this was probably a student project. just like how novice painter copies other masterpiece while practicing, filmmakers do the same. He probably didn't think this would get that much attention.

Why bother with a remake? The original was fine!

@ADSuri

7 жыл бұрын

hackberry flat That's what Hollywood's been hearing for the past 10 years!

@Poottisman

7 жыл бұрын

Because the lazy cunts can't come up with something original besides jacking of already used ideas. Ghost Busters Remake! Jurassic World! -They say it's using plot of Jurassic park but that's just a little excuse. Doctor WHo! Each generation is just a remake.

@hectic7043

7 жыл бұрын

Original recipe

@theunitsquad3144

7 жыл бұрын

hackberry flat eh I think this was more of a joke making fun of the original

@nomadpi1

7 жыл бұрын

You think the remake was intended as a spoof? I didn't. The remake didn't cover (rebut) the points of the original. But we're both being subjective. The "original, I saw, was actually a short film posted to Atom Films prior to that organization being absorbed by THE BLOB.

1:53 he cutted the paper when he got his hand into the black door to make it look like he perforates the black triangle as you can see the difference between the solid black of the triangle and the plain black of the door :) .. #epicfail

@abdur6703

7 жыл бұрын

IKR this is st5upid

i think he likes apples

Why is everyone saying that this is such a bad video because it was "ripped off"? Like, it says right in the title that it was a remake, so what's the big deal? Yeah, the original was really good, but I also love this one. I think it was very creative that they used an existing idea and put their own twist on it. It made me laugh when he went to the safe expecting money but got half eaten apples instead! Awesome work!

@Prasen1729

3 жыл бұрын

It is a bad video in the sense, in what world would you be having so many bitten apples ? :-) and black holes are not triangular.

@Alt3R

3 жыл бұрын

@@Prasen1729 I left this comment over 3 years ago, I forgot it was even here. But as a quick reply, it's their video so they can use money, apples, or whatever they want. Same with the shape of the black hole, it literally doesn't matter. I just don't see how apples and a triangle would make the whole video bad, it's complete creative freedom to the creators.

@Prasen1729

3 жыл бұрын

@@Alt3R I don't say bad. I dont call it creative. They just copied it from another video, making sole changes. That's it. So no creativity. Those changes do not make sense, that's why ridiculuous. You know i dont check how old the comments are, it apperaed at the top, i replied. :-)

@dankazmarek1259

3 жыл бұрын

@@Prasen1729 Your viewpoint has some points, but nonetheless so has the opposite frontier. There are some subtle differences in the bunch of expressions and the synchronization. The eaten apples may also be symbolic and so can be the omission of the scene of vending machine. It is nonethless good to comment like this. It brings out a heck of discussion eventually. Is not it?

In my opinion, that apple indicates that many people entered the safe and were trapped in this way.

I can't wait for the upcoming reboot of the reboot, "The Black Trapezoid"

Had me knowing everything yet on the edge of the seat

what defines how deep the apple goes inside the machine? There's the cover then the glass, the drums, motors, paper trays 1st, 2nd etc.

All of you criticizing these guys for making this short are clearly not part of the film world and should not be making terrible comments like these. The point isnt to copy what someone else has done, its to find something they enjoyed and to make something of their own. So to any of you writing these comments here: go make a movie. Go make something to call your own. And then you can make these statements

if you put an apple into the hole, you will find 1.000.000 apples if you put one dollar, you will find ....1.000.000 dollars

Possible the triangle will copy anything that went through it, or maybe it would only copy the first thing that passes through it - so he blew an opportunity. I don't think it works as well as the original, would the going through to open the locked door still work under these revised changes to the portal?

Very nice !!!

I like it's variety

Bwahahaha I like the parody, great job :)

I watched the first one and then watched this remake - - hilarious!!

LOL~ very funny

@puwhppi

3 жыл бұрын

Lol

@negansmith5875

3 жыл бұрын

I was 2 when u commented this

@purekringe5789

3 жыл бұрын

@@negansmith5875 that’s crazy

my thoughts exactly

why does someone keep apples locked in a safe what is it a magic apple

I'm just thinking about how all of the people who made this had to take a bite out of every single one of those apples

DO YOU HAVE A TUTORIAL ON THIS???

Wtf why would any one put a bited apple in a company locker?

Kāpēc...

very good acting

@user-pk7by2gn5q

7 жыл бұрын

where?

Nice take on an original 👌

This is hilarious, how does it have so many dislikes?!

How do you fit in there

This is not even a hole ,it is a triangle 😂

@SmashItBashIt

Жыл бұрын

innstead of the black hole it should be the black triangle

i can see the effects XP

Little Girl Lost - Twilight Zone (from 976-CREOLEMAN)?

Great short film. This is actually better quality than the original. Glad to see it made.

واووو

It is an "okay" homage to the Original.

lol who has a safe full of apples lmao

@quantumbits

7 жыл бұрын

You only get out what you put into a black hole.

@dirtiestharry6551

6 жыл бұрын

watch movie more carefully

@chronicdonut7946

5 жыл бұрын

@@quantumbits But then the guy from the original would be getting plastic cups from the safe.

@successflowstome

4 жыл бұрын

@@chronicdonut7946 slow coach, that exactly is the twist in this remake. Phew!

👏👏👏

there is a shinigami inside

So he could have copied money with this black hole in the shape of a triangle?

Solves world hunger

it should be called the black triangle

the apple from Apple, the apple from Eva....and so on......

The other one was better. There is an obvious hole in the paper were he puts his hand through in this one. The editing in the last one was a lot better. Also this one didn't make a lot of sense. Apples in a safe? Really?

it's triangle! Illuminati confirmed!

@harkyreagan1089

3 жыл бұрын

You deserve thousand like

Movie name keya hai koi bataye ga

The original sin. The Apple. Greed is too an original sin. So I think. Greed is what leads to the trap.

original was fine but since it can duplicate he should have tried put some other thing in and experiment

It copies what is thrown in the paper. Shouldve just thrown 100 inside and get 200 k on 4 minutes

good

Movie??

Parody?

This time, The paper is an Illuminati :) :)

very nice :-) tutorial please.

@Chinomoreno_007

7 жыл бұрын

fuck you you fucking fuck. bela merda...chupamos

@mannysea5120

6 жыл бұрын

Loser lol

this takes the wild e coyote premise to a whole new level. the 1st black hole was better. either way pretty bad ass....

did u see the black traingole get bigger??

@bourbonfan1

7 жыл бұрын

anyone see a black pumping unit?

This is thuggg

Holy shit it's the illuminati!!!!!!

Only for 🍎 apple

Why did you feel the need to remake it?

apples?

Lol he should of dropped a $100 bill in there

Hole-mOLE

"viensmakarons" :D :D :D

nice! bet lidzigs sizhets jau ir redzets

Actor without Oscar

Y por qué no metió un billete?

If it multiplies then drop some money

Hi

What are u doing the other one was fine

He can put one dollar or 5 dollar than takr it many time

IS REAL?!

Super try Good.

lol apple

Black hole is shape in triangle😅

To be honest I've seen a lot of remakes but this is the best that I've seen

illuminati at it

:)

🤔🤔🤔

comenzó mal el remake, no debió haber tirano la manzana, se supone que no sabe que el papel tiene un black hole, malo malo.

So the circle turned into triangle now huh?

@jimgerardgonzalez2620

7 жыл бұрын

LovePsychos This Time, Illuminati made the Paper :) :)

this remake makes absolutely zero sense

@johnseraphim8427

4 жыл бұрын

no it was about Adam and Eve Apple eating and Illuminati

Why remake that film instead of create a new idea?

@Luka1180

7 жыл бұрын

Because remaking scenes are actually an encouraged practise when learning your craft as a filmmaker. No joke. It's not for everyone, but some people use it to find their very own style, their unique visual finger-print. They try different stuff. Plus, remaking things can be a good way to analyze something, though analyzing the original in the regular good ol' film analyzing way may be better. But it can show someone how different things were achieved behind the camera. Ultimately it is his choice. I know this film isn't that good, but people saying it's just dumb of him to remake The Black Hole isn't seeing a possible bigger picture here. I am not saying that you're saying it is dumb, because you are clearly not, but a lot of people are. And yeah, I know your comment is pretty old by now, but I just had to get this off my chest... Bottom line: Recreating things can be a very good way of honing your own craft, hence why artists trace other people's works, or redraw it without just tracing. It's a valid practise technique in different arts.

This is V2! I love it! ❤️

still can make millions by selling apple juice

is everyone just stupid? ithe hole duplicates what you put in it ?-?

@cmh6690

6 ай бұрын

Il me semble qu'il ne duplique pas ; il multiplie.

Sorry, but the idea on this one is o.k. but misses the mark. Too close to the original. Triangle instead of a circle, apples instead of cash, into the safe and paper falls off. I was hoping they would go in a different direction altogether.

illuminati confirmed

This is true are fake but block hole very deep power full force

That doesn't even look like the safe

come with something new

Lol :p

Baaaaaad

I want have it I want toach on my heart.

lol

Let's say black triangle 🤣

What's the use of remaking original..

wtf

Hggg

Your copy

Bad acting.....

@Poottisman

7 жыл бұрын

lameWB That's the first thing people try to use against you when they are not mature enough to move on. GRAMMAR

@Poottisman

7 жыл бұрын

lameWB and techniquelly i never spelled anything wrong. When you type fast you forget words. It's just the little 8 year olds like you trying to make it look like a world war shame to try and get their point

@Poottisman

7 жыл бұрын

lameWB just keep correcting me. The more you do it, the more you point out that you're just another kid not knowing any better.

@Poottisman

7 жыл бұрын

lameWB. And now he's blaming me, if you're any better then just move on. Also you're the one finding it damn important to fix some stranger's grammar in order to gain selfsatisfaction and then i'm being the bitch about the whole thing? You are just one hell of a person aren't you?

@mreueujj1

7 жыл бұрын

ToPaLeY *I'm.... With a capital i.

Copies future short

Copy