽「我是歌手4」時的改編版更青出於藍，至今每逢他在演唱會表演這首歌仍然驚艷四座的！期待老師們的反應和意見，非常感謝！🙏🏻

This was live on "I Am A Singer 4" Contest in China. He placed Ist on this round. Also try “Bang Bang Bang” from the same show which captivated Chinese audience and HCY became a Hallyu star.

Hwang Chiyeul is a great dancer and awesome singer too. His songs were very touching deep into our hearts. 👍👍👍😍😍😍

I have watched Hwang Chiyeul’s live performance of this song during concert. He totally delivered it. ❤

The last one, handsome, talented & good dancer. I'm attracted to him😍

황치열 Hwang Chiyeul 黃致列 is a marvelous singer especially on the stage ❤❤❤

我也願意看年輕性感歌手黄致列的演出.....我是歌手4 他確實是現場演唱並獲第一名..此後 HONEY 他演出上百場通通都是現場唱跳演出...從來沒有例外🥰

@egg1080

5 күн бұрын

+1

JYP其实很舞台艺术，整个百老汇的感觉。张学友天王风范，整个舞台掌控，帝王欢愉的松弛感。黄致列……“我会请他喝一杯”太真实了！魔力麦克VIP和谐特供场。三个人完全是三个面向的感觉，没有一个是输的。

三位都非常棒，但我最喜歡황치열黃致列的演出❤🎉

Hwang Chiyeul is a gem on stage. His live performance, be it singing or dancing, is amazing. Of course, I do think he’s good looking too.😍

黃致烈在當時歌手的表現更甚現在的反西亞，能文能舞會唱會跳，魅力四射

Thanks so much for featuring - and enjoying - the performance of Hwang Chi Yeul. HCY actually started out as a B-boy over 20 years ago :) Hope you will react to more of Hwang Chi Yeul's performances on "I Am A Singer 4", thanks in advance.

Hwang Chi Yeul & Jacky are both balladeer. Singing a dance song to them has been incredibly amazing. I have attended to both of their concert & they are equally entertaining. Hwang's live concert has added bonus. He performs continuously a few dance song without his voice getting raspy and he don't even panting! yes, he is too hot to handle. 😍

我的MJ的忠粉,他在自傳Moonwalk説了,moonwalk的舞步不是他創的,他是跟街頭的黑人舞者學的,學了很久,一直都不敢在演出時跳,他總是那麼完美主義...直至Motown那晚,他跳了,技驚四座,仍然覺得自己跳得不夠好,在后台哭了

@mialiu9289

6 күн бұрын

我記得的是歐普拉去Neverland訪問他時，他說是看到黑人小朋友跳然後完善了這個舞步，第一次表演他覺得不夠好在後台哭了，直到他要上車離開有個猶太小孩對他說跳的太棒了，他才真心相信而開心並說…他覺得只有小孩不會說謊…結果那些傷害他的事件😢

@hilarylau6840

6 күн бұрын

​@@mialiu9289我也有看這訪問，訪問很好看，亦是首次談及"整容"的傳聞

看過黃致列現場唱這歌，跟"我是歌手"版本唱得一樣咁好👍👍

Last one❤❤❤

I would like to say a few words for Hwang Chi Yeul. During the long competition in "I Am a Singer," his throat condition was indeed not good at the time. However, you can find many fancams of his concerts on KZread, and his live performances are really excellent.

黃致列當時確實喉嚨狀況不太好(頻繁搭機往返中韓、爆紅後行程滿檔)，但演唱會他現場唱跳這首完全沒問題🙌 KZread有很多演唱會現場演唱影片🥰

@user-yo2se9ji3d

6 күн бұрын

現在糊了

Many Canto-pop in the 90s cover a lot of songs from Japan, Korea & the Western. Original released in 1998 by JY Park and the melody bought over and rewrite into sang by Jacky and another singer from Taiwan. Melody rearrange according vibe and style. Hwang Chi Yeul edition is for competition purposes so it is more attractive & eye catching. Jacky's performance mainly for concert so it is more grand, whereas JYP ed the original more on funky style since it is very popular during that era.

Hwang Chi Yeul...his voice like Live CD

Great video and I enjoyed hearing the expert's comments on the three performances. This is one of the episodes on the "I am a Singer 4" singing competition show where Hwang Chi Yeul won first place.

It could be edited, but definitely no lip-sync. It's a competition, not allowed to lip-sync. Competition - "I am a Singer".

黃致列現場超級 👍

All of them are great singers❤️ but I prefer the last one❤️ Maybe next time the live concert version of Hwang chiyeul could be commented. I believe it could be much sexier, enjoyable and good for my eyes and ears🤩

@user-fq6hw9eo5k

5 күн бұрын

太棒啦 致列❤

My pick is Hwang. 😊 If you watch some of his live clips by fans, you'll see that he really doesn't need "technical help".

The last one is the best, sexy and charismatic.

期待更多黃致列的歌曲❤他還有許多可以挖掘的優點，模仿韓國著名歌手唱法對他來說只是基礎能力。想確切知道他現場live的唱跳功力和穩定度，看現場演唱就能知道（簡直跟聽唱片一樣…😭沒有瑕疵到分不出來自己在聽演唱會😅）。但重點還是必須強調，抒情歌才是他的主場， 至於唱腔和唱功😅同樣身為聲樂老師的他，豐富多變是絕對的😁

@longlongtrip

3 күн бұрын

确实re这种反差大的才有趣呢，帅，能唱，还能舞，还壮！😂可惜不红

LOVE that song Rozette sings at the end of the video ❤

我最黃致列那段，雖然影片不清楚，但他真的會唱也非常帥❤謝謝老師及杰凱❤

‘‘呢條友呀’’😂😂😂 估唔到左右護法會用廣東話交流

@yohoman0000

6 күн бұрын

邊個呀🤣🤣

@mpf1031

6 күн бұрын

所以其實我好好奇佢哋係邊度嘅人嚟？😂

@ceciX3panda

2 күн бұрын

@@mpf1031 Jay來自江南

Three of them are amazing! They are great vocalist esp Jacky & Hwang and they are a great dancer too esp JYP & Hwang. Overall I prefer Hwang Chi Yeul - he is sexier & masculine and of course a talented handsome singer 😍

I’ve watched so many live concerts of very renowned artists. I also love musicals and watched a lot of masterpieces. I ended up becoming a fan of Hwang Chiyeul. He’s the only artist whose live performance, to me, is miraculously better than his recorded CD(although his CDs are great too). His concerts are not to be missed. You have to see to believe!

我喜歡第三位表演,好吸眼球,看了會尖叫

HONEY-1998 影片中播出時間 JYP-2001.6.16 (BORN 1971.12) Jacky Cheung-2019.1(BORN 1961.7)

@shirley-hk

6 күн бұрын

@@Lin-mp2vw Hwang Chi Yeul-2016.3 (BORN 1982.12)

@test2test911

6 күн бұрын

thank you。找了半天jyp的视频，幸好看到你的留言

@pengsoon81

3 күн бұрын

根据视频中 JYP当时30岁。 歌神张学友当时58岁。 黄致列当时34岁。 在58岁还能够有那样的体力唱跳真的没几个能够做到。 ❤👍🏻

老師這集按暫停次數是有史以來最誇張了😅

최고의 퍼프먼스 가창력 춤실력이 대단한 황치열 ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

男導師的資訊成日誤導左老師, 請問呢條片既可比性喺邊? 三個年紀差咁遠? 仲要話Jacky Cheung 同JYP差唔多大? 要比都搵返Jacky Cheung 1999年左右既 live 黎比啦. 呢隻歌派台時張學友都巳38歳, 都大過另外兩位表演時幾年, 當時隻舞係勁好多, 你知唔知人每過10年大關, 身體狀況都會差好遠? 今年張學友63歳的演唱會, 同佢58時比係差左好多, 唔講把聲衰退了, 呢隻要邊唱邊跳, 體力上差30年差幾遠? 而且張學友果個仲要係連做幾年既演唱會, 其餘兩個係表演一首歌! 做對比片唔做好資料搜集, 好易會誤導人. 由其老師係外國人仕, 同埋亦會踩低左一D歌手既真正能力. 真心希望正視問題. JYP-2001.6.16 (BORN 1971.12) - At age 30 Jacky Cheung-2019.1(BORN 1961.7) - At age 58 (大過另外兩個成倍呀) Hwang Chi Yeul-2016.3 (BORN 1982.12) - At age 34. (但由於佢係80後, 唱法上肯定較貼近現今).

@HenaKim

Күн бұрын

講得好啱 係好應該交代清楚大家出歌嘅背景

@EC-ez6tu

Күн бұрын

@@HenaKim 最重要係佢根本無查過資料，老師問到佢就求其答個答案，話大家差唔多大都講得出.....

黃至列在我是歌手唱都非常精彩.感覺比原唱更好聽😅

老師最後的表演真棒🎉

You may wish to know that this song was written in 1998. While Bruno mars uptown funk was written in 2014.

我是看了黃致列表演‘BangBangBang"’而留意喜愛上他的👇🏻👇🏻 kzread.info/dash/bejne/h2uDx8mbebLeaaQ.htmlsi=pTUEDaGBH5cZVPQd 毒性很強的表演😊😊

好期待！！少幫主❤

您好～MJ沒有說過他發明了太空步喔，歐普拉的紀錄片有這段描述 以及Honey 並不是2000初期而是1998年的歌曲🙏

期待❤❤❤

Hwang Chi Yeul ist legit!!! You have to listen to him more with his live stuff accoustic versions or his extreme versions! He can sing this live ☺️ hope you will give him more tries! P.S. he used to be a vocal coach 😉

Very interesting samples, the original song writer and singer, the Chinese/canto original translated cover and a Korean singing covering on a competition show with both versions 🤣

yes，last one❤

Hwang Chi Yeul can sing without missing his pitch or breath while doing a head stand, you should have seen that one then you will believe what he can do. Besides, I have seen him performing this song in his concerts, trust me, it is real.

@johanne1225

5 күн бұрын

kzread.info/dash/bejne/Zo2W1syznrHdj7A.htmlsi=u3wHyLpGTClllGLR

黃致列是裡面最棒的❤ 他在韓國也是一位聲樂老師。他不只是舞蹈跳的很棒。也教導很多韓國歌手唱歌。

@user-yo2se9ji3d

6 күн бұрын

他在韓國算幾線

@JohnDoe-pn6me

6 күн бұрын

張學友才是最棒的，傻爆眼

@user-qt8du4yi4p

6 күн бұрын

@@user-yo2se9ji3d 他在韓國的身分應該算是輔助一些新人歌手或是男子團體的教唱老師. 畢竟他的年紀在韓國演藝圈來說也不年輕了.

@user-op7jm9pd9v

3 күн бұрын

@@JohnDoe-pn6me很現實 實力擺在那你所謂的歌神只能排第三

@JohnDoe-pn6me

3 күн бұрын

@@user-op7jm9pd9v 真的，歌神的實力一聽就知道是第一了

Listen to 黄致列 Live concert please

歌手4的時候也很喜歡黃致列 可以給老師看看決賽的片段吧 黃致列在決賽LIVE表現不俗 特別喜歡幫唱那首 張學友光Classic tour我就看了三次每次都穩到不行 何況這首是演唱會中段的曲目 前面也有唱跳 年紀也是50+真的很神

黄致列好帅好性感❤

今天這集前面有種老人家講古的感覺，滿有趣的。

橘老師還是太小看黃致列了,後期修音也不是他願意,但他完全有那個實力 kzread.info/dash/bejne/lpmhzqmFcaiWnZs.htmlsi=5q3YabDxweV-m5uP

Last one ❤❤❤

我選JYP ，真的很好看，韓國 K-POP教父。

My love star Hwang Chiyeul❤❤❤

JPY表現最好也最完整，但滿累的.....唱的也不錯~

我有黄致列演唱honey的现场视频，可以发给老师做比较。

期待老師品評黃致列唱跳的版本，這是［我是歌手］節目的競賽演出，要與其他歌手同場分高低，奪得這輪第一名。

Should have used fancam live concert versions for all 3 of them for a fairer comparison to avoid any doubts perhaps?

@susannac4839

6 күн бұрын

Yes, agreed with you! 😂 We must show off that he once sang and danced the same song twice in a row at the 2023 Taipei concert at the request of fans. Even though he was sweating profusely, he still sang happily, enthusiastically, and enjoyed himself, trying his best to satisfy all the audience present. That’s him ❤ #황치열 #hwangchiyeul kzread.info/dash/bejne/ZmpnpdWrmJetYps.htmlsi=YAl4M3ekrk1jEUxb

@swloong8582

5 күн бұрын

@@shirley-hk yes if fan cam versions were used , you will find Hwang Chiyeul’s live is always impeccable. He always exceeds expectations!

Rozette is so cute. How come she always forgotten who is The One. Infact she has done twice a reaction video on him🤭 I bet she also does not recognise that young man who sang 默 is Hwang Chi Yeul🤪🤪🤪It looks like two different person, isn't it?🤣🤣🤣

Totally get that it’s hard to find fault in Hwang Chi Yeul’s singing, and Jay is right that wasn’t lip-syncing. That’s the incredible vocal quality he delivers in every live performance. And who doesn’t wanna get him a drink just like the girl said.😉🙌🏻

@susannac4839

6 күн бұрын

Agree 😂

@assunta.

6 күн бұрын

@@susannac4839🤭🤭

@anailian8217

6 күн бұрын

Yes, his live concerts can prove it.

黃致烈版本大愛❤可惜限韓令阻礙他在中國發展

@user-yo2se9ji3d

6 күн бұрын

解除了

hwangchiyeul👍🏽

非常好的一首音乐。 如果有人正在阅读此评论，请记住在某个地方，总有人祝您一切顺利，

老師有點低估了黃致列一邊唱一邊跳的能力.他體力跟邊唱邊跳的能力一直是很優秀的. 因為他有固定健身.跳舞的習慣.有在固定健身的人.特別像這黃致列這種跳舞很厲害的歌手. 在歌手這樣的節目一個星期表演一首歌根本不是問題.. 像之前老師講評李玟唱那首英文歌.李玟也是來本來就很會跳舞. 她唱邊跳一首英文歌根本不是問題.橘老師她說過自己的體力不是很好的那種. 所以她只要看到邊唱邊跳的歌手.她就會開始懷疑.真唱的真實性 我覺得這樣的觀念很不好.你自己體力不好.你不是擅長跳舞. 但不要去懷疑可以邊唱邊跳很好的歌手阿.. 那如果橘老師看一下Jolin跨年現場的表演. Jolin常常可以搭配舞群連續跳很激烈的一系列的舞曲組曲.而且唱歌氣息都保持非常穩定好聽 那橘老師是不是又要懷疑蔡依林對嘴....大家都知道Jolin對於表演有多努力.處女座的她對自己表演要求有多高. 所以請橘老師真的不要拿自己的身體健康狀態還有體力去懷疑那些對自己體能要求很高的歌手....ok... 歌手就是就是一個星期專注排練這歌.然後把這首歌表現好. 又不是像開演唱會要連續唱跟跳幾十首.那才真的比較累人. 加上黃致列唱歌的肺活量本來就非常驚人. 而且幾年過去了.黃致列目前的狀態依然非常好.歌聲.外型還是身材都保持得很好. kzread.info/dash/bejne/m3iVtaqHj9zHmKQ.html 老師可以看一下他今年的HONEY演唱會的側錄版本.就知道他邊跳邊唱的功力. kzread.info/dash/bejne/maaIsrOAqbTYaKw.html

@yuluntu1350

6 күн бұрын

看完連結的影片 發現老師說的好像是真的😳 老是懷疑的應該是 只有跳完舞那句是錄好的 其他歌手也會做這件事 只有最危險那句對嘴 但他還是很棒👍

"His hair gel does not owe him anything" I'm laughing on the ground.

HCY 👍👍👏👏💖💖💖🔥🔥🔥

其實黃致列演唱會表演這首，一樣非常讚喔～

蹲個首播❤❤❤

真心推荐老师去听黄致列的现场演唱

竟然有老板jyp 他是原唱 作曲人

Dear Rozette and CZ Media, please consider to do an episode to talk about Korean singer IU Lee Ji-eun. From her popular "Good day" at the beginning, to "Heart" and "Through the Night" with increasingly ethereal sounds, and now to her super solid queen-like "Dear Name","My Sea" and "Love wins all", she has lots of changes in singing methods, I really hope to hear you guys talking about it, thank you! (IU has also covered many English songs, such as "Officially missing you", "Loving you", "Marry you", "I Don't Wanna Love Somebody Else", which are also worth listening to) 老師你好，懇請可以做一集談談韓國歌手IU李知恩的歌聲。她從一開始爆紅的《Good day》，到後來聲音越趨空靈的《Heart》、《Through the Night》，再到現在超級扎實女皇般的《Dear Name》、《My Sea》、《Love wins all》，當中有著很多的唱法改變，很希望能聽老師談談，謝謝！（IU也翻唱過很多英語歌，例如《Officially missing you》、《Loving you》、《Marry you》、《I Don't Wanna Love Somebody Else》也很值得聽聽） Some links that maybe useful: Good day live at 2010 kzread.info/dash/bejne/iKGhusWuaLu4aKg.html Good day live at 2019 kzread.info/dash/bejne/dnmDtsqsed23drA.html Through the night + Dear Name live kzread.info/dash/bejne/qX-uyryklaXPotY.html My Sea live kzread.info/dash/bejne/oKJl0sSxlZvIcaw.html

20幾年前就在聽頭髮亂了～一直不知道有韓文版🤣

@longlongtrip

3 күн бұрын

成个八九十年代香港嘅歌曲，可以话好大部分都係翻唱，翻唱最多係日本，其次英文，再嚟係韩国

JYP還幫不少自己藝人團隊創作舞蹈,所以他是有舞蹈功底.

我記得以前張學友年輕的時候，唱頭髮亂了也是跳舞跳得很激烈的

@meis2720

6 күн бұрын

係，記得以前唱得好輕鬆

@user-mb5nb3tq5j

6 күн бұрын

老了要認老，無法像年輕時候，跳得那麼激烈，唱的也沒那麼帶勁

@jayli6658

6 күн бұрын

@@meis2720 這首歌當年真的是神曲，這三位都翻唱的很棒，很有自己的魅力

@greentofuhouse

4 күн бұрын

@@jayli6658第一位是原唱啦😂還是作曲作詞人😅

为张学友和JYPark鼓掌👏！！

Jacky is ten years older than JYP. That’s why JYP danced harder but actually Jacky also danced hard when he’s younger.

黄致列❤️❤️👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

非常喜欢你们的节目，提高了很多对音乐的鉴赏。谢谢🙏。能否点评刀郎的歌？

@guayihchang

6 күн бұрын

刀郎不太適合這個頻道,刀郎的歌詞寫得很好,但老師不會中文,其實評不了什麼

都好听！如果硬选就jyp😂😂😂

Last one❤️❤️❤️

mj saw so kids did it on the ghetto so he prefect it from it. first time show on motown award and people was supprise by it. so yeah he show it.

其實張敬軒也有唱這首歌 也可以放到這裡喇🥺

이 채널 영상 재밌네. 한국의 최상급 실력파 가수 영상은 없네. ㅋㅋ

簽到影片下方給你們點個讚👍 遇廣告看完看🈵

黃致列未大紅之前也曾經是教唱歌的導師

张学友的对比真不应该选他50岁之后的舞台，拿他30多岁的现场要强不少

@test2test911

6 күн бұрын

录音设备不同，那时候音响效果不好

@yuanchen10

6 күн бұрын

@@test2test911 尽管如此，有几十场演唱会都是超高水平的

這首在韓國經典到Wonder Girls 的 Nobody 開頭就是穿插這首。