Bremmer statement, for Indian very hard to digest

@valetudo1569

6 күн бұрын

Sometimes thats how it is. He's a smart dude, not always right.. but smart, and should be listened to

As long as unemployment and extreme corruption is everywhere in Bharath, no economy will progress.

@treepiesinc1418

18 күн бұрын

Forgot to add illiterate extremists?

This guy is comparing India with 1.5 Billion people with 23 official languages and Mexico with a 112 million Spanish speaking people! Do not pay serious attention this guy! Remember! You cannot be friends with the U.S.

@valetudo1569

6 күн бұрын

What does the language thing have to do with anything? And btw - he's not comparing the population numbers, dummy. He's comparing the economic positioning of the countries

@valetudo1569

6 күн бұрын

What does the language thing have to do with anything? And btw - he's not comparing the population numbers, dummy. He's comparing the economic positioning of the countries

Around 0.25-0.31 he mentions there are not enough "westerners" here? I fail to understand the relevance of that comment. Maybe someone can enlighten me

@ShubhamShubhra

18 күн бұрын

in the crowd. not many came because they are not as willing to invest in India as everyone had hoped and assumed

@vetiarvind

17 күн бұрын

why do we take these westerners seriously? all they brought is poverty and misfortune to India. Ignore everything from their condescending mouths. They will just spin a fable to make themselves seem better than they really are. Don't trust them.

@joyceching6487

16 күн бұрын

REGARDING THE AUDIENCE... Why I See So Many GLOOMY FACES. Or is it just me. 😊

@mic3099

15 күн бұрын

This is his real meaning - Not many western investor and expats living in India so it not attractive market in India . When China in 1990s has a lot of western investors and expats living in China

Around 0.25-0.31 he mentions there are not enough "westerners" here --meaning - Not many western investor and expats living in India so it not attractive market in India for westerners. Compared to when China in 1990s has a lot of western investors and expats living in China

Yes India has to grow and grow till our economy gains some substance and strength. India has a long way to go. Only thing is the present leadership is efficient and working towards this goal. Hope together we reach there. It is not important to become a world power but our immediate goal is to become a strong and self sufficient economy internally.

@ShyamS-sx7xt

20 күн бұрын

aise kon chilla chilla ke bolta hai? hum global leader banne wale hai, gdp barne wali hai, bla bla

@suresh-dv7he

20 күн бұрын

Remember what US did to Raisi. They could have done that to our CDS. And plan the same to Modi.

@lokikadavra2676

19 күн бұрын

@@suresh-dv7he Gabbar singh yeh kehke gaya, jo darr gaya woh marr gaya

@HellBot-gi5si

17 күн бұрын

No Indian, India's Dharma is to a "Spiritual Leader" not a lead the world in manufacturing. Both Shakyamuni Buddha and the Lotus Born Buddha hid away Spiritual teaching to counter act the powerful demons that now plague this world. These teaching are still being discovered. These teachings are from the Buddha's of Hell Realms and they pacific very negative states of mind.

@HellBot-gi5si

17 күн бұрын

So we see problem in Israel with Gaza or in other places the Tibetan Buddhist even now do power rituals and pujas to counter act these evils. They also protect India from the China as well.

"The level of condescension in his tone. OMG." He may be a good person but the observation is accurate.

He makes a strong case for India to go for BRICS Plus in a strong manner

@HellBot-gi5si

19 күн бұрын

The BRICS nations including India are some the most corrupt nations on earth. If you tried to do business with these nations you going have to add another 35% for the bribery and corruption. You just signed a deal with Iran, you see they one these most corrupt nations which means India will have a hard time doing business with them.

@HellBot-gi5si

16 күн бұрын

BRICS isn't going solve the problems that India has. Also, India sell to over 40 nations world wide so BRICS isn't really helpful in that way.

The world, including The US, has given China an open ground to grow its economy. In the case of India, there will be many obstacles, including the new player China. If India has to reach a 10 trillion economy, it will have to work twice as hard as China.

@ranfak

18 күн бұрын

lol 😂 what a ignorant commnet. Why do Indian always do this kind of comment idk. Rather what is truth is the world has given so many opportunity and opne ground to India but always failed. And this time the result will be same for India. no different always blaming other and full of ego , and always trying to downplay other hardwork and being jealous of other specially of china. That’s what your comment show lol

@HellBot-gi5si

17 күн бұрын

India's Dharma is to uses it's advance Spiritual technology it not to become a world economic leader but a spiritual one. Many powerful beings reincarnated in India. Princess Mandarava live many years ago in the northern India Kingdom of Zahor, at sixteen you left the life of Indian Princess and lived in caves in the Himalayas. She achieved high realizations and when her people found her teaching eventually made the entire Kingdom of Zahor enlightened. The Kingdom and it's people disappeared into the higher realms.

@HellBot-gi5si

17 күн бұрын

It was later revealed that Princess Mandarava was the emanation of one great 5 female Buddhas. She left behind many teachings on wisdom and compassion for Indians that even to this day follow her teachings.

He is speaking the truth about india. Indian needs to accept

@hpremjit

22 күн бұрын

Points to be considered what he said, but don't treat it as gospel.

@nicholastariang1017

21 күн бұрын

@@hpremjit india is very very weak n nothing infront of u.s.a ,china , Russia. accept that in every area come on that is the truth

@dhirajmalapati268

21 күн бұрын

India doesnt care about western opinions, were done.

@vetiarvind

17 күн бұрын

we accept you are entitled to your opinion and can stfu, we have no need to accept Western garbage lies.

@jaisuryabanerjee

16 күн бұрын

Absolutely.. Climate change alone will be the biggest obstacle to India's potential growth trajectory..

Ian Bummer.

India is within the strategic generosity phase of the West. The phase is double edge sword

@HellBot-gi5si

17 күн бұрын

India's Dharma is not to become economic leader but a powerful spiritual leader of this world. It was predicted by Shakyamuni Buddha 2,800 years ago. He hid away powerful wrathful teaching from the Buddha's of the hell realms in the eight charnel grounds of India guarded by powerful demons so that only the right beings may discover them.

@HellBot-gi5si

17 күн бұрын

Even now Buddhist practice the VarjaKilya the Razor that destroys with a Touch. In this degenerate age powerful demons are allowed to reincarnate as humans. These are being that broken the oaths and fell to hell realms the Kilya helps to counteract their evil minds. Do not worry it protect India from invasion from China and other demonic entities in world.

The level of condescension in his tone. OMG. 😂

@indianmilitary

19 күн бұрын

He knows that the US and other western nations are finished due to impending de-dollarization after 2025. So, don't fall for their fake "condenscending" attitude 🤣🤣. He knows that the party is over for the west and also know that Indis will be the bridge between east and the west for new currency and trade negotiations

@HellBot-gi5si

19 күн бұрын

That because India constitution is not designed to be a manufacturing power house. So India will mostly just make products just for India so we not seem become super rich.

@ShubhamShubhra

18 күн бұрын

he is not condescending. he is stating facts.

@vivianrikhey8256

18 күн бұрын

@@ShubhamShubhra No shit Sherlock. It is the tone of his voice which is condescending. The original comment had nothing to do with 'Facts'. It's the way he talks.

@ShubhamShubhra

18 күн бұрын

@@vivianrikhey8256 the journalist is goading him to sing praises for Modi which he is not doing. Nor is he costing up to Indians who want to feel good about the progress we have made so far. It's actually presumptuous to be so boastful when we have barely begun walking on our own two feet to ask someone else running the circuit to sing praises for us. The tone is not condescending at all. It's just that he is not going gaga over our remarkable yet meagre progress. He mentioned that there are not many westerners here. That was him speaking to the room because they did not get people from the western hemisphere as interested in this event as they should. It's not about their approval. It's about their investment. He mentions how India or rather Modi getting Japan to invest in India instead of elsewhere was a good move. This is less about his tone but, about hurt egos. A little pin prick to an inflated ego of Modi's fans is needed. Nationalism is an infantile disease.

Challenge accepted. We Indian will grow our economy bigger than that of USA's 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽

@indianmilitary

19 күн бұрын

US economy is fake. it was built on mindless printing of trillions of dollars out of thin air through petro dollar ponzi scheme enforced in the early 70s by arm twisting OPEC mullahs to accept only dollar for oil. Now, the party is over due to impending de-dollarization after 2025 because of accumulation of huge debt for the past 5 decades. World' s biggest debtor nation which outsourced everything and does not produce anything on its own cannot be the biggest economy

@HellBot-gi5si

19 күн бұрын

No, it will not but you will grow. However, unless you change your constitution there probably see India only really make products for India that about it.

@JohnAbraham-gh6dz

18 күн бұрын

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

@andrewzhang985

17 күн бұрын

In another 100 years maybe.😂

interesting to note the opening question - a fixation over Stories vs. focus on Substance (socioeconomic progress for the vast population)

Interview this fellow after 5 years and we would like to see what he has to say on USA vis a vis Bharat. 😂😂😂

Pls don’t put western templates to the world. Geography is different whether they like it or not. We were suppressed for 400 years from British and then suppressed by the family (we all know who) . Now we have one daring and inspiring leader . If goats are lead by lion, goats will definitely have the same attitude as the lion. Here lion is Modi. Again India is unique in its own way

@PawanMehra-ll3rb

20 күн бұрын

What after modi why not we as youngsters try to change things modi is not immortal But I love him too but we are over dependent ❤❤❤❤

@agnosticatheist4093

18 күн бұрын

Bas kar bhakt

Hear all the opinions. But listen to those that helps you grow. He has opinions on a lot of things , some like climate change and it’s impacts are unavoidable and are going to impact our growth. But we don’t have to takes all he said as ground truth.

You say skeptical i say realistic. We need to work really hard!

💯 dude knows exactly what he is talking about. India should align with any country that suits their India first strategy.

India has 1.4 billion consumers and growing. Who can stop that

@NiteshKumar-ue1yp

17 күн бұрын

I.N.D.I.A.

@jimmylam9846

15 күн бұрын

when ppp is $1800 usd there is much consumer spending available.

@vhrui904

13 күн бұрын

60％ indians cant affort decent food...they rely on free grains by the Gov...WHAT purchasing power ??😂😂😂😂😂😂

The thing is you are missing the point, china until recently even when it came to big brokers wasn't that the most exciting of a market. You dont have to be the first in this case you will be great even if you can get really close to the mist exciting market(when it cones to market performance)

This guy doesn't know india very well. India has a huge young population and ambitious. It doesn't matter how hot the climate, what geography we are in, people find a way to work hard & create business. Lot of people are not included in the taxing system, once all of them enter the system economy will sky rocket. India's defence budget is far less than America, US has enemies across the globe. I also want to say that he doesn't have a clue about ev technology. Chinese made EVs are far superior than American EVs, Chinese ev safety regulations are much stronger than US regs. I am sure he never read a EV regulatory document and will never understand even if he reads one.

Right. He is telling the truth which can't be ignored.

There should be reform in education system .

Agree on AI. Dominated by USA (many Indian engineers maybe inside That )plus Energy dominated by Chinese

, Modi is the only person who can make Indian story a reality

@ShyamS-sx7xt

20 күн бұрын

kalnemi hai wo aur tu ek bhaand brahmin..

Us has to make new alliance and influence in Mexico and south America. This is sales pitch for investment in there.

In Modi's third term more international strategic moves will take place

Bremmer's assessment is correct regarding India, but the statement regarding the US is illusionary.

He is correct

@lokikadavra2676

22 күн бұрын

Not disagreeing with him, but there is a small detail he missed. The US population is aging and their birth rate is falling. From a future growth perspective, both these metrics are extremely important. Not sure why he did not factor this into his explanation and how the US plans to handle this.

@prodigiii712

19 күн бұрын

He is totally incorrect and I live in the US. This is a country with the highest national debt, highest homeless population, highest drug overdose deaths and highest illegal immigration.

@nyarlathotep466

18 күн бұрын

@@prodigiii712 By "this" do you mean India or US? And how does either make him totally incorrect? Not asking rhetorically, I genuinely want to understand your reasoning.

@vhrui904

13 күн бұрын

60％ indians cant affort decent food...they rely on free grains by the Gov...WHAT purchasing power ??😂😂😂😂😂😂

I dont think we need to look for external validation from these so called experts. We are on the right path and in the next 10 years will be game changing for us.

good thing is now we don't get intimidated by these narratives. But we started using our 🖕more

Not bothered about USA. Let them go take a walk. USA needs India more than India needs USA.

@sherlockholmes882

19 күн бұрын

Lol

@1729krish

19 күн бұрын

Bro being patriotic is one thing. But don't be delusional

I agree india needs time maybe a long hall but saying usa is stable a joke you have debt with Chinese 2 trillion and other investments your political instability your establishment doesn't want trump but the other side has sleeping joe and hardly a local American political person running for election most are either indian American or someone more related to Europe trump too had a European background!

Ian is so nervous. Why is he doing this if he's not comfortable

What does he mean in his opening statement “no westerners in India “…. Who cares what this guy thinks ? And no Westerner knows India . Indians know India the best .

Short summary: 1) Climate change affect India. 2) Mexico as a partner of US. 3) Geo political tension in India's borders Opinion : None of the above matters, if you make low cost reliable products that world can't say no to. Look at PRC, they hv tensions with almost the whole world and yet their trade only increases year aftr yr.

Lol, who is he? I live in US. The chances of this country surviving another decade looks grim. Internally the country is broken. People don't have money, the rich are getting richer. This country has so many problems and dude just went and procliamed US will be the most significant country. I want whatever he is smoking.

@RKV8527

24 күн бұрын

Internally country is broken. Population control is a MUST to address this challenge. Climate change causes the destruction of agriculture and water sources. Population control is a MUST AI and Robotics technology will destroy jobs. Population control is a MUST

@thampikarukaseril5020

23 күн бұрын

Are you an Indian really ? VERY POOR

@samswe-fr2tr

23 күн бұрын

​@@RKV8527360 million is not that much compared to india and china

@samswe-fr2tr

23 күн бұрын

You're an indian living in usa. So if usa is broken why dont you come here to india

@sherlockholmes882

19 күн бұрын

​@@samswe-fr2trHaha, thanks for this comment. He believes US is a broken nation yet migrated there. I guess he is highly educated too. The problems he mentioned about US(internal division, wealth inequality etc) are there in India too.

Why is this India guy and India need Ian Bremmer's approval ? Just look at the body language. If India does everything ''for the people'', it should not worry about foreign opinions such as Bremmer's

too much bling in US's will blind their eyes and wont see others shine.. thats their reality..🔥

He said the US is a very attractive market becoz the Americans are subsidizing their industries......! Wow..he admitted that and yet the US can accuse other nations of subsidizing their own domestic industries! What a double standard & blatant hypocrisy!

Its like climate change is not an issue for USA😂

Post World War 2, We are living in the Era of The American Empire, We are also living in the Era of Neo Colonialism(indirect control), We are also living in the era of Weasel politicians, who would bow down to anyone with money. And America is the queen of indirect control. Once Neo Colonialism collapses Democracies will thrive. Basically, after the second world war America has been running from third base to fourth base and calling themselves winner of the "world series". The era of China has begun, though the era of America is not completly lost. China is strong but not that strong. America is weak but not that weak. So, in this contest America will try to use G7 countries China will try to use Brics+ (Iran and Saudi Arabia). That tells you the era of a multi polar world is upon us. Whoever controls the middle east controls the world, The Europeans once controlled the middle east so they ruled the world, now America controls the middle east so it controls the world, if the indications are true tomorrow China is going to control the world and global economy because they have forged a relationship with Middle East. They are the going to be the defacto epicenter of the global economy and trade in the coming years. Where America has reached in 240 years, China has reached there in 40 years. Take that American Capitalism! The name of the game is Capitalism. "Who knew China (Communist party of China) is going to be so good at it?" China is winning because USA has allowed it to win, which is the biggest foreign policy blunder in the last 40 years. Socialism with Chinese Characteristics is just a euphemism for Authorotarian capitalism. China owes "it's whole success" to a series of poor foreign policy decision by America (The West) which is to involve China in WTO and shifted evey job from Detroit to Shanghai, Apparently the wonders of capitalism was supposed to make China more "democratic" nither did that happen nor did it drive a wedge between Soviet Russia and China. It has created a more powerful China and Russia alliance. Which is extremely hard to counter for the west. By 2030-32 China is going to become the largest economy in world which is going to be a massive change in the world and if it's goes really bad for US and it collapses (40 years after the Soviet Empire collapsed) then we might be ushered into a new era. There is nothing as soft power, there is hard power and everything flows from there. That's true for American Empire, Russia, China and the British Empire. In America the political parties change but the policies don't change, In China the political party don't change but the policies change all the time. Till America doesn't change course it is in for a rough ride for the next couple of decades.

Please don't listen to this guy - he does not know what he is talking about. He does not know why India is not in Belt and Road Initiative. India should simply have good relations with every country - unless really necessary. We don't need to be on this camp or that camp.

Winston Churchill

Presenting sponsor Galgotias University

Westerners have consistently underestimated India's potential... We may have a considerable GDP gap between the first two and the expected third India, but that Gap will be filled quickly once we reach 5 Trillion...Second, India has already pulled out from QUAD, indicating that we can defend ourselves ...... This guy feels otherwise... His tone is typical westerner

We need Jaishankar to reply him

1) Global warming will negatively impact not just India but all of the world...just as an example, all coastal cities from Tokyo to Hong Kong to Mumbai to NY r equally threatened , systemic risk 2) Mexico has the benefit of geography but India has size which not too many players have 3) India has the STEM advantage since u mentioned AI and also green energy etc etc. STEM drives innovation, STEM drives economy and the world. 4) India bcums #3 by 2028 ish, sure there still remains a huge gulf between 1 & 2....but what do 2050 ish foreasts say.....how abt looking further ahead and what does the top 3 look like???? Ofcourse long term is hazier than short term...but we only talking future here. 5) India lives in a v hostile neighborhood. But leme tell u abt Seoul which grew and still is despite its perpetual conflicts and tensions with the North. Japan grew despite its chronic relationship issues with the neighbouring big dad China. Look at Israel, but I wud not take that example for v different factors at work there. Now let me come to Russia. It's economy isnt doing that bad despite all usa biz pull outs and the ballooning def expenditure and the destruction war brings....another worst case scenario also hasn't brought abt a near apocalytical scenario. Success more often comes to those who underplay their weakness and overplay their strengths. Single most important factor that wud determine the future is leadership...communities who get that right will actualise their potential. That's the single most critical and defining factor.

India will be the next global macroeconomic player¡¡Ian Bremmer is right¡¡¡

Face of Rahul and people sitting in audience 😂😂😂😂 Kyun bulaya isko😅 Tum ko agar ase neighbours mile hote tum to tik v nai pate,ham thrive kar rahe itne problematic neighbours k bad v😊

You want to be an ally of the US? Buy American bonds first, must buy a lot to please Americans.

He only himself, so speak about himself

This guy is BS, indian can always come up with whatever GDP numbers they wish.

why do we give such people a stage ?

@WandaVision19

19 күн бұрын

Exactly 💯

All are selfish. West thought China will never have its brands or tech and eill work for them.

Highly condescending fellow!

U don’t need to be environment scientist

Biased , Western opinion, take it with a pinch of salt his opinion

India growth story is over rated. It's noise created by Modi and his chamachas

@dhruvakumar7187

24 күн бұрын

did you even listen to what he said, wtf man!, Modi is the only person who can make Indian overrated story a reality, It always starts with an overrated story and slowly it becomes reality, its not going to happen like one overnight somebody declares India is huge success

@MellowMelodiesGoa

24 күн бұрын

I concur with you, hype, if India was so developed why beg the German Engine for MBT, now that they stopped they are begging CAT for engines. To be truly world leader we need to surge ahead by employing vast pool of Engineers and Doctors in R&D and developing own tech. This will solve to a much better extent underemployment, but Indian billionaires only interested in quick money by starting deliveries and malls and hyped grocery stores.

@RKV8527

24 күн бұрын

Climate change causes the destruction of agriculture and water sources. Population control is a MUST AI and Robotics technology will destroy jobs. Population control is a MUST

@dhruvakumar7187

24 күн бұрын

@@MellowMelodiesGoa fashion, beauty products, true, unless there is total overhaul of education system i dont think there will be much development in quality of people in India

@Rider15277

23 күн бұрын

​@@MellowMelodiesGoaall nations are inter dependent, that doesn't mean Bharat isn't developing. Your comment is really funny & one can know you do not know anything about economics. BTW Bharat has developed an indigneous tank engine after germany's refusal.

Indian politicians need to talk less n work more...too much talking

trust me policy makers dont watch this stupid show😂

What arrogance!

*incredible! superpower! india! TALK, TALK, TALK, TALK, BRAG AND BOAST, BRAG AND BOAST, BRAG AND BOAST, BRAG AND BOAST, TALK, TALK, TALK, TALK BIG SHIITTEEE, BRAG AND BOAST, BRAG AND BOAST, BRAG AND BOAST, BRAG AND BOAST, TALK, TALK, TALK, TALK, TALK BIG SHITTEEE......... AND LIKE TYPICAL incredible! superpower! india! OVER 7 DECADES: DO ABSOLUTE NOTHING.........*

@douglaswong6975

18 күн бұрын

Freedom and democracy, talking but never solve any problem

@vetiarvind

17 күн бұрын

Hello clown. india has grown leaps and bounds to become the 4th largest economy and sent spacecraft to the moon and mars, produces indigenous nuclear facilities, building it's 5th gen fighters and so on.

I fail to understand why bringing such ppl & give their opinion so much importance!!! We have a long way to go & we will make it. We dont have to be yesman to your USA like Mexico is.

This guy is talking nonsense looking down on India. A typical disrespectful westerner.

This is bullshit

This guy clearly don't like India

Sorry ! Mexico is nowhere nearer to India. US and China are not growing as fast as India. One day.....not far away (By 2100) India will be number 1.

@jimmylam9846

15 күн бұрын

UN report: India in 2050 survivability is questionable.......high temperature, depleting water resource, farm and industry bankruptcy..........

Typical European & Company mindset...😂😅😂

1:03 Look at that guy, seems like he wants to eat Ian alive!