You never have to tell me why I should care about international relations, I'm always interested to hear the spilling of the geopolitical tea

I can’t help but to notice that: 1. You failed to mention that Qatar itself is an ABSOLUTE MONARCHY. 2. That turks and arabs are not the same race and only joined by Sunni Islam. 3. The Aljazeera source mentioned in this video is a Qatari governmental news network. 4. How modern democracy is fundamentally held together by Secularism and why “Islamic Democracy” would never work. 5. Before Qatar ever needed a “NATO” ally, it has the largest US military base outside of the US. 6. How strengthening the Qatari - Iranian relationship put the US also in a bind. Hope to see more cohesive and accurate content from your channel in the future. Cheers!

@shafsteryellow

2 жыл бұрын

Islamic democracy can work don't be a munafiq... Secularism is haraam. The prophet was political... islam is political. Monarcial dictatorships are the antithesis of what the ummah is supposed to look like.

@kunalkar2667

2 жыл бұрын

@@shafsteryellow your extremist thought like this has labeled Islam as a terrorist religion. Thinking Islam is greatest and other religion are inferior gives rise to tensions and violence. If same intolerance happened in whole world where Muslim are forced to follow Christian rule, Buddhist rule, Hindu rules or Confucianism rules then middle east economy will seriously come under trouble. When trump put travel ban on immigrnats from 7 muslim country, then there was so many rhetoric about it. you can very well see the reason why. Other religions are not so intolerant to each other expect islam which always tries to dominate. Therefore acheiving peace with islam is never possible. You can't force sharia on non muslim people. Bcoz what will happen if christian rule is forced upon muslim living in europe and america

@shafsteryellow

2 жыл бұрын

@@kunalkar2667 jewish people believe they're the chosen people and the state of Israel as a Jewish state conducts itself as such. Evangelical Christians which are the largest unified voting block in the U.S AKA the nuclear armed single superpower believe the establishment of a Jewish state will lead to the second coming of Jesus. Please stop it. We know what Neandra Modi and the BJP religiously motivated policies are we know we see the Eastern orthodoxy impact on Russian foreign policy and their religiously motivated intervention in Syria. Don't move goalposts when it comes to Islam.

@MrPolymath0

2 жыл бұрын

@@shafsteryellow democracy is shirk

@tahamohammedi5898

2 жыл бұрын

@@kunalkar2667 So being a true Muslim means you're an extreme radical islamist fundematalist ? The amount of hypocrisy and ignorance you showed here is astonishing, Islam's message was never solely aimed at the individual level, Islam governed a state, it gave instructions to govern a state through the Prophet, granting individual relegious freedom and denying the state's relegious affiliation is unacceptable in an Islamic state, And of course a Muslim believes that his religion is true while others are false, like any relegious person would when he enters a relegion what's the mystery here? how's that intolerant? you have been fed with a vast amount of bullshit that you're contradicting yourself big time, you have a problem with Islam's message and i would hope you don't call yourself a Muslim

Turkey is facing an even worse economic crisis nowadays and UAE invested 10 billion $ in Turkey. UAE, once considered a nemesis to Turkey, is its savior now. Due to economic reasons, Erdogan loses domestic popularity, thus willing to do anything to stay in power. So Turkey's foreign policy doesn't show any sign of consistency.

@plataoplomo9096

2 жыл бұрын

Qatar did 15 billion $. Also bought their drones

@ayhamkimo4488

2 жыл бұрын

they're trying to change turkish foriegn policy by promising erdogan money in return, i hope they get success though

@badluck5647

2 жыл бұрын

You know the Lira is in trouble when it looks bad in an exchange with a dollar going through Biden's inflation crisis.

@theancientsancients1769

2 жыл бұрын

Because the US is leaving the middle East and those countries need a security partner and Turkey

@omarb1912

2 жыл бұрын

Uncle Sam will ensure that lira fails, the coup continues, even the Russian won't be able to stop it

Sorry but to ignore Iran in this conversation is kind of an error.

@bertone83

2 жыл бұрын

HAHAHA I stopped watching after the intro when he totally left out Iran out of the equasion.

@joecurran2811

2 жыл бұрын

They didn't ignore Iran but they didn't talk about them much.

@YTYY

2 жыл бұрын

Simply because Iran isnt a player anymore after losing the war against iraq

@williamdavis9562

2 жыл бұрын

The video was about the two sunni blocks. Talking about Iran would make this a much different and MUCH longer video.

@riderchallenge4250

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah Iran and Israel are powerful nations of Middle east

Superbly done. Thank you!

Turkish, Azeris, Kazakhs, Uyghurs, Uzbeks, Kyrgyzs, Turkmens, Tatars, Bashkirs many more all TURKS more than 300 Million Turks Total 🇹🇷🇦🇿🇰🇿🇺🇿🇹🇲🇹🇲🇹🇯

@torelloBank

2 жыл бұрын

and they are all poor unlike the arabs with the oil

@shashlek5751

2 жыл бұрын

They're under Russian influence lol 🤣

@williamdavis9562

2 жыл бұрын

@@torelloBank Yes but they aren't genetically damaged from 1000s of years of inbreeding. They're also not likely to starve to death once the world gets off oil.

@esramnor6734

2 жыл бұрын

@@torelloBank are arabs rich? just saudi qatar etc lol

@lb3843

2 жыл бұрын

@@esramnor6734 the Levant isn’t Arab there Canaanite and Northern Africa is well Northern African mostly Berber ancestry in North Africa .

This was a decent video but there was a huge mistake at 3:12. Islamic democracy? First of all, Qatar is not democratic in any way, shape or form. Turkey is a REPUBLIC it is explicitly NOT an 'Islamic Democracy'. It is true that Erdoğan runs Turkey but the democratic system has held in no thanks to him, his government, or his party which has attacked democratic norms in Turkey. The Mulsim Brotherhood are not interested in democracy either.

@briano7986

2 жыл бұрын

He clearly said Democracy in a way that implied he believed the opposite was true.

@shafsteryellow

2 жыл бұрын

@@briano7986 MB is predicated on democracy. Egypt first democratically elected leader was a proponent of mb

@rejvaik00

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly in fact the Muslim brotherhood arose from opposition to Attaturk's reforms and modernization of the Turkish nation

@qjtvaddict

2 жыл бұрын

Not every country needs democracy look at Americas nuff said it only works in a technically advanced country with high level education and it quite terrible look at Muslim brotherhood and US democracy aka IT DOESNT WORK!!!!!!! Keeping religious zealots under control is necessary to survival. The last thing the Muslim world needs IS DEMOCRACY!!!!! Aka Democrazy. Democracy only works in Europe cause a large % of the people are ATHEISTS!!!!! So yes US will eventually be forced to abandon democracy or end up like an Islamic shithole. Religious people should not vote or be in government!!!!!

@thebatman6235

2 жыл бұрын

@@briano7986 it's nothing imagine he control Muslim world which has somany oil and gas fields and becoming EU member how powerful it is then he will gain control of eu

Qatar needed an ideological ally that was large, *relatively rich* , and militarily strong. *Enter Turkey* Hah, and a few years later Erdogan has, by his own stupidity, tanked the Turkish economy, and the currency has lost 40% of it value.

@karankapoor2701

2 жыл бұрын

Election is in 23

@ulascingil

2 жыл бұрын

@@karankapoor2701 not necessarily, probably will be sooner.

@karankapoor2701

2 жыл бұрын

@@ulascingil how doesn't he have a majority

@ulascingil

2 жыл бұрын

@@karankapoor2701 he lost many of his supporters in recent times. Opposition is much stronger and acting together now. Recent economic situation is not helping him as well. He won't win another election, he needs a miracle.

@karankapoor2701

2 жыл бұрын

@@ulascingil really , I also think that tv stations like TRT are basically his mouthpiece but whyy doesn't Turkish opposition parties form coalition with Kurdish party

"Muslim brotherhood- their aim is a kind of Muslim democracy" He said with a straight face. Oh for goodness sake.

@palestinabaddie

2 жыл бұрын

you're subbed to Ray

@williamdavis9562

2 жыл бұрын

I'd imagine the will of the people to be better than a tyrant. I could however be wrong considering I don't live in any of these nations. But from my worldview I think any group of people deserves to elect their own leaders rather than have one imposed on them. Regardless of what we in the west might or might not think about their choices.

@gizlihesap1567

2 жыл бұрын

Call it Arab leauge they don t have anything to do with religion

@gizlihesap1567

2 жыл бұрын

@@williamdavis9562 do they have money gun s resoruces after break up country or their daddy country s like usa would let them succed with rebbelion or do it like what he did with saddam husain which saddam husian get education in usa to destory it s own country

@williamdavis9562

2 жыл бұрын

@@gizlihesap1567 Did Saddam also work really hard so he can be killed? Was it all part of his master plan? lol

Really good episode guys, thought provoking

Well this was eye opening, great video!

Host: talking about the split in the Arab politics. Turkey: hello?

one big mistake . Hezbollah is not part of the brotherhood and infact they're fighting them in syria

@shafsteryellow

2 жыл бұрын

This guy has clear agenda... MB is the boogeyman in this vid as opposed to the dictotorial corrupt arab 'kingdoms'

@mxkinist

2 жыл бұрын

same shit different flavor

@williamdavis9562

2 жыл бұрын

Yea that part of this video was rather strange to hear.

Thank you for this one. This was very enlightening:)

This video was very informative.

Thanks for this one. Most content on ME geopolitics focuses on Iran vs KSA..

@aryan1645

2 жыл бұрын

Because it's the most relevant. This is just a different, less prevalent subject. Not even an actual conflict.

@halaldunya918

2 жыл бұрын

Saudi Arabia is not a real geo political power, paper tiger that relies on foreign investors, don't like Iran either, but at least they can stand on their own legs.

@al3ndlib

2 жыл бұрын

@@halaldunya918 foreign investors 🤣🤣

Missing US, Iran and Other Stakes holder.. Ur Prospective died between Ur own Story..

@3inchesoffun154

2 жыл бұрын

Can someone translate this into English?

Thanks for the video. Honestly I was expecting to see more between Saudi and Turkey (video is mostly focussed on Qatar-Turkey relations). For example Saudi boycotting Turkey, Saudi Israel relationship, Egypte siding, Mediterranean issue etc.

@KGF-zf2qj

2 жыл бұрын

Saudi Israel relationship!! Saudi do not recognize Isreal and had no economic nor military relations with Israel. On the otherhand turkey had the biggest economic relation with Israel in the middle east and they have Israeli weapon companies on their soil!! Erdogan just visited Zionist regime so what you think about that ?

@Nocturnal1453

2 жыл бұрын

@@KGF-zf2qj uae normalized relations with Israel and that could not be done unless Saudi Arabia said so. Israel traded with Saudi Arabia and still does. Israel is against turkey in every aspect. How come I never see Israel making propaganda against Saudi Arabia? Because Saudi Arabia is a Zionist partner. But they do it against turkey. Saudi Arabia acts like they have no relations but they really do. While Turkey was supporting Palestine Saudi Arabia was funding Palestinian genocide.

@KGF-zf2qj

Жыл бұрын

@Timur Serdengeçti You mean when we kicked your ass 😂 you lose we didn’t betray you because we didn’t recognize you from the beginning

Happy Thanksgiving!

the editor had a little too much fun with this one

Today, UAE and Turkey negotiated each other. UAE will invest to Turkey. They made peace.

@prajodcp7145

2 жыл бұрын

THEY LL ROOT OUT ERDOGAN ONCe and for all inshallah

@zs9640

2 жыл бұрын

Also, the saudi minister of trad just went there. Things are going to cool down

@mdsabahuddin8251

2 жыл бұрын

@@prajodcp7145 okay hendu

@prajodcp7145

2 жыл бұрын

@@mdsabahuddin8251 am not a hendooo

@davidjma7226

2 жыл бұрын

Iran is courting UAE too. Surprise, surprise. Trying to make trouble as usual.....as they see Israel and UAE getting to be pals.

Thanks for educating about middle east 👍

@immammuddin5019

2 жыл бұрын

It is riddled with half truths and some falsehoods as well bro. Don't think you have figured out middle East based on this video.

@rammahesh3349

2 жыл бұрын

@@immammuddin5019 sure but nobody can tell 100% accurate analysis.. Far better than woke mainstream 🤣

@immammuddin5019

2 жыл бұрын

@@rammahesh3349 yeah agreed, better than mainstream.

@rammahesh3349

2 жыл бұрын

@@immammuddin5019 👍👍happy to hear from you

@LebSonic

2 жыл бұрын

I’m from the Middle East. This video is full of sensational BS and ignores a lot of facts. Very shallow.

Fascinating, I'd not heard that about the Arab Spring before

The elephant in the room is Turkey is the successor state of the Ottoman Caliphate. Some elements are interested in reviving it, and that’s the danger.

Saudi-Arabia Turkey Iran should work together and lead the Muslim-World to better development instead of fighting for power and dominance Love to the countries 🇸🇦🇹🇷🇮🇷 🇸🇦🇹🇷🇮🇷🇸🇦🇹🇷🇮🇷❤️❤️❤️

@mrityunjaytiwari6224

2 жыл бұрын

That can never happen dude humans will always fight no matter what

@bluefish4457

Жыл бұрын

Where are you from?

@rebellefleur2993

Жыл бұрын

This is not possible. There is a war for dominance in the region. Not seen anytime soon

As an answer to that question, look the war in Yemen, Azerbaijan and other areas around those countries. Who could have imagined 10 years ago a mandatory conscription in the UAE? Saudi and Bahrain are on the way too, not far from now. Surely bellies in those countries would start to shrink over the upcoming years!

😂🤣 I love your shirt man!

5:07 Where did u get this t-shirt from? Its amazing!! Oh, I guess that is also a good question.

I noticed that you skipped that even Israelis have sided with the monarchs pointing to the fact that the Palestinians were not part of the revolution against the Turks.

@uze1196

2 жыл бұрын

Great point

Errdogan’s stubborness in devaluating the lira will have the same outcome it had in all the African countries where local leaders decided to apply the same strategy: the removal of the local leaders. It’s historic evidence.

@sakibsarwat5064

2 жыл бұрын

we’ll see about that, also you should run for president candidate

@ottomanosman2463

2 жыл бұрын

True.

@SamtheIrishexan

2 жыл бұрын

The Turkish people have a democracy still, I didn't buy the whole staged coup thing and I don't think the Turks want him anymore but Turks correct me if wrong. Now if elections start being compromised I doubt the west will prop erdogan up. Which is exactly why he has shifted to Russia, he knows the west does not accept dictators in its wings.

@sakibsarwat5064

2 жыл бұрын

@@SamtheIrishexan the us is fully supporting ypd/pkk which threatens turkey’s sovereignty also committed and committing terroristic attacks against turks also child soldiers , russia violated nato turks aro space turkey shot down russian jet west didn’t almost nothing,us didn’t gave turkey patriot when it needed that the most and almost begged for it also withdrew all its deployed nato patriots in the face of russian threats!,nato assad/russia killed 40 turkey troops in idlib syria where turkey trying to set up a safe zone for displaced syrians so the refugee flow can stop and the west didn’t support turkey, nato backed Ukraine bought nato turkish drone to used against russia but that’s a big wrong thing according to nato! now erdogan didn’t bow down like other dogs and now he beceme the bad guy huh!🤔 wow man! just wow! how can you do all this?!

@arolemaprarath6615

2 жыл бұрын

@@ottomanosman2463 You are Greek. Check DNA

Good video

هلا من الإمارات العربية المتحدة ابوظبي 🇦🇪☪️🕌 Hello from the united Arab Emirates 🇦🇪☪️🕌

First to comment: great content as always👌

I think the video is quite outdated. First political islam in Turkey is a lost cause and ironically it is done by Erdogan himself. Currently there no islamist left in AKP. There are only people who seeks benefit by being 100% loyal to Erdogan. I can say that politcal islam has no chance of survival even in Turkey. In the rest of the world muslim brotherhood is far from being a threat to any one. On the other hand crown prince of UAE MNZ was in Turkey lastweek making approx. 10 bn $ agreement in return moving its goods via Turkish ports. So long story short your video is no more valid.

Like your videos 🤞🏾🤞🏾 from Yemen 🇾🇪

VisualPolitik, brought to you straight out of TelAviv.

أَشْهَدُ أَنْ لَا إِلَٰهَ إِلَّا ٱللَّٰهُ وَأَشْهَدُ أَنَّ مُحَمَّدًا رَسُولُ ٱللَّٰ 🌇🇲🇦 🕌🕋 🇸🇦☀ 🕌🇮🇩 🌅

Please do a documentary on Aljazeera which is a mouth organ of Qhatar ! It will be interesting as it will reveal the bias of Aljazeera and how it has bought many journalists all over the world who have sold their soul to Aljazeera!

Maybe a subtle fact, but Turkey is not an Arab country nor an Arabic Language speaking country, making the situation a bit different than an Arab cold war

Great

From the Quatar standpoint this analysis omits another major alliance, that with the US. Remember that the US has a major military base in Doha and that they too contribute to security of the country.

@BlackHolePublications

2 жыл бұрын

This is covered somewhere around the 7min mark in the video.

@williamdavis9562

2 жыл бұрын

@Moris this is true however I think the Qatari government is well aware that if hostilities ever erupted, the United States would side with Saudi Arabia and the UAE. Bringing in Turkish military bases in Qatar was basically a way to hedge all their best and plan for every possible outcome. It was in a way a stroke of genius on the part of the Qatari strategic thinkers. For Saudi Arabia and the UAE to make a physical move on Qatar they'd basically have to convince both Turkey and the United States to walk away. No easy task convincing both. Which basically means Qatar is safe.

@OmarOsman98

2 жыл бұрын

Qatar's hosting of an American military base does nothing but improve U.S. interests in the region. Perhaps, Qatar is paid handsomely for thr hosting but not much is done for Qatar geopolitically outside of that. If the Saudis and Emirstis had fallen through with removing the Qatari leadership in 2017, the US troops there surely would have not got involved. For this reason, Turkey decided to build a base immediately on Qatari soil. Apparently, this hindered Saudi-Emirati interests to remove the Qatari leadership. Turkey gained a wealthy ally in the process that was able to funnel billions of dollars in aid to the Turkish economy.

The middle east is now a 3-player chess game with Saudi, UAE, Bahrain and Egypt on Monarchical side, Iran, Syria, Hezbollah and Houthis on Shiite side and Turkey, Qatar, Azerbaijan and Muslim Brotherhood on Islamist side

@stalinsalazar2733

2 жыл бұрын

I prefer the Turkish model for the whole if the middle east

@mangolassi5273

2 жыл бұрын

@@stalinsalazar2733 its not a good model? its secular

@addielove

2 жыл бұрын

Us in sudan want out.. we want to get rid of all external influences like qatar and saudi .. they are what causing all these wars just to stay in power

@FAISAL-od4zx

2 жыл бұрын

You forgot Isreal 😄

@stalinsalazar2733

2 жыл бұрын

@@mangolassi5273 yet the secularist in Turkey are crying that secularism is fading away. It's a process and the Turkish example is best

Couldnt agree less

During desert storm I was at the elbow of Kuwait and Saudi Arabia. Top that in Summer. Plus it's 100 percent humid at times but doesn't rain. It's Hot there.

@shakiMiki

2 жыл бұрын

Great story, Have you thought of writing a memoir?

@danielbenner7583

2 жыл бұрын

That's too hot. I don't want to even want to think of that level of heat.

@ayhamkimo4488

2 жыл бұрын

@@danielbenner7583 it gets up to 70 Celsius with the humidity in Kuwait and iraq

@danielbenner7583

2 жыл бұрын

@@ayhamkimo4488 I would die.

@ronanyomu5967

2 жыл бұрын

OK, sooo what's ur salted biscuit story have to with the topic??

The more things change the more they stay the same

Update: UAE top leader MBZ is in turkey and signed 10 billion dollars deal.

@prajodcp7145

2 жыл бұрын

He (erdogan) will be toppled soon inshallah

@sammiemakki9339

2 жыл бұрын

@@prajodcp7145 your dreaming 😴

@williamdavis9562

2 жыл бұрын

@@prajodcp7145 Turkey isn't Iran or an Arab nation. Their leaders don't get "toppled" they lose elections and a new guy comes in. I'd imagine the voters of that country will decide who will and won't serve as their leaders. With that said Erdogan will probably lose the next election, his economic policies of late have really hurt the middle and lower classes. But your use of the word "topple" really shows where your head is at and what type of backward society you come from.

@prajodcp7145

2 жыл бұрын

@@williamdavis9562 either go get a newspaper Or just stop reading it from those dumb websites Do u know why putin isnt going away Simple! Election fraud as usual Dont u know that it will take atleast another year for the next turkish election if he isnt stopped now then the damages that he may inflict on the rest of the ME region will be irreconcilable by any means

@prajodcp7145

2 жыл бұрын

@@williamdavis9562 P.S. your dad is the one who belongs to the backward society not me

hey bro it's a good video can I ask its gold plated teeth you got.

If you want to tell upside down history watch this video

Iran: “ don’t forget us Persians”

My fifty bucks goes on the square that says MBS has the same fate as Louis XVI.

@antyspi4466

2 жыл бұрын

No chance. There is simply not the underlying civil structure that did exist in France back then and so far Saudi Arabia is not indebted as much as the French Crown was back then, which just conjured up the political crisis that led up to the revolution. What is most likely to happen if MBS fucks up more stuff, is that parts of his family that still retain some extent of power and influence will conspire either to oust him from his position as crown prince and replace him by one of his brothers or cousins, or to have some accident happen to him if everything else fails.

I feel like one of these days your editor might do a color correction on your face shot........

Your t-shirt game is strong

I think they should follow the Singapore model like Ethiopia is doing try to build government funded egalitarian capitalist open society that doesn’t discriminate based on ethnicity/ race or religion. The tplf wants to stop us funded by some bad actors but they’ll fail it’s like fighting gravity

@polishherowitoldpilecki5521

2 жыл бұрын

Their already at Addis abba. And your right this wouldn’t have happened if abiy Ahmed and the Oromo’s did not discriminate against Tigrayans and committed genocide against them. Abiy Ahmed will be tried for war crimes.

@edinhusic8288

2 жыл бұрын

does Ethiopia still exist, Tigray and Oromia forces are at the Addis Ababa front door, all because you scared pharaoh with your dam.

@pradeepsureshv716

2 жыл бұрын

And it worked so splendidly for the Ethiopians

@sharilsamad9727

2 жыл бұрын

Singapore is not a Muslim country; it is a country that spied on its Muslim neighbour; Malaysia, Indonesia and Brunei for ISRAEL, US and Australia. Beware of Greeks bearing a gift; that is Singapore. In 2018 Singapore admits involvement and apologized, in the same year, the Sultan of Brunei, president of Indonesia and PM of MALAYSIA attended Singapore independent day. Diplomatic issues resolved, keep your friends close but enemy closer. That is the in south-east Asia Muslim input in this topic. Team Turkey and Qatar all the way

@LamZL1

2 жыл бұрын

@@sharilsamad9727 all countries spy on each other....

Turks vs. Saudis... hmm Both are US allies, no?

@BruceWayne-qe7bs

2 жыл бұрын

Yesn't

@joecurran2811

2 жыл бұрын

Turkey not so much at the minute.

@yemliha4434

2 жыл бұрын

Being US Ally doesn't mean much in this conflict. Middle east is not that simple to understand.

@decus9544

2 жыл бұрын

Allies of convenience, nothing more.

@rollog1248

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, the US would most likely pressure to stop the fighting. I don't think they'll choose who to back.

This video was really confusing. MORE MAPS are needed. This is VISUALpolitik.

Iran and Israel to Turkey and Saudi Arabia: Hold my beer!

Incredibly biased and ill-researched video. There’s no issues with Islamic democracy if people of a country want it. What’s wrong is the absolute monarchies and dictatorships that grip the people of a country and don’t let them evolve. What’s worse is the constant interference of the West in the Middle East and dictation to their countries for how they should be governed. In the end, most of the worst governments in the Middle East are there, or have been there, because of Western and primarily US support - Hosni Mubarak, the Saudis, Saddam Hussain, etc etc. If you don’t allow a country to run its course, threat of extremism will never finish. As for why Muslim Brotherhood was designated a terrorist group by the US? Of course the Saudis pressured them to do it as they threaten Saudi legitimacy. Before the revolution happened in Egypt, they weren’t really labelled as a terrorist group. This video speaks like a mouthpiece for Saudi amd UAE. Why would you rely on an Emirati kings view of why Muslims are not ready for a democracy? Iran had a moderate democracy more than two decades ago which was overthrown by the CIA as it didn’t suit its motives. Pakistani moderate democracy has been overthrown many times by generals supported by the US. Egyptian democracy was highjacked by Saudi and US collusion. Only surviving democracies are Turkey, Indonesia and Malaysia at the moment, however proof of the pudding is that Muslims are highly capable of moderate democracies but the West’s self-serving intentions have always scuppered them and then changed the narrative. Also your video says Arab spring came about because Turkey and Qatar financed it. Tsk tsk. It was homegrown revolutions, maybe helped by Turkey and Qatar later as they had good intentions towards the people of those countries. But ultimately sabotaged by Saudis, UAE and the US as it threatened their governments or their interests.

@karankapoor2701

2 жыл бұрын

Morsi was a islamist

@ammarkhalid874

2 жыл бұрын

Your argument falls apart because there never really were democracies in the Middle East or Islamic world to begin with (besides Turkey for a period of just 90 years until Erdogan lost his mind!). All of these countries were created by colonial powers to keep the region in check, for Cold War play, and for resource extraction for which the local population initially had no interest/demand for. Furthermore, everyone needs to accept that there is simply a clash of civilizations in the general populations at play here and we are talking about between the Islamic world and non-Islamic world. The majority of Muslims just don’t believe/accept in the basic tenets of human rights and most of the scientific scholarly work that the rest of the world does which creates a big gap in bridging between the two vastly different regions. Likewise, while the West which until the late 16th or early 17th century used to be politically/culturally very similar to present Islamic world, it underwent Christian reformation which reduced religion to private life. Islamic world hasn’t gone through that reformation process yet so applying democracy on such people simply won’t work for now. I don’t know whether democracy is the solution to the myriad of problems that currently exist in the Islamic world as we know that other countries have undergone development using other political systems, China is an example. However, let’s just say for the sake of argument that these Muslim countries become Islamic states. Now assuming that all the Islamic scholars, politicians, and local people are able to agree on the right interpretation of the Islamic law and are able to devise some sort of a political system, the new problem that arises is that historically speaking the basis of Islam relies on conquering non-Muslim world and constant warfare just for the sake of religion as the religion does not believe in national borders with no actual concern for human economic/social development and the betterment of the material conditions. Therefore, the situation cannot simply be reduced to blaming the West for the current problems of the Middle East.

@williamdavis9562

2 жыл бұрын

@@karankapoor2701 Regardless of what we believe Morsi is or isn't doesn't change the fact the majority of voters in that country voted for him. I can't ever imagine a foreign power coming to my country here in the United States and telling us our elected leader can't be in charge because of x,y and Z. It's insanity. I don't need to know anything about Egyptian politics to know that the Egyptian people should be respected enough to pick their own leaders.

Grant's grown into his role. Replacing Simon was no mean feat.

@davidjma7226

2 жыл бұрын

He has porked out a bit!

Middle Eastern politics is always Instresting to observe

Yessir

Those sanctions on Qatar was for routinely supporting rebels in Syria that were not approved by NATO allies. They were well deserved.

@tsubadaikhan6332

2 жыл бұрын

Those sanctions achieved next to nothing. Qatar went out & ordered 100 F16's from the US & 100 Rafael's from France. They had no want, need, or intention to purchase said aircraft. They don't have the ground crews or pilots to operate such a number of planes. But they laid down a huge deposit so the US & European Union ignored Saudis blockade, & the Saudis weren't going to stop ships/planes from those regions, so the blockade did nothing. (I know nothing about whether the blockade was deserved or not. Just impressed how they beat it. Turns out we're as susceptible to bribery as anyone)

@dimitriantanov3150

2 жыл бұрын

@@tsubadaikhan6332 Their currency took a dive, so there is that outcome; very interesting what youve said. At the time oil scarcity was also up. Major oil producers Libya and Syria weren't able to keep their exports up. They were Russian allies in OPEC, the US's allies in OPEC allowed prices to drop despite this increased scarcity. Qatar didn't align themselves with this move, so this might have also been a motivation for the sanctions. To tank their currency and make them increase production.

@tsubadaikhan6332

2 жыл бұрын

@@dimitriantanov3150 That increased oil production dropping prices had the added benefit of bankrupting many US based Fracking & Shale operations. Practically none of them have reopened despite todays high prices. There's always wheels within wheels. If you read comments regularly you've probably also noticed most US voters are convinced their President sets the oil price, & it has nought to do with the Russians & OPEC. Bizarre.

@luishernandezblonde

2 жыл бұрын

@@dimitriantanov3150 Qatar is still an American ally. You have to mention the American Udeid base in Qatar to see why the West is so unwilling to do something to Qatar.

Of course you will ignore the fact that the Muslim Brotherhood was founded in Egypt and exiled to Turkey. And that the Arabs remember the rule of the Ottoman Empire and therefore any Turkish intervention in Arab affairs is considered to be Turkish imperialism.

@justsefa1843

2 жыл бұрын

Yes how dare Turkey not hand over the MB-refugees to Egypt, so Egypt can execute them. In an ideal world Egypt is not a dictatorship and the MB refugees get a fair trial. But that's not the reality we live in. And yes literally everyone in the middle east is fighting for some sort of control or power, but we sure have to look out for the turks and only the turks. This comment is totally not biased at all.

@trillmoney263

2 жыл бұрын

You speak the truth. Turkey wants nothing good in the arab world. But Qatar controls aljazera so they hide this from the arab world. Turkey should honestly focus on turan and other Turkic countries. And not the arab world

@justsefa1843

2 жыл бұрын

@@trillmoney263 How about the arabic countries take over the 4 million syrian refugees then? It is quite disgusting to claim that Turkey wants only bad things for the arabic world, while it is hosting 4 million of you guys in its own territory. And it wasn't Turkey either pulling the trigger against Syria. Turkey was in fact one of the last countries doing so. And when Saudi-Arabia starts an illegal war in Yemen or supports a war lord against the government of Libya, it is obviously Turkey that is being problematic. Sure fam. You totally know what the heck is going on.

@trillmoney263

2 жыл бұрын

@@justsefa1843 first off there are more Syrian refugees in Lebanon and Jordan than in turkey and most Syrians still live in Syria also they are in Denmark and Germany as well. I just don’t understand why Turks like to use that as a leverage against arabs when in fact your country uses the refugees as a leverage against Europe. Turkey is an anomaly with their Georgian president erdogan It’s gonna collapse soon erdogan basically just sold you out to the uae.

@trillmoney263

2 жыл бұрын

@@justsefa1843 uae just put 10 billion in your economy you think their doing that from the kindness of their heart don’t you think they want something in return honestly we’ll find out soon.

Why is the speed of this video so fast?!

I actually like that guitar like instrument.

I've never heard anyone putting the "joy" in "Rajoy"! What a miserable, drab Presidente del Gobierno. The pronunciation of the "j" is like "loch", the ch part in Scottish. However, putting the joy in Rajoy is akin to putting the fun in funeral.

Its Time to Bet for your favorite Arab Horse... *TURK* 🐎 Or *ARAB* 🐎 _Its How the British Wanted it..!!!_ 😂

@user-rz9vb8vj5u

2 жыл бұрын

You mean like India

You really need to work on your choice of background music.

The report that you presented which implicates Egypt and the UAE in the turky coup was written by al-jazzera which is owned by Qatar which is kinda sus

An analysis that's outdated and frankly poor.

@cnadergamer9891

2 жыл бұрын

Yes

"The Middle East is a place which is geographically as close to the west as is socially, politically and culturally distant." This statement sums it up.

@mariolis

2 жыл бұрын

Dont forget "religiously" Islam is the primary reason why the middle east is so fucked up

Can't even buy chewing gum with lira i bet shorters happy asf

4:57 hey ! Don’t picture their mistresses, they get picky about that !

Well I understand Qatar is more worried about Saudi Arabia right now but doesn't Qatar seem threatened too by Muslim brotherhood means it is actually a monarchy too.Isn't it like feeding a snake which will bite others but it can bite you too.

@Chni-3andk

2 жыл бұрын

It's kind of a meme in the Arab world that the muslim brotherhood is unsurprisingly quiet on Qatar's monarchy because they are the ones keeping them fed.

@prajodcp7145

2 жыл бұрын

They need the money flowing after all

@williamdavis9562

2 жыл бұрын

Qatar has a small population which in the end is very comfortable and highly unlikely to start a revolution against the monarchy. Saudi Arabia however has been a revolution waiting to happen since it's inception. Context matters.

@binabdoh6436

2 жыл бұрын

@@williamdavis9562 Saudis love their monarchs. The young population ( a majority) loves MBS and King Salman to the fact that Nationalism is on the highest levels ever seen. So no, you are wrong about Saudi being a revolution waiting to happen especially after we have seen what failures they have become in places like Tunisia and Egypt. Keep the wishful thinking.

@williamdavis9562

2 жыл бұрын

@@binabdoh6436 I'd imagine those who benefit from that corrupt regime would love them. I'd imagine those who dont' benefit would be scared to speak up. So yes, in a way what you say makes sense. Unfortunately it doesn't make any headway in dispelling my earlier point.

How are your teeth sooo yellow? It looks like uranium cakes

@thijsaalbregtse3075

2 жыл бұрын

Indeed. Go see the dental hygienist

@jekboy2003

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly what I was thinking...I was about to say that...his yellow teeth is so distracting I can't bare to watch him

@decus9544

2 жыл бұрын

Too much tea, too little brushing.

@cyberyann

2 жыл бұрын

This has been commented in previous videos… time to move on and change record…

03:15, when you uses trump as a reference, lol.

excluding iran, especially its proxies colonizing iraq, syria, lebanon, and yemen was a mistake

This video points only small part of the regional story. And everything is changing quickly in the region. Yesterday Turkey and UAE agreed on economical and political terms. UAE will be investing $10 billion in Turkey. The details of the agreement is not clear yet, but it seems the KSA-UAE unity takes another hit, one of many in recent times. Turkey and Qatar will most likely continue to act together, both sides have too much at stake. It will not be affected even after Turkey has a new leadership.

@Qfoxrythm

2 жыл бұрын

The royal family trying to defend themselves and befriend everyone. It’s a good move but if you look at history. That might not work well for long time

@ArawnOfAnnwn

2 жыл бұрын

Also the Houthis from Yemen are actually bombing KSA now. The war down south has really turned against them.

@barrydysert2974

2 жыл бұрын

🤔

@f98m14

2 жыл бұрын

@@Qfoxrythm You mean that al-Houthi receives great blows and defeats in Ma'rib and Hodeidah, and severe blows in Sana'a, which is run by the Iranian Hassan Erlo! Saudi Arabia has good defenses and its borders have not been exposed to anything. The end of Iran's plans in Yemen is near.

@QasimAlKhuzaie

2 жыл бұрын

An enemy of my enemy is...

Quite biased They focused on turkey and Qatar more than the other side And there is 2 things he got wrong : 1st was that Qatar didn't instigate the Arab spring it truly was populist and stared in Tunis because a average man burned himself after his vegetables cart was confiscated but the just went with the wave supporting it mostly with al Jazeera covering and this gets us too the second one 2nd Muslim brotherhood is only an Egyptian organization based and founded in Egypt it's not global uae pines any political party that has Islamic background or founding & tendencies or is just plain conservative as a part of the islamic brotherhood A side note he didn't speak about the current counter revolution in which the uae side puts military and authoritarian regimes all over the region

@evilmelez

2 жыл бұрын

and beneath them all corruption lies and muslim nation pays their debt. erdoğan bought all the media with the borrowed money from the banks and mortgaged that debt with his borrowed land from the country then later pays nothing and owned them all whom his son mur*dered a person with his car then tried to clean the body with firefighters which his close family friend? who drowned the country with usury since he came to power(80bil when he came now its 600bil) ? erdoğan. who sold all the factories that was belonged to the turkey to the west? erdoğan. who made a 1 billion dolar worth bridge for 8 billion dolar and for 25 years he gave it to the western world made us pay it while his company made billions of dollars from interest money?erdoğan litterally handed over uygur turks to china when they protested and his party stopped recognition of genocide of uygurs in parlement. *Date 14 November 2009: AKP Aydin Provincial President: “Our leader and prime minister (Tayyip Erdogan) is almost a second prophet for us”* *It was 14 July 2014. Minister of Interior Efkan Ala: “The Prophet was proud, we were not!”* *AKP Düzce Deputy said the following about Tayyip Erdogan on January 16, 2014: “There is a leader who has gathered all the qualities of Allahu ta'ala!”* *AKP Bursa Deputy Hüseyin Sahin: “Even touching the Prime Minister (Tayyip Erdogan) is a form of worship.”*

How about Al Ula's agreement and the diplomatic reapproachment recently

Gosh plz choose a proper theme song for Turkey.

And now Turkey's economy is in free-fall lol

Well if you didn't get the news uae and ksa are not in good terms now. Couple of months ago most of saudis left uae by orders from the government.

5:06 lmao

They are still young, we're not really helping either

Turkey’s ambitions extend far beyond just the middle east. They have designs on central asia and even as far as western China under the misguided notion of pan turkism.

@shafsteryellow

2 жыл бұрын

What makes it misguided... turkic people benefit from a big power thats culturally linked. Turkey benefits from expanded sphere of influence.

@janusjones6519

2 жыл бұрын

@@shafsteryellow its misguded because there is zero cultural linkage between modern turkey and those historical areas. The whole concept is based on a lie.

@ronindude9640

2 жыл бұрын

@@janusjones6519 Really ? Which lie is that ? Obviously, you know nothing about the Turkic languages and how much they relate to each other and how much mutually intelligible they are. In the last few centuries, Turkic people have lost Siberia to Russians and east Turkistan to China. The biggest enemies to the Turkic world have always been Russia and China. These two are also biggest enemies of the west and biggest threat to the west. But western countries never wake up and say "my enemy's enemy is my friend.....So Turkic world should be my friend." West has never been clever like that. Why is that ?

@shafsteryellow

2 жыл бұрын

@@janusjones6519 you're not turkic.. you don't get to make that claim.

@williamdavis9562

2 жыл бұрын

@Janus Jones, wanting to forge between relations with people who (in their opinion) have something in common doesn't sound very "misguided" to me. You and I can make arguments that they do or don't share XYZ but in the end I don't think that's up to us to decide. If these groups of people want closer and warmer relations, more power to them. Us telling 4 guys who want to be friends, screaming at them saying "you have nothing in common" would make us look like the lunatics no? And yes, in a way I basically just called out your insanity.

It is kinda simplistic to summarize the Arab spring as a one group/country pipedream, it is in fact bordering racisme to reduce the revolts of multiple nations against dictatorships to a merly one islamic group ideology experiment. some fact checks: In yemen the main faction that Saudis are fighting are not sunni (as in the Muslim brotherhood) in fact quit the opposit The dictatorship in Sudan was already Muslim Brotherhood for the last 40 years before the revolution (probably the reason the global players let it slide relatively peacefuly) and now trying to install a new one that is not affiliated with the group. In Libya it was called a revolution (as it is) and the Global intervention was swift because Qaddafi was not an ally of the west (not talking to you Italy). currently there is an ongoing coup in the most promising democracy in the middle east (outside Israel) with Europe looking the other way. And finally, we lost almost 1 million of my country people in Syria, not because we were Muslim brotherhoods, but because people like yourself in the well established democracies are reducing the struggles of many, into a shallow and superficial cockfights. I expected more from this channel that I used to like!

@CKBmay10

2 жыл бұрын

I am curious - Who is the most promising democracy in the middle east you mention in your comment? Can you expand on what coup is going on in which Europe is looking to the other side?

@Ramiarmuni

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks! I just realised that I forgot to name the country :), it is Tunisia, and it is currently going through the most bizarre cop, where the president suddenly assumed all powers and suspended the parliament, and EU is yet to be even concerned!

@Ramiarmuni

2 жыл бұрын

@Nisr Masry88 𓅓𓁺𓄿𓁼𓃭𓎦𓏭 𓂝 well the whole discussion started by talking about the "Arab Spring", and it acutely started with revolution in Tunisia, so in this regard Tunisia has everything to do with this struggle, As for the names; middle east is actually is a political term, where North Africa is a geopolitical term, maybe to correct this confusion we should start using the term "West Asia" :)

@planetarysolidarity

2 жыл бұрын

@@Ramiarmuni Southeast Mediterranean?

@Ramiarmuni

2 жыл бұрын

@@planetarysolidarity anything but the middle east, it makes no sense, as it is only middle east in regards to the US, but not to the rest of the world

Turkey, stop occupying your Syrian Muslim brothers and help the Yemenese prevent the Saudi Arabians from destroying their country and most of all Help the Palestinians to Freedom.

"Democracy in Turkey" the same guy has been in power for two decades

@sunnsunn435

2 жыл бұрын

The same guy has been in power because Turkish people elected him with their votes in the election with "DEMOCRACY".. so what?!

Qatar forgets its place in the Arabian Gulf, and it has not learnt anything. Fortunately, the Turkish economy is falling fast, and the Central Asians will have to vacate.

@abdulazizalghamdi988

2 жыл бұрын

@МеніңҚазақстаным No evidence presented otherwise the Americans will treat the Saudis differently. If you have solid proof (not from the media, speculations, or assumptions), please post the link here. If you are a parrot who repeats what it sees on the TV, please STFU.

@OmarOsman98

2 жыл бұрын

I definitely do not think the Saudi government was behind those attacks. Apparently, the vast majority if ghe hijackers were Saudi nationals, but even then, that would not necessarily implicate the Saudi government.

@esramnor6734

2 жыл бұрын

but you are wrong

Saudi power and the best 💪🇸🇦

@ArcanumArcanorum17

2 жыл бұрын

Lost to a bunch of yemeni 20 year olds

Excuse my ignorance but… any future for political moderation in the muslim world? What would it take for other Atatürk’s to appear and modernise societies in the middle east?

@maverick7291

2 жыл бұрын

@Nisr Masry88 𓅓𓁺𓄿𓁼𓃭𓎦𓏭 𓂝 the only one you mentioned that has a bit of semblance to a democratic system and a slim amount of human rights is Lebanon and Indonesia. Even then Lebanon is basically controlled partially by hezb and the rest by autocrats. Freedom of religion, freedom of speech, women rights, gay rights, freed of the press are horrible in all the Muslim majority countries. They usually are at the bottom of list for human rights. That's how man rights, not "Islamic human rights" which is a warped and twisted mentality that only sociopaths would appreciate and see nothing wrong with.

I just realised how beautiful Turkey is

@user-dp3kw1cp3r

2 жыл бұрын

If you’re Turkish and you like your country Take your people form Saudi Arabia back to your country

Comments section will be fun.

@LuisRomeroLopez

2 жыл бұрын

I hope so!

@MonDieuMaCauseMonEpee

2 жыл бұрын

أَشْهَدُ أَنْ لَا إِلَٰهَ إِلَّا ٱللَّٰهُ وَأَشْهَدُ أَنَّ مُحَمَّدًا رَسُولُ ٱللَّٰ

Your prediction of a direct military conflict between the UAE and Turkey is quite ridiculous. The UAE will continue to poke Turkey in the eye as long as it feels it is protected by the United States. Once the UAE feels that protection is waning, they will simply bribe Turkey to leave them alone. The gulf in military strength between these two nations is far too great for the UAE to take any chances of it happening.

@abdokordy2

2 жыл бұрын

Uae funds opposition, Kurdish,democratic army in Syria,&haftar in lybia..in addition Erdogan is involved militarily so his economy is declining ...uae want to make alliance against iran

Stop showing Egypt or another Middle Eastern country while you are talking about Turkiye!!!!

i have a question too... umm have you EVER brushed your teeth like once a week?

أين الترجمة العربية ؟! الإنجليزية ليست لغة العالم , من فضلكم طالما تتحدثون عن بلاد العرب (الشرق الأوسط) عليكم بوضع اللغة العربية لغة العالم 😄🖐

@Fahad-Qahtany

2 жыл бұрын

@abbkk ها ؟

@Fahad-Qahtany

2 жыл бұрын

@Marko Marinovic هههههههه خطأ

@Fahad-Qahtany

2 жыл бұрын

@Marko Marinovic لأنهم مهزومين فهم يتحدثون لغة القوي .. ننتظر انتهاء هؤلاء وتخرج لنا أجيال قوية عزيزة بلغتها ووطنها

*Only Morocco 🇲🇦 is only African who have long history and unbroken relationship with America since their revolution in 1776.* 🇹🇼

A political clusterfluck if I ever scene one.

First thing to do is go get Hollywood smile …