His identity has probably been stolen. He should investigate that.

@VientianeSabaidee

Ай бұрын

Probably systematic racism ❤

@the0ne809

Ай бұрын

that doesn't happen with an identity stolen. Someone can use your identity, nobody can change your naturalization status. Also, who in their right mind would change from american born citizen to an undocumented one? LMao

@cpmow831

Ай бұрын

This was my guess too

@mbords01

14 күн бұрын

This is worrisome situation alright; wonder if he could dig out original birth certificate.

This poor guy is going to be dealing with that bureaucracy for years. My heart goes out to him.

I migrated as a child permanent resident , my grandmother was born in america so thru her we migrated ,i was 10 yrs old. By age 19 a dmv employee sold copies of my license to 3 illegal aliens they got into accidents which resulted in my license being suspended. I had warrants everywhere and was arrested several times. By age 21 one of these impostors committed crimes and was arrested and convicted , went before a immigration judge twice as me and was deported as me. Its been years and ive had to provide fot my 2 American sons without credit, welfare or a green card. I didnt ask to come here. I hate what they've done to me and how neglectful this country is.

@ArabellaPottery

Ай бұрын

So you are an illegal. The guy in this story was born here. You should blame your parents.

In the middle of my US Military career one of my soldiers told me of his efforts and obstacles to enlist. He was born to two American citizens stationed in Europe with the US Air Force in an Air Force Hospital. His recruiter insisted he show his Green Card or Naturalization Papers, of which he had neither. It took his parents writing their Congressman to get it straightened out to allow the young American Citizen to enlist in the US Armed Forces.

@elpacho....9254

2 ай бұрын

No such thing as an American citizen. You can’t be a citizen of a continent.

@pauliedweasel

Ай бұрын

At that point I’d just give up trying to enlist just so my ,ice could be squandered in another useless war that will only enrich some congressman’s wealthy military contract donor. You’re not defending the country being in the military, you’re defending the bank accounts of the military industrial complex.

@elpacho....9254

Ай бұрын

@@pauliedweasel that’s keeping it real.

@rancidpitts8243

Ай бұрын

@@pauliedweasel Because of a fire in the Records Center in Missouri in the early 1970's, after 26 years of service I was denied a Retirement as the record office had no record of my enlistment. Why then were they paying and promoting me all those years? I had to resort to contacting my Congressman. They were and always will be Bureaucrats and need to be kicked in the backside to go beyond what they always do everyday. One must think, to do something different.

@franciscody9622

Ай бұрын

Hopefully he does not get killed in one of the US "forever wars" and die for nothing.

When i was about 14 i went on a fishing trip to Oceanside,CA with a bunch of friends. On the way back home we got stopped at a checkpoint in Temecula. They pulled us all out and asked us if we had our green cards with us. I remember thinking whats a green car. Me and all my buddies were born right here in California but just because we were hispanic they assumed we were illegal. The messed up part is they were talking to us in spanish and we all only speak english.

@destinyalberico7789

6 жыл бұрын

That is messed up.. it is such a small world, I live in Temecula and tbh I never liked living here because of racial discrimination as I was treated as Hispanic who also did not speak any English by many people here but I’m Italian and Filipino and I am a native English speaker. I am sorry you had to go through that.

@karenwilson9508

5 жыл бұрын

Alexander Espinoza Lol, can you imagine the look on their faces when they find out you all only speak English. This is crazy and it’s call racial profiling. Welcome to the new America where this is the new normal.

@mrroyixo

5 жыл бұрын

@@karenwilson9508 iam Hispanic I was braugth here as a kid in the early 70s and I was treated very well through the years in an all white school , I have never been discriminated on but again I speak for myself , as a matter of fact my race was so racist against central Americans back in the 80s as far as america today I see on tv some racist people but its always been that way back then there was no fb or social media

@skylamanning2931

5 жыл бұрын

Alexander Espinoza. Thank God you made it back safe

@sharonbartley808

5 жыл бұрын

What did they do then?

I had to call the passport branch of the gov and and tell them what qualified my daughter for her passport. She care here legally and had her stamp on foreign passport and the official said she wasn’t eligible. Then he said I’ll have to look into it and called me back later saying she’s eligible. Dam right a lot of people in government know nothing.

someone just put accidentally that piece of paper in the wrong envelop...

I am a natural born citizen of the U.S.A. and have had problems with my citizenship. In the early seventies I was in the military and they wanted to make me a fighter pilot. When they started to do a background investigation for a top secrete security clearence they stoped because I couldn't prove to them I was a citizen. In ninety one I lost my social security card. When I went to get a replacement they told me I was an alien. I asked them what country I was a citizen of and they didn't know. I brought in all my paperwork and straightened it out. After 911 happened I called the Social Security office to see what they said about my citizenship. This time I was an alien student restricted. That meant I was in this country to go to school and could only have a job on campus. I told them that I hadn't been to school in over thirty years and I had my own business. I brought all my paperwork in again and straightened it out again. I call the Social Security office a couple of times a year just to check, so far so good. I do know this though, if i weren't white I would have been deported.

@321g9

6 жыл бұрын

Thomas Thornhill Wow!!!! I'm so sorry to hear your struggle. I thought only undocumented people had issues. I'm naturalized citizen for 22 yrs, and I'm preparing my defense from now just in case

@tommystyx

6 жыл бұрын

Thanks, but what I have been though has just been small problems. I have the privilege of being white so government officials would help me out. If it wasn't for being white they would have sent me back to where ever the hell they thought I belonged.

@gfdsa2866

6 жыл бұрын

Deported?? to Where? To the State / town of your birth? 😂✌👌😉

@gfdsa2866

6 жыл бұрын

I'm not white. So I'll be deported back to Nebraska?? 😨😨😨😂😂😂😉😉😉

@tommystyx

6 жыл бұрын

"Deported?? to Where? To the State / town of your birth? 😂✌👌😉" You may not have noticed that I said I was a natural born citizen not native born. I was not born in the U.S., so yes they threatened to send me back to where I was born and it wasn't Nebraska.

if this is happening to this person, can't imagine what would happens to the rest of us.

I used to work in a call center for USCIS and I'd get calls about shit like this all the time. The Department of Homeland Security as well as the Department of State are terrible at communicating and updating their information. It doesn't surprise me at all that there are so many who experience this.

@kalijasin

Жыл бұрын

For reals? 😮

@nopenotgonna175

2 ай бұрын

Yup. I suspect the his name or face matched that of someone who is on a no-no list. The Passport adjudicator couldn’t clear the hit without supervisor approval, so they rejected the application just to get it out of their face.

@TheMilpitasguy

2 ай бұрын

5 years ago? The USCIS was on the old IBM mainframe system which ran smoothly. Shortly thereafter, they switched to a newfangled database with bells and whistles that didn't work. Ergo, problems.

@TheAwesomeWeirdo2000

2 ай бұрын

@@TheMilpitasguyYou’re not taking into account the human error. Just because a computer system works smoothly doesn’t mean the people operating it do. From my experience the Immigration Officers were often very rude and did not want to help people. Many of them were racists and I remember some instances of them straight up threatening to deny people’s cases just because they were prejudiced against immigrants.

That guy looks pretty good for being old enough to celebrate 50 years of marriage.

@mushy18100

6 жыл бұрын

Andrew Henderson he got married when he was 10

Insane situation. Poor guy.

@mbords01

2 ай бұрын

Government is powerful; so, I would say this is indeed worrisome. I do hope he is going to be helped and alright because by all signs he is legitimately an American citizen.

well. i went to the SS office and had to have them make 3 different SS cards, each time they kept making the name wrong. i was starting to think i was in a 3rd world country with no education. and all they had to do was copy the name off the passport to get it right. but nooooooooooooo

@bellebellebelle5485

6 жыл бұрын

Jeremy Parsons who says third world countries have less educated people? I assure you that many of us are overqualified and so I find your statement unpleasant and totally out of line. Next time don't use us as a statement in your poor choice of words. Funda.

@anandnairkollam

5 жыл бұрын

What does SS mean. Shutz stafl office? Has trump opened SS offices in the US?

@billsmith981

5 жыл бұрын

They were probably some if the 800,000 non essential federal employees we don't need.

@billsmith981

5 жыл бұрын

You were dealing with government employees...what did you expect? If they were competent they would have a real job.

@atlkidz1

5 жыл бұрын

Anand Nair Social Security but it might as well stand for Shutz stafl 🤦🏾‍♀️

You can leave the US any time, you just can't come back... 😢

This is obviously some sort of administrative screw-up. Hopefully the gentleman had his issue straightened out by now. Good luck to you sir!

@kalijasin

Жыл бұрын

Sounds like racism to me.

I’m a natural born citizen (thank you 14A!) but my parents immigrated here and then naturalized later on. I still keep my documents accessible because you never know when the government will be on some BS.

They like "turn in your green card" him "but I was born here" them "no excuses"

I just got denied a green card yesterday turning my life upside down in the worst of times. 1) we had a solid case & they still asked for information ALREADY sent half a year later! 2) The letter asking for I formation also wanted us to send USCI $1,000 fee for something that didn’t apply to me AT ALL. And to top it off they end it with “should we decide you don’t apply for this penalty, they money will not be refunded” WHAT!?!? 3) we had to reply explaining my case all over and that we didn’t have to send that penalty fee because it doesn’t apply to my case 4) They did not follow protocol of sending a work permit while they decide on the case. So, 10 months after not working I’m in HUGE debt. I used all my credit for food and paying my car and getting my younger brother through Senior year. 5) Now that I’m denied, they get to keep the money from the forms that weren’t even clearly read. I get it, a quick way to save up for the wall perhaps. I’m now in complete financial ruin as well as depressed, it has been the roughest year I’ve ever lived through. Amongst other things related to me waiting on immigration. Absolutely awful. They completely ruined my family. My husband is also destroyed, he been trying so hard for us and it breaks me that all I can do is watch. I wish other honest applicants good luck.

@ibobeko4309

Жыл бұрын

Did you get your passport ?

@WilleyNelson69

8 ай бұрын

@@ibobeko4309can’t get American passport with green card

@exeuropean

2 ай бұрын

Always hire a good and competent immigration lawyer. I did and the process was a breeze.

@exeuropean

2 ай бұрын

@@ibobeko4309 agreen card is not a passport

@meismeLHA

Ай бұрын

Rather than burdening yourself in debts and not working, go back to your country, work there even the wage is at minimum

Get a lawyer and sue them

This is not fake news. It indicates confusion, ignorance and bigotry on the part of some unqualified so-called official. Should we expect this to happen again, and more regularly, in the current atmosphere of fear and prejudice?

@RobertoLopez-li9fc

6 жыл бұрын

AnnaMargolin I am a US-born citizen: I have my birth certificate, SS card, everything. 30 years ago I got my first US passport, not a problem. I renewed it 16 years ago, again not a problem. I tried to renew it again nine months ago, only to be told that I am under investigation by the State Department. A State Department that takes direction from a "man" who believes all Hispanics are rapists and murderers. so there you have it

@wilhard45

6 жыл бұрын

@annamargolin -- well there is bigotry but it is all on your part. The most obvious reason is that someone registered with the same name and possibly the same SSN and birth date. It is called ID theft and is very common. It will take time to straighten it out but it has nothing to do with confusion, ignorance and bigotry. One of the advantages of being a veteran is your fingerprints are on file with the federal government. I also have prints on file from my top secret security clearance investigation, as a volunteer with the 1984 Olympics in Los Angeles, with my employment with various government agencies over the years. I insist on affixing my thumb print to important documents such as loan applications and even credit card applications. No thumb print then it wasn't me. I don't mind taking responsibility for my actions and it would be nearly impossible to steal my ID. I feel for this guy. It is unfortunate that he has to go through this nonsense but blame the person who stole his ID and not some guy working in an office.

@waynerobinson2301

6 жыл бұрын

AnnaMargolin all illegals need to leave and make proper application to be here

@MrMazhar8551

6 жыл бұрын

Hi Donald Johnson, I think your comments regarding this gentleman who needs to hand in his passport reeks of RACISM. I have only one question which if you are true to yourself, and tell me what is your identity? Do you know as a matter of fact anyone who claims to be American must go back in time and pull out your ancestry and you will be shocked to know that you yourself and your ancestors are NOT ethnic Americans. You are all immigrants who came to the Americas from Europe. The true Americans are the natives who you call them Red Indians, and the likes of you have huddled them into reserves. Even Donald Duck oops Trump is an immigrant. BTW, I am from Kenya of Indian ethnicity and enjoy Kenyan Citizenship.

@wilhard45

6 жыл бұрын

Roberto Lopez -- Who said that? If you mean president Trump, then you are a liar. He NEVER said that. He is critical of illegal aliens coming across our borders with violent criminal records. Not the same thing. You know, ese, you need to read what he wrote and said and not be a puppet of the lying liberal media.

someone pressed the wrong button

System failures

@citizenofnowhere7776

6 жыл бұрын

Ma Chatte Incompetence.

@retnavybrat

6 жыл бұрын

Or stolen identity.

@ahigatso2442

6 жыл бұрын

Ma Chatte People failure!

@XellosMetallium

6 жыл бұрын

You sound liberal, uneducate uninform liberal. The Green Card is not valid when you have Citizenship END OF STORY.

@maximefamily6208

6 жыл бұрын

Xellos Metallium so you're green card isn't valid so you have to turn it in and make appointments to not get arrested?

wow its getting more messy now :)

@heronmiah2093

6 жыл бұрын

ars11 you bloody liberals democrats immigrant go fkoff back home shithole where you belong....

@kiminseattle3476

6 жыл бұрын

Heron Miah Are you 100% native American? Otherwise you shutthefkoff and go back to your ancestor's sh#thole country.

@doratiscareno5856

6 жыл бұрын

ars11 ya...because they all look alike lol lol

@rozapavlova4131

6 жыл бұрын

Heron Miah, you are totally right.

@mintbrisk5961

6 жыл бұрын

Heron Miah You go back to your moms house you rejected drop out!

Someone stole his identity guaranteed.

Sounds like someone stole his identity

This same stuff happened to me in Mexico wen I was coming back to the USA " I got pull over by Mexican immigration they told me I was from the country of Chile I was wtf this people talking about I stayed in there office like 2 hours then they released me and i came back to the states thanks God nothing happened to me

Recently, my mother in law was not able to complete her My Social Security account online. We had to go in person to a Social Security office. What was the problem? Their computer code said that she had “permanent resident” status. However, she is a U.S. citizen, born in Minnesota. I joked with her. She could have been deported, but to where? Mexico? She is of Chinese descent.

I would refuse the Immigration Dept... I have been a citizen since over 200 years of lineage in America... Hold the government responsible for violating the 14th Amendment to the Constitution of the United States of America...

I hope he hires a lawyer right away.

he didn't have a green card. the are the one telling him to turn in his green card that he didn't have in the first place he is American

@waynerobinson2301

6 жыл бұрын

patsy graham so he politely brings it to their attention it ain't a federal issue until it is . Maybe they know something of this man you and he dint . Being born here does not confer citizenship on you unless your mother was born here / what do you think natural born citizen means ? Well it has been defined in past laws wait and see .

@robertlee-nq6mg

6 жыл бұрын

Wayne Robinson being born in US is enough to have citizenship...you dumbass

@waynerobinson2301

6 жыл бұрын

robert lee no you are mistaken / if your mother is a united states citizen and you are born here you are " natural born citizen " this is a matter of public record . Read your birth certificate .As far as the law it is all a matter of record and was established many many years ago . Just wait you will see . Circumstances have arose that requires these issues to be clarified and they will be . You are wrong . An illegal ariving here having a child does not make the child legal but compassion has constrained us . The cubans that arrive wet and have a child that child is a citizen because special laws were passed to make it so . But just wait if you were born to illegal citizen i could very well understand your concern . When a American has a child in Mexico are they citizen of Mexico ? Of course not don't be retarded

@Suresh_Kamath

6 жыл бұрын

Wayne Robinson A child born in USA is a US Citizen, even if the parents are illegal .The only exception are children born to diplomats and government officials from foreign countries.

@waynerobinson2301

6 жыл бұрын

Suresh Kamath you are 100% wrong / if this were true every property controlled by United states in other countries would be invaded by pregnant woman cause that would make them u.s. Citicenz . What is more 14th Amendment does not applyto illegal aliens . Do you really think that American laws reward criminal behavior how stupid . Citicenship is determined by public records . Every live birth is registered and is a matter of public record . Read your birth certificate . Whydo you suppose it list citizenshipand birth city of mother ? Oh i know cause it does not matter right . Natural born citizen has to do with your mother not your dad but your mother . If she is a us citizen you are no matter where you are born . Stop arguing against common sense and common laws of America .

Does not surprise me. It took me 25 years to become a citizen all legal. 25!!!!!!!!

someone was using his name and numbers....

@TheDirtflyer

6 жыл бұрын

And do Democrats care? They are the number one cause of Corruption. Millions of illegals getting Tax returns in the thousands,claiming 18 dependants, did IRS,Louis Lerhner put them aside for Auditing? Hell NO. They were intientionally allowed to go through, til Pres. TRUMP put a stop to the Theft, this year..

@samthepoet107

6 жыл бұрын

Oh please stop it. So Trump is the savior on a white horse? It's identity fraud. Nothing to do with political parties. Some even hack companies sites then get the W2 information then file a tax return and have it go to the real person's bank account. Then call them with threats to wire the money to them or they would be imprisoned. The IRS is currently warning about this scam. Not sure why people want to make these incidents political.

@TheDesmo54

6 жыл бұрын

Yep

@rickymac54321

6 жыл бұрын

sirvando vargas Time to deport you Señor Vargas!

@TinoSoto

5 жыл бұрын

@@TheDirtflyer I've known plenty of natural born citizens that do the same thing and get back $10,000 checks from the IRS. In the meantime, I, a naturalized citizen, have to pay more because I make "too much".

What a joke?

had to go to Philly this past weekend and when I tried use my cell phone I got message that international rates would be applied as I was outside the USA.feel for the guy I know how it feels dealing with idiots

Ive gotten pizza mistakenly delivered to my address... it does happen 😂

This shows how immigration snafus happen. He's lucky they didn't order him deported to Ellis Island.

@brianwilson9501

6 жыл бұрын

Kim O'Brien you do realize Ellis island is in America you dumb fuck. So your saying he's lucky he was not deported to America ........

@outdoorsguy

6 жыл бұрын

They'll just deport him to the moon...

@evelynbaitz2732

6 жыл бұрын

Brian Wilson that is his point. He's a US born citizen where are they going to deport him? New York where he's born?

@janebook294

6 жыл бұрын

DO YOU KNOW WHAT "SNAFU" MEANS YOU FUCKING IMBECILE

@2exclusive4u2see

6 жыл бұрын

Ellis Island... really? Are you stupid?

This is the kind of STUPID that happends when you have a quota of workers with different backgrounds to fill position in government agencys even if these people are not qualified

@staceyc8780

5 жыл бұрын

What are you talking about? How does affirmative action tie in to any of this? You need to get your head examined. Sounds like you are missing a couple of bolts and screws

@msgn1132

5 жыл бұрын

@@staceyc8780 hmm, directly. It forces organisations to hire not the most qualified, but the most suitable by imposed quotas. The overall qualification level goes down obviously.

@nocopyright7957

Ай бұрын

​@@staceyc8780sounds like you're a white liberal

@staceyc8780

Ай бұрын

@@nocopyright7957 actually I am a mixed race, black and and Lebanese guy who voted for trump

Must have been an error. A horrible one at that.

You ask the government a question and they say: “I dunno.” Are we surprised ?

If he's a US citizen why does he need greencard.

@maxalberts2003

Ай бұрын

I think you should go back to elementary school and start over.

wtf? i had to give up my green card to become a citizen 20 yrs ago.duh! isn't giving up your green card for naturalized citizenship an upgrade? this sounds weird to me

@roys8870

7 жыл бұрын

Maybe he got a fake birth certificate? Weird reaction indeed for somebody who knows only one country since birth.

@teatime1858

7 жыл бұрын

jamarican gurl wow you just called giving up your own citizenship and passport of your country to carry one with the name of a place that is NOT your country an upgrade. I guess everyone wants to be an American. I suppose I'm lucky. 2nd, he doesn't have a green card to turn in because he was BORN in the United States. So explain to me who's ass will he pull out a green card he's never had?

@simpliciticbeauty1824

7 жыл бұрын

Exactly

@kimobrien.

7 жыл бұрын

I never had a green card either but my passport says I was born in Massachusetts. One problem though is I was not legally competent at birth.

@DCFunBud

7 жыл бұрын

Or now.

Awful treatment

This is horrible I’m a Native American USA 🇺🇸 born citizen but I also have a Central American Passport and Colombian Passport I have triple citizenship I’m a investor and a entrepreneur and invest outside the USA 🇺🇸 so I needed to become citizen in these other countries and as for now I just renew my passport and no problem hope it stays that way

sound like someone has used his info that how this comes up

@amanecer7778

6 жыл бұрын

fastone942 my thought exactly.

@Amv1992

6 жыл бұрын

Amanecer 777 to apply or renew a passport does not require a Social Security number. That’s two different federal administration agencies (department of state- immigration and renewed and the social security department is its own department) don’t use the same information nor share information with one another. It’s more like the State department is over worked and needs a get their shit together.

It's called a man trying to run away from a vacation after 50 years of marriage

"Nearly a 30 mile drive" WAAA! Poor baby. I used to drive almost 40 miles a day to go from home to my high school.

Wait she said "50th wedding anniversary"! I thought this man was in his late 40s to early 50s. Dude does have a wrinkle to be spoken of!😯

Pause at 0:22 and you'll see the letter is not addressed to him directly. Instead of freaking out and causing drama, realize that it's not addressed to him. That usually means that it was most likely put into the same envelope as his passport BY ACCIDENT. In that case you ignore it. As for CBSDFW, that was terrible reporting because it lead to believe everything people said in the comment section. It causes unnecessary anxiety and hatred towards the government. Clerical errors like this one happen in large organizations, including the government 🤦🏼‍♀️🤷🏼‍♀️ Next time mention that it wasn't specifically addressed to him so that people can come to proper conclusions and not BS conclusions based on lack of vital information.

How is this newsworthy??? Let the race and flamebaiting continue..

Ignore it. Where they going to send this man back to?

just curious if he was born here where is the birth certificate , wouldn’t the problem be solve as soon as you show them the birth certificate

Even if you are naturalized US Citizen you you have to return the green card if you don't they don't let you enter to the ceremony

@rosie2818

6 жыл бұрын

Janet Rojas watch the news again.

@TheGogetassj

6 жыл бұрын

You’re special kind of stupid. He’s a born citizen. There is no naturalization

@blessedchild4941

6 жыл бұрын

I think you missed her point. She is saying that even if he was naturalized, he would have had to return his green card before he got his previous passports. So this all made no sense!

@alexsimpson2247

6 жыл бұрын

He was naturalized through birth he never needed or had a green card

@rickymac54321

6 жыл бұрын

Alex Simpson Not naturalized but was a citizen at birth.

BORN IN THE USA AND HE HAD A GREEN CARD ??

You can tell he's a citizen by that horrible Brooklyn accent. Gees! Hard to listen to. Thank God this was so short.

That being said, this is actually a 'non-issue' for the Person involved here. He still got his Citizenship and he already got his Passport. Only on how he got his Passport puzzled him and he's affraid that the system might incorrectly identified him as a Foreign Born instead of being born inside the USA; that could lead to possible future problems. Remember, the Department of State only asked him to return his non-existing Permanent Resident Card. All he really need is for the Department of State to declare he does NOT need to return his Permanent Resident Card, because he never got one or even need one. He also might need the Department of State to declare that he was born in the USA, therefore not needing any Permanent Resident Card. Now on how this issue could arise, maybe be on how the previous Passport applications were handled, possible being 2006~2007, or 1996~1997, or even 1986~1987, but not really 1976~1977 because the immigration laws back then were quite different. Either that, there is a glitch in the printing system that caused the system to think he has a Permanent Resident Card. The printing system doesn't need to know that all of the stuff it printed conflicted with the data in the system. All it needs to know is that, 'print this, and this, and this'. Now on why the office didn't just say it was a printing error, well… Remember, even all of the offices involved said that it's impossible for them to help him, because they do NOT have the data that said he has a Permanent Resident Card. So who said he has a Permanent Resident Card? Easy, the letter did.

US citizen and American citizen are two different things immigration can be us us citizens .....Americans are the copper color races

@exth2294

7 жыл бұрын

ALL U.S. citizens are U.S. nationals, but not all U.S. nationals are U.S. citizens

@JakeMissy-cr4oj

6 жыл бұрын

Xavier Knox WHAT??????

@ceejamm3180

6 жыл бұрын

Huh?

@adbc1f72

6 жыл бұрын

Xavier Knox Yep 1828 Webster’s dictionary 3rd edition.

@boragamerz9145

6 жыл бұрын

idiots vs idiots.... 🍿🍿🍿

50th wedding anniversary? Wow. I thought he was in his 50s just looking at him. He's aged well.

--- It's 2024. Any update on this issue?

Someone stole his identity and ended up getting a green card with a fake id.

He should be glad the country is taking such measures to protect all legal citizens

MY DAD WHAS TOLD HE WHAS DECEASED 5 YEARS AGO, WITH ALL DOCUMENTS SUBMITED THEY STILL BELIVE HE IS DEAD. THATS BUROCRASY FOR YOU.

Whenever I'm faced with such bureaucratic bullsh.. I take it to one of my elected representatives, e.g. U.S. Congressman, U.S. Senator, state assembly member, county supervisor, or even my auto club contact. You can find b.s. and incompetence anywhere in public or private organizations. We all have representatives who are allegedly working on our behalf and we rarely use their help. Hell, most people don't even know the names of their various representatives.

If I were this guy I would get hold of my birth certificate and have it with me if I visited the immigration office.

They know you are powerless to do anything without paying extortion fees.

You must look as you sound,thats why the confusion,a man his age should have known the consequences.

Only thing worse than a New Yorker is someone from New Jersey...

Government bureaucracy at work.

he should have just ignored it as he is a US citizen.

If I receive a letter that states that I must relinquish my Green Card, I would call the number that I find on the letter and let them know that they made a big mistake. I would even go so far as to have them send someone to my house and show them the paperwork that states that I was born here in Brooklyn, NY.

Fudge, a first world nation doesn't have proper records of its citizenry?

Why they keep doing that to black people who was born in this country.

I am Native American and legally how can Europeans come into our country and state laws? I native and most people call me a Mexican. what court would rule in our favor?

Congratulations on your 50th wedding anniversary!!

Outrageous!!

So, they got the wrong person. So what?

I not only believe him but have seen this happen in many forms! A friend born in New York with a African mother and Irish Caucasian father appears Hispanic! We live in California and this is the early 90s! She was walking minding her own business when Border A**hole and asked her was she a citizen and even after stating yes born in New York they still tried to deport her! We got a call from her crying begging us to get there fast! Her husband got there just as they were supposed to be sending her to Mexico! Since she looks Hispanic she has been subjected to so many prejudices and stereotypes! She married a Caucasian man and their children looked Caucasian but when she would be doing her daily errands with them in the stroller countless times people asked to hire her to watch their children along hers because they assumed her to be the nanny! She would go to nursery school to get her oldest and it never failed that new staff refused to give her her son! They immediately tried to direct her to any child of Hispanic origins! She was even told repeatedly that inspire of being a citizen she needed to carry her immigration documents to be able to conduct business from enrolling her kids in school, trying to rent an apartment, getting WIC and these micro aggressions aren’t just a one off! Sadly the political environment is so xenophobic that now I am scared for her living in California fearing next time Immigration will deport her overseas before anyone can help her!

What is he doing with a Green card if he was born in the State's? that's what I want to know what State is charging Citizens for a Green Card

If he is a us citizen, why does he need a green card?

Somebody forged his ID

Do not leave the US for any reason...you might not be able to get back in!

Of course they can never provide additional information. It's always so convenient for them...

Sounds like a mix up honestly. He clearly is an American and always was and has never had a green card. It should be an easy issue to resolve.

Whats wrong with taking away a green card after you are already a citizen?? Not sure what the big deal is.

Comply or we will deport you to... New York? Uhm. Oops.

How come there is no date this letter was mailed by the office.

Years ago I gave up my green card to become a citizen. I was told if I don't have one I will have to get one.

Born here, Where's your birth certificate?

@blafonovision4342

Ай бұрын

Not everybody has a birth certificate. Out here in Midwest, many people still born at home.

I have had a Green Card for a VERY long time and have applied for Citizenship last June, Paid,was fingerprinted and given the booklet to study ....am waiting now to be contacted ..will call them to follow up soon .Been a EMPLOYED TAXPAYER since 1982 !! Never got a damn thing for free !! I am too scared to fly anyway @ worried to leave the country ...cause some weird stuff might happen !! I think that is Outrageous !! Seriously Outrageous !!

He can't leave the US til he gets a valid passport.

Well he might want to have it checked into because they are finding our that people are having their social security number and other information stolen. It's possible someone could have used his information. I have a friend that found out that her information was used.

Wait-- he's a citizen.. why would he have a green card in the first place? Doesn't make sense.

Here comes America watch out!

i can see why they are questioning it!!! do you?

Somebody probably used the wrong form or checked the wrong block in the system. Much ado about nothing.

BUILT THAT WALL!!!!!

Some illegal immigrant used his SSN and name for ID theft to get a green card.

One day someone told me that he feels that no one I mean no one in America own anything. Weird huh. Yeah that right we don’t own nothing. You think you own your car well stop paying monthly statements and see what will happen. Or be behind a couple of parking tickets and see what will happen. You think you own your house you must be kidding, them miss a couple of months of mortgage and see what will happen. Try to be behind of not paying your taxes oh yah baby. You don’t even own your driver license after 12 points or if you didn’t pay your spending tickets. That right you don’t own your citizenship even though you’re born here. I feel sorry for this guy abd for the Floridian guy who served this country and they denied him for his citizenship and his pension after he turned 65 years old and he been paying taxes all his life

In spain you got your finger prints taken and saved in a database linked to an id number. You get a birth certificate when you are born or even as a foreigner when you get Spanish citizenship (the place of birth { the country you were born is shown in that Spanish document though } ) So either way by birth or by naturalization you get both birth certificate and id card number. You are obliged by law to carry your ID with you out of your house ( even if you are just taking out the rubbish round the corner ) You can't id yourself with your driving license. So the amount of checks and controls are to the extend that something like being an alien is next to impossible 😂 I thought it was bad but after watching this video I'm now convinced that the Spanish way of registering people are actually not bad at all 😊

Reminds me of Winds of War (on youtube) where Natalie, US citizen,Jewish about 1940, needs flight from Switz on Lufhansa to I think, Lisbon & safety. A routine airline form asks for religion, and when she inquires why, gets a horrible (OH-I see) smile from otherwise nice German ticket agent. Natalie (Ali McGraw) runs away in horror.

disregard the letter!