Thank you so much for your help in trying to play this marvelous etude. It is Sooooo Nice of you to take time explaining ! Thank you🙏🙏🙏

One of the best lessons i have seen. Thank you so much

Thank you! As usual, your tutorials are a treasure for all who play those pieces. I really apreciate the valuable work you do for us!

I had done this piece years ago when I was very young but I stopped playing for a long time after that. Recent I have started practicing all my old pieces again and this is one of them. Your tutorial is so helpful to me. Thank you so much. If you were living here in the US, I would moved heaven and earth to take some lessons from you.

Brilliant! Thanks Greg for such a detailed strategy. Taking notes. I first played this a couple of years ago, it was my first Etude and couldn't get it. I'm going to rework it using your suggestions methodically. Thank you for your generosity. ⭐⭐⭐

God bless you mr niemkzuc I found your page just few days ago but I've learnt so many things from you already thank you very much❤️

Thank you so much sir!🙏🏻🌸

Thank you so much. ❤

Great video! This is helping immensely! I've been playing for a long while, but I plateaued years ago, coupled with life events that didn't allow me to practice for years, as well as some teachers whose behavior towards me made me not want to pursue my music degree. And it's only recently that I found my childhood passion for music again. I recently finished Chopin's op 64 no 2 in C# minor. And it feels great to finish a piece after such a long time. Thank you!

Thank you so much for your tips on this etude. 🎵

This is very helpful. Thank you so much.

Truly a magnificent teaching! Thank you so much.

@gregniemczuk

10 ай бұрын

Thank you so much!

Wow, what a great tutorial about this beautiful etude. 🤩 Thank you very much Greg! 🙏 I am going to rewatch this video many times 👍.

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Prinzo!

ありがとうございます。感謝です。❤❤❤

I love how you keep teaching engaging. Makes me really happy to see such enthusiasm. 😊😊

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

Happy to see that! I think it's very important

congratulations on closing your so generous project for all the hobby pianists over the world! thank you thousand and million times for this magnificent contribution! lovely greetings from berlin

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

Thank you!!! There is still op.25 to do 😊

Great useful info - thanks

Świetne wytłumaczenie, bardzo mi pomogło ponieważ właśnie zaczynam uczyć się tej etiudy 🙏🎹

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

Cieszę się!

FANTASTIC! THE BEST EXPLANATION OF PIANO TECHNIQUE ON KZread I'VE EVER SEEN THANK YOU!!!

@gregniemczuk

18 күн бұрын

Thanks!

Can't wait for Op25. Thank you, Greg!!!

Thank you so much for sharing! I see some hope now, in learning to play this wonderful epic Chopin piece. You're an awesome teacher ! : )

@gregniemczuk

7 ай бұрын

Thanks!

It was my first Chopin etude, almost 10 more years ago... and now I'm on a journey to master all Chopin etude. It's really helpful, thanks.

@gregniemczuk

3 ай бұрын

Wonderful! Good luck with that!

Thank you so much, sir. This is very helpful!

@gregniemczuk

4 ай бұрын

Happy to hear that!

Hi Greg! I hope everything is fine after Norway's tour. Happy to see you back on KZread. Greetings!

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

Yes it is! I’m just very busy with many things but I will start to upload the new content again!

thanks, I'm trying to study this beautiful piece...

Wow, such an incredible Video, thanks for your thoughts on this amazing Piece. I always thought it was a missed opportunity that this isent the polish national anthem.

Hi Greg, I am revisiting this etude after years away to raise kids and teach. Your video has given me a fresh vision of how I will play this at this later point in my life. Thank you so much for taking the time to give us your practice techniques. You’ve given me some new ideas on how to approach this since I know it already. I’m so excited to rework this piece with the soul of a Nocturne. ❤

@gregniemczuk

5 ай бұрын

I'm happy to read this comment. Thank you!

The best video of this Etude

@gregniemczuk

Ай бұрын

Thanks Marco!

This is a very good tutorial. I see two minutes a day, and just practice all the good exercises.

@gregniemczuk

2 ай бұрын

Great! Thanks!

Your teaching is very good, you explained it very clearly. I could now able to learn it more confidently. I wish you all the best in 2024.

@gregniemczuk

6 ай бұрын

Happy New Year to you too!

Me parece una forma de estudiar profunda. Asi quedará precioso. Soy pianista jubilado y estoy enseñando éste estudio a mi nieto. Felicidades por cómo lo haces. Desde ahora mismo vamos a estudiar con tu video. Gracias muchísimas gracias.

@gregniemczuk

7 ай бұрын

Gracias por su comentario!

I look forward to the lesson the Ocean Etude Op 25, No 12? Thank you for all you do.

Thank you so much Greg for your valuable time and energy in creating this tutorial. There were some wonderful moments and quotes from you throughout, including when you played mechanically and said “It’s not music, It’s not Chopin. It’s simply ugly!”. I started to play this piece a very long time ago and gave up as I couldn’t get close to the speed nor did I manage to get past the first page. I was never taught how to tackle this piece, however I am going to approach this piece again as you have suggested by first mastering the left hand and memorising it, which I know will be a challenge for me personally. Thank you once again.

@gregniemczuk

11 ай бұрын

Good luck!! I hope you can make it!

@sheetalpatel6286

11 ай бұрын

@@gregniemczuk thank you ! I just finished practising my first 4 bars - still needs a bit of work. I may get there in 4-6 months time 😀

Very interesting. My teacher wants me to study this etude to practise my left hand. I have already studied berceuse but this etude seems to me more difficult to play than berceuse. My teachers told me the contrary , in her opinion berceuse is difficult a little bit more. I hope she is right!

Лайк не глядя!

happy to see you back, was missing you alot ^_^. I love short practice units alot as well. But most of the students DO NOT do it, so sad -_-

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

Yesz they do not! It's a pity. But we must keep encouraging them! Thank you for your words. I've been tired after Norwegian tour and bisy with teaching and my University. I will try to upload more content again!

@Hanna-vq6in

Жыл бұрын

Ja das dachte ich, dass es eine anstrengende Tour war durch Norwegen. Ich habe mich an sämtlichen Video‘s, ganz besonders an Ihrem wundervollen Klavierspiel, sehr gefreut. Liebe Grüsse und ganz herzlichen Dank für all Ihre Arbeit. Hanna

Wowww super help. for next video, can you please focus the so we can see wich finger you play every note with? Thanks!

@gregniemczuk

11 ай бұрын

Hmmm ..... I'm mostly using those written in my edition (Ekier) but not always. I'm not sure if I'll be making another video about this etude. I have so many other projects waiting!

useful!!!!!!

@gregniemczuk

Ай бұрын

Thanks!

This is the best Revolutionary tutorial that has ever been created..... Thx so much.

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

Thank you!!!!

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

I was a bit afraid that it's too long....

@rothschildianum

Жыл бұрын

@@gregniemczuk No, it is very important to show how to practice left hand part by part. There is another pianist on KZread who does similar approaches but he has not done Revolutionary etude.

@rothschildianum

Жыл бұрын

@@gregniemczuk I have never had a teacher who shows me like what showed in this video. All my teachers just expect me to know how to practice. It is very unreasonable. Ten years ago, I brought this etude to my teacher, he said impossible for me to do. He is a concert pianist, but has no teaching skills. He is just good in playing. That is why he cannot produce good students. After I quit from him, I found a good teacher. I started entering amateur piano competitions, my former teacher was speechless when I told him that I was able to advance to several finals.

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

@@rothschildianum bravo!!! Yes, I also not always had good teachers unfortunately.... that's why now it's my mission to help on the internet everyone who are searching this help!

Panie Grzegorzu. Z racji tego, że jest pan doświadczonym i wybitnym pianistą, chciałbym podsunąć pomysł na nowy film. Myślę, że bardzo dużo osób chciałoby zobaczyć porady dotyczące nauki dowolnego utworu. Chodzi mi o poradnik gdzie pokaże pan swoje sposoby jak nauczyć się utworu od zera, w jak najszybszy sposób (nie chodzi o konkretny utwór). Swoją drogą ten film jest bardzo ciekawy i pomocny, pozdrawiam :)

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

Dzień dobry. Dziękuję bardzo!! Dobrze, chętnie zrobię coś takiego. Raczej w języku angielskim, gdyż jest to bardziej międzynarodowe. Na dwa takie firmy raczej nie będę miał energii i czasu. Serdecznie pozdrawiam

@Spigll

Жыл бұрын

@@gregniemczuk oczywiście rozumiem, szukałem wszędzie takiego filmu i naprawdę ciężko jest znaleźć. Jeszcze raz serdecznie pozdrawiam, uwielbiam pańskie filmy 😊

❤️❤️❤️

Greg, would you say that the tips you were telling us for the Revolutionary étude, learning LH alone (hands apart), memorized and up to tempo before hands together…do you think that applies to 10/3 and 10/4 as well? Thank you!

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

Yes Micki!

Very interesting. It is very encouraging, inspiring even, to see how hard you work on your pieces. Are there any specific Hanon exercises you would suggest, and do you stick to the same fingering in C♯ for those exercises? BTW is F♯ an alternative Hanon key to C♯ (as there is more variety of stretches between black and white notes), or is it just unnecessarily awkward?

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

Yes, definitely the same fingering!

A valuable tutorial Greg. Your comments remind me much of my teacher. It’s so important to practice in the patterns. This Etude must be played precise. There’s no room for stodginess. May I request some information as to how your recommend to pedal this Etude? It is often over pedaled and blurry.

@gregniemczuk

10 ай бұрын

Yea.....well, it all depends on the room in which you play and on the piano itself ... pedal with your ears, not with your feet

@michaelsmith697

10 ай бұрын

@@gregniemczuk makes sense!

więc jest nadzieja!! To jednak jest dla ludzi i można to ćwiczyć?! A ja myślałam, że to tylko kosmici mogą grać, bo przecież to wykracza poza zdolności zwykłych śmiertelników... to tempo....... Zaczęłam grać tą etiudę jakiś tydzień temu. Znaczy tak wewnętrzne, w marzeniach to grałam ją juž dużo wcześniej, ale nigdy wcześniej nie przypuszczałam że się w końcu odważę i naprawdę usiądę do tego utworu, że zacznę. I stało się. No i zaraz to "czy kiedykolwiek zbliżę się chociaż na odległość wzroku do tego jakie to powinno być..?🥴". I obejrzałam ten film.. zatem jest nadzieja!!! Jest pomysł co z tym robić, jest nadzieja!!! Nie taka bardzo bliska, no nie bedzie to na wyciagniecie ręki. Ale jednak!! 😀😀😀😌

@gregniemczuk

6 ай бұрын

Brawo!!! Wierzę!!! Uda się!!!!!

Do you suggest to do the grouping excercise with metronome?

@gregniemczuk

11 ай бұрын

You can do it, changing tempos every few minutes

Groups that you train separately. Is it good to change these groups? I mean other tones in the group. Another three or another four tones?

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

Yes, you can do it of course

I'm an organist trying to understand piano thought...do you practice scales in the same way in groups??? Thanks in advance!!!

@gregniemczuk

4 ай бұрын

Yes!

Bardzo uzyteczny instruktaż !!! Mialbym pare zapytań: - Jak ma sie rzeczywistosc do podanego tempa - 160/cwiercnute ?? osobiscie maltretowalem etiudke pare razy w zyciu, 130 sama lewa dla mnie to juz slizgawka :D - Podaje Pan rozne propozycje cwiczenia. Chcac rzetelnie przecwiczyc po fragmenciuku zajmie to duzo czasu. Wiec ile powtorzen danym sposobem fragmentu spelnia juz zadanie ? 5, 12, .. 30 ?? ile czasu dziennie optymalnie cwiczy sie taka etiude ? Dzieki i pozdrawiam

@gregniemczuk

11 ай бұрын

Dzień dobry. To wszystko są bardzo indywidualne kwestie. Tempo Chopina jest moim zdaniem tempem, które być może on sobie sam śpiewał w głowie gdy miał zanotować puls metronomiczne, ale ono nie działa akustycznie podczas występów. Ta etiuda jest jak drzewo podczas burzy, tempo chwieje się co chwilę. Proszę nie grać jej z metronome NIGDY. Ilość powtórzeń zależy od stopnia zaawansowania. Generalnie polecam przeznaczać na etiudę ilość czasu, jaka jest możliwa, robić minimum 50 powtórzeń (sto jest idealnie). Zajmuje to trochę czasu ale nie trzeba podczas jednej sesji ćwiczeniowej pograć całej etiudy. Poćwiczenie dokładne jednej strony przez godzinę da dużo więcej! Serdecznie pozdrawiam

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Takie pytanie. Takt 25, lewa ręka, pierwsza czwórka - zaskoczyło mnie całkiem (żeby nie powiedzieć że wręcz zszokowało), że tam na drugiej nucie B ma być niejako 3ci palec! I patrzę w nuty, kurczę, tam też napisane 3 pod tym B. W życiu bym na to nie wpadła. Czy mogę to B (druga nuta z czwórki )zagrać po prostu 1szym? Wydaje się to być wtedy proste i intuicyjne. Potem dalej jak leci, mogą być te palce które tam zasugerowane lub już cały czas 3ci, który może się tego klawisza trzymać. Ale czemu miało by służyć takie skomplikowanie i wykręcanie, że po piątym palcu na pierwszej nucie gramy 3cim kiedy 1szy jest pod ręką i dalej wszystko pasuje. ? Zastanawia mnie to bardzo 🤔🤔🤔🤔

@gregniemczuk

6 ай бұрын

Ja tam gram 2 palcem na B. Trzeci jest bez sensu!!! 1 palec też może być. Generalnie palcowanie napisane w nutach nie jest obowiązkowe. Każda reka jest inna i musimy sami dostosowywać palcowanie pod siebie. Więc POPIERAM swoją własną inwencję! Pozdrawiam serdecznie

@anetapaszek5808

6 ай бұрын

@@gregniemczuk 😃😃😃😃 super, no to już mogę pracować dalej, no tak mi to nie dawało spokoju! 👍👍👍🙂

W poniedziałek gram to na dyplomie bo to jedna z niewielu które sie da na szybko ogarnac ;D

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

Powodzenia! Dobry, bezpieczny wybór

Could you write here what edition has your fingering indicated in it? Is there one?

@gregniemczuk

9 күн бұрын

Jan Ekier National Polish edition

After how many years of learning do you recommend to start with this etude?

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

It's hard to say, at what age did you start? Everyone is individual and different so it's really hard to say......

@syvina4309

Жыл бұрын

@@gregniemczukI know It is complicated. I started at 9 (learned 5years). Then 3 years as adult when I was around 22. Then there was a big pause many years as I did not have piano. After 16 years I started again, I had tried to learn myself 2 years. Now I am learning 1 year with teacher. I am willing to play to the end of my life.

I think practicing ONLY the left hand in your session can be frustrating. I think the one needs to mix in something like 1/2 proportion. 20 mins left hand, 10 mins right, repeat. Very good tutorial in general though.

@gregniemczuk

Жыл бұрын

Thanks! Yes , of course it can be frustrating. But when you see the results that you feel satisfaction. Thanks for the comment!